What do you think?
Rate this book
The London Charismatics #4
What the Ravens Sing
A world torn by war. A castle full of secrets. And the darkness of the space between the stars.
In a Europe devastated by four years of conflict, a platoon of elite Italian soldiers is horrifically and mysteriously slaughtered. Strangford’s arcane ability can uncover the truth behind the massacre, but a violent fate stalks him from the trenches. It’s up to Lily to change its course.
To succeed, she’ll need the help of unlikely allies, from the brilliant police inspector who once accused Strangford of murder to an elusive spy full of dangerous secrets—and a friend that Lily once terribly betrayed. Together, they’ll follow a trail of whispers from ice-dimmed caverns to forests haunted by more than wolves where a terrible threat rises, born from the blood-soaked work of Lily’s greatest enemy.
Strangford’s life. The outcome of the war. The future itself. All of it hangs in the balance, carried in the implacable call of a black-winged oracle over a devastated landscape of wire and mud—where Lily must open herself to the darkest potential of a power that could tear her apart.
And hope there is someone left at the end to pull her back together.
Read What the Ravens Sing now and fall into the shattering conclusion of The London Charismatics series.
In a Europe devastated by four years of conflict, a platoon of elite Italian soldiers is horrifically and mysteriously slaughtered. Strangford’s arcane ability can uncover the truth behind the massacre, but a violent fate stalks him from the trenches. It’s up to Lily to change its course.
To succeed, she’ll need the help of unlikely allies, from the brilliant police inspector who once accused Strangford of murder to an elusive spy full of dangerous secrets—and a friend that Lily once terribly betrayed. Together, they’ll follow a trail of whispers from ice-dimmed caverns to forests haunted by more than wolves where a terrible threat rises, born from the blood-soaked work of Lily’s greatest enemy.
Strangford’s life. The outcome of the war. The future itself. All of it hangs in the balance, carried in the implacable call of a black-winged oracle over a devastated landscape of wire and mud—where Lily must open herself to the darkest potential of a power that could tear her apart.
And hope there is someone left at the end to pull her back together.
Read What the Ravens Sing now and fall into the shattering conclusion of The London Charismatics series.
482 pages, Kindle Edition
Published April 1, 2023
90 people are currently reading
560 people want to read
About the author
Jacquelyn Benson
16 books885 followersJacquelyn Benson writes smart historical thrillers where strong women confront the stranger things that occupy the borders of our world.
She once lived in a museum, wrote a master’s thesis on the cultural anthropology of paranormal investigation, and received a gold medal for being clever. She owes a great deal to her elementary school librarian for sagely choosing to acquire the entire Time-Life Mysteries of the Unknown series.
Her debut novel, The Smoke Hunter, was nominated for Best Historical Fiction by RT Times. When not writing, she enjoys the company of a tall, dark, and handsome English teacher and practices unintentional magic.
If you’d like to be friends, you may find her everywhere @jbensonink or join the email list at jacquelynbenson.com.
She once lived in a museum, wrote a master’s thesis on the cultural anthropology of paranormal investigation, and received a gold medal for being clever. She owes a great deal to her elementary school librarian for sagely choosing to acquire the entire Time-Life Mysteries of the Unknown series.
Her debut novel, The Smoke Hunter, was nominated for Best Historical Fiction by RT Times. When not writing, she enjoys the company of a tall, dark, and handsome English teacher and practices unintentional magic.
If you’d like to be friends, you may find her everywhere @jbensonink or join the email list at jacquelynbenson.com.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 75 reviews
November 26, 2023
Listen, I am doing it. I am giving this 5 stars.
It's not the book I liked the most in the series (book 1 is unbeatable for me), but it is such an amazing conclusion I am awarding it all I have.
I hoped, I despaired, I hoped again. I screamed, I laughed, and I cried. Particularly cried. If there could be a way to give a roaring applause on paper, I would.
I commend the author on her meticulous research on WWI (as an Italian, seeing the Alpini in her book warmed my heart) and particularly the settings. In my personal opinion, she really shines when describing Edwardian London, particularly interiors. All the houses and buildings the characters enter come alive in my mind. Because of the story, books 1 and 2 are those in which she can showcase her talent the most. Book 3 happens in a smaller settings that I found it slightly penalized her. Book 4 is all around Europe, and mostly outdoor, but some of the locations still manage to burn through my mind. The house in Luxembourg. The trenches. Even in a moment of the story so packed with tension, I still had to stop and think "wow, this is masterful".
Being this the final book, with all the characters we learned to know and love spread around several countries within an ageing war, it wasn't an easy task to close up all the storylines; but in a way that never felt forced, the author pulls all characters back one after the other, giving them their time to shine one last time, and for us to bid them goodbye as this extraordinary story reaches its conclusion.
This is a story to read, and re-read, and then re-read again. I will never be grateful enough for the day I randomly stumbled across a Kindle promotion, and grabbed the first book because the cover was pretty. Maybe it was the onmyōdō that made it shine brighter than the others in my eyes. Thank you, Jacquelyn. I will take your story and characters with me for a long, long time.
It's not the book I liked the most in the series (book 1 is unbeatable for me), but it is such an amazing conclusion I am awarding it all I have.
I hoped, I despaired, I hoped again. I screamed, I laughed, and I cried. Particularly cried. If there could be a way to give a roaring applause on paper, I would.
I commend the author on her meticulous research on WWI (as an Italian, seeing the Alpini in her book warmed my heart) and particularly the settings. In my personal opinion, she really shines when describing Edwardian London, particularly interiors. All the houses and buildings the characters enter come alive in my mind. Because of the story, books 1 and 2 are those in which she can showcase her talent the most. Book 3 happens in a smaller settings that I found it slightly penalized her. Book 4 is all around Europe, and mostly outdoor, but some of the locations still manage to burn through my mind. The house in Luxembourg. The trenches. Even in a moment of the story so packed with tension, I still had to stop and think "wow, this is masterful".
Being this the final book, with all the characters we learned to know and love spread around several countries within an ageing war, it wasn't an easy task to close up all the storylines; but in a way that never felt forced, the author pulls all characters back one after the other, giving them their time to shine one last time, and for us to bid them goodbye as this extraordinary story reaches its conclusion.
This is a story to read, and re-read, and then re-read again. I will never be grateful enough for the day I randomly stumbled across a Kindle promotion, and grabbed the first book because the cover was pretty. Maybe it was the onmyōdō that made it shine brighter than the others in my eyes. Thank you, Jacquelyn. I will take your story and characters with me for a long, long time.
May 16, 2023
I'll start with this quote by Markus Zusak: "Sometimes you read a book so special that you want to carry it around with you for months after you've finished just to stay near it."
Wow. I get it. This basically sums up this series I just finished. (I spouted a lengthy post about the first book as well.) When I read that What the Ravens Sing would be the "shattering conclusion of the London Charismatics," I was not well. Conclusion?! These characters had become my very dear friends, and I wanted to grow old with them and read all about their adventures and lives for the rest of mine. Haha* It seems silly, but sometimes an author can make you feel so connected to the setting, characters, and storyline that you feel like you're a part of it all. I'll say it: I don't want to leave, and literal tears have formed in my eyes thinking about it (I know, I know ... and it's happened two other times with other books, so oh well). What a wonderful time. Thank you, Ms. Benson, for writing one of my favorite stories. I would NOT be opposed if you changed your mind and continued or did a spin-off with one of the side characters (*cough* Sam Wu). These will definitely be books that I hold close to my heart. Who knew historical fiction fantasy books could do this to a person?
Wow. I get it. This basically sums up this series I just finished. (I spouted a lengthy post about the first book as well.) When I read that What the Ravens Sing would be the "shattering conclusion of the London Charismatics," I was not well. Conclusion?! These characters had become my very dear friends, and I wanted to grow old with them and read all about their adventures and lives for the rest of mine. Haha* It seems silly, but sometimes an author can make you feel so connected to the setting, characters, and storyline that you feel like you're a part of it all. I'll say it: I don't want to leave, and literal tears have formed in my eyes thinking about it (I know, I know ... and it's happened two other times with other books, so oh well). What a wonderful time. Thank you, Ms. Benson, for writing one of my favorite stories. I would NOT be opposed if you changed your mind and continued or did a spin-off with one of the side characters (*cough* Sam Wu). These will definitely be books that I hold close to my heart. Who knew historical fiction fantasy books could do this to a person?
