What do you think?
Rate this book
Discerning God's Best #3
Matters of the Heart
Even when the war within seems never-ending, God promises hope and healing.
Katie Murphy has a heart for what matters. She wants to open an orphanage, but the town’s magistrate won’t allow it. Determined to champion the needs of the homeless, Katie finds ways around the man’s policies, like convincing a talented cart designer and maker to transport one of her orphans to a waiting adoptive family.
Hans Korhonen bravely served in a Civil War field hospital and is ready for a life without orders and the unrealistic expectations of others. He seeks a future that matters—one where people respect his abilities and where his heart and mind can heal. Working with Katie helps. So does accompanying the circuit-riding preacher on the trail.
Hans appreciates Katie’s fire and admires how she advocates for the needy. Katie values Hans’s willingness to serve every community he visits. The rebuilding of two lives in the 1866 era of reconstruction comes easier when they learn to depend wholly on God; knowing His love for them draws them closer—to Him and each other.
Katie Murphy has a heart for what matters. She wants to open an orphanage, but the town’s magistrate won’t allow it. Determined to champion the needs of the homeless, Katie finds ways around the man’s policies, like convincing a talented cart designer and maker to transport one of her orphans to a waiting adoptive family.
Hans Korhonen bravely served in a Civil War field hospital and is ready for a life without orders and the unrealistic expectations of others. He seeks a future that matters—one where people respect his abilities and where his heart and mind can heal. Working with Katie helps. So does accompanying the circuit-riding preacher on the trail.
Hans appreciates Katie’s fire and admires how she advocates for the needy. Katie values Hans’s willingness to serve every community he visits. The rebuilding of two lives in the 1866 era of reconstruction comes easier when they learn to depend wholly on God; knowing His love for them draws them closer—to Him and each other.
312 pages, Kindle Edition
First published July 1, 2022
299 people are currently reading
1405 people want to read
About the author
Heidi Gray McGill
24 books930 followersSelah Award finalist Heidi Gray McGill writes award-winning Christian fiction that draws readers into stories of hope, grace, and redemption. Her Discerning God’s Best series brings the American frontier to life with historical richness and biblical truth, while her contemporary novels explore modern struggles with the same heartfelt honesty. Blindness has not limited Heidi’s vision but refined her focus, shaping the way she writes about resilience and faith. She lives near Charlotte, North Carolina, with her husband of more than thirty years and treasures her role as Grammie to three energetic grandsons. Connect with Heidi and receive a free prequel at HeidiGrayMcGill.com.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 106 reviews
July 6, 2022
I held this book in my hands but the book held my heart. Seeing God’s design come to fruition in each life, Katie and Hans in particular, reinforced what I know and have been taught in my head but brought the reality of His love and faithfulness alive once again in my spirit. I felt the emotion, the hurt, the pain, the confusion, the doubt, the uncertainty, but also the redemptive power of God in each scenario. Heidi’s writings entertain yet keep the reader grounded in the true intent of her books, the message of Christ. I am so very grateful to have found her and look forward to her next creation and her next and her next…….
Read
October 13, 2023NOTE FROM THE AUTHOR:
Where did the idea for Matters of the Heart originate?
Before I was an author, I was the founder and director of an English as a Second Language ministry. The program touched the lives of students from 35 different countries. Regardless of culture, religion, language, or age, I found a substantial similarity in these students—they all wanted to improve their lot in life and that of their children.
Stories abounded of walks across deserts, financial hardships, desperate attempts to explain emergencies to medical professionals or law enforcement, failed verbal connections with schoolteachers, and an inability to obtain work because of their lack of language skills. Prejudice and distrust blocked them, culture shock took them outside their comfort zones, and the urgent need to survive made them scramble to dig deep inside and find creative ways to secure shelter and put food on their tables.
It wasn’t that these immigrants weren’t capable of achieving success. In their home countries, vocations varied from chemist and biologist with PhDs, to teachers, lawyers, and medical professionals. Others came from poverty and had little education but were not afraid of hard work, long hours, and low pay. They were tenacious, and they worked with relentless determination and a bullheaded resolve to achieve their goals. They relied on each other and soaked in everything around them in their desire to assimilate into the American culture and find a new place to belong.
Immigrants in the late 1800s were not much different. Individuals came to improve their lot in life and be a part of the greatest country in the world. In Matters of the Heart, Hans Korhonen leaves Finland with his brothers to take advantage of the land grants. Together, they work to establish a farm large enough to sustain four families and support troops during the Civil War. Yet, in their desire to belong and give back to our great nation, Hans’s idyllic life changes through his service as a Union soldier.
Kathleen Murphy, or Katie, came to the United States to escape a life of extreme poverty and abuse in Ireland. Working in her aunt’s boarding house offers more than a job; it provides the love and support of a family. Katie rises from her previous station and starts fresh with hope on the horizon. She finds a source of ministry that gives her life a purpose.
My association with my former ESL students helped me develop the characters in this book into individuals with which readers can identify. I invite you to join Katie and Hans as they establish themselves in their new home of Shumard Oak Bend. Universal Link: https://books2read.com/u/4X6Ye9
To read the FREE prequel, please visit my website at: https://bit.ly/freeprequel4you
Where did the idea for Matters of the Heart originate?
