What do you think?
Rate this book
On Central Park #1
The Metropolitan Affair
For years her explorer father promised Dr. Lauren Westlake she'd accompany him on one of his Egyptian expeditions. But as the empty promises mounted, Lauren determined to earn her own way. Now the assistant curator of Egyptology for the Metropolitan Museum of Art, Lauren receives two unexpected invitations.
The first is her repentant father's offer to finally bring her to Egypt as his colleague on a new expedition. The second is a chance to enter the world of New York's wealthiest patrons who have been victims of art fraud.
With Egyptomania sweeping the city after the discovery of King Tut's tomb, Detective Joe Caravello is on the hunt for a notorious forger preying on the open wallets of New York's high society. Dr. Westlake is just the expert he needs to help him track the criminal. Together they search for the truth, and the closer Lauren and Joe get to discovering the forger's identity, the more entangled they become in a web of deception and crime.
In this rich 1920s tale, bestselling author Jocelyn Green invites you into one of New York City's most esteemed museums, where a young woman discovers secrets, betrayal, and romance.
The first is her repentant father's offer to finally bring her to Egypt as his colleague on a new expedition. The second is a chance to enter the world of New York's wealthiest patrons who have been victims of art fraud.
With Egyptomania sweeping the city after the discovery of King Tut's tomb, Detective Joe Caravello is on the hunt for a notorious forger preying on the open wallets of New York's high society. Dr. Westlake is just the expert he needs to help him track the criminal. Together they search for the truth, and the closer Lauren and Joe get to discovering the forger's identity, the more entangled they become in a web of deception and crime.
In this rich 1920s tale, bestselling author Jocelyn Green invites you into one of New York City's most esteemed museums, where a young woman discovers secrets, betrayal, and romance.
384 pages, Kindle Edition
First published March 14, 2023
190 people are currently reading
7207 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 470 reviews
March 2, 2023
The Metropolitan Affair is the third book I've read by Jocelyn Green, and it's definitely my favorite.
I enjoyed getting to know Joe and Lauren and found them both to be sympathetic, well-developed characters. Joe's and Lauren's professions were each interesting in their own right, and I liked how they intersected due to the plot. I wasn't aware people in the 1920s were so fascinated by Egypt. Which brings me to the research ... It was obvious (and impressive) how much research Jocelyn Green did while writing this book. But while everything was well researched, I wasn't subjected to historical info dumps that would take away from the plot and slow my reading.
The plot contained lots of twists and turns I didn't see coming and kept me flipping pages. I did think this book could've been a little bit shorter, but that's a personal gripe. Long books and I have a bit of an interesting relationship. I appreciated the themes of family, second chances, and God's love. I'm also glad Jocelyn Green kept the romance sweet and clean. I'm looking forward to continuing the series when the next book is released!
Overall, I enjoyed reading The Metropolitan Affair and would recommend it to those who love Christian fiction and historical novels with a touch of romance.
Disclosure: I received this book free from Bethany House through Interviews & Reviews. The opinions I have expressed are my own, and I was not required to write a positive review. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255.
I enjoyed getting to know Joe and Lauren and found them both to be sympathetic, well-developed characters. Joe's and Lauren's professions were each interesting in their own right, and I liked how they intersected due to the plot. I wasn't aware people in the 1920s were so fascinated by Egypt. Which brings me to the research ... It was obvious (and impressive) how much research Jocelyn Green did while writing this book. But while everything was well researched, I wasn't subjected to historical info dumps that would take away from the plot and slow my reading.
The plot contained lots of twists and turns I didn't see coming and kept me flipping pages. I did think this book could've been a little bit shorter, but that's a personal gripe. Long books and I have a bit of an interesting relationship. I appreciated the themes of family, second chances, and God's love. I'm also glad Jocelyn Green kept the romance sweet and clean. I'm looking forward to continuing the series when the next book is released!
Overall, I enjoyed reading The Metropolitan Affair and would recommend it to those who love Christian fiction and historical novels with a touch of romance.
Disclosure: I received this book free from Bethany House through Interviews & Reviews. The opinions I have expressed are my own, and I was not required to write a positive review. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255.
March 18, 2023
Story Enjoyment Rating: 9/10 Christian Faith Rating: 2/3
I really enjoyed reading The Metropolitan Affair. It is a Christian historical mystery and suspense/romance.