November 13, 2024
Ce final est superbe ! Bouleversant et tenant en haleine jusqu'au bout. On retrouve de nombreux personnages croisés depuis le premier tome. On trouve des solutions et des réponses. C'est grandiose. J'ai beaucoup aimé !
Cette saga des Charismatiques aura été une très belle découverte en audio. ♥
Cette saga des Charismatiques aura été une très belle découverte en audio. ♥
June 6, 2023
Unlike a lot of the near pulp I download and skim ‘for free’ on Kindle Unlimited this is a book to be savoured. I loved this book. There isn’t an ounce of filler anywhere in its 460 pages.
I liked the use of several languages without translations. You want to know what it says? Or do you want to luxuriate in Lily’s bafflement? (I chose the latter) Also the exploration of Lily’s precognition, not some superpower to be used to escape all peril. Who would want to know the future if it could not be changed?
Jacqueline Benson’s use of language is beautiful. The few brief sentences where Lily and Strangford talk about her possible pregnancy had me in tears.
I very much hope that Ms Benson continues to write and revisits the Strangfords post the birth of their twins. I forsee much enjoyable complication …
I liked the use of several languages without translations. You want to know what it says? Or do you want to luxuriate in Lily’s bafflement? (I chose the latter) Also the exploration of Lily’s precognition, not some superpower to be used to escape all peril. Who would want to know the future if it could not be changed?
Jacqueline Benson’s use of language is beautiful. The few brief sentences where Lily and Strangford talk about her possible pregnancy had me in tears.
I very much hope that Ms Benson continues to write and revisits the Strangfords post the birth of their twins. I forsee much enjoyable complication …
April 19, 2023
Loved it!
Loved this ending to this series! I definitely wouldn’t mind seeing more in this series though. I loved the characters and their unique way of moving through the world. It’s also very interesting to read a book that takes place during WWI rather than WWII. I had to keep reminding myself that the Germans mentioned weren’t Nazis yet. WWI definitely gets eclipsed by WWII. And while I take great interest in the latter, I found this glimpse into the former, fascinating. Lily and Strangford have a lovely relationship and I enjoyed seeing how that relationship has evolved since the beginning. Meeting up with Sam Wu again was something I had been looking forward to and I wasn’t disappointed. While their initial reintroduction was a bit awkward, Sam and Lily found their footing with each other again. True friends always find their way back to each other.
Loved this ending to this series! I definitely wouldn’t mind seeing more in this series though. I loved the characters and their unique way of moving through the world. It’s also very interesting to read a book that takes place during WWI rather than WWII. I had to keep reminding myself that the Germans mentioned weren’t Nazis yet. WWI definitely gets eclipsed by WWII. And while I take great interest in the latter, I found this glimpse into the former, fascinating. Lily and Strangford have a lovely relationship and I enjoyed seeing how that relationship has evolved since the beginning. Meeting up with Sam Wu again was something I had been looking forward to and I wasn’t disappointed. While their initial reintroduction was a bit awkward, Sam and Lily found their footing with each other again. True friends always find their way back to each other.
July 11, 2025
Such a good ending to this lovely series! I’m a bit sad that I’ve read them all now.
August 2, 2024
Je remets mes idées en place et je fais une meilleure chronique demain ! Mais Lily et Strangford vont me manquer 🥺
March 5, 2023
The final installment of the Charismatics series was truly fantastic. It’s sad that the series is over, I’ve loved it from the moment I read the first few pages of the first book, and have been in love with the characters from their first lines. Benson did a great job of wrapping up stories and bringing the whole story as a whole to an explosive finish. It was full of action and adventure and twinges of heartbreak.
Lily and Strangford’s relationship in this book was truly beautiful, they are married in this book and that just warms my heart. These two are one of my favourite couples they have bared their souls to each other and despite all the ugliness they love each other with, trust, acceptance, and passion. The moments between them are tender and warm and full of love and some moments were filled with heartbreak that was so beautifully written my heart ached.
This whole story is about Lily trying to prevent horrible things from coming to pass in the final months of World War I, at the possible expense of her husbands' life. She refuses to lose him and their future. Their journey takes them from Paris, to the Swiss alps and down into the occupied German territory of Luxembourg to an old castle, and then to the front line trenches of the war in France. The final battle in the trenches and no man’s land was amazing and was a fitting and epic end to this story.
Sam finally comes back into the story and although he’s changed and done things that will haunt him forever he’s still a favourite. His and Lily’s relationship although a little shattered from previous events is still strong and full of familial love and trust. The small moments between them were heartwarming and also sad and I wouldn’t change any of it. His care and love for those around him and his nonchalant attitude have made him a favourite. The way him and Lily leave things is perfect and brought to this point by the author with great storytelling.
You can tell that the author has done extensive research, and this does not go unnoticed it brings World War I to life with vivid intensity. It feels as if this all actually happened within the madness that was at that time. I loved all the atmosphere that was brought about and the descriptions were wonderful, Benson has some great character lines and prose.
This series has had a special place in my heart since I started reading it and I’ve loved every moment. I will carry these books and characters with me forever, and continue to re-read them over and over.
Lily and Strangford’s relationship in this book was truly beautiful, they are married in this book and that just warms my heart. These two are one of my favourite couples they have bared their souls to each other and despite all the ugliness they love each other with, trust, acceptance, and passion. The moments between them are tender and warm and full of love and some moments were filled with heartbreak that was so beautifully written my heart ached.
This whole story is about Lily trying to prevent horrible things from coming to pass in the final months of World War I, at the possible expense of her husbands' life. She refuses to lose him and their future. Their journey takes them from Paris, to the Swiss alps and down into the occupied German territory of Luxembourg to an old castle, and then to the front line trenches of the war in France. The final battle in the trenches and no man’s land was amazing and was a fitting and epic end to this story.
Sam finally comes back into the story and although he’s changed and done things that will haunt him forever he’s still a favourite. His and Lily’s relationship although a little shattered from previous events is still strong and full of familial love and trust. The small moments between them were heartwarming and also sad and I wouldn’t change any of it. His care and love for those around him and his nonchalant attitude have made him a favourite. The way him and Lily leave things is perfect and brought to this point by the author with great storytelling.
You can tell that the author has done extensive research, and this does not go unnoticed it brings World War I to life with vivid intensity. It feels as if this all actually happened within the madness that was at that time. I loved all the atmosphere that was brought about and the descriptions were wonderful, Benson has some great character lines and prose.
This series has had a special place in my heart since I started reading it and I’ve loved every moment. I will carry these books and characters with me forever, and continue to re-read them over and over.
