The Case of The Cat Crazy Lady was a typical, first of a series, cozy mystery, called Buttercup Bend Mysteries. The name of the town is Buttercup Bend, feeling a little bit like Cabot Cove because cozy mystery writers seem to love alliterative appellations. Typical because the novel uses standard tropes that are a bit paint-by-the-number: nosy wannabe investigators, non-likeable murder victims, a profuse number of red herrings, and a few literal and figurative save the cat moments.
Here, Maggie Broom (the eponymous Cat Lady) is found murdered with a house full of cats and the accompanying smell. When the will is read, her brother and sister receive a small portion of the inheritance, but her house and the bulk of her money goes to the animal rescue and cemetery nearby. Cathy and her brother Doug Carter are the beneficiaries of that major amount, and yet, Cathy and her friend, Nancy, will do some investigating because they are curious (nosy AF) neighbors.
Doug's wife is pregnant, which is meant to increase drama. The Broom siblings are mostly unlikeable characters, but they are not the only ones. I think Grandma Florence, who raised Cathy and Doug, is the most gregarious and loving person. There are nice touches, but really there's not much to the mystery. It's a tepid story that moved me very little. For a story with the word Crazy in the title, there was a great deal of sanity to the story.
The story was better than OK but merely good. Ergo, I call this one down the middle.