Rating books has more to do with where I am in life than the book itself. I'm coming to the end of my life as a priest and I didn't find this work "useful" nor did it give me any new insight since I've read versions of the stories and quotes elsewhere. There is something childlike in some of the desert fathers stories, they are simple, can be read literally, though that may never have been their purpose. I am not inspired by stories of demons who throw rocks at the saint or the fact that in his life though he constantly defeats the demons, the life never allows him to be completely victorious and it shows an ambivalent attitude toward victory. For partly he is so admired as a saint because he suffers so, and if he triumphs over demons than he is not suffering, so it is a dilemma for his biographer. He wants him victorious since he is a saint, but he can only be a saint if he is constantly suffering and struggling so he can never triumph once and for all. It makes me wonder what role the Cross or Resurrection of Christ plays in the life, for we sing constantly that demons have been utterly defeated and overthrown, and in baptism demons are exorcised forever. And yet in these monastic stories demons ride roughshod over everyone and seem totally unaffected by Christ or baptism or the Cross. They have free reign not only to spiritually torment but to physically torment as well thought they are bodiless beings. One wonders where the angels are and where God is. After Macarius' life time of torment by demons, God finally protects him from the rocks being thrown by demons. One has to wonder why didn't God do that all along?