This was a fantastic collection and I'm surprised it's not getting more love. Seems like it has all sorts of things going for it: a killer cover, a public that is hungry for 80s nostalgia, and a batch of awesome stories.
The premise is this: each story is set in the year 1986.
There wasn't a weak story in the bunch. While the subject matter and themes varied greatly from story to story, I found there to be a modern literary style to the prose that was consistent across the pages and this regularity kept me engaged. At the end of the book, I was left with a list of new authors to check out.
Some stories were downright surprising in where they ended up, particularly the stories, "Just Elaine" by Ali Seay, "Latchkey" by Amanda Cecelia Lang, "And the Universe Went On" by Jason P. Burnham, and "Everyday's a Party With You" by Christi Nogle.
Caleb Stephens's "Camp Klehani" was a total Goosebumps throwback. Fun and quippy characters and a nostalgic setting. Edith Lockwood's "Derailed" kinda felt like the Fear Street version of the collection.
"One of those Nice Guys" by Jonathan Duckworth is an unsettling creeper that will have you second guessing diners and road trips and helping out strangers, while "Jaws" by Christopher O'Halloran ramps things up to 11 so fast that your head will spin.
So all in all, I strongly recommend this collection. The theme never wears out its welcome, instead it easily pulls you along for the ride into a different time and place.