What do you think?
Rate this book
Brontë Sisters Mystery #3
Une enquête des soeurs Brontë, T3 : Le Monarque rouge
The Brontë sisters' first poetry collection has just been published, potentially marking an end to their careers as amateur detectors, when Anne receives a letter from her friend Lydia Robinson.
Lydia has eloped with a young actor, Harry Roxby, and following her disinheritance, the couple been living in poverty in London. Harry has become embroiled with a criminal gang and is in terrible danger after allegedly losing something very valuable that he was meant to deliver to their leader. The desperate and heavily pregnant Lydia has a week to return what her husband supposedly stole, or he will be killed. She knows there are few people who she can turn to in this time of need, but the sisters agree to help Lydia, beginning a race against time to save Harry's life.
In doing so, our intrepid sisters come face to face with a terrifying adversary whom even the toughest of the slum-dwellers are afraid of...The Red Monarch.
Lydia has eloped with a young actor, Harry Roxby, and following her disinheritance, the couple been living in poverty in London. Harry has become embroiled with a criminal gang and is in terrible danger after allegedly losing something very valuable that he was meant to deliver to their leader. The desperate and heavily pregnant Lydia has a week to return what her husband supposedly stole, or he will be killed. She knows there are few people who she can turn to in this time of need, but the sisters agree to help Lydia, beginning a race against time to save Harry's life.
In doing so, our intrepid sisters come face to face with a terrifying adversary whom even the toughest of the slum-dwellers are afraid of...The Red Monarch.
366 pages, Kindle Edition
First published November 4, 2021
28 people are currently reading
1150 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 119 reviews
November 5, 2021
The detectorists are back!! In August 1852 Charlotte Bronte reflects on her sisters character and all the different aspects of her personality and how people in the future will never really know her. Perhaps this latest offering from Bella Ellis will allow us some glimpses of Emily as she is central to this latest case. The dramatic events all start with a terrifying awakening for pregnant Lydia Roxby (nee Robinson) with an attack on her and her husband Harry by a gang led by Noose, Lord of the Rookery of St Giles, London. Noose seizes Harry and gives Lydia a week to recover a jewel or he will kill Harry. Lydia writes a desperate plea for help to Ann Bronte. The three sisters, helped by Bramwell (maybe?!), travel as fast as the times allow to go to her aid.
‘There is so much wrong with this world’ and this is proven true in this the sisters most dangerous case. Beneath cloaks of respectability lurk demons, devils incarnate, if Noose is bad then the Red Monarch who rules much of London is far, far worse. Who is he? The desperate search to unmask him and rescue Harry is well and truly on with powerful and dangerous forces at play plunging the resourceful sisters into a treacherous, wicked and cruel world of so much pain, suffering, betrayal and unbearable sadness. The quest reveals the dark underbelly of London society and it’s a deeply disturbing tale. The writing is extremely descriptive, the colour, the gothic hints, the little dashes of humour all make the unfolding events come alive with all the dark corners of London revealed with its stinks, filth, noise, pace and unseen dangers lurking round many a corner. The Rookery of St Giles is a slum which sends a shiver down your spine with suitably accompanying low life characters, the heart breaking poverty and the harshly tentative hold on life. I love the theatre element in this novel which is central to the plot and adds a vivid dimension with its actors, the acts, the magnificent buildings with all their history and ghostly presences which keep you immersed . The plot is a fascinating one and takes many twists and turns until the Red Monarch is unmasked. Oh very clever, Ms Ellis, this so isn’t beyond the realms of possibility!! (Lips, sealed!) The ending is maybe a bit neat but it works and I enjoy how Emily is restored by the embrace of the winds of beloved Moors and her dog!
Overall, there is much to admire in this series as the talented author gives us her insights into these sisters who have enthralled us with their writing. We see their personalities, their kindness, bravery, determination, their understanding of each other and their close bond. The style of writing is very much in keeping with the century in which the stories are set. I enjoyed the previous two detectorist books but this one is my favourite so far. It has so much in it to entertain you from start to finish. Excellent cover art too.
With thanks to NetGalley and especially to Hodder and Stoughton for the much appreciated arc in return for an honest review.
‘There is so much wrong with this world’ and this is proven true in this the sisters most dangerous case. Beneath cloaks of respectability lurk demons, devils incarnate, if Noose is bad then the Red Monarch who rules much of London is far, far worse. Who is he? The desperate search to unmask him and rescue Harry is well and truly on with powerful and dangerous forces at play plunging the resourceful sisters into a treacherous, wicked and cruel world of so much pain, suffering, betrayal and unbearable sadness. The quest reveals the dark underbelly of London society and it’s a deeply disturbing tale. The writing is extremely descriptive, the colour, the gothic hints, the little dashes of humour all make the unfolding events come alive with all the dark corners of London revealed with its stinks, filth, noise, pace and unseen dangers lurking round many a corner. The Rookery of St Giles is a slum which sends a shiver down your spine with suitably accompanying low life characters, the heart breaking poverty and the harshly tentative hold on life. I love the theatre element in this novel which is central to the plot and adds a vivid dimension with its actors, the acts, the magnificent buildings with all their history and ghostly presences which keep you immersed . The plot is a fascinating one and takes many twists and turns until the Red Monarch is unmasked. Oh very clever, Ms Ellis, this so isn’t beyond the realms of possibility!! (Lips, sealed!) The ending is maybe a bit neat but it works and I enjoy how Emily is restored by the embrace of the winds of beloved Moors and her dog!
Overall, there is much to admire in this series as the talented author gives us her insights into these sisters who have enthralled us with their writing. We see their personalities, their kindness, bravery, determination, their understanding of each other and their close bond. The style of writing is very much in keeping with the century in which the stories are set. I enjoyed the previous two detectorist books but this one is my favourite so far. It has so much in it to entertain you from start to finish. Excellent cover art too.
With thanks to NetGalley and especially to Hodder and Stoughton for the much appreciated arc in return for an honest review.
May 14, 2024
I was so excited to get back into this series and with only 2 more books to go I wanted to really cherish every word. I think I could even go as far as saying this is MY FAVOURITE book in the series so far 😮😍
This instalment kicks off with a poem called ‘Last words’ written by Emily Bronte…and as we read on into the prologue, Charlotte is in a rather sad state of affairs of what seems like Emily’s death. It is a rather shocking start to the book. However, as we read on into chapter one, all three sisters are very much alive. In fact, Anne, the youngest of the sisters, has grown into her own; more opinionated and less obliging. And Charlotte loved her even more for it.
They then very quickly embark on there next mystery - ‘Dragging the darkest matters into the light…’. Anne took charge and announced they were going to London at dawn to rescue their latest victim: Mrs Lydia Roxby. With her husband, Harry Roxby, under threat of murder, the situation could not be more serious! It was a race against time; Harry had been taken and Lydia was told she had 7 days to return a jewel to them or else…
What the jewel looked like was completely unknown; what were they looking for? A gem or something gold, no doubt?!
However, as the clock ticks on, it seems the sister’s purpose only grows…the intensity was so real! Furthermore, the reality of the Red Monarch reveals himself and is said to be worse than the devil himself…as per Emily’s usual confidence she says “ we’ve dealt with devils before, sir… they do not frighten us.”. Right until the last sentence Emily’s minx-like personality see her through and entertains us greatly; she truly is wild at heart!
I absolutely adore all of the Bronte sister’s writing so having the pleasure of reading this series feels like a secret insight into the details of their lives. I love how Bella Ellis has captured all the sisters so vividly. It SUCH a SPECIAL SERIES, I highly suggest reading it, especially if you enjoy any of their books.
🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟
October 26, 2021
This series, featuring the Bronte Sisters as ‘detectorists,’ is going from strength to strength. In this third outing, the sisters, accompanied by brother Bramwell, swop the wide, Yorkshire moors, for the narrow alleys and notorious, poverty ridden slums, of the Rookery in London.
Bramwell is still bemoaning his lost love, wallowing in drink and self-pity, when a note comes from Lydia Roxby, previously Robinson and the daughter of the woman who he is obsessed with. The letter comes to Anne, saying that her husband, Harry, has been snatched by criminals and that ‘Noose,’ Lord of the Rookery, is demanding back a jewel he believes that Harry has stolen, or he will kill them both. To make matters worse, Lydia is pregnant and staying in the theatre of her unsympathetic father-in-law.
Without even waiting to read the review of their recently published collection of poetry, the siblings set out to help. The sisters for altruistic reasons and Bramwell in the hope that he can prove himself to Lydia’s mother. This novel makes great use of the setting, both of the theatre and of the slums. We have some great characters, such as Kit Thornfield, an actress, and Louis Parensell, who befriends Emily. We learn a great deal about Emily’s character in this novel. A very enjoyable addition to the series. I received a copy of this book from the publisher, via NetGalley, for review.
Bramwell is still bemoaning his lost love, wallowing in drink and self-pity, when a note comes from Lydia Roxby, previously Robinson and the daughter of the woman who he is obsessed with. The letter comes to Anne, saying that her husband, Harry, has been snatched by criminals and that ‘Noose,’ Lord of the Rookery, is demanding back a jewel he believes that Harry has stolen, or he will kill them both. To make matters worse, Lydia is pregnant and staying in the theatre of her unsympathetic father-in-law.
Without even waiting to read the review of their recently published collection of poetry, the siblings set out to help. The sisters for altruistic reasons and Bramwell in the hope that he can prove himself to Lydia’s mother. This novel makes great use of the setting, both of the theatre and of the slums. We have some great characters, such as Kit Thornfield, an actress, and Louis Parensell, who befriends Emily. We learn a great deal about Emily’s character in this novel. A very enjoyable addition to the series. I received a copy of this book from the publisher, via NetGalley, for review.
October 16, 2021
The Red Monarch is the third book in this delightful series featuring the sisters Brontë: Emily, Anne and Charlotte. In this fourth book their brother Branwell plays more of a role than he did in the first books.
Well now, only recently I visited the Fries Museum who currently have an exhibition with a great number of portraits on loan from the London Portrait Gallery. There they were, the famous sisters, painted by their brother Branwell in 1864. I would love to copy the picture here but I don't know how. I'm sure you can find it ;-).
At the start of this story, the sisters are at home, writing and working as always, when they receive a message from Lydia Robinson, who eloped with her boyfriend Harry and is now married and pregnant and living under horrible circumstances. Harry began working for a criminal which led to more criminals which again led to heavier crimes. Apparently Harry now has stolen a jewel and the sisters need to help Lydia to find this jewel before Harry will be killed by someone called The Noose. All very frightening, and above that the sisters have to travel to London to ‘detect’ the solution to this big problem.
The book is filled with descriptions of the late 19th century London, a place where three young ladies from York are absolutely not wanted or needed – or so some unsavoury types try to tell them. And not only tell, the sisters have to literally fight for the freedom of Harry, Lydia and themselves. There is a lot going on in this story and I liked this book just a little more than the first two. There were some interesting characters and we get more insight in the different characters of the sisters. After all, they are three very different personalities. It was not very hard to guess what Harry was supposed to have stolen, and this added an interesting idea to the plot.
Thanks to Hodder&Stoughton and Netgalley for this review copy.
Well now, only recently I visited the Fries Museum who currently have an exhibition with a great number of portraits on loan from the London Portrait Gallery. There they were, the famous sisters, painted by their brother Branwell in 1864. I would love to copy the picture here but I don't know how. I'm sure you can find it ;-).
At the start of this story, the sisters are at home, writing and working as always, when they receive a message from Lydia Robinson, who eloped with her boyfriend Harry and is now married and pregnant and living under horrible circumstances. Harry began working for a criminal which led to more criminals which again led to heavier crimes. Apparently Harry now has stolen a jewel and the sisters need to help Lydia to find this jewel before Harry will be killed by someone called The Noose. All very frightening, and above that the sisters have to travel to London to ‘detect’ the solution to this big problem.
The book is filled with descriptions of the late 19th century London, a place where three young ladies from York are absolutely not wanted or needed – or so some unsavoury types try to tell them. And not only tell, the sisters have to literally fight for the freedom of Harry, Lydia and themselves. There is a lot going on in this story and I liked this book just a little more than the first two. There were some interesting characters and we get more insight in the different characters of the sisters. After all, they are three very different personalities. It was not very hard to guess what Harry was supposed to have stolen, and this added an interesting idea to the plot.
