What do you think?
Rate this book
Natalie Marsh #5
Come, Gentle Night
After her entanglement in several homicide investigations, psychologist Natalie Marsh is determined to avoid further trouble. But when her intern needs help monitoring and calming family drama for the duration of a party, Natalie steps up. After all, acting as a peacemaker at a fundraising gala seems relatively risk-free in comparison to her past escapades—what could happen at a dance? When an argument between feuding guests becomes assault, Natalie realizes the situation is more complicated than she anticipated, with one man at the center of it all: Rowan Montrose.
Four years ago, Rowan’s brother was convicted of murdering his wife. But Rowan believes there’s more to the story, suspecting that the real murderer is walking free. His romantic interest in the younger sister of a police detective renders him more determined than ever to clear the family name. Familiar with Natalie’s reputation, he seeks out her assistance. Natalie tries to decline—she’s no private detective—but as frightening incidents unfold, it’s clear she’s in the middle of this whether she wants to be or not, and breaking through the layers of deception that hide the truth may have lethal consequences.
Four years ago, Rowan’s brother was convicted of murdering his wife. But Rowan believes there’s more to the story, suspecting that the real murderer is walking free. His romantic interest in the younger sister of a police detective renders him more determined than ever to clear the family name. Familiar with Natalie’s reputation, he seeks out her assistance. Natalie tries to decline—she’s no private detective—but as frightening incidents unfold, it’s clear she’s in the middle of this whether she wants to be or not, and breaking through the layers of deception that hide the truth may have lethal consequences.
296 pages, Paperback
First published November 2, 2022
13 people are currently reading
154 people want to read
About the author
Stephanie Black
24 books278 followersStephanie Black has loved books since she was old enough to grab the pages, and has enjoyed creating make-believe adventures since she and her sisters were inventing long Barbie games filled with intrigue and danger or running around pretending to be detectives. She is a four-time Whitney Award winner for Best Mystery/Suspense novel.
Stephanie lives in California, in the Bay Area. She plays the violin in a community symphony (but never practices enough), enjoys homemade chocolate-chip cookies, and takes pictures of birds. Her favorite activity is spending time with her family, currently consisting of her husband, five kids, three kids-in-law, a cat, and three grandpets.
Stephanie lives in California, in the Bay Area. She plays the violin in a community symphony (but never practices enough), enjoys homemade chocolate-chip cookies, and takes pictures of birds. Her favorite activity is spending time with her family, currently consisting of her husband, five kids, three kids-in-law, a cat, and three grandpets.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 79 reviews
November 3, 2022
Wowsers!!! I know I can always count on Stephanie Black to make me lose sleep at night because I just can't set her books down! I'm reading along and thinking "just one more chapter," as I fight to keep my eyes open and my book is bashing me in the face.
If you're a fan of suspense/thriller books, you need to pick up these Natalie Marsh books! I didn't start with the first book when I first picked them up and then went back and enjoyed them. As I read this I felt like readers who are picking up book #5 without having read any of the previous books, they'd be able to dive right in and enjoy it and not feel lost. The author gives back info that fills in the pertinent info. But I like them all that I suggest reading or listening to them all.
The characters are well developed and the relationships between all of the characters are built up and leave you thinking there's no way any of them could be the one causing all of the problems. Oh, but you'll be shocked by all of the twists and turns and what happens throughout the book. Poor Natalie, she needs a break. Maybe one of these books, the author will give her a break. Hahaha! I was guessing and guessing and making many conjectures of who, what, where and why. I'm happy to say I guessed right on some but I guessed wrong on other aspects. But it was sooooo good! I love when an author keeps me guessing throughout the whole book.
Get ready for some great reading material when you pick this one up. And don't forget that you might lose sleep as well. I wish you luck!!!
Content: Clean. This book is clean and written very well even with the suspense/thriller content. There are murders and such but the author does a great job of not being overly graphic and keeping it clean that a wide age range can read and enjoy her books. The main character is married but there are only a couple kisses throughout the book and nothing further. I'd let my older teenagers read/listen to it. They have the previous books and really enjoy them.
I received a copy from the pubisher, Covenant Communications, via NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions in the review are my own.
Happy Reading!!!
If you're a fan of suspense/thriller books, you need to pick up these Natalie Marsh books! I didn't start with the first book when I first picked them up and then went back and enjoyed them. As I read this I felt like readers who are picking up book #5 without having read any of the previous books, they'd be able to dive right in and enjoy it and not feel lost. The author gives back info that fills in the pertinent info. But I like them all that I suggest reading or listening to them all.
The characters are well developed and the relationships between all of the characters are built up and leave you thinking there's no way any of them could be the one causing all of the problems. Oh, but you'll be shocked by all of the twists and turns and what happens throughout the book. Poor Natalie, she needs a break. Maybe one of these books, the author will give her a break. Hahaha! I was guessing and guessing and making many conjectures of who, what, where and why. I'm happy to say I guessed right on some but I guessed wrong on other aspects. But it was sooooo good! I love when an author keeps me guessing throughout the whole book.
Get ready for some great reading material when you pick this one up. And don't forget that you might lose sleep as well. I wish you luck!!!
Content: Clean. This book is clean and written very well even with the suspense/thriller content. There are murders and such but the author does a great job of not being overly graphic and keeping it clean that a wide age range can read and enjoy her books. The main character is married but there are only a couple kisses throughout the book and nothing further. I'd let my older teenagers read/listen to it. They have the previous books and really enjoy them.
I received a copy from the pubisher, Covenant Communications, via NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions in the review are my own.
Happy Reading!!!
October 30, 2022
Bravo Stephanie Black, well played! What a rollercoaster ride! I love it when a mystery keeps me guessing. Usually, I’m pretty good at figuring out whodunit before the end. Not this story! This mystery was so full of twists and turns and just when I thought I’d figured it out, there was a new clue. Not only was the mystery fabulous, but I loved the relationships, the humor, and the overall themes. I also enjoyed the nods to one of Shakespeare’s most famous plays. So well done!
Natalie Marsh is a psychologist who frequently finds herself in the middle of police investigations. Now married, she and her husband have a countdown to see how long they can go without a police entanglement. Needless to say, it’s not long. While attending a benefit for the women’s shelter owned by her intern’s father, Natalie and Gideon are asked to keep an eye on two young men. When the night ends in disaster, Natalie once again finds herself involved in a mystery.
