EJ Noyes has been a little hit or miss, for me. I heard so many ppl raving abt her and then the first couple of books I read I enjoyed, but didn’t love the way so many ppl seemed to—then I read a couple more, and enjoyed the hell out of them. She’s now a must read for me, but part of what I like and appreciate abt Noyes is how often she changes things up. She writes what she wants and takes big swings with the plots; they all RLLY differ in fun ways that I can rlly respect.
However… this one didn’t rlly do it for me. The first book, Gold, was one of those not favs for me, so I already was going into this less fond that I would have for a sequel to one of her other books (a pov of Olivia from Alone plsssssssss🤞🤞🤞). iirc, I wasn’t as fond of Aspen in book one, and found some of their romance a little clunky, but I actually liked Aspen in this one! Her scenes with Gemma especially were my fav. Similarly, to Gold, I found myself not liking Stacy, the skier, as much as I liked and connected with Gemma. So… rooting for them was hard. I think also… I’ve realized recently that friends to lovers is a trope that I only rlly like in very specific ways, and the way it played out here wasn’t quite it. Stacy has known abt Gemma’s crush on her since they became friends, YEARS AGO. and yet she is soooo touchy feely and kinda flirty, bc she also likes Gem, BUT, she has no plans to do anything abt it in the beginning, and the way that she acted with Gemma bothered me a little in that respect. It felt a lot like trying having your cake and eat it too, or whatever that phrase is. It didn’t endear me to her, and she already had a long way to go, bc kinda cocky sort of butch jock is not my type. Also, ngl, the nickname “Gemmy Gem” is AWFUL and felt sickeningly cutesy and childish, and with how much feeling too young/not adult enough was part of Gem’s arc, I was so surprised that Gemma never was like.. so I’m can you come up with a different nickname for me pls and thank. (Lol, my name is Emily. And if anyone ever called me Emmy Em in any regular or serious way I would simply leave immediately and never date them). So, Stacy had a lot going against her, personally, for me.
I liked Gemma quite a bit. I remember rlly liking her in book one, but I also was a little… she felt like a kid. I wonder why Noyes wanted to set their story with the two of them still pretty young. I might have enjoyed it more if they had been college age and this actually felt more like a New Adult book rather that pretty YA overall, what with Gem still being in high school. (I don’t have anything against YA, I used to read it almost exclusively not even that many years ago, but this felt slightly off and unsure if it wanted to be YA or NA, in some respects).
I think that Noyes is a good writer, and I respect how often she changes things up, and tries new things, and I’m RLLY glad that she seems to be using more dual povs in her books (bc that is DEF my preference in romance) but this one wasn’t rlly for me. Not terrible, but she’s done much better.