Thanks to Hodder&Stoughton and Netgalley for this review copy.
November 18, 2021
In The Red Monarch the Brontë sisters, along with their brother Branwell, leave their beloved Yorkshire Moors for the much less salubrious streets of Victorian London. As well as viewing it as a mission of mercy there is also, they have to admit, the thrill of having a new case to investigate and the prospect of ‘adventure aplenty and fiendishly difficult riddles to be solved’. Sounds good to me, and so it turns out.
Charlotte, as the last surviving sister, is once again given the role of custodian of the accounts of their hitherto unknown adventures as ‘lady detectorists’. There is a poignant moment in the book when Anne reassures Charlotte, ‘We shall always be at your side, irritating your every thought always, I swear it’ causing Charlotte to shudder ‘as if someone had just walked over her grave… an unwelcome message delivered from an uncertain future’.
As in the two previous books – The Vanished Bride and The Diabolical Bones – the individual characters of the siblings are carefully drawn. Indeed, the sisters themselves recognise one another’s strengths and weaknesses when it comes to their role as investigators of crime. Anne’s gift, in Charlotte’s words, is ‘to intuit revelations that are invaluable’, whilst Anne praises Charlotte’s ‘bravery and cleverness’. Emily is the adventurer of the trio, as she soon proves. And Branwell? Well, he comes in useful as a protector when he’s able to lift himself from his current melancholy state, the result of an unsuccessful (real life) love affair.
The bond between the sisters is touching, Charlotte declaring at one point ‘we are never alone when we have one another’. Their other shared passion is, of course, writing although at this point in their lives they are yet to write the novels that will make them famous and are eagerly awaiting the first review of their volume of poetry. Every author knows what that’s like! In one memorable scene Charlotte encounters a famous (male) writer who is dismissive of her literary ambitions. Fortunately, she receives a more sympathetic and encouraging response from a female novelist quite famous in her day but now, I suspect, little known. The said lady novelist proves a useful ally as well.
I had fun spotting allusions to people or places in the Brontë sisters’ novels, including one which refers to a misreading of the title of one of the sister’s poems. Full disclosure: I had to Google that one and I’m sure there were others that I missed! Such references demonstrate the author’s extensive knowledge of, and obvious affection for, the Brontës and their works, as well as acting as little gifts for the observant reader.
Of course there is also an intriguing mystery to be solved that involves Emily, Charlotte, Anne and Branwell exploring ‘the dark and undoubtedly dangerous underworld of the grimmest and most violent parts of the city’. I’ll say. What they uncover is a web of evil and depravity that reaches into the highest echelons of society.
The Red Monarch is another terrific instalment in what has become one of my favourite historical mystery series. It’s a book (and a series) I can highly recommended for fans of historical mysteries or of the Brontës.
Charlotte, as the last surviving sister, is once again given the role of custodian of the accounts of their hitherto unknown adventures as ‘lady detectorists’. There is a poignant moment in the book when Anne reassures Charlotte, ‘We shall always be at your side, irritating your every thought always, I swear it’ causing Charlotte to shudder ‘as if someone had just walked over her grave… an unwelcome message delivered from an uncertain future’.
As in the two previous books – The Vanished Bride and The Diabolical Bones – the individual characters of the siblings are carefully drawn. Indeed, the sisters themselves recognise one another’s strengths and weaknesses when it comes to their role as investigators of crime. Anne’s gift, in Charlotte’s words, is ‘to intuit revelations that are invaluable’, whilst Anne praises Charlotte’s ‘bravery and cleverness’. Emily is the adventurer of the trio, as she soon proves. And Branwell? Well, he comes in useful as a protector when he’s able to lift himself from his current melancholy state, the result of an unsuccessful (real life) love affair.
The bond between the sisters is touching, Charlotte declaring at one point ‘we are never alone when we have one another’. Their other shared passion is, of course, writing although at this point in their lives they are yet to write the novels that will make them famous and are eagerly awaiting the first review of their volume of poetry. Every author knows what that’s like! In one memorable scene Charlotte encounters a famous (male) writer who is dismissive of her literary ambitions. Fortunately, she receives a more sympathetic and encouraging response from a female novelist quite famous in her day but now, I suspect, little known. The said lady novelist proves a useful ally as well.
I had fun spotting allusions to people or places in the Brontë sisters’ novels, including one which refers to a misreading of the title of one of the sister’s poems. Full disclosure: I had to Google that one and I’m sure there were others that I missed! Such references demonstrate the author’s extensive knowledge of, and obvious affection for, the Brontës and their works, as well as acting as little gifts for the observant reader.
Of course there is also an intriguing mystery to be solved that involves Emily, Charlotte, Anne and Branwell exploring ‘the dark and undoubtedly dangerous underworld of the grimmest and most violent parts of the city’. I’ll say. What they uncover is a web of evil and depravity that reaches into the highest echelons of society.
The Red Monarch is another terrific instalment in what has become one of my favourite historical mystery series. It’s a book (and a series) I can highly recommended for fans of historical mysteries or of the Brontës.
October 8, 2024
Without a doubt, the Brontë Sisters mystery series is a top-notch delight. The Red Monarch was different, as Charlotte, Emily, and Anne travel to London to detect the latest mystery—the disappearance of a newly married man, the husband of one of Anne’s formal pupils—although this one was good, it wasn’t as good as The Diabolical Bones, which was crazy good. Still, it was worthy addition to the series. Although there is one more book in series—thus far—I fear there may not be anymore as we have come almost to the end of the timeline for the Sisters before the family begins to succumb to illness and death. Hopefully, Miss Bella Ellis (a pen name brilliantly conceived) surprises us with another after A Gift of Poison.
The most delightful aspect of this series is, of course, the Brontë Sisters as individuals, and as detectors. Each of them shine as themselves with their fears and dreams and hopes, and with chapter written from one if their particular point of view, it just adds dimension to the story.
Overall, a great third installment to the series that deepens the character and personalities of the sisters, and hints at their future with constant references to long lives and the aforementioned dreams.
For those unacquainted with the sisters and their brother Branwell, Charlotte lived longer than the others, two of which, Emily and Branwell, pass within months of each other in 1848, and Anne in 1849. Charlotte passed in 1855 with none of them living past the age of 31, except Charlotte (38). The story takes place in 1847, hence my concern earlier that may only be four novels in this series. Sad, because it is great writing. Highly recommended!
The most delightful aspect of this series is, of course, the Brontë Sisters as individuals, and as detectors. Each of them shine as themselves with their fears and dreams and hopes, and with chapter written from one if their particular point of view, it just adds dimension to the story.
Overall, a great third installment to the series that deepens the character and personalities of the sisters, and hints at their future with constant references to long lives and the aforementioned dreams.
For those unacquainted with the sisters and their brother Branwell, Charlotte lived longer than the others, two of which, Emily and Branwell, pass within months of each other in 1848, and Anne in 1849. Charlotte passed in 1855 with none of them living past the age of 31, except Charlotte (38). The story takes place in 1847, hence my concern earlier that may only be four novels in this series. Sad, because it is great writing. Highly recommended!
April 1, 2022
Najsłabsza z serii, ale to nadal super rozrywka. Jak zwykle, jestem pod ogromnym wrażeniem wiedzy i riserczu autorki. Zrobiła niesamowitą robotę, tchnęła życie w całą rodzinę Brontë, tworząc wyraziste postaci z krwi i kości. Świetnie, że historie nadal mają feministyczny rys, ale tu zrobiło się „za bardzo” jeśli chodzi o zagadkę - skala za wielka, w pewnym momencie było trochę niedorzecznie (zakończenie na minus), wyprawa do Londynu też trochę odarła powieść z klimatu. Ale oderwałam głowę, więc i tak kocham Bellę Ellis i czekam na więcej.
October 31, 2021
This is the third novel featuring the Brontes from Bella Ellis and yet again she has managed to deliver an entertaining read. The sisters and their brother go to London to help Lydia Robinson (Branwell had an ill fated affair with her mother), Lydia ran away from home to marry an actor and he has become involved in a dark affair featuring some of the worst criminals in London. With lots of vivid description of the poverty faced by many in London and the dangers of the criminal underworld. Ellis is very knowledgable about the history of the Brontes so the timelines always work well A great series.
May 8, 2023
3.25🌟
November 20, 2021
My thanks to Hodder & Stoughton for an eARC via NetGalley of ‘The Red Monarch’ by Bella Ellis in exchange for an honest review.
This is Book 3 in Bella Ellis’ series of historical mysteries featuring the Brontë siblings.
This proved to be an extremely thrilling mystery as the Brontës find themselves facing formidable new adversaries in the infamous Rookery of St.Giles.
The Brontë sisters' first poetry collection has just been published. Given this, their activities as amateur detectors may be coming to an end. Then Anne receives an urgent letter from her former pupil Lydia Robinson. Lydia had recently eloped with a young actor, Harry Roxby. Due to her being disinherited the couple are living in poverty in London.
It appears that Harry has become embroiled with a dangerous criminal gang, who are now holding him captive. The heavily pregnant Lydia has been given a week to return what her husband had supposedly stolen or he will be killed. The sisters, along with their brother, Bramwell, agree to help Lydia. They travel to London where they face a race against time to save Harry's life.
My first thought was thank goodness that the post was reliable between London and Yorkshire! The case is complex and enters very sinister territory.
I was completely transfixed by this novel that proved a gripping page-turner with some elements of the Victorian penny dreadful. I was also again impressed with Bella Ellis’ attention to period detail.
So what is next for the Brontës? Will there be more mysteries in this excellent series? I certainly hope so.
Highly recommended book and series.
This is Book 3 in Bella Ellis’ series of historical mysteries featuring the Brontë siblings.
This proved to be an extremely thrilling mystery as the Brontës find themselves facing formidable new adversaries in the infamous Rookery of St.Giles.
The Brontë sisters' first poetry collection has just been published. Given this, their activities as amateur detectors may be coming to an end. Then Anne receives an urgent letter from her former pupil Lydia Robinson. Lydia had recently eloped with a young actor, Harry Roxby. Due to her being disinherited the couple are living in poverty in London.
It appears that Harry has become embroiled with a dangerous criminal gang, who are now holding him captive. The heavily pregnant Lydia has been given a week to return what her husband had supposedly stolen or he will be killed. The sisters, along with their brother, Bramwell, agree to help Lydia. They travel to London where they face a race against time to save Harry's life.
My first thought was thank goodness that the post was reliable between London and Yorkshire! The case is complex and enters very sinister territory.
I was completely transfixed by this novel that proved a gripping page-turner with some elements of the Victorian penny dreadful. I was also again impressed with Bella Ellis’ attention to period detail.
So what is next for the Brontës? Will there be more mysteries in this excellent series? I certainly hope so.
Highly recommended book and series.
October 17, 2021
With her powerful storytelling and immersive world-building, Bella Ellis has done it again. This third installment of the Bronte Sisters Mysteries will keep you speeding through the chapters as the suspense and drama build.
This time, the Brontes are summoned south to London by an acquaintance who has recently eloped, only to have her husband kidnapped by a band of rogues who give her one week to find and return "the jewel" they have lost.
The Bronte sisters are accompanied by their brother Branwell. I like that this series humanizes Branwell and draws out from the reader a feeling of regret for what he could have been. And the characterization of all three sisters is brilliantly done, particularly Emily in all her antisocial glory.
The suspense and pacing are excellent.
Content note: The evil that the Brontes encounter is very grim, involving dens of iniquity and child trafficking. Readers should be aware that there are a couple of brief moments that involve the supernatural, though these are not central to the plot.
Thanks to Hodder & Stoughton for this advance review copy!
This time, the Brontes are summoned south to London by an acquaintance who has recently eloped, only to have her husband kidnapped by a band of rogues who give her one week to find and return "the jewel" they have lost.
The Bronte sisters are accompanied by their brother Branwell. I like that this series humanizes Branwell and draws out from the reader a feeling of regret for what he could have been. And the characterization of all three sisters is brilliantly done, particularly Emily in all her antisocial glory.
The suspense and pacing are excellent.
Content note: The evil that the Brontes encounter is very grim, involving dens of iniquity and child trafficking. Readers should be aware that there are a couple of brief moments that involve the supernatural, though these are not central to the plot.
Thanks to Hodder & Stoughton for this advance review copy!