Detective Bartholomew’s sister Jenna is visiting for the summer and attends the same benefit. There she meets Rowan, a handsome young English major, and there’s an instant attraction between them. When Rowan is confronted by a cop, things quickly go downhill.
Rowan has a reason to mistrust the police. His brother Brett was accused of murdering his wife, but he believes he was framed by a cop. As Rowan and Jenna work to clear Brett’s name, they wind up in unimaginable trouble. When someone ends up dead, Rowan is the first to be blamed, but is he guilty or a victim? Natalie of course is right in the middle of it trying to determine fact from fiction and putting her own life in danger.
Murder, feuds, young love, an angry mother, a meddling neighbor, a questionable cop, and a host of other suspects make this story so hard to put down. The ending will have you on the edge of your seat. It’s a must read for mystery lovers. While it’s the fifth book in the series, it can definitely be read as a standalone. Those familiar with the series will especially love this. It’s a cozy clean mystery akin to an Agatha Christie or Mary Higgins Clark novel. I received an advanced complimentary copy from the author and publisher. All opinions are my own and I was not required to provide a positive review.
Natalie Marsh is a psychologist who frequently finds herself in the middle of police investigations. Now married, she and her husband have a countdown to see how long they can go without a police entanglement. Needless to say, it’s not long. While attending a benefit for the women’s shelter owned by her intern’s father, Natalie and Gideon are asked to keep an eye on two young men. When the night ends in disaster, Natalie once again finds herself involved in a mystery.
Detective Bartholomew’s sister Jenna is visiting for the summer and attends the same benefit. There she meets Rowan, a handsome young English major, and there’s an instant attraction between them. When Rowan is confronted by a cop, things quickly go downhill.
Rowan has a reason to mistrust the police. His brother Brett was accused of murdering his wife, but he believes he was framed by a cop. As Rowan and Jenna work to clear Brett’s name, they wind up in unimaginable trouble. When someone ends up dead, Rowan is the first to be blamed, but is he guilty or a victim? Natalie of course is right in the middle of it trying to determine fact from fiction and putting her own life in danger.
Murder, feuds, young love, an angry mother, a meddling neighbor, a questionable cop, and a host of other suspects make this story so hard to put down. The ending will have you on the edge of your seat. It’s a must read for mystery lovers. While it’s the fifth book in the series, it can definitely be read as a standalone. Those familiar with the series will especially love this. It’s a cozy clean mystery akin to an Agatha Christie or Mary Higgins Clark novel. I received an advanced complimentary copy from the author and publisher. All opinions are my own and I was not required to provide a positive review.
October 28, 2022
I've been reading these Natalie Marsh mystery books since the very beginning and I'm always so excited to get a new one. Natalie is a character with smarts and a gift for patience but she is also a trouble magnet. And when I say trouble, I mean death and destruction kind of trouble. It's frightening. Just ask her husband. Poor guy. He is always put through the ringer. I don't know how they both don't have PTSD.
This mystery was so well crafted. I love suspecting everyone and finding the truth right along with the characters. This one had me so invested from beginning to end. The danger had a growing momentum that had me reading so fast, I had to purposely slow myself down. I was in such a hurry to find out the "who done it" that I was missing the good stuff. I'm impatient like that.
The ending was awesome. I loved how everything came together. I'm a fan of this author and her mysteries. So, so good.
This book releases on Nov. 2nd! It is part of a series and I think you will be happier if you read it in order because Natalie will feel like a friend and you will know her history. But, I think you could read it as a stand alone.
Content: violence, death, peril. Kissing.
- I received a complimentary copy of this book. All opinions expressed are my own.
This mystery was so well crafted. I love suspecting everyone and finding the truth right along with the characters. This one had me so invested from beginning to end. The danger had a growing momentum that had me reading so fast, I had to purposely slow myself down. I was in such a hurry to find out the "who done it" that I was missing the good stuff. I'm impatient like that.
The ending was awesome. I loved how everything came together. I'm a fan of this author and her mysteries. So, so good.
This book releases on Nov. 2nd! It is part of a series and I think you will be happier if you read it in order because Natalie will feel like a friend and you will know her history. But, I think you could read it as a stand alone.
Content: violence, death, peril. Kissing.
- I received a complimentary copy of this book. All opinions expressed are my own.
September 14, 2022
Jemma meets Rowan at a fundraising gala for Daffodil House. Violet Devin is an intern with Nefesh Bria and has asked Natalie Marsh to act as a peacemaker during some family drama but, it ends up being more than she bargains for.
Rowan Montrose is convinced that his older brother, Brett was wrongly accused of murdering his wife, and he is convinced that Natalie can help him.
For me, the beginning and the middle was slow and lethargic, but I stuck with and I am glad I did because after Jemma Bartholomew stopped making really bad choices, which we all do under stressful situations, she was able to see that not everyone was doing her a favor. Sometimes I can get lost with all the information in a mystery but in Come, Gentle Night, I wasn’t. There were lots of loose ends in the beginning but everything by the end is explained. I really enjoyed this.
My gratitude to Covenant Communications and NetGalley. All opinions expressed are honest and mine.
Rowan Montrose is convinced that his older brother, Brett was wrongly accused of murdering his wife, and he is convinced that Natalie can help him.
For me, the beginning and the middle was slow and lethargic, but I stuck with and I am glad I did because after Jemma Bartholomew stopped making really bad choices, which we all do under stressful situations, she was able to see that not everyone was doing her a favor. Sometimes I can get lost with all the information in a mystery but in Come, Gentle Night, I wasn’t. There were lots of loose ends in the beginning but everything by the end is explained. I really enjoyed this.
My gratitude to Covenant Communications and NetGalley. All opinions expressed are honest and mine.
November 21, 2022
This book should come with a warning label: DO NOT START AT NIGHT. Basically, do not start reading this book if you want to get anything else accomplished, because once you get a couple of chapters into the story you aren't going to be able to put it down!
