What do you think?
Rate this book
Spirits' Valley Duology #1
Greywolf's Heart
A man born for war. A bastard raised in contempt. Only together can they defend their tribe from slaughter.
Fierce-hearted Comran is the chief’s son and the favored choice to be the next leader. Then his father chooses Comran’s half-brother Etran for the role, straining the loyalties of the tribe and reinforcing the distance between the two men. When Comran is offered the role of battlewolf, he is ready to do his duty—but expects no friendship in return.
Steady Etran has long been shunned as the chief’s bastard. Becoming the chief brings even more hostility, so he offers Comran the title of battlewolf to maintain tribal unity. But can he trust this reckless warrior as his general when Comran has never stood by his side?
As tensions mount within the tribe, a traitorous act leads to war. Comran and Etran must overcome their inner demons and fight for their brotherhood before the Greywolves fall to their worst enemies.
Fierce-hearted Comran is the chief’s son and the favored choice to be the next leader. Then his father chooses Comran’s half-brother Etran for the role, straining the loyalties of the tribe and reinforcing the distance between the two men. When Comran is offered the role of battlewolf, he is ready to do his duty—but expects no friendship in return.
Steady Etran has long been shunned as the chief’s bastard. Becoming the chief brings even more hostility, so he offers Comran the title of battlewolf to maintain tribal unity. But can he trust this reckless warrior as his general when Comran has never stood by his side?
As tensions mount within the tribe, a traitorous act leads to war. Comran and Etran must overcome their inner demons and fight for their brotherhood before the Greywolves fall to their worst enemies.
468 pages, Paperback
Published July 14, 2022
12 people are currently reading
362 people want to read
About the author
C.M. Banschbach
15 books119 followersC.M. Banschbach is a native Texan and would make an excellent Hobbit if she weren’t so tall. She’s a pizza addict, a multi-faceted fangirl, and a firm believer in being authentic—even if it means acting like a dork sometimes! When not writing fantasy stories packed full of adventure and snark, she works as a pediatric physical therapist where she happily embraces the fact that she never actually has to grow up.
She also writesYA/MG fantasy-adventure as Claire M. Banschbach.
She also writesYA/MG fantasy-adventure as Claire M. Banschbach.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 64 reviews
June 12, 2022
Filled with action, breath-taking settings, and hard journeys, this standalone was the perfect read. I loved Banschbach's deep exploration of the bonds of brotherhood, loyalty, and love. The humor was delightful (as always) and the sweet little twists of romance topped things off with the best of fuzzy feelings.
Perfect for fans of action-adventure that aims straight for the heart.
Perfect for fans of action-adventure that aims straight for the heart.
November 20, 2025
“I swore my oath to you. I have the warriors, but you have my sword. Like you said, we stand together or not at all.”
He tilted a small nod, not quite deep enough to hide the relief flickering in his eyes. “Together.”
“Greywolf's Heart” is the first book in the Spirit’s Valley duology. I’m just going to directly quote the blurb because it perfectly describes this book without giving too much away.
❝Fierce-hearted Comran is the chief’s son and the favored choice to be the next leader. Then his father chooses Comran’s half-brother Etran for the role, straining the loyalties of the tribe and reinforcing the distance between the two men. When Comran is offered the role of battlewolf, he is ready to do his duty—but expects no friendship in return.
Steady Etran has long been shunned as the chief’s bastard. Becoming the chief brings even more hostility, so he offers Comran the title of battlewolf to maintain tribal unity. But can he trust this reckless warrior as his general when Comran has never stood by his side?
As tensions mount within the tribe, a traitorous act leads to war. Comran and Etran must overcome their inner demons and fight for their brotherhood before the Greywolves fall to their worst enemies.❞
“I’ve always wanted a brother.”
I am a sucker for tense sibling relationships, especially if they were raised in competition or were taught to hate each other but deep down they just want to get along. The angst is sweeter to me than whatever a romance plotline could ever come up with. Sadly not that many books focus on sibling relationships so as soon as I discovered this, I picked it up immediately and I had such a great time.
There were some issues I had with the writing such as not enough time being given for the characters to just take in all that they’ve learned or are experiencing. To be fair a war is going on and the book is fast-paced but still I wanted more. Especially more moments between Comran and Entran. But the “Where is my brother” scene made up for it.
“What are you going to do?”
“I am going to get my brother. And if they have killed him, I will tear down the rest of their cursed mountain and bury them all.”
December 9, 2022
I'm going to do you a favor and instead of dumping all my squeals in the beginning, I'll save them for the end...
The Good:
Banschbach once again blew me out of the water with her plot, world-building, and characters. I confess I had my doubts about this one, but as has been the case with her last few releases I've read, I ended up binging this book so hard. I could not put it down, and when I was forced my life to put it down, I found myself still thinking about this book—which means I was obsessed...or I should say, still am. The world-building was well done, reminded me a lot of the stories I tried to make up years ago when I first ventured into writing. The plot was fantastic and every time I wondered where the story would end up, especially with so much of the book left, Banschbach would throw me in for another loop. The characters, though, are the best I've seen yet from Claire. Brilliantly done all the way through, and even the bit of romance was enjoyable!
The Bad:
Almost nothing to say here except...I would have appreciated a glossary. A lot of the terms (especially 'countings') had me so confused when reading and I didn't quite figure them out even by the end. Also, this may have been stylistic, but the way the dialogue and action beats were set up often had me confused by what was exactly going on.
What the Reader Thought:
Like I said above, I had my doubts. This book's concept was *out there* and I wasn't sure whether it'd be something I enjoy. Honestly, I bought it merely because the cover is so beautiful. I need more covers this green and this Celtic and epically cool in my life and on my bookshelves. But the story did live up to everyone's high praise. I absolutely loved it. It's very different from other stuff I've read from Banschbach, but in a good way? Her style was definitely a lot more antiquated, which I absolutely love, and it reminded me of some of my favorite Rosemary Sutcliff novels, which is very high praise from me. Definitely didn't see that coming. It's well deserving of all the love it's received and more. I can't wait for book two!