July 29, 2024
A gripping and enjoyable mystery which takes the Brontës away from Yorkshire and into the heart of murky London. There are many questions and many mysteries to be solved as the sisters go to the aid of Lydia Roxby whose husband Harry has been snatched by a ruthless gang leader. But there may be greater horrors that await discovery. Set against the backdrop of the London theatrical world, this is a colourful yet dark novel, and the strongest in the series so far.
October 13, 2021
The Red Monarch by Bella Ellis
Genre: Historical Fiction
Publisher: Hodder & Stoughton
Publish Date: 4 November 2021
Star Rating: 3.5/5
I love this time of year because like clockwork a new Bella Ellis novel comes out! From the first book, I have been a devoted follower of this Bronte series. I love the cover artwork, the story, how the Brontes are brought to life, and the dark undertones that weaves through the pages. The latest installment is ‘The Red Monarch’. The siblings must rush to London to save the daughter's Husband of none other than Mrs. Robinson, the same Mrs. Robinson who has crushed our poor Branwell’s heart into the dirt. During this adventure, we meet questionable characters, explore London and the theatre.
Like always Ellis has done an amazing job and I’m glad I have read it. Unfortunately, the first and second books remain my favorites out of the series. This one just didn’t capture me the same. I don’t mind the Brontes visiting London but they belong at home on the moors and have a whole book venturing in London was too much. The other books contained beautiful comparisons that led to inspiring their writing but I didn’t feel the magic of this in this book. I am looking forward to the next installment in the series hopeful of returning to the moors.
I may not have loved this book as much as the others but I’m loyal and must insist that you read this book and especially the first two. If you have already I highly recommend reading them again!
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher, Hodder & Stoughton, for an E-ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.
Genre: Historical Fiction
Publisher: Hodder & Stoughton
Publish Date: 4 November 2021
Star Rating: 3.5/5
I love this time of year because like clockwork a new Bella Ellis novel comes out! From the first book, I have been a devoted follower of this Bronte series. I love the cover artwork, the story, how the Brontes are brought to life, and the dark undertones that weaves through the pages. The latest installment is ‘The Red Monarch’. The siblings must rush to London to save the daughter's Husband of none other than Mrs. Robinson, the same Mrs. Robinson who has crushed our poor Branwell’s heart into the dirt. During this adventure, we meet questionable characters, explore London and the theatre.
Like always Ellis has done an amazing job and I’m glad I have read it. Unfortunately, the first and second books remain my favorites out of the series. This one just didn’t capture me the same. I don’t mind the Brontes visiting London but they belong at home on the moors and have a whole book venturing in London was too much. The other books contained beautiful comparisons that led to inspiring their writing but I didn’t feel the magic of this in this book. I am looking forward to the next installment in the series hopeful of returning to the moors.
I may not have loved this book as much as the others but I’m loyal and must insist that you read this book and especially the first two. If you have already I highly recommend reading them again!
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher, Hodder & Stoughton, for an E-ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.
November 15, 2021
4.5 of 5 stars
https://lynns-books.com/2021/11/15/th...
My Five Word TL:DR Review : Yet another winning detectorist novel
The Red Monarch is the third novel by Bella Ellis and is a story that. again, easily captured my attention. This time the three sisters, accompanied by their brother, make their way to London to help a friend who finds herself in dire straits. Lydia Roxby (formerly Robinson) finds herself alone and destitute. Lydia has been disinherited by her family after eloping with Harry. The two live in poverty in London and Harry is driven by circumstances to a life of crime. As the story begins Harry is taken by notorious crime lord, Noose, having stolen a valuable jewel. Lydia has a week to return the missing item or both will suffer the consequences (involving lead boots and a watery grave perhaps). Anne is the only friend that Lydia can turn to and consequently the family soon find themselves travelling to the Capital to help.
As with the Diabolical Bones I’m not going to elaborate on the plot. Instead, I will again focus on those elements of the story that worked really well for me.
Firstly, the setting. This time we are taken away from the wilds of Howarth and the moors that inspired their works. We find ourselves in a London roughly around the year 1846 (the sisters having recently published their poems). London was a place of extreme contrasts. Home to royalty, nobles and the upper class with their opulent lifestyles and extreme wealth but on the opposite side of the coin overpopulated by those suffering deprivation and poverty. This is a city with a seething criminal underbelly. Dirty and unsanitary, people lived in dilapidated slums and were driven to lives of crime. Ellis uses the period well utilising the infamous slums of the period known as the Rookery. A seething mess of alleys and a twisted warren of streets where unsuspecting visitors could easily become targets for pickpockets and much worse. We spend a good portion of time in a theatre where Lydia and her husband lived in a small apartment. I just loved this setting. The theatre is an inspired choice, it almost has a world of it’s own contained beneath the stage and seating. Twisted corridors, rickety staircases leading to the precarious heights of the building and below the bright lights a warren of secret tunnels created for the rich and famous as a way to come and go in secret. It’s a wonderful contrast between the gilded public side of the building and the worn and dark interior that hides many secrets.
Ellis manages to take the siblings into the very heart of danger as they explore London looking for answers.
Secondly, the characters. Again, the family are really well portrayed. The love between them all is apparent even as their differences shine out from the pages. All the sisters have alternating chapters but Emily in particular enjoys the limelight. Their characters really stand out, Charlotte’s shy yet bold nature, Emily’s complete desire to follow her own singular route, Anne, just maturing enough to have her own voice and Branwell who comes across even better in this instalment as he enjoys a period free from other influences. On top of this we make the acquaintance of two very enigmatic members of the theatre who help the family stay safe and guide them through the perils of London. These two characters really play into the story, particularly the actor Louis who is undoubtedly being portrayed as inspiration for Emily’s future writing. The Machiavellian underworld has some very seedy characters that come from all walks of life, stooping to despicable acts and taking life without thought or regret.
Again, I loved the writing. Ellis manages to really conjure the period, her pacing is great and after a little set up I found myself glued to the page.
In terms of criticisms. Well, I haven’t elaborated on the plot for good reason. I would say it’s fairly obvious what is going on here in many respects, but, I don’t really think that’s a negative to be honest – you have to remember the time and the characters themselves. Reading from a different and much more cynical period it’s much easier to think the worst unlike these genteel and sheltered young women.
Overall, I’m loving this series. There’s the mysteries, the period, the amazing characters and some small fantastical elements that play into the sensibilities and superstitions of the period. My only quibble is (knowing the short lives of the Brontës I worry how many more novels we can expect and enjoy (hopefully at least a couple more).
I received a copy through Netgalley, courtesy of the publisher, for which my thanks. The above is my own opinion.
https://lynns-books.com/2021/11/15/th...
My Five Word TL:DR Review : Yet another winning detectorist novel
The Red Monarch is the third novel by Bella Ellis and is a story that. again, easily captured my attention. This time the three sisters, accompanied by their brother, make their way to London to help a friend who finds herself in dire straits. Lydia Roxby (formerly Robinson) finds herself alone and destitute. Lydia has been disinherited by her family after eloping with Harry. The two live in poverty in London and Harry is driven by circumstances to a life of crime. As the story begins Harry is taken by notorious crime lord, Noose, having stolen a valuable jewel. Lydia has a week to return the missing item or both will suffer the consequences (involving lead boots and a watery grave perhaps). Anne is the only friend that Lydia can turn to and consequently the family soon find themselves travelling to the Capital to help.
As with the Diabolical Bones I’m not going to elaborate on the plot. Instead, I will again focus on those elements of the story that worked really well for me.
Firstly, the setting. This time we are taken away from the wilds of Howarth and the moors that inspired their works. We find ourselves in a London roughly around the year 1846 (the sisters having recently published their poems). London was a place of extreme contrasts. Home to royalty, nobles and the upper class with their opulent lifestyles and extreme wealth but on the opposite side of the coin overpopulated by those suffering deprivation and poverty. This is a city with a seething criminal underbelly. Dirty and unsanitary, people lived in dilapidated slums and were driven to lives of crime. Ellis uses the period well utilising the infamous slums of the period known as the Rookery. A seething mess of alleys and a twisted warren of streets where unsuspecting visitors could easily become targets for pickpockets and much worse. We spend a good portion of time in a theatre where Lydia and her husband lived in a small apartment. I just loved this setting. The theatre is an inspired choice, it almost has a world of it’s own contained beneath the stage and seating. Twisted corridors, rickety staircases leading to the precarious heights of the building and below the bright lights a warren of secret tunnels created for the rich and famous as a way to come and go in secret. It’s a wonderful contrast between the gilded public side of the building and the worn and dark interior that hides many secrets.
Ellis manages to take the siblings into the very heart of danger as they explore London looking for answers.
Secondly, the characters. Again, the family are really well portrayed. The love between them all is apparent even as their differences shine out from the pages. All the sisters have alternating chapters but Emily in particular enjoys the limelight. Their characters really stand out, Charlotte’s shy yet bold nature, Emily’s complete desire to follow her own singular route, Anne, just maturing enough to have her own voice and Branwell who comes across even better in this instalment as he enjoys a period free from other influences. On top of this we make the acquaintance of two very enigmatic members of the theatre who help the family stay safe and guide them through the perils of London. These two characters really play into the story, particularly the actor Louis who is undoubtedly being portrayed as inspiration for Emily’s future writing. The Machiavellian underworld has some very seedy characters that come from all walks of life, stooping to despicable acts and taking life without thought or regret.
Again, I loved the writing. Ellis manages to really conjure the period, her pacing is great and after a little set up I found myself glued to the page.
In terms of criticisms. Well, I haven’t elaborated on the plot for good reason. I would say it’s fairly obvious what is going on here in many respects, but, I don’t really think that’s a negative to be honest – you have to remember the time and the characters themselves. Reading from a different and much more cynical period it’s much easier to think the worst unlike these genteel and sheltered young women.
Overall, I’m loving this series. There’s the mysteries, the period, the amazing characters and some small fantastical elements that play into the sensibilities and superstitions of the period. My only quibble is (knowing the short lives of the Brontës I worry how many more novels we can expect and enjoy (hopefully at least a couple more).
I received a copy through Netgalley, courtesy of the publisher, for which my thanks. The above is my own opinion.
November 11, 2021
"I am a bad man, Miss Bronte —the worst of them —but the Red Monarch is the devil himself."
The Bronte Mysteries and the escapades of the feisty and determined Bronte sisters are now a highlight of my autumn. The third book in this series, The Red Monarch, is another addictive, enthralling and witty novel that follows Charlotte, Emily and Anne in their alternative existence as lady detectors.
This time they have come to London to help Lydia Roxby, one of Anne’s former pupils, who was awoken a few nights ago by a gang of vicious thugs who took her husband Harry and demanded that she find and return their lost jewel within seven days or they would both be killed. With little to go on, it looks like an impossible task. But they soon make alliances with a couple of locals that lead them to the gang they are looking for.
But they aren’t the only ones they need to fear. The sisters soon discover there is a much greater terror that looms over London: the Red Monarch. A man so evil that even the thugs fear him. A man whose name they dare not speak. Can the sisters find this illusive devil and save Harry and Lydia before it’s too late?
"As it happens, my sisters and I have found that even though we are but weak and feeble women, we can do most things that must be done entirely ourselves without the slightest bit of aid from any gentleman."
Bella Ellis has done it again. As soon as I began reading I was enveloped in a sense of comfort that felt like a warm hug, the familiar writing, place and characters making me feel like I was coming home. Luscious prose and evocative imagery come together to create an atmospheric and vivid read that transports me back in time and makes me feel like I am there beside them as they do their detecting. It is so well written that I find myself completely caught up in the story and forgetting that they weren’t actually lady detectors. Though I wish they had been.
The Brontes are the embodiment of the Yorkshire Moors so it was fascinating to see them out of their comfort zone and in the bleak, grimy streets of London this time around. I enjoyed seeing how they reacted to a different environment and being away from people who know them. It’s easy for us to forget how isolated even the most educated and well-read people would have been in somewhere such as Haworth at that time and how frightening a place like London would have been. We are so used to knowing about the most far flung corners of the world and seeing its wonders online or on TV that it is hard to imagine the impact travelling must have had on people back then.
"Sir, if decent people never take a stand against encroaching dark, then soon the entire world will live in constant terror."
