What do you think?
Rate this book
The Storm Girl
The gripping new historical novel from the USA Today bestselling author of The Girl from Bletchley Park and The Forgotten Secret.
A heartbreaking choice. A secret kept for centuries.
1784. When Esther Harris’s father hurts his back, she takes over his role helping smugglers hide contraband in the secret cellar in their pub. But when the free traders’ ships are trapped in the harbour, a battle between the smugglers and the revenue officers leads to murder and betrayal – and Esther is forced to choose between the love of her life and protecting her family…
Present day. Fresh from her divorce, Millie Galton moves into a former inn overlooking the harbour in Mudeford and plans to create her dream home. When a chance discovery behind an old fireplace reveals the house’s secret history as a haven for smugglers and the devastating story of its former residents, could the mystery of a disappearance from centuries ago finally be solved?
A heartbreaking choice. A secret kept for centuries.
1784. When Esther Harris’s father hurts his back, she takes over his role helping smugglers hide contraband in the secret cellar in their pub. But when the free traders’ ships are trapped in the harbour, a battle between the smugglers and the revenue officers leads to murder and betrayal – and Esther is forced to choose between the love of her life and protecting her family…
Present day. Fresh from her divorce, Millie Galton moves into a former inn overlooking the harbour in Mudeford and plans to create her dream home. When a chance discovery behind an old fireplace reveals the house’s secret history as a haven for smugglers and the devastating story of its former residents, could the mystery of a disappearance from centuries ago finally be solved?
384 pages, Paperback
First published May 11, 2022
About the author
Kathleen McGurl
25 books494 followersKathleen McGurl lives in Bournemouth with her husband and cat. She has two grown-up sons who have now left home. She always wanted to write, and for many years was waiting until she had the time. Eventually she came to the bitter realisation that no one would pay her for a year off work to write a book, so she sat down and started to write one anyway. Since then she has sold dozens of short stories to women's magazines and written three books for writers. These days she is concentrating on longer fiction and has published several dual timeline novels with CarinaUK and HQ. She works full time in the IT industry and when she's not writing, she's often out running, slowly.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 114 reviews
May 18, 2022
This story starts off in the year 1784 in a town were tradesmen helps smugglers hide contraband as the price is too high for them to stay in business and buy at the normal cost. Esther and her father forms part of the tradesmen desperate for their pub to thrive and use an underground tunnel to hide some of the goods. But when things get a bit too hot she is faced with some difficult decisions.
In the same location in the present day Millie has bought the same building, which is now a very beautiful old landmark home. She starts some renovations and soon discovers a few little secrets in the house.
What a beautiful story, with two timelines you can really feel the history behind this house. Both stories were a little different but still kept you invested and engaged. The past timeline gave you so much insight and understanding of how how these people had to work to keep their businesses going. You can feel the effort put into developing all the characters, and can really connect with all of them.
The narration was really good, nice and steady and the voice changes was really different.
Highly recommend!
My thanks to Netgalley and HarperCollins UK Audio for the ARC.
In the same location in the present day Millie has bought the same building, which is now a very beautiful old landmark home. She starts some renovations and soon discovers a few little secrets in the house.
What a beautiful story, with two timelines you can really feel the history behind this house. Both stories were a little different but still kept you invested and engaged. The past timeline gave you so much insight and understanding of how how these people had to work to keep their businesses going. You can feel the effort put into developing all the characters, and can really connect with all of them.
The narration was really good, nice and steady and the voice changes was really different.
Highly recommend!
My thanks to Netgalley and HarperCollins UK Audio for the ARC.
June 9, 2022
Kathleen McGurl to me is the Queen of the Dual Timeline!
This is my absolute favourite format in a book, and when it is done well, it can be immense!
This was a great audiobook. Albeit it took me some time to get into, and the contraband smuggling ring didn't grab me initially as an amazing story to write a book about. The narrator and characters soon got under my skin to make me keep listening and interested to see what would happen.
It was certainly a suspenseful listen, and the intestity of the characters' secret being hidden from the authorities was wonderfully portrayed.
A gripping book, but not one of my favourites from the author.
This is my absolute favourite format in a book, and when it is done well, it can be immense!
This was a great audiobook. Albeit it took me some time to get into, and the contraband smuggling ring didn't grab me initially as an amazing story to write a book about. The narrator and characters soon got under my skin to make me keep listening and interested to see what would happen.
It was certainly a suspenseful listen, and the intestity of the characters' secret being hidden from the authorities was wonderfully portrayed.
A gripping book, but not one of my favourites from the author.
May 7, 2022
I always enjoy Kathleen’s books and this was just as good as her others. This was a dual time-line which I always enjoy, set in Dorset this book dealt with smuggling which reminded me of Poldark and unfortunate without Adrian Turner🤭. The characters were all enjoyable and I highly recommended this book. My thanks to Netgalley and the publishers for giving me the opportunity to read this book in return for an honest review.
March 31, 2025
This wasn’t my more favoured read from McGurl: the narrative struggled to hold my interest and I felt that there was some loose ends that could have been tied up at the end.
McGurl’s historical tale is all about the smuggling that took place near Christchurch in the eighteenth century. A dual narrative, we follow how Esther and her father are involved in bringing in goods, hiding them in the cellar of their pub. Just like our modern day protagonist, Millie, I was fascinated by the description of the smuggler’s tunnels and found it added a lot of atmosphere to the story. Millie has moved into a dilapidated house and, when renovations begin, she discovers the hidden cellar and tunnels.
Over the story, McGurl presents the threats faced by the smugglers, as well as how some of the local militia were willing to turn a blind eye – provided they get cut into the goods. However, for Esther, this leads to an uncomfortable compromise with Thomas Mercer, threatening her own personal happiness. I would have preferred if McGurl had expanded on this element a bit more, especially as I thought Esther didn’t really experience any major difficulties, despite helping the smugglers. Furthermore, I wanted the writer to detail what exactly happens to Mercer. It was a bit disappointing that this was implied rather than described.
I enjoyed seeing Millie uncover the secrets of her house. I didn’t find her relationship with Nick to be particularly convincing and was desperately hoping that McGurl would turn it into something sinister. I found I grew to care less about the subplot of the local crime, instead wanting to see more come from Nick and his father’s connections. I think this would have made the story a lot grittier, especially combined with if Esther had struggled more as well.
Overall, this was an interesting story from a historical perspective and I found my imagination ignited due to McGurl’s obvious research. It was a good read with a sweet, romantic element but I did want something a little more sinister or tense to reflect the dangers of smuggling.
With thanks to HQ and NetGalley for providing me with a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
McGurl’s historical tale is all about the smuggling that took place near Christchurch in the eighteenth century. A dual narrative, we follow how Esther and her father are involved in bringing in goods, hiding them in the cellar of their pub. Just like our modern day protagonist, Millie, I was fascinated by the description of the smuggler’s tunnels and found it added a lot of atmosphere to the story. Millie has moved into a dilapidated house and, when renovations begin, she discovers the hidden cellar and tunnels.
