In his now classic volume Prospero and Caliban, Octave Mannoni gives his firsthand account of a 1948 revolt in Madagascar that led to one of the bloodiest episodes of colonial repression on the African continent. It is in Prospero and Caliban that Mannoni constructs the notion of the “dependency complex,” for which his book has since been remembered and widely discussed in both psychoanalytical and anthropological writing. Prospero and Caliban was one of the first books to challenge traditional approaches to the study of native American societies by Western colonizers and anthropologists; and Mannoni is recognized today for his close association with and influence on the French psychoanalyst Lacan.
Noted anthropologist Maurice Bloch has written a powerful and critical new foreword to the English translation, which allows the reader to view Mannoni’s unique work in its historical and intellectual context.
Mannoni is a self-proclaimed Freudian psycho-analyst. Some of his insights seem a little out there. Also, he writes specifically to Madagascar with the thought that some of this might apply to Africa as well. But living in Madagascar, I found book is historically and psychologically enlightening.
One of the biggest insights I’ve taken away from this Mannoni is the psychological dynamic of the colonial personality, which he says hinges on inferiority. The colonial European is conditioned to break off from his community and become an individual, foregoing collective identity and forging an individual personality. However, this estrangement from being sent out leaves the individual feeling inferior and needing to prove themselves over and against other individuals. It is also this lack of collective identity that prompts more communal cultures to find a way to bind the individual to the community through dependency.
It is this dynamic that leads Westerners, seeing the world through individualism, call the Malagasy lazy and greedy, always asking them for things while the Malagasy puzzle over the Westerner without community and try to bring them into community by depending on them for things.
I just finished Mannoni’s book about the psychology of colonization and, because of that, re-read Shakespeare’s The Tempest. At the time Mannoni’s book was first published in France (Psychologie de la colonisation) in 1950, psychologists around the world were spending a lot of effort studying personality types and personality development. For example, in the same year the famous Adorno et al project, The Authoritarian Personality, was published.
Mannoni, who was later to become a loyal student of the maverick French psycho-analyst Jacques Lacan, was also very familiar with the issues of colonization having been resident in Madagascar for many years.
This is a challenging book in many ways, and is still somewhat controversial. The more famous Frantz Fanon was to write a pretty scathing critique of it two years after it was published. Regardless of the books merits as a work of social psychology, however, it later had a big impact on how Shakespeare’s play, The Tempest, was performed. If fact, I don’t think you can think about Shakespeare’s characters Prospero and Caliban in the same way after reading Mannoni’s book, which is perhaps praise enough.
It is ever-fascinating to me that the anthropologists most harangued by the cry of racism are nearly always the ones who painstakingly, even didactically, go out of their way to explicitly counter the prejudices of their time (Mannoni, Malinowski, even Lévi-Strauss). And despite my appreciation of Fanon's scholarship, I think his reading of Prospero and Caliban (specifically, Mannoni's development of the concept of a "dependency complex" in attempting to theorize the Malagasy) in Black Skin, White Masks is simply wrong: Mannoni is relatively clear that he doesn't think there's an innate psychological difference between human beings on the basis of race or any other factor, but that the conditions of colonization give rise to different psychological effects. He always offers the example of Madagascans living in France as a counterpoint to this effect. His claim is merely to counterpose an Adlerian "inferiority complex," which requires some shared basis on which competition/comparison can occur, with what he terms a "dependency complex," which is merely to say that, in the colonial situation, one cannot even find oneself inferior, because there isn't even a minimal formal equality from which actual inequality could be measured. This actually - ironically - coheres rather well with a Fanonian sociogenic approach to this question. And in blending Madagascan anthropology with psychoanalytic theory, Mannoni is at once able to psychoanalyze the anthropologist, accounting for their positionality via their projections onto the indigenous populations. On that account, it joins a vaunted lineage of what Bourdieu would later come to call "reflexive sociology."
Ce livre qui propose un modele psychologique du comportement du colonisateur et du colonise dans le tier monde a été vivment contesté lors de sa parution en 1950. D'apres ses critiques qui etaient surtout des milieux communiste, la Psychologie faisait l'apologie de l'imperialisme et a été rasciste. Face a la vehemence de la critique, la maison d'édition a lachement retire ce livre de la vente.
La these de Mannoni est que le colonisateur a adopté un mentalité rasciste afin de justifier son exploitation du colonisé tandis que le colonisé surevaluait le pouvoir du colonisateur afin de justifier sa soumission.
Le point de vue de Mannoni ne me semble pas etre vraiment rasciste. Il n'a ni nié le caractere rasciste du systeme colonaliale ni le fait qu'il etait un systeme d'exploitation economique. Son péché etait de proposer une these qui s'accordait mal avec l'orthodoxie marxiste-leniniste. Devant la puissance des communistes dans les milieu intellectuelles, personne en France ne voulait defendre le droit de Mannoni de presenter sa these. C'a ete un affaire tres triste dans l'Histoire de la vie intellectuelle francaise.