These three ladies now hold a piece of my heart and I feel like this series has given me a greater appreciation for who they really were and the ways they broke the mould. Though their escapades are fiction, their characters and other events in their lives are based in fact, allowing us to really get to the heart of who they are. iIthout this series I don’t think I’d have that knowledge or the passion it has sparked for them in my bookish heart. So I am forever thankful to Ms. Ellis for her genius in creating this series.
An addictive and mesmerising mystery, this was a joy to read from beginning to end. I just wish I didn’t have to wait a year for the next installment. And, as I’ve said before, it is just crying out to be adapted for TV. BBC and Netflix: where are you?
If you haven’t tried this series yet, then you are missing out. What are you waiting for? Read it now!
The Bronte Mysteries and the escapades of the feisty and determined Bronte sisters are now a highlight of my autumn. The third book in this series, The Red Monarch, is another addictive, enthralling and witty novel that follows Charlotte, Emily and Anne in their alternative existence as lady detectors.
This time they have come to London to help Lydia Roxby, one of Anne’s former pupils, who was awoken a few nights ago by a gang of vicious thugs who took her husband Harry and demanded that she find and return their lost jewel within seven days or they would both be killed. With little to go on, it looks like an impossible task. But they soon make alliances with a couple of locals that lead them to the gang they are looking for.
But they aren’t the only ones they need to fear. The sisters soon discover there is a much greater terror that looms over London: the Red Monarch. A man so evil that even the thugs fear him. A man whose name they dare not speak. Can the sisters find this illusive devil and save Harry and Lydia before it’s too late?
"As it happens, my sisters and I have found that even though we are but weak and feeble women, we can do most things that must be done entirely ourselves without the slightest bit of aid from any gentleman."
Bella Ellis has done it again. As soon as I began reading I was enveloped in a sense of comfort that felt like a warm hug, the familiar writing, place and characters making me feel like I was coming home. Luscious prose and evocative imagery come together to create an atmospheric and vivid read that transports me back in time and makes me feel like I am there beside them as they do their detecting. It is so well written that I find myself completely caught up in the story and forgetting that they weren’t actually lady detectors. Though I wish they had been.
The Brontes are the embodiment of the Yorkshire Moors so it was fascinating to see them out of their comfort zone and in the bleak, grimy streets of London this time around. I enjoyed seeing how they reacted to a different environment and being away from people who know them. It’s easy for us to forget how isolated even the most educated and well-read people would have been in somewhere such as Haworth at that time and how frightening a place like London would have been. We are so used to knowing about the most far flung corners of the world and seeing its wonders online or on TV that it is hard to imagine the impact travelling must have had on people back then.
"Sir, if decent people never take a stand against encroaching dark, then soon the entire world will live in constant terror."
These three ladies now hold a piece of my heart and I feel like this series has given me a greater appreciation for who they really were and the ways they broke the mould. Though their escapades are fiction, their characters and other events in their lives are based in fact, allowing us to really get to the heart of who they are. iIthout this series I don’t think I’d have that knowledge or the passion it has sparked for them in my bookish heart. So I am forever thankful to Ms. Ellis for her genius in creating this series.
An addictive and mesmerising mystery, this was a joy to read from beginning to end. I just wish I didn’t have to wait a year for the next installment. And, as I’ve said before, it is just crying out to be adapted for TV. BBC and Netflix: where are you?
If you haven’t tried this series yet, then you are missing out. What are you waiting for? Read it now!
November 16, 2021
I’m just going to come out and say it right away. This third instalment in the Brönte Sisters Mystery series is the best one yet. And that’s saying something because the previous two books were absolute corkers in their own right.
The sisters have just published their first poetry collection but they will have to wait to see how it’s being received by the critics because more pressing matters are calling. Anne’s friend Lydia desperately needs some detecting help. Lydia’s husband has been kidnapped by a criminal gang which is ruling the streets of London. If Lydia wants to see her husband alive again, she must return something her husband allegedly stole. How hard can it be, right? Well, pretty hard. Because Lydia is heavily pregnant, living in poverty and most importantly, doesn’t have a clue what something she’s supposed to be looking for.
Charlotte, Emily, Anne and their brother Branwell travel down to London to help. They are entirely unprepared for what awaits them there. The streets of the big city are so very different from their beloved Yorkshire moors and danger lurks around every corner. With only three days left until Lydia’s husband faces certain death, the Bröntes are on a desperate race against time to save this man’s life. If only they knew where to start.
It takes Bella Ellis less than a paragraph to completely transport me to the 1800s. For there is so much more to this story than simply solving a mystery. Through the eyes of the main characters, the reader too witnesses the horrible circumstances many residents of London live in. From the opera singer with her sugar daddy, who provides her with a questionable sense of protection; to Lydia herself, who lost out on an inheritance when she chose love and now lives in the tiniest attic room above a theatre; to so many others who toil day and night to try and move forward in life, only to be shoved back down by criminal overlords. And this is just what they can see on the surface as there are far more despicable things happening behind closed doors. My lips are sealed. You’ll have to discover that for yourself.
These characters grow with every book and it is such a joy to get to know them better. With Lydia being Anne’s friend, I had assumed Anne would take a more central role this time around. While the youngest sister is most definitely stepping up and surprising every one around her, and even Branwell gets involved, for me it is once again Emily who steals the show as she has done since the first book in the series. I adore her and her temperament, I adore how she longs for adventure and yet ultimately always ends up feeling home is still best, I adore her spontaneity, I adore how she doesn’t always think before she jumps …. The list goes on.
These delightful characters have most definitely captured my heart. The supporting cast is every bit as strong and brilliant. As to the mystery, it took me a minute to figure out who was behind it all, calling themselves the red monarch, but I thoroughly enjoyed doing my own bit of detecting. And the something that everyone is looking for, well, let’s just say that shocking reveal left me reeling. Really didn’t see that coming at all. For 340 pages I was absolutely enthralled, absorbed, glued to the pages and I even ended up feeling rather emotional. A perfect afternoon’s reading. I absolutely love this series and I can’t wait for more! ❤️
The sisters have just published their first poetry collection but they will have to wait to see how it’s being received by the critics because more pressing matters are calling. Anne’s friend Lydia desperately needs some detecting help. Lydia’s husband has been kidnapped by a criminal gang which is ruling the streets of London. If Lydia wants to see her husband alive again, she must return something her husband allegedly stole. How hard can it be, right? Well, pretty hard. Because Lydia is heavily pregnant, living in poverty and most importantly, doesn’t have a clue what something she’s supposed to be looking for.
Charlotte, Emily, Anne and their brother Branwell travel down to London to help. They are entirely unprepared for what awaits them there. The streets of the big city are so very different from their beloved Yorkshire moors and danger lurks around every corner. With only three days left until Lydia’s husband faces certain death, the Bröntes are on a desperate race against time to save this man’s life. If only they knew where to start.
It takes Bella Ellis less than a paragraph to completely transport me to the 1800s. For there is so much more to this story than simply solving a mystery. Through the eyes of the main characters, the reader too witnesses the horrible circumstances many residents of London live in. From the opera singer with her sugar daddy, who provides her with a questionable sense of protection; to Lydia herself, who lost out on an inheritance when she chose love and now lives in the tiniest attic room above a theatre; to so many others who toil day and night to try and move forward in life, only to be shoved back down by criminal overlords. And this is just what they can see on the surface as there are far more despicable things happening behind closed doors. My lips are sealed. You’ll have to discover that for yourself.
These characters grow with every book and it is such a joy to get to know them better. With Lydia being Anne’s friend, I had assumed Anne would take a more central role this time around. While the youngest sister is most definitely stepping up and surprising every one around her, and even Branwell gets involved, for me it is once again Emily who steals the show as she has done since the first book in the series. I adore her and her temperament, I adore how she longs for adventure and yet ultimately always ends up feeling home is still best, I adore her spontaneity, I adore how she doesn’t always think before she jumps …. The list goes on.
These delightful characters have most definitely captured my heart. The supporting cast is every bit as strong and brilliant. As to the mystery, it took me a minute to figure out who was behind it all, calling themselves the red monarch, but I thoroughly enjoyed doing my own bit of detecting. And the something that everyone is looking for, well, let’s just say that shocking reveal left me reeling. Really didn’t see that coming at all. For 340 pages I was absolutely enthralled, absorbed, glued to the pages and I even ended up feeling rather emotional. A perfect afternoon’s reading. I absolutely love this series and I can’t wait for more! ❤️
October 31, 2022
This is the third book in the series, in which the Brontë sisters investigate various crimes, including theft and murder. In this instalment, they get caught up in a mystery that starts with theft and kidnapping and turns into exposing the nefarious head of the London crime scene, the titular Red Monarch. You don’t really need to have read the first two books in order to read this one, as it stands alone, but you should read them anyway because they’re all pretty good!
I should just add a trigger warning here, that child abuse forms part of the plotline and was absolutely harrowing despite mostly being alluded to, with no graphic details and with great sensitivity.
The focus remains firmly on the main characters – Anne, Emily, Charlotte, and on this occasion, Bramwell – and their emotional bonds with each other, their relationships with others (one falls in love, one takes the lead, one finds a slightly sapphic BFF and one attempts to recover from a disastrous affair), and their different approaches to investigation (cerebral, emotional, adventurous, dramatic).
As with the previous novels, this was an enjoyable mystery read with the added literary element of following the fictional adventures of these real-life characters, and recognising details from history and from their own written works. It is clear that Bella Ellis is very familiar with the lives of the Brontës, has researched well, and has the writing skill to knit fact and fiction together seamlessly.
I did find the climactic reveal a little bit disappointing, as I had been attempting to uncover the identity of the Red Monarch before the characters and failed to do so, but when they got there first I was a little piqued that there hadn’t been enough clues for the play-along readers… but maybe I just missed them in my enjoyment of the character development and my emotional reactions to the darker plot elements.
Despite that minor quibble, this is another great addition to the Brontë mystery series and I will definitely be looking out for the next one!
I should just add a trigger warning here, that child abuse forms part of the plotline and was absolutely harrowing despite mostly being alluded to, with no graphic details and with great sensitivity.
The focus remains firmly on the main characters – Anne, Emily, Charlotte, and on this occasion, Bramwell – and their emotional bonds with each other, their relationships with others (one falls in love, one takes the lead, one finds a slightly sapphic BFF and one attempts to recover from a disastrous affair), and their different approaches to investigation (cerebral, emotional, adventurous, dramatic).
As with the previous novels, this was an enjoyable mystery read with the added literary element of following the fictional adventures of these real-life characters, and recognising details from history and from their own written works. It is clear that Bella Ellis is very familiar with the lives of the Brontës, has researched well, and has the writing skill to knit fact and fiction together seamlessly.
I did find the climactic reveal a little bit disappointing, as I had been attempting to uncover the identity of the Red Monarch before the characters and failed to do so, but when they got there first I was a little piqued that there hadn’t been enough clues for the play-along readers… but maybe I just missed them in my enjoyment of the character development and my emotional reactions to the darker plot elements.
Despite that minor quibble, this is another great addition to the Brontë mystery series and I will definitely be looking out for the next one!
October 13, 2021
Loved this, the 3rd adventure of the Brontë sisters detective work, great as a standalone but if you read this you'll probably want to read the others.
This time the sisters are called to help a friend in London with their Sober Brother who is heart broken after the elder Mrs Robinson rejection but it's her Daughter Lydia who has eloped with an actor Harry she met in Scarborough that needs their help. Lydia and Harry have moved to Londons Drury Lane and the theatre his Dad owned. But things have gone a bit 🍐 pear-shaped. Theatre land is not a safe place specially for 3 Ladies even with their brother and a pistol. They make some friends ruffle feathers and find their way but this is the toughest test they have faced and danger lurks at almost every corner.
I love the settings and era it allows for some great characters and situations to test your steel as well as our intrepid hero's. Kit and Louise are but 2 of them plus there is the horrid elder Rowley and a couple of literary guest appearances you will not want to miss. But these are not the villans they are fitting for the times horrendous vile characters.
I really enjoyed this adventure of the Brontë Sisters it had a good mixture of fun and edge of your seat moments ready for the next one now.
This time the sisters are called to help a friend in London with their Sober Brother who is heart broken after the elder Mrs Robinson rejection but it's her Daughter Lydia who has eloped with an actor Harry she met in Scarborough that needs their help. Lydia and Harry have moved to Londons Drury Lane and the theatre his Dad owned. But things have gone a bit 🍐 pear-shaped. Theatre land is not a safe place specially for 3 Ladies even with their brother and a pistol. They make some friends ruffle feathers and find their way but this is the toughest test they have faced and danger lurks at almost every corner.
