I'm going to be straight forward when I say that I may have some bias behind why I read this book. I grew up watching 16 and Pregnant. Most of the women who are currently on Teen Mom OG are the same age as me and I remember when they all got pregnant. I also still watch a lot of the franchise to this day so I was extremely excited to see that LaLa Thomas was slated to write this book. I really enjoyed this one. It wasn't perfect by any means, but based on enjoyment and conversations that happened in the book, I found myself wanting to give this book a high rating. 4.5 Stars. CW: discussions surrounding abortions, underage drinking
16 & Pregnant follows best friends Erykah and Kelly who are navigating their junior year of high school. At the beginning of the book, Erykah discovers that she is pregnant and has to make the decision to either keep the pregnancy or have an abortion. When she ultimately decides to go through with her pregnancy, both Erykah and Kelly truly learn what it means to be a teen mom with every step challenging the strength of their friendship.
What Worked: I LOVED the relationship between Erykah and Kelly. They had such a strong love and bond for each other that made my heart sing. Sure, their relationship is tested greatly throughout the course of the book, but readers can see that even during their darkest moments the two love and care for each other in ways that can only hold true for best friends who are like sisters. Thomas also did interesting things with the discussions about pregnancy, birth control, and more. I'm not sure that I was anticipating such complexity within the framework of the narrative. While these things may be obvious for readers my age, I think that there are some teens that will benefit from seeing the variety of reasons people choose to go through with pregnancies while others choose not to. There are a variety of ways in which people choose to use or not use birth control. However, what I loved most of all is the lack of judgement that Thomas weaves into the narrative. Yes, the characters struggle with not making rash judgements about each other, BUT Thomas uses these moments as a way to illustrate that every girl and woman has the right to decide what to do with HER BODY. That, to me, is the most important message of all. Women of all ages need to hear that their reproductive rights should be theirs and theirs alone and that they have should have the right to make the decisions that are most helpful and healthy for them. There are also some really supportive adults in this book which I appreciated because that's not something that is always considered in YA. Thomas also delves deep into complications that come with pregnancy and I APPRECIATE THAT. Too often (and I'm sad to say that this still happens today) pregnancy is glorified and only illustrated in terms of perfect scenarios. The trauma that the body experiences during pregnancy and L&D is very real and more people should be honest about it. This also means discussing the intersection of race and gender when it comes to pregnancy & L&D. Black women are still facing inequities from the medical field particularly with the sky rocketed mortality rates that we face when giving birth. Thomas does not shy away from any of these topics and I'm happy that teens will have access to the content of this book.
What Didn't Work: I definitely enjoyed watching Erykah grow as a character, but she did annoy me at times because of her inability to see beyond her own experiences. Understandably, I didn't hold this against her because she is a teenager and the behavior wasn't that far fetched for a 16 year old. I think a little more deep diving into her character development would have eased this, but I'm also not the target audience.
Overall, this was a great read. I wasn't necessarily expecting it, but I'm glad that it was. I also recommend listening to this one on audio! The narrators really brought the story to life.