Over the story, McGurl presents the threats faced by the smugglers, as well as how some of the local militia were willing to turn a blind eye – provided they get cut into the goods. However, for Esther, this leads to an uncomfortable compromise with Thomas Mercer, threatening her own personal happiness. I would have preferred if McGurl had expanded on this element a bit more, especially as I thought Esther didn’t really experience any major difficulties, despite helping the smugglers. Furthermore, I wanted the writer to detail what exactly happens to Mercer. It was a bit disappointing that this was implied rather than described.
I enjoyed seeing Millie uncover the secrets of her house. I didn’t find her relationship with Nick to be particularly convincing and was desperately hoping that McGurl would turn it into something sinister. I found I grew to care less about the subplot of the local crime, instead wanting to see more come from Nick and his father’s connections. I think this would have made the story a lot grittier, especially combined with if Esther had struggled more as well.
Overall, this was an interesting story from a historical perspective and I found my imagination ignited due to McGurl’s obvious research. It was a good read with a sweet, romantic element but I did want something a little more sinister or tense to reflect the dangers of smuggling.
With thanks to HQ and NetGalley for providing me with a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
August 20, 2024
1784. Esther Harris and her brother Matthew work in their father's pub, The Ship at Anchor in Mudeford, England. Since losing her mother, Esther Harris has taken over many of her mother's roles in the pub including meeting the free traders' ships bringing contraband into the harbor. Due to its location, John Streeter, owner of the vessels, held meetings at Haven House Inn to disseminate information about upcoming deliveries. The days and nights are long and filled with hard work, but sharing it with her brother and Sam Coombes, the love of her life, makes everything bearable until Esther's father asks her to do the unthinkable.
Present Day. Millie Galton has purchased a former pub in Mudeford. It has been vacant for a long time, but Millie sees the possibility of creating her dream home with a garden and the joy of the sea view. Her cat Mir has just had kittens. Mir's choice after their birth will instigate the beginnings of the house’s history and secrets held and never before realized by former residents after it changed from pub to home, adding a new layer of intrigue to the story.
As a reader who enjoys novels with dual timelines, I often find one period more captivating. However, with compelling narrative and character development, this novel combines intrigue, romance, mystery, and history with captivating and page-turning storytelling in both periods, offering a revealing glimpse into the past.
The author's Historical Note at the end of the novel is an integral part of the reading experience. It provides valuable context and enhances the reader's understanding of the historical backdrop.
Present Day. Millie Galton has purchased a former pub in Mudeford. It has been vacant for a long time, but Millie sees the possibility of creating her dream home with a garden and the joy of the sea view. Her cat Mir has just had kittens. Mir's choice after their birth will instigate the beginnings of the house’s history and secrets held and never before realized by former residents after it changed from pub to home, adding a new layer of intrigue to the story.
As a reader who enjoys novels with dual timelines, I often find one period more captivating. However, with compelling narrative and character development, this novel combines intrigue, romance, mystery, and history with captivating and page-turning storytelling in both periods, offering a revealing glimpse into the past.
The author's Historical Note at the end of the novel is an integral part of the reading experience. It provides valuable context and enhances the reader's understanding of the historical backdrop.
May 10, 2022
The same central location but in two different times
A home with surprises, secrets and crimes.
A fascinating read that will slowly unfold
As threads from the present and past are told.
In the present this is the new home and fresh start,
But a pet cat and new kittens will play a key part
As they reveal a secret that's been hidden for years
Should this be a celebration or will it end in tears?
Back in 1784 this home was an inn
That played a special role in the local smuggling.
The hiding of contraband, keeping its whereabouts a mystery
Are all entombed in this home's history.
What a fascinating insight into the history of those times
Alongside a present day murder mystery, rumours and crimes.
There's also romance in both eras, too,
But others involved may part them before dreams come true.
It is a story with great characters, a huge sense of mystery
All skilfully entwined with the location's fascinating history.
The romances are in danger of being thwarted by others
And the ending the answer to a centuries old mystery discovers.
The author's writing is engaging and a pleasure to read
Such a different dual timeline could be just what you need.
It has elements of family drama, crime thriller and mystery
Alongside several romances both now and in history.
It is a fascinating, dual timeline read to escape into
With such a clever plot, I recommend it to you.
For my complementary copy, I say thank you,
I really enjoyed it and this is my honest review.
A home with surprises, secrets and crimes.
A fascinating read that will slowly unfold
As threads from the present and past are told.
In the present this is the new home and fresh start,
But a pet cat and new kittens will play a key part
As they reveal a secret that's been hidden for years
Should this be a celebration or will it end in tears?
Back in 1784 this home was an inn
That played a special role in the local smuggling.
The hiding of contraband, keeping its whereabouts a mystery
Are all entombed in this home's history.
What a fascinating insight into the history of those times
Alongside a present day murder mystery, rumours and crimes.
There's also romance in both eras, too,
But others involved may part them before dreams come true.
It is a story with great characters, a huge sense of mystery
All skilfully entwined with the location's fascinating history.
The romances are in danger of being thwarted by others
And the ending the answer to a centuries old mystery discovers.
The author's writing is engaging and a pleasure to read
Such a different dual timeline could be just what you need.
It has elements of family drama, crime thriller and mystery
Alongside several romances both now and in history.
It is a fascinating, dual timeline read to escape into
With such a clever plot, I recommend it to you.
For my complementary copy, I say thank you,
I really enjoyed it and this is my honest review.
May 4, 2022
I first discovered Kathleen McGurl a few years ago and have thoroughly enjoyed every book she's published since. However, I have to say that this one was a disappointment for me...not because it wasn't well written or plotted out well but because the story really didn't interest me. I've never been all that interested in stories around smugglers and I have to admit being far more interested in the present day plot than the historical one. I loved wondering what was going to be uncovered next in the renovation of the 18th century house rather than the play out in the past.
Thirtysomething Millie, recently separated from her husband and going through a very amicable divorce, buys an 18th century house in much of need of some TLC...if not, complete renovation. She hires builder Nick to undertake the renovations for her and a discovery is made that begins an exciting and interesting historical journey for Millie who thus seeks out a local historian to clue her in on the history of her new "old" house.
Rewinding back to 1784, Esther Harris works alongside her brother and father in their pub The Ship at Anchor. But besides this, she also works by night with the smugglers (or free traders) as they loot and store smuggled items in their very secret and purposely built cellar beneath the pub. She faces many difficult decisions and challenges, one of which questioning her steadfast love for one man when she is given an opportunity to wed another. But she must choose carefully...for there will be consequences far reaching should it be the wrong one. And then the battle raging between the smugglers and the Revenue and Customs officers brings things to a head...never knowing who to trust and who might betray them.
The present and the past are interwoven beautifully with each aspect of the past revealed at just the right time the story unfolds in the present. One of my favourite things about dual timelines.
However, this was not one of my favourites of Kathleen McGurl's but that isn't to say it isn't well researched or well written, because it is. Reading is subjective and what appeals to one does not to another. As I said at the beginning, the subject matter wasn't an appealing one to me and I found little interest in it. But I did read it to the end all the same.
I do look forward to more by Kathleen McGurl as she is a wonderful storyteller and a master at weaving the past with the present, however tenuous the link. It just so happens, this story wasn't for me but it was still exceptional storytelling.
I would like to thank #KathleenMcGurl, #Netgalley, #HQStories and #RachelsRandomResources for an ARC of #TheStormGirl in exchange for an honest review.