Stephanie Black is one of my favorite clean suspense authors and I'm always excited for another Natalie Marsh book. That poor woman has been through the wringer, and I hope she and her husband have a good therapist because somehow she always finds herself mixed up in these dangerous situations. I'd definitely have nightmares on a regular basis if I'd experienced what Natalie's been through. Only Natalie Marsh trying to help her intern keep an eye on a couple of people at a fundraiser can turn into a fight for her life!
I loved the Romeo and Juliet vibes in the story--from the bad decisions Jemma and Rowan kept making to the scene in the cemetary. I feel the author did a great job incorporating those elements into the story. There were a few great suspects and for once I was right about one of them (go me because this rarely happens), but the other one completely took me by surprise!! And that ending!!! I was not prepared for it and immediately texted my book besties about my surprise. I didn't give any spoilers but I had to let them know to be prepared--it's what we book besties do!
You don't have to read the previous books in the series before reading this one but I recommend you do so you can see Natalie and Gideon's relationship from the beginning and you'll also see Natalie's relationship with a few of the characters that are in this book. The series starts with Not a Word.
I received a complimentary copy from the publisher Covenant Communications via NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions expressed in this review are my own.
Stephanie Black is one of my favorite clean suspense authors and I'm always excited for another Natalie Marsh book. That poor woman has been through the wringer, and I hope she and her husband have a good therapist because somehow she always finds herself mixed up in these dangerous situations. I'd definitely have nightmares on a regular basis if I'd experienced what Natalie's been through. Only Natalie Marsh trying to help her intern keep an eye on a couple of people at a fundraiser can turn into a fight for her life!
I loved the Romeo and Juliet vibes in the story--from the bad decisions Jemma and Rowan kept making to the scene in the cemetary. I feel the author did a great job incorporating those elements into the story. There were a few great suspects and for once I was right about one of them (go me because this rarely happens), but the other one completely took me by surprise!! And that ending!!! I was not prepared for it and immediately texted my book besties about my surprise. I didn't give any spoilers but I had to let them know to be prepared--it's what we book besties do!
You don't have to read the previous books in the series before reading this one but I recommend you do so you can see Natalie and Gideon's relationship from the beginning and you'll also see Natalie's relationship with a few of the characters that are in this book. The series starts with Not a Word.
I received a complimentary copy from the publisher Covenant Communications via NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions expressed in this review are my own.
May 26, 2023
I'm a fan of the Natalie Marsh series and this one kept me guessing right up until the very end!
Psychologist Natalie and her husband, Gideon, find themselves deep in a murder mystery, thanks to her intern needing some help with a little family drama. This intriguing, and seemingly guilty, cast of characters was as mysterious as a Clue game.
There are so many reasons to pin the murder (turned murders) on a wide variety of people. As the clues slowly unravel and come to a thrilling reveal, I was completely captivated. This dangerous tale is one of Stephanie Black's finest and I was engrossed from start to finish.
Content: mild moments of danger/peril; non-graphic murders; mild romance
*I received a complimentary copy through Netgalley. All thoughts and opinions are my own and were voluntarily given.*
Psychologist Natalie and her husband, Gideon, find themselves deep in a murder mystery, thanks to her intern needing some help with a little family drama. This intriguing, and seemingly guilty, cast of characters was as mysterious as a Clue game.
There are so many reasons to pin the murder (turned murders) on a wide variety of people. As the clues slowly unravel and come to a thrilling reveal, I was completely captivated. This dangerous tale is one of Stephanie Black's finest and I was engrossed from start to finish.
Content: mild moments of danger/peril; non-graphic murders; mild romance
*I received a complimentary copy through Netgalley. All thoughts and opinions are my own and were voluntarily given.*
November 2, 2022
This next book in the Natalie Marsh series is off the charts! The suspense, the action, the whodunnit, I was suspecting everyone! Black pulls the reader straight into Natalie and Gideon’s world and doesn’t let them go until the last word is read. The mystery alone keeps the reader page turning but add in all of the suspense and crazy situations and this book is unputdownable! Warning: do not start this book at night! You will not be able to put it down once you start reading it. This one is a sleep thief that keeps you engaged until the very last page. If you love suspense novels Come, Gentle Night is a must read! I couldn’t put it down, I flew right through the pages. This can definitely be read as a standalone but it is a part of a series. I received a copy of this book for free; all thoughts and opinions are my own.
November 12, 2022
The Natalie Marsh Mystery Series has been so good and all of the stories, although connected, have also been very different. This novel held many surprises and things I didn't guess until almost the end. Natalie Marsh is a psychologist by trade. The problem is, she always finds herself in the middle of some murder mystery. Her poor husband has a hard time keeping up with her and gets so stressed worrying about Natalie...and for good reason. It's like trouble sniffs her out despite her always trying to do the right thing and help people.
There is a lot of action; car chases, homicide, drugging, and kidnapping to name a few. Please know, there is nothing too graphic in the storytelling. As far as crazy twists and turns you will find plenty of them. Just when you think you can sit back and proudly say you know what is happening, you're in for another curveball that leaves you wondering what you just read.
If you are a fan of this series it's an absolute must that you read this fifth book. If you've never read a Natalie Marsh Mystery, you could read this and still enjoy it but like I always recommend, you'll have a much richer experience with the characters if you've read the previous books. Stephanie Black has another hit on her hands with Come, Gentle Night.
There is a lot of action; car chases, homicide, drugging, and kidnapping to name a few. Please know, there is nothing too graphic in the storytelling. As far as crazy twists and turns you will find plenty of them. Just when you think you can sit back and proudly say you know what is happening, you're in for another curveball that leaves you wondering what you just read.
If you are a fan of this series it's an absolute must that you read this fifth book. If you've never read a Natalie Marsh Mystery, you could read this and still enjoy it but like I always recommend, you'll have a much richer experience with the characters if you've read the previous books. Stephanie Black has another hit on her hands with Come, Gentle Night.
May 28, 2022
Ohmyword, so much going on with this story!
Natalie and Gideon indeed get their "entanglement with the police" punch-cards punched once again despite the situation not having anything directly to do with them. But involved they get in several situations and by the time they figure out how severe they are, it's too late to back out.
In true Stephanie Black fashion, there's a lot of action and a lot of whodonit guessing. Every time I thought I had it, I really didn't. The emotional investment kept me on the edge at all times, and I had to read carefully to make sure I didn't miss any clues.