June 22, 2025
2,75⭐️
•
Bon Bon boooon globalement je suis plutôt déçue : ayant plutôt apprécié les 3 tomes précédents jusqu’alors, ce tome me laisse sur un sentiment d’échec 🫠
•
Clairement ce qui a joué c’est que je l’ai lu en audio et malheureusement ce format je trouve qu’il ne laisse rien passer 🙅🏼♀️ En tout cas, j’ai trouvé le style louuuuurd mais louuuurd en audio, avec des expressions qui tombent comme un cheveu sur la soupe 🍜 Et ça m’a beaucoup sorti de ma lecture sur le premier tier du roman 🤷🏼♀️ (après disons que bon an, mal an, on finit par s’habituer)
•
En plus du style empâté, l’autre truc qui pardonne pas avec l’audio c’est la voix de Lily 🤣🤣 Je vois bien la nécessité de changer d’intonation pour marquer le changement de perso, mais malheureusement le ton choisi la fait passer pour plus débile qu’elle n’est vraiment (déjà que c’est pas fameux…). À un moment, sa voix est décrit comme « Une voix d’enfant geignard qu’elle ne contrôlait pas » bah c’est exactement comme ça qu’elle parle tout du long dans le livre audio DONC PAS OUF en vrai pour sa crédibilité 🤣
•
Ce qui fait la transition parfaite avec l’autre point qui m’a fait dire « bouarf » sur ce tome : Lily c’est quand même pas le pingouin qui glisse le plus loin 🐧 Genre y’a des énormes projecteurs lumineux qui sont braqués sur des évents du récit par l’autrice (donc ✨CLAIREMENT✨ le lecteur il a bien compris ce qui se tramait) et 3 chapitres plus loin t’as Lily qui est « mais non mais pas possible dis-moi pas que c’est pas vrai » 🤦🏼♀️🤦🏼♀️ Donc bon, ça respire pas l’intelligence
•
Globalement j’ai pas trop aimé Lily dans ce tome, elle nous prend la tête et tourne en boucle sur certaines relations 🌀 Et j’étais là « viens on lâche du leste et on avance sur l’intrigue » Intrigue à laquelle j’ai beaucoup moins accroché que les autres tomes malheureusement 🫠 Et j’ai trouvé la fin un peu longuette personnellement 🙈Heureusement que Strangford est resté égal à lui-même, sinon c’était la fin là pour moi 🥸
•
Bref. Une fin de saga décevante pour ma part mais contente d’être allée au bout quand même 🤷🏼♀️
•
Bon Bon boooon globalement je suis plutôt déçue : ayant plutôt apprécié les 3 tomes précédents jusqu’alors, ce tome me laisse sur un sentiment d’échec 🫠
•
Clairement ce qui a joué c’est que je l’ai lu en audio et malheureusement ce format je trouve qu’il ne laisse rien passer 🙅🏼♀️ En tout cas, j’ai trouvé le style louuuuurd mais louuuurd en audio, avec des expressions qui tombent comme un cheveu sur la soupe 🍜 Et ça m’a beaucoup sorti de ma lecture sur le premier tier du roman 🤷🏼♀️ (après disons que bon an, mal an, on finit par s’habituer)
•
En plus du style empâté, l’autre truc qui pardonne pas avec l’audio c’est la voix de Lily 🤣🤣 Je vois bien la nécessité de changer d’intonation pour marquer le changement de perso, mais malheureusement le ton choisi la fait passer pour plus débile qu’elle n’est vraiment (déjà que c’est pas fameux…). À un moment, sa voix est décrit comme « Une voix d’enfant geignard qu’elle ne contrôlait pas » bah c’est exactement comme ça qu’elle parle tout du long dans le livre audio DONC PAS OUF en vrai pour sa crédibilité 🤣
•
Ce qui fait la transition parfaite avec l’autre point qui m’a fait dire « bouarf » sur ce tome : Lily c’est quand même pas le pingouin qui glisse le plus loin 🐧 Genre y’a des énormes projecteurs lumineux qui sont braqués sur des évents du récit par l’autrice (donc ✨CLAIREMENT✨ le lecteur il a bien compris ce qui se tramait) et 3 chapitres plus loin t’as Lily qui est « mais non mais pas possible dis-moi pas que c’est pas vrai » 🤦🏼♀️🤦🏼♀️ Donc bon, ça respire pas l’intelligence
•
Globalement j’ai pas trop aimé Lily dans ce tome, elle nous prend la tête et tourne en boucle sur certaines relations 🌀 Et j’étais là « viens on lâche du leste et on avance sur l’intrigue » Intrigue à laquelle j’ai beaucoup moins accroché que les autres tomes malheureusement 🫠 Et j’ai trouvé la fin un peu longuette personnellement 🙈Heureusement que Strangford est resté égal à lui-même, sinon c’était la fin là pour moi 🥸
•
Bref. Une fin de saga décevante pour ma part mais contente d’être allée au bout quand même 🤷🏼♀️
October 5, 2025
I don't remember the last time I read a book that was this good. Definitely an amazing end to one of my favorite series.
This book has the best of Benson's strengths: a plot that grasps you and keeps you hooked throughout, phenomenal historical research that brings the setting to life in often unexpected ways (her care and attention to including non-white characters in Britain is superb), and deep, nuanced, characters.
I think for me the best thing about it is that although the plot is shaped by outside forces (it takes place in WWI after all), it moves forward through character relationships. Yes, there is war and fighting and battle - but the most interesting thing is Lily's relationship with each of the other characters, and how it changes.
I love Lily's brotherly relationship with Sam and how it grew as they both grew.
I love Lily's relationship with Strangford - now, as a married couple in this book, there was less of the relationship drama about "will they end up together, will they not" and more of the actual love and trust and it was refreshing to see.
I love that Lily's relationship with Strangford in fact never had any of the miscommunication trope.
I love Lily's relationship with *herself* and her power, and how she grows through her experiences and relationships and love.
I love that unlike many strong female leads, Lily doesn't need to minimize or run from her femininity in order to find strength. Her strength is in fact *in* her femininity - and her strength is distinct from the other types of strengths of the characters around her.
I love that Lily grows from not loving nor feeling loved nor imagining herself capable of loving nor feeling loved to loving and being loved by so many people in so many different ways.
The fantasy element was also very creative and added much depth to the story.
Also, as a Muslim, I truly love Kazi's character. It was done so subtly but he was so clearly Muslim - and his character was defined not only by his faith but his very unique quirks as well.
Although in the previous book I felt that the tone was implying that Britain was 100% on the right side of WW1, this book shows more nuances and the capacity humans have for evil on both sides.
I might have more to say later, but this is truly one of my favorite books and probably the best of Benson's writings (out of what I read so far - I can't wait to read more of her work). Cozy, deep, meaningful, imaginative, immersive, and it just felt...real.
This book has the best of Benson's strengths: a plot that grasps you and keeps you hooked throughout, phenomenal historical research that brings the setting to life in often unexpected ways (her care and attention to including non-white characters in Britain is superb), and deep, nuanced, characters.
I think for me the best thing about it is that although the plot is shaped by outside forces (it takes place in WWI after all), it moves forward through character relationships. Yes, there is war and fighting and battle - but the most interesting thing is Lily's relationship with each of the other characters, and how it changes.
I love Lily's brotherly relationship with Sam and how it grew as they both grew.
I love Lily's relationship with Strangford - now, as a married couple in this book, there was less of the relationship drama about "will they end up together, will they not" and more of the actual love and trust and it was refreshing to see.
I love that Lily's relationship with Strangford in fact never had any of the miscommunication trope.
I love Lily's relationship with *herself* and her power, and how she grows through her experiences and relationships and love.
I love that unlike many strong female leads, Lily doesn't need to minimize or run from her femininity in order to find strength. Her strength is in fact *in* her femininity - and her strength is distinct from the other types of strengths of the characters around her.
I love that Lily grows from not loving nor feeling loved nor imagining herself capable of loving nor feeling loved to loving and being loved by so many people in so many different ways.
The fantasy element was also very creative and added much depth to the story.
Also, as a Muslim, I truly love Kazi's character. It was done so subtly but he was so clearly Muslim - and his character was defined not only by his faith but his very unique quirks as well.
Although in the previous book I felt that the tone was implying that Britain was 100% on the right side of WW1, this book shows more nuances and the capacity humans have for evil on both sides.
I might have more to say later, but this is truly one of my favorite books and probably the best of Benson's writings (out of what I read so far - I can't wait to read more of her work). Cozy, deep, meaningful, imaginative, immersive, and it just felt...real.
July 24, 2024
Un quatrième et dernier tome à la hauteur de ces prédécesseurs. J’ai beaucoup aimé qu’on sorte de Londres pour des zones en guerre ou occupées. Ça a donné beaucoup de rythme au récit, qui de par son intrigue est assez dynamique. Je ne me suis pas ennuyée et me suis laissé porter par l’histoire sans chercher à deviner les dénouements. J’ai tellement apprécié cette aventure que je n’ai pas vu le temps passer. Si ce n’est pas un coup de cœur c’est peut être car l’unité du groupe de base me manque ou que j’ai trouvé certains légers défauts. Néanmoins je ressors de ma lecture de cette saga avec un super bon avis. Je trouve que c’est le compromis parfait entre historique et fantastique, saupoudré de supers personnages et questionnements de fonds très pertinents. Je recommande à 200% cette quadrilogie vraiment poétique et attachante qui possède une belle fin qui laisse un sentiment très positif. Foncez.