I requested a copy from Netgalley, and Bethany House kindly gave me an advanced ebook copy. I believe the book releases on the 14th of March 2023.
The story follows Dr Lauren Westlake, an Egyptologist working at the Metropolitan Museum in New York in 1925. She had a difficult relationship with her father growing up and always wanted to go to Egypt with him.
At the beginning of the book, Lauren’s father gave her the opportunity to go on an expedition with him. However, to do this, she must prove herself to the board of his newly formed society. At the same time, she also met up with Joe, an old friend who was a detective with the NYPD. He asked her to help him find Egyptian forgeries which were being sold to wealthy people in New York.
The book followed both Lauren’s and Joe’s perspectives. The narrative focused on the criminal investigation of tracking down forgers. It also spent time showing the development of Lauren's relationships with her father, Joe, her work colleagues and her flatmates.
I loved the characters and the emotional complications that arose from the plot. I also loved the mystery — some of which I predicted, but many other events and revelations I did not see coming.
There were only a few references to the Christian faith in this book. However, those parts were strong and gave a good message, which I appreciated.
I would like to continue with this series in the future.
(Content — the romance is clean, the mystery contains a small amount of violence.)
I really enjoyed reading The Metropolitan Affair. It is a Christian historical mystery and suspense/romance.
I requested a copy from Netgalley, and Bethany House kindly gave me an advanced ebook copy. I believe the book releases on the 14th of March 2023.
The story follows Dr Lauren Westlake, an Egyptologist working at the Metropolitan Museum in New York in 1925. She had a difficult relationship with her father growing up and always wanted to go to Egypt with him.
At the beginning of the book, Lauren’s father gave her the opportunity to go on an expedition with him. However, to do this, she must prove herself to the board of his newly formed society. At the same time, she also met up with Joe, an old friend who was a detective with the NYPD. He asked her to help him find Egyptian forgeries which were being sold to wealthy people in New York.
The book followed both Lauren’s and Joe’s perspectives. The narrative focused on the criminal investigation of tracking down forgers. It also spent time showing the development of Lauren's relationships with her father, Joe, her work colleagues and her flatmates.
I loved the characters and the emotional complications that arose from the plot. I also loved the mystery — some of which I predicted, but many other events and revelations I did not see coming.
There were only a few references to the Christian faith in this book. However, those parts were strong and gave a good message, which I appreciated.
I would like to continue with this series in the future.
(Content — the romance is clean, the mystery contains a small amount of violence.)
May 7, 2023
Another absolute page turner by one of my favorite authors! Jocelyn Green has a gift for immersing readers in a world of impeccable history; and this time it’s New York City in the 1920s, when the graft and corruption of Prohibition is overshadowed by a new kind of crime in art fraud. I was fascinated to learn about “Egyptomania,” a craze that strikes the city with the arrival of rare Egyptian artifacts that are coveted by New York’s richest. No price seems too high until the buyers become victims of forgeries. As New York Met Museum’s Egyptologist Dr. Lauren Westlake and NYPD Detective Joe Caravello draw closer to discovering who’s behind the phony art, they learn some hard truths about themselves, in matters of love, family, and forgiveness. Compelling, emotional, Green's newest kept me up way past my bedtime reading to see how things would turn out!
February 6, 2023
The Metropolitan Affair was quite possibly—and most definitely—my favorite of all Jocelyn Green’s books!
This book had such rich historical detail about Egyptology, and it was fascinating learning more about artifacts and what makes them genuine or counterfeit. It’s quite obvious the author invested a ton of time into making this plot thread accurate, insightful, and engaging!
Also, the themes in this book were powerful. How do we keep from building up walls and shutting out those we love when we’ve been hurt in our past? How do we trust those who have deeply let us down? How do we let go of what we hoped would come about that never did? Those questions are powerful themes in the story, and if you’ve ever had a broken relationship, especially with a parent, that was never mended, this book might really meet you where you are.
I adored the characters, and I was rooting for Lauren and Joe’s romance pretty much from the first scene we see them together. Their romance was so sweet and intentional, and I absolutely loved it.
My only complaint is that sometimes the narrating style felt a bit more contemporary than historical, at least to me. But beyond that, I loved this book!!