This review appears on my blog at https://stinathebookaholic.blogspot.com/.
Thirtysomething Millie, recently separated from her husband and going through a very amicable divorce, buys an 18th century house in much of need of some TLC...if not, complete renovation. She hires builder Nick to undertake the renovations for her and a discovery is made that begins an exciting and interesting historical journey for Millie who thus seeks out a local historian to clue her in on the history of her new "old" house.
Rewinding back to 1784, Esther Harris works alongside her brother and father in their pub The Ship at Anchor. But besides this, she also works by night with the smugglers (or free traders) as they loot and store smuggled items in their very secret and purposely built cellar beneath the pub. She faces many difficult decisions and challenges, one of which questioning her steadfast love for one man when she is given an opportunity to wed another. But she must choose carefully...for there will be consequences far reaching should it be the wrong one. And then the battle raging between the smugglers and the Revenue and Customs officers brings things to a head...never knowing who to trust and who might betray them.
The present and the past are interwoven beautifully with each aspect of the past revealed at just the right time the story unfolds in the present. One of my favourite things about dual timelines.
However, this was not one of my favourites of Kathleen McGurl's but that isn't to say it isn't well researched or well written, because it is. Reading is subjective and what appeals to one does not to another. As I said at the beginning, the subject matter wasn't an appealing one to me and I found little interest in it. But I did read it to the end all the same.
I do look forward to more by Kathleen McGurl as she is a wonderful storyteller and a master at weaving the past with the present, however tenuous the link. It just so happens, this story wasn't for me but it was still exceptional storytelling.
I would like to thank #KathleenMcGurl, #Netgalley, #HQStories and #RachelsRandomResources for an ARC of #TheStormGirl in exchange for an honest review.
This review appears on my blog at https://stinathebookaholic.blogspot.com/.
April 30, 2022
After reading the blurb of this book it sounded just like my kind of read, as I have always loved stories about the historical ways of life from the past. The story follows two very different timelines, one is of present day and the other is of the past, alternating between chapters. It kind of felt like a buy one get one free deal as your reading two romance stories set centuries apart but are totally connected by the place where the story is set.
I really loved how this story played out with all the suspense, mystery and drama within each timeline, it kept me wanting to keep on reading to see what would happen next.
This is my first book to read by this author and would definitely read more from them in the future. as their writing style was so easy to read, that I found myself getting lost amongst it’s pages and couldn’t put it down.
I really loved how this story played out with all the suspense, mystery and drama within each timeline, it kept me wanting to keep on reading to see what would happen next.
This is my first book to read by this author and would definitely read more from them in the future. as their writing style was so easy to read, that I found myself getting lost amongst it’s pages and couldn’t put it down.
June 29, 2022
I LOVED this book! I love historical fiction and what you can learn from it. I learned about a part of history that I had no idea existed. It was fun to learn about the smugglers or 'free traders' as they liked to call themselves. The great part about this book is that Kathleen McGurl used the actual places and real names of many of the people during this time period, 1784. It really brought the story to life. She did a great job intertwining the present with 1784. She kept you engrossed in the characters to find out what would happen next. I now want to travel to Christchurch, England, (Mudeford) to visit the actual places the events in this story took place. You will love this story!
June 24, 2022
This was a great historical story.
I liked learning more about the smugglers and seeing how the Inn was being restored in the present.
The characters where well written and the story was interesting.
I do think the description can use a rewrite since it gives away to much of the story.
And I liked most of the voices by the narrator but not all of them.
Thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for providing me with a free copy of this book in exchange for an honest review!
I liked learning more about the smugglers and seeing how the Inn was being restored in the present.
The characters where well written and the story was interesting.
I do think the description can use a rewrite since it gives away to much of the story.
And I liked most of the voices by the narrator but not all of them.
Thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for providing me with a free copy of this book in exchange for an honest review!
May 13, 2022
This is a thrilling tale of smuggling in bygone days combined with a modern-day story that tries to solve an old mystery. I love this kind of dual timeline novel and this one had me gripped. Both threads were well narrated and morphed seamlessly into each other, keeping me turning the pages. A thoroughly enjoyable read.
February 3, 2023
Two fabulous stories in one. First, set in a modern day town that is steeped in smugglers history when a young women purchases a beautiful old property that needs renovating. Through the renovation she experiences the renovation of her life.
Second story takes the reader back in time when the property was a small inn, the owner and his daughter part of the smuggling community.
This was a thrilling read, I was totally engrossed and invested in the stories.
Second story takes the reader back in time when the property was a small inn, the owner and his daughter part of the smuggling community.
This was a thrilling read, I was totally engrossed and invested in the stories.
April 19, 2022
I always look forward to a new Kathleen McGurl book and this one was no exception.
The smuggling escapades of long ago finely interweave with the story in the present when the new owner of an old inn with a long history of smuggling unlocks secrets from the past during renovations to the building. Enjoyable and gripping, I loved it!
The smuggling escapades of long ago finely interweave with the story in the present when the new owner of an old inn with a long history of smuggling unlocks secrets from the past during renovations to the building. Enjoyable and gripping, I loved it!
May 13, 2022
Thank you to NetGalley and HQ Digital for the opportunity to read and review this book before it's publication date! This in no way affected my review, opinions are my own.
B̷R̷I̷N̷G̷ ✨ 𝗕𝗢𝗥𝗥𝗢𝗪 ✨ B̷Y̷P̷A̷S̷S̷
After reading (&LOVING) a couple of Kathleen McGurl's books back in 2020, I've since read most all of her backlist plus any of her new releases - and while I still enjoy them, I have found that it's becoming somewhat repetitive. This will work really well if you want the same types of books/plot devices/characters but maybe not if you're reading them back to back.
I would say The Storm Girl is one of her stronger titles, and there was a lot to like about it, but for someone that has read almost 10 of her novels, I would recommend The Forgotten Secret or The Secret of the Chateau to someone interested in reading a book by Kathleen McGurl.
B̷R̷I̷N̷G̷ ✨ 𝗕𝗢𝗥𝗥𝗢𝗪 ✨ B̷Y̷P̷A̷S̷S̷
After reading (&LOVING) a couple of Kathleen McGurl's books back in 2020, I've since read most all of her backlist plus any of her new releases - and while I still enjoy them, I have found that it's becoming somewhat repetitive. This will work really well if you want the same types of books/plot devices/characters but maybe not if you're reading them back to back.
I would say The Storm Girl is one of her stronger titles, and there was a lot to like about it, but for someone that has read almost 10 of her novels, I would recommend The Forgotten Secret or The Secret of the Chateau to someone interested in reading a book by Kathleen McGurl.
May 16, 2022
I have read several books by this author and have always enjoyed them. The books I’ve read have all been similar in that they are dual timeline stories, usually in present day and centuries earlier. This book is no different and we are transported between the modern-day coastal town of Mudeford and then the town in its smuggling heyday of the late 1700’s. In the present-day timeline, we meet Millie Galton. She’s just moved to Mudeford following her divorce and has bought a house which she later finds out used to be the former Ship at Anchor pub. Hundreds of years earlier, the Ship at Anchor was run by Esther Harris and her father. They were involved with the local smugglers bringing in black market goods to avoid paying the revenue. Both stories revolve around the old pub and the tunnels that lead from it, and both also feature the mystery and romance from both timelines.
