3.5! Rounded up for Goodreads
I read Gwendy's Button Box by Stephen King and Richard Chizmar two summers ago. I rated it 5 stars and had this to say,
"Every good story, even a short one, has conflict--maybe something dangerous or threatening so that our protagonist can work through it and grow, make choices, handle the conflict. In this story, we get to ask ourselves, what would you do?"
I highly recommend reading the first book before jumping into this one for two reasons; the first is that Gwendy has a character arc that starts back in Button Box when she's twelve years old and in Magic Feather, she's in her late thirties. That's a lot of life experience! Secondly, there are so many flashbacks and references to Button Box that readers would feel cheated out of knowing everything the rest of us know going into this book. Richard Chizmar does a fine job catching potential new readers up to speed but I still think it would be beneficial. No need to re-read though, there's enough refresh for those of us who read it already.
The first half (about 150 pages) of Gwendy's Magic Feather was a little slow going for me. I enjoyed learning about all of Gwendy's accomplishments and relationships but then the novelty of that wore off pretty quickly and I found myself growing impatient with the day-to-day transcription of a pretty normal, uneventful life.
There were a few sub-plots introduced: Something from Gwendy's past resurfaces and there are some girls that have gone missing in Castle Rock (Gwendy's hometown) that catch her attention. However, there are many chapters that go by where Gwendy is at the office, hanging out with her parents, jogging, eating, bathing and I started longing for the story to get interesting.
Finally, around the halfway mark--there are some juicy plot developments and from here on, I was rapidly turning pages and getting more and more invested as the story moved on. I only wish that the compelling nature of a specific plot development happened earlier so that the reader could spend more time thinking about it--everything gets resolved rather quickly and without much fanfare or complication. Just sort of a *slap-slap-of-the-hands* and that's a wrap! All the loose ends are tied up neatly and all our burning questions are answered, which in some ways is satisfying but in other ways, it feels like the reader wasn't trusted to work things out for ourselves. There weren't very many breadcrumbs to trail after.
I did love the supernatural elements Chizmar brought into the story to add some magic. The ending was especially sweet and potentially left open for another Gwendy adventure? I'd be all for it.
I would recommend this book to readers who love: The first book, short chapters, illustrations (yes! This book has lovely pictures!), magical realism, cozy mysteries, YA literature, Castle Rock tales, and supernatural elements.