This shows the impact of war upon hundreds of millions of people around the world - soldiers, sailors and airmen; housewives, farm workers and children. Reflecting Max Hastings's thirty-five years of research on World War II, All Hell Let Loose describes the course of events, but focuses chiefly upon human experience.
This volume includes the chapters: Poland Betrayed, No Peace, Little War, Blitzkriegs in the West, Britain Alone, The Mediterranean, Barbarossa, Moscow Saved, Leningrad Starved, America Embattled, Japan's Season of Triumph, Swings of Fortune, The British at Sea.
Sir Max Hugh Macdonald Hastings, FRSL, FRHistS is a British journalist, editor, historian and author. His parents were Macdonald Hastings, a journalist and war correspondent, and Anne Scott-James, sometime editor of Harper's Bazaar.
Hastings was educated at Charterhouse School and University College, Oxford, which he left after a year.After leaving Oxford University, Max Hastings became a foreign correspondent, and reported from more than sixty countries and eleven wars for BBC TV and the London Evening Standard.
Among his bestselling books Bomber Command won the Somerset Maugham Prize, and both Overlord and The Battle for the Falklands won the Yorkshire Post Book of the Year Prize.
After ten years as editor and then editor-in-chief of The Daily Telegraph, he became editor of the Evening Standard in 1996. He has won many awards for his journalism, including Journalist of The Year and What the Papers Say Reporter of the Year for his work in the South Atlantic in 1982, and Editor of the Year in 1988.
He stood down as editor of the Evening Standard in 2001 and was knighted in 2002. His monumental work of military history, Armageddon: The Battle for Germany 1944-1945 was published in 2005.
He is also a Fellow of the Royal Society of Literature.
Sir Max Hastings honoured with the $100,000 2012 Pritzker Military Library Literature Award for Lifetime Achievement in Military Writing.
The great strength of All Hell Let Loose is Max Hastings’s ability to combine the macro perspective with the experiences of individual human beings. From the strategic course of the war, its fronts and troop movements, he zooms in on the people who actually found themselves in the midst of events. The war thus becomes not merely a sequence of military events, but the sum of millions of individual human fates.
What affected me most was the account of the beginning of the war – the invasion of Poland: how people who had barely had time to grasp that a war had begun were suddenly thrown into an utterly brutal reality. Particularly horrifying is the very transition from normal life to a state in which people begin killing other people. Hastings depicts it without embellishment.
The book takes a global view of the war, covering, among other places, the Soviet Union, China, India and other parts of Asia. Particularly interesting is the contrast between Nazi Germany’s considerable tactical military skill and its significantly poorer overall strategic leadership.
In a foreword or introduction, I would have liked to see a systemic perspective on the background to the war: how the economic relations within the capitalist system and the class relations arising from them, together with the economic crises and unemployment of the period, contributed to the social conditions in which Nazism was able to emerge.
More generally, the rise of Nazism should not be reduced to a story of a struggle between “evil” and “good”, or to a matter of individual evil people. Such an account risks obscuring the social and historical conditions that made it possible. Hastings’s focus, however, is on portraying the war itself and the people caught up in it, rather than providing a comprehensive analysis of its causes.
Overall, I found the account highly factual and impartial. The use of the term “warlords” for Hitler and Stalin, however, strikes me as an unnecessarily value-laden epithet.
Cameron Stewart’s narration is superb, and the book works extremely well in audio format. One clear exception is his imitation of a Finnish accent, which simply does not sound Finnish and instead brings to mind the portrayal of a German officer in the British comedy series 'Allo 'Allo!. Some geographical orientation is helpful, and I occasionally supplemented the audiobook with maps.
A basic school-level knowledge of the Second World War is enough to follow the book. But All Hell Let Loose is not only for those who are already interested in history. It says something more universal about the utter horror of war and what it does to us as human beings.
🇸🇪 Det stora med All Hell Let Loose är Max Hastings förmåga att förena makroperspektivet med den enskilda människans erfarenhet. Från krigets strategiska skeenden, fronter och truppförflyttningar zoomar han in till människorna som faktiskt befann sig mitt i händelserna. Kriget blir därmed inte bara ett militärt händelseförlopp utan summan av miljontals individuella människoöden.
Starkast grep mig skildringen av krigets inledning – invasionen av Polen: hur människor som knappt hunnit förstå att ett krig hade börjat plötsligt kastades in i en fullkomligt brutal verklighet. Särskilt fasansfull är själva övergången från normalt liv till ett tillstånd där människor börjar döda andra människor. Hastings skildrar det utan försköning.
Boken har ett globalt perspektiv på kriget och behandlar bland annat Sovjetunionen, Kina, Indien och andra delar av Asien. Särskilt intressant är också kontrasten mellan Nazitysklands stora taktiska militära skicklighet och den betydligt sämre övergripande strategiska ledningen.
I ett förord eller en inledning hade jag gärna sett ett systemperspektiv på krigets bakgrund: hur de ekonomiska relationerna i det kapitalistiska systemet och de klassrelationer som följer av dem, tillsammans med periodens ekonomiska kriser och arbetslöshet, bidrog till de samhälleliga förutsättningarna för nazismens framväxt.
Mer generellt bör nazismens framväxt inte förenklas till en berättelse om en kamp mellan ”ont” och ”gott” eller till en fråga om enskilda onda individer. En sådan framställning riskerar att dölja de samhälleliga och historiska förhållanden som gjorde den möjlig. Hastings fokus ligger dock på att skildra själva kriget och människorna i det, inte på att ge en fullständig orsaksanalys.
Framställningen uppfattar jag överlag som mycket saklig och opartisk. Beteckningen ”warlords” om Hitler och Stalin känns dock som ett onödigt värdeladdat epitet.
Cameron Stewarts uppläsning är ypperlig och boken fungerar mycket bra i ljudformat. Ett tydligt undantag är imitationen av finskt uttal, som helt enkelt inte låter finsk utan närmast för tankarna till gestaltningen av en tysk officer i den brittiska komediserien 'Allå, 'allå, hemliga armén. Viss geografisk orientering underlättar, och jag kompletterade ibland med kartor.
Grundläggande skolkunskaper om andra världskriget räcker för att följa boken. Men All Hell Let Loose är inte bara för den redan historieintresserade. Den säger något mer allmängiltigt om krigets fullständiga vidrighet och vad det gör med oss människor.