April 10, 2024
Dernier tome d'une saga que j'ai appris à apprécier avec le temps et dont j'avais hâte de connaître la fin. Bien que le lys de feu n'ait pas du tout été ce à quoi je m'attendais, j'ai fini par me plaire dans cet univers si particulier. Et Jacquelyn Benson a même réussi l'exploit de me faire aimer un roman dont le centre était la Première Guerre mondiale, moi qui ne suis pas du tout fan de tout ce qui a attrait à la guerre.
Nous l'avions vu venir au fil de l'histoire, le lys de feu allait nous conduire à la guerre de 14-18. Je n'avais pas particulièrement hâte. le tome trois nous avait gentiment mis le pied dedans mais cela restait encore assez lointain. Avec Les Vents impérieux Lily et Anthony plongent littéralement dans les combats. Quatre ans ce sont écoulés, nous sommes en 1918 et la guerre fait rage. Les Strangford sont engagés dans les services de renseignements à différents niveaux, mais ils sont "en sécurité" sur le sol anglais. Enfin, en sécurité toute relative car les bombardements sont monnaie courante. Et puis l'inspecteur Kazi refait surface demandant au couple de l'aider sur une affaire sensible qui pourrait tout faire basculer. Sans trop d'hésitation, nos héros acceptent, quitte à ce que la prémonition tant redoutée de Lily se produise.
Parlons de la guerre en premier lieu. Comme je l'ai dit, je ne suis pas fan de ce genre "d'univers" car la guerre représente pour moi toute l'horreur dont sont capables les Hommes. Mais Jacquelyn Benson, en ne nous épargnant rien, réussit ici à donner du réalisme à son histoire, mais sans que je me sois sentie étouffée par les affrontements. Elle a pourtant fait un énorme travail autour de toute cette époque. J'avais clairement l'impression de me retrouver en 1918 et j'ai trouvé le réalisme de ce qu'elle écrivait absolument génial. Que ce soit les zones occupées, les affrontements, la barbarie, le rationnement, toutes les petites choses du quotidien des gens de l'époque, tout y était. Je ne suis pas historienne même si j'ai étudié au cours de mes études la Première Guerre mondiale. Je ne pourrais pas vous dire si tout est réaliste, mais j'y ai cru et rien ne m'a semblé étrange. Une belle réussite, surtout vis-à-vis de mon ressenti.
L'histoire maintenant. le début est très lent. Je ne le nie pas, j'ai eu du mal à vraiment me plonger dans ce dernier tome mais lorsque l'élément déclencheur arrive, ce fut une grande respiration et à partir de là, impossible de lâcher le roman. Il faut dire qu'il y a aussi beaucoup de choses à mettre en place avant de vraiment se lancer dans la dernière ligne droite. Je suis plutôt une lectrice d'action, mais je suis certaine que beaucoup apprécieront la première partie. Car là encore, le texte de Jacquelyn Benson est vraiment très bien travaillé et ne laisse pas indifférent. Quand nous découvrons la grande menace qui pèse sur les Alliés, tout s'accélère, au point où nos deux héros doivent faire appel à d'anciens connaissances pour les aider. Et là, oui, si vous me connaissez, vous savez que c'était tout ce dont j'avais besoin pour adorer ma lecture. Un groupe qui s'unit pour la plus noble des causes, moi, je fonds. le rythme s'accélère, les pics émotionnels aussi, le danger se fait de plus en plus grand, mais rien n'arrêtera nos héros. Et ce n'est pas de l'héroïsme mal placé, si je puis dire, on sent vraiment que Lily, Anthony, Kazy, Sam et tous les autres agissent pour le bien commun, parce que c'est la chose à faire.
Le développement de l'intrigue va crescendo tout en nous offrant une vue globale de la guerre. Il y a aussi de très bonnes réflexions sur un tas de sujets, la guerre s'y prêtant toujours. La partie fantastique a toujours une part dans le récit et je dirais même qu'ici, nos héros sont obligés de se servir de leurs dons comme jamais ils ne l'avaient fait. Ce n'est pas le centre de l'histoire, mais il y a un paroxysme que j'attendais depuis longtemps vis-à-vis de cela. Et je n'ai pu que m'en réjouir.
Il est aussi beaucoup question de famille, au sens large du terme (oui, encore un point que j'adore). Lily et Anthony sont mariés depuis quatre ans et bien entendu cherchent à fonder une famille, mais la guerre remet beaucoup de choses en questions. Sam est de retour et sa relation avec Lily n'est toujours pas au beau fixe... Mais petit à petit on voit ce frère et cette soeur de coeur retrouver la complicité qu'ils avaient. Il est aussi question de George, le frère de Lily (mais que cet homme est un amour), de Craincross, de lord Torrington... des liens compliqués mais qui sont aussi sublimés ici de la plus tendre des façons. Et en ce temps de guerre, c'était ce genre de petites touches qui faisaient que le roman n'était pas trop lourd à lire. Globalement, j'ai adoré les relations diverses et variées que l'on voit évoluer. Sam et Lily restant mes préférés (tout juste derrière Lily et Anthony, je vous rassure) mais la complicité des deux amis m'avait tellement manqué ! Et là, même si rien n'est facile, j'ai adoré les retrouver.
Le dernier tome du Lys de feu est donc un ascenseur émotionnel, une histoire envoûtante et emplie de réalisme avec une héroïne complexe qui évolue à son rythme. La fin était parfaite à bien des égards et je serai clairement au rendez-vous si une autre oeuvre de l'auteur venait à voir le jour en France.
Nous l'avions vu venir au fil de l'histoire, le lys de feu allait nous conduire à la guerre de 14-18. Je n'avais pas particulièrement hâte. le tome trois nous avait gentiment mis le pied dedans mais cela restait encore assez lointain. Avec Les Vents impérieux Lily et Anthony plongent littéralement dans les combats. Quatre ans ce sont écoulés, nous sommes en 1918 et la guerre fait rage. Les Strangford sont engagés dans les services de renseignements à différents niveaux, mais ils sont "en sécurité" sur le sol anglais. Enfin, en sécurité toute relative car les bombardements sont monnaie courante. Et puis l'inspecteur Kazi refait surface demandant au couple de l'aider sur une affaire sensible qui pourrait tout faire basculer. Sans trop d'hésitation, nos héros acceptent, quitte à ce que la prémonition tant redoutée de Lily se produise.
Parlons de la guerre en premier lieu. Comme je l'ai dit, je ne suis pas fan de ce genre "d'univers" car la guerre représente pour moi toute l'horreur dont sont capables les Hommes. Mais Jacquelyn Benson, en ne nous épargnant rien, réussit ici à donner du réalisme à son histoire, mais sans que je me sois sentie étouffée par les affrontements. Elle a pourtant fait un énorme travail autour de toute cette époque. J'avais clairement l'impression de me retrouver en 1918 et j'ai trouvé le réalisme de ce qu'elle écrivait absolument génial. Que ce soit les zones occupées, les affrontements, la barbarie, le rationnement, toutes les petites choses du quotidien des gens de l'époque, tout y était. Je ne suis pas historienne même si j'ai étudié au cours de mes études la Première Guerre mondiale. Je ne pourrais pas vous dire si tout est réaliste, mais j'y ai cru et rien ne m'a semblé étrange. Une belle réussite, surtout vis-à-vis de mon ressenti.
