Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Answering Jewish Objections to Jesus: General and Historical Objections, Vol. 1

Rate this book
An honest, fair, and thorough discussion of the issues raised in Jewish Christian apologetics, covering thirty-five objections on general and historical themes.

300 pages, Paperback

First published February 1, 2000

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Michael L. Brown

145 books193 followers
Michael L. Brown (born March 16, 1955) is a Messianic Jewish Old Testament scholar, professor, activist, itinerant speaker, and author who has preached in numerous countries and written twenty books. He is the founder and president of ICN Ministries. His writings have been translated into more than a dozen languages. He was married to Nancy Gurian on March 14, 1976 and they have two daughters, Jennifer and Megan, and four grandchildren.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
67 (49%)
4 stars
44 (32%)
3 stars
17 (12%)
2 stars
5 (3%)
1 star
2 (1%)
Displaying 1 - 14 of 14 reviews
Profile Image for Jacob Aitken.
1,706 reviews438 followers
February 3, 2020
Brown, Michael L. Answering Jewish Objections to Jesus vol. 1.  Grand Rapids, MI: Baker Books.

This volume introduces Michael L. Brown’s larger project of Jewish evangelism.  Working through these objections is a neat exercise for Christians, as you get to use your Old Testament knowledge in ways you didn’t expect.

Remind them that the rabbinic traditions which they follow aren’t any older than Christianity.  That means the debate is over who is the best expression of the Jewish tradition: Yeshua Messiah or the rabbis?

The Problem of Interpretation.  The key question is not whether Christianity or Judaism is true.  The key question is which is the biblical faith: the rabbis or Yeshua (Brown 1.7)? 

The first section dealt with general objections to Yeshua.  None were formidable. These are the standard CNN/NPR objections.  In section 2 Brown deals with more scholarly opponents.

Why isn’t there peace on Earth? The OT Messianic prophecies point to worldwide peace.   This is a more sophisticated objection than we might think at first. It's a devastating criticism of amillennialism. The objection is not saying that “We Jews expect a David-like conqueror.”  No, the OT messianic promises point to “the glory of God covering the earth.” 

Brown responds that Messiah must bring purification before peace, judgment before justice (2.1).  The peace that Messiah brings happens at the end of the age (Isaiah 2; Zech. 14). See Hagg. 2:6-9.  See also Daniel 9:24-27.

Daniel 9 is an important chapter for End Times Bible Prophecy, but it also provides an important point here.  Brown notes that “Final atonement for Israel’s sin must be made before the second temple was destroyed.”

If Yeshua is the Messiah, why have wars and famines increased (2.2)?  We’ve already dealt with the faulty premise of the question, as explained in 2.1.  Messiah does not bring in a universal, unqualified peace.

Zechariah’s Sequence of Messiah’s Return

The trumpet will sound; Messiah returns, then Day of Atonement.  Yahweh will protect the City (Zech. 14:1-5), and these nations afterwards will celebrate the Feast of Tabernacles.  Here is the exciting part: this is laid out in the Jewish calendar: Passover, Firstfruits (Yeshua’s rising from the dead), Shavu’ot/Pentecost [Gap in Time] we are now waiting on the eschatological Feast of Tabernacles following the rescue of Jerusalem.


Profile Image for CaptKirk42 Classic Whovian.
38 reviews13 followers
July 8, 2008
"Either The Massiah came almost two thousand years ago, or the biblical prophets were false prophets - in which case we can throw The Bible out and go join some other religion (or abandon religion completely)."

Answering Jewish Objections To Jesus - Volume One - (General and Historical Objections) Michael L. Brown. This book was intended by the author to be read primarily by a Jewish audience and then secondly by Christians to further understand somewhat were Jews are coming from historically. The book has a basic format of common questions (or objections) that Jews have about Jesus and Christianity, followed by an answer and then often lengthy endnotes as an explanation. It is interesting that many Jews haven't even bothered to find out anything about Jesus. They normally just dismiss anything about him and don't bother with reading any of the New Testament. The author of this book is a messianic Jew, that is someone who was born into a Jewish family and has accepted Jesus as his savior and believes he is The Messiah. Often they call themselves True Christians, many traditional Jews consider them traitors and believers of a cult or of an enemy religion.

I found this book to be a difficult read, since I am unfamiliar with many of the references to Jewish Scriptures that many Jews wouldn't even bat an eye at since it (the original Hebrew scriptures often not found in the Christian Bible) was something they already know and are very comfortable with. I was disappointed when I realized that this book was only the first of a three volume set, and many of the objections that I have heard about (and wanted to hear the answer to) are supposedly in either volume two or more likely in volume three. There is a 3-in-1 Volume available now I think, with updates, and I fear there is also a volume 4 now. I believe that many Jewish readers will still be asking the same questions and will not be satisfied with the answers the author gives.