I liked Millie’s storyline and enjoyed her relocation to the old pub, and the subsequent renovation she had planned. I love the historical features found there and would have loved to have ventured down the old smuggling tunnels! Millie’s character was interesting, although she did annoy me a little when she preferred to listen to idle gossip rather than find out the truth. I also liked Esther’s character and enjoyed her storyline. The portrayal of the communities during those times was interesting and I loved how some of the characters and storylines were based on true stories and people. Esther’s storyline was definitely the stronger of the two, but I did enjoy them both equally.
This was a lovely read, which held my interest right from the beginning. It’s a mixture of history and mystery with a little bit of romance thrown into both timelines. The smuggling storyline was intriguing and had me reading with bated breath with the suspense of it all. There was a lot of emotion written into the book, particularly with Esther’s story, and I felt myself getting swept away with it as the storylines moved on. The author creates perfect dual timeline stories and has caught the essence of both timelines so well. Would definitely recommend.
I liked Millie’s storyline and enjoyed her relocation to the old pub, and the subsequent renovation she had planned. I love the historical features found there and would have loved to have ventured down the old smuggling tunnels! Millie’s character was interesting, although she did annoy me a little when she preferred to listen to idle gossip rather than find out the truth. I also liked Esther’s character and enjoyed her storyline. The portrayal of the communities during those times was interesting and I loved how some of the characters and storylines were based on true stories and people. Esther’s storyline was definitely the stronger of the two, but I did enjoy them both equally.
This was a lovely read, which held my interest right from the beginning. It’s a mixture of history and mystery with a little bit of romance thrown into both timelines. The smuggling storyline was intriguing and had me reading with bated breath with the suspense of it all. There was a lot of emotion written into the book, particularly with Esther’s story, and I felt myself getting swept away with it as the storylines moved on. The author creates perfect dual timeline stories and has caught the essence of both timelines so well. Would definitely recommend.
June 3, 2022
Alright, who do I need to be having words with?! *puts hands on hips* I swear, you lot have been holding out on me. I can’t believe this was my first Kathleen McGurl read.
I am a sucker for dual timeline stories; most especially when there is a mystery involved. Add in real historical events with a fictionalised take and you have yourself ‘Laura Catnip’ personified.
I have to admit I was h-o-o-k-e-d (that’s hooked, but more!) from the prologue. I had to have a stern word with myself (which never goes over well as you can imagine! *smirks*) that I was not to flick to the end just for reassurance… the struggle is real! *shrugs*
Esther and Millie are both special to me in different ways.
Can you imagine being Esther during this turbulent time? Smuggling would be fraught with danger but imagine the excitement of living life on the edge. (Although, there were two chances of getting me into that tunnel!) However, she’ll do what she has to do to protect those she loves. Even sacrifice her own happiness if necessary. (I was stress eating over a certain odious character.)
Divorce is never easy, but Millie is embracing her fresh start with gusto. It’s all about rediscovering herself and what she needs/wants in life which may include a little frisson of romance. Some places just call to the soul and Millie’s cottage has certainly done just that.
Who needs to eat, sleep, basically adult, when you are reading a story this good? As Esther and Millie’s stories unfolded, I had to find out what happened!
Drama, romance, suspense, intrigue, you name it, TSG has it in spades. Me being me, there were a few tears! Well, did you expect anything less? Pfft, I don’t think so. *crosses arms*
TSG is a definite must-read for all my fellow historical mystery/dual timeline readers!
I am a sucker for dual timeline stories; most especially when there is a mystery involved. Add in real historical events with a fictionalised take and you have yourself ‘Laura Catnip’ personified.
I have to admit I was h-o-o-k-e-d (that’s hooked, but more!) from the prologue. I had to have a stern word with myself (which never goes over well as you can imagine! *smirks*) that I was not to flick to the end just for reassurance… the struggle is real! *shrugs*
Esther and Millie are both special to me in different ways.
Can you imagine being Esther during this turbulent time? Smuggling would be fraught with danger but imagine the excitement of living life on the edge. (Although, there were two chances of getting me into that tunnel!) However, she’ll do what she has to do to protect those she loves. Even sacrifice her own happiness if necessary. (I was stress eating over a certain odious character.)
Divorce is never easy, but Millie is embracing her fresh start with gusto. It’s all about rediscovering herself and what she needs/wants in life which may include a little frisson of romance. Some places just call to the soul and Millie’s cottage has certainly done just that.
Who needs to eat, sleep, basically adult, when you are reading a story this good? As Esther and Millie’s stories unfolded, I had to find out what happened!
Drama, romance, suspense, intrigue, you name it, TSG has it in spades. Me being me, there were a few tears! Well, did you expect anything less? Pfft, I don’t think so. *crosses arms*
TSG is a definite must-read for all my fellow historical mystery/dual timeline readers!
December 26, 2025
Frustrating and the writing style was irritating. The dialogue was stiff and unnatural, with characters repeatedly using each other’s names in ways no one actually speaks (“Millie, I would like that”). There was a lot of unnecessary explanation of characters’ internal thoughts.
Both romance plotlines dragged. And Walker… I genuinely couldn’t tell what the author wanted him to be. Lecherous and unsettling? Or secretly a decent guy? Same with the nosey neighbour: an interfering Karen, or a good friend? The inconsistencies made these characters more confusing than compelling.
Lastly the nickname Storm Girl was thrown in strangely in the last 40 pages and appeared to have no connection or relevance other than for the purposes of the book title.
I was bothered by this book early on and probably should have DNF’d, but it was short, so I committed but in the end, it wasn’t my jam.
Both romance plotlines dragged. And Walker… I genuinely couldn’t tell what the author wanted him to be. Lecherous and unsettling? Or secretly a decent guy? Same with the nosey neighbour: an interfering Karen, or a good friend? The inconsistencies made these characters more confusing than compelling.
Lastly the nickname Storm Girl was thrown in strangely in the last 40 pages and appeared to have no connection or relevance other than for the purposes of the book title.
I was bothered by this book early on and probably should have DNF’d, but it was short, so I committed but in the end, it wasn’t my jam.
April 19, 2022
Once again, Kathleen McGurl has given us an incredible dual time line story that sparks the imagination. She has a gift that I think is unique to the combo past and present novel realm. I loved both timelines equally for they sing of sacrifice, discovery, mystery, romance, danger and fulfilment.
With every story of Kathleen’s, you get a generous slice of intriguing history, and each one seems to climb even higher up the scale of perfection (if that is possible). The Storm Girl shines (particularly in the past timeline) with a fresh advanced skill of craftmanship (I hasten to add that her books are all well written but there’s a little dash of something extra in this one). This genuine complex thread must have required much research, too. Possibly because Kathleen knows this region well and may have walked past all the areas she describes in great detail. In doing so, she has absorbed its atmospheric elements and natural beauty to the point she is able to deliver a very believable setting (even in transporting us back to the past). It is obvious she is writing from the depths of her heart, for a special care of the topic and location really shine through.
