Thanks to NetGalley, St. Martin's Press, and Minotaur Books for the opportunity to read this compelling ARC. I had previously enjoyed a couple of this author's books and am a big fan of Nordic Noir, especially those with an Icelandic setting. I found the atmosphere to be cold and dark, like the personality of its new protagonist, retired Detective Konrad. It is both an in-depth character study and an intensive police procedural that made it slow-paced, as investigations into cold cases must be in real-life situations.
We learn that Konrad is a gloomy person, direct and abrupt with others. His father was harsh with him and abusive towards his mother. His mother left home with his sister, but he was forced to remain with his father, who was a criminal and used his son in some of his criminal schemes. Konrad's father was murdered years before, and that killing has never been solved. Konrad was bullied in school because of a withered arm. He learned to be brutal in revenge as a result. However, this disability did not prevent him from becoming an effective police officer. This handicap comes into the story towards the end.
His beloved wife died of cancer. He left the police force six years before to care for her and retired amidst his grief at her death. He feels guilty about being unfaithful to her with a co-worker. He denies being bored in his retirement but has not acquired a fulfilling pastime and only takes pleasure with visits with his grandchildren at his son's home.
Konrad has been haunted by a cold case he was never able to solve. Thirty years earlier, a businessman, Sigurvin, disappeared in 1985. His former partner, Hjaltain, was arrested on circumstantial evidence and a witness claiming he heard the two men arguing before his disappearance. Hjaltain was released due to inadequate proof of his involvement and always proclaimed his innocence. Konrad thought him guilty.
A group of German tourists have just discovered Sigurvin's body uncovered by melting ice in a glacier. The body has been perfectly preserved for thirty years. Forensic evidence points to murder. A police officer draws him reluctantly back into the case. She tells him that Hjaltain is back in prison and has requested to speak to him. Konrad agrees because he has always been bothered by the case and is bored. He hopes Hjaltain is prepared to confess to him. He is ordered not to get involved in the case beyond his interview with the imprisoned man. Hjaltain still professes his innocence, and Konrad is rude and unsympathetic to him during their encounter. He also pleads with Konrad to find the true culprit.
Konrad becomes more involved in the case after a woman visits him, requesting he find out who killed her brother, a man named Villi, in a hit and run in 2009. It becomes evident that the two cases may be connected. As a young boy, Villi encountered a strange man around the time and at the place where Sigurvin vanished. The man threatened the young boy that he would kill him if he ever spoke of his presence. His sister believes he was deliberately killed for what he witnessed as a child.
Konrad begins a slow, deliberate investigation as a private citizen and retired police officer, methodically uncovering clues. This involves questioning anyone involved in the earlier cases who are still alive, going through old files, and surveillance of suspects from his car. The book became slow-paced and tedious for me at this point, and there was a minimum of action. However, I felt this must be how attempts to solve cold cases must be in real life. Because Konrad does not have police authority to investigate, doors are slammed in his face if witnesses do not want to cooperate. The lead investigator from 1985 is a corrupt cop who is hostile towards him.
What is surprising is that many of the witnesses and suspects still have sharp and vivid memories after all that time. They recall things they did not reveal in the past or admit to giving false testimony. Konrad's investigation uncovered clues, such as acquaintances from a childhood Boy Scout troop, fraudulent spiritualism, liquor and drug smuggling, a vehicle demolition shop, forced statements, and a hidden stash of money. Can all these clues be tied together?
I was left wondering if the police will now reinstate Konrad in some capacity. The long-ago murder of his father is still unresolved, and will he continue to investigate it further? He is feeling some guilt about the imprisonment of Hjaltain, who has since died, protesting his innocence. Konrad also has a secret about his role in the act of recent revenge that cannot be uncovered. There is much to be resolved, and I am looking forward to the second book featuring Detective Konrad. Hopefully, this gruff, sad detective will show a glimmer of happiness in the next book in the series.
Recommended to those who like Nordic Noir and a slow-paced, detailed police procedural. 3.5 stars rounded off to 4.