I reviewed this book in my blog http://klandersen.blogspot.com/ "A Recent Read Number 7"
11.7k reviews44 followers
November 18, 2026
THE FIRST VOLUME IN A 5-VOLUME SERIES

Dr. Michael L. Brown is founder and president of ICN Ministries and of FIRE School of Ministry; he was also a key figure in the Brownsville Revival. He is also of Jewish background, and is perhaps the most "scholarly" of converted Jews who wish to convert other Jews to evangelical Christianity. (In recent years, however, his reputation has been severely damaged by allegations followed by the ‘Firefly Independent Sexual Abuse Investigations Report’ released in 2025, which concluded that Brown engaged in inappropriate interactions with two women employed by his ministry.)

He wrote in the Preface to this 2000 book, “In November of 1971, as a … Jewish 16-year-old… I found out that Jesus was the Jewish Messiah!… This was my predicament: I was sure my faith was sound and that Jesus really was the Messiah, but I could find almost no literature ... to help me. When I did find some solid academic works by Christians dealing with Messianic prophecy and related subjects, they tended to be insensitive to the traditional Jewish objections I was hearing… How could I effectively answer the questions of the rabbis and refute their objections?… In the providence of God, I became somewhat of a specialist in Jewish debate and dialogue, and … my Messianic Jewish friends and colleagues began to ask me, ‘When are you going to put all of this in writing?’ … At last I can answer, ‘Now,’ … only it’s now a series of books.” (Pg. xi-xiii)

He argues, “the question must be asked: Who determined that Rabbinic Judaism was the true Judaism? Who decided that the teachings of the rabbis were Jewish while the teachings of the disciples of Jesus were not Jewish?’ … The real question is, What do the Hebrew Scriptures teach? Which Jewish expression follows the Bible? That must be the rule of Jewish faith and practice.” (Pg. xx)

He notes, “Most Jews who have come to know Jesus as Messiah have experienced a deep reawakening of their Jewishness. Many have recovered aspects of the biblical Jewish lifestyle, while others have made aliyah (i.e., emigrated to Israel) for life… It is because these people have so deeply recovered their Jewishness that some of them have changed their names---e.g., from Martin to Moishe.” (Pg. 10.) “The most famous change of names among Jewish believers was that of Martin Rosen, an ordained Baptist minister, to Moishe Rosen, the founder and longtime leader of Jews for Jesus.” (Pg. 13)

He asserts, “In terms of those who have never heard about Jesus, we believe that virtually all of them are in a fallen, lost state, although there might be someone somewhere who has longed for true salvation through the one true God, finding it and finding him without a human being telling him the message. Such things can and do happen. But there is no question that our responsibility as children of the one true God is to tell everyone that there is a judgment, there is a hell… and there is a way of escape: Jesus the Messiah has paid for our sins.” (Pg. 33)

He asks, “Is it possible the messiah DID come two thousand years ago, but ‘because our iniquities were many’ we did not recognize him?… In fact… this position is not only more logical but is actually more BIBLICAL, since according to the Hebrew Bible, the Messiah was to arrive before the Second Temple was destroyed---in other words, more than 1900 years ago.” (Pg. 73)

Have Christians always hated and persecuted the Jewish people? He reports, “Shall I recount the passionate words of the influential 4th-century [Christian] leader John Chrysostom in his seven sermons against the Jews? His ferocious accusations have thundered through the centuries. The Jews are ‘inveterate murderers, destroyers, men possessed by the devil’ who ‘know only one thing, to satisfy their gullets, get drunk, kill and maim one another.’ The synagogue is … ‘a domicile of the devil’ … and the Jewish religion is ‘a disease.’” (Pg. 125)

He reports an objection: “But didn’t Paul teach that the Church was the new Israel?’ Not at all. Rather, he taught that Gentile believers in the Messiah became fellow members of the household of God along with Jewish believers, but they remained Gentiles… It is true that Paul applied some of the spiritual descriptions of Israel to Gentile Christians, but he never said the church was Israel or, more importantly, that the church had REPLACED Israel.” (Pg. 172)