High praise, I suppose, but I believe this story, and all Kathleen’s, are worthy of the raving. And yes, I am a die-hard fan of this author but my reasons come from the experiences I have had in reading her many wonderful genealogical stories. I always learn a lot from the characters and identify with the themes and this novel is the same. Time and again she delivers such smooth transitions between two worlds and eras. I never feel once that I get lost or confused by the time shifts. I might get anxious as she leaves us at the end of each chapter dying to know more, but never muddled by or severed from each story. Kathleen is a great teller of tales and weaver of past and present lives creating a beautiful tapestry of hope and redemption.
The Storm Girl begins with an excerpt from Rudyard Kipling’s ‘A Smuggler’s Song’— an apt quote suitable to the novel’s plot. Kathleen has drawn from the fascinating local town history of Mudeford (set at the entrance to Christchurch Harbour in Dorset, England) and created an exciting, revealing story surrounding the challenges of smuggling in the 1700’s. It is a quaint setting of old fishermen’s cottages and an impressive historic Haven House Inn by the Mudeford Quay. This area and original building are linked with smuggling operations. Kathleen mentions this venue often in the story where celebrations readily occurred after a successful run. Plus she has utilised the battles that existed between the bootleggers and Customs Officers of the time.
Added to her own imaginative telling, we learn more about the Haven House Inn building and the real people involved in the background notes of the novel which is well worth reading. It has been a rich resource at her fingertips that she has utilised well, for the telling of this story is heavily soaked in adventure, drama, romance, twists and awe-inspiring revelations. Friendships, courtships and family connections fill these pages. The characters (some created and others real figures) are memorable and well fleshed out. We really get to know who they are: their past experiences, their dreams, their failures, their hopes for the future. And in some cases, their sacrifices.
The story begins in 1784 with a short ingenious Prologue, and you will understand why I say this more towards the end of the novel, for what is written in that passage sheds a whole new light on things when you look back!
Chapter One takes us to our modern day thread where we meet Millie who has split from her husband (a mutual agreement) and has purchased an old house that she is seeking to renovate. When a potential builder arrives at her door, she blurts out that her cat and kittens are up inside the old closed up fireplace and she cannot reach them. So, Nick, the builder attempts to free them and, once doing so, a discovery is made that begins an amazing historical journey.
In the past timeline, Esther Harris is a character we appreciate for she works hard to help her injured father in the pub and deals with all the secret goings on with the smugglers. She is faced with many difficult decisions��including one that requires great sacrifice. Her steadfast love for one man is challenged and the undercurrents of troubles put her in a heartbreaking position. The smugglers’ war with the Custom’s Officers stirs up her life in ways she never expected: including a possible betrayal. We, as the reader, watch these incredible scenes as they are played out. The danger elements are heightened to such a feverish pitch, we are left grasping the edge of our seats wondering what will happen next to Esther and the others involved. How will it all end? Read this beautifully crafted novel and you will see. But beware, there is more than one war in this novel: a war with the heart over head is present in ample measure in both timelines.
I am saying very little about the plot in both past and present as there is much going on that involve various character developments and misconstrued judgements. Both timelines convey how appearances are not always what they seem. But the end brings everything together into a unified fulfilling whole. Yes, there are sad and horrific moments in the story but also joyful and well-earned celebrations. And the theme of forgiveness shatters the voice of regret.
In closing, The Storm Girl is exquisitely crafted and you will be racing through the pages to see what each character and timeline offers. This is a powerful story that sparkles with creative maturity, depth and unexpected outcomes. It also has some certain unpredicted character arc developments and personality reveals. You won’t forget this one. The smuggling history is intriguing and how the past and present merge. I loved The Storm Girl from start to finish and highly recommend you partake of this dual timeline masterpiece. 5 Illuminating Stars ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Many thanks to Kathleen McGurl and her publisher HQ (HarperCollins) for a review copy.
With every story of Kathleen’s, you get a generous slice of intriguing history, and each one seems to climb even higher up the scale of perfection (if that is possible). The Storm Girl shines (particularly in the past timeline) with a fresh advanced skill of craftmanship (I hasten to add that her books are all well written but there’s a little dash of something extra in this one). This genuine complex thread must have required much research, too. Possibly because Kathleen knows this region well and may have walked past all the areas she describes in great detail. In doing so, she has absorbed its atmospheric elements and natural beauty to the point she is able to deliver a very believable setting (even in transporting us back to the past). It is obvious she is writing from the depths of her heart, for a special care of the topic and location really shine through.
High praise, I suppose, but I believe this story, and all Kathleen’s, are worthy of the raving. And yes, I am a die-hard fan of this author but my reasons come from the experiences I have had in reading her many wonderful genealogical stories. I always learn a lot from the characters and identify with the themes and this novel is the same. Time and again she delivers such smooth transitions between two worlds and eras. I never feel once that I get lost or confused by the time shifts. I might get anxious as she leaves us at the end of each chapter dying to know more, but never muddled by or severed from each story. Kathleen is a great teller of tales and weaver of past and present lives creating a beautiful tapestry of hope and redemption.
The Storm Girl begins with an excerpt from Rudyard Kipling’s ‘A Smuggler’s Song’— an apt quote suitable to the novel’s plot. Kathleen has drawn from the fascinating local town history of Mudeford (set at the entrance to Christchurch Harbour in Dorset, England) and created an exciting, revealing story surrounding the challenges of smuggling in the 1700’s. It is a quaint setting of old fishermen’s cottages and an impressive historic Haven House Inn by the Mudeford Quay. This area and original building are linked with smuggling operations. Kathleen mentions this venue often in the story where celebrations readily occurred after a successful run. Plus she has utilised the battles that existed between the bootleggers and Customs Officers of the time.
Added to her own imaginative telling, we learn more about the Haven House Inn building and the real people involved in the background notes of the novel which is well worth reading. It has been a rich resource at her fingertips that she has utilised well, for the telling of this story is heavily soaked in adventure, drama, romance, twists and awe-inspiring revelations. Friendships, courtships and family connections fill these pages. The characters (some created and others real figures) are memorable and well fleshed out. We really get to know who they are: their past experiences, their dreams, their failures, their hopes for the future. And in some cases, their sacrifices.
The story begins in 1784 with a short ingenious Prologue, and you will understand why I say this more towards the end of the novel, for what is written in that passage sheds a whole new light on things when you look back!
Chapter One takes us to our modern day thread where we meet Millie who has split from her husband (a mutual agreement) and has purchased an old house that she is seeking to renovate. When a potential builder arrives at her door, she blurts out that her cat and kittens are up inside the old closed up fireplace and she cannot reach them. So, Nick, the builder attempts to free them and, once doing so, a discovery is made that begins an amazing historical journey.
In the past timeline, Esther Harris is a character we appreciate for she works hard to help her injured father in the pub and deals with all the secret goings on with the smugglers. She is faced with many difficult decisions��including one that requires great sacrifice. Her steadfast love for one man is challenged and the undercurrents of troubles put her in a heartbreaking position. The smugglers’ war with the Custom’s Officers stirs up her life in ways she never expected: including a possible betrayal. We, as the reader, watch these incredible scenes as they are played out. The danger elements are heightened to such a feverish pitch, we are left grasping the edge of our seats wondering what will happen next to Esther and the others involved. How will it all end? Read this beautifully crafted novel and you will see. But beware, there is more than one war in this novel: a war with the heart over head is present in ample measure in both timelines.