The Good:
Banschbach once again blew me out of the water with her plot, world-building, and characters. I confess I had my doubts about this one, but as has been the case with her last few releases I've read, I ended up binging this book so hard. I could not put it down, and when I was forced my life to put it down, I found myself still thinking about this book—which means I was obsessed...or I should say, still am. The world-building was well done, reminded me a lot of the stories I tried to make up years ago when I first ventured into writing. The plot was fantastic and every time I wondered where the story would end up, especially with so much of the book left, Banschbach would throw me in for another loop. The characters, though, are the best I've seen yet from Claire. Brilliantly done all the way through, and even the bit of romance was enjoyable!
The Bad:
Almost nothing to say here except...I would have appreciated a glossary. A lot of the terms (especially 'countings') had me so confused when reading and I didn't quite figure them out even by the end. Also, this may have been stylistic, but the way the dialogue and action beats were set up often had me confused by what was exactly going on.
What the Reader Thought:
Like I said above, I had my doubts. This book's concept was *out there* and I wasn't sure whether it'd be something I enjoy. Honestly, I bought it merely because the cover is so beautiful. I need more covers this green and this Celtic and epically cool in my life and on my bookshelves. But the story did live up to everyone's high praise. I absolutely loved it. It's very different from other stuff I've read from Banschbach, but in a good way? Her style was definitely a lot more antiquated, which I absolutely love, and it reminded me of some of my favorite Rosemary Sutcliff novels, which is very high praise from me. Definitely didn't see that coming. It's well deserving of all the love it's received and more. I can't wait for book two!
July 18, 2022
This book is clean as a whistle. Certainly would fall under the YA designation. For those needing to know, there is no smut, nor is there cursing. The word "bastard" appears frequently, but it's used in the literal sense.
The story deals with relationships. Two half-brothers with some heavy sibling rivalry, difficult relations with parents, friendships within the tribe, a sweet tentative romance, etc. There are a few action scenes, but the focus is more on relationship dynamics.
I read a lot of fiction that leans toward military action, settings, and characters. Because of this, I found the warriors to be too touchy-feely and too angsty. But from the YA side, that really isn't a problem. Had I not read so many warrior/soldier stories, I might not have had an issue with all of this. But I have, and I did.
However!
I genuinely liked the characters. I am very forgiving if I like the characters. Plus I have always been a sucker for stories dealing with sibling relationships, for whatever reason, and it was nice to see the brothers develop. This author consistently writes wholesome stories dealing with love, honor, trust, acceptance, encouragement and families. I really enjoyed her book Oath of the Outcast in particular. If she were to write a sequel to this book, I would read it.
The story deals with relationships. Two half-brothers with some heavy sibling rivalry, difficult relations with parents, friendships within the tribe, a sweet tentative romance, etc. There are a few action scenes, but the focus is more on relationship dynamics.
I read a lot of fiction that leans toward military action, settings, and characters. Because of this, I found the warriors to be too touchy-feely and too angsty. But from the YA side, that really isn't a problem. Had I not read so many warrior/soldier stories, I might not have had an issue with all of this. But I have, and I did.
However!
I genuinely liked the characters. I am very forgiving if I like the characters. Plus I have always been a sucker for stories dealing with sibling relationships, for whatever reason, and it was nice to see the brothers develop. This author consistently writes wholesome stories dealing with love, honor, trust, acceptance, encouragement and families. I really enjoyed her book Oath of the Outcast in particular. If she were to write a sequel to this book, I would read it.
April 11, 2024
I am in love with everything Banschbach writes, I just want y’all to understand that.
April 3, 2023
Brothers and giant wolves and sabertooth cats and war and feels and humor and banter and COMRAN! Comran forever. Etran forever toooo. This story of two half-brothers trying to protect their valley and finding out what it’s like to truly be brothers is just . . . ❤ It has my whole heart! The stabbiness, the snark, the feels, the comrades-in-arms . . . It’s everything I love! One of my top-5 favorite reads of 2022. ❤
(Note: I had the honor of being a copyeditor for this, which in no way influenced my views as a reader.)
(Note: I had the honor of being a copyeditor for this, which in no way influenced my views as a reader.)
November 8, 2023
Bros fight for peace for their tribe and family and it is fantastic.
I love the different personalities between the brothers (extrovert, talkative charismatic boi and quiet leader boi) and just their chaotic self-sacrificial selves. Quite enjoyable.
As per usual of Claire's books, there is humor, violence, and courage in darkness.
The brothers go from "...... yeah we don't talk," to "I WOULD DIE FOR MY BROTHER!" *applause*
I love the different personalities between the brothers (extrovert, talkative charismatic boi and quiet leader boi) and just their chaotic self-sacrificial selves. Quite enjoyable.
As per usual of Claire's books, there is humor, violence, and courage in darkness.
The brothers go from "...... yeah we don't talk," to "I WOULD DIE FOR MY BROTHER!" *applause*
July 25, 2023
This was so good! I really enjoyed the world it was set in, and Comran and Etran were both characters I cared about right off the bat. There were a lot of side characters I enjoyed, too. (A couple in particular that I can't mention without spoilers.) And Eska! 😊 I'm not much of a dog person, and I definitely don't want to be a wolf-riding warrior, but I think I'd like an Eska.
Looking back on the plot, I realize...it was actually kind of slow most of the time, even though there were plenty of action scenes. (Great action scenes, by the way!)
I didn't care, though. I was content to follow the journey of those two lugheads trying to figure out what exactly they were to each other. (Um, guys, hello? How about BROTHERS?)
