**Many thanks to NetGalley, St. Martin's Press, and Sally Hepworth for an ARC of this book! Now available as of 4.4!!**
"You can't reason with your heart; it has its own laws, and thumps about things which the intellect scorns."-Mark Twain
The battle of head vs. heart that permeates the pages of the Soulmate was eerily reminiscent of my OWN personal struggle with how to feel about my reading experience with this one...and I'm still not ENTIRELY sure who won!
The Drop: it sounds like a thrilling theme park ride, but in reality, it's a terrifying and steep cliff, right in the backyard of married couple Pippa and Gabe (and their poor kids...not sure how their nerves survive!) The spot has unfortunately gained some significant notoriety: it is a popular spot for jumpers. Gabe, aside from being devastatingly handsome and dreamy in every way, has ANOTHER natural gift: he is able to talk would be jumpers "off the ledge." Pippa often observes from afar, proud of the man she gets to call her husband...until one day, when she watches one such instance...but rather than a rescue, she witnesses a deadly fall.
Pippa is horrified, of course, but what confuses her is that it LOOKS to her like the victim didn't take a leap...and Gabe's chat with the female stranger seemed different than most. The police determine the jump was indeed a suicide, but the victim's husband is adamant that his wife would NEVER have intentionally ended her life. Pippa then learns that the stranger wasn't exactly a stranger to Gabe...and that final conversation may have been a far cry from helpful. Could the perfect man, the man she knows inside and out, her very best friend be hiding a secret so dark, so dangerous, that it was worth dying for....or even worth KILLING for?
Ever since I had the good fortune to pick up Hepworth's The Mother in Law after rave reviews from some trusted reader friends, I have been enamored with her craft. If there's one thing she does PHENOMENALLY well (and perhaps better than any other domestic suspense writer I read regularly) it's to put the DOMESTIC in domestic suspense in an authentic, no nonsense and often FUN way. Her books are always tinged with humor, the child characters in her books are so real and adorable you feel like they'll be running around the corner towards you at any moment, and she captures the 'normal' (both good and bad) of daily suburban (and at times wealthy suburban) life to a T. Her dialogue is never forced or over the top, and I always feel as though I KNOW her characters (and USUALLY grow to love them...special shout-out to Wally and Fern from The Good Sister...the world needs more of you both! 😍)
Where Hepworth's books sometimes falter for me, however, is in the execution of the 'suspense' itself. I'm not sure why this is, but despite her books having twists, this one in particular didn't feel twisty to me. I also LOVED The Good Sister and even THAT book played out in a pretty straightforward fashion. Although I was surprised at times during this book, I didn't ever feel as though I was properly 'tricked.' I kept waiting for a lot of dramatic 'a ha' moments, but what I got instead felt more like simple explanation rather than revelation.
I also didn't love the back and forth timelines
AND
the dual POV format for the book: in this case, it just felt like a bit much in terms of literary device and to be honest, the backstory timeline dragged a bit. There is also a thread of the plot that deals with mental health in a somewhat unbelievable way, but buy in from the reader is necessary to serve the plot, so you sort of have to just go with it. That being said, once again I applaud Hepworth for her vulnerability and willingness to include this sort of content without getting preachy OR being over the top...but again, this doesn't necessarily serve the SUSPENSE side of the story. I think her strength is on the domestic side of the street, and I'm curious at this point in time if I might enjoy some of her earlier books (more in this vein, from what I understand) than her current trajectory into suspense: time will tell!
Though my head kept telling me over and over that this was a 3 star read, there is just something indescribable and truly exceptional about Hepworth and her craft that tipped the scales and compelled me to give this book a 4.
Perhaps, like your high school 'soulmate', it was just 2 Good 2 Be "4" Gotten.
😉
3.5 stars, rounded up to 4