I hope we see more of Natalie and Gideon getting embroiled in things they shouldn't again.
I received a copy from the publisher through NetGalley and this is my honest opinion.
Natalie and Gideon indeed get their "entanglement with the police" punch-cards punched once again despite the situation not having anything directly to do with them. But involved they get in several situations and by the time they figure out how severe they are, it's too late to back out.
In true Stephanie Black fashion, there's a lot of action and a lot of whodonit guessing. Every time I thought I had it, I really didn't. The emotional investment kept me on the edge at all times, and I had to read carefully to make sure I didn't miss any clues.
I hope we see more of Natalie and Gideon getting embroiled in things they shouldn't again.
I received a copy from the publisher through NetGalley and this is my honest opinion.
October 29, 2022
I received an ARC in exchange for an honest review; HOWEVER, I am a longtime reader and fan of not only the Natalie Marsh Mysteries but Stephanie Black's work in general. As you can see from my rating, this installment did not disappoint.
Because the main storyline stands on its own, anyone can read this book as their first foray into Black's work, but I personally feel that in order to connect deeply with Natalie and her husband, Gideon, you really should start with book one.
I loved the angle the author took with this time, focusing on the obsessive, insta-love relationship between the sister of a police detective and the brother of a man serving time for the murder of his wife. Rowan, said love interest, has long insisted that his brother is innocent, even to the point of clashing with the local police department. See where the romantic conflict comes in?
As intrigue and drama unfold, Natalie finds herself drawn in--whether she likes it or not. The contrast between mature Natalie and love-sick, 19 year-old Jemma serves the story well.
Aah! I loved this book! It had all the hallmarks of a Natalie Marsh mystery--a wide cast of characters with believable motives, Gideon's snark, mental healthcare awareness, and clues that lead you in every direction.
My one complaint: the setup came off as a little contrived. I was surprised that Black didn't include a suspense hook, typically a scene either showing or eluding to the crime. Still, the other 90% of the book more than made up for a shaky start.
Let's just say, I'm already dying for the next one. :)
Because the main storyline stands on its own, anyone can read this book as their first foray into Black's work, but I personally feel that in order to connect deeply with Natalie and her husband, Gideon, you really should start with book one.
I loved the angle the author took with this time, focusing on the obsessive, insta-love relationship between the sister of a police detective and the brother of a man serving time for the murder of his wife. Rowan, said love interest, has long insisted that his brother is innocent, even to the point of clashing with the local police department. See where the romantic conflict comes in?
As intrigue and drama unfold, Natalie finds herself drawn in--whether she likes it or not. The contrast between mature Natalie and love-sick, 19 year-old Jemma serves the story well.
Aah! I loved this book! It had all the hallmarks of a Natalie Marsh mystery--a wide cast of characters with believable motives, Gideon's snark, mental healthcare awareness, and clues that lead you in every direction.
My one complaint: the setup came off as a little contrived. I was surprised that Black didn't include a suspense hook, typically a scene either showing or eluding to the crime. Still, the other 90% of the book more than made up for a shaky start.
Let's just say, I'm already dying for the next one. :)
November 12, 2022
**4.5 stars**
Thank you Stephanie Black for crafting another novel that confused me and glued me to the pages! Natalie Marsh is a psychiatrist that is so good at her job that mystery and suspense come looking for her. She tries very hard to stay out of those situations, but somehow she finds herself in the middle of the puzzle with her life in danger.
Come, Gentle Night begins at a charity ball. The intensity starts full throttle when there is a conflict between the police and a young man who believes his brother was wrongfully convicted of murder. From the opening pages, Stephanie Black doesn't engage the brakes and takes the reader on a journey at full speed. At one point I firmly believe it is a bad cop who is the villain, then later, it was the crazy mom. There are so many twists and turns that left me guessing. I was amazed at how the author was able to bring all of the theories and characters into play and have all the strings neatly tied at the end.
If you love a mystery that keeps you guessing, pick up this book. You do not need to read all of the previous books to follow this story. Each book is a story of its own.
Source: I received a complimentary copy. All thoughts and opinions expressed are my own.
Thank you Stephanie Black for crafting another novel that confused me and glued me to the pages! Natalie Marsh is a psychiatrist that is so good at her job that mystery and suspense come looking for her. She tries very hard to stay out of those situations, but somehow she finds herself in the middle of the puzzle with her life in danger.
Come, Gentle Night begins at a charity ball. The intensity starts full throttle when there is a conflict between the police and a young man who believes his brother was wrongfully convicted of murder. From the opening pages, Stephanie Black doesn't engage the brakes and takes the reader on a journey at full speed. At one point I firmly believe it is a bad cop who is the villain, then later, it was the crazy mom. There are so many twists and turns that left me guessing. I was amazed at how the author was able to bring all of the theories and characters into play and have all the strings neatly tied at the end.
If you love a mystery that keeps you guessing, pick up this book. You do not need to read all of the previous books to follow this story. Each book is a story of its own.
Source: I received a complimentary copy. All thoughts and opinions expressed are my own.
October 27, 2022
A clean suspense novel. Natalie Marsh is is a psychologist who sometimes gets entangled with murder investigations. This is the 5th book in a series, which I didn’t realize when I requested an ARC. The title comes from Romeo & Juliet, and while this isn’t a retailing there are easy plot comparisons to the Shakespeare play.
At a fundraising gala for a domestic violence shelter, a cop gets pepper sprayed and accuses two men (in their 20s). They are taken into custody but released when one is alibied by Natalie because she was dancing with him at the time. A 19 year old sister of one of the detectives at the event was dancing with one of the men and is inexplicably drawn to him. He believes the police faked evidence putting his older brother in jail. She wants to help him in his quest to exonerate his brother. But things quickly escalate between the police and the men with Natalie being dragged in as someone they reach out to for help.
There are a lot of good twists and turns. I did however easily predict two of the major potential masterminds and their reasons. (But I read a lot of mysteries.) I was surprised that Natalie didn’t actively investigate but people came to her to share confidences. And she is good at observations. I don’t know if that is the same in her other stories. One of my least favorite characters is her husband Gideon. I found him pompous, condescending and breaching of trust. I wouldn’t have minded if he gotten killed off. I saw another reviewer who said he was their favorite character. That must be a hold over feeling from previous books because I saw nothing attractive or supportive in him. He was good for gathering one clue and being dramatic when Marsh goes missing.