My only complaint would be that certain parts near the end felt rushed. Maybe that's because I knew it was a duology, so I didn't expect it to wrap up everything the way it did for the characters. Even so, I'm excited to read the second book, and will hopefully get to it very soon!
Looking back on the plot, I realize...it was actually kind of slow most of the time, even though there were plenty of action scenes. (Great action scenes, by the way!)
I didn't care, though. I was content to follow the journey of those two lugheads trying to figure out what exactly they were to each other. (Um, guys, hello? How about BROTHERS?)
My only complaint would be that certain parts near the end felt rushed. Maybe that's because I knew it was a duology, so I didn't expect it to wrap up everything the way it did for the characters. Even so, I'm excited to read the second book, and will hopefully get to it very soon!
April 30, 2024
Greywolf’s Heart sucked me in from the first page, the first line. It’s a story about estranged half-brothers, sons of the village chief, who have grown up wary of one another and yet also each secretly longing for that brother relationship, that brotherly bond. When the time comes for the chief to choose which son will be the leader and which son will be the warrior, everyone is surprised by his choice. Now the two brothers must work together and learn what all of this means for them, for their village, and for their very survival against warring clans.
This story is beautiful and poignant and I loved how much it focused on brotherhood. Also, giant cats that men ride into battle… I’m a big fan of that.
This story is beautiful and poignant and I loved how much it focused on brotherhood. Also, giant cats that men ride into battle… I’m a big fan of that.
July 28, 2023
4.5 stars rounded up.
This story was full of so many feels but also a lot of cool action and GIANT KITTIES. DID I SAY THEY RIDE GIANT DOGGOS AND KITTIES????
But back to the feels. Comran and Etran were both so broken, desperate for their father’s love, distrusting of each other. And Etran especially felt so unworthy. Seeing them learn to accept love from their father and from others, including each other, was so beautiful. I loved how they finally called each other brother. <3 restored sibling relationships are really important to me, so this was a really great thing to see.
Their ladies were awesome! I loved both Maren and Sasha. I too was cheering when Etran finally told Maren how he felt. About time. XD I loved how Comran learned Sasha’s signs so he could communicate with her. <3
I don’t even know which animal I’d choose to ride. Probably lynx because, um, big kitty!! But the greywolves are like big fierce puppies. And sablecats are ALSO big cats (though the intro to them in this book was not very flattering, I think we’ll like them more in Saber’s Pride). Maybe it’s just me, but I got some Warriors vibes with defending the territories and cat behavior… probably just me reading Warriors into everything. XD
A few notes of caution. There are some instances where greywolves lose their riders and vice versa. If you’re sensitive to animal death, it might be triggering. Some of the scenes made me cry. Also, the word “bastard” is used frequently. I mean, Etran is literally a bastard child, which is a big point of the plot.
Also, there was a bit of a slow part right before the middle where it was feeling kind of repetitive. But then it picks up again. So never fear.
I’m very excited to see what happens with Davor in Saber’s Pride!
This story was full of so many feels but also a lot of cool action and GIANT KITTIES. DID I SAY THEY RIDE GIANT DOGGOS AND KITTIES????
But back to the feels. Comran and Etran were both so broken, desperate for their father’s love, distrusting of each other. And Etran especially felt so unworthy. Seeing them learn to accept love from their father and from others, including each other, was so beautiful. I loved how they finally called each other brother. <3 restored sibling relationships are really important to me, so this was a really great thing to see.
Their ladies were awesome! I loved both Maren and Sasha. I too was cheering when Etran finally told Maren how he felt. About time. XD I loved how Comran learned Sasha’s signs so he could communicate with her. <3
I don’t even know which animal I’d choose to ride. Probably lynx because, um, big kitty!! But the greywolves are like big fierce puppies. And sablecats are ALSO big cats (though the intro to them in this book was not very flattering, I think we’ll like them more in Saber’s Pride). Maybe it’s just me, but I got some Warriors vibes with defending the territories and cat behavior… probably just me reading Warriors into everything. XD
A few notes of caution. There are some instances where greywolves lose their riders and vice versa. If you’re sensitive to animal death, it might be triggering. Some of the scenes made me cry. Also, the word “bastard” is used frequently. I mean, Etran is literally a bastard child, which is a big point of the plot.
Also, there was a bit of a slow part right before the middle where it was feeling kind of repetitive. But then it picks up again. So never fear.
I’m very excited to see what happens with Davor in Saber’s Pride!
September 20, 2022
Why did I wait so long to read this book?!?!?!
I LOVED IT SO MUCH!
Seriously. I love Comran and Etran. Brotherhood vibes have my heart.
This is a book of relationships: friends, parents, siblings, light romance, and brotherhood. It’s a story of heart, of hope, of forgiveness, of reconciliation, of tears shed, of dreams realised.
My heart strings were tugged and torn to pieces with every page, and tears were most definitely shed.
The battle scenes can only be described as epic, and the animal connections were the sweetest.
I cannot wait for book 2, and in the mean time, I desperately need to read more from Claire!
I LOVED IT SO MUCH!
Seriously. I love Comran and Etran. Brotherhood vibes have my heart.
This is a book of relationships: friends, parents, siblings, light romance, and brotherhood. It’s a story of heart, of hope, of forgiveness, of reconciliation, of tears shed, of dreams realised.
My heart strings were tugged and torn to pieces with every page, and tears were most definitely shed.
The battle scenes can only be described as epic, and the animal connections were the sweetest.
I cannot wait for book 2, and in the mean time, I desperately need to read more from Claire!
December 6, 2023
I almost gave this 3⭐️ because I loved the storyline, but had problems with a few aspects of the writing. However, it gets 4 full ⭐️ because I *really* enjoyed this story once I found my footing, so to speak.
One issue I had was the abbreviated and somewhat inaccurate exposition. The plot got off the ground too quickly—I didn’t know much about the world and I completely misunderstood one of the main characters. More set up would have greatly helped me settle in to the characters and world, so I would have been prepared for the plot.
