When Monica announced this series I was SO excited-but not for the reasons you’d think. I was so in love with the Callahan kids, I was desperate to get even more of them- even if they were just glimmers in these stories. And while I liked all the characters featured in the college years series, to me they felt just like what they were in the Callahan series- secondary. Interesting side characters with their own stories who shine brightly enough for me to care about them but not quite enough to detract from the stories’ center. But if what Monica did with Tony is indication about what is to come in this series, I may end up loving the college years even more than the Callahans- GASP. I know. But Monica somehow took a somewhat interesting supportive side character and transformed him into her swooniest leading man yet- and dare I say, he might yet be my favorite! Even more so, she gives some of our other secondary characters central billing here- elevating them all from fun periphery characters to deeply intriguing and lovable leading men. And now I’m ravenous for all their books!
TONY IS A DREAMBOAT. I loved getting to know more about him in this story- finally understand the layers and nuances of a character I hadn’t thought as intensely about. And he is so fantastically created- AND SWOONY AF. But what charmed me the most about him is how different he is from the other heroes Monica has given us in this series- he’s profoundly mature, laid back, rationale and self-aware. Monica brilliantly juxtaposes him with his friends- especially Caleb and Eli- for us to see this unexpectedly level-headed and grounded man. He’s got integrity, he’s sensitive and kind, honest and open. I instantly fell for him- and I relished the endearing ways he both works through his own feelings and is supportive and affectionate to Hayden. Hayden is a total pistol- and again, felt radically different than some of the other Monica heroines- she’s brash, confident, sexually confident and ballsy. Because she’s a less openly vulnerable character, it took a minute for me to warm up to her, but when we get more of her heart and see her perfect chemistry with Tony, I just adored her. And I loved these two together! They have a fiery and sweet chemistry- the perfect mix of tender passion.
The story also didn’t unfold quite how I expected, which made it be even more emotionally interesting. Our narrative set-up gives me all sorts of angsty Romeo and Juliet vibes. And while that dynamic does play into the climactic conflict (which did have some odd notes), this story was actually blissfully lower angst and more even keeled, and the conflict centered less on their familial vendetta and more on the anti-relationship baggage they both carry from the radically unhealthy, toxic examples of “love” they’ve seen in their parents’ failed relationships. That to me made the story far more interesting for character developed-as what could easily be a story about externalized drama instead becomes a story about these two stumbling into a very healthy and sweet romance and finding the courage to take a risk on it when love is nothing but destructive all around them. Way more friends to lovers than enemies to lovers- which means way more sweet swoons and giddy butterflies.
The BROMANCES though- oh my goodness. This may be the TRUE star of this story. Watching these teens start to become adults, formulate a supportive, fun, and vivid family unit, and help each other work though the angst of maturing into real adults is going to make for such a beautiful overarching theme for this series. I’m in love with ALL of these characters, and I’m so transfixed by their special dynamics. I have a feeling we have a new favorite Monica Murphy series in the works!