The title piece is deservedly famous; a portrait of a giant foregrounding the chink in his armour, rendering him flawed and human without ever denying his talent and mystique. But it's preceded by pieces which feel like dry runs, variations on the same theme hunting that killer combination of reverence and truth-telling, all of them taking men who fit that same early Loaded template of male iconography (boxers, Peter O'Toole) and looking at them through a flaw (being past their best, making bad bets). And in each case it comes across more like a petty attempt at one-upmanship than the magisterial sweep of 'Sinatra'. Though even in the latter there is one passage which history has rendered faintly ridiculous, detailing a fractious encounter between Sinatra and Harlan Ellison, Ellison here being painted as strictly a supporting character, someone who will never loom as large as Sinatra. Well...he's not far off, is he now? Still, after that itch has finally been scratched, it seems as if Talese can move on. There's a wry account of the newspaper obituarist's lot, and an entertaining story from the youth of Talese's dad, in which quick thinking saved him from a terrible fate after he inadvertently holed a mafioso's trousers...
And then we get another sodding boxer. Yes, it's Ali, yes he's meeting Castro, but still. That's a third of the pieces in the book. Now, obviously, these are nine pieces culled from decades of work, and there's no telling what sort of selection bias may be at work; perhaps Talese was doing all sorts of great work ahead of 'Sinatra', and it's only the attempt to give us more stuff like the hit which has front-loaded the collection with failed sketches for it. If this collection were designed for free magazine giveaways in the nineties, like they used to do with Rat Pack Confidential, then fine; as is, being published in whatever this clusterfuck of a decade is called, it can't help but feel doubly dated. OK, the book then closes with a fabulous self-analytical potted autobiography, in which it is also established that Talese got his start as a sportswriter...but of all sports, why did it have to be boxing? I mean, I find them all tedious, but I can still enjoy some in the right artistic hands, a Damned Utd or an Any Given Sunday. Men hitting each other in the head for money...I couldn't even bear with Raging Bull.
So yeah, I might well read more Talese. He's very good at the whole New Journalism bit, even if he has reservations about the term. I just need to check next time that there's no bloody boxing.