Another problem I had was that a few story elements seemed abrupt. For example, a man is told his brother’s illegitimacy was a decision between his mother and father (think Abraham, Sarah, & Hagar). Yes, he is shocked, but that was it. He had the information and nothing else was said about it throughout the storyline. I think maybe some reconciliation needed to take place between the father and mothers involved.
Some of the tension between the brothers was confusing. They vascilate in their feelings for each other throughout the story, sometimes showing positive feelings and then swinging back to negative. I get that a lifetime of tension doesn’t disappear overnight, but I felt like it could have been written in a less frustrating way.
Ok, last issue—sometimes the narration and dialogue was confusing. I got the gist of it, but it took me out of the story trying to figure it out.
However, even with all that, the story had me on the edge of my seat and I found myself rooting for these brothers and their tribe. I recommend this book because the great story overcomes the drawbacks.
Content: Lots of battles and war related injuries; torture (not described in process, just the aftermath); within-world curses mentioned, the word b*st*rd is used repeatedly in derision of one of the main characters; infrequent drinking and a mention of getting drunk; light romance involving some kisses and holding, but physical desire is not described (I felt it was tastefully done.)
One issue I had was the abbreviated and somewhat inaccurate exposition. The plot got off the ground too quickly—I didn’t know much about the world and I completely misunderstood one of the main characters. More set up would have greatly helped me settle in to the characters and world, so I would have been prepared for the plot.
Another problem I had was that a few story elements seemed abrupt. For example, a man is told his brother’s illegitimacy was a decision between his mother and father (think Abraham, Sarah, & Hagar). Yes, he is shocked, but that was it. He had the information and nothing else was said about it throughout the storyline. I think maybe some reconciliation needed to take place between the father and mothers involved.
Some of the tension between the brothers was confusing. They vascilate in their feelings for each other throughout the story, sometimes showing positive feelings and then swinging back to negative. I get that a lifetime of tension doesn’t disappear overnight, but I felt like it could have been written in a less frustrating way.
Ok, last issue—sometimes the narration and dialogue was confusing. I got the gist of it, but it took me out of the story trying to figure it out.
However, even with all that, the story had me on the edge of my seat and I found myself rooting for these brothers and their tribe. I recommend this book because the great story overcomes the drawbacks.
Content: Lots of battles and war related injuries; torture (not described in process, just the aftermath); within-world curses mentioned, the word b*st*rd is used repeatedly in derision of one of the main characters; infrequent drinking and a mention of getting drunk; light romance involving some kisses and holding, but physical desire is not described (I felt it was tastefully done.)
July 26, 2022
I know I read this kinda slowly, but that had everything to do with me and nothing to do with this book. And, much like my brain was being obnoxious about focusing on reading the last couple months, it's not wanting to help me write an eloquent review, so this will be random. 😆
The book's setting is sort of Iron Age with some Viking vibes and somehow it just totally works and I loved the world. But also I just want to ride a giant wolf, so...
There's tension and plots and a war, but the main focus of this book is definitely relationships, self-worth, and healing...so obviously I loved it.
We've got two (half) brothers, both of whom have their own struggles with self-worth and father-issues, and both of whom would like a brother but have no idea how to express or go about that. The growth arcs and resolution to the main struggles of the characters is so, so good and so touching.
This book made me emotional several times, in sorrow, anger, and warm, fuzzy feelings.
There's some minor romance plots that are subtle but cute and satisfying.
Definitely recommend if you like:
-Stories about brotherhood/guy bonds
-Stories that let guys show emotion
-Stories that acknowledge the nuance complexity of relationships, that allow side characters to repent and grow, but doesn't brush aside the hurt they've caused (if you *hate* when stories try to put a "but they're your family member, so you have to forgive them" bandaid on poor familial relationships--in this case, father/son--or that act like people never change, this allows room for anger and distrust and struggles to forgive *and* for relationships to potentially mend when the family member admits to fault/regret and makes an honest effort to improve, but also doesn't demand the hurt person act like the hurt didn't happen)
-Wolves (and lynxes)
-Warriors
-Stories about characters unlearning lies about themselves/their value
-Stories with some disability rep (a secondary character is hearing but nonverbal and uses an in-world sign language)
-Low fantasy
This may be for you!
Parts of the first third are maybe a touch slow, but in a way that completely made sense and was necessary for the plot and character development to be realistic.
Content: Violence, death, injuries/blood, use of the word "bastard" as both it's literal and figurative meanings, fake cursing, implied rude hand gestures.
Trigger warnings: Torture (primarily the aftermath and one short scene, bloody but not gory), ostracization, neglectful/difficult-to-please father, mention of miscarriage, animal death.
The book's setting is sort of Iron Age with some Viking vibes and somehow it just totally works and I loved the world. But also I just want to ride a giant wolf, so...
There's tension and plots and a war, but the main focus of this book is definitely relationships, self-worth, and healing...so obviously I loved it.
We've got two (half) brothers, both of whom have their own struggles with self-worth and father-issues, and both of whom would like a brother but have no idea how to express or go about that. The growth arcs and resolution to the main struggles of the characters is so, so good and so touching.
This book made me emotional several times, in sorrow, anger, and warm, fuzzy feelings.
There's some minor romance plots that are subtle but cute and satisfying.
Definitely recommend if you like:
-Stories about brotherhood/guy bonds
-Stories that let guys show emotion
-Stories that acknowledge the nuance complexity of relationships, that allow side characters to repent and grow, but doesn't brush aside the hurt they've caused (if you *hate* when stories try to put a "but they're your family member, so you have to forgive them" bandaid on poor familial relationships--in this case, father/son--or that act like people never change, this allows room for anger and distrust and struggles to forgive *and* for relationships to potentially mend when the family member admits to fault/regret and makes an honest effort to improve, but also doesn't demand the hurt person act like the hurt didn't happen)
-Wolves (and lynxes)
-Warriors
-Stories about characters unlearning lies about themselves/their value
-Stories with some disability rep (a secondary character is hearing but nonverbal and uses an in-world sign language)
-Low fantasy
This may be for you!