I love the settings and era it allows for some great characters and situations to test your steel as well as our intrepid hero's. Kit and Louise are but 2 of them plus there is the horrid elder Rowley and a couple of literary guest appearances you will not want to miss. But these are not the villans they are fitting for the times horrendous vile characters.
I really enjoyed this adventure of the Brontë Sisters it had a good mixture of fun and edge of your seat moments ready for the next one now.
December 8, 2021
For my full review: https://girlwithherheadinabook.co.uk/...
And they're back! The Brontë sisters are once again ready to fight crime in this fantastically fun series from Bella Ellis, otherwise known as Rowan Coleman. We rejoin the family just as the women are celebrating the publication of their first poetry collection. This third instalment sees a real shift in pace however when a letter arrives for Anne from her erstwhile pupil Lydia Roxby. Disowned by her family for having eloped with an actor, Lydia now finds herself pregnant and missing a husband after he is suddenly abducted by notorious gangster Noose. Lydia has one week to track down the jewel that Harry Roxby has supposedly stolen or else face certain widowhood. Naturally, the Brontë 'detectorists' decide to swing into action and off to London they go with Branwell along for the ride due to hopes of ingratiating himself once more with Lydia's mother Mrs Robinson should their mission prove successful. With little to go on and no time to lose, the sisters face their toughest challenge yet ...
The Brontë Mysteries are an absolute treat for the Brontëphile and Ellis has clearly done her research. Of all the supporting players in the family's life, Lydia Roxby probably would be the best go-to for scandal and intrigue. But my biggest whoop came when the siblings arrived at the theatre where Lydia was sheltering and they were introduced to none other than Louis Parensall. 1930s Brontë biographer Virginia Moore struggled to read Emily's handwriting and so came to the mistaken conclusion that Emily's poem 'Love's Friendship' was named after a hitherto unknown French lover, Louis Parensall. I could only bow to Ms Ellis' ingenuity in flipping this ridiculous misapprehension on its head and playing it seriously. Another intriguing acquaintance at the theatre is Kit Thornfield, who appears on the stage as Celine Varens and seems to long for a better life.
As with the two previous books in the series, the mystery builds up well and maintains suspense. The camaraderie between the siblings is well displayed. However, I did feel that Ellis was starting to lay things on a little thick with Charlotte declaring, 'we are never alone when we have one another' and Anne assuring her that they will always be together. Yes, we know that imminent and multiple bereavements are around the corner but it feels heavy-handed to signal it so heavily to the reader. Also, this is the third time that the central riddle has finished up in a way that I found unconvincing. Not least because in this instance, the case was cracked because they just so happened to show charity to a beggar who just so happened to be key to the mystery. A little too serendipitous. For all three novels, I have heartily enjoyed the story until the final couple of chapters and then it all rolls up rather too neatly. In this case, I was also a little uncomfortable about as dark a subject as child trafficking being made use of for what is essentially light-hearted froth. I picture The Brontë Mysteries as the literary equivalent of red velvet cake with very generous icing. Delicious but not designed for heavy digestion.
With any creative medium, the third time out is often the decider. I remember television writer Stephen Bochco saying that the third season was typically when he would expect a show to hit its stride. It is at this point that there is enough ground trodden for a series to have in-jokes and make references to its past. I have often noticed similar patterns in long-running book series. For me, the best Harry Potter novel was the third. Similarly, Ben Aaronovitch's Rivers of London felt a lot more confident from Whispers Underground onwards. I am not sure that The Red Monarch marks a similar moment here. For one thing, Ellis is already flagging that her protagonists are set to die soon. For another, while the shift of setting could have marked an interesting 'fish out of water' crime novel, instead the situation just felt forced. The series definitely gelled more successfully in Yorkshire.
But having said all of this, there is still much to praise. Earlier this year, I tried reading Pride and Prescience, the first of the Mr and Mrs Darcy Mysteries, which sees Elizabeth Bennet and her husband fighting crime after their marriage. I got about ten pages in and realised that this really was not going to be for me. I think that the difference between the two franchises is that in contrast to my feelings about the Brontë sisters, I feel that I have a close familiarity with the characters of Pride and Prejudice so that Carrie Brebis' use of creative licence (and even - shudder - Americanisms) really grated with me. By comparison, I accept that the truth around the Brontë family has been too overshadowed by myth-making, white-washing and hangers-on seeking to steal the spotlight (looking at you, Ellen Nussey) for the reader to ever feel certain of who they were. While it may be absurd to imagine the sisters playing detective, it is no less ridiculous than many of the other theories which have been asserted as fact - the various purported photographs, Anne's unprovable passion for William Weightman, and of course Emily's fictional French lover. I admire how Ellis is able to take these many strands of stories and twist them together into something quite this fun - it is a mark of true skill. Regardless of any criticisms around the plot of this particular novel, I do believe that The Brontë Mysteries represents the most creative venture within the Brontë fandom that I can ever remember.
I will be back for the sisters' next outing as detectors. I hope there will be many more instalments before they meet their inevitable tragic ends. However, I do hope that the plot resolution next time lands with a little more care. At its best, this series has been truly magical but on this occasion it lacked its usual sparkle.
And they're back! The Brontë sisters are once again ready to fight crime in this fantastically fun series from Bella Ellis, otherwise known as Rowan Coleman. We rejoin the family just as the women are celebrating the publication of their first poetry collection. This third instalment sees a real shift in pace however when a letter arrives for Anne from her erstwhile pupil Lydia Roxby. Disowned by her family for having eloped with an actor, Lydia now finds herself pregnant and missing a husband after he is suddenly abducted by notorious gangster Noose. Lydia has one week to track down the jewel that Harry Roxby has supposedly stolen or else face certain widowhood. Naturally, the Brontë 'detectorists' decide to swing into action and off to London they go with Branwell along for the ride due to hopes of ingratiating himself once more with Lydia's mother Mrs Robinson should their mission prove successful. With little to go on and no time to lose, the sisters face their toughest challenge yet ...
The Brontë Mysteries are an absolute treat for the Brontëphile and Ellis has clearly done her research. Of all the supporting players in the family's life, Lydia Roxby probably would be the best go-to for scandal and intrigue. But my biggest whoop came when the siblings arrived at the theatre where Lydia was sheltering and they were introduced to none other than Louis Parensall. 1930s Brontë biographer Virginia Moore struggled to read Emily's handwriting and so came to the mistaken conclusion that Emily's poem 'Love's Friendship' was named after a hitherto unknown French lover, Louis Parensall. I could only bow to Ms Ellis' ingenuity in flipping this ridiculous misapprehension on its head and playing it seriously. Another intriguing acquaintance at the theatre is Kit Thornfield, who appears on the stage as Celine Varens and seems to long for a better life.
As with the two previous books in the series, the mystery builds up well and maintains suspense. The camaraderie between the siblings is well displayed. However, I did feel that Ellis was starting to lay things on a little thick with Charlotte declaring, 'we are never alone when we have one another' and Anne assuring her that they will always be together. Yes, we know that imminent and multiple bereavements are around the corner but it feels heavy-handed to signal it so heavily to the reader. Also, this is the third time that the central riddle has finished up in a way that I found unconvincing. Not least because in this instance, the case was cracked because they just so happened to show charity to a beggar who just so happened to be key to the mystery. A little too serendipitous. For all three novels, I have heartily enjoyed the story until the final couple of chapters and then it all rolls up rather too neatly. In this case, I was also a little uncomfortable about as dark a subject as child trafficking being made use of for what is essentially light-hearted froth. I picture The Brontë Mysteries as the literary equivalent of red velvet cake with very generous icing. Delicious but not designed for heavy digestion.
With any creative medium, the third time out is often the decider. I remember television writer Stephen Bochco saying that the third season was typically when he would expect a show to hit its stride. It is at this point that there is enough ground trodden for a series to have in-jokes and make references to its past. I have often noticed similar patterns in long-running book series. For me, the best Harry Potter novel was the third. Similarly, Ben Aaronovitch's Rivers of London felt a lot more confident from Whispers Underground onwards. I am not sure that The Red Monarch marks a similar moment here. For one thing, Ellis is already flagging that her protagonists are set to die soon. For another, while the shift of setting could have marked an interesting 'fish out of water' crime novel, instead the situation just felt forced. The series definitely gelled more successfully in Yorkshire.
But having said all of this, there is still much to praise. Earlier this year, I tried reading Pride and Prescience, the first of the Mr and Mrs Darcy Mysteries, which sees Elizabeth Bennet and her husband fighting crime after their marriage. I got about ten pages in and realised that this really was not going to be for me. I think that the difference between the two franchises is that in contrast to my feelings about the Brontë sisters, I feel that I have a close familiarity with the characters of Pride and Prejudice so that Carrie Brebis' use of creative licence (and even - shudder - Americanisms) really grated with me. By comparison, I accept that the truth around the Brontë family has been too overshadowed by myth-making, white-washing and hangers-on seeking to steal the spotlight (looking at you, Ellen Nussey) for the reader to ever feel certain of who they were. While it may be absurd to imagine the sisters playing detective, it is no less ridiculous than many of the other theories which have been asserted as fact - the various purported photographs, Anne's unprovable passion for William Weightman, and of course Emily's fictional French lover. I admire how Ellis is able to take these many strands of stories and twist them together into something quite this fun - it is a mark of true skill. Regardless of any criticisms around the plot of this particular novel, I do believe that The Brontë Mysteries represents the most creative venture within the Brontë fandom that I can ever remember.
I will be back for the sisters' next outing as detectors. I hope there will be many more instalments before they meet their inevitable tragic ends. However, I do hope that the plot resolution next time lands with a little more care. At its best, this series has been truly magical but on this occasion it lacked its usual sparkle.
November 18, 2021
Lydia, the daughter of Branwell's married ex-lover, eloped with a young actor, Harry Roxby, & they have been living in dire straits in London ever since. Harry is now being held for ransom by the leader of a notorious criminal gang & his safe return depends upon Lydia finding a missing jewel. Lydia contacts the Bronte sisters & begs for their help & the three sisters plus Branwell head for London.
The third book in this series is slightly darker in tone involving the kidnapping of young girls for nefarious purposes. Again, the incorporation of people such as Victorian authors Charles Dickens & Catherine Crowe lends itself well to the story. There was also the author's take on what could possibly have sparked the beginning of Wuthering Heights in the imagination of Emily Bronte. I didn't enjoy it quite as much as the first two books so I have rated it 4 stars. I recommend this series for any historical mystery fans.
My thanks to NetGalley & publishers, Hodder & Stoughton, for the opportunity to read an ARC.
The third book in this series is slightly darker in tone involving the kidnapping of young girls for nefarious purposes. Again, the incorporation of people such as Victorian authors Charles Dickens & Catherine Crowe lends itself well to the story. There was also the author's take on what could possibly have sparked the beginning of Wuthering Heights in the imagination of Emily Bronte. I didn't enjoy it quite as much as the first two books so I have rated it 4 stars. I recommend this series for any historical mystery fans.
My thanks to NetGalley & publishers, Hodder & Stoughton, for the opportunity to read an ARC.
November 8, 2021
I really like this series and was looking forward to this new book. And I wasn’t disappointed! The old characters in new environment is always an interesting idea, and London in the 19th century is quite a treat ( not really, of course) I found the story quite interesting, the character development was again well done and easy to follow. Each sister acquired some new nuances and that’s why some more depth. Also the new characters were interesting and helped to understand the story better. I liked the twists and can only completely recommend this book!
September 14, 2025
While the previous two volumes amused me, this one, unfortunately, felt rather dull in spite of being the most action-packed. Perhaps because we are no longer on the moors but in London? Perhaps because it becomes way too unrealistic? Or perhaps because the dialogue has turned into a "who knows thesaurus better" competition?
May 27, 2025
Another very good mystery starring the Bronte sisters and Branwell. This story is set in London so it takes us away from our beloved Yorkshire moors. Bella Ellis does not shy away from difficult topics which are disturbing. Because of this I cannot recommend younger readers picking this up. But nevertheless, it is a page turner and again, Ellis brings the sisters to life.