I enjoyed the storytelling for the most part. There did seem to be some retelling as different people are brought up to speed on plot points. Also the sister comes off as a very young 19 and her instant infatuation and believing the guy was over the top. But so is Romeo and Juliette in that regards. There is a murder, shooting, knives and mentions of domestic violence and previous homicides. I’ve already checked and my local library has the other books in the series so I may read earlier adventures. (It is a local to my state publisher.)
Thank you to NetGalley and Covenant Communications for an eARC in exchange for an honest review.
(3.5 stars)
At a fundraising gala for a domestic violence shelter, a cop gets pepper sprayed and accuses two men (in their 20s). They are taken into custody but released when one is alibied by Natalie because she was dancing with him at the time. A 19 year old sister of one of the detectives at the event was dancing with one of the men and is inexplicably drawn to him. He believes the police faked evidence putting his older brother in jail. She wants to help him in his quest to exonerate his brother. But things quickly escalate between the police and the men with Natalie being dragged in as someone they reach out to for help.
There are a lot of good twists and turns. I did however easily predict two of the major potential masterminds and their reasons. (But I read a lot of mysteries.) I was surprised that Natalie didn’t actively investigate but people came to her to share confidences. And she is good at observations. I don’t know if that is the same in her other stories. One of my least favorite characters is her husband Gideon. I found him pompous, condescending and breaching of trust. I wouldn’t have minded if he gotten killed off. I saw another reviewer who said he was their favorite character. That must be a hold over feeling from previous books because I saw nothing attractive or supportive in him. He was good for gathering one clue and being dramatic when Marsh goes missing.
I enjoyed the storytelling for the most part. There did seem to be some retelling as different people are brought up to speed on plot points. Also the sister comes off as a very young 19 and her instant infatuation and believing the guy was over the top. But so is Romeo and Juliette in that regards. There is a murder, shooting, knives and mentions of domestic violence and previous homicides. I’ve already checked and my local library has the other books in the series so I may read earlier adventures. (It is a local to my state publisher.)
Thank you to NetGalley and Covenant Communications for an eARC in exchange for an honest review.
(3.5 stars)
November 5, 2022
I have really enjoyed this series and was excited to read this next installment of the Natalie Marsh mysteries. Each book has a fun nod to a Shakespeare play and I enjoyed trying to figure out which this one was and loved when I did figure it out.
The suspense was just the right amount to keep me guessing and on the edge of my seat. I found myself constantly trying to figure out who the villain was and was happy I did guess right, but I will admit, even having guessed correctly by the time of the reveal, I was still surprised by some twists that went with it! There were just enough things to throw me off the trail, I felt like I was right there solving things with Natalie and Gideon.
While this is a standalone novel, I personally enjoyed seeing this stage of Natalie and Gideon's relationship. The romance in this book is very light, with Natalie and Gideon's having developed throughout the series and then a new romance introduced that played into the plot, but wasn't a dominating theme. I would say this is more suspense than romantic suspense.
I received an advance reader copy of this novel. All thoughts and opinions are my own. I recommend this book and this series.
The suspense was just the right amount to keep me guessing and on the edge of my seat. I found myself constantly trying to figure out who the villain was and was happy I did guess right, but I will admit, even having guessed correctly by the time of the reveal, I was still surprised by some twists that went with it! There were just enough things to throw me off the trail, I felt like I was right there solving things with Natalie and Gideon.
While this is a standalone novel, I personally enjoyed seeing this stage of Natalie and Gideon's relationship. The romance in this book is very light, with Natalie and Gideon's having developed throughout the series and then a new romance introduced that played into the plot, but wasn't a dominating theme. I would say this is more suspense than romantic suspense.
I received an advance reader copy of this novel. All thoughts and opinions are my own. I recommend this book and this series.
July 12, 2022
Stephanie Black does it again with Natalie Marsh. I enjoyed the twist this time where Natalie wasn't the main one having a run-in with the law. Sometimes I just wanted to shake the main character. What were you thinking girl?? Unfortunately, there are many girls out there who lead with their hearts and not their heads. Thank goodness good old Dr. Marsh was on her side!
This book kept me awake reading at night when I should have been sleeping. It sustained me through the sick days of my COVID booster shot. My only regret is that now the book is over. Thank you Shadow Mountain for an ARC.
This book kept me awake reading at night when I should have been sleeping. It sustained me through the sick days of my COVID booster shot. My only regret is that now the book is over. Thank you Shadow Mountain for an ARC.
January 29, 2025
I listened to this series (everything but the second) and honestly love it. I’m planning on buying it to keep on my bookshelf. The perfect cozy mystery with a little bit of romance and a lot of plot twists and intrigue and characters you can’t help but love or hate (depending on the character). Highly recommend if you like thought provoking mysteries!
November 3, 2022
I was excited to read this new installment in the Natalie Marsh series! As usual, it starts off calmly, but quickly heats up with some surprising twists and turns. Nothing is quite what it seems, and you are left wondering how it will all turn out! A great read!
November 6, 2022
“Come, Gentle Night” is a riveting tale that leaves the reader craving more drama, secrets, and action amidst a roller coaster of emotions caused by a budding romance that is tried and tested in every manner.
Read full review in the 2022 November issue of InD'tale Magazine.
Read full review in the 2022 November issue of InD'tale Magazine.
November 16, 2022
The story sucks you in and is hard to put down. A couple of the characters were a little over the top and many situations were totally unrealistic but I still liked it. This is part of a series and best to read in order.
January 26, 2023
This was really fun and a crazy ride but the ending felt a little messy and left me with questions. Still recommend but I’ve enjoyed others in the series more. I am super impressed how nothing feels repetitive from book to book, especially with how varied the crimes, people of interest, and the danger is.
May 5, 2025
Yet AGAIN, I did NOT see that coming. Well done, Stephanie Black. I loved this series and am bummed it’s over!!! My husband listened to a few chapters with me, and he was hooked after just those few. Highly recommend!!!