Parts of the first third are maybe a touch slow, but in a way that completely made sense and was necessary for the plot and character development to be realistic.
Content: Violence, death, injuries/blood, use of the word "bastard" as both it's literal and figurative meanings, fake cursing, implied rude hand gestures.
Trigger warnings: Torture (primarily the aftermath and one short scene, bloody but not gory), ostracization, neglectful/difficult-to-please father, mention of miscarriage, animal death.
September 21, 2022
How many times can I say Comran and Etran have my heart?
From the beginning, Banschbach’s characters come to life, and I found myself sobbing and reading pages as fast as I could to find what would happen next to my favorites. If you’re a fan of heart-racing action, loyalty, overcoming prejudice, and slow burn romance, don’t wait to pick up this book!
From the beginning, Banschbach’s characters come to life, and I found myself sobbing and reading pages as fast as I could to find what would happen next to my favorites. If you’re a fan of heart-racing action, loyalty, overcoming prejudice, and slow burn romance, don’t wait to pick up this book!
June 26, 2024
Courage has many different forms.
A tale of brothers and brothers-in-arms, honor and loyalty, grit and grace, banter and solemnity. It’s fantastic, and moving, and gripping in its beauty and starkness. (And it has a whole lot of the tropes I’m an absolute sucker for, so that’s fun, too.)
Excellent dialogue and description meets prose that snaps, and there was no unbelievable phrasing or inconsistent detail to distract me from the storyline. The worldbuilding, too, is fascinating and rich, enthralling without being too dense. As she writes, the author trusts her readers to catch on to the intricacies of the world she’s building, dropping just enough hints without ever overloading or info dumping. It’s such a perfect, natural unfolding of detail that richens her world. The spiritual elements are arresting and thought-provoking, in how they’re tribal but still hint unmistakably at the author’s Catholic faith. And the story never slacks in being engaging while remaining beautifully character-driven. Despite its “slower” pace, it’s in no way less gripping.
Comran seemed to me to switch a little abruptly in his feelings about Etran at the beginning of the novel, but that’s only a tiny, tiny thing. In every other way, Comran is a dynamic, achingly real character, with both his admirable qualities and his flaws blazing evidently, rawly, and honestly.
His doubt, his shame and blame towards himself, his turmoil, his health struggles, his fiercely burning love and surging protectiveness, his kindness, his strength…ahhh, I love him. And I identified with him so much, connecting with him instantly and deeply. Oftentimes, too, it’s a deep struggle to create a male character like him without making him effeminate or just plain annoying. Comran, though, was grounded and strong in his convictions and his masculinity without being inconsistent, grating, or unbelievable. He’s just so excellently written, and I admire the author so much for it.
It’s very difficult to get me to fall in love with a story’s protagonist. But Comran snagged my heart immediately and still has it.
Each of C.M.’s other characters was also distinct and vibrant, from Etran with the new mantle of his leadership to Loke with his steady and fortifying presence to Jens’s levity and loyalty…it’s such a difficult thing to pull off, breathing life into a large cast, but the author mastered it so beautifully.
The only characters I didn’t connect with as much were Maren and Sasha, just because I wished I could have seen so much more of them. But they’re still lovely and strong in their own right, and though it took a little longer, they also won me over by the end of the novel. C.M. didn’t try to make them into more than they weren’t or shoehorn them in where they wouldn’t fit. Maren’s unmistakable femininity paired with her fierce warrior strength, and Sasha’s gentleness paired with her flexibility and quiet but unbreakable resolve, rendering them wonderful female characters I would love to read more about.
I felt like a couple of the theme’s aspects could be taken as a heart-centered, trust yourself message flavor. But to me, overall, it was done in a really good way. A way I can take to heart. A way I needed so much.
At least I needed to read about Comran so much. I don’t have his mouth or his impulsiveness, but I do have many of his other qualities. And it was an encouragement to plunge into the struggle with him and come out stronger, more hopeful, and more resolved.
A masterful, non-magical fantasy, with vibrant worldbuilding and admirable character work, Greywolf’s Heart is a keeper. A novel on my shelf that I treasure.
I just loved this book. It’s so excellent. Aching. Bittersweet. Wonderful.
🐺 content: several uses of “bastard” (sometimes in its correct sense and sometimes in a name-calling sense). Violence. A little non-descriptive kissing. Jens makes a joke about wanting to get “roaring drunk.” A man pulls his love interest onto his lap. 🐺
June 18, 2022
I had the immense pleasure of reading an eARC copy of Greywolf's Heart, and all I can say is, WOW. And can I also just say, WOW. I can't remember the last time a book has been so good, and full of such raw emotions, that it left me on the edge of my seat for nearly half the book - if not more. I'm pretty sure at one point I fell off the seat and was hiding one eye behind my hand peeking between my fingers in nervous anticipation of what was to happen next.
There are so many things to love about this story (and not a single thing to hate, in my opinion), but can we talk about the characters? Ugh, the brothers - such an incredible development throughout the story. I loved each and every moment inside their heads. Their fierceness, strength, doubt and loyalty were so real. I was sad when they were sad, hurting when they were hurting. The author did an amazing job of making these two (and all the characters, really) so believable and relatable - It was near bittersweet when the story ended.
And don't even get me started on the Greywolves 😭 (Literal tears - I'm not crying, you're crying - and if you're not crying, you will be).
To say that this was one of my favorite reads in a long time, would be an understatement. So do yourself a favor, and pre-order a copy of this book ASAP. You don't want to miss out on this amazing read. Well done on an incredible story. I'd be lying if I said you weren't one of my new favorite authors. I can't wait to read your other works, and the next installment of this one.