All in all, The Metropolitan Affair is a lovely book and I’d absolutely reread it again! Thank you to NetGalley and the author for an eARC. A positive review was not required, only my honest opinion. All thoughts are expressly my own.
This book had such rich historical detail about Egyptology, and it was fascinating learning more about artifacts and what makes them genuine or counterfeit. It’s quite obvious the author invested a ton of time into making this plot thread accurate, insightful, and engaging!
Also, the themes in this book were powerful. How do we keep from building up walls and shutting out those we love when we’ve been hurt in our past? How do we trust those who have deeply let us down? How do we let go of what we hoped would come about that never did? Those questions are powerful themes in the story, and if you’ve ever had a broken relationship, especially with a parent, that was never mended, this book might really meet you where you are.
I adored the characters, and I was rooting for Lauren and Joe’s romance pretty much from the first scene we see them together. Their romance was so sweet and intentional, and I absolutely loved it.
My only complaint is that sometimes the narrating style felt a bit more contemporary than historical, at least to me. But beyond that, I loved this book!!
All in all, The Metropolitan Affair is a lovely book and I’d absolutely reread it again! Thank you to NetGalley and the author for an eARC. A positive review was not required, only my honest opinion. All thoughts are expressly my own.
January 8, 2023
What a richly layered story. Set in the 20s in New York City, the heroine, Dr. Lauren Westlake, is an Egyptologist at the height of public fascination with Egypt thanks to King Tut. A woman ahead of her time, she just wants to preserve the past thorugh her work and make it understandable. But then an old friend asks her to help identify forgeries. Detective Joe Caravello is determined to bring those behind the forgeries to justice, but finds a devious web of deceit and layers that put others at risk. Add Lauren's father appearing and this is a book I inhaled in two days. Highly recommend for lovers of atmospheric historical novels laced with romance.
June 20, 2023
1925-1926 New York. This book will surprise you, The Metropolitan Affair is a stunning story, of strength, complex relationships, and the little details that made the story so rich in historical reference..... Stunning Cover!
"With Egyptomania sweeping the city after the discovery of King Tut's tomb, Detective Joe Caravello is on the hunt for a notorious forger preying on the open wallets of New York's high society. Dr. Lauren Westlake is just the expert he needs to help him track the criminal. Together they search for the truth, and the closer Lauren and Joe get to discovering the forger's identity, the more entangled they become in a web of deception and crime."
Intriguing-Mystery-Romance, and a little bit of danger. The romance was heartwarming and sweet, loved how Lauren meets again with her first love Joe, for a second chance to love
A dramatic, gripping, and emotional read, which certainly kept me guessing and which kept me on the edge of my seat. Characters dealing with past hurts, broken relationships, and how to trust again.
The Metropolitan is superbly written, Jocelyn Green has an easy-going writing style, that is easy to get used to and easy to get along with, the author knows how to grab the readers' attention and draw them into what proves to be one heck of a story. For me, the story hit the ground running and maintain a study pace throughout. I loved most all the characters and the way in which they interacted with each other. I would definitely recommend this book to other readers. I will certainly be reading more of Jocelyn Green's work in the future.
Clean Read, kissing only but nothing further.
Thank you, NetGalley and Bethany House for this stunning eARC. A positive review was not required, only my honest opinion. All thoughts are expressly my own.
"With Egyptomania sweeping the city after the discovery of King Tut's tomb, Detective Joe Caravello is on the hunt for a notorious forger preying on the open wallets of New York's high society. Dr. Lauren Westlake is just the expert he needs to help him track the criminal. Together they search for the truth, and the closer Lauren and Joe get to discovering the forger's identity, the more entangled they become in a web of deception and crime."
Intriguing-Mystery-Romance, and a little bit of danger. The romance was heartwarming and sweet, loved how Lauren meets again with her first love Joe, for a second chance to love
A dramatic, gripping, and emotional read, which certainly kept me guessing and which kept me on the edge of my seat. Characters dealing with past hurts, broken relationships, and how to trust again.
The Metropolitan is superbly written, Jocelyn Green has an easy-going writing style, that is easy to get used to and easy to get along with, the author knows how to grab the readers' attention and draw them into what proves to be one heck of a story. For me, the story hit the ground running and maintain a study pace throughout. I loved most all the characters and the way in which they interacted with each other. I would definitely recommend this book to other readers. I will certainly be reading more of Jocelyn Green's work in the future.