L'histoire maintenant. le début est très lent. Je ne le nie pas, j'ai eu du mal à vraiment me plonger dans ce dernier tome mais lorsque l'élément déclencheur arrive, ce fut une grande respiration et à partir de là, impossible de lâcher le roman. Il faut dire qu'il y a aussi beaucoup de choses à mettre en place avant de vraiment se lancer dans la dernière ligne droite. Je suis plutôt une lectrice d'action, mais je suis certaine que beaucoup apprécieront la première partie. Car là encore, le texte de Jacquelyn Benson est vraiment très bien travaillé et ne laisse pas indifférent. Quand nous découvrons la grande menace qui pèse sur les Alliés, tout s'accélère, au point où nos deux héros doivent faire appel à d'anciens connaissances pour les aider. Et là, oui, si vous me connaissez, vous savez que c'était tout ce dont j'avais besoin pour adorer ma lecture. Un groupe qui s'unit pour la plus noble des causes, moi, je fonds. le rythme s'accélère, les pics émotionnels aussi, le danger se fait de plus en plus grand, mais rien n'arrêtera nos héros. Et ce n'est pas de l'héroïsme mal placé, si je puis dire, on sent vraiment que Lily, Anthony, Kazy, Sam et tous les autres agissent pour le bien commun, parce que c'est la chose à faire.
Le développement de l'intrigue va crescendo tout en nous offrant une vue globale de la guerre. Il y a aussi de très bonnes réflexions sur un tas de sujets, la guerre s'y prêtant toujours. La partie fantastique a toujours une part dans le récit et je dirais même qu'ici, nos héros sont obligés de se servir de leurs dons comme jamais ils ne l'avaient fait. Ce n'est pas le centre de l'histoire, mais il y a un paroxysme que j'attendais depuis longtemps vis-à-vis de cela. Et je n'ai pu que m'en réjouir.
Il est aussi beaucoup question de famille, au sens large du terme (oui, encore un point que j'adore). Lily et Anthony sont mariés depuis quatre ans et bien entendu cherchent à fonder une famille, mais la guerre remet beaucoup de choses en questions. Sam est de retour et sa relation avec Lily n'est toujours pas au beau fixe... Mais petit à petit on voit ce frère et cette soeur de coeur retrouver la complicité qu'ils avaient. Il est aussi question de George, le frère de Lily (mais que cet homme est un amour), de Craincross, de lord Torrington... des liens compliqués mais qui sont aussi sublimés ici de la plus tendre des façons. Et en ce temps de guerre, c'était ce genre de petites touches qui faisaient que le roman n'était pas trop lourd à lire. Globalement, j'ai adoré les relations diverses et variées que l'on voit évoluer. Sam et Lily restant mes préférés (tout juste derrière Lily et Anthony, je vous rassure) mais la complicité des deux amis m'avait tellement manqué ! Et là, même si rien n'est facile, j'ai adoré les retrouver.
Le dernier tome du Lys de feu est donc un ascenseur émotionnel, une histoire envoûtante et emplie de réalisme avec une héroïne complexe qui évolue à son rythme. La fin était parfaite à bien des égards et je serai clairement au rendez-vous si une autre oeuvre de l'auteur venait à voir le jour en France.
August 13, 2025
[Audiobook] Une conclusion très satisfaisante pour cette saga que j’ai adoré suivre en audio !! 🥰
June 27, 2025
….
Comment on enlève cette sensation de vide après avoir terminé un dernier tome d’une saga coup de cœur ?
L’attachement que j’ai pour chacun des personnages est juste énorme. Lily et Strangford en haut de ma liste évidemment. Mais clairement mon chouchou reste bien Sam.
Piouf…. C’est vraiment la fin quoi. La fin d’une saga sur fond de première guerre mondiale (qui apporte tellement à l’histoire). La fin d’une saga sous le signe d’une puissant Found Family pleine d’amour.
J’aurais découvert l’entièreté de la saga sous la version audio et j’ai adoré ça. Je l’ai trouce hyper bien lu et interpreté.
Je ne peux pas dire grand chose de ce 4eme tome. Je ne veux rien spoiler.
Mais lisez cette saga. Donnez-lui sa chance. Embarquez dans au sein des Charismatiques et découvrez leurs pouvoirs (et les faiblesses associées)
Saga coup de cœur quoi 🥹❤️
Comment on enlève cette sensation de vide après avoir terminé un dernier tome d’une saga coup de cœur ?
L’attachement que j’ai pour chacun des personnages est juste énorme. Lily et Strangford en haut de ma liste évidemment. Mais clairement mon chouchou reste bien Sam.
Piouf…. C’est vraiment la fin quoi. La fin d’une saga sur fond de première guerre mondiale (qui apporte tellement à l’histoire). La fin d’une saga sous le signe d’une puissant Found Family pleine d’amour.
J’aurais découvert l’entièreté de la saga sous la version audio et j’ai adoré ça. Je l’ai trouce hyper bien lu et interpreté.
Je ne peux pas dire grand chose de ce 4eme tome. Je ne veux rien spoiler.
Mais lisez cette saga. Donnez-lui sa chance. Embarquez dans au sein des Charismatiques et découvrez leurs pouvoirs (et les faiblesses associées)
Saga coup de cœur quoi 🥹❤️
December 4, 2025
My heart. What a beautiful series! Such a wonderful exploration of the different relationships that make up a life and what it means to be known by the people you love. Such a satisfying ending but I'm so sad it's over!
Read
April 23, 2023what in the W O R LD! happened in this book!!
also just straight spoilers through because this is not a review im once again dumping thoughts (i really have none right now im exhausted buuut it be like that question mark)
I have been thinking about this book for a full day and I'm like !!!!"the big thing is that it is incredibly well-researched... you can see that in every line of the war. I also realized that I very much missed the characters, all of them, and it was pretty cool w Kazi being the catalyst here and so important throughout. I am a little bewildered by the kharisma but it was cool. just kind of what happens when you deal with sort of more tangible but unruly things like time and emotions esp in a historical context. i was and am still very sleep deprived so that didn't really help but woah ok then i guess. what the heck was going on w the bersekers Man. cairncross 0_0. also shoutout to cool fight scenes.
anyway like. really glad to return to this world and the characters. loved the built world from the previous books still was pretty good here even though there was a mad time skip and less focus on building and more on just utter chaos bc yea. war. Lily and Strangford are epic (i have always really liked their romance and that's. unfortunately rare these days) and Kazi too tbh. Estelle and Miss Baird and help what's her name the housekeeper and Cairncross and Gardiner thumbsup GEORGE was AWESOME shoutout to cool brothers and Eversleigh too and then Torrington too and then of course my favorites, Sam and Zhao Min. SAM bro sfjdfiweieyywqERWEIQGSDKGGDSAGEWOG rams head into wall I was reading the ravens part during registration yesterday and i, of course, kept getting interrupted bc i had to, you know, register people, but i was in agony HELLO! i afsdfdkasgskghshdagjds <-- acting like im 15 again with these keyboard slams i'm that tired. sometimes i care very deeply for specific characters out of nowhere and Sam Wu is one of those. and then Zhao Min AFASAFEUWTIOUWQ yeah words have completely fled the premise.
i did pick up the little epilogue story ... cute ! went and yelled in the snap server about the Wus' unfinished stories because :(. i think they are so important to me in part just because of their roles in the story and personalities and then also because i am also a chinese elder sister to a brother.. not in the same way Zhao Min is to Sam.. but idk yea. hm. i desperately!!!! need Sam's story now helloooo wdym ravens and hope and not alone and a mention of Zhao Min at least! she wasn't even there sob it also slapped being able to read the pinyin . Jia indeed.
i don't know if it was just the kindle edition but a lot of the dialogue punctuation was off... lots of periods instead of commas or question marks. im guessing it was just the kindle ed bc the rest of the book seemed perfectly fine.
im very normal about books
also just straight spoilers through because this is not a review im once again dumping thoughts (i really have none right now im exhausted buuut it be like that question mark)
I have been thinking about this book for a full day and I'm like !!!!"the big thing is that it is incredibly well-researched... you can see that in every line of the war. I also realized that I very much missed the characters, all of them, and it was pretty cool w Kazi being the catalyst here and so important throughout. I am a little bewildered by the kharisma but it was cool. just kind of what happens when you deal with sort of more tangible but unruly things like time and emotions esp in a historical context. i was and am still very sleep deprived so that didn't really help but woah ok then i guess. what the heck was going on w the bersekers Man. cairncross 0_0. also shoutout to cool fight scenes.
