I can't remember when was the last time I read a firefighter story, but The One That Got Away delivered everything I was hoping for: a sweet romance between Bryce and Krystal (though they certainly fought it, and it's all pretend, right?), seeing firefighters in action (and be left humbled and grateful for their service), the camaraderie and banter between the crew of MRFD, and of course, the learning to seek God's will and guidance for the future and the plans one may have. I must admit I'm not a fan whenever matchmakers pop up, but I enjoyed how it worked in this story to bring the two MCs (and their fake relationship plan) together. It was also great getting to enjoy small-town life (with its pros and cons), and while I haven't read the Bloom Sisters series, it didn't take away from my understanding and enjoyment of this book (though it did make me want to go, pick it up, and work my way through them).
Overall, a great Christian Contemporary Romance, perfect for fans of the genre, the author, and/or the firefighter, and fake relationship tropes. I seriously can't wait for Monica and Jake's story! ~ 5 stars