November 16, 2022
Natalie Marsh is in top form in this suspense mystery. The way this story is laid out is just amazing. There are so many twists and turns with plenty of Natalie's cool logic and propensity for trouble.
Stephanie Black is a master of suspense and mystery. She keeps you on the edge of your seat and wanting more.
I love that Natalie is a psychologist and the way she interacts with others. She does tend to be a bit trusting and finds herself in so many situations. =]
The characters are wonderful and the conflicts are on point. I found myself pulled into the story, caring about the characters, and trying to figure out the mystery as I go.
Stephanie Black is a master of suspense and mystery. She keeps you on the edge of your seat and wanting more.
I love that Natalie is a psychologist and the way she interacts with others. She does tend to be a bit trusting and finds herself in so many situations. =]
The characters are wonderful and the conflicts are on point. I found myself pulled into the story, caring about the characters, and trying to figure out the mystery as I go.
May 31, 2024
I struggled with this book fighting a constant eye roll. Too much unbelievability for my taste. I stuck it out to the end though.
October 28, 2022
With the reference to the quote from Romeo and Juliet, much of the story comes into focus. Jemma and Rowan are two starry eyed young adults who do impetuous things, not considering the consequences, which some prove to be deadly.
Dr. Natalie Marsh is no stranger to difficult situations and becomes involved in the case of treachery, deceit, and murder. With several twists and subplots, the culprits are not revealed until the very end that have you guessing throughout the story.
I did like the book, but I believe I would have had a better sense of the characters if I had read previous books in the series. Thank you to the publisher and Net Galley for an advanced e-arc of the book. I was not required to write a positive review. All opinions are my own.
3.5/5 stars
Dr. Natalie Marsh is no stranger to difficult situations and becomes involved in the case of treachery, deceit, and murder. With several twists and subplots, the culprits are not revealed until the very end that have you guessing throughout the story.
I did like the book, but I believe I would have had a better sense of the characters if I had read previous books in the series. Thank you to the publisher and Net Galley for an advanced e-arc of the book. I was not required to write a positive review. All opinions are my own.
3.5/5 stars
November 25, 2022
Every high school English teacher’s favorite: Romeo and Juliet!
Yep, this time we get star-crossed lovers: Jemma Bartholomew, Detective Bartholomew’s sister, and Rowan Montrose, who, with his cousin, hates the police and believes they covered up his brother’s innocence in the case of his wife’s murder.
Again, we have a variety of people to be suspicious of. And Natalie finds herself protecting one of them—a client who is one of the cops who worked the case of Serena Montrose’s murder. In her attempts not to reveal that he is her client, she sometimes makes things worse.
Gideon continues to be the wonderful and supportive husband we know and love, while trying to keep Natalie from putting herself in danger. Naturally, it doesn’t work, but he’s always there to pick up the pieces.
I particularly enjoyed getting to see Abe Bartholomew move from a side character to an integral part of the story. His frustration in dealing with his little sister, who is determined not to listen, rings true. Even better, rather than our young lovers dying, we see them survive their idiocy and become wiser people. And Jemma is able to separate herself from Rowan’s infatuation, so that’s definitely a win.
Black continues to give us stories that use complicated family dynamics as part of the impetus for her plots. Can’t wait for the next installment!
Thank you to NetGalley and Covenant Communications for providing an ARC in exchange for my unbiased review.
Possible Objectionable Material:
Murders. Danger, Betrayal. Lying. A difficult marriage dynamic. A little gaslighting. Mental illness. Natalie’s somewhat abusive mother is mentioned frequently. There is no swearing and the violence is not graphic. Some people drink alcohol, but I don’t recall anyone being actually drunk. Drug use. Complicated personal relationships. Manipulation.
Who Might Like This Book:
People who like suspense stories. Those who like complicated family dynamics and other relationships. People who like allusions to Shakespeare stories. There is bit of romance here, but it is definitely not the focus of the story.
This book also reviewed at https://biblioquacious.blogspot.com/2...
Yep, this time we get star-crossed lovers: Jemma Bartholomew, Detective Bartholomew’s sister, and Rowan Montrose, who, with his cousin, hates the police and believes they covered up his brother’s innocence in the case of his wife’s murder.
Again, we have a variety of people to be suspicious of. And Natalie finds herself protecting one of them—a client who is one of the cops who worked the case of Serena Montrose’s murder. In her attempts not to reveal that he is her client, she sometimes makes things worse.
Gideon continues to be the wonderful and supportive husband we know and love, while trying to keep Natalie from putting herself in danger. Naturally, it doesn’t work, but he’s always there to pick up the pieces.
I particularly enjoyed getting to see Abe Bartholomew move from a side character to an integral part of the story. His frustration in dealing with his little sister, who is determined not to listen, rings true. Even better, rather than our young lovers dying, we see them survive their idiocy and become wiser people. And Jemma is able to separate herself from Rowan’s infatuation, so that’s definitely a win.
Black continues to give us stories that use complicated family dynamics as part of the impetus for her plots. Can’t wait for the next installment!
Thank you to NetGalley and Covenant Communications for providing an ARC in exchange for my unbiased review.
Possible Objectionable Material:
Murders. Danger, Betrayal. Lying. A difficult marriage dynamic. A little gaslighting. Mental illness. Natalie’s somewhat abusive mother is mentioned frequently. There is no swearing and the violence is not graphic. Some people drink alcohol, but I don’t recall anyone being actually drunk. Drug use. Complicated personal relationships. Manipulation.
Who Might Like This Book:
People who like suspense stories. Those who like complicated family dynamics and other relationships. People who like allusions to Shakespeare stories. There is bit of romance here, but it is definitely not the focus of the story.
This book also reviewed at https://biblioquacious.blogspot.com/2...
November 8, 2022
I had a big old spiel on Shakespeare retellings, but it was too long, so I’ll just cut to the chase: it’s a retelling. Ms Black does these really, really well.
In this retelling, Ms Black manages to keep the structure of the story, so you know exactly what’s going on, but it not satirical or making fun of the story in a way that will take away from the gravity of the story. In this way, it is a true retelling, but with modern twists that keep it relevant and poignant with a modern audiences. This is key, as there are some very toxic elements in the original text, but I feel like she has really masterfully navigated those, and on top of that, taken the imagery from the story itself and used that to her advantage to enhance the mystery.
