The Colour Out of Space: 4/5 A very interesting story- while it has a bit of a now well-used idea, it was definitely more groundbreaking in its time. Lovecraft is obviously a master of sci-fi and horror, and this is a perfect blend of the two. The only reason I can’t give it 5 stars is how much of a drag it felt like in the first 5 or so pages. One has to be in a certain type of mindset to enjoy this as it is a wordy and heavy story. Fantastic little tale.
The Man with a Thousand Legs: 2/5 Good writing and a pretty good idea but nothing that stood out to me. I like that the yellow tentacle creature was a part of its host and the way the story was told through different people’s accounts, but the idea itself was nothing special and it didn’t stick out to me- but that may be because I’m reading it 90 years too late.
The Vaults of Yoh Vombis: 3/5 I liked the idea of the archaeology mission here but the story itself I found pretty boring and felt like there was only about a page of excitement wedged between the drudgery. I did enjoy the more interesting bits a lot, but this tale didn’t stand out to me and just felt unnecessary.
Who Goes There?: 5/5 A fantastic story that is genuinely chilling and written unbelievably well. The actual logic and science behind this story is something to marvel at especially considering when it was written. The tale itself perfectly displays human nature and paranoia in a seriously talented way, along with being very entertaining and having a great ending. I loved this story and the movie adaptions and would highly recommend it to any sci-fi or horror connoisseur.
They: 2/5 A faster read than a lot of the others in this anthology, this story is a very strange but not quite original read that I can’t say I loved. Most of it follows the man’s experience in a psychiatric hospital, only the last few paragraphs displaying the twist. That being said, it was still well done and likely a pioneer for its time. There’s also a lot of good philosophy here that I quite liked seeing in a genre normally devoid of such.
It Happened Tomorrow: 2/5 The foreword to this was probably my favorite part, the idea of rebelling against a literary industry still remains important to date. The story itself is a bit unrealistic and holds too much literal personification for my taste, but the writing is good and it’s a quicker read considering it’s one of the longest stories in the collection. Its lack of realism is really what ruined it for me along with its unnecessary length, but it wasn’t absolutely terrible and I didn’t hate it.
Asleep in Armageddon: 4/5 I quite liked this story and the writing itself was very fun to read. It was somewhat humorous while also being cleverly entertaining and I liked seeing where it would go. The end was absolutely fantastic and the emotion portrayed throughout was palpable. A good and solid story.
A Walk in the Dark: 4/5 This story was rather spooky and again well written but not horribly exciting. I liked the idea and the ending but it just wasn’t too grabbing for me. That being said, it was a good piece of writing and I did enjoy it.
The Father-Thing: 4/5 I loved the adventurous aspect of this story and the way it followed kids discovering something alien. The creature itself was far more unique in its time but is still rather spooky. I liked this a lot and it was a very solid work.
Born of Man and Woman: 5/5 This was an absolutely fantastic story no matter how short. I love how it’s told from the monster’s point of view and how the people react to it. Loved this so much.
Hell-Fire: 2/5 A good metaphor but a ridiculous story. A devil appearing in the explosion of an atom bomb is somewhat foolish in my opinion, but I do think that this was a fantastic metaphor for the destruction of the then new nuclear age.
Nightmare Gang: 2/5 This story wasn’t too magical and didn’t stand out to me at all really, but the idea was rather unique and I did like the characters. The ending and plot overall wasn’t too riveting and it was rather unrealistic. That being said, the idea was cool.
Soft: 4/5 I really liked this story and it was super unique. The idea of a strange sickness softening the bones was something I’ve never seen before and I loved the way it was portrayed. Overall it was a good story, but there wasn’t as much interest to it as there could’ve been.
Ticket to Heaven: 5/5 I really like the idea for this story but I’m not a huge fan of the writing itself or grammar. That being said, I adored the concept of humans going so far as to disrupt the divine limits that were created to stay unbroken. The ending was absolutely fucking insane and I was open-mouth shocked at it, hence the 5 stars. Such a great concept and philosophical ideology, everyone should read this story at least once.
Metastasis: 4/5 Fantastic start to a story, but it then slowly descends into a weirdness that was genuinely strange to read and somewhat difficult to comprehend. The idea of cancer being so malevolent as to be caused by hell spawn is very unique and was quite well done, and the horror in this story was actually palpable. The ending and the way the main character took out the ‘evil’ was quite confusing and I’m not sure I fully understood it, but it was neat to read.
Orange is for Anguish, Blue for Insanity: 4/5 It pains me to be unable to give this story a 5/5, it does come quite close. The only thing holding it back is that it could’ve been more exciting and a tad less lengthy. I loved the mystery and suspense in this story along with the idea itself, the discoveries made throughout were absolutely captivating and intrigued me greatly. I can’t give it a perfect review but quite want to as I really liked this story.
The Age of Desire: 1/5 I just don’t even know where to start with this story. If rape erotica deemed horror is your thing, then this is for you- but don’t read it, no one should. The description compares it to Frankenstein and claims it shows ‘a monster that sees more clearly than the creator’ and is a ‘sympathetic’ tale. I don’t know how one could ever find sympathy in a serial rapist, even if he was drugged. Worst and most insane 40 pages I’ve ever read, which sucks considering I actually quite like Barker’s other works.
Overall: The average of all the stories was a 3/5, so that’s what I’ll give it. I really like how this anthology brings in a genius side of science fiction. Myriad sci-fi stories don’t follow genuine science or reason, unlike the ones in this collection. It’s nice to see so many authors writing genius stories with real thought behind them. Considering that, it’s not surprise that this collection will take a while to get through. I also really liked the small intros before each story that profiled the author and gave a small description of the tale, it was good to see especially as the book grows older and the authors (sadly) become more obscure.