I am saying very little about the plot in both past and present as there is much going on that involve various character developments and misconstrued judgements. Both timelines convey how appearances are not always what they seem. But the end brings everything together into a unified fulfilling whole. Yes, there are sad and horrific moments in the story but also joyful and well-earned celebrations. And the theme of forgiveness shatters the voice of regret.
In closing, The Storm Girl is exquisitely crafted and you will be racing through the pages to see what each character and timeline offers. This is a powerful story that sparkles with creative maturity, depth and unexpected outcomes. It also has some certain unpredicted character arc developments and personality reveals. You won’t forget this one. The smuggling history is intriguing and how the past and present merge. I loved The Storm Girl from start to finish and highly recommend you partake of this dual timeline masterpiece. 5 Illuminating Stars ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Many thanks to Kathleen McGurl and her publisher HQ (HarperCollins) for a review copy.
June 27, 2022
I love stories written in a dual timeline and I enjoyed both equally. This was full of drama, tension, mystery and it was nice to have some romance too.
I love the setting which sits perfectly with the smuggling aspect, I found it interesting and once again I went off to Google! The authors descriptions made the story feel more realistic and I was gripped throughout.
I will definitely be reading more from this author and I highly recommend this book.
I love the setting which sits perfectly with the smuggling aspect, I found it interesting and once again I went off to Google! The authors descriptions made the story feel more realistic and I was gripped throughout.
I will definitely be reading more from this author and I highly recommend this book.
November 29, 2022
The Storm Girl
When I started to read this book I was expecting a great book involving smugglers and of the time. I quite like books telling two stories of two people and their lives in different centuries unfolding the same property. However this book would probably be an easy holiday read. I did not enjoy it as expected. The stories of the two girls was very ordinary and slow to start.
When I started to read this book I was expecting a great book involving smugglers and of the time. I quite like books telling two stories of two people and their lives in different centuries unfolding the same property. However this book would probably be an easy holiday read. I did not enjoy it as expected. The stories of the two girls was very ordinary and slow to start.
July 23, 2022
Slightly disappointed
I've read a few of this author's books, this one based on fact but with fictional main characters was for me disappointing. I didn't like the writing style it felt like it was written by a teenager. The main character in the story got on my nerves. I think this was a great idea for a story but could have been so much better in my opinion.
I've read a few of this author's books, this one based on fact but with fictional main characters was for me disappointing. I didn't like the writing style it felt like it was written by a teenager. The main character in the story got on my nerves. I think this was a great idea for a story but could have been so much better in my opinion.
August 6, 2022
Once started, I couldn't put this book down until it was finished. I absolutely love books with a dual timeline, 2 stories in 1, but with a connection.
Can't wait for Kathleen's next book, my favourite author by far!!!!
Can't wait for Kathleen's next book, my favourite author by far!!!!
May 25, 2022
One thing I have to mention first: The Storm Girl is addictive! I read it on two evenings in a row!
18th century smugglers on the famous Dorset-Hampshire coast. Brave folk risking their lives, to get goods into England in order to circumvent the prohibitive taxes. And to profit a little from it, of course... But there's always a risk!
Add to that the glorious coastline, a bunch of troubled characters, and a mystery through time, and you have the perfect combination. I loved it!
In the present day, Millie Galton has treated herself to the kind of home she'd always craved, but her ex-husband had other ideas. While she is milling over the demise of their marriage, she plans to renovate the former inn she bought in Mudeford. She considers several offers, when a nosy neighbour warns her off a few, but by then it's too late. She's already engaged the services of Nick, who gets stuck into the project – and discovers a hidden cellar and tunnel. But where might it lead to?
Back in 1784, Esther struggles to keep their inn open. Her father's suffering from a poor back, and her brother ends up sailing the seas. And the man she loves – and who loves her in return – doesn't propose for lack of prospects. There's also her work with the smugglers, adding to her stress. When a revenue officer takes more than a passing interest in her and discovers their hidden cellar, she must take an important decision.
The historical setting is exquisite. We learn in detail the lay of the land, and the (often only) way of life there was for fishermen and villagers. The plot around Esther is utterly gripping. All the characters are very well-defined, and act in line with their station at the time. Her fate seems bleak, and full of dangers, yet there are also glimpses of enduring friendships, a strong sense of loyalty, and the attitudes of ordinary folks towards the Law and its officers.
The present-day setting is quaint. Millie's house is no longer an inn, and she is free to do as she pleases following her divorce. There is a sense of sentimentality towards her past, which she soon comes to understand. Her budding romance with Nick is also credible, especially given her neighbour's interference. Who should she believe? But then, a murder is discovered, the plot of which was quite complex in some ways, which I found intriguing, but it was resolved a little too smoothly for my liking.
The Storm Girl is a wonderful tale about the fight against poverty, dangers people faced, and chances they took. It's also a story about new beginnings, and the often confusing emotions that come with these.
It's a compelling novel. Highly recommended.
18th century smugglers on the famous Dorset-Hampshire coast. Brave folk risking their lives, to get goods into England in order to circumvent the prohibitive taxes. And to profit a little from it, of course... But there's always a risk!
Add to that the glorious coastline, a bunch of troubled characters, and a mystery through time, and you have the perfect combination. I loved it!
In the present day, Millie Galton has treated herself to the kind of home she'd always craved, but her ex-husband had other ideas. While she is milling over the demise of their marriage, she plans to renovate the former inn she bought in Mudeford. She considers several offers, when a nosy neighbour warns her off a few, but by then it's too late. She's already engaged the services of Nick, who gets stuck into the project – and discovers a hidden cellar and tunnel. But where might it lead to?
Back in 1784, Esther struggles to keep their inn open. Her father's suffering from a poor back, and her brother ends up sailing the seas. And the man she loves – and who loves her in return – doesn't propose for lack of prospects. There's also her work with the smugglers, adding to her stress. When a revenue officer takes more than a passing interest in her and discovers their hidden cellar, she must take an important decision.
The historical setting is exquisite. We learn in detail the lay of the land, and the (often only) way of life there was for fishermen and villagers. The plot around Esther is utterly gripping. All the characters are very well-defined, and act in line with their station at the time. Her fate seems bleak, and full of dangers, yet there are also glimpses of enduring friendships, a strong sense of loyalty, and the attitudes of ordinary folks towards the Law and its officers.
The present-day setting is quaint. Millie's house is no longer an inn, and she is free to do as she pleases following her divorce. There is a sense of sentimentality towards her past, which she soon comes to understand. Her budding romance with Nick is also credible, especially given her neighbour's interference. Who should she believe? But then, a murder is discovered, the plot of which was quite complex in some ways, which I found intriguing, but it was resolved a little too smoothly for my liking.
The Storm Girl is a wonderful tale about the fight against poverty, dangers people faced, and chances they took. It's also a story about new beginnings, and the often confusing emotions that come with these.
It's a compelling novel. Highly recommended.
July 20, 2022
Rating: 4.5 Stars
Kathleen McGurl’s The Storm Girl is the latest atmospheric, immersive and enthralling tale of skullduggery, betrayal and secrets from this talented storyteller.
