Grab a favorite beverage and snack. Buckle your seatbelt. This book inspired a bit of a rant after reading one star reviews, this book, along with treasure trove of others. Some mentioned below.
Not my typical review style, sigh, thanks for supporting me if you take a journey down the animated frustration road of the topic.
In case you’d rather not, know I really like the book. Research it required. People. The book is well done. Gave me a fresh perspective of the times and topic.
Answers the question, what is black and white without a clear result. Mostly due to people not having their own answers. Just eye sight, in my opinion.
Now, onto some bucking and bitching 😁
Revolving around a married couples plight, this story, Master Slave Husband Wife, by ILyon Woo, weaves in the many factors to William and Ellen’s success toward freedom.
Rarely is an event leading to slavery’s abolishment successful such as this without the inclusion of factors like the Underground Railroad and many people involved. Either directly or not to include people on both sides being entangled based on location.
Harriet Tubman and Sojourner Truth are mentioned though briefly due to their lack of notoriety yet for reference to a wider view of the activism at the time. Painting a wide picture along with other influential leaders toward freedom, such as, Frederick Douglass. Multiple times as a part of the life to this harrowing tale of survival. He, as well as the Carter’s prior to marriage following their harrowing escape. Following nuptials, although legality is questionable, but supported by the notion of national building morally is more important than how they’ve been living to this point married in spirit, not legally.
I’ve read many reviews that complain of the focus being less on the couple and more on the movement toward freedom within a complicated system of trafficking humans our government constitution allows at the time including states rights.
It’s easy for someone in the future (today) to compliment or complain about the world of human cruelty and forced servitude told here. Offering a one star review because the story isn’t how they want it to be. More about the couple when losing perspective this is about them while speaking of conditions that contribute. The main thread is William and Ellen’s path to this heroic book.
The reality of the totality of what this world was told based on factual details from relentless research is a marvel in and of itself.
I’m amazed at the wealth of info about the Carter’s amassed to create this epic tale. As a maturing writer and researcher who enjoys genealogy imagine the struggles to compile enough data to weave a life quilt. Enough to satisfy publication and justify readership.
As far as I’m concerned the story is perfect. The tale important. This couple triggered changes and conversations on the story telling circuit contributed to changing out nations.
Having participated in storytelling events could visualize everyone sharing the details to communities around the world to rally support. Today, these are afterthoughts. If we do not have authors who commit to these publications the historical value is lost forever. Not just several generations. Such as the case here.
We must never forget. First, we must know. How else but by the effort of people like Ms. Woo.
Having read countless accounts on this topic as far back as childhood relating to slavery and mistreatments of people via studying Man’s Inhumanity to Man in school like my current read, Jonathan Freedland’s The Escape Artist: the man who broke out of Aschwitz to warn the world. This author talks about why he wrote the story in the prologue. These artifacts of humanity must be remembered. In the case of Woo and Freedland, they are both correct.
It amazes me how many stories must be lost. Especially during slavery. Books like Four Hundred Souls nails it. Sharing pieces like the first ships to arrive to America were very different. One filled with people’s who’s names were noted in the ships log. The other, nameless cargo of African slaves listed without identity in the early 1600’s.
This reminds me of Irish slaves being kept and transported though very little is known about them. Until recently I was not aware, either.
Master Slave Husband Wife is a story about a period of time in our world. Not just america but international. Not just slave owners revealed. But how the trade provided for people in free states, sugar, cotton for material, etc.
This story is about more than a husband and his wife. It’s representative of a plight toward a different society we benefit from today.
One obvious fact mentioned on different occasions for other freed peoples is the they were offspring of a slave owner providing dna displaying as more white than black is what triggered many toward being aghast about Ellen’s position. Seeing these are just as much alike people of little melatonin considered white. Seeing themselves in those held captive is what pushed further the end to slavery.
Making me think, the rape of women becoming a blessing toward ending slavery sickens me inside. Thankful at the same time. Being a faith based person struggle with this believing good comes from evil and appreciate Ellen and William’s fortitude to pray and believe. Though, Ellen’s birth from her mother’s rape … and the sex industry maintained using slavery to proposer humans for cruel and horrid greed is an abomination to humanity.
If you are expecting this story to be focused only on a couple may be disappointed. If you are hoping for a harrowing tale of a couple who find freedom. Change the world. Meeting many who played a roll through documentation and as the author admits some creative conveyance as required to help the story move may really enjoy these historically researched experiences.
Writing this story requires piecing together a puzzle. Which includes many different parts. From news articles to stories handed down generations. Though the couple did not like to talk much about their past, enough was shared including historical moments, such as news articles, involving the couple this book could exist.
I think the lower reviewers do not realize this is not a typical journey. They are use to reading a fiction story or different style of author. Watching the made for TV event. Which I’m guessing will no doubt focus on the couple more.
Makes me reflect on the book Kindred compared to the Hulu series. My preference is the book. With an understanding the recreation of mystical realism is a challenge though doubt the producers of MSHW will experience similar issues. As I’m imagining they will trim the historical research as it is extensive and weave the focal characters into the made for screen version.
I would like to see the painting of Ellen in her disguise at the end. Other than this, am prepared to experience a different story. Though in my heart relate and will remember the immense work it took to find all the research. Bravo Ms. Woo. I too am a research hound and appreciate your ability.
The point, for me, is based on storytelling events to convey what it took to alleviate the nation of slavery. This couple was one of many catalysts.
