What do you think?
Rate this book
Cowboys and Angels #45
Proposal by Post
He wants someone to share his heart. She wants someone to share her life. Can two friends find true love together?
Katie “Long Shot” Dickson has to make a choice before time runs out. When a man with whom she corresponds proposes marriage, Katie’s heart tugs her toward the offer. However, tender feelings toward Judge Milton have recently emerged, and she’s torn with her decision. Should she decline the proposal and take a chance on the judge, possibly losing both?
Judge Ernest Milton is a tough man. As a circuit judge in the new state of Colorado, he travels through the mining country, dispensing justice with little time for personal commitments before moving on to the next town and case. Just as he recognizes his love for Katie, he stands to lose her to another man.
Will Ernest and Katie seize the spark between them or suffer the ache of lost love?
If you like stories of the American Wild West and Touched by an Angel, you’ll feast on this series.
Katie “Long Shot” Dickson has to make a choice before time runs out. When a man with whom she corresponds proposes marriage, Katie’s heart tugs her toward the offer. However, tender feelings toward Judge Milton have recently emerged, and she’s torn with her decision. Should she decline the proposal and take a chance on the judge, possibly losing both?
Judge Ernest Milton is a tough man. As a circuit judge in the new state of Colorado, he travels through the mining country, dispensing justice with little time for personal commitments before moving on to the next town and case. Just as he recognizes his love for Katie, he stands to lose her to another man.
Will Ernest and Katie seize the spark between them or suffer the ache of lost love?
If you like stories of the American Wild West and Touched by an Angel, you’ll feast on this series.
- GenresWestern Romance
124 pages, Kindle Edition
First published August 7, 2019
155 people are currently reading
16 people want to read
About the author
Jo Noelle
47 books334 followersThis mother/daughter writing team writes “Sweet, Swoony Ever-Afters.”
Sweet Historical Western under the name Gemma Stuart
Sweet Victorian & Regency Time Travel under the pen name Jo Noelle, who a USA TODAY bestselling author
Sweet Contemporary under the name Evee Tuttle.
They write stories about the places they’ve lived, the places they’ve visited around the world, and the places still on their bucket lists.
Follow us on Amazon, Goodreads, and Bookbub to get notices for all our new releases!
Join our Facebook Groups and chat with us and other readers who love sweet and clean romance.
• Cowboys and Angels and The Matchmaker’s Ball
• Loving Sweet Historical Romance
• Sweet Kisses Readers’ Group
• Sweet and Sassy Books Facebook Page
Sweet Historical Western under the name Gemma Stuart
Sweet Victorian & Regency Time Travel under the pen name Jo Noelle, who a USA TODAY bestselling author
Sweet Contemporary under the name Evee Tuttle.
They write stories about the places they’ve lived, the places they’ve visited around the world, and the places still on their bucket lists.
Follow us on Amazon, Goodreads, and Bookbub to get notices for all our new releases!
Join our Facebook Groups and chat with us and other readers who love sweet and clean romance.
• Cowboys and Angels and The Matchmaker’s Ball
• Loving Sweet Historical Romance
• Sweet Kisses Readers’ Group
• Sweet and Sassy Books Facebook Page
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 30 reviews
January 9, 2020
Another wonderful installment in a great multi author series.
March 11, 2024
Answering an advertisement in the newspaper led to a marriage proposal from a stranger for Katie. Torn between accepting and turning it down, Katie writes 2 letters so she would be ready to post her answer to Henry. However, Katie begins to spend a lot of time with the judge when the railroad company fails to make its payment on leasing the land for letting the train cross her property. Now, life is not as easy as it was.
Henry, however, has the same dilemma...He proposed to Catherine, but after spending time with someone else, he realizes that she may not be who God intends for him to marry.
All the CREEDE series are great but need to be read in order.
Henry, however, has the same dilemma...He proposed to Catherine, but after spending time with someone else, he realizes that she may not be who God intends for him to marry.
All the CREEDE series are great but need to be read in order.
March 13, 2022
Such a sweet story! 💞
This was such a sweet and very romantic story! Absolutely love it when an author includes what’s written in letters between the man and woman ❤️
This was such a sweet and very romantic story! Absolutely love it when an author includes what’s written in letters between the man and woman ❤️
December 23, 2022
Katie Longs for her Love
I really enjoyed this book so very much 😊 . PROPOSAL BY POST, SWEET HISTORICAL WESTERN ROMANCE. BY GEMMA STUART . I recommend teens and up .