August 21, 2022
The story:
The Brontës of Haworth have received a desperate plea for help. Lydia Roxby, formerly Anne’s pupil, now estranged from her family following her elopement with an actor, is in terrible trouble. Her husband has been accused of cheating some very dangerous men, and if Lydia can’t produce what they ask for in seven days, both her husband’s life and her own will be forfeit. Ever willing to try and help their fellows, and following their success as detectors in their past adventures, the Brontës set out for London to aid Lydia. But will the dangers they meet in the slums of the capital and the theatres of Drury Lane be too much even for the intrepid siblings?
My thoughts:
“The Red Monarch” by Bella Ellis (the very appropriate pen name of author Rowan Coleman), is the third book in the Brontë Sisters Mysteries. It is the first I have read in the series, but it works well as a standalone.
I think this is such a wonderful idea for a mystery series, and the author reimagines each Brontë sibling with what is clearly great affection. Branwell, with his disastrous romances and weaknesses of character, who is none the less loved and protected by his sisters (despite thinking it is he who is protecting them). Charlotte, with her desire to be proper in all things and take care of her sisters, but also with a shyness and longing for passion in her life. Emily, defiantly independent and her own person, who nonetheless cares deeply about her world in Yorkshire and those in it. And Anne — youngest sister, but in many ways the most sensible, clever and determined of them all.
The siblings are out of their element in the seedy underbelly of London, but are uncowed by it, and even when they are afraid, their sense of responsibility to those around them (friends or strangers), especially those who are weaker, drives them to do what’s right.
I particularly enjoyed the subtle references to the Brontës’ works throughout this book, and it’s fun to think that the events that take place and the people they meet go on to inspire some of the greatest books in English literature.
Overall this is a thoroughly enjoyable read — exciting, funny and with a great mystery at its heart. I thoroughly recommend this book to all historical mystery fans and Brontë devotees!
The Brontës of Haworth have received a desperate plea for help. Lydia Roxby, formerly Anne’s pupil, now estranged from her family following her elopement with an actor, is in terrible trouble. Her husband has been accused of cheating some very dangerous men, and if Lydia can’t produce what they ask for in seven days, both her husband’s life and her own will be forfeit. Ever willing to try and help their fellows, and following their success as detectors in their past adventures, the Brontës set out for London to aid Lydia. But will the dangers they meet in the slums of the capital and the theatres of Drury Lane be too much even for the intrepid siblings?
My thoughts:
“The Red Monarch” by Bella Ellis (the very appropriate pen name of author Rowan Coleman), is the third book in the Brontë Sisters Mysteries. It is the first I have read in the series, but it works well as a standalone.
I think this is such a wonderful idea for a mystery series, and the author reimagines each Brontë sibling with what is clearly great affection. Branwell, with his disastrous romances and weaknesses of character, who is none the less loved and protected by his sisters (despite thinking it is he who is protecting them). Charlotte, with her desire to be proper in all things and take care of her sisters, but also with a shyness and longing for passion in her life. Emily, defiantly independent and her own person, who nonetheless cares deeply about her world in Yorkshire and those in it. And Anne — youngest sister, but in many ways the most sensible, clever and determined of them all.
The siblings are out of their element in the seedy underbelly of London, but are uncowed by it, and even when they are afraid, their sense of responsibility to those around them (friends or strangers), especially those who are weaker, drives them to do what’s right.
I particularly enjoyed the subtle references to the Brontës’ works throughout this book, and it’s fun to think that the events that take place and the people they meet go on to inspire some of the greatest books in English literature.
Overall this is a thoroughly enjoyable read — exciting, funny and with a great mystery at its heart. I thoroughly recommend this book to all historical mystery fans and Brontë devotees!
March 12, 2022
The Red Monarch is the third Brontë Mystery book in which the main characters are the three Brontë sisters, Charlotte, Emily and Anne and their brother Branwell. I’ve read the first two and enjoyed them. But when I came across the first book I wasn’t at all sure I wanted to read it, as I’m never very keen on books that use real people as fictional characters. So, I was delighted to find that I thoroughly enjoyed the books even though, of course, the stories about the Brontës being ‘detectors’, or amateur sleuths, are pure imagination. The setting in the Yorkshire Moors is superb, the characters came across as ‘real’ and the books are well plotted.
And so, I was looking forward to reading The Red Monarch and it began well in Haworth in August 1852 as Charlotte is trying to write Villette. She is in despair after the deaths of her siblings – Emily and Branwell in 1848, and Anne in 1849. Instead of writing she reads a little notebook containing Emily’s poems and one particular poem brought back to her the dreadful events that had taken place and the terrors and cruelties they had seen, on their excursion to London. It had all taken place just after the Brontë sisters’ first poetry collection had been published – in 1846.
It was at this point, right at the beginning of the story about their time in London, that I thought I was reading a completely different type of mystery from the earlier books – not only is in not set in Yorkshire this book is a gothic melodrama. In a terrifying attack on Lydia and her husband Harry, a gang of thieves and murderers, led by Noose, had burst into Harry and Lydia’s bedroom. They had seized Harry and threatened to kill him unless Lydia brought them the jewel that Harry had been ordered to collect. Lydia, who was pregnant, had seven days to save their lives. But it is the Red Monarch, who was in control of the gang, and who held them all under his control – a most villainous and fearsome gangster. In desperation Lydia wrote to Anne for help.
The story is melodramatic, sensational and fast-paced. It is told through each of the sisters’ eyes, each one clearly distinctive, whilst Emily (once more) is the standout character. They are all independent women, strong-willed and determined and as Victorian women, vastly underestimated by the men. But, I had a hard time accepting the Brontë sisters in this story. Whereas in the two previous books I could believe that the Brontë family were just as Bella Ellis has described them, in this book I couldn’t.
The descriptions of mid 19th century London are vivid, clearly depicting the filthy living conditions of the poor, the sights and foul smells. The details of the Brontës’ search for Harry and the missing jewel test their strength, courage and skill in detection.
There are a few other real people who play a minor role, notably Charles Dickens, who is dismissive when Charlotte, somewhat in awe of him, asks for his advice as a writer, telling her to abandon any ideas of being a novelist and to marry, or teach. His companion, Mrs Catherine Crowe, another real author who wrote supernatural tales, was much more approachable and friendly, contacting her spirit friends to help with Charlotte’s search as well as giving her useful advice as a writer. Another character, with a larger role, is Louis Parensell, who develops a passion for Emily. He was not a real person, but Virginia Moore, a Brontë biographer, misread the handwritten title of Emily’s poem ‘Love’s Farewell’ as ‘Louis Parensell’, and developed the theory that Louis was Emily’s secret lover.
As the novel reached its dramatic climax, Emily in particular is in danger of losing her life as she dared to challenge the Red Monarch. I was most interested in the identity of The Red Monarch – was he in fact a real person, or totally fictitious? There various references to him throughout the novel, what was the origin of his name, and what was the meaning of his insignia? It seemed to be two capital Rs back to back topped with a crown and contained within a five-pointed star of pentagram. Anne had first discovered them and she felt sure they carried a secret meaning to those in know. When the identity of the Red Monarch is finally revealed I was surprised – but it is appropriate in that the real person has been described as a maniacal, controlling man.
I enjoyed this book, but I think the two previous books are much better and seem more authentic, aided by being set in the Brontës’ Yorkshire. They were out of place in London. It all seems to me to be over dramatic and unbelievable. The fictional element far outweighs the historical.
My thanks to Hodder Stoughton for a review copy via NetGalley
And so, I was looking forward to reading The Red Monarch and it began well in Haworth in August 1852 as Charlotte is trying to write Villette. She is in despair after the deaths of her siblings – Emily and Branwell in 1848, and Anne in 1849. Instead of writing she reads a little notebook containing Emily’s poems and one particular poem brought back to her the dreadful events that had taken place and the terrors and cruelties they had seen, on their excursion to London. It had all taken place just after the Brontë sisters’ first poetry collection had been published – in 1846.
It was at this point, right at the beginning of the story about their time in London, that I thought I was reading a completely different type of mystery from the earlier books – not only is in not set in Yorkshire this book is a gothic melodrama. In a terrifying attack on Lydia and her husband Harry, a gang of thieves and murderers, led by Noose, had burst into Harry and Lydia’s bedroom. They had seized Harry and threatened to kill him unless Lydia brought them the jewel that Harry had been ordered to collect. Lydia, who was pregnant, had seven days to save their lives. But it is the Red Monarch, who was in control of the gang, and who held them all under his control – a most villainous and fearsome gangster. In desperation Lydia wrote to Anne for help.
The story is melodramatic, sensational and fast-paced. It is told through each of the sisters’ eyes, each one clearly distinctive, whilst Emily (once more) is the standout character. They are all independent women, strong-willed and determined and as Victorian women, vastly underestimated by the men. But, I had a hard time accepting the Brontë sisters in this story. Whereas in the two previous books I could believe that the Brontë family were just as Bella Ellis has described them, in this book I couldn’t.
The descriptions of mid 19th century London are vivid, clearly depicting the filthy living conditions of the poor, the sights and foul smells. The details of the Brontës’ search for Harry and the missing jewel test their strength, courage and skill in detection.
There are a few other real people who play a minor role, notably Charles Dickens, who is dismissive when Charlotte, somewhat in awe of him, asks for his advice as a writer, telling her to abandon any ideas of being a novelist and to marry, or teach. His companion, Mrs Catherine Crowe, another real author who wrote supernatural tales, was much more approachable and friendly, contacting her spirit friends to help with Charlotte’s search as well as giving her useful advice as a writer. Another character, with a larger role, is Louis Parensell, who develops a passion for Emily. He was not a real person, but Virginia Moore, a Brontë biographer, misread the handwritten title of Emily’s poem ‘Love’s Farewell’ as ‘Louis Parensell’, and developed the theory that Louis was Emily’s secret lover.
As the novel reached its dramatic climax, Emily in particular is in danger of losing her life as she dared to challenge the Red Monarch. I was most interested in the identity of The Red Monarch – was he in fact a real person, or totally fictitious? There various references to him throughout the novel, what was the origin of his name, and what was the meaning of his insignia? It seemed to be two capital Rs back to back topped with a crown and contained within a five-pointed star of pentagram. Anne had first discovered them and she felt sure they carried a secret meaning to those in know. When the identity of the Red Monarch is finally revealed I was surprised – but it is appropriate in that the real person has been described as a maniacal, controlling man.
I enjoyed this book, but I think the two previous books are much better and seem more authentic, aided by being set in the Brontës’ Yorkshire. They were out of place in London. It all seems to me to be over dramatic and unbelievable. The fictional element far outweighs the historical.
My thanks to Hodder Stoughton for a review copy via NetGalley
September 8, 2022
Ayant plus qu’apprécié les deux précédents volets – synonymes de qualité et d’évolution – j’étais plus qu’impatient de retrouver mes trois auteures favorites en tant qu’apprenties détectives et c’est plus qu’enthousiaste que je me suis lancé dans cette lecture qui s’est avérée encore plus délicieuse qu’à l’accoutumée tant le style de Bella Ellis s’élève à nouveau.
Cette dernière s’affranchît des précédents tomes en dévoilant une intrigue bien différente que précédemment et ce, aussi bien dans son fond ainsi que dans sa forme. Cette fois-ci, l’intrigue laisse derrière elle les Landes anglais que j’affectionne tant pour me transporter ainsi que le lecteur dans les bas-fonds de la capitale londonienne, aussi dangereux que mystérieux et aussi froids que hostiles. J’ai été ravi de ces nouveaux décors qui permettent un rafraîchissement de l’univers des plus salvateur qui soit. D’autant plus que comme je le disais, la ville se dessine terne et sombre et les décors dévoilés démontre la pauvreté et la saleté des environs visités et affirme les qualités visuelles du style de l’auteure. Ce percutant contraste avec l’orientation légère et divertissante de cette série m’a beaucoup plus et j’ai pris un immense plaisir à découvrir l’univers théâtrale d’antan en compagnie d’une troupe de troubadours aux caractères et à la construction pertinente et alléchante. Mieux encore, l’enquête en elle-même m’a paru bien plus mature et réfléchie que précédemment tant celle-ci se veut solide et aboutie. D’autant plus que cette dernière n’est avare ni en action, ni en retournements de situations et j’ai été sensible au dynamisme de ce troisième volet que je n’ai pu m’empêcher d’engloutir de part en part jusqu’à découvrir l’identité du célèbre et fameux monarque rouge.