As for the mystery itself, it is so, so good. When I got to 31% I knew I was going to have to put it down for the night before I read anymore, because it was getting late and I was absolutely going to stay up to finish it if I didn’t. Even though I was responsible and went to bed on time, I was absolutely right about the pacing and more or less fought tooth and nail to have time to read the rest throughout the week. I usually don’t read during the week just because of my work and writing responsibilities, but I did make the time for this because it was really compelling and I really, really, really needed to know what happened.
Lastly, I really enjoyed the way it ended. Now, to prevent any spoilers, I’m gonna leave it at that, but this is probably going to be a book you’re going to want to read more than once.
In this retelling, Ms Black manages to keep the structure of the story, so you know exactly what’s going on, but it not satirical or making fun of the story in a way that will take away from the gravity of the story. In this way, it is a true retelling, but with modern twists that keep it relevant and poignant with a modern audiences. This is key, as there are some very toxic elements in the original text, but I feel like she has really masterfully navigated those, and on top of that, taken the imagery from the story itself and used that to her advantage to enhance the mystery.
As for the mystery itself, it is so, so good. When I got to 31% I knew I was going to have to put it down for the night before I read anymore, because it was getting late and I was absolutely going to stay up to finish it if I didn’t. Even though I was responsible and went to bed on time, I was absolutely right about the pacing and more or less fought tooth and nail to have time to read the rest throughout the week. I usually don’t read during the week just because of my work and writing responsibilities, but I did make the time for this because it was really compelling and I really, really, really needed to know what happened.
Lastly, I really enjoyed the way it ended. Now, to prevent any spoilers, I’m gonna leave it at that, but this is probably going to be a book you’re going to want to read more than once.
October 13, 2022
Synopsis:
Mental health therapist Natalie Marsh and her husband, Gideon, become involved with a police investigation after witnessing the aftermath of a strange assault at a charity gala. In the following days, things quickly escalate as the primary suspect for the assault also becomes the primary suspect for a police officer's death--and he asks Natalie to help him clear his name, as well as the name of his brother who was convicted of murdering his own wife years before. Although she tries to distance herself from the case, Natalie finds she is becoming more and more bound to the center of it all. She and Gideon must find the truth and report it before the murderer tries to silence her forever.
Review:
I liked how this book didn't take long to really get going. Almost from the first chapter it was a whirlwind of detail! There were plenty of confusing, plot-twisting clues. I have to be honest though, the whirlwind-like quality of the plot flow made it a little exhausting with keeping track of who was doing what crazy thing at a given moment.
Some of the characters were definitely mentally ill and others were downright exasperating, but Natalie and Gideon were anchors of reason and goodness. I appreciated how at least one character comes to realize her need for better mental health and explicitly states that she plans to seek help, based on her poor judgement calls.
This was a fun read, but I don't recommend reading it at night by yourself. You may start hearing things.
Content Guide:
Language: Aggressive threats and slander are exchanged between a couple characters
Sex & Affection: A couple holds hands, kisses, and gazes into one another's eyes
Drug & Substance Use: Champagne is consumed
Violence & Crime: Many crimes are committed, including verbal and physical assault, vandalism, kidnapping, murder, and drugging against a person's will. However, most of these crimes are not described in detail and the reader is not informed until after the crime was already committed and the clues are being examined
I received a free copy of this book from the publisher. All opinions are entirely my own.
Mental health therapist Natalie Marsh and her husband, Gideon, become involved with a police investigation after witnessing the aftermath of a strange assault at a charity gala. In the following days, things quickly escalate as the primary suspect for the assault also becomes the primary suspect for a police officer's death--and he asks Natalie to help him clear his name, as well as the name of his brother who was convicted of murdering his own wife years before. Although she tries to distance herself from the case, Natalie finds she is becoming more and more bound to the center of it all. She and Gideon must find the truth and report it before the murderer tries to silence her forever.
Review:
I liked how this book didn't take long to really get going. Almost from the first chapter it was a whirlwind of detail! There were plenty of confusing, plot-twisting clues. I have to be honest though, the whirlwind-like quality of the plot flow made it a little exhausting with keeping track of who was doing what crazy thing at a given moment.
Some of the characters were definitely mentally ill and others were downright exasperating, but Natalie and Gideon were anchors of reason and goodness. I appreciated how at least one character comes to realize her need for better mental health and explicitly states that she plans to seek help, based on her poor judgement calls.
This was a fun read, but I don't recommend reading it at night by yourself. You may start hearing things.
Content Guide:
Language: Aggressive threats and slander are exchanged between a couple characters
Sex & Affection: A couple holds hands, kisses, and gazes into one another's eyes
Drug & Substance Use: Champagne is consumed
Violence & Crime: Many crimes are committed, including verbal and physical assault, vandalism, kidnapping, murder, and drugging against a person's will. However, most of these crimes are not described in detail and the reader is not informed until after the crime was already committed and the clues are being examined
I received a free copy of this book from the publisher. All opinions are entirely my own.
November 2, 2022
Oh, my goodness! This book caught me from the very beginning.
I picked up this ARC, and it's the first I've read in the series. The good news is that it's written so well, I understood everything without having read the others first. Now, I want to go back and read more!
This is such an interesting mystery. It's not exactly cozy but it's certainly not hard boiled. The characters actually talk to each other. No one is a Sherlock. And it's not a grandma in curlers solving the crime. (Mind you I love those other types of mysteries too.) It's the perfect blend of small town mystery, a competent police force, and savvy citizens interested in solving a breech of justice and exposing the truth.
The character have to work to piece and stitch the clues together, figuring out what to discard. I was sifting through everything from page one trying to figure out the big question in a mystery: whodunnit?
I love how this story feels so realistic. The characters and their relationships feel like actual people. Messy, possible gas lighting, loving, angry, angsty, lying, miscommunication, and every other human emotion. Sometimes, I was even angry at characters and talking to them to shape up or warning them not to do anything stupid.
And the end? Oh—so satisfying!
Did I solve it in advance? Not too early, but I figured it out right when the author wanted me to. She's a master at devising a mystery.
I highly recommend this book (and the author).
Happy reading!