Clean Read, kissing only but nothing further.
Thank you, NetGalley and Bethany House for this stunning eARC. A positive review was not required, only my honest opinion. All thoughts are expressly my own.
March 10, 2023
This is a beautiful cover and was so excited to get an ARC. I gave this a 4.5⭐️ and I need you to understand that I love museums and this was all things museums. If you haven’t been to one lately you need to go. I love historical finds and the artifacts and or finds of Egypt.
Lauren was an expert in her field and she was smart with a beautiful spirit. Joe was honorable and held true to his responsibilities that I found so charming. This mystery, historical romance was memorable and I highly recommend it. It was good.
Thanks Bethany House and Jocelyn Green via NetGalley. I really enjoyed it.
Lauren was an expert in her field and she was smart with a beautiful spirit. Joe was honorable and held true to his responsibilities that I found so charming. This mystery, historical romance was memorable and I highly recommend it. It was good.
Thanks Bethany House and Jocelyn Green via NetGalley. I really enjoyed it.
Read
May 4, 2023I'm always amazed by how much research Jocelyn Green does for the books she writes for us! And she weaves all of the bits and pieces of history into her stories so well, bringing us novels that feel true to life and deeply grounded in place. She did it all again with The Metropolitan Affair. Of course she did. She's consistently excellent.
March 21, 2023
This cozy mystery is set in 1920s New York. Lauren Westlake is an Egyptologist who works at the Metropolitan Museum of Art. She is the daughter of acclaimed archaeologist Lawrence Westlake, who spent most of Lauren's life working on his career and not his relationship with his daughter. But now he's back and wants to get closer by having Lauren join him on a dig in Egypt. Then Lauren is approached by old friend/beau Joe Caravello, a police detective. He suspects a ring of forgers is selling fake Egyptian artifacts. Will Lauren help him?
What a great cozy read! This is the first book in the On Central Park series by Jocelyn Green. The descriptions of 1920s New York, especially of Central Park and the Museum, bring the city and that time period to life. The author's research into Egyptology was extremely thorough, as the main character's knowledge of the subject is extensive. The reader learns so much about Egyptian artifacts and how to tell a fake. Lauren's struggles in her relationship with her father are heartbreaking and real. Her relationship with Joe is a refreshing break from the constant disappointment she suffers at the hands of her father. The mystery is complex and includes plenty of red herrings.
This is great historical fiction with engaging, interesting characters and a lesson in Egyptology. I highly recommend this novel to cozy mystery lovers and those interested in Egyptian artifacts. The Christian messages include faith and forgiveness.
I received a free copy of this book from Bethany House. My review is voluntary and the opinions expressed are my own.
What a great cozy read! This is the first book in the On Central Park series by Jocelyn Green. The descriptions of 1920s New York, especially of Central Park and the Museum, bring the city and that time period to life. The author's research into Egyptology was extremely thorough, as the main character's knowledge of the subject is extensive. The reader learns so much about Egyptian artifacts and how to tell a fake. Lauren's struggles in her relationship with her father are heartbreaking and real. Her relationship with Joe is a refreshing break from the constant disappointment she suffers at the hands of her father. The mystery is complex and includes plenty of red herrings.
This is great historical fiction with engaging, interesting characters and a lesson in Egyptology. I highly recommend this novel to cozy mystery lovers and those interested in Egyptian artifacts. The Christian messages include faith and forgiveness.
I received a free copy of this book from Bethany House. My review is voluntary and the opinions expressed are my own.
May 6, 2023
1925 New York City
For the love of history! Fascinating historical details about Egyptian artifacts.
My favorite character was lawman Joe. He had a big heart and stood for what was right.
For the love of history! Fascinating historical details about Egyptian artifacts.
My favorite character was lawman Joe. He had a big heart and stood for what was right.
April 8, 2023
4.5⭐
A Dr. of Egyptology finds herself in peril while working with her ex boyfriend on a case to find Egypt artifacts that have been possibly faked. Along with finding her father coming back into her life unexpectedly to make amends in her life, she gets more than she bargained for.
