Song of Dark Tides is a Little Mermaid retelling where Viola, the Ursula figure in this tale, is the FMC, and her love interest, Aric, is an Ariel style MMC. It twists the original story in such interesting ways, and the description had me immediately jumping on it! I’ve never read a story where the Ariel figure was male, or where the Ursula figure was the protagonist, let alone for the two to be love interests! But it works so well! All the little aspects from the original story that show up here in new and interesting ways were fascinating. The eel!! The world itself was really interesting to learn about. As we usually view magical mermaid lands and Atlantis as wonderful places. But here, life underwater is as bad as it sounds to us!
Viola, known as the Violent Sea, is a witch cursed by the evil King Triton. He’s spread horrible lies about her, leaving everyone to believe her evil. But she only targets male predators who deserve it. Prince Aric is a siren, one who has trouble killing those he lures in. Who struggles with meeting the expectations of his father. Triton expects him to be like he is, but Aric doesn’t want to kill. When Viola meets him, she assumes he’s as evil as his father, and targets him, trapping him into a deal. But things quickly go awry when the two are not only drawn to one another, but they begin to see the other isn’t what they believe.
Viola is such an intriguing character. Villainized and alone expect for the mermaids she’s saved and the horrible couple of men she’s bound to her service, she’s unable to go to Atlantis due to Triton, and can’t stay on land often due to her curse pulling her back. But she has the favor of a Goddess, and the magic to make nearly any deal possible. She saves females who need it and punishes men who prey on women. Stalking the city to reap those who breaks her terms. But she’s truly a traumatized girl who was forced into a life she doesn’t want. She has no way out. Triton made it so she can’t even die to escape. She can’t hurt him. He can’t hurt her. Triton is obsessed with her and wants her for himself, and this is punishment. But her will is strong, and despite loosing all she loved to him, she refuses to give in.
Prince Aric is unsatisfied with his life. Unable to take to the cruelty his father expects, he feels himself a failure of an heir. He is drawn to the humans as much as Viola is. Wanting to experience life on the surface. But not at the expense of his voice. His power lies on his ability to sing, and Viola takes it away and returns it only when they’re alone. His simmering resentment of both his father and Viola are palpable. He believes all the lies his father told him about Viola, and her targeting him certainly doesn’t help. Nor making him have to get the Princess he had been visiting in his siren form to agree to marry him in three days. He has no interest in pursuing said Princess, but he’ll do anything to gain his freedom.
The chemistry between Viola and Aric is so good! The enemies to lovers tension is on point, and their arguing and antagonism is wonderful. They have a great back and forth with one another. They both have major misconceptions about the other, including Aric thinking she killed his mother. But regardless, they’re both attracted to the other. While Viola tries to tempt and distract him to get him to mess up with the Princess, ensuring she’ll own him at the end of the three days, she finds herself second guessing her games when the two of them have trouble keeping their hands off the other. The hate f*ck*ng is perfection!
The pace of the relationship was really good too. We had a good solid chunk of the story where they’re antagonistic, and then the slow fall. But things are complicated by both Triton, and an awful human who thinks he knows how to kill Viola. The parts where Aric is trying to woo the Princess while without a voice is a lot of fun, especially Viola and Aric’s interactions during this part! And the magic done! Viola has some seriously creative mischievousness she busts out. But we inevitably get into the heavier parts. Triton, the abusive pr*ck, will not give up on the idea he and Viola are a perfect match. The motivations of the human are less clear. But I’m assuming it’s some sort of power grab. As the world itself is set up where the humans are aware of magic but it they seem to not be totally understanding of the scope.
This book is dark in parts. Viola and Aric both do some things and act certain ways that is definitely dark and messed up. Then there’s the horrendous actions and of Triton that is touched on, and what the human evil attempts. But there is also a wonderful storyline here about hope. About finding love. About healing hearts. About life. Even when the worst happens there is still beauty and wonder in the world. Hope should never be given up. Love can overcome anything. Even a theme about first impressions and not believing the worst of people. There’s a definite optimistic slant to this dark Little Mermaid retelling!
The world here is so fascinating to me. The Princess calls to a Siren from her bed. There are humans with magic items. And yet they don’t seem to realize how far that magic goes. There’s also the fact that the beautiful and illustrious Atlantia is the not the shining jewel of the kingdom you might expect. Actually, the whole of underwater life is lacking to the characters, who try to get away from it whenever they can. Everything is wet and muted, food is tasteless, and drinks have salt water in them. There’s the magic Viola has, given to her by the goddess, which seems near limitless and gives her tentacles. There’s Aric’s siren magic, allowing him to create intricate illusions. And there is indeed merman/female tentacle s*x here! It’s absolutely wild!
This was definitely an entertaining and surprisingly heartfelt Little Mermaid retelling! Even with dark themes and darker characters, there is the message of a better tomorrow underpinning it all. I loved the romance and the back and forth game the two play. And the plot kept me just as invested as the characters. I would definitely recommend this if you enjoy fairy tales, darker themes, spice, complex characters, and magic!
I received an eARC of this book. This is my honest review.