Alafair Burke writes a twisty psychological thriller that is simultaneously a standalone, yet features her series NYPD detective, Ellie Hatcher, providing resolution to her ongoing doubts that her father, also a police detective, committed suicide. 15 years ago Lindsay Kelly, a defence lawyer, came across an overturned car with a seriously injured woman who recovered but suffered amnesia, never recovering her memories through the years. She was named Hope Miller, and the two women developed a close relationship through the years, even living together, with Hope being protected by the townsfolk of Hopewell, New Jersey. However, a restless Hope now wants to assert her independence and forge her own path, moving to East Hampton and becoming a realtor staging homes for sale.
An unhappy Lindsay has no choice but to come to terms with Hope's decision, and get used to seeing her less. However, on not hearing from Holly, a worried Lindsay sets out to find out what happened to her missing friend, last known to have set up a home for sale. An off duty local cop, Carter Decker, finds blood spots at that home, although he is far from convinced that there is anything wrong, thinking Hope has simply moved on. Learning that the blood connects to a long ago College Serial Killer case in Wichita, Kansas, a disturbed Lindsay calls in Ellie, drawing Ellie into a case she has a strong interest in. The discovery of a dead body that turns out to be murder has Carter taking a greater interest in Hope's disappearance. A tenacious Lindsay is determined to do everything she can to protect Hope as she digs deeper, uncovering a past of trauma, abuse and murder. Will Hope at long last learn who she is?
Burke writes an intriguing and suspenseful mystery of secrets and lies, a past that returns to haunt the present, for Hope, a woman with no memories of who she used to be, and for Ellie who has a musician brother, Jess. I loved the characters of both Lindsay and Hope, their enduring relationship with each other, seeing just how far Lindsay will go for Hope. This is an engaging crime mystery that drew me in easily, wanting to know what happened to Hope, and I appreciated the inclusion of Ellie, who at long last finds harrowing answers to the demons that had plagued her for so long. Many thanks to the publisher for an ARC.