I really liked the characters in this story. The Buzzword Egypt is definitely what drew me in as I love a good mystery set around Egypt and its culture. The ending went totally in the opposite direction I thought it was going though. I can't wait to find out what happens in the next book of the series.
Thank you to Baker Publishing and #bethanyhouse for a copy of this book to read and review.
A Dr. of Egyptology finds herself in peril while working with her ex boyfriend on a case to find Egypt artifacts that have been possibly faked. Along with finding her father coming back into her life unexpectedly to make amends in her life, she gets more than she bargained for.
I really liked the characters in this story. The Buzzword Egypt is definitely what drew me in as I love a good mystery set around Egypt and its culture. The ending went totally in the opposite direction I thought it was going though. I can't wait to find out what happens in the next book of the series.
Thank you to Baker Publishing and #bethanyhouse for a copy of this book to read and review.
April 22, 2023
⭐⭐⭐⭐
Once upon a time, I read a book by Jocelyn Green. I’d expected it to be atmospheric and romantic and intriguing—a bit like a Laura Frantz novel—but to me, it didn’t hit the mark. So every time since then, when Green releases a new book, I shy away, even though I’ve never heard a negative thing about her work.
Well, folks, I succumbed to the peer pressure this time and I gave her a second chance. And boy, am I glad I did!
The Metropolitan Affair was so much better than I anticipated. The premise was fascinating and the plot flowed so well (although I personally think the ending was rushed). I was kept on my toes the whole time and my curiosity was thoroughly piqued. The research was impeccable, and the niche history was so intriguing. I felt like I’d been transported into the world of my childhood, where I read Tut’s Mummy: Lost...and Found by Judy Donnelly on my laundry room floor and watched Night at the Museum twenty times in a row. Even though I’m not quite so captivated by Egyptology, I was entirely captivated by this novel, and it wasn’t just the insane plot twists that held my attention.
The real shocker, though?
I actually liked Lauren.
*collective gasp rings out*
Lauren managed to be an intelligent woman in a “male-dominated profession” without being the stereotypical heavy-handed, entitled, annoying “strong female lead.” In fact, she was soft and compassionate and gentle and kind—all those biblical characteristics that matter more than one’s degree or position. Not to mention, her emotional journey and depth wasn’t sacrificed in favor of making her a bad-butt. Rather, I felt connected to her and her thoughts, and whatever she felt (particularly in correlation with her father), I felt as well. I was rooting for her the whole way.
As for Joe, of course I appreciated him. He was a doll. Strong and levelheaded while also being caring and self-sacrificing. But the best part? He was an Italian cop in New York. *chef’s kiss* I am a huge sucker for Italians.
Their romance was a sweet and subtle second chance romance that I actually enjoyed. (Yes, I’ve been known to imbibe in second chances every now and then. Kell, you oughta be proud. 😉) It wove into the plot perfectly, along with the characters’ growth and development. Both were a tasteful compliment to the plot, giving it a character-driven quality while retaining that sense of mystery and action.
Speaking of subtlety...the faith message in this story was very light but still so impactful. I was a bit unsure at first with how subtle it was, but when the theme was wrapped up in the end, it really hit home! Subtlety isn’t always the best route, but when you do it, this is how you do it.
Once upon a time, I picked up my second book by Jocelyn Green, and I felt in love. I eagerly await my next read by her!
Disclaimer: I received a complimentary review copy of this book from the publisher. All opinions expressed are my own.
Once upon a time, I read a book by Jocelyn Green. I’d expected it to be atmospheric and romantic and intriguing—a bit like a Laura Frantz novel—but to me, it didn’t hit the mark. So every time since then, when Green releases a new book, I shy away, even though I’ve never heard a negative thing about her work.
Well, folks, I succumbed to the peer pressure this time and I gave her a second chance. And boy, am I glad I did!
The Metropolitan Affair was so much better than I anticipated. The premise was fascinating and the plot flowed so well (although I personally think the ending was rushed). I was kept on my toes the whole time and my curiosity was thoroughly piqued. The research was impeccable, and the niche history was so intriguing. I felt like I’d been transported into the world of my childhood, where I read Tut’s Mummy: Lost...and Found by Judy Donnelly on my laundry room floor and watched Night at the Museum twenty times in a row. Even though I’m not quite so captivated by Egyptology, I was entirely captivated by this novel, and it wasn’t just the insane plot twists that held my attention.