He states, “Is it scriptural to view the Holocaust, at least to some extent, as an act of divine judgment? The answer, as difficult as it was for many to handle, is yes---at least to some extent. God’s Word---from the Torah through the Prophets through the Psalms and Wisdom Literature---is just so clear. As a nation, if we were in right standing with God, it is simply impossible to believe that such calamities could have overtaken us in such devastating fashion. Whether you believe that God was judging Jewish assimilation or departure from rabbinic tradition or failure to return to the land or rejection of the prophets and the Messiah or human arrogance and self-will---whatever the specific causes of judgment were, there must be SOME recognition of judgment. Now, please don’t misquote me as saying that the Holocaust occurred because Jews did not believe in Jesus… if Jewish suffering in the Holocaust was because of rejecting the Messiah, why did it take so long for judgment to come? Rather, I would say… our sins of greed, lying, immorality, and … other things polluted our lives when we forsook God’s laws, ALL contributed to taking us out of the place of divine favor and protection.” (Pg. 183)

He asserts, “I have debated a number of rabbis … presenting clear, biblical evidence that Jesus is the Messiah… What were the results? You can easily judge for yourself. First, you can listen to these debates on audiotape or view those that were video recorded. Second, you can ask yourself a question: Why does my ministry organization actively distribute each and every recorded debate I have done with rabbis… while those I debated virtually never distribute the debates? What does that tell you?” (Pg. 201)

In a footnote, he states, “Of my two debates with the anti-missionary Rabbi Tovia Singer… our ministry distributes only the second. This is because Rabbi Singer asked me NOT to distribute the first debate, which was held quite unexpectedly at the home of a Russian Jew without Rabbi Singer or me having any real idea that it was coming… Both parties informally recorded the proceedings, but Rabbi Singer was not at all happy with the debate and … he asked me to stop distributing any of the tapes…. I complied with his request.” (Pg. 251)

His response to the question about the Holocaust may offend some/many, but this whole book series will be of keen interest to anyone studying these issues.
Profile Image for Etienne OMNES.
303 reviews15 followers
March 19, 2019
Michael Brown est un très bon apologète, avec un style et un rhétorique très efficace, en plus d'un coeur très charitable. Ce livre consacré à l'apologétique face aux juifs mérite sa place de référence. Mention particulière aux questions consacrées à l'antisémitisme dans l'église, où Michael Brown a su être très honnête, sans pour autant jeter l'église ancienne à la poubelle, mais au contraire la défendant.

J'ai hâte de lire les autres volumes, où les points les plus techniques seront abordés.
Profile Image for Nelson Banuchi.
179 reviews
January 24, 2023
Dr. Brown lists introductory objections by Jews against the Christian faith and answers them. Surprisingly this book is very informative for those unfamiliar with the Jewish faith, like me. Dr. Brown's scholarship always surprises me how, with plain common sense, he answers the most difficult objections with simple logic as well as providing a thorough understanding of Judaism and Jewish history (he is Jewish himself).

"Answering Jewish Objections" is in 5 volumes of which this is the first. Highly recommended for anyone wanting to know our parent faith and seeking to share it with the Jew.
Profile Image for Joseph Trocchio.
5 reviews
January 8, 2019
“Brown Books”...

...are filled with blessings. I strongly recommend for serious seekers/believers, both Jewish and Gentile. Rich reads. Eye opening. Very thoughtful and applicable on many relevant issues. His work is a blessing to his People and the Church. 5 Stars are not enough.

I Kindled his latest, The Power of Music , the other day. A subject I’ve wondered about for a long time. Good timing Dr! Re “Objections” and “Blood”, same here!! You reading my mind Dr Brown??!
17 reviews
May 10, 2024
I bought all five volumes of this series. I just finished the first volume and it was enlightening. I didn't know that there were that many objections to Jesus, but Dr. Brown answered them superbly with all kinds of evidence, take a look at the notes. Scholarly work.
Profile Image for Angel Davila.
21 reviews1 follower
June 19, 2022
Valuable Resource

Dr. Brown thoroughly goes through the objections to the truth of Jesus being the Messiah. Every answer is explained well and each objection is treated carefully.
7 reviews
April 29, 2025
Insightful.

I've found a source of information clearly explained over this first volume, looking forward to continue all the way through the whole collection.
Profile Image for Wesley Wheeler.
1 review
August 18, 2026
Scholarship is obviously a little old. I would have liked to see more proofs in some areas from extra-Biblical sources. Good starting point though
Profile Image for Alexandra.
1,309 reviews3 followers
September 8, 2007
These books are written with Jews as the target audience, but is basic enough to be interesting for Christians to learn more about how Christian beliefs do fit with it's roots of Judaism. My only disappointment is that there isn't more material.
Profile Image for Summer Hurst.
127 reviews3 followers
September 19, 2012
The whole Answering series is the best material on the subject of the Messiahship of Yeshua

All should read this series to understand and learn more, thoughtful and accurate, Dr. Brown’s best work despte most of the series being over ten years old now
Displaying 1 - 14 of 14 reviews