2.25*
I rated Of Gods and Monsters (book #1) 3 stars. I’ll admit that it wasn’t my favorite book of the year, but I still liked and enjoyed the story. I was even looking forward to reading Of Truths and Bonds (book #2) to find out what was going to happen.
And yet, when I opened the pages of this novel, there was something lost between one book and the next. The writing felt lackluster and the shine of the story had rubbed off. I couldn’t summon a lot of excitement to keep reading and the care I had developed for the characters waned. This book was okay; it was fine and passable and all of the other mediocre terms of blandness you can think of. What life and spark the prior novel had brought, faded into the background. It was sad to watch.
So, where did this book go wrong?
The writing style was choppy and the plot was unconvincing. While the author seemed to have us flit from one scene to the next without a lot of reasoning, explanation, or build, the plot was in the background rushing to hit its points and ‘twists.’ There was so much that didn’t make sense. For example, Quen is described in the previous book and multiple times throughout this novel as being someone who isolates herself, doesn’t tend to develop a lot of strong connections with others, and has a general sense of unapproachability surrounding her. It’s not said that she’s not nice, but in book 1, she admitted to being a little arrogant and had the personality where she didn’t need a lot of friends, just a few close ones. And yet, when she’s put into a situation where her plan is to get to know and win over both the gods that had voted to end her life as well as the minor gods (just to be seen, noticed, and to make it harder for the council to kill her quietly), she suddenly becomes a social butterfly that everyone loves. She makes friends (a lot of friends) – and she makes them quickly. She’s the most popular person around and without even trying, has the backing of individuals she’s barely said two words to. Was everything happening behind-the-scenes? How was she forming such deep connections and bonds with people? It not only felt a bit contradictory (because even if Quen had been able to flip a switch and suddenly become a personable, friendly, and charismatic person – it was something completely out of her comfort zone at the very least), but it also felt incredibly unrealistic and lacked believability.
Similarly, as a continuation of book #1, Archer’s obsession with Quen still baffles me. Maybe there’s more to the story that still needs to be explored and explained, but it’s still as weird by the end of this novel as it was by the end of the previous one.
I didn’t like how Quen reacted to Gray’s past either. Archer shows her one side of the story, but Quen refuses to hear/see Gray’s side for a really long time. While Gray was an idiot for not telling her, I didn’t like how this scientific-minded and analytical researcher refused to gather all of the facts before making her judgements.
Also, Quen drove me absolutely mental with her repeated term of endearment usage. I can be particular about nicknames or terms of endearment, I’ll admit, but the never-ending steam of “Bubba” over and over again made me want to throw up. I couldn’t get through reading a line without cringing, recoiling, and quite literally thinking “OMG gag me” every single time. It was such a distraction from the story and took me out of what was happening each time it was said.
I hated the fact that Cass’ wedding was so insignificant as well. For the brother that she loves and only family she has left (at least from the family that she grew up with), not to mention how much it’s mentioned throughout book #1, the barely-there scene not only made it feel like I was dropped into it from out of nowhere, but it was there and gone before I could even blink.
I didn’t like the ending of this novel either. At this time, there’s not an indication on Goodreads that this is more than a duology, so I didn’t know that this wasn’t the final book of the series when I started it. While that’s not a huge deal, I’m really upset with how the entire book played out. The council vote is hanging over Quen’s head throughout this entire book and by the end, we still have yet to have it. Not only that, but instead of having the vote, Hunter arranges to have Gray arrested (even though that should be part of the council’s decision too and it doesn’t even matter because Gray was just following HUNTER’S orders) and he’s planning on manipulating Quen into marrying him instead (because of her sudden and increased popularity with everyone – something that was questionable in and of itself). Not only does this all lack plausibility and realism, but it was so freaking aggravating to watch Quen and Gray completely ignore Hunter’s leading and highly suspicious questions or really stop to ponder what this controlling and manipulative jerk was scheming. It wasn’t prioritized when they knew it should have been. Their stupidity here isn’t winning the scene any brownie points.
While I think that some of this information definitely should’ve been in book 1, I am glad that we got just a teeny tiny smidge more world-building and answers to questions. They weren’t good answers, but they were answers. Nevertheless, the world-building still wasn’t very impressive and I wish the author would’ve taken the time to develop her world a bit more.
Even though the book ends on a cliff-hanger and I wouldn’t hate getting a cliff-notes rundown of what was going to happen next, the magic of this world and the story are gone. I don’t have any interest or drive to read the next book (or finish the series).