My Interest
As a frustrated historian (I had to earn a living instead) I know that history tends to go in cycles of approximately 100 years each. The dot com boom was about 100 years after the Robber Barons of the Gilded Age for example. In the years of Hitler’s rise to power, between 1923 and 1933, just like today, many people on both sides of the American political divide saw potential for dictatorship to arise from the other side. The USA has both embraced and renounced dictators throughout history–having them near when they needed them and pushing them away later (Saddam Hussein is an example of this).
The old world aristocracy and the wealthy Americans dubbed that in the press have a vested interest in keeping their standard of living. Americans in the “interior” of the country (I will not use the gag-inducing term the press of today so loves, “the heartland”) are far more conservative than those on the coasts. There are people with German ancestors everywhere. It is interesting to see how, after the bad is seen an accepted, people distance themselves from what they so recently espoused. That, too, is going on today.
The Story
Edward VIII (Prince of Wales at the start of Hitler’s rise, later Duke of Windsor), Diana Mitford [Guiness], her sister Unity (she born in the Canadian hamlet of Swastika) and their parents Lord and Lady Redesdale, as well as Lord Londonderry, the Duke of Buccleuch (brother of H.R.H. the Duchess of Gloucester), Nancy Astor (and American by birth who was a Member oft he British House of Commons) and many others were ardent Nazi supporters. One of especial note was Sir Oswald Mosley–son-in-law of the former Viceroy of India, Lord Curzon, and later Diana Mitford’s 2nd husband, who led the British Union of Fascists.
In America Henry Ford, Charles Lindbergh of Lucky Lindy fame, Prescott Bush, father of President GHW Bush (“41”) and grandfather of “W” “(43”), Senator William Borah, longtime lover of TR’s daughter, Alice Roosevelt Longworth were among the legions of Americans who supported the Nazis well into the late 1930s. All kinds of ordinary Americans approved–after all this was the years of lynching, the resurgence of the [c]lan, and the American eugenics movement.
Both groups had one thing in common: A terror of a “communism” as represented by the Soviet Union. In America, FDR was seen by many as trying to bring in socialism, if not communism. The Nazis seemed to be improving Germany after the “debacle” of the Weimar years (in which an early transgender movement gained the ability to register and live as the “other”–see? Cycles of history). Immigration controls kept out “foreigners.” It was sadly normal to hold antisemitic and racist views, so concern for the Jews of Germany was not great.
The British aristocracy also had the worry of losing their Empire–in a few cases not realizing what a tenuous hold they had over India and other “jewels in the crown.” Lord Francis Scott, uncle of the Duke of Buccleuch, helped govern Kenya.
Stephanie Hohenlohe-Waldenburg-Schillingsfürst, a princess only by a bad marriage, is woven in and out of the story. She gives the red haired prince of today’s wife a run for it. Also discussed are the various ways the countries spied on each other showing, how things like the great Norden bombsight got to the Nazis.
The ridiculous ex-King, the Duke of Windsor, showing exactly where today’s red-haired bearded prince with the awful wife got his genetic inheritance, made as big a mess of things as today’s guy, but with a slightly less over-bearing wife pulling his strings. His cousin, the Old Etonian and grandson of Queen Victoria, Carl Edward, Duke of Saxe-Coburg-Gotha (whose daughter gave birth to Sweden’s King Carl XVI Gustav) led the Nazi Red Cross. Carl’s sister, Princess Alice, Countess of Athlone (who, after the war, would try to rescue him) was married to Queen Mary’s brother. Of course most of this came from Queen Victoria’s insistence on marrying her many children to every European royal house hoping to make peace. The First World War put paid to that, but families are families. [Even during WWII, Lord Mountbatten’s sister and Prince Philip’s aunt, Queen Louise of Sweden (Carl Gustav’s step-grandmother) would pass letters from the “enemy” side of the family to the to the other side).
Eventually, most saw the true light of who Hitler was (another parallel to today’s great awakening about a prominent political figure) and reverted to being true to their country.
My Thoughts
Obviously, I found this fascinating. Prescott Bush was the only unexpected name–most I’ve known about for years. But, in truth, it makes sense. At that time no one knew of the “final solution” and old money is old money–of course he’d support the right and not the traitor to their class, FDR.
It was history repeating itself that I found as interesting as the personalities of those involved. Political history, royal history, economic history–it all repeats. Here was the Prince of Wales [as Edward VIII was then] screaming about deserving a private life away from the press (so go to Balmoral or Sandringham already), here were Americans screaming that the other party wanted a dictatorship, her were the 1% determined to keep people as housemaids and low-wage earners. Here were the Eurotrash of the day exerting their privilege. Here were foreign attempts to influence US opinion…..on and on just like today, It didn’t take social media to invent any of it. Social media just made it easier.
My Verdict
4 stars
Hitler’s Aristocrats by Susan Ronald
I listened to the audio version.