Perhaps it is because I haven't reviewed anything here in a while, but it's difficult for me to give an accurate description of this book. The word 'Pymish', of course, comes to mind, but it only says something to somebody who has read Pym before, and this somebody likely doesn't need this here review.
So, it is often said that nothing happens in Pym's novels. Having just read a particularly dramatic instalment from a novel by Dickens, I understand where this is coming from; but thinking about life in general, I cannot agree with this any more than I can agree that nothing worthy of interest ever happens to married women. I mean, however humble our excitements and disappointments might seem, this is our life, so of course, for us, they are meaningful.
This is less 'light & bright & sparkling' than 'Excellent Women', but less sad than 'Quartet in Autumn'. It is an amusing read, but with a strong undertone of melancholy. I enjoyed it, but I kept wishing that the protagonist would get something better than what she gets, or maybe than anybody in a Pym novel ever gets.
And it's very difficult to quote this novel: every quote I've looked at is so tongue in cheek. Like this one:
'Yes, but I suppose we should all be able to make our lives sound romantic if we took the trouble to write about them,' I said.
This is said at the very beginning of the novel, and as it comes from our narrator, one would suppose that this is a kind of foreshadowing; but this is more akin to a private joke from the author.
If you like quiet, understated, slightly ironic books, this is for you. (And maybe not for you if you're looking for a lot of dramatic action).
P. S. I loved it that there is a very minor character called Miss Pim :)