anyway like. really glad to return to this world and the characters. loved the built world from the previous books still was pretty good here even though there was a mad time skip and less focus on building and more on just utter chaos bc yea. war. Lily and Strangford are epic (i have always really liked their romance and that's. unfortunately rare these days) and Kazi too tbh. Estelle and Miss Baird and help what's her name the housekeeper and Cairncross and Gardiner thumbsup GEORGE was AWESOME shoutout to cool brothers and Eversleigh too and then Torrington too and then of course my favorites, Sam and Zhao Min. SAM bro sfjdfiweieyywqERWEIQGSDKGGDSAGEWOG rams head into wall I was reading the ravens part during registration yesterday and i, of course, kept getting interrupted bc i had to, you know, register people, but i was in agony HELLO! i afsdfdkasgskghshdagjds <-- acting like im 15 again with these keyboard slams i'm that tired. sometimes i care very deeply for specific characters out of nowhere and Sam Wu is one of those. and then Zhao Min AFASAFEUWTIOUWQ yeah words have completely fled the premise.
i did pick up the little epilogue story ... cute ! went and yelled in the snap server about the Wus' unfinished stories because :(. i think they are so important to me in part just because of their roles in the story and personalities and then also because i am also a chinese elder sister to a brother.. not in the same way Zhao Min is to Sam.. but idk yea. hm. i desperately!!!! need Sam's story now helloooo wdym ravens and hope and not alone and a mention of Zhao Min at least! she wasn't even there sob it also slapped being able to read the pinyin . Jia indeed.
i don't know if it was just the kindle edition but a lot of the dialogue punctuation was off... lots of periods instead of commas or question marks. im guessing it was just the kindle ed bc the rest of the book seemed perfectly fine.
im very normal about books
April 4, 2023
Excellent Conclusion to the Series
Jacquelyn Benson’s series, The London Charismatics, concludes with this fourth novel, and the tense, dramatic pace of the previous books continues here to enthrall and engage readers. The First World War seems like much longer removed from us than a mere ninety-some years, but in these novels, the immediacy of the the war, with its hitherto unprecedented scope and violence, seems awfully immediate, current, and extremely relevant to our modern life.
The historical narrative works seamlessly with the supernatural elements of the Charismatics and their intuitive powers. Ash’s house, his physical monument to those powers, with its mystical prophetic murals vividly illustrated by his late wife, has burnt to the ground, leaving the loosely connected but emotionally tethered members of the “family” that Ash formed and nurtured left to their own devices, without a physical space to gather. The fallout of the previous novel’s conclusion has created rifts which are not yet healed as these characters appear throughout this final book.
We perceive the action through Lily’s perspective, as we have from the start, but we are fortunate to renew our acquaintance with Lord Strangford, now Lily’s husband; Estelle, her former neighbor who is a medium, and Estelle’s lover, who researches folklore; Lily’s father, the Earl; Ash’s old friend and curator/librarian, James; brash young pickpocket and animal-communicating Sam, now an RAF pilot, and his mysterious victim-turned-rescuer sister; the marvelous doctor who can diagnose through touch; and even former foe Tariq, the police inspector who almost had Strangford condemned as a murderer. Though most of the characters are involved in some form with the war effort at the beginning of this book, their fight is just beginning.
What the Ravens Sing is a powerful, fast-moving all-out race to prevent the Kaiser’s invading forces from employing a devastating new weapon that will surely end any hope of a free Europe and independent Britain. Lily and Strangford must use every unique ability they possess, and enlist help from others, to avert this grim outcome.
Their success is not without cost, but that’s part of what gives the novel its emotional punch. The pragmatic and the paranormal go hand in hand here, and characters who have more-than-human abilities face questions about how far is too far, as well as struggle with the bigger question of what is life’s purpose amid the intentionally-inflicted suffering that is war.
This fourth book is a worthy, excellent conclusion to a well-written, forceful, and fascinating series. Despite its vividly depicted WWI setting, at its core this series is a journey of self-discovery and -acceptance, not only for its main character, Lily, but for a number of her closest friends and fellow Charismatics and the more normally-gifted individuals with whom they associate. I highly recommend this series to anyone reading my review.
Jacquelyn Benson’s series, The London Charismatics, concludes with this fourth novel, and the tense, dramatic pace of the previous books continues here to enthrall and engage readers. The First World War seems like much longer removed from us than a mere ninety-some years, but in these novels, the immediacy of the the war, with its hitherto unprecedented scope and violence, seems awfully immediate, current, and extremely relevant to our modern life.
The historical narrative works seamlessly with the supernatural elements of the Charismatics and their intuitive powers. Ash’s house, his physical monument to those powers, with its mystical prophetic murals vividly illustrated by his late wife, has burnt to the ground, leaving the loosely connected but emotionally tethered members of the “family” that Ash formed and nurtured left to their own devices, without a physical space to gather. The fallout of the previous novel’s conclusion has created rifts which are not yet healed as these characters appear throughout this final book.
We perceive the action through Lily’s perspective, as we have from the start, but we are fortunate to renew our acquaintance with Lord Strangford, now Lily’s husband; Estelle, her former neighbor who is a medium, and Estelle’s lover, who researches folklore; Lily’s father, the Earl; Ash’s old friend and curator/librarian, James; brash young pickpocket and animal-communicating Sam, now an RAF pilot, and his mysterious victim-turned-rescuer sister; the marvelous doctor who can diagnose through touch; and even former foe Tariq, the police inspector who almost had Strangford condemned as a murderer. Though most of the characters are involved in some form with the war effort at the beginning of this book, their fight is just beginning.
What the Ravens Sing is a powerful, fast-moving all-out race to prevent the Kaiser’s invading forces from employing a devastating new weapon that will surely end any hope of a free Europe and independent Britain. Lily and Strangford must use every unique ability they possess, and enlist help from others, to avert this grim outcome.
Their success is not without cost, but that’s part of what gives the novel its emotional punch. The pragmatic and the paranormal go hand in hand here, and characters who have more-than-human abilities face questions about how far is too far, as well as struggle with the bigger question of what is life’s purpose amid the intentionally-inflicted suffering that is war.
This fourth book is a worthy, excellent conclusion to a well-written, forceful, and fascinating series. Despite its vividly depicted WWI setting, at its core this series is a journey of self-discovery and -acceptance, not only for its main character, Lily, but for a number of her closest friends and fellow Charismatics and the more normally-gifted individuals with whom they associate. I highly recommend this series to anyone reading my review.
April 3, 2023
It is a bit difficult to write a review without giving any spoilers. I had missed the characters and the world of The London Charismatics, and their return was as good as I had expected it to be (I recommend re-reading The Bridge of Ash, to get reacquainted with some of the characters that appear again in What The Ravens Sing.). This time, the story moves from London to the grim reality of the front lines, leading us through a whirlwind of fast-paced action, life-altering decisions, and inner torment (but don’t you worry, Lily and Strangford are as cool as ever). The storytelling is as immersive as in the other three books, it grabs you and drags you into the gripping world of war-torn Europe. There is plenty of action in this one, from nocturnal plane stunts, running across German-occupied territory, and up to fighting an incredible enemy. My favourite scene involves a barn on the way to another country. So heart-warming and lovely and I just wanted to hug one particular character in that scene.
What I loved the most in this book: to my surprise, it was Sam Wu. I liked him a lot in the other books, but in this one he is wonderful, gorgeous, grown-up-but-still-Sam, and an absolute darling. The black coat detail was just the perfect addition. Read the book and you’ll know what I mean (inserts huge grin).
I also ended up having a soft spot for Lily’s brother, George. He is such a solar character, wish he had more stage time.