Before I was an author, I was the founder and director of an English as a Second Language ministry. The program touched the lives of students from 35 different countries. Regardless of culture, religion, language, or age, I found a substantial similarity in these students—they all wanted to improve their lot in life and that of their children.
Stories abounded of walks across deserts, financial hardships, desperate attempts to explain emergencies to medical professionals or law enforcement, failed verbal connections with schoolteachers, and an inability to obtain work because of their lack of language skills. Prejudice and distrust blocked them, culture shock took them outside their comfort zones, and the urgent need to survive made them scramble to dig deep inside and find creative ways to secure shelter and put food on their tables.
It wasn’t that these immigrants weren’t capable of achieving success. In their home countries, vocations varied from chemist and biologist with PhDs, to teachers, lawyers, and medical professionals. Others came from poverty and had little education but were not afraid of hard work, long hours, and low pay. They were tenacious, and they worked with relentless determination and a bullheaded resolve to achieve their goals. They relied on each other and soaked in everything around them in their desire to assimilate into the American culture and find a new place to belong.
Immigrants in the late 1800s were not much different. Individuals came to improve their lot in life and be a part of the greatest country in the world. In Matters of the Heart, Hans Korhonen leaves Finland with his brothers to take advantage of the land grants. Together, they work to establish a farm large enough to sustain four families and support troops during the Civil War. Yet, in their desire to belong and give back to our great nation, Hans’s idyllic life changes through his service as a Union soldier.
Kathleen Murphy, or Katie, came to the United States to escape a life of extreme poverty and abuse in Ireland. Working in her aunt’s boarding house offers more than a job; it provides the love and support of a family. Katie rises from her previous station and starts fresh with hope on the horizon. She finds a source of ministry that gives her life a purpose.
My association with my former ESL students helped me develop the characters in this book into individuals with which readers can identify. I invite you to join Katie and Hans as they establish themselves in their new home of Shumard Oak Bend. Universal Link: https://books2read.com/u/4X6Ye9
To read the FREE prequel, please visit my website at: https://bit.ly/freeprequel4you
August 6, 2022
This story has so much emotions running throughout that I devoured every word. From the beginning we can see how faith holds this story together and how it affects our two main characters. I loved the historical facts scattered within the scenes which made them come to life. The author captures the time period with depth and shows how hard it was to survive everyday. Food was scarce and at times there was little to share with others.
Katie is someone who is fiery, determined and outspoken. She has this dream to open a place where widows and orphans can go for shelter and help in getting their lives back in order. Her soft heart for this dream makes her sometimes try to get ahead of God’s plan. Have you ever stepped out ahead of God’s timing? I know I have. It didn’t turn out well but it was a lesson I needed to learn about patience.
Hans is very unsettled in his life. He has taken orders from others for so long that he has to get out on his own. The things he witnessed in the war has left scars on his emotions. We can also see that the unkind words he has heard growing up has made him feel like a failure. His heart has turned away from God yet he knows that he needs to find his way back to him.
My favorite character is the sweet woman who Katie calls Aunt Aideen. She has this gift of hospitality and makes everyone feel welcome at her boarding house. I could smell the fresh bread baking and the aroma of meals that made me feel content. She has a special relationship with her niece. I love how she always has a warm smile for everyone and tells Katie, “ we chose to have joy in our present circumstances rather than dwell on all that were wrong around us.” Oh my were those such profound words. We do have a choice to either be happy where we are or be miserable and continue to try to do things on your own.
There is much wisdom spoken from people who try to guide Katie and Hans. They both seem a little unsure of themselves. As they search for where they belong, the author delivers a strong message. “ when our identity comes from anything or anyone other than God, we will fail.”
Both Katie and Hans take a journey to overcome their past, learn to trust God and use their servant’s heart to help others. It is a beautiful story that reminds us that,” Every step forward changes the view, it never remains the same.” As we focus on what is in front of us, we can let go of the past. Once we let go of the feeling that we will fail, we can walk in freedom and follow God’s direction.
I received a copy of this book from Celebrate Lit. The review is my own opinion.
Katie is someone who is fiery, determined and outspoken. She has this dream to open a place where widows and orphans can go for shelter and help in getting their lives back in order. Her soft heart for this dream makes her sometimes try to get ahead of God’s plan. Have you ever stepped out ahead of God’s timing? I know I have. It didn’t turn out well but it was a lesson I needed to learn about patience.
Hans is very unsettled in his life. He has taken orders from others for so long that he has to get out on his own. The things he witnessed in the war has left scars on his emotions. We can also see that the unkind words he has heard growing up has made him feel like a failure. His heart has turned away from God yet he knows that he needs to find his way back to him.
My favorite character is the sweet woman who Katie calls Aunt Aideen. She has this gift of hospitality and makes everyone feel welcome at her boarding house. I could smell the fresh bread baking and the aroma of meals that made me feel content. She has a special relationship with her niece. I love how she always has a warm smile for everyone and tells Katie, “ we chose to have joy in our present circumstances rather than dwell on all that were wrong around us.” Oh my were those such profound words. We do have a choice to either be happy where we are or be miserable and continue to try to do things on your own.
There is much wisdom spoken from people who try to guide Katie and Hans. They both seem a little unsure of themselves. As they search for where they belong, the author delivers a strong message. “ when our identity comes from anything or anyone other than God, we will fail.”