In 1784, necessity dictates that Esther Harris takes over her father’s role of helping smugglers to hide contraband in the pub’s secret cellar. A dangerous undertaking that could have deadly consequences should it ever be discovered, Esther must tread carefully and not arouse anyone’s suspicions or else risk a fate worse than death. But when the free traders’ ship is trapped in the harbour, tensions rise and the danger intensifies when a battle between the smugglers and the revenue officers leads to murder – and to Esther making an impossible choice between familial duty and her heart’s desire…
In the present day, Millie Galton is looking for a fresh start after her divorce. Having found her dream home, which overlooks the harbour in Mudeford, Millie starts putting all of her plans into action. Millie has got quite a challenge on her hands, but she wasn’t expecting to uncover a devastating discovery from centuries earlier that could be linked to a powerful secret that has lain hidden for so long. Can Millie solve a mystery that has haunted Mudeford for so long? And can her new home be the safe haven she had hoped it would be?
Kathleen McGurl has the storyteller’s gift and she has this exquisite ability to conjure up the past and draw her reader into her story by imbuing her narrative with atmosphere, suspense, intrigue and romance.
The Storm Girl is a layered, exciting, emotional and powerfully told page-turner written in the tradition of Barbara Erskine full of bold characters, evocative period details, nail-biting tension and emotional intensity that will keep readers hooked all through the night.
I voluntarily read and reviewed an Advanced Reader Copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Kathleen McGurl’s The Storm Girl is the latest atmospheric, immersive and enthralling tale of skullduggery, betrayal and secrets from this talented storyteller.
In 1784, necessity dictates that Esther Harris takes over her father’s role of helping smugglers to hide contraband in the pub’s secret cellar. A dangerous undertaking that could have deadly consequences should it ever be discovered, Esther must tread carefully and not arouse anyone’s suspicions or else risk a fate worse than death. But when the free traders’ ship is trapped in the harbour, tensions rise and the danger intensifies when a battle between the smugglers and the revenue officers leads to murder – and to Esther making an impossible choice between familial duty and her heart’s desire…
In the present day, Millie Galton is looking for a fresh start after her divorce. Having found her dream home, which overlooks the harbour in Mudeford, Millie starts putting all of her plans into action. Millie has got quite a challenge on her hands, but she wasn’t expecting to uncover a devastating discovery from centuries earlier that could be linked to a powerful secret that has lain hidden for so long. Can Millie solve a mystery that has haunted Mudeford for so long? And can her new home be the safe haven she had hoped it would be?
Kathleen McGurl has the storyteller’s gift and she has this exquisite ability to conjure up the past and draw her reader into her story by imbuing her narrative with atmosphere, suspense, intrigue and romance.
The Storm Girl is a layered, exciting, emotional and powerfully told page-turner written in the tradition of Barbara Erskine full of bold characters, evocative period details, nail-biting tension and emotional intensity that will keep readers hooked all through the night.
I voluntarily read and reviewed an Advanced Reader Copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
May 14, 2022
This book is told through two time lines. Millie has moved into a new house, having split up with her husband. She employs a builder, Nick, who discovers she has a secret cellar behind the fireplace and a tunnel leads away from it towards the reed marshes behind the house. Millie checks with an antiquarian in the village and finds that her house used to be pub and the suspicion is that the tunnel was used by smugglers.
Meanwhile back in 1784 Esther Harris in running the pub The Ship at Anchor since her brother has been conscripted into the navy and her father has a bad back. She is also involved with the smuggling gang that works the south coast - most people are involved in some way or another, moving or storing goods, and they all benefit from the extra income and goods they couldn't afford because of the hefty excise duty. All goes well until one night the gang leader decides to bring in a double load and the excise men are waiting for them.
The writer uses both stories to slowly reveal the other's plot and interlink the lives of the Millie and Nick with those form the past.
The descriptions are good - it is obvious the author knows the area well and the characters well drawn. I particularly like Esther and Millie's nosy neighbour Sharon. It is a slick and easy read but it is obvious a good degree of research has been done regarding the smuggling at the time. The author's notes at the end confirm that many of the things in the story actually took place, if not at the actual time of the setting of the book.
With thanks to Netgalley and HQ for an arc copy in return for an honest review.
Meanwhile back in 1784 Esther Harris in running the pub The Ship at Anchor since her brother has been conscripted into the navy and her father has a bad back. She is also involved with the smuggling gang that works the south coast - most people are involved in some way or another, moving or storing goods, and they all benefit from the extra income and goods they couldn't afford because of the hefty excise duty. All goes well until one night the gang leader decides to bring in a double load and the excise men are waiting for them.
The writer uses both stories to slowly reveal the other's plot and interlink the lives of the Millie and Nick with those form the past.
The descriptions are good - it is obvious the author knows the area well and the characters well drawn. I particularly like Esther and Millie's nosy neighbour Sharon. It is a slick and easy read but it is obvious a good degree of research has been done regarding the smuggling at the time. The author's notes at the end confirm that many of the things in the story actually took place, if not at the actual time of the setting of the book.
With thanks to Netgalley and HQ for an arc copy in return for an honest review.
June 24, 2022
Brief synopsis from the book cover:
A heartbreaking choice. A secret kept for centuries.
1784. When Esther Harris’s father hurts his back, she takes over his role helping smugglers hide contraband in the secret cellar in their pub. But when the free traders’ ships are trapped in the harbour, a battle between the smugglers and the revenue officers leads to murder and betrayal – and Esther is forced to choose between the love of her life and protecting her family…
Present day. Fresh from her divorce, Millie Galton moves into a former inn overlooking the harbour in Mudeford and plans to create her dream home. When a chance discovery behind an old fireplace reveals the house’s secret history as a haven for smugglers and the devastating story of its former residents, could the mystery of a disappearance from centuries ago finally be solved?
My rating:
Plot: 5 out of 5 stars
Writing: 5 out of 5 stars
Character development: 5 out of 5 stars
Overall: 5 out of 5 stars
Recommended for readers of:
Women’s Fiction
Historical Fiction
Review:
This is a beautiful vividly written dual time line story. The story captured me from the start and slowly pulls you in until it’s almost impossible to put the book down. The characters are interesting and well developed. The books centers around two strong women who live in the same place but over two hundred years apart. The dual time line and the setting in beautiful Dorset giving a historical insight into the area, was what I enjoyed most.
Review copy provided through NetGalley at no cost to me.
A heartbreaking choice. A secret kept for centuries.
1784. When Esther Harris’s father hurts his back, she takes over his role helping smugglers hide contraband in the secret cellar in their pub. But when the free traders’ ships are trapped in the harbour, a battle between the smugglers and the revenue officers leads to murder and betrayal – and Esther is forced to choose between the love of her life and protecting her family…
Present day. Fresh from her divorce, Millie Galton moves into a former inn overlooking the harbour in Mudeford and plans to create her dream home. When a chance discovery behind an old fireplace reveals the house’s secret history as a haven for smugglers and the devastating story of its former residents, could the mystery of a disappearance from centuries ago finally be solved?