I really enjoyed this book so very much 😊 . PROPOSAL BY POST, SWEET HISTORICAL WESTERN ROMANCE. BY GEMMA STUART . I recommend teens and up .
April 5, 2020
I really enjoyed reading the story of Katie and the Judge. It took me a little while to get into it , to make it through the layers, and then it started to make sense to me. Then I started chuckling, and you will too. There are a lot of dusty layers to go thru but funny and heartfelt. I recommend you read this book.
March 11, 2020
Two hearts met through letters
When Henry asked for a wife he didn't except it to be from Katie as she signed it catherine lee not her full name but half off her name
When Henry asked for a wife he didn't except it to be from Katie as she signed it catherine lee not her full name but half off her name
December 18, 2019
Reviewed at Keeper Bookshelf
I loved PROPOSAL BY POST so much, on several different levels. My problem is going to be saying enough about the story to give my reaction and not too much that would spoil it for future readers, for I want to talk about Ernest and Katie’s lovely romance but know to be careful with spoilers.
It’s a special touch in this series to eventually have the story of characters who have been around for a long time but in the background as secondary characters. Now it’s Judge Milton’s and Katie’s turn to shine. Answering an ad that may lead to friendship or more forms the basics of this couple’s story – but what happens when two people who have known each other for years begin to see each other in a different light. And make that discovery after corresponding with someone they might have “settled” for as a life partner even though they wouldn’t have thought “settled” at the time.
I enjoyed watching Ernest and Katie slowly see each other and watch the slow burn of their romance take place. They both have lived a full life, decidedly differently, yet finding true love for Ernest and a second chance at love for Katie is something that will draw the reader in and keep them turning pages until the end. Ernest’s guardian angel is such fun and has been on this assignment for a very long time but things are about to start hopping and Bucko couldn’t be happier about that for both of these people. I loved Katie’s gumption in taking on a, at that time, huge business and Ernest’s helping hand along the way to the resolution was perfect. I had fun with PROPOSAL BY POST, especially love seeing Seasoned Romance again entering this series because love happens every single day no matter the age and fiftyish isn’t too old to fall in love.
I’d recommend any story in the Cowboys and Angels series, but this one was very special and one you shouldn’t miss – especially if you’ve followed the series.
I read this title through my Kindle Unlimited subscription.
I loved PROPOSAL BY POST so much, on several different levels. My problem is going to be saying enough about the story to give my reaction and not too much that would spoil it for future readers, for I want to talk about Ernest and Katie’s lovely romance but know to be careful with spoilers.
It’s a special touch in this series to eventually have the story of characters who have been around for a long time but in the background as secondary characters. Now it’s Judge Milton’s and Katie’s turn to shine. Answering an ad that may lead to friendship or more forms the basics of this couple’s story – but what happens when two people who have known each other for years begin to see each other in a different light. And make that discovery after corresponding with someone they might have “settled” for as a life partner even though they wouldn’t have thought “settled” at the time.
I enjoyed watching Ernest and Katie slowly see each other and watch the slow burn of their romance take place. They both have lived a full life, decidedly differently, yet finding true love for Ernest and a second chance at love for Katie is something that will draw the reader in and keep them turning pages until the end. Ernest’s guardian angel is such fun and has been on this assignment for a very long time but things are about to start hopping and Bucko couldn’t be happier about that for both of these people. I loved Katie’s gumption in taking on a, at that time, huge business and Ernest’s helping hand along the way to the resolution was perfect. I had fun with PROPOSAL BY POST, especially love seeing Seasoned Romance again entering this series because love happens every single day no matter the age and fiftyish isn’t too old to fall in love.
I’d recommend any story in the Cowboys and Angels series, but this one was very special and one you shouldn’t miss – especially if you’ve followed the series.
I read this title through my Kindle Unlimited subscription.
September 6, 2019
Great Story Telling Us About Previous Characters
This is the 45th book in the Cowboys and Angels series. Now we hear the story about Katie 'Long Shot' Dickson and Judge Ernest Milton. They have been secondary characters in previous books and are older than the typical main characters for stories in this genre. A nice addition of this series is there is a guardian angel who guides the couple together. This guardian angel has been on duty for 30 years. The author intertwined interesting passages from Christian teachings and she included many characters from previous stories in this series and some likely to appear in future stories.This is a great series.