*Immediately goes and buys all other books by said author to read ASAP, lol!
There are so many things to love about this story (and not a single thing to hate, in my opinion), but can we talk about the characters? Ugh, the brothers - such an incredible development throughout the story. I loved each and every moment inside their heads. Their fierceness, strength, doubt and loyalty were so real. I was sad when they were sad, hurting when they were hurting. The author did an amazing job of making these two (and all the characters, really) so believable and relatable - It was near bittersweet when the story ended.
And don't even get me started on the Greywolves 😭 (Literal tears - I'm not crying, you're crying - and if you're not crying, you will be).
To say that this was one of my favorite reads in a long time, would be an understatement. So do yourself a favor, and pre-order a copy of this book ASAP. You don't want to miss out on this amazing read. Well done on an incredible story. I'd be lying if I said you weren't one of my new favorite authors. I can't wait to read your other works, and the next installment of this one.
*Immediately goes and buys all other books by said author to read ASAP, lol!
June 22, 2022
This book was so fun! It was full of wholesome character development and brotherly kinship and I am 1000% here for it.
I didn't entirely know what the plot would be like when I started, but WOW, it was intense and I began to worry about the safety of the characters.
But I loved Comran and Etran. I loved how despite so much awkwardness between them, they tried to make their friendship work. They both have their own personal hurdles, but they don't really let that get in their way of cooperating and holding their tribe together.
Also Etran is a precious cinnamon roll and he always will be.
I don't wanna say too much and spoil things, but just know if you're looking for a story full of excellent characters, HUGE wolves that people ride (I didn't realize the wolves were that big when I started reading XD), a plot that keeps throwing curve balls (and feels), lots of brotherly moments...
Well, you should pick up Greywolf's Heart ASAP.
(I received an eARC in exchange for an honest review)
I didn't entirely know what the plot would be like when I started, but WOW, it was intense and I began to worry about the safety of the characters.
But I loved Comran and Etran. I loved how despite so much awkwardness between them, they tried to make their friendship work. They both have their own personal hurdles, but they don't really let that get in their way of cooperating and holding their tribe together.
Also Etran is a precious cinnamon roll and he always will be.
I don't wanna say too much and spoil things, but just know if you're looking for a story full of excellent characters, HUGE wolves that people ride (I didn't realize the wolves were that big when I started reading XD), a plot that keeps throwing curve balls (and feels), lots of brotherly moments...
Well, you should pick up Greywolf's Heart ASAP.
(I received an eARC in exchange for an honest review)
paused
February 22, 2025Love the premise of this series—putting it on hold until I can give it fuller attention!
May 31, 2025
"Blood is a poor way to judge a man's worth."
So so good. Especially the second half/ending. *cries*
This book now sits on the shelf of my favorite fantasy stories. The worldbuilding, the brotherhood themes, the final chapters with Etran and Comran... *cries again*
CW: One or two short, non-described kisses. One MC is illegitimate, and a huge part of the plot revolves around that. Blood wounds, general war stuff---and a few pretty gruesome torture/just after torture scenes.
So so good. Especially the second half/ending. *cries*
This book now sits on the shelf of my favorite fantasy stories. The worldbuilding, the brotherhood themes, the final chapters with Etran and Comran... *cries again*
CW: One or two short, non-described kisses. One MC is illegitimate, and a huge part of the plot revolves around that. Blood wounds, general war stuff---and a few pretty gruesome torture/just after torture scenes.
September 11, 2022
A beautiful story of brotherhood and healing set amidst an action packed backdrop of rugged wilds, giant wolves, and war. I loved the portrayal of complicated relationships, redeeming them while acknowledging the pain and struggles that come with it. Oh yes, and featuring two absolute disaster boys whom I adore. Though I might be slightly partial to Comran. Mainly cause he's the worst of the disaster boys who's favorite pastimes seem to be snarking off to villains and body-slamming armed men who get too close to his family.
June 24, 2023
A book easy to devour. Never have I read such a good male perspective. A story of messy families, expectations and war.
Reading book 2 immediately!
Reading book 2 immediately!
May 12, 2023
If you love bromances, and you love big giant animal companions, and you love excellent worldbuilding and character development, then you should DEFINITELY read this. It had an atmospheric, pondering feel to it, to me, but it still completely sucked me in. The main characters are half-brothers, estranged and somewhat pitted against each other, and the book follows their journey to maintain peace in their tribe and break down the wall their circumstances have built between them. It's a rich, gorgeous standalone, and I could see myself rereading it to savor all the facets of it.
May 16, 2025
May 2025
Just as good the second time around. I'm quite sure there will be more rereads in the future.
June 2023
I've been hearing good things about this book since it first released, but with no audiobook, it took me a while to get to it. The delay worked in my favor since now I have a shorter wait until book 2 comes out!
Comran and his half-brother have never lived as brothers. Though both desire the bond of brotherhood, the sting of comparison and history of hurt drive them apart. Until one is chosen as chief and the other is not. It seems an unlikely catalyst to close the distance between them, but they will need to stand united to keep their tribe together in the days ahead.
This book is a strong contender to become a comfort re-read for me. Though some of the formatting (particiularly with action beats and dialogues) was distracting, the struggle Comran and Etran to find their place in their world and with each other is fully engaging. The relational tention between two genuinely good people, especially in a scenario devoid of romantic tensions, felt both unique and refreshing. And the battle to defend their village was the stuff of good-old-adventures.
I'll definately be prioritizing other books by this author.
Romance: Both brothers move shyly into recognition of their feelings for women they have first formed friendships with. These blooming relationships are sealed with kisses.
Language: The word "bastard" is used frequently in its literal sense. Swear words are present, but presented in non-English. (For example, scata in place of sh*t)
Religion: The tribes follow a religious system reminiscent of the Norse or perhaps Native Americans. They believe in the All-Father and pray to the spirits.