Their unique journey is not the only one including a couple portraying themselves as a master and slave. Though the rarity mixed with notoriety is what gave the author a seed with an enormous trail of documentation because at the time this instance was such a unique anomaly for a couple to make it this far. From this grew a forest. Each tree telling its perspective into this wonderfully written book, in my opinion.
Hoping anyone seeing this review might be gentler in their criticism when reading the text. Point of view is only as qualified as the experience and imagination of the holder.
Mine includes a great grandfather considered less than even the “negro” for his heritage as an Italian immigrant. Americanizing his name to eventually attempting to hide in the census.
Only finding out about this a handful of years ago realize at some point someone voted to make me white. In my view, as an attempt to further suppress people of color. As I would be if someone had not waved their pen, meaning signed into law or rule, likely a man as women did not hold office back then, to make my grandmother feel shame for her roots.
To the one star reviewers, at the end of the book the author notes all the ways the facts were recovered to preserve the Craft’s history.
This in turn filled in gaps in documentation from the couple who did not speak of some information. Though these gaps are tillable based on a treasure trove of research since this couple was so well known for their plight.
If you are looking for a narrow minded story this will not be for you. This book is about the couples many neurons or unique experiences like tethers to this time period. What made them noticed is their journey and all that were impacted.
Certain you would get a more narrow focus on a movie or mini series. Not so in this epic tale I thoroughly enjoyed.
The struggle these two endured for freedom could be its own college or highschool course. Weaving in the many factors as branches to the tree of the 1800’s slave struggle from the north and south.
If you hope to learn about this couple throughout the journey will endure the many name drops like Fredrick Douglas who was on the story telling tour circuit to help end slavery at the same time.
Having extensively read and studied him and others within this time period find it enthralling to learn a new story I had never heard before. Found myself on the edge of my seat at times unsure if the couple would survive.
I wanted more at each turn.
Legally married (read to find out how and the significance of this forbidden love. Highly recommend Betty DeRamus’s Forbidden Fruit: Love Stories from the Underground Railroad to understand the depth of the significance of William’s and Ellen’s vows supported by those helping them escape) and fugitives the couple William and Ellen Craft with the help of many people are the pinnacle of a society that longs for two ends. Slavery being maintained and denying the bondage of humans. In this case not due to the color of their skin, as one passes for what was decidedly white and another marked by increased melatonin.
For the one star reviewers to miss the distinguishable story of freedom capped by this unique couples plight. Taken on by society as a marker toward freedom for all or die trying makes me wonder how much exposure they have had to the entirety of the subject at hand.
The story is about a movement toward freedom. This unique circumstance of a couple is the marker moved as the conjecture thickens. States verses federal rights.
Funny how much today is a reflection of then. Just different names.
My great grandfather was an Italian immigrant in the early 1900’s. He Americanized his name to appear white. While mass lynchings of Italians across the country were condoned by the president and politicians.
How does Giovanni di Filippi become John Phillips? A lie I’d only learned about in recent years when I could not find any genealogical info. A family friend from the 70’s met recently told me. Though I knew I had Italian heritage for about a decade did not know to ask more questions before my father died. Having uncovered info while researching people gave me the questions too late.
Who made my people white?
This is not about skin color. This is about racial injustice as one of the two within this couple resembles her white slave owning rapist father or how else could they have escaped?
This is about more than skin color or this couple. Based on the witness accounts I dare say, had we not had a white resembling person I doubt it would have gleaned as much notoriety.
People see color. Not people. This is a seed within the story for me.
An interesting fact, how without social media this couples movement was reported. Which makes it easy to track and become this very story.
Seeing how our government treated people like Irish, Negro’s, “foreigners”. How much our current day resembles over a hundred years ago proves our composted lives as a nation have remained mixed and similar all at once. Simply different nationalities.
Appreciate if you have read this far. Typically, my review motive is non-partisan … for me means no affiliated with one group or another.
Example, who created the Klu Klux Klan? Democrats. Was Lincoln a Republican? Nope, and he ran with a democrat. Who actually voted on the Supreme Court to approve Abortion rights in the 70’s? All republicans and one democrat. The other two said no.
I use these examples of why I do not subscribe to one side or the other.
Our country has a long standing tradition to support BS. Flip sides. Back and forth. Or stand their ground and fight for a position that is utter crap. As a veteran see it in a different way than civilians. Meaning, me, you, everyone is influenced by experiences.
Those people who fear whatever the narrative is are the biggest components to how Italian’s were hung. Native peoples except Meskwaki were plopped on reservations. Fun fact: the Meskwaki people live on a settlement, meaning they own the land and it is a separate nation. Though does follow federal and state laws has its own, too. Long story. Fun research. As for Irish and African who came her initially as servants who worked off passage on a ship then form towns. Only to be segregated by the creation of race in the 1600’s. Hundreds of years later and we are barely ahead. We are more divided than ever.
Hearing this story from the spectacular breadth of research along with all the other books, research, and people I have met who shared their stories, felt compelled to share more. Hoping perhaps the information could encourage others to read more. See more. Relate more.
How else are we, the people, of the United States of American, and the world if you’re from over the pond going to create change we need in the world?
This isn’t about what an individual wants. Good grief, it is about humanity to man.
I see a lot of the politics of the 1800’s reflected in today. Masked in some other policy or value. Saddened and empowered.
What I know for sure, Peace in oneself. Peace in the world. This is the only control I actually have.
Anyone ever said in response to the idea they want world peace how on earth they could make this happen?
Me, literacy with stories like this. Understanding people for where they are. Creating peace in myself and the circle of influence I have control over. Expand outward all around me. This is my answer.
What’s yours?
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️💯