De plus et mieux encore que l’univers en lui-même, mes trois chères sœurs ainsi que leur frère, Branwell m’ont de nouveau totalement charmé et séduit. Nous sommes bien loin de l’image assez brouillonne et hasardeuse du premier volet tant chacune d’elle se dissocie des autres et brille pour son caractère et sa personnalité bien distincts. Plus je les découvre et plus j’ai l’impression de retrouver de vieilles connaissances et ainsi, je m’attache de plus en plus à chaque membre de cette audacieuse mais aimante famille. D’autant plus que les sentiments sont au cœur de ce périple et j’ai trouvé la plume de Bella Ellis des plus sensible et touchante. Notamment en ce qui concerne Emily qui découvrira les joies et les peines des premiers émoi amoureux et alors que je l’appréciais déjà plus particulièrement, j’ai été des plus réceptif quand à l’évolution de ce personnage. C’est touché que j’ai suivi le soupçon de romance dévoilé à travers cette dernière et j’ai apprécié cette nouvelle dimension mise en avant. Ainsi et plus que n’importe quel volet et qu’il s’agisse de Charlotte, Anne ou Émilie toutes sont plus ou moins mises à nu et leur bonté ainsi que leur courage n’a cessé d’être sublimé en parallèle de ce doux et exquis écorchement. Ainsi, les liens familiaux qui unissent chacune ces dernières entre elles mais aussi à Branwell se dévoilent bien davantage développé et même si l’absence du cadre rassurant et paternel de Haworth m’a parfois manqué, j’ai adoré cette impression constante d’unité. Leur fraternité se révèle une force et celle-ci sera bien plus d’une fois mise à contribution au cours de cette course contre la montre pour sauver le mari de leur ancienne amie Lydia ayant quitté le domaine familiale pour vivre une vie de bohème. Grâce à cette dernière et aux différents protagonistes secondaires et parfaitement réalisés également, l’auteure offre une vision des conditions de vie de l’époque pour les personnages marginales et sortant des codes sociaux encadrant cette société d’antan. D’autant plus que Bella Ellis dépeint une importante toile de portraits tous plus séduisants et intriquants les uns que les autres et réservant bon nombre de surprises.
C’est pourquoi, j’ai encore bien davantage apprécié ce volet que ses prédécesseurs. En effet et au fil des tomes, la plume et le style de Bella Ellis ne cesse d’évoluer, de se perfectionner et s’affine pour s’affirmer amplement. Ainsi, l’enquête se dévoile solide, aboutie et addictive tandis que les personnes se dessinent hautement touchants et attachants. Je suis ravi de tisser de tels liens avec la famille Brontë qui ne cesse de m’épater et dont la force des sentiments se veut le véritable atout de cette équipe d’enquêteurs.
Cette dernière s’affranchît des précédents tomes en dévoilant une intrigue bien différente que précédemment et ce, aussi bien dans son fond ainsi que dans sa forme. Cette fois-ci, l’intrigue laisse derrière elle les Landes anglais que j’affectionne tant pour me transporter ainsi que le lecteur dans les bas-fonds de la capitale londonienne, aussi dangereux que mystérieux et aussi froids que hostiles. J’ai été ravi de ces nouveaux décors qui permettent un rafraîchissement de l’univers des plus salvateur qui soit. D’autant plus que comme je le disais, la ville se dessine terne et sombre et les décors dévoilés démontre la pauvreté et la saleté des environs visités et affirme les qualités visuelles du style de l’auteure. Ce percutant contraste avec l’orientation légère et divertissante de cette série m’a beaucoup plus et j’ai pris un immense plaisir à découvrir l’univers théâtrale d’antan en compagnie d’une troupe de troubadours aux caractères et à la construction pertinente et alléchante. Mieux encore, l’enquête en elle-même m’a paru bien plus mature et réfléchie que précédemment tant celle-ci se veut solide et aboutie. D’autant plus que cette dernière n’est avare ni en action, ni en retournements de situations et j’ai été sensible au dynamisme de ce troisième volet que je n’ai pu m’empêcher d’engloutir de part en part jusqu’à découvrir l’identité du célèbre et fameux monarque rouge.
De plus et mieux encore que l’univers en lui-même, mes trois chères sœurs ainsi que leur frère, Branwell m’ont de nouveau totalement charmé et séduit. Nous sommes bien loin de l’image assez brouillonne et hasardeuse du premier volet tant chacune d’elle se dissocie des autres et brille pour son caractère et sa personnalité bien distincts. Plus je les découvre et plus j’ai l’impression de retrouver de vieilles connaissances et ainsi, je m’attache de plus en plus à chaque membre de cette audacieuse mais aimante famille. D’autant plus que les sentiments sont au cœur de ce périple et j’ai trouvé la plume de Bella Ellis des plus sensible et touchante. Notamment en ce qui concerne Emily qui découvrira les joies et les peines des premiers émoi amoureux et alors que je l’appréciais déjà plus particulièrement, j’ai été des plus réceptif quand à l’évolution de ce personnage. C’est touché que j’ai suivi le soupçon de romance dévoilé à travers cette dernière et j’ai apprécié cette nouvelle dimension mise en avant. Ainsi et plus que n’importe quel volet et qu’il s’agisse de Charlotte, Anne ou Émilie toutes sont plus ou moins mises à nu et leur bonté ainsi que leur courage n’a cessé d’être sublimé en parallèle de ce doux et exquis écorchement. Ainsi, les liens familiaux qui unissent chacune ces dernières entre elles mais aussi à Branwell se dévoilent bien davantage développé et même si l’absence du cadre rassurant et paternel de Haworth m’a parfois manqué, j’ai adoré cette impression constante d’unité. Leur fraternité se révèle une force et celle-ci sera bien plus d’une fois mise à contribution au cours de cette course contre la montre pour sauver le mari de leur ancienne amie Lydia ayant quitté le domaine familiale pour vivre une vie de bohème. Grâce à cette dernière et aux différents protagonistes secondaires et parfaitement réalisés également, l’auteure offre une vision des conditions de vie de l’époque pour les personnages marginales et sortant des codes sociaux encadrant cette société d’antan. D’autant plus que Bella Ellis dépeint une importante toile de portraits tous plus séduisants et intriquants les uns que les autres et réservant bon nombre de surprises.
C’est pourquoi, j’ai encore bien davantage apprécié ce volet que ses prédécesseurs. En effet et au fil des tomes, la plume et le style de Bella Ellis ne cesse d’évoluer, de se perfectionner et s’affine pour s’affirmer amplement. Ainsi, l’enquête se dévoile solide, aboutie et addictive tandis que les personnes se dessinent hautement touchants et attachants. Je suis ravi de tisser de tels liens avec la famille Brontë qui ne cesse de m’épater et dont la force des sentiments se veut le véritable atout de cette équipe d’enquêteurs.
November 4, 2021
It is no secret that I am a huge fan of Rowan Coleman, and have devoured the two previous Brontë Mysteries, written by her under the name Bella Ellis. I've been looking forward to The Red Monarch for so long and I have not been disappointed in the least. In fact, I'd say that this one surpassed all of my expectations and is the best book from the series so far.
The Brontë sisters have become very good at detecting, having solved two previous cases in their home county of Yorkshire. When Anne receives a letter from former pupil Lydia Robinson, now known as Mrs Roxby after eloping and moving to London, she is very disturbed by what she reads.
Lydia is in London, she's pregnant and her her husband Harry is missing. Lydia has been told by members of the violent and very dangerous criminal gang who rule the streets of London that she has one week to return what Harry has stolen from them. Lydia has no idea what it is, or where it is. She's living a squalid room over the Adelphi theatre, far away from the comforts she was brought up in.
Anne, along with sisters Emily and Charlotte and accompanied by brother Branwell (who has his own personal interests in the Robinson family) decide that they must travel to London, to help Lydia. After misleading their father about their destination they set out for the city.
I was totally and utterly captivated by this story. Ellis has such skill with description of place and people. Her ability to bring to life the dirt and the smells of the huge city is outstanding, and her creation of character is just wonderful.
There is no doubt however, that the stars of the story are the three sisters. Each one has their own individual personality, and whilst they are totally loyal to one another, they couldn't be more different and often bicker and disagree on their plan of action.
London is a dangerous place in Victorian times, especially for three spinsters from the wilds of Yorkshire. Despite their bravery and determination to reunite Lydia and Harry, they are faced with challenges that they could never have imagined. From the lowest in society, right to the very top, they are met with violence and danger and some dark and disturbing events along the way.
What I found particularly interesting whilst reading this tale was the comparisons to social issues that are still around today. The poverty and terrible living conditions of the poor, the danger to women and young children from those who are determined to prey upon them and the utter greed and power displayed by those in the highest of places. It's convincing and adds such a depth to what is far more than a Victorian mystery story.
I was on the edge of my seat towards the end of the story, as characters were exposed and double dealings were revealed. It's intricately detailed, full of vibrant and vividly created characters and has such heart.
I loved The Red Monarch and am desperate to know what detections the sisters will attempt in the next book.
The Brontë sisters have become very good at detecting, having solved two previous cases in their home county of Yorkshire. When Anne receives a letter from former pupil Lydia Robinson, now known as Mrs Roxby after eloping and moving to London, she is very disturbed by what she reads.
Lydia is in London, she's pregnant and her her husband Harry is missing. Lydia has been told by members of the violent and very dangerous criminal gang who rule the streets of London that she has one week to return what Harry has stolen from them. Lydia has no idea what it is, or where it is. She's living a squalid room over the Adelphi theatre, far away from the comforts she was brought up in.
Anne, along with sisters Emily and Charlotte and accompanied by brother Branwell (who has his own personal interests in the Robinson family) decide that they must travel to London, to help Lydia. After misleading their father about their destination they set out for the city.
I was totally and utterly captivated by this story. Ellis has such skill with description of place and people. Her ability to bring to life the dirt and the smells of the huge city is outstanding, and her creation of character is just wonderful.
There is no doubt however, that the stars of the story are the three sisters. Each one has their own individual personality, and whilst they are totally loyal to one another, they couldn't be more different and often bicker and disagree on their plan of action.
London is a dangerous place in Victorian times, especially for three spinsters from the wilds of Yorkshire. Despite their bravery and determination to reunite Lydia and Harry, they are faced with challenges that they could never have imagined. From the lowest in society, right to the very top, they are met with violence and danger and some dark and disturbing events along the way.
What I found particularly interesting whilst reading this tale was the comparisons to social issues that are still around today. The poverty and terrible living conditions of the poor, the danger to women and young children from those who are determined to prey upon them and the utter greed and power displayed by those in the highest of places. It's convincing and adds such a depth to what is far more than a Victorian mystery story.
I was on the edge of my seat towards the end of the story, as characters were exposed and double dealings were revealed. It's intricately detailed, full of vibrant and vividly created characters and has such heart.
I loved The Red Monarch and am desperate to know what detections the sisters will attempt in the next book.
October 27, 2021
The Red Monarch - Bella Ellis
‘𝘈 𝘸𝘰𝘮𝘢𝘯 𝘪𝘯 𝘭𝘰𝘷𝘦 𝘸𝘪𝘭𝘭 𝘧𝘪𝘨𝘩𝘵 𝘵𝘰 𝘵𝘩𝘦 𝘥𝘦𝘢𝘵𝘩 𝘧𝘰𝘳 𝘵𝘩𝘦 𝘮𝘢𝘯 𝘸𝘩𝘰 𝘩𝘰𝘭𝘥𝘴 𝘩𝘦𝘳 𝘢𝘧𝘧𝘦𝘤𝘵𝘪𝘰𝘯𝘴.’
We return to another adventure with the Brontë sisters. This time they are to London, to answer a cry for help from Lydia Roxby nee Robinson. Her husband Harry is in trouble and if they don’t find a missing jewel within a week they will be killed. All this amongst the dark criminal underbelly of the Rookery and a terrifying adversary known as The Red Monarch.
‘𝘊𝘰𝘮𝘦 𝘪𝘯 𝘵𝘩𝘦𝘯, 𝘔𝘪𝘴𝘴 𝘉𝘳𝘰𝘯𝘵ë,’ 𝘓𝘰𝘶𝘪𝘴 𝘴𝘢𝘪𝘥. ‘𝘓𝘦𝘵’𝘴 𝘨𝘰 𝘢𝘯𝘥 𝘨𝘦𝘵 𝘰𝘶𝘳𝘴𝘦𝘭𝘷𝘦𝘴 𝘩𝘰𝘳𝘳𝘪𝘣𝘭𝘺 𝘮𝘶𝘳𝘥𝘦𝘳𝘦𝘥.’