Both Katie and Hans take a journey to overcome their past, learn to trust God and use their servant’s heart to help others. It is a beautiful story that reminds us that,” Every step forward changes the view, it never remains the same.” As we focus on what is in front of us, we can let go of the past. Once we let go of the feeling that we will fail, we can walk in freedom and follow God’s direction.
I received a copy of this book from Celebrate Lit. The review is my own opinion.
November 19, 2022
I loved the characters in this novel! This novel follows the struggles of Katie and Hans struggling to find themselves and what they want in life. The Civil War has ended but Hans still struggles with everything he saw during his time working at field hospitals and Katie, an orphan who was taken in by her aunt when she got to America, wants to help others like her but it seems no one is willing to take her seriously or help her get started. The two struggle with finding the right path, while trusting that God is guiding them and they need to have a little more trust and faith in him and themselves. This was a quick heartfelt read and was easy to read as a stand alone even though it is part of a series. I look forward to reading the others. I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book which I received from the author. All views expressed are only my honest opinion. Thank you to Just Read Tours for the invite.
November 16, 2022
Kathleen Murphy living with Aunt Aideen, helps her run the boarding house. After the war, there are a lot of widows and orphans, and her calling seems to be to help them despite the laws against it. Her dream is to open an Orphanage. Hans Korhonen, a young man hardened by the suffering of the war and helping with the injured, is confused, feels displaced and plagued by nightmares, and feels God has abandoned him.
This is a beautiful but heartbreaking story about redemption and finding God's plan for your life, even though it comes with tough choices. The characters are well-developed and diverse, and all bring their sense of belonging and wisdom to the story. I enjoyed them all.
Another great read from the author. Highly recommended. I received a complimentary copy from the author and voluntarily choose to review it. All opinions are my own.
This is a beautiful but heartbreaking story about redemption and finding God's plan for your life, even though it comes with tough choices. The characters are well-developed and diverse, and all bring their sense of belonging and wisdom to the story. I enjoyed them all.
Another great read from the author. Highly recommended. I received a complimentary copy from the author and voluntarily choose to review it. All opinions are my own.
April 1, 2023
It’s hard to live in the “yet” waiting for God’s way to become clear
Heidi Gray McGill breathes life into her characters. They are men and women I believe we can each identify with. Their struggles are real, but so is their hope. Each time I read a book by Heidi, my faith grows. I highlight multiple passages that are full of such wisdom. I loved the stories of Katie and Hans. I know the fourth in the series is coming soon. I can’t wait!
Heidi Gray McGill breathes life into her characters. They are men and women I believe we can each identify with. Their struggles are real, but so is their hope. Each time I read a book by Heidi, my faith grows. I highlight multiple passages that are full of such wisdom. I loved the stories of Katie and Hans. I know the fourth in the series is coming soon. I can’t wait!
November 24, 2022
First Initial Thoughts:
Katie is a young woman who has come to live with her aunt, Aideen, at her boarding house after her mother passed. She has a spunky, opinionated, and feisty personality and I chuckled a few times reading scenes where her personality shined through. Katie doesn't want to spend the rest of her life cleaning rooms at her Aunt's boarding house. She has the desire to help people. Specifically orphans and widowed women. She wants to create an orphanage for children and safe haven for widowed wives. Will she be able to achieve her dreams?
At the beginning of the book, we follow Hans's journey at his home. He has just come home from the war and is probably suffering from PTSD. He helps out his family with the harvest season but because of tensions at home decides to leave and try to make it on his own. With almost no money to his name, he comes across Aideen's boarding home. He is offered to work at the boarding home in exchange for free room and board. Will he be able to find a new home and life? And recover from the war?
Setting
Heidi instantly takes you to the midwest during the late 19th century. It's still rough and rugged and many are still recovering from the war. However, I felt that the town was kind of unfazed by the war and I would have liked to see more relatable content in that department. However, you felt instantly transported to a time when most towns were just a street and immigrants embarked on making a new life for themselves.
Final Thoughts
The main lesson in this book I think is that we can't go about life all alone. We need people. We need a community, friends, and family to help us through the most difficult of times.
Katie had such a temperament in the beginning and Aideen often tried to help her take that attitude without avail. However, I do think that was her personality it was tenfold because of the passing of her family. While I will not go into her past, I do think she needed to forgive to move toward the future she desperately wanted.
Shumard Oak Bend is exactly what Hans needed. He has given up on God, which is understandable after witnessing the horrors of war. He was definitely a sensitive, deep-thinker kind of man, and I really liked that Heidi made Hans this way. I think more men in novels need to be written this way because we don't see it that often. Hans's redemption was beautiful and it reminds us of God's everlasting love and presence.
Would I Recommend?
While I haven't read the rest of the series, I do find that if you enjoy western fiction you will thoroughly enjoy this "Hallmark" Esque novel!
Note: I was sent a copy of this book from the publisher to review. All opinions are my own.
Katie is a young woman who has come to live with her aunt, Aideen, at her boarding house after her mother passed. She has a spunky, opinionated, and feisty personality and I chuckled a few times reading scenes where her personality shined through. Katie doesn't want to spend the rest of her life cleaning rooms at her Aunt's boarding house. She has the desire to help people. Specifically orphans and widowed women. She wants to create an orphanage for children and safe haven for widowed wives. Will she be able to achieve her dreams?