This is the 45th book in the Cowboys and Angels series. Now we hear the story about Katie 'Long Shot' Dickson and Judge Ernest Milton. They have been secondary characters in previous books and are older than the typical main characters for stories in this genre. A nice addition of this series is there is a guardian angel who guides the couple together. This guardian angel has been on duty for 30 years. The author intertwined interesting passages from Christian teachings and she included many characters from previous stories in this series and some likely to appear in future stories.This is a great series.
August 9, 2019
Love my mail
Katie is lonely and writes to Henry and develops feelings for Henry but an old friend Ernest shows up in town. Ernest stirs feelings in Katie and it makes her wonder about her relationship with Henry. Ernest has a romance he's writing to also and proposes marriage to his correspondence romance interest. As he waits for a reply, he realizes his deep feelings for Katie. Should he have waited to propose? There are interesting things going on in Katie's life that make for a fun and entertaining story.
Katie is lonely and writes to Henry and develops feelings for Henry but an old friend Ernest shows up in town. Ernest stirs feelings in Katie and it makes her wonder about her relationship with Henry. Ernest has a romance he's writing to also and proposes marriage to his correspondence romance interest. As he waits for a reply, he realizes his deep feelings for Katie. Should he have waited to propose? There are interesting things going on in Katie's life that make for a fun and entertaining story.
August 7, 2019
I really enjoyed reading this book,
from the very first pages to the last.
Proposal By Post is a feel-good
& moving romance.
Love has no age limit.
Delightful characters & small town
charm, make it the perfect read.
Ernest & Katie, steal your heart.
I loved everything about this Must
Read Story!!
from the very first pages to the last.
Proposal By Post is a feel-good
& moving romance.
Love has no age limit.
Delightful characters & small town
charm, make it the perfect read.
Ernest & Katie, steal your heart.
I loved everything about this Must
Read Story!!
August 8, 2019
What's in a name
Catherine is Katie and Henry is his middle name. They've known each other forever, but they really don't know each other. He's had an angel for thirty years! This is the best Credentials story ever!! He's handsome and a judge. She's beautiful and self sufficient. Together they can take on the world.
Catherine is Katie and Henry is his middle name. They've known each other forever, but they really don't know each other. He's had an angel for thirty years! This is the best Credentials story ever!! He's handsome and a judge. She's beautiful and self sufficient. Together they can take on the world.
September 14, 2019
Sweet
Catherine answered an add Henry placed looking for a wife and companion. Things were moving forward with their communication and looking promising. However, they both had revelations that they had strong feelings for someone other than the one they were writing to and had to do a great deal of thinking and praying and listening so they could each make a good decision.
Catherine answered an add Henry placed looking for a wife and companion. Things were moving forward with their communication and looking promising. However, they both had revelations that they had strong feelings for someone other than the one they were writing to and had to do a great deal of thinking and praying and listening so they could each make a good decision.
August 7, 2019
Loved it.
Great love story between an older couple. That's not usual in romance novels but I really enjoyed it. The angel plays a fairly big role in this book and I found his interactions quite funny and endearing. Highly recommended.
Great love story between an older couple. That's not usual in romance novels but I really enjoyed it. The angel plays a fairly big role in this book and I found his interactions quite funny and endearing. Highly recommended.
August 8, 2019
Loved this Book.
Such a wonderful book, it was exciting and fun, Ernest and Katie enjoyed each other's company and each had someone they were writing to. Sweet and Wonderful, Thank you Jo Noelle.
Such a wonderful book, it was exciting and fun, Ernest and Katie enjoyed each other's company and each had someone they were writing to. Sweet and Wonderful, Thank you Jo Noelle.
August 8, 2019
Proposal by Post( Cowboys and Angels)
What a delightful book. I enjoyed every sentence.
It brought back many characters from former books. which I love as a tie in, but Bucko was a hoot especially at the ball. I hope to read more of these characters in future books.
What a delightful book. I enjoyed every sentence.
It brought back many characters from former books. which I love as a tie in, but Bucko was a hoot especially at the ball. I hope to read more of these characters in future books.
