How does music heard and played over many years inform one's sense of home? In Distant Melodies , Edward Dusinberre, the English first violinist of the Tak�cs Quartet, explores changing ideas of home, exile and return in the lives and particular chamber works of four Antonin Dvor�k, Edward Elgar, Bela Bart�k and Benjamin Britten. A resident of Boulder, Colorado for nearly three decades, Dusinberre discovers ways in which music may both accentuate and ameliorate homesickness, as he visits and imagines some of the places crucial to these composers' creative inspiration. Drawn to the storiesof Dvor�k, Bart�k and Britten's American sojourns as they try to reconcile their new surroundings with nostalgiafortheir homelands, Dusinberre looks at his own evolving relationship to England through the prism of Elgar's unusual Piano Quintet and the landscapes that inspired it.New aspects of familiar music reveal themselves under altered circumstances. In the forty-eight years since the Tak�cs Quartet was founded in Budapest, the ensemble has undergone several significant changes of personnel. During a concert tour in Hong Kong and a return to Budapest to perform in the same hall where Bart�k gave his last concert in Hungary, Dusinberre examines how a piece of music may both reinforce roots and cross borders. When travel is forbidden, the ability of music to affirm home and transcend distance takes on extra significance. As the Tak�cs welcomes a new violist during the COVID-19 pandemic, Britten's string quartets shape the ensemble's experience of rehearsing at home.Combining travel writing with revealing and humorous insights into the working lives of string quartet musicians, Distant Melodies illuminates the relationship between music and home.
It was a straight man trying to talk about emotion, and only managing it via talking about music.
There were endless clunky switches between talking re the Takacs Quartet, and the the very interesting theme of "distance" from homeland, with no concept of distance from SELF; in the case of (where it was most jarring):Britten: GAY self; the fact it was never even CONCEIVED of that Britten experienced unrest and inability to settle, or fully inhabit a geographical space, MAY(at least) be have been related to him having been a gay man in a double positionally of being a darling of the establishment and a gayman in an inimical socio-political landscape(he died in 1976).
I thought the chapters on Dvorak(geographical homesicknessness and hiraeth for Czechia being Dvorak's true issues) were both the most emotionally accurate and well-rendered, with some integration of Dvorak's( and the Takacs') music processes and his emotional dislocation; Bartok, as a human, seemed unlocatable, in Dusinberre's faltering account. Elgar, I missed out, because I didn't want to be privy to someone trying to explicate/unentangle a man who wrote utter bombastic colonialist drivel AND some of the most heartfelt music ever...it would have been just too upsetting and excruciating.
I think of Koestenbaum:"The Queens Throat"(1993); this lifts the marriage of music-writing and critical theory and memoir (that Dusinberre seemed to be stabbing at) to a MUCH higher level a degree of emotional wisdom-gay men living fractured lives through the media of opera divas- that a straight man(Dusinberre included) could only dream at.
I want to think music is BEYOND sexual orientation and gender identity; this awkward book tells me this is unlikely; and post-colonial/queer/feminist musicology is a VERY valid field, because it opens up the idea that geography is NOT just place: its a (queer) community, a state of mind, an INNER connection with your tribe; which, yes, can be expressed via music.
A fascinating look at classical music from the inside with in depth looks at the music (and lives) of four composers: Antonin Dvorak, Edward Elgar, Bela Bartok, and Benjamin Britten, from within the prism of of the author’s position of first violinist for Takacs Quartet. And also reflecting how changes in membership of that quartet along with dealing with a much more isolated lifestyle occasioned by Covid has influenced both how he plays as well as how it has changed his approach and appreciation of these composers. Am very glad I picked up a copy of the book after attending a recent concert by the Takacs Quartet here in Portland.