At the beginning of the book, we follow Hans's journey at his home. He has just come home from the war and is probably suffering from PTSD. He helps out his family with the harvest season but because of tensions at home decides to leave and try to make it on his own. With almost no money to his name, he comes across Aideen's boarding home. He is offered to work at the boarding home in exchange for free room and board. Will he be able to find a new home and life? And recover from the war?
Setting
Heidi instantly takes you to the midwest during the late 19th century. It's still rough and rugged and many are still recovering from the war. However, I felt that the town was kind of unfazed by the war and I would have liked to see more relatable content in that department. However, you felt instantly transported to a time when most towns were just a street and immigrants embarked on making a new life for themselves.
Final Thoughts
The main lesson in this book I think is that we can't go about life all alone. We need people. We need a community, friends, and family to help us through the most difficult of times.
Katie had such a temperament in the beginning and Aideen often tried to help her take that attitude without avail. However, I do think that was her personality it was tenfold because of the passing of her family. While I will not go into her past, I do think she needed to forgive to move toward the future she desperately wanted.
Shumard Oak Bend is exactly what Hans needed. He has given up on God, which is understandable after witnessing the horrors of war. He was definitely a sensitive, deep-thinker kind of man, and I really liked that Heidi made Hans this way. I think more men in novels need to be written this way because we don't see it that often. Hans's redemption was beautiful and it reminds us of God's everlasting love and presence.
Would I Recommend?
While I haven't read the rest of the series, I do find that if you enjoy western fiction you will thoroughly enjoy this "Hallmark" Esque novel!
Note: I was sent a copy of this book from the publisher to review. All opinions are my own.
November 18, 2022
I was entranced from the beginning. I don’t know what it is about this novel, but it had my heart from the beginning, and the heartstrings tightened the more I read. The world building is unmatched, the ebb and flow almost melodic in its tempo. This is a very character driven novel that gave me Little House on the Prairie vibes with all of these wholesome characters that are doing life on the prairie together, along with that whisper of faith.
Hans is suffering from PTSD, though it didn’t have a name back then, and is having a faith and identity crisis. After coming home from being a medic in the Civil War he’s not sure what to do with himself, only knowing that he is tired of being told what to do, so he sets out on his own, the future uncharted. He immediately comes upon a traveling pastor that leads him to Grammies Boarding House, and to Katie.
Katie Murphy is a fiery redhead with a strong faith and even stronger conviction, wanting to open an orphanage in their small town, and help as many as she can, despite facing adversity from the town magistrate. Nothing is going to stop Katie from pursuing her dreams, her tenacity and passion for children is admirable and her toughness is helping to make true change in her community.
The faith of many of these characters, including Katie, inspired me greatly as I read, especially with what I am going through in this season of my life. They are living what they believe and stand strong, even in the face of adversity, which is very inspirational. I also loved how Hans talks to his horse Dorcas like a person, and how Dorcas responds, truly seeming to understand her owner. Such a cute touch!
I was quite charmed by all of it and often found myself lost in the narrative. This was truly a delight to read and though this is the first novel that I’ve read in the stores, and the first novel I’ve read by this author, it will not be my last. I am hooked!
*I have voluntarily reviewed a copy of this book which I received from the author/publisher through JustRead Tours. All views and opinions expressed are completely honest, and my own.
Hans is suffering from PTSD, though it didn’t have a name back then, and is having a faith and identity crisis. After coming home from being a medic in the Civil War he’s not sure what to do with himself, only knowing that he is tired of being told what to do, so he sets out on his own, the future uncharted. He immediately comes upon a traveling pastor that leads him to Grammies Boarding House, and to Katie.
Katie Murphy is a fiery redhead with a strong faith and even stronger conviction, wanting to open an orphanage in their small town, and help as many as she can, despite facing adversity from the town magistrate. Nothing is going to stop Katie from pursuing her dreams, her tenacity and passion for children is admirable and her toughness is helping to make true change in her community.
The faith of many of these characters, including Katie, inspired me greatly as I read, especially with what I am going through in this season of my life. They are living what they believe and stand strong, even in the face of adversity, which is very inspirational. I also loved how Hans talks to his horse Dorcas like a person, and how Dorcas responds, truly seeming to understand her owner. Such a cute touch!
I was quite charmed by all of it and often found myself lost in the narrative. This was truly a delight to read and though this is the first novel that I’ve read in the stores, and the first novel I’ve read by this author, it will not be my last. I am hooked!
*I have voluntarily reviewed a copy of this book which I received from the author/publisher through JustRead Tours. All views and opinions expressed are completely honest, and my own.
July 9, 2022
This third installment of McGill's Discerning God's Best series introduces us to a new character, Kathleen Orla Murphy, aka Katie, niece of Aideen and Paddy. She has come to Shumard Oak Bend from Ireland after her mother dies, full of spit and fire and desire to follow God, but also fear of the unknown. The beautiful redhead raises hackles and steps on toes, but with Aideen's help, she learns how to live in this small town and get along with people. She has a strong desire to help those who have been left destitute without fathers and husbands by the Civil War, but struggles to wait on God's perfect timing. She knows His way is best, but we can see ourselves in Katie as she keeps making mistakes and getting angry when she should keep calm and patient.
A character we briefly met in the first book is a major figure in this story: Hans Korhonen. He has come home from the war, wounded in body, spirit, and soul. He ends up in Shumard Oak Bend and falls for Katie almost immediately, but due to his shy nature, he keeps saying the wrong things or nothing at all and we wonder if they will ever figure it out.
