I love when I come upon a book at random, with little to no expectations, and I end up not being able to put it down because it is so good. The Mourning Sexton was one of those books. Given to me in a bag of books that a co-worker brought in (he gifts me books he finishes by the bag full, which is extremely wonderful), I decided after putting together a new set of bookshelves that I'd start selecting books at random to read. This was my first "grab".
Though I had to consult the glossary in the back, as well as ask a friend of mine at times to explain, some of the Jewish traditions and ceremonies, after awhile I felt that I understood more about the religion, and what the title refers to. It was exciting to learn about a part of life I have little experience with, and it helped to ground the lead character, David, into something about himself that had no real bearing on the central mystery, but was necessary to bring him to life, all the same.
This was a crime mystery which involved politics, journalists, lawyers and corruption in the courts and justice system. Not a unique genre in that regard, but what was unique is the redemption story that exists within the criminal mystery. My favorite part of this book had to do with that redemption, and the humanity at the core of it all. I especially enjoyed the friendship between David and his friend/partner in law, Seymour - their relationship was rich and complex and believable, and the strongest in the story. I like that our lead was not perfect, that even in his "redemption" there were flaws.
My only criticism of the story was that the female characters were not as richly drawn as the male ones. I wanted to know more of Dulcie than we saw, though I know she was only seen from the perspective of David, I still wanted a few more conversations that would tell her story. Judith, the "dead girl" of the case, I could understand not being painted in full form as she was only brought to life in pieces left behind, but I did want Dulcie to be richer, as well as David's daughter, Lauren. I will say, I was glad that the underlying "romance" of the book was kept on a back burner. I believed in its existence, I just didn't think it needed to take center stage, so I was glad it didn't.
There was great suspenseful moments in this book that kept me turning the page, and the short chapters worked in the pace of the story, keeping it moving at times as fast as I could read. For a first novel I'd say this was a good read, and the author shows tremendous promise. I will definitely seek out another from him when I have the opportunity.