I picked up this ARC, and it's the first I've read in the series. The good news is that it's written so well, I understood everything without having read the others first. Now, I want to go back and read more!
This is such an interesting mystery. It's not exactly cozy but it's certainly not hard boiled. The characters actually talk to each other. No one is a Sherlock. And it's not a grandma in curlers solving the crime. (Mind you I love those other types of mysteries too.) It's the perfect blend of small town mystery, a competent police force, and savvy citizens interested in solving a breech of justice and exposing the truth.
The character have to work to piece and stitch the clues together, figuring out what to discard. I was sifting through everything from page one trying to figure out the big question in a mystery: whodunnit?
I love how this story feels so realistic. The characters and their relationships feel like actual people. Messy, possible gas lighting, loving, angry, angsty, lying, miscommunication, and every other human emotion. Sometimes, I was even angry at characters and talking to them to shape up or warning them not to do anything stupid.
And the end? Oh—so satisfying!
Did I solve it in advance? Not too early, but I figured it out right when the author wanted me to. She's a master at devising a mystery.
I highly recommend this book (and the author).
Happy reading!
December 11, 2022
🧤THOUGHTS:
🥀I loved getting to see more of Abe in this book. Meeting his sister created this great sibling dynamic that was entertaining and heartwarming. ❤️
🥀Right off the bat, I was so excited to see Natalie and Gideon again. They made such an impression that I was waiting for more. This book delivered!
🥀I loved meeting new characters and seeing all the familiar faces. The characters were great and the dialogue was amazing. I have so many great quotes that I would have shared but I don’t want to spoil anything.
🥀Also, this cover! I love how it relates to a scene in this book! It is so eerie and haunting, which is so great with this book!
🥀I also really love the chapter headings. The way they look is incredible and they match the words on the cover. It just creates another visual aspect that I loved!
🥀I highly recommend you read this book.
🧤REVIEW:
🥀Stephanie Black did an incredible job with this. I was sucked in from page 1. The entire Natalie Marsh series is phenomenal, but this one just surpassed all of them. It was absolutely incredible.
🥀The suspense and mystery of it had me questioning everything and everyone the entire book. While I did guess some things at the end (the curse of knowing a bunch of Law Enforcement 😂), I could not have guessed the ending. It totally came as a surprise. That is how you know it is a great suspense book.
🥀Incredible book to add to a fantastic series. I can't wait to read more.
🥀I loved getting to see more of Abe in this book. Meeting his sister created this great sibling dynamic that was entertaining and heartwarming. ❤️
🥀Right off the bat, I was so excited to see Natalie and Gideon again. They made such an impression that I was waiting for more. This book delivered!
🥀I loved meeting new characters and seeing all the familiar faces. The characters were great and the dialogue was amazing. I have so many great quotes that I would have shared but I don’t want to spoil anything.
🥀Also, this cover! I love how it relates to a scene in this book! It is so eerie and haunting, which is so great with this book!
🥀I also really love the chapter headings. The way they look is incredible and they match the words on the cover. It just creates another visual aspect that I loved!
🥀I highly recommend you read this book.
🧤REVIEW:
🥀Stephanie Black did an incredible job with this. I was sucked in from page 1. The entire Natalie Marsh series is phenomenal, but this one just surpassed all of them. It was absolutely incredible.
🥀The suspense and mystery of it had me questioning everything and everyone the entire book. While I did guess some things at the end (the curse of knowing a bunch of Law Enforcement 😂), I could not have guessed the ending. It totally came as a surprise. That is how you know it is a great suspense book.
🥀Incredible book to add to a fantastic series. I can't wait to read more.
October 23, 2022
Come, Gentle Night, the fifth in the Natalie Marsh series, is in many ways the best of the bunch. In this one there are a host of new main characters and Natalie is not so personally involved, rather more involved as counselor and, of course, does some good sleuthing as usual. I think this is Stephanie Black’s best production for a host of varied characters. Each one is individual, giving the sense it must be someone with whom the author is personally acquainted, and they run the gamut of pleasant to vile. Even Gideon, not my favorite character, seems to have matured, and he takes a more assertive role. In particular, from my point of view, there are two new young female characters who are so delightful and finely drawn that you can’t help falling for them. This in spite of the fact that falling for any of the characters in a Stephanie Black mystery is asking for it. Will she turn out to be a villain or perpetrator? Another thing I noticed is the writing is filled with humor, good sense, and deliciously quotable material. I could see this as a set book for study in schools or universities.
As always, don’t be surprised if you reach the point where you can’t put the book down, and be prepared to lose some sleep time. Things are going to get very tense and breathtaking. I haven’t yet figured out who ‘dunnit’ in any of Stephanie Blacks’ books. It’s best not even to try.
As always, don’t be surprised if you reach the point where you can’t put the book down, and be prepared to lose some sleep time. Things are going to get very tense and breathtaking. I haven’t yet figured out who ‘dunnit’ in any of Stephanie Blacks’ books. It’s best not even to try.
October 29, 2022
Come Gentle Night is the fifth in the excellent Natalie Marsh series, part mystery, part suspense, part clean romance. Natalie Marsh is a psychologist who is attending a gala fundraiser for the Daffodil House Women's Shelter when her assistant requests she keep an eye on two young men who are known to be confrontational when around authorities. And there were plenty of authorities at the ball. Rowan and Jemma meet at the event and have eyes only for each other. But Natalie and her husband Gideon get themselves into an unexpected mess when they discover skeletons in the closets of Rowan's family. Rowan's brother, Brett, has been accused of a murder years ago and Rowan believes him to be innocent. Well. Sparks fly. Crimes are committed and murder comes knocking. Who can one really trust?
Mystery fans who prefer their crime stories with a side of romance ought to seek out this series, well worth reading. I particularly enjoy the psychological slant. Romance I could do without but it does play a role in the story.
My sincere thank you to Covenant Communications and NetGalley for the privilege of reading this engrossing book and for introducing me to this fabulous series.
Mystery fans who prefer their crime stories with a side of romance ought to seek out this series, well worth reading. I particularly enjoy the psychological slant. Romance I could do without but it does play a role in the story.
My sincere thank you to Covenant Communications and NetGalley for the privilege of reading this engrossing book and for introducing me to this fabulous series.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 79 reviews