Lots of familiar friends are in this wonderful story of waiting on God, learning about love, leaning on others when loved ones die, and facing the future knowing God always knows the best plan. I was laughing aloud and crying several times while reading and hope McGill plans to keep this series going for a long time! She has a gift for creating real characters and nailing their responses and need for a relationship with God that is life changing, just like we do.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the author/publisher with no obligation to write a positive review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
A character we briefly met in the first book is a major figure in this story: Hans Korhonen. He has come home from the war, wounded in body, spirit, and soul. He ends up in Shumard Oak Bend and falls for Katie almost immediately, but due to his shy nature, he keeps saying the wrong things or nothing at all and we wonder if they will ever figure it out.
Lots of familiar friends are in this wonderful story of waiting on God, learning about love, leaning on others when loved ones die, and facing the future knowing God always knows the best plan. I was laughing aloud and crying several times while reading and hope McGill plans to keep this series going for a long time! She has a gift for creating real characters and nailing their responses and need for a relationship with God that is life changing, just like we do.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the author/publisher with no obligation to write a positive review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
July 13, 2022
Matters of the Heart is Book 3 of the Discerning God’s Best series by Heidi Gray McGill.
We meet Kathleen Murphy, a spunky Irish immigrant with a passion to save Civil War orphans and widows while struggling against convention and the expectations of others. Katie has many lessons to learn, and it’s often a bumpy ride as most of her issues are self-imposed—she truly is her own worst enemy.
Meanwhile, Hans Korhonen is a war veteran running from his past, the demons of PTSD, and a God who he believes wants nothing to do with him. He is a deep thinker, albeit slightly awkward, and tends to over-analyze to the point of suffering from guilt about things that aren’t his to take on.
Katie and Hans meet but circle each other like prizefighters in the ring until Hans is convinced it’s time for him to leave rather than face his demons. It doesn’t take long though for him to realize that he can’t outrun God… or his feelings for Katie.
He hooks up with a most unlikely travel companion in the Reverend Jenkins, and God penetrates his stone-hard heart while Katie struggles with how she mistreated him.
This sweet, post-Civil War romance will keep you rooting for Katie, despite her foibles and for Hans as he struggles to recover from the trauma of his past. It proves that broken people can always have hope although often God’s best is totally different from what we expect or want—a lesson we all need.
We meet Kathleen Murphy, a spunky Irish immigrant with a passion to save Civil War orphans and widows while struggling against convention and the expectations of others. Katie has many lessons to learn, and it’s often a bumpy ride as most of her issues are self-imposed—she truly is her own worst enemy.
Meanwhile, Hans Korhonen is a war veteran running from his past, the demons of PTSD, and a God who he believes wants nothing to do with him. He is a deep thinker, albeit slightly awkward, and tends to over-analyze to the point of suffering from guilt about things that aren’t his to take on.
Katie and Hans meet but circle each other like prizefighters in the ring until Hans is convinced it’s time for him to leave rather than face his demons. It doesn’t take long though for him to realize that he can’t outrun God… or his feelings for Katie.
He hooks up with a most unlikely travel companion in the Reverend Jenkins, and God penetrates his stone-hard heart while Katie struggles with how she mistreated him.
This sweet, post-Civil War romance will keep you rooting for Katie, despite her foibles and for Hans as he struggles to recover from the trauma of his past. It proves that broken people can always have hope although often God’s best is totally different from what we expect or want—a lesson we all need.
July 13, 2022
Thank you so much to the author for my e-arc of this book!
This was a pure delight to read. I felt like I was "reading" a Hallmark historical movie. I loved how the characters were clearly human -- they struggled with internal conflicts, with faith, and with their relationships with each other. Katie had a heart of gold, and she's a heroine you will cheer for. She had to learn patience the whole book through... which I liked because I also struggle with patience, lol. Hans was a wonderful love interest. I loved his Finnish heritage and learning his backstory. The rest of the cast is a whole community full of colorful and interesting characters. My heart just went out to poor little Sam; I loved Katie's heart for widows, orphans, and those less unfortunate than herself. My favorite character was Essie; she was so unique and funny!
If you're looking for more Christian fiction to explore, I would absolutely recommend Heidi Gray McGill. This series is definitely a hidden gem!
This was a pure delight to read. I felt like I was "reading" a Hallmark historical movie. I loved how the characters were clearly human -- they struggled with internal conflicts, with faith, and with their relationships with each other. Katie had a heart of gold, and she's a heroine you will cheer for. She had to learn patience the whole book through... which I liked because I also struggle with patience, lol. Hans was a wonderful love interest. I loved his Finnish heritage and learning his backstory. The rest of the cast is a whole community full of colorful and interesting characters. My heart just went out to poor little Sam; I loved Katie's heart for widows, orphans, and those less unfortunate than herself. My favorite character was Essie; she was so unique and funny!
If you're looking for more Christian fiction to explore, I would absolutely recommend Heidi Gray McGill. This series is definitely a hidden gem!
August 6, 2022
Matters of the Heart: A Shumard Oak Bend Novel is the third installment from Heidi Gray McGill’s Discerning God’s Best series. I have not had the pleasure of reading the first two books yet, but felt that this one can be read as a stand alone. I thought it was a great story. I loved the faith element within the pages and felt as though I was on the same journey with Hans and Katie.