My rating:
Plot: 5 out of 5 stars
Writing: 5 out of 5 stars
Character development: 5 out of 5 stars
Overall: 5 out of 5 stars
Recommended for readers of:
Women’s Fiction
Historical Fiction
Review:
This is a beautiful vividly written dual time line story. The story captured me from the start and slowly pulls you in until it’s almost impossible to put the book down. The characters are interesting and well developed. The books centers around two strong women who live in the same place but over two hundred years apart. The dual time line and the setting in beautiful Dorset giving a historical insight into the area, was what I enjoyed most.
Review copy provided through NetGalley at no cost to me.
April 26, 2022
The Storm Girl is a dual timeline novel, and as a reader and writer of historical fiction, it was the historical storyline that captivated me far more than the modern-day tale of divorce and starting afresh.
Coming at this from a 'newb' point of view, I expected both storylines to have some connection, other than the most tenuous one, of them simply taking place in the same space although at different times. That wasn't what happened, and I did encounter some problems, whereby the one storyline gave away events in the other - which was a little frustrating.
With all that said, I did enjoy this book. The historical storyline, while a little too wholesome for me, did capture my imagination and The Storm Girl is very much a competent and go-getting type of gal that a modern audience will thrill to discover.
Will I try a dual timeline novel again, that remains to be seen? I confess I would have been happy to have the story revolve only around the historical elements, and not worry about the modern-day setting at all, but I more than understand that a dual timeline narrative is extremely popular, and I'm sure fans of this genre will be captivated by this tale of a place in two different timelines, over two hundred years apart, and will, hopefully, consider learning more about their own local history as a result of reading the book.
Coming at this from a 'newb' point of view, I expected both storylines to have some connection, other than the most tenuous one, of them simply taking place in the same space although at different times. That wasn't what happened, and I did encounter some problems, whereby the one storyline gave away events in the other - which was a little frustrating.
With all that said, I did enjoy this book. The historical storyline, while a little too wholesome for me, did capture my imagination and The Storm Girl is very much a competent and go-getting type of gal that a modern audience will thrill to discover.
Will I try a dual timeline novel again, that remains to be seen? I confess I would have been happy to have the story revolve only around the historical elements, and not worry about the modern-day setting at all, but I more than understand that a dual timeline narrative is extremely popular, and I'm sure fans of this genre will be captivated by this tale of a place in two different timelines, over two hundred years apart, and will, hopefully, consider learning more about their own local history as a result of reading the book.
October 29, 2023
Parallel storylines again: an historical incident, this time the Mudeford Battle between smugglers and Revenue officers in 1784, and a contemporary story told by a woman in the first person. This structure seems to be McGurl’s style. Millie Galton renovates an old house that was once a hotel used by smugglers with tunnels reaching to the beach where the boats unloaded their illegal goods. The whole community depended on the proceeds from smuggling. The story of Esther Harris, daughter of old Luke Harris, whose hotel it was, is interesting and based on fact. Esther and Sam Coombes are in love but a bent Revenue Officer Thomas Walker, who knows their ways of smuggling, says he will have them arrested if Esther doesn’t marry him. Millie’s story has sometimes contrived parallels with the historical story but is more cliched chick-lit, same as in The Girl with the Emerald Flag. I didn’t like Millie’s continual self-questioning (“what will I wear this time?” “why did I say that, what will he think of me” etc etc), which suggests weakness and following that, lack of respect for the character. There is the man Nick who she rather likes, a nosy neighbour in the unbelievable character of Sharon who puts her off, but then all end happily ever after. I gave this and the Girl with the Emerald Flag each three stars but actually this is not as good but very much the same sort of thing.
June 24, 2024
Kathleen McGurl's novel is a beautifully crafted dual-timeline story that intertwines the lives of Esther Harris in 1784 and Millie Galton in the present day. Set against the backdrop of a small harbor town, the novel offers a fascinating glimpse into the world of 18th-century smugglers and the modern-day restoration of a historic inn.
Esther's story of love, betrayal, and her family's desperate attempts to survive by aiding smugglers is gripping and emotionally resonant. Meanwhile, Millie's journey to transform her newly acquired inn, and her discovery of its hidden past, adds a layer of mystery and connection to the historical narrative.
Both timelines are vividly depicted, showcasing McGurl's talent for bringing historical settings to life. While Esther's storyline is particularly compelling, Millie's renovation project and the secrets she uncovers keep readers equally engaged. The audiobook narration is well-executed, though some character voices might not appeal to all listeners. Overall, this novel is a wonderful summer read that seamlessly blends history, suspense, and romance. Highly recommended for fans of historical fiction and dual-timeline stories.
If you are interested in other of my book reviews, make sure to follow me on GoodReads! #TheStormGirl #NetGalley #LifeLongLearning
Note: This review is based on an ARC copy
Esther's story of love, betrayal, and her family's desperate attempts to survive by aiding smugglers is gripping and emotionally resonant. Meanwhile, Millie's journey to transform her newly acquired inn, and her discovery of its hidden past, adds a layer of mystery and connection to the historical narrative.
Both timelines are vividly depicted, showcasing McGurl's talent for bringing historical settings to life. While Esther's storyline is particularly compelling, Millie's renovation project and the secrets she uncovers keep readers equally engaged. The audiobook narration is well-executed, though some character voices might not appeal to all listeners. Overall, this novel is a wonderful summer read that seamlessly blends history, suspense, and romance. Highly recommended for fans of historical fiction and dual-timeline stories.
If you are interested in other of my book reviews, make sure to follow me on GoodReads! #TheStormGirl #NetGalley #LifeLongLearning
Note: This review is based on an ARC copy
May 12, 2022
Another great book by Kathleen McGurl. I look forward to her dual time novels, and this one did not disappoint.
The novel takes place in two time periods. 1784 and present day. In 1784 the book follow Esther Harris, the daughter of a local publican whose family enjoys a bit of smuggling on the side. When her brother is pressed into the Navy, Esther takes on the mantle of chief smuggler for the family, as her father is to infirm to assist. Smuggling was a dangerous occupation with the Revenue men around. Some could be bribed, some could not.
In the present is Millie Galton, recently divorced and purchasing an old cottage in Mudeford to renovate. Millie hires a local builder Nick Marshall and through the renovations they discover a hidden passage behind her fireplace. The mystery of the passage and it’s smuggling past are too enticing to resist.
I enjoyed the dual time periods, the smuggling history and the mystery. This is a great book to curl up with on a lazy afternoon.
Thanks to Netgalley, HQ Digital and the author, Kathleen McGurl for the chance to read and review this book.
The novel takes place in two time periods. 1784 and present day. In 1784 the book follow Esther Harris, the daughter of a local publican whose family enjoys a bit of smuggling on the side. When her brother is pressed into the Navy, Esther takes on the mantle of chief smuggler for the family, as her father is to infirm to assist. Smuggling was a dangerous occupation with the Revenue men around. Some could be bribed, some could not.
In the present is Millie Galton, recently divorced and purchasing an old cottage in Mudeford to renovate. Millie hires a local builder Nick Marshall and through the renovations they discover a hidden passage behind her fireplace. The mystery of the passage and it’s smuggling past are too enticing to resist.
I enjoyed the dual time periods, the smuggling history and the mystery. This is a great book to curl up with on a lazy afternoon.
Thanks to Netgalley, HQ Digital and the author, Kathleen McGurl for the chance to read and review this book.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 114 reviews