The ending was really satisfying, and it contained an unexpected element that turned it from great to brilliant. It was a most natural conclusion to all the events that led to the story in What the Ravens Sing.
I have just one tiny bit of complaint, now that the series is over: can we have more Sam in the future, please? Pretty please?
What I loved the most in this book: to my surprise, it was Sam Wu. I liked him a lot in the other books, but in this one he is wonderful, gorgeous, grown-up-but-still-Sam, and an absolute darling. The black coat detail was just the perfect addition. Read the book and you’ll know what I mean (inserts huge grin).
I also ended up having a soft spot for Lily’s brother, George. He is such a solar character, wish he had more stage time.
The ending was really satisfying, and it contained an unexpected element that turned it from great to brilliant. It was a most natural conclusion to all the events that led to the story in What the Ravens Sing.
I have just one tiny bit of complaint, now that the series is over: can we have more Sam in the future, please? Pretty please?
November 12, 2024
Enfin la fin de la saga “Le Lys de Feu” de Jacquelyn Benson que j’ai lue sur toute l’année 2024 en audio. Et quel bonheur que d’avoir la conclusion des aventures de Lily, Strangford, Sam et les autres ! Cette saga se déroule sur plusieurs années au début du XXe siècle et nous apprenons à découvrir les différents personnages.
Lily est une jeune femme qui a des visions d’un avenir inéluctable. Strangford, lui, voit le passé des objets et des gens rien qu’en les touchant… Quand ces deux là se rencontrent, ça fait des étincelles. Ensemble, ils enquêtent, aidés en cela par les différents membres du club tenu par Ash, appelés Charismatiques et tous dotés de pouvoirs. Au fur et à mesure des différents tomes, les enquêtes se suivent mais un fil rouge reste en toile de fond : une vision apocalyptique et funèbre qui se présente régulièrement à Lily.
Dans ce tome, nous avons la conclusion de cette vision. Car toutes les visions de Lily sont inéluctables. Mais arrivera-t-elle à empêcher celle-ci ? Car de cette réussite dépend tout son bonheur et son avenir !
Qu’est-ce que c’était bien ! J’ai adoré suivre toute cette saga en audio avec la voix agréable de la narratrice ! Non seulement l’histoire est magnifiquement menée par l’autrice mais la version audio offre une vraie plus value à ce roman !
J’ai adoré les personnages et leur évolution. Chaque personnage a une vraie consistance et une vraie personnalité en fonction de ses choix et erreurs. C’est vraiment la grosse force de ce roman.
Bref, vous comprenez que j’ai un coup de cœur pour l’ensemble de cette saga et je ne peux que vous encourager à la découvrir !
Lily est une jeune femme qui a des visions d’un avenir inéluctable. Strangford, lui, voit le passé des objets et des gens rien qu’en les touchant… Quand ces deux là se rencontrent, ça fait des étincelles. Ensemble, ils enquêtent, aidés en cela par les différents membres du club tenu par Ash, appelés Charismatiques et tous dotés de pouvoirs. Au fur et à mesure des différents tomes, les enquêtes se suivent mais un fil rouge reste en toile de fond : une vision apocalyptique et funèbre qui se présente régulièrement à Lily.
Dans ce tome, nous avons la conclusion de cette vision. Car toutes les visions de Lily sont inéluctables. Mais arrivera-t-elle à empêcher celle-ci ? Car de cette réussite dépend tout son bonheur et son avenir !
Qu’est-ce que c’était bien ! J’ai adoré suivre toute cette saga en audio avec la voix agréable de la narratrice ! Non seulement l’histoire est magnifiquement menée par l’autrice mais la version audio offre une vraie plus value à ce roman !
J’ai adoré les personnages et leur évolution. Chaque personnage a une vraie consistance et une vraie personnalité en fonction de ses choix et erreurs. C’est vraiment la grosse force de ce roman.
Bref, vous comprenez que j’ai un coup de cœur pour l’ensemble de cette saga et je ne peux que vous encourager à la découvrir !
September 2, 2024
Livre audio – Lu par Adélaïde Poulard : 15h38
Dès la parution du volume 4 en audio, je me suis empressée de l’acheter tant j’avais apprécié les 3 précédents. Mon engouement n’a pas disparu, tant les rebondissements ont été brillamment mis en scène par l’autrice, les traducteurs et la lecture d’Adelaïde Poulard a été une fois de plus excellente, toutes ses intonations donnant vie aux personnages et soutenant les intrigues !
1918, des soldats d’élite italiens ont été littéralement déchiquetés. Lily et Strangford partent en France pour découvrir quelles forces sont capables de ces massacres et risquent de mettre à mal les armées des alliés. Kazi se joint à eux, sans qu’ils ne sachent s’ils peuvent lui faire confiance. L’Histoire est en marche !
L’acmé de la guerre est atteinte et, sans nous épargner les horreurs, l’histoire nous ramène petit à petit à la vie anglaise et ses rituels immuables, consolateurs et apaisants !
Certains personnages seront pour toujours mystérieux et d’autres se sont découverts attachants, de ceux qu’il est toujours eu peu difficile de quitter à la fin d’une saga !
Dès la parution du volume 4 en audio, je me suis empressée de l’acheter tant j’avais apprécié les 3 précédents. Mon engouement n’a pas disparu, tant les rebondissements ont été brillamment mis en scène par l’autrice, les traducteurs et la lecture d’Adelaïde Poulard a été une fois de plus excellente, toutes ses intonations donnant vie aux personnages et soutenant les intrigues !
1918, des soldats d’élite italiens ont été littéralement déchiquetés. Lily et Strangford partent en France pour découvrir quelles forces sont capables de ces massacres et risquent de mettre à mal les armées des alliés. Kazi se joint à eux, sans qu’ils ne sachent s’ils peuvent lui faire confiance. L’Histoire est en marche !
L’acmé de la guerre est atteinte et, sans nous épargner les horreurs, l’histoire nous ramène petit à petit à la vie anglaise et ses rituels immuables, consolateurs et apaisants !
Certains personnages seront pour toujours mystérieux et d’autres se sont découverts attachants, de ceux qu’il est toujours eu peu difficile de quitter à la fin d’une saga !
April 19, 2023
I have really enjoyed reading the London Charismatics series and have been eagerly waiting to read the fourth book.
I would strongly recommend that you read the first three books, otherwise this book won’t make as much sense. Besides the first three books are all excellent stories themselves.
This final book was tense, with lots of action and plot twists. We get to see many of the characters from the other books, although not as much of Estelle, Cairncross and Gardner as we see of Lily, Strangford,Sam and Kazi. I was sure they were goners many times but they always managed to come through.
We finally see the result of Lily’s vision of Strangford at the Front, which was a theme that ran through all four books. I loved how Benson resolved that. Very creative.
I was pleasantly surprised at the sweet plot twist at the very end.
Benson said she may write more books about these characters in the future which would be wonderful. I’d love to hear more about Lily, Strangford, Sam and Gardner who is my particular favourite.
I would strongly recommend that you read the first three books, otherwise this book won’t make as much sense. Besides the first three books are all excellent stories themselves.
This final book was tense, with lots of action and plot twists. We get to see many of the characters from the other books, although not as much of Estelle, Cairncross and Gardner as we see of Lily, Strangford,Sam and Kazi. I was sure they were goners many times but they always managed to come through.
We finally see the result of Lily’s vision of Strangford at the Front, which was a theme that ran through all four books. I loved how Benson resolved that. Very creative.
I was pleasantly surprised at the sweet plot twist at the very end.
Benson said she may write more books about these characters in the future which would be wonderful. I’d love to hear more about Lily, Strangford, Sam and Gardner who is my particular favourite.
September 4, 2024
3.5 rounded up because this series deserves it!
Definitely still maintain my opinion that this series is largely underrated. It’s well-written and has so much depth, with a great cast of characters. But I think after three great books, this fourth one feels slightly repetitive— the same idea applied to a broader scope/plot-line. It’s why by the middle of it I started losing interest. Interestingly enough, I will concede that stopping at the third book makes the series feel incomplete so I went ahead with the last one.