August 11, 2019
Another great story!!
Judge Milton/Earnest/Henry-ready for a wife
Catherine/Katie- owns land that part of the railroad rents.
I enjoyed reading this engaging story that is well written with vibrant characters and a witty angel. Their story has a wonderful HEA!
Judge Milton/Earnest/Henry-ready for a wife
Catherine/Katie- owns land that part of the railroad rents.
I enjoyed reading this engaging story that is well written with vibrant characters and a witty angel. Their story has a wonderful HEA!
August 10, 2019
A truly wonderful read!
This is honestly one of my favorite Cowboys and Angels stories. Watching Katie and Ernest navigate the twists and turns was fun and had me smiling and laughing too! Wonderful plot, well crafted and delivered! Thank you!
This is honestly one of my favorite Cowboys and Angels stories. Watching Katie and Ernest navigate the twists and turns was fun and had me smiling and laughing too! Wonderful plot, well crafted and delivered! Thank you!
August 12, 2019
Outstanding Story!
Out of all 45 Cowboys And Angels books, to date, I think this is my favorite! It was so enjoyable to read a story about an older couple finding a special love later in life.
Shows that love can be found at all ages!
Out of all 45 Cowboys And Angels books, to date, I think this is my favorite! It was so enjoyable to read a story about an older couple finding a special love later in life.
Shows that love can be found at all ages!
August 20, 2019
I loved the characters
Katie is a strong woman with a sharp mind, she has a lot of friends and isn't afraid of hard work.
Judge Milton has an angel with him where ever he goes. The judge writes an ad for a a mail order bride.
Katie is a strong woman with a sharp mind, she has a lot of friends and isn't afraid of hard work.
Judge Milton has an angel with him where ever he goes. The judge writes an ad for a a mail order bride.
September 1, 2019
Finding love isn't just for the young
I'm a widow in my fifties who appreciates stories about those in their more senior years finding love. Thanks to this writing team for creating such a sweet love story for Katie and Ernest.
I'm a widow in my fifties who appreciates stories about those in their more senior years finding love. Thanks to this writing team for creating such a sweet love story for Katie and Ernest.
November 26, 2019
Katie and Ernest
Adventurous and fun story of Katie and the Judge. Katie and Steffen have a dance then a rodeo and a trial against the railroad. Falling in love was between all of those! - Babs
Adventurous and fun story of Katie and the Judge. Katie and Steffen have a dance then a rodeo and a trial against the railroad. Falling in love was between all of those! - Babs
August 8, 2019
Great Historical Series
Another great book in a great series. I loved Katie and Ernest's story and all the characters. I look forward to more books in the series.
Another great book in a great series. I loved Katie and Ernest's story and all the characters. I look forward to more books in the series.
August 11, 2019
Wonderful book.
August 10, 2019
Wonderful book!
Loved this book and this story. The angel in this book was a fun character. I love this book and this series.
Loved this book and this story. The angel in this book was a fun character. I love this book and this series.
August 11, 2019
Oh so good!
The judge and Katie will make a great team. So g
Ad it turns out that way! Or does it? Maybe Catherine and Henry should be together! Loved Bucko
The judge and Katie will make a great team. So g
Ad it turns out that way! Or does it? Maybe Catherine and Henry should be together! Loved Bucko
August 13, 2019
Awesome book!
A great story of redemption and the love of a strong woman. The dual romance was sweet. I also enjoyed the angel who was with him for thirty years.
A great story of redemption and the love of a strong woman. The dual romance was sweet. I also enjoyed the angel who was with him for thirty years.
August 14, 2019
this is a sweet story about middle age people finding love again. a good story, i was given a copy of the book but this is an honest review
August 20, 2019
Heart warming
Lovely tale of Love found in the Silver Years. Intrigue, Mystery and Love what a combination.
You will love this story.
Lovely tale of Love found in the Silver Years. Intrigue, Mystery and Love what a combination.
You will love this story.
October 21, 2019
Very good story!
November 9, 2019
Proposal by Post (Cowboys and Angels Book 45)
This is the forty fifth book in this series about angels in creede and finding love and happiness for their assignments
This is the forty fifth book in this series about angels in creede and finding love and happiness for their assignments
Displaying 1 - 30 of 30 reviews