I’m indebted to Fowler’s faded yellow tome, it served as map, glossary and torch through dozens of evenings during my first two readings of Gravity’s Rainbow. It wasn’t as necessary on this latest complete reading but I did spend more time on the synopsis essays which are nearly Kantian in their need for an ur-code at the core of the novel something as eschatological as the parabola as mandala.
Despite such, or perhaps because of this need to situate each element in an interdependent milieu I do applaud the effort. The scene by scene analysis is indispensable to most newcomers to Pynchon’s supreme achievement. Then again, I’m just a cockeyed optimist awaiting a ghost shirt.
So I went to read Gravity's Rainbow and this reader's guide was beside it on the university library shelf. Knowing GR's reputation as an especially challenging and often frustrating book, I picked up the reader's guide as well, just in case. But all guides are not created equal, and this is not the best choice for someone seeking a side-by-side guidebook to read along with GR.
First, this guide is not spoiler-free. The scene-by-scene section often gives away key surprises by referring to future events in the novel.
Second, the scene-by-scene guide is more of a collection of speculative opinions than an authoritative explanation. Often Fowler seemed to be just as puzzled by Pynchon's meaning as me.
Third, there are multiple typos and misspellings which can be distracting.
However, the first section of Fowler's guide is invaluable to framing GR in a more comprehensible fashion (AFTER you've already read it through at least once). With much praise and insightful explanations, Fowler helped me identify and ruminate on key themes and repeated imagery which helped immensely in understanding Pynchon's writing. I do encourage readers of GR to read through the first 90 pages upon concluding the original text, as it will help to give the book some context and call attention to some underlying structure that I found hard to follow. It really did amplify the meaning of GR for me.
David Cowart has written a fine review of this work which is available online in "Pynchon Notes" No. 5 (http://www.ham.miamioh.edu/krafftjm/p...). I generally agree with Mr. Cowart's review although I cannot help but provide my own meager contribution below.
Douglas Fowler de-mystified "Gravity's Rainbow" and showed us how to read Pynchon's art over 35 years ago. Fowler's work seems to have been rejected and/or mostly ignored for any number of reasons or perhaps for no reason at all. It is ironic that Fowler taught us that Pynchon's trademark is the suspension of plot resolution as a technique for creating terror. In this, Pynchon has no doubt succeeded - that legions of stupefied readers have created, and continue to create, insane and incoherent screeds motivated by fundamentally deficient readings of his work may be Pynchon's most terrifying legacy. However, one questions if this was the terror Pynchon intended. I don't think so. In any case, "A Reader's Guide to Gravity's Rainbow" is highly recommended for anyone who has finished the novel, but now wishes to see it complete.
I was going through a box of old books and discovered they belonged to Douglas Fowler. In the box was this book along with his personal very worn copy of Gravity's Rainbow. It's annotated and there is writing by Fowler on almost every page. What a treasure! I'm so glad I had Fowler's book to help me understand Gravity's Rainbow. If you're out there Fowler I feel honored to come by some of your personal book collection.