There isn’t anything wrong with this fourth book objectively and technically speaking. In fact, I appreciate how seamlessly the author wove her story into the events of World War II (with cameo appearances by Churchill). I just didn’t feel the stakes as much this time around, perhaps knowing in the back of my mind there would surely be a happy ending. I felt “done” with the series, I suppose? It’s definitely a mood thing on my part.
Please do not let MY mood dissuade you from reading this wonderful series!!!
Definitely still maintain my opinion that this series is largely underrated. It’s well-written and has so much depth, with a great cast of characters. But I think after three great books, this fourth one feels slightly repetitive— the same idea applied to a broader scope/plot-line. It’s why by the middle of it I started losing interest. Interestingly enough, I will concede that stopping at the third book makes the series feel incomplete so I went ahead with the last one.
There isn’t anything wrong with this fourth book objectively and technically speaking. In fact, I appreciate how seamlessly the author wove her story into the events of World War II (with cameo appearances by Churchill). I just didn’t feel the stakes as much this time around, perhaps knowing in the back of my mind there would surely be a happy ending. I felt “done” with the series, I suppose? It’s definitely a mood thing on my part.
Please do not let MY mood dissuade you from reading this wonderful series!!!
December 15, 2025
This is an exciting conclusion to The London Charismatics series! It’s the fourth and final book and should not be read out of order.
The story flashes forward a few years, with Lily and Strangford each doing their part to aid the war effort. When an unexpected request sends them deep behind enemy lines, we reconnect with many past characters as they work to uncover and stop their enemies. Lily must learn how to harness her power and discover what she must sacrifice in order to succeed.
I adored this book! I really enjoyed how it became a grand dangerous adventure across Europe during WWI, featuring historical locations. All of the past characters play their part and work together, making it the perfect way to wrap up the series.
I’m sad to see this beautiful series end, but I’m very happy with how it concluded. I look forward to reading more books by Jacquelyn Benson and plan to start Raiders of the Arcana soon.
Spice 2/5
Plot: 5/5
Writing: 5/5
Narration: 4.5/5
My Enjoyment: 5/5
The story flashes forward a few years, with Lily and Strangford each doing their part to aid the war effort. When an unexpected request sends them deep behind enemy lines, we reconnect with many past characters as they work to uncover and stop their enemies. Lily must learn how to harness her power and discover what she must sacrifice in order to succeed.
I adored this book! I really enjoyed how it became a grand dangerous adventure across Europe during WWI, featuring historical locations. All of the past characters play their part and work together, making it the perfect way to wrap up the series.
I’m sad to see this beautiful series end, but I’m very happy with how it concluded. I look forward to reading more books by Jacquelyn Benson and plan to start Raiders of the Arcana soon.
Spice 2/5
Plot: 5/5
Writing: 5/5
Narration: 4.5/5
My Enjoyment: 5/5
March 11, 2023
Amazing ending! I love the series and this book did not disappoint. The writing is exceptionally good - like always, the plot is thrilling - even more so. Somehow I expected the story to go on where we left, but actually it's a couple of years later during the war, when the charismatics have to fight a new kind of enemy. Lily and Strangford make a very strong couple, they are protective, loving, trusting and know each other like very few can - I loved their duo. Sam is back finally (I missed him) and gets to be a major part of the team. He's battling his demons but Lily never let him doubt that they are family. And what a great family they are. Everything I enjoyed previously is here. This book is gripping and heart wrenching and hopeful and beautiful. It's magic. Thank you for the experience.
August 22, 2023
There are times when reading a book that I'm not sure if the book itself is not enjoyable or what's going on in my life is interfering with my enjoyment of this book. This was one of those times. This series is creative with its portrayals of characters with special, usually burdensome, powers. In this final book of the series, the characters are caught up in WWI. The premise of their investigation surrounding a strange weapon the Germans are using annoyed me for some reason. Their subsequent attempts to stop these weapons strained my credulity. I did, however, overlook the annoyance and skepticism enough to enjoy the action.
January 16, 2024
jacquelyn est une génie
j'ai, cependant, ressenti une frustration avec la fin. elle est belle, sans aucun doute... mais j'attendais tellement plus venant de la "found family trope". meme si l'autrice a réintroduit tous les personnages pour, justement, ne pas les mettre de cote. je ne sais pas... je comprends la symbolique, le sous-entendu, je voulais surement plus. je n'ai même pas pleuré??
je peux dire sans soucis que c'est une de mes sagas favorites
adieu lily et anthony, adieu le refuge, adieu les charismatiques
j'ai, cependant, ressenti une frustration avec la fin. elle est belle, sans aucun doute... mais j'attendais tellement plus venant de la "found family trope". meme si l'autrice a réintroduit tous les personnages pour, justement, ne pas les mettre de cote. je ne sais pas... je comprends la symbolique, le sous-entendu, je voulais surement plus. je n'ai même pas pleuré??
je peux dire sans soucis que c'est une de mes sagas favorites
adieu lily et anthony, adieu le refuge, adieu les charismatiques
May 4, 2025
This was a great series! I throughly enjoyed it. Downton Abbey meets X-men meets Sherlock Holmes. ..maybe. It was good whatever it was. Unique. Refreshingly adult without being “mature content.” Though I will note the 3rd book had a spicy, but closed door scene. The fourth had multiple close doors scenes but notably with less spice.
I was very pleased with the ending. It wasn’t overly obvious to me how it would end. Maybe the author would surprise us, idk. Even now I can see multiple endings I would have liked. The actually one was very satisfying though.
I was very pleased with the ending. It wasn’t overly obvious to me how it would end. Maybe the author would surprise us, idk. Even now I can see multiple endings I would have liked. The actually one was very satisfying though.
November 4, 2025
This book was perfect 😭 What a wonderful ending to a fantastic series!
Jacquelyn has a way of perfectly intertwining magical realism with historical events. Her attention to detail with history and its environment is unmatched; I felt like I was right alongside Lily the entire book.
Lily was fierce, brave, and intelligent. Strangford, my gothic cupcake, was wry, witty, and honorable. Sam broke my heart but still had his loveable charm. I have loved these characters (including the rest of the Ash estate crew) for four books and will greatly miss reading about them 🖤
Jacquelyn has a way of perfectly intertwining magical realism with historical events. Her attention to detail with history and its environment is unmatched; I felt like I was right alongside Lily the entire book.
Lily was fierce, brave, and intelligent. Strangford, my gothic cupcake, was wry, witty, and honorable. Sam broke my heart but still had his loveable charm. I have loved these characters (including the rest of the Ash estate crew) for four books and will greatly miss reading about them 🖤
July 2, 2023
Brilliant ending
This book is clearly what the series has been building up to all along. And it's brilliant. It's so nice to read a series where the ending has been thought through.
I'm sorry to bid farewell to these characters. They have been good companions since the first book was released. I hope Ms. Benson continues to write. I will be pleased to meet new characters in her words.
This book is clearly what the series has been building up to all along. And it's brilliant. It's so nice to read a series where the ending has been thought through.
I'm sorry to bid farewell to these characters. They have been good companions since the first book was released. I hope Ms. Benson continues to write. I will be pleased to meet new characters in her words.
November 11, 2023
4.5/5⭐️
This was a great and satisfying conclusion to the 4-book series of The London Charismatics.
Taking place in multiple European locations during WW1, we see the supernaturally-gifted group reunited as they struggle to overcome a new monstrous war threat from the enemy.
Lots of action, lovely relationships re-established and a neat wrap up. I recommend this entire series and hate to see it end. And yes, I definitely would recommend reading it in order for clarity.
This was a great and satisfying conclusion to the 4-book series of The London Charismatics.
Taking place in multiple European locations during WW1, we see the supernaturally-gifted group reunited as they struggle to overcome a new monstrous war threat from the enemy.
Lots of action, lovely relationships re-established and a neat wrap up. I recommend this entire series and hate to see it end. And yes, I definitely would recommend reading it in order for clarity.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 75 reviews