I am giving Matters of the Heart: A Shumard Oak Bend Novel five stars. Readers who enjoy reading clean historical fiction. I will be soon grabbing Desire of My Heart and With All My Heart to find out what happened previously.
I received a paperback copy of Matters of the Heart: A Shumard Oak Bend Novel from the publisher, but was not required to write a positive review. This review is one hundred percent my own honest opinion.
I am giving Matters of the Heart: A Shumard Oak Bend Novel five stars. Readers who enjoy reading clean historical fiction. I will be soon grabbing Desire of My Heart and With All My Heart to find out what happened previously.
I received a paperback copy of Matters of the Heart: A Shumard Oak Bend Novel from the publisher, but was not required to write a positive review. This review is one hundred percent my own honest opinion.
December 16, 2022
This story is what Christian Fiction should all strive to be—a reminder of the lessons and truths found within the Bible.
This was my first time reading a book by Heidi Gray McGill but I am now eagerly going back and reading the rest of the books she has written. Matters of The Heart was very well written and will go down as one of the best books in 2022 that I have read.
From the characters that were so lovely detailed, how they overcame their struggles, and how Heidi Gray McGill wrote them with so much biblical truth. Just wow. I cannot believe that I hadn't read her books before.
Truly a book I recommend reading.
5 Stars.
*I volunteered to read this book in return for my honest feedback.
This was my first time reading a book by Heidi Gray McGill but I am now eagerly going back and reading the rest of the books she has written. Matters of The Heart was very well written and will go down as one of the best books in 2022 that I have read.
From the characters that were so lovely detailed, how they overcame their struggles, and how Heidi Gray McGill wrote them with so much biblical truth. Just wow. I cannot believe that I hadn't read her books before.
Truly a book I recommend reading.
5 Stars.
*I volunteered to read this book in return for my honest feedback.
April 21, 2024
This series is worth the read for everyone. You see how God works in the lives of people and how people learn to listen to God. Most of the people are fun to get to know as they work out there problems. There is heartache, tears, love and humor as people grow in relationships. I like how people accept each other no matter the circumstances. I was able to preread this novel as an ARC reader. I look forward to Heidi Gray McGill next book.
August 8, 2022
She leaves Ireland and lives with her aunt.
They run a boarding house. And when an intertant pastor comes to town with his friend life becomes very interesting. She has a dream to open an orphanage. He has no dream, except to stay with his pastor friend. Totally an amazing book - God working in spite of fears and failures!!!
I received a copy of this book from the publisher. All thoughts and comments are my own.
They run a boarding house. And when an intertant pastor comes to town with his friend life becomes very interesting. She has a dream to open an orphanage. He has no dream, except to stay with his pastor friend. Totally an amazing book - God working in spite of fears and failures!!!
I received a copy of this book from the publisher. All thoughts and comments are my own.
July 20, 2022
Katie and Hans are both determined people one for God and one not for sure. The author has written an interesting read with a Christian thread throughout that also has family and dealing with the after effects of war. It is a descriptive write that makes you feel like you are there. I highly recommend this book.
I received an ARC from the author and am leaving my own opinion on my own accord.
I received an ARC from the author and am leaving my own opinion on my own accord.
June 28, 2024
Love, Love, Love This Series!
I found Heidi Gray McGill’s books thanks to my sister Tema Banner who is in a writing group with Heidi. These books literally draw me closer to God. Living in the “Yet” is what I am taking from this one. To find out what I am talking about you will have to read the book! 😊
I found Heidi Gray McGill’s books thanks to my sister Tema Banner who is in a writing group with Heidi. These books literally draw me closer to God. Living in the “Yet” is what I am taking from this one. To find out what I am talking about you will have to read the book! 😊
July 15, 2022
Matters of the Heart was another delightful story by the author. You can see faith on all pages. You also really get to know the characters as you read. The seem like friends to me. Well done to the author on another wonderful story!
August 5, 2022
God gives redemption and vision
Hans Shows us what happens when a person truly accepts Jesus. Katie shows us that If we have a vision, we need to hold onto it even if everyone seems to be against it. God always makes a way for His desire to happen. Very well done!
Hans Shows us what happens when a person truly accepts Jesus. Katie shows us that If we have a vision, we need to hold onto it even if everyone seems to be against it. God always makes a way for His desire to happen. Very well done!
Read
August 6, 2022Lost But Found
I loved all of it. Heidi writes such awesome believable stories. I loved the story as well as the characrers. We need God directing our way and she protrays that so well.Awesome job, Heidi!
I loved all of it. Heidi writes such awesome believable stories. I loved the story as well as the characrers. We need God directing our way and she protrays that so well.Awesome job, Heidi!
November 16, 2025
Picture God Running after Hans
This story illustrates the fact that you can run from God’s calling, but He never stops pursuing or removes the calling from your life. Hans and Katie’s story.
This story illustrates the fact that you can run from God’s calling, but He never stops pursuing or removes the calling from your life. Hans and Katie’s story.
February 1, 2026
Another great read! Really enjoyed Katie and Han’s story.Went to download the 4th book in this series Healing of the Heart from kindle unlimited. Sadly there is an issue.Not sure how to tell Amazon.When you download the 4th book it shows the cover and title but when you go to read it,it’s actually the 3rd book Matters of the heart I just read.Sure hope it gets worked out soon. Would love to read it.