The real shocker, though?
I actually liked Lauren.
*collective gasp rings out*
Lauren managed to be an intelligent woman in a “male-dominated profession” without being the stereotypical heavy-handed, entitled, annoying “strong female lead.” In fact, she was soft and compassionate and gentle and kind—all those biblical characteristics that matter more than one’s degree or position. Not to mention, her emotional journey and depth wasn’t sacrificed in favor of making her a bad-butt. Rather, I felt connected to her and her thoughts, and whatever she felt (particularly in correlation with her father), I felt as well. I was rooting for her the whole way.
As for Joe, of course I appreciated him. He was a doll. Strong and levelheaded while also being caring and self-sacrificing. But the best part? He was an Italian cop in New York. *chef’s kiss* I am a huge sucker for Italians.
Their romance was a sweet and subtle second chance romance that I actually enjoyed. (Yes, I’ve been known to imbibe in second chances every now and then. Kell, you oughta be proud. 😉) It wove into the plot perfectly, along with the characters’ growth and development. Both were a tasteful compliment to the plot, giving it a character-driven quality while retaining that sense of mystery and action.
Speaking of subtlety...the faith message in this story was very light but still so impactful. I was a bit unsure at first with how subtle it was, but when the theme was wrapped up in the end, it really hit home! Subtlety isn’t always the best route, but when you do it, this is how you do it.
Once upon a time, I picked up my second book by Jocelyn Green, and I felt in love. I eagerly await my next read by her!
Disclaimer: I received a complimentary review copy of this book from the publisher. All opinions expressed are my own.
March 14, 2023
I have read and loved several of Jocelyn Green's books and this is definitely one of my favorites. She has proven that she is a master storyteller, adept at switching from one historical setting to another with ease.
In The Metropolitan Affair, she has penned an outstanding blend of history, mystery and romance. I adored this story set in Prohibition era NYC. With a hero who is solving crime within the dangerous mafia world of speakeasies and a heroine who is an expert on Egyptian antiquities. I found the characters well-written and engaging. They combine their talents to undercover the identity of a forger that might have connections in the art world as well as the underworld of organized crime. Joe is a true hero, a man of integrity, in pursuit of justice. Lauren is a successful Egyptologist who has spent her lifetime seeking her father's approval and love.
With a well-paced plot, I found myself glued to the pages, intrigued not only by the mystery but by the fascinating details of Egypt and its antiquities that Ms. Green wove throughout the story. This is also a story of grief and loss, of family and faith. Looking forward to reading more books in this series.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the author/publisher through Netgalley and was not required to write a review. All opinions expressed are my own.
In The Metropolitan Affair, she has penned an outstanding blend of history, mystery and romance. I adored this story set in Prohibition era NYC. With a hero who is solving crime within the dangerous mafia world of speakeasies and a heroine who is an expert on Egyptian antiquities. I found the characters well-written and engaging. They combine their talents to undercover the identity of a forger that might have connections in the art world as well as the underworld of organized crime. Joe is a true hero, a man of integrity, in pursuit of justice. Lauren is a successful Egyptologist who has spent her lifetime seeking her father's approval and love.
With a well-paced plot, I found myself glued to the pages, intrigued not only by the mystery but by the fascinating details of Egypt and its antiquities that Ms. Green wove throughout the story. This is also a story of grief and loss, of family and faith. Looking forward to reading more books in this series.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the author/publisher through Netgalley and was not required to write a review. All opinions expressed are my own.
April 17, 2023
I love Jocelyn Green novels but…
This one wasn't my favorite. It has all the elements of a great book but something was missing. It felt clunky and slow. I knew “whodunit” a loooong time before it was revealed and Joe, for being such a great detective, was super slow on the uptake, in a really unbelievable way.
I also felt like there was so much tell and not enough show. One example: we were just told how Joe and Lauren had already fallen in love and had been such good friends. There was almost no tension between them. There was especially a lot of retelling around telephone calls. Something would happen and then it would skip ahead and then all of the sudden insert “she told him all this on the telephone” to try to bridge the gap. It happened so many times that it started to grate. In addition, for me the long descriptions of the locations detracted from the story. I know it is supposed to immerse you in 20's NY and all that but it just felt like a guidebook rather than world-building. This author is usually much, much better at balancing that.