Violence: Battle is frequently portrayed in a non-graphic way. A character is tortured but the scenes fade to black without becoming gory.
Just as good the second time around. I'm quite sure there will be more rereads in the future.
June 2023
I've been hearing good things about this book since it first released, but with no audiobook, it took me a while to get to it. The delay worked in my favor since now I have a shorter wait until book 2 comes out!
Comran and his half-brother have never lived as brothers. Though both desire the bond of brotherhood, the sting of comparison and history of hurt drive them apart. Until one is chosen as chief and the other is not. It seems an unlikely catalyst to close the distance between them, but they will need to stand united to keep their tribe together in the days ahead.
This book is a strong contender to become a comfort re-read for me. Though some of the formatting (particiularly with action beats and dialogues) was distracting, the struggle Comran and Etran to find their place in their world and with each other is fully engaging. The relational tention between two genuinely good people, especially in a scenario devoid of romantic tensions, felt both unique and refreshing. And the battle to defend their village was the stuff of good-old-adventures.
I'll definately be prioritizing other books by this author.
Romance: Both brothers move shyly into recognition of their feelings for women they have first formed friendships with. These blooming relationships are sealed with kisses.
Language: The word "bastard" is used frequently in its literal sense. Swear words are present, but presented in non-English. (For example, scata in place of sh*t)
Religion: The tribes follow a religious system reminiscent of the Norse or perhaps Native Americans. They believe in the All-Father and pray to the spirits.
Violence: Battle is frequently portrayed in a non-graphic way. A character is tortured but the scenes fade to black without becoming gory.
November 1, 2022
ohmygosh P E R F E C T I O N!
And it's official. Bromance beats romance.
And it's official. Bromance beats romance.
December 6, 2022
If you like wolves, brother stories, epic warriors, snow, pine trees, characters spending way too much of the book wounded in bed and breaking stay-in-bed rules and the rest of the book having fights and character growth and hilarious/epic dialogue (sometimes all at the same time), this book is for you! (I love. . . all those things. *grins sheepishly*)
Comran!!!!! Comran is SO fun. Love him to bits. Very much a fierce hearted, almost reckless, funloving, daring and brave fellow. He gave me slight Achan Cham vibes which I loved.
Etran. . . surprised me. I cannot think of a character pigeonhole for him. He’s not at all what I expected (aka Rhys2.0), he is his own quiet something. He’s just so different. And cool. And epic. Uncertain but also quietly determined and strong except he remember it all the time. Some very unique characteristics going on. And it kind of takes him awhile to get going but once he goes he goes. I think I like him more than Comran. Just a little bit. :D
Shasha is the best!!! Love her so much. Loved how much character she displayed even before she and Comran could communicate, when she had no “dialogue”. Sign language is so cool.
Maren is also a great character. So much going on with her in so few words and pieces of information. Girls by the Banschbach are such a great balance of tough but never over the top while being nice.
Also special shout out: Amend, Jens, Luka, and Loke!!!!!! Love those dudes!!!
(Also, a book with parents??? I liked them. Especially Comran’s mom.)
There were also some Rise of Aredor vibes which I was ecstatic about, because that’s what started me on this whole read-books-by-the-Banchbach-till-the-end-of-time thing. I don’t know. Something about the brothers and the pines and the playful warrior band dynamic.
AND.
WOLVES.
DID I SAY WOLVES??? GIANT WOLVES. TO RIDE ON. AND HUG. AND PET. AND WOLLLLLLLVES. AAAAAAWOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO. Wolves have been one of my favorite animals for like all my life. These wolves don’t talk, but they are very nice and very smart and THEY RIDE ON THEM. FUZZZZZZZZZZZY
The best thing about this book, hands down on da floor, is the ending. <3 <3 <3 All the things about the ending. All the wrap up stuff. It all worked splendidly. I was so pleased.
It’s just. . . a very comfortable read. Like all the characters are my pals.
I’m excited for the sequel/companion. :D
Warnings: think Abraham or Jacob for the romantic backstory and it won’t feel weird at all. Think saints for the spirit stuff and it will feel less weird but still kinda weird, though the All Father is definitely in charge of the universe and the characters know that so. The characters like to use the word on the back cover a lot. Also some kissing. The usual blood and guts.
Comran!!!!! Comran is SO fun. Love him to bits. Very much a fierce hearted, almost reckless, funloving, daring and brave fellow. He gave me slight Achan Cham vibes which I loved.
Etran. . . surprised me. I cannot think of a character pigeonhole for him. He’s not at all what I expected (aka Rhys2.0), he is his own quiet something. He’s just so different. And cool. And epic. Uncertain but also quietly determined and strong except he remember it all the time. Some very unique characteristics going on. And it kind of takes him awhile to get going but once he goes he goes. I think I like him more than Comran. Just a little bit. :D
Shasha is the best!!! Love her so much. Loved how much character she displayed even before she and Comran could communicate, when she had no “dialogue”. Sign language is so cool.
Maren is also a great character. So much going on with her in so few words and pieces of information. Girls by the Banschbach are such a great balance of tough but never over the top while being nice.
Also special shout out: Amend, Jens, Luka, and Loke!!!!!! Love those dudes!!!
(Also, a book with parents??? I liked them. Especially Comran’s mom.)
There were also some Rise of Aredor vibes which I was ecstatic about, because that’s what started me on this whole read-books-by-the-Banchbach-till-the-end-of-time thing. I don’t know. Something about the brothers and the pines and the playful warrior band dynamic.
AND.
WOLVES.
DID I SAY WOLVES??? GIANT WOLVES. TO RIDE ON. AND HUG. AND PET. AND WOLLLLLLLVES. AAAAAAWOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO. Wolves have been one of my favorite animals for like all my life. These wolves don’t talk, but they are very nice and very smart and THEY RIDE ON THEM. FUZZZZZZZZZZZY
The best thing about this book, hands down on da floor, is the ending. <3 <3 <3 All the things about the ending. All the wrap up stuff. It all worked splendidly. I was so pleased.