December 26, 2025
Accepting God and yielding to His will.
___________________________
pg. 271
“But scriptures are just phrases until we know God on a deeper level and on more than just paper. I’ve learned God’s Word doesn’t become powerful until it becomes personal.” 🙏❤️
“I’ve learned it’s easier to act like a Christian than react like one.”
___________________________
pg. 271
“But scriptures are just phrases until we know God on a deeper level and on more than just paper. I’ve learned God’s Word doesn’t become powerful until it becomes personal.” 🙏❤️
“I’ve learned it’s easier to act like a Christian than react like one.”
March 24, 2025
I was really impressed by the accurate Conservative Christianity and the development of Hans conversion. The story kept me engaged throughout. I especially liked the "rescuing" of women and children displaced by the Civil War and the acceptance of the Negro girl, Essie. There were a few instances of gaps in the story, so I deducted 1 star.
June 25, 2025
A very good read.
I have very much enjoyed reading another book by author Heidi Grey McGill. She has become one of my favorite Christian historical fiction authors.
I have very much enjoyed reading another book by author Heidi Grey McGill. She has become one of my favorite Christian historical fiction authors.
August 11, 2022
Matters is the Heart is written by Heidi Gray McGill. This is part of the Shumard Oak Bend series. I had not read the other books in the series but did it feel lost at all. This book is set right after the Civil War and opens in 1866. The author chose to see the story in Missouri and included great historical details.
Katie has come over from Ireland to live with her aunt in her boarding house. Katie has some big dreams and feels it is her calling to open a orphanage in order to care and help the widows and orphans from the war. Katie however isn’t the most lady-like woman. But her spitfire personality made me like her even more.
Hans feels like a broken failed man. He didn’t see action during the Civil War but was affected a different way. He handled a lot of the deceased individuals. He worked at a field hospital and saw broken and deceased men all day long. He returned to his families farm afterwards but his brothers wife would rather see him off then assisting. Hans isn’t sure what God has in store for him and is afraid to talk to him. Until he meets Reverend on his way to Shumard Oak.
This book has a whole cast of secondary characters that make the book feel complete. The whole town has its own dynamics including the magistrate who will do anything to make sure Katie’s dreams are squashed. The author did a phenomenal job with bringing the town to life. I felt like I was a part of the story. I could see the scenes unfolding In front of my eyes.
I enjoyed seeing the characters all evolve throughout the book. The author places some great scripture in to back up the lesson she is trying to teach. Katie and Hans have an interesting meeting and it kept me laughing throughout the book.
Historically, I felt the author did a good job creating her story as accurate as possible. There were still prejudices that those of different descent faced at this time period. The nation was still healing from a horrible war. There were some that were still stuck in their ways.
Thank you to the author, publisher and Celebrate Lit for allowing me to read a copy of this story. All thoughts are my own.
August 17, 2022
Christian Historical Fiction is a favorite genre of mine. Matters of the Heart by Heidi Gray McGill is Book 3 in the Shumard Oak series. I have not read the first 2 books in the series YET, but this book is a great standalone book.
Kathleen Murphy has come to America from Ireland to help her Aunt and Uncle with their boarding house. Katie has a passion for Widows and Orphans of the Civil War and wants to love and support them. Katie has a lot to overcome and she feels that she lacks confidence which can be her worst enemy. Hans Korhonen is a War Veteran and suffers from PTSD and his faith in God is lacking. A chance meeting between Hans and Katie and Hans knows immediately that he has "love at first sight" for Katie. Hans being shy and also having an accent from Finland, has trouble communicating with Katie and feels he has said so many wrong things. He wants to run from the situation, but his heart is tugging. Katie's heart is also troubled as she realizes she treated Hans poorly and she regrets it. Will Katie and Hans work things out and are they destined for a relationship? Will they both trust God for future plans or continue to lack Faith?
I grabbed this book to read on a Rainy Day and had nothing else going on. I am glad I had no other plans for that day, as I did not stop reading until I was done with the book. Katie is a determined woman who wants to care for all the Widows and Orphans. She also struggles with patience in most situations. I LOVE how she worked on her Patience throughout the book. Hans is a man who knows he has a lot to overcome after the effects of the War. He also sees a beautiful woman in Katie and is very interested in having a relationship with her. The Book is Faith-Based and I appreciate how the author makes that the center of this book. The characters all have faith issues, but throughout the book the author helps the characters gain faith again. I am soo encouraged by this book and I will be going back and reading the first 2 books in this series! FANTASTIC BOOK!
Kathleen Murphy has come to America from Ireland to help her Aunt and Uncle with their boarding house. Katie has a passion for Widows and Orphans of the Civil War and wants to love and support them. Katie has a lot to overcome and she feels that she lacks confidence which can be her worst enemy. Hans Korhonen is a War Veteran and suffers from PTSD and his faith in God is lacking. A chance meeting between Hans and Katie and Hans knows immediately that he has "love at first sight" for Katie. Hans being shy and also having an accent from Finland, has trouble communicating with Katie and feels he has said so many wrong things. He wants to run from the situation, but his heart is tugging. Katie's heart is also troubled as she realizes she treated Hans poorly and she regrets it. Will Katie and Hans work things out and are they destined for a relationship? Will they both trust God for future plans or continue to lack Faith?
