Not sure how to rate this book. Ultimate rating is probably 3.5/5 stars, but it ended on a really annoying note for me so rounding down.
The good:
-This was really easy to read, which is not something I can say about most books these days (that's a me problem, but still, it was nice to find something that I could just get through without struggling too much with focus)
-I mostly really liked the characters (caveat below) and the romance was nice, although not one that really got me invested
-The Bachelor In Paradise type format was really very fun. I had some minor nitpicks on logistics, but overall, I spent most of the book seeing the Show Twists as things the Bachelor producers would absolutely do
-A contemporary romance billed as a romcom that wasn't sad (caveats below), even though it dealt with some of the characters' baggage!
The not-so-good:
-Wes having streaked through the outfield at Yankee Stadium is an automatically disqualifying thing for a romance hero for me. Especially when it kept being brought up, and later it was revealed that it happened very recently, and not when he was drunk and 19 years old. (1) Based on everything else about Wes, it just didn't seem to fit his personality. (2) I'm sorry, but if your romance hero is someone I can imagine Michael Kay having to talk about as interrupting the Yankees' broadcast because some idiot ran out onto the field, then you have created a problem for me, as a reader who (this past month aside) watches or listens to basically every inning of every Yankees game, 162 games a year. I didn't realize this was going to be a thing for me, but as soon as I read it, my reaction was "Oh, no. This is going to be a Problem."
-This book was billed as a romcom but... I didn't actually find it funny at all. I think some of the things that were supposed to be funny ended up being really high secondhand embarrassment to me. Emmy's wardrobe was a major one.
-The ending generally was really fast and unearned. The way the ILY happened really annoyed me, as did the throwing the option to get married at the three remaining couples (which, for the record, there was a HIGH volume of successful couples based on the total volume of people on the show). This isn't a nitpick about reality tv, because similar things have definitely happened on the Bachelor before. I just didn't like it as a plot device because it distracted from the other thing I wanted them to focus on. Which, of course, then they did not.
-And this leads me to one of my #1 pet peeves about reality tv couples: We virtually never see them talking about what their lives are going to be like long-term and how they see themselves making it work (and then, shocker, it usually does not work). Yes, yes, I know, we got a few moments of them talking about Philly and NY being close and her coming to visit him. But... they actually are building lives and careers in two different cities. She's actually taking her money and starting a new business in Philly! How is that ultimately going to work?? ANYWAY, this book had an opportunity to address it and did not. So, this ended on a really meh note for me.