The slums of London are a long way from the wild moors of Yorkshire but the sisters are determined to help Lydia in this gothic murky dark adventure for the Bronte sisters
I enjoyed reading this book with the chapters alternating between the sisters, you hear their different voices and really notice the difference between them all.
Emily, is I think my favourite sister as she is more gung - ho, but I also grew to like quiet determined Anne - she is kind and wants to save everyone. Charlotte the eldest seems to have life weighing heavy on her more than the others and Branwell seems quite hapless but loves his sisters.
‘𝘌𝘮𝘪𝘭𝘺 𝘉𝘳𝘰𝘯𝘵ë 𝘸𝘪𝘭𝘭 𝘯𝘦𝘷𝘦𝘳 𝘭𝘰𝘷𝘦, 𝘴𝘩𝘦 𝘸𝘪𝘭𝘭 𝘯𝘦𝘷𝘦𝘳 𝘱𝘪𝘯𝘦, 𝘴𝘩𝘦 𝘸𝘪𝘭𝘭 𝘯𝘦𝘷𝘦𝘳 𝘧𝘢𝘭𝘭.’
Although all the siblings are involved it felt more focussed on Emily for me and I know it is fictitious but it makes you think of them all as real people and possible events that could have affected them in their day to day lives….yes I know they didn’t really fight crime, but a fangirl can dream! They are all totally believable as amateur sleuths and the sibling relationships are brought to life through their bickering and love for each other.
‘𝘍𝘰𝘳 𝘪𝘧 𝘪𝘯 𝘢 𝘩𝘶𝘯𝘥𝘳𝘦𝘥 𝘰𝘳 𝘵𝘸𝘰 𝘩𝘶𝘯𝘥𝘳𝘦𝘥 𝘺𝘦𝘢𝘳𝘴, 𝘱𝘦𝘰𝘱𝘭𝘦 𝘴𝘵𝘪𝘭𝘭 𝘵𝘢𝘭𝘬𝘦𝘥 𝘢𝘣𝘰𝘶𝘵 𝘌𝘮𝘪𝘭𝘺 𝘉𝘳𝘰𝘯𝘵ë, 𝘵𝘩𝘦𝘯 𝘵𝘩𝘦𝘺 𝘸𝘰𝘶𝘭𝘥 𝘯𝘦𝘷𝘦𝘳 𝘵𝘳𝘶𝘭𝘺 𝘬𝘯𝘰𝘸 𝘩𝘦𝘳.’
There are ghosts, safe cracking and despair. They never falter from their mission, they are beset by danger and this is one of the biggest challenges they have yet faced. They unravel the tangle of intrigue and the murky truth when they find it is horrifying. With betrayal and vengeance and forensics…yes!! It’s a great plot, very cleverly done, loved it! It all just begs the question - what will they do next?
‘𝘔𝘢𝘳𝘷𝘦𝘭𝘭𝘰𝘶𝘴,’ 𝘌𝘮𝘪𝘭𝘺 𝘴𝘢𝘪𝘥. ‘𝘈𝘯𝘥 𝘩𝘰𝘸 𝘪𝘴 𝘵𝘩𝘢𝘵 𝘱𝘭𝘢𝘯 𝘧𝘢𝘳𝘪𝘯𝘨?’
✩✩✩✩✰
[AD PR PRODUCT]
Many thanks to Steven at Hodder Books for my copy of this book and spot on the blog tour
‘𝘈 𝘸𝘰𝘮𝘢𝘯 𝘪𝘯 𝘭𝘰𝘷𝘦 𝘸𝘪𝘭𝘭 𝘧𝘪𝘨𝘩𝘵 𝘵𝘰 𝘵𝘩𝘦 𝘥𝘦𝘢𝘵𝘩 𝘧𝘰𝘳 𝘵𝘩𝘦 𝘮𝘢𝘯 𝘸𝘩𝘰 𝘩𝘰𝘭𝘥𝘴 𝘩𝘦𝘳 𝘢𝘧𝘧𝘦𝘤𝘵𝘪𝘰𝘯𝘴.’
We return to another adventure with the Brontë sisters. This time they are to London, to answer a cry for help from Lydia Roxby nee Robinson. Her husband Harry is in trouble and if they don’t find a missing jewel within a week they will be killed. All this amongst the dark criminal underbelly of the Rookery and a terrifying adversary known as The Red Monarch.
‘𝘊𝘰𝘮𝘦 𝘪𝘯 𝘵𝘩𝘦𝘯, 𝘔𝘪𝘴𝘴 𝘉𝘳𝘰𝘯𝘵ë,’ 𝘓𝘰𝘶𝘪𝘴 𝘴𝘢𝘪𝘥. ‘𝘓𝘦𝘵’𝘴 𝘨𝘰 𝘢𝘯𝘥 𝘨𝘦𝘵 𝘰𝘶𝘳𝘴𝘦𝘭𝘷𝘦𝘴 𝘩𝘰𝘳𝘳𝘪𝘣𝘭𝘺 𝘮𝘶𝘳𝘥𝘦𝘳𝘦𝘥.’
The slums of London are a long way from the wild moors of Yorkshire but the sisters are determined to help Lydia in this gothic murky dark adventure for the Bronte sisters
I enjoyed reading this book with the chapters alternating between the sisters, you hear their different voices and really notice the difference between them all.
Emily, is I think my favourite sister as she is more gung - ho, but I also grew to like quiet determined Anne - she is kind and wants to save everyone. Charlotte the eldest seems to have life weighing heavy on her more than the others and Branwell seems quite hapless but loves his sisters.
‘𝘌𝘮𝘪𝘭𝘺 𝘉𝘳𝘰𝘯𝘵ë 𝘸𝘪𝘭𝘭 𝘯𝘦𝘷𝘦𝘳 𝘭𝘰𝘷𝘦, 𝘴𝘩𝘦 𝘸𝘪𝘭𝘭 𝘯𝘦𝘷𝘦𝘳 𝘱𝘪𝘯𝘦, 𝘴𝘩𝘦 𝘸𝘪𝘭𝘭 𝘯𝘦𝘷𝘦𝘳 𝘧𝘢𝘭𝘭.’
Although all the siblings are involved it felt more focussed on Emily for me and I know it is fictitious but it makes you think of them all as real people and possible events that could have affected them in their day to day lives….yes I know they didn’t really fight crime, but a fangirl can dream! They are all totally believable as amateur sleuths and the sibling relationships are brought to life through their bickering and love for each other.
‘𝘍𝘰𝘳 𝘪𝘧 𝘪𝘯 𝘢 𝘩𝘶𝘯𝘥𝘳𝘦𝘥 𝘰𝘳 𝘵𝘸𝘰 𝘩𝘶𝘯𝘥𝘳𝘦𝘥 𝘺𝘦𝘢𝘳𝘴, 𝘱𝘦𝘰𝘱𝘭𝘦 𝘴𝘵𝘪𝘭𝘭 𝘵𝘢𝘭𝘬𝘦𝘥 𝘢𝘣𝘰𝘶𝘵 𝘌𝘮𝘪𝘭𝘺 𝘉𝘳𝘰𝘯𝘵ë, 𝘵𝘩𝘦𝘯 𝘵𝘩𝘦𝘺 𝘸𝘰𝘶𝘭𝘥 𝘯𝘦𝘷𝘦𝘳 𝘵𝘳𝘶𝘭𝘺 𝘬𝘯𝘰𝘸 𝘩𝘦𝘳.’
There are ghosts, safe cracking and despair. They never falter from their mission, they are beset by danger and this is one of the biggest challenges they have yet faced. They unravel the tangle of intrigue and the murky truth when they find it is horrifying. With betrayal and vengeance and forensics…yes!! It’s a great plot, very cleverly done, loved it! It all just begs the question - what will they do next?
‘𝘔𝘢𝘳𝘷𝘦𝘭𝘭𝘰𝘶𝘴,’ 𝘌𝘮𝘪𝘭𝘺 𝘴𝘢𝘪𝘥. ‘𝘈𝘯𝘥 𝘩𝘰𝘸 𝘪𝘴 𝘵𝘩𝘢𝘵 𝘱𝘭𝘢𝘯 𝘧𝘢𝘳𝘪𝘯𝘨?’
✩✩✩✩✰
[AD PR PRODUCT]
Many thanks to Steven at Hodder Books for my copy of this book and spot on the blog tour
May 19, 2022
I’ve loved both of the Bella Ellis’s Brönte Mysteries series to date and the latest, ‘The Red Monarch’, is my favourite so far. If I could give it 6*, I would. It ticks so many boxes. Fast action, thoughtful detecting, literary and Brönte references, romance, the dirty violent underworld of London, dastardly baddies to defeat and wrongs to be righted.
When Lydia Roxby runs into trouble in London, she writes to her former governess Anne Brönte appealing for help. Lydia’s actor husband Harry has been imprisoned by a violent gang, accused of stealing a jewel. Heavily pregnant Lydia is given seven days to return the jewel or Harry will be killed. The four Brönte siblings rush to London and find Lydia living in an attic room at the Covent Garden Theatre, run by Harry’s father.
The first problem for the Bröntes is how to find a jewel when no information is available. Lydia knows nothing and either people are ignorant or frightened to speak. The streets around Covent Garden are run by a gangster, Noose, and his network of thugs and spies. So, naturally, the first thing the Bröntes do is seek a face-to-face meeting with Noose.
Operating out of their comfort zone but driven by a clear determination of what is right, backed up by their love for each other, Charlotte, Emily, Anne and Branwell must negotiate the danger
ous streets of the slums, adopting disguises, refusing to be cowed by threats and bluster, taking risks on who to trust. The more they find out, the clearer it is that they must confront the crime boss who terrifies everyone. But the so-called Red Monarch is so feared that no one dare say his name for fear of being overheard by one of his spies and subsequently killed as a traitor. The whole area exists in an atmosphere of fear and exploitation.
This is an original concept and a plot that, like its two predecessors, combines genres effortlessly. With witty asides and foreshadowing of the Bröntes' writings – as this novel starts, the sisters’ first edition of poetry is published – this is both familiar and unfamiliar territory. Like comfort food, but surprisingly different. As the thoughtful, literary siblings pursue criminals, we see the strengths and weaknesses of each. Who would have imagined Emily carrying a sword?
Loved it. Oh, and another beautiful cover.
Read more of my book reviews at http://www.sandradanby.com/book-revie...
When Lydia Roxby runs into trouble in London, she writes to her former governess Anne Brönte appealing for help. Lydia’s actor husband Harry has been imprisoned by a violent gang, accused of stealing a jewel. Heavily pregnant Lydia is given seven days to return the jewel or Harry will be killed. The four Brönte siblings rush to London and find Lydia living in an attic room at the Covent Garden Theatre, run by Harry’s father.
The first problem for the Bröntes is how to find a jewel when no information is available. Lydia knows nothing and either people are ignorant or frightened to speak. The streets around Covent Garden are run by a gangster, Noose, and his network of thugs and spies. So, naturally, the first thing the Bröntes do is seek a face-to-face meeting with Noose.
Operating out of their comfort zone but driven by a clear determination of what is right, backed up by their love for each other, Charlotte, Emily, Anne and Branwell must negotiate the danger
ous streets of the slums, adopting disguises, refusing to be cowed by threats and bluster, taking risks on who to trust. The more they find out, the clearer it is that they must confront the crime boss who terrifies everyone. But the so-called Red Monarch is so feared that no one dare say his name for fear of being overheard by one of his spies and subsequently killed as a traitor. The whole area exists in an atmosphere of fear and exploitation.
This is an original concept and a plot that, like its two predecessors, combines genres effortlessly. With witty asides and foreshadowing of the Bröntes' writings – as this novel starts, the sisters’ first edition of poetry is published – this is both familiar and unfamiliar territory. Like comfort food, but surprisingly different. As the thoughtful, literary siblings pursue criminals, we see the strengths and weaknesses of each. Who would have imagined Emily carrying a sword?
Loved it. Oh, and another beautiful cover.
Read more of my book reviews at http://www.sandradanby.com/book-revie...
Displaying 1 - 30 of 119 reviews