I grabbed this book to read on a Rainy Day and had nothing else going on. I am glad I had no other plans for that day, as I did not stop reading until I was done with the book. Katie is a determined woman who wants to care for all the Widows and Orphans. She also struggles with patience in most situations. I LOVE how she worked on her Patience throughout the book. Hans is a man who knows he has a lot to overcome after the effects of the War. He also sees a beautiful woman in Katie and is very interested in having a relationship with her. The Book is Faith-Based and I appreciate how the author makes that the center of this book. The characters all have faith issues, but throughout the book the author helps the characters gain faith again. I am soo encouraged by this book and I will be going back and reading the first 2 books in this series! FANTASTIC BOOK!
July 25, 2022
Matters of the Heart: A Shumard Oak Bend Novel, Book 3 in the Discerning God’s Best Series by Heidi Gray McGill is an unapologetically Christ-filled novel with engaging plot lines, endearing characters and unexpected twists and turns. Told from the points of view of both protagonists, the short chapters are clearly labeled to help the reader keep track of the whose point of view we are experiencing the story from. Jumping between perspectives did seem a bit jarring at first, but as the book progressed, it began to feel more natural and by the end, I didn’t even notice it. The characters in Ms. McGill’s book are wonderfully entertaining. Katie is feisty, fun and full of life. Her persistence and determination to follow God’s plan for her life, even when faced with many setbacks and doubts, is inspiring. Her sassiness and strong spirit kept me grinning. Hans is stoic and frustrating at times, but warm and extremely loveable at others, and his arc is my favorite one in the novel. Readers will get to see the redemption of a person resistant to Christ and gain wonderful truths about Christ’s love for us and the path to salvation through grace and belief in Him. Essie, Aideen and the Reverend kept me smiling (and sometimes laughing out loud) throughout the entire novel as well. I would highly recommend this book to any reader who enjoys Christian historical fiction that boldly proclaims Christ’s love and our need for His gift of salvation. I believe it will inspire you and encourage you in your faith walk, and I will definitely be going back to read books 1 and 2 in the series.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the author/publisher with no obligation to write a positive review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the author/publisher with no obligation to write a positive review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
August 10, 2022
Matters of the Heart: A Shumard Oak Bend Novel, is Book 3 in the Discerning God’s Best Series by author Heidi Gray McGill. This is a Christian historical novel that does not hide its Christian message. Brava author McGill! I adore Christian novels where the inspirational and faith messages are not hidden or diluted. If you have not read the first two books in this series, you will be able to follow alone just fine. It makes a nice stand alone book. You will, however, be missing two great back stories that are equally as wonderful as this one.
The author has done a wonderful job. The storyline is engaging. I was immediately invested in the story and characters. There were a few twists and turns thrown in for surprises. Characters are believable. They are down to earth and easily relatable. Descriptions were on point and took me back in time to 1866 Missouri. The writing style is very nice. The story is told from two different points of view. Each chapter is clearly noted as to whose it is.
This is the story of feisty Irish immigrant Katie Murphy and Finnish immigrant Hans Korhonen who fought in the Civil War. Each are searching for a new beginning. These characters are open and had me emotionally invested. Katie was a fun, fireball. She was determined to follow God and His plan for her. Hans is not sure about God. He is goes back and forth between being closed off to open and lovable.
I thought this was an extremely entertaining and inspirational read. The more I read, the more I felt that I was part of the community. The characters felt like friends. A few were quirky and provided humor. It was very enjoyable.
I highly recommend Matters of the Heart. It gets a 4 star rating from me. I received a copy from Celebrate Lit, but these are my honest thoughts.
August 11, 2022
I appreciate being privy to journey alongside the main characters in this book. I especially relate to Katie as she is non-conforming, feisty, confident, outspoken, and driven but of which God still holds value. When Hans arrives on scene, he’s a bit broken from his past and doubts that God could possibly use him for good. I cheered this couple on from their first meeting. However, will they make it? In relationships, it takes two to tango plus God to make it so. Their paths must take the necessary turns to grown and learn. Katie learns to live in the ‘yet,’ and hopes to discover her best life. Hans invests time with the reverend as they trek from town to town. Hans admits he never cared much for religious men but found the reverend to have an ‘easy, non-judgmental way’ about him, speaking about God as though He were a ‘personal friend’. Unbeknownst to Hans, this allowed himself to discover his new faith and much needed change of heart. I loved reading the three simple words uttered by Hans when he made one of life’s most important decisions. He learned how ‘God’s Word doesn’t become powerful until it becomes personal.’
I cherished the relationship journey within this story. I found myself laughing, empathizing, and aching when each character did. The author (Heidi) was able to clearly depict the scenes and what each person was experiencing. One of my favorites being when Hans and Katie would interact. Their playful banter reminds me of the fun I continue to experience with my spouse after more than 25 years of marriage.
I enjoyed reading this as an eBook, as it was easy to lookup any new words (especially those from the time period).
I cherished the relationship journey within this story. I found myself laughing, empathizing, and aching when each character did. The author (Heidi) was able to clearly depict the scenes and what each person was experiencing. One of my favorites being when Hans and Katie would interact. Their playful banter reminds me of the fun I continue to experience with my spouse after more than 25 years of marriage.
I enjoyed reading this as an eBook, as it was easy to lookup any new words (especially those from the time period).
Displaying 1 - 30 of 106 reviews