It’s just. . . a very comfortable read. Like all the characters are my pals.
I’m excited for the sequel/companion. :D
Warnings: think Abraham or Jacob for the romantic backstory and it won’t feel weird at all. Think saints for the spirit stuff and it will feel less weird but still kinda weird, though the All Father is definitely in charge of the universe and the characters know that so. The characters like to use the word on the back cover a lot. Also some kissing. The usual blood and guts.
October 15, 2022
3.5 stars
Two estranged brothers must find a way to defend their tribe from their enemies in a prehistoric world. But they will need to set aside their own conflicts and hurts if they are to be the leaders their people need.
Power struggles, internal politics and a harsh, unforgiving world add to the troubles facing Comran and Etran. The supporting characters add dimension and authenticity to the setting. There is a touch of romance but this is firstly focused on action and the brothers. Through grudging collaboration to a desire for true brotherhood, hardwon and fought for through bloodshed and suffering, their journey is the core of this book.
The characters are deftly drawn. (The giant battlewolves are characters in their own right) There is heart and humor woven throughout. This is a standalone adventure but I was pleased to learn there will be one more story set in this world following different characters!
Two estranged brothers must find a way to defend their tribe from their enemies in a prehistoric world. But they will need to set aside their own conflicts and hurts if they are to be the leaders their people need.
Power struggles, internal politics and a harsh, unforgiving world add to the troubles facing Comran and Etran. The supporting characters add dimension and authenticity to the setting. There is a touch of romance but this is firstly focused on action and the brothers. Through grudging collaboration to a desire for true brotherhood, hardwon and fought for through bloodshed and suffering, their journey is the core of this book.
The characters are deftly drawn. (The giant battlewolves are characters in their own right) There is heart and humor woven throughout. This is a standalone adventure but I was pleased to learn there will be one more story set in this world following different characters!
November 15, 2025
C M BANSCHBACH DOES IT AGAIN absolutely magnificent story. I loved the GIANT WOLVES and the slow burn brotherhood arc brought me LIFE!!! The characters were amazing—Comran was probably my favorite with his chronic inability to stop talking, but I also loved Etran, Loke, and Sasha. Incredible world building and character arcs, and the emphasis of forgiveness and believing in yourself? Absolutely magnificent!! Highly recommend
June 30, 2023
DNF at 40% or around page 170.
I just am not in the mood for this right now. It's pretty slow moving, and it's on my Kindle, which usually means I read it even slower. The brothers aspect is nice, but the overall plot and the world have me yawning at the moment.
I just am not in the mood for this right now. It's pretty slow moving, and it's on my Kindle, which usually means I read it even slower. The brothers aspect is nice, but the overall plot and the world have me yawning at the moment.
December 29, 2024
Just as I had predicted, Greywolf’s Heart ended up being my favorite read of the year. This story captivated me from start to finish and had me on the edge of my seat my the end. I especially loved the themes of brotherhood and the world building! The pacing was well done, and the character development was amazing.
July 12, 2022
There are exactly four authors whose books are automatic buys for me, and Greywolf’s Heart is from one of them.
Setting: unlike anything I’ve ever read
I heard the description ‘prehistoric’ and immediately paused. Ah, then I read the book! And it WORKS. This is (low) fantasy, but the tropes and storyline work immaculately against a backdrop of glacier-fed rivers and sharp mountains, giant animals, and tribe-based politics. Love. Absolutely love.
Characters: achingly familiar to people I dearly love.
When the author describes their main character as a golden retriever in human form—exactly the phrase I use to describe my irl battle buddy (hi love, I’m talking about you)—you sit up and take notice. When the rendition of that character leaves you alternately wheezing with laughter at the similarities and smacking your forehead at the sheer stubbornness, you KNOW you have a winner.
Relationship dynamics: simply the best
Ok, so it’s not a spoiler to say this book revolves around two half-brothers learning to become family in more than just blood. But the way that process played out?! It left me (A) wanting to smack their foreheads together for being too stubborn and (B) shouting ‘just hug already’. Any kind of dynamic relationship, be it romantic or platonic, has to have those types of ups and downs charted, and the author does that flawlessly in this story.
Right. Enough of me nattering on. Read this book if you like low fantasy, impeccable action, large fluffy dogs, angsty family dynamics, and a story where there is always hope. Then go check out the rest of Claire’s books. You won’t be disappointed.
Setting: unlike anything I’ve ever read
I heard the description ‘prehistoric’ and immediately paused. Ah, then I read the book! And it WORKS. This is (low) fantasy, but the tropes and storyline work immaculately against a backdrop of glacier-fed rivers and sharp mountains, giant animals, and tribe-based politics. Love. Absolutely love.
Characters: achingly familiar to people I dearly love.
When the author describes their main character as a golden retriever in human form—exactly the phrase I use to describe my irl battle buddy (hi love, I’m talking about you)—you sit up and take notice. When the rendition of that character leaves you alternately wheezing with laughter at the similarities and smacking your forehead at the sheer stubbornness, you KNOW you have a winner.
Relationship dynamics: simply the best
Ok, so it’s not a spoiler to say this book revolves around two half-brothers learning to become family in more than just blood. But the way that process played out?! It left me (A) wanting to smack their foreheads together for being too stubborn and (B) shouting ‘just hug already’. Any kind of dynamic relationship, be it romantic or platonic, has to have those types of ups and downs charted, and the author does that flawlessly in this story.
Right. Enough of me nattering on. Read this book if you like low fantasy, impeccable action, large fluffy dogs, angsty family dynamics, and a story where there is always hope. Then go check out the rest of Claire’s books. You won’t be disappointed.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 64 reviews