Ten years ago, Meghan Chisholm drowned in a creek during a bonfire with friends. When the police investigated, her sister Sam admitted that she had seen enough that night to know that Meghan’s ex-boyfriend, Cal, was behind her sister’s death. At trial, she testified and helped put him behind bars for ten years.
A decade later, each of the now somewhat fragmented Chisholm family receive a mysterious anonymous letter in the mail. Inside, it directs them to a house on the coast of Oregon where they’ll finally learn exactly what happened to Meghan that ill fated night. Is the truth far from what they’ve believed all these years? Or is the invitation a cruel prank on a still grieving family?
Despite the cloak and dagger approach, all six members of the Chisholm family show up at the isolated cliffside home on the designated night. Before they get the truth they all so desperately want, however, Cal is discovered unconscious in his car after running headlong into a tree. Why was he also in the area? Could he have been the one who invited them all there?
Their nightmare suddenly goes from bad to worse, however, when an approaching storm unleashes itself on the the remote Oregon coast. Thrashing the group, they must decide what to do with the now comatose Cal. Against their better judgement, they carry him back to the house. But just as they return, the lights suddenly go out and a downed tree cuts them off from the main road. With no cell service and not another person in sight, they must huddle together and wait out the storm.
But just as they’re coming to terms with being face-to-face with Cal after all these years, it becomes clear that they’re divided on what to do with him. After all, it would be all too easy to let him simply succumb to his already present injuries and claim it was just an accident. Especially since half of the family wants to take the ultimate revenge. The other half, however, merely want answers so they’ll do almost anything to keep the young man alive.
The only thing is, if Cal does regain consciousness, whatever he knows might just reveal that one of their own knows more than they’ve ever said. If that’s true, someone else just might be responsible for Meghan’s death. Have they been grieving side-by-side with the actual killer while an innocent Cal was rotting behind bars? If so, are they trapped in the darkened house with whoever it is right now?
Wow. In one word, I am stunned by the utter brilliance of the writing in One Night. The first of Georgina Cross’s books that I’ve read, I was sucked in by the premise as soon as I read the synopsis. So when I finally picked up my copy and dove in, I was thrilled to instantly fall for the eerie locale, evocative prose, and constantly rising foreboding. Just the same, there were some very real issues here and there, but let’s tackle the selling points first.
Right from the get-go, Cross had me from hello with the magically illustrated impending doom. With a family on the edge all gathered together for what they did not know, their panic and hysteria were perfectly done. Add to that the threatening storm that trapped them alone in the dark without any means of getting help? Well, what can I say… I fell in love on the spot.
It was the plot that had me won over, yet also disappointed just a smidge. After all, for probably two thirds of the book, it felt more like a domestic drama with quite a bit of foreboding than a locked room mystery or psychological thriller. Once I accepted that I wasn’t going to get any shocking twists and turns, I settled down for a riveting tale of a grieving family desperate for answers. Resonating with emotion, it led me down the path of what turned out to be a pretty sad story in the end.
So imagine my surprise when I hit that last third and found one startling reveal after another. Even better, the best one was saved until last, right there in the very finale. I do have to say, however, that I did have to suspend my disbelief as I nevertheless flipped the pages faster and faster. With events that felt somewhat contrived and reactions that rang with just a bit of melodrama, I had to look beyond it to enjoy it all. It was, however, something I was happy to do as I watched this family fully unravel.
My biggest problem, however, was how drawn out the whole evening—and storyline—felt. This was far from action-packed, instead coming across as a long, slow burn that was, at times, just a bit repetitive. In actuality, I believe it all would’ve been much more successful had it been shortened into a hard-hitting novella. But then, that’s just this very non-author’s take on what could’ve amped up the plot.
Ultimately, however, the multiple POVs and timelines wove together in a captivating way to create a gripping and poignant tale that kept me guessing throughout. And while part of the conclusion probably should’ve been readily apparent to me, a shedload of red herrings and plenty of characters hiding unguessable secrets kept me fully in suspense. So as long as you approach this without expecting Agatha Christie-esque vibes, you’ll probably enjoy it just as much as I did. After all, this is one story that actually equaled its beautiful cover. Rating of 3.5 stars.
Trigger warning: death of a daughter/sister, drowning, bullying, mention of: attempted suicide