Jocelyn Green is one of my most favorite authors so maybe my expectations were too high or maybe she struggled writing this and I can just feel it. I wonder if the 20s is just too modern because I felt it in her Chicago series, too. Just less tension and less compelling writing overall.
Lastly, I wish it had stated explicitly how Jesus redeems us. How God loves his children and redeems them is seen foremost in the sending of Jesus and his work on the cross. I think there’s one line that alludes to it and one comment on redemption-but of what?? How??
Overall: is it a bad book? No. Could it have been better? Definitely.
This one wasn't my favorite. It has all the elements of a great book but something was missing. It felt clunky and slow. I knew “whodunit” a loooong time before it was revealed and Joe, for being such a great detective, was super slow on the uptake, in a really unbelievable way.
I also felt like there was so much tell and not enough show. One example: we were just told how Joe and Lauren had already fallen in love and had been such good friends. There was almost no tension between them. There was especially a lot of retelling around telephone calls. Something would happen and then it would skip ahead and then all of the sudden insert “she told him all this on the telephone” to try to bridge the gap. It happened so many times that it started to grate. In addition, for me the long descriptions of the locations detracted from the story. I know it is supposed to immerse you in 20's NY and all that but it just felt like a guidebook rather than world-building. This author is usually much, much better at balancing that.
Jocelyn Green is one of my most favorite authors so maybe my expectations were too high or maybe she struggled writing this and I can just feel it. I wonder if the 20s is just too modern because I felt it in her Chicago series, too. Just less tension and less compelling writing overall.
Lastly, I wish it had stated explicitly how Jesus redeems us. How God loves his children and redeems them is seen foremost in the sending of Jesus and his work on the cross. I think there’s one line that alludes to it and one comment on redemption-but of what?? How??
Overall: is it a bad book? No. Could it have been better? Definitely.
![Profile Image for Jasmine (Jazzie) [Jesus Loves You!!].](/_next/image?url=https%3A%2F%2Fi.gr-assets.com%2Fimages%2FS%2Fcompressed.photo.goodreads.com%2Fusers%2F1766755819i%2F174090398._UX200_CR0%2C4%2C200%2C200_.jpg&w=128&q=75)
January 4, 2023
I have been reluctant to see Green's novels turn from Chicago to New York, a city I hold much less affection for, and was even more dismayed to see another novel featuring Egyptology, a field that interests me not at all.
Yet despite all of that, The Metropolitan Affair contains very realistic characters that held me captive and a plot that kept me turning pages. Jocelyn never writes stories with neat bows; sometimes things don't turn out the way you hoped, even though the ending is satisfying.
I liked policeman Joe, and was uncertain about Lauren, a female PhD in academia, but thankfully feminism wasn't one of the main messages of the book (relieved because of how overdone and tired that line is). Not too much is said about faith throughout the story, but the end held a moment of reckoning between the character and God. I think people who do and who don't want a very religious book could be pretty content here.
I enjoyed it more than I thought I would, because Green is a fantastic storyteller with attention to detail.
I read a copy provided by Netgalley and the publisher so I could write an honest review, but all opinions are my own.
Yet despite all of that, The Metropolitan Affair contains very realistic characters that held me captive and a plot that kept me turning pages. Jocelyn never writes stories with neat bows; sometimes things don't turn out the way you hoped, even though the ending is satisfying.
I liked policeman Joe, and was uncertain about Lauren, a female PhD in academia, but thankfully feminism wasn't one of the main messages of the book (relieved because of how overdone and tired that line is). Not too much is said about faith throughout the story, but the end held a moment of reckoning between the character and God. I think people who do and who don't want a very religious book could be pretty content here.
I enjoyed it more than I thought I would, because Green is a fantastic storyteller with attention to detail.
I read a copy provided by Netgalley and the publisher so I could write an honest review, but all opinions are my own.
April 25, 2023
Interesting mystery with lots of great information about ancient Egypt. This story was WAY too long for what it was and despite its being set in 1920s New York, only a few references make it feel that way; this could have been set in any time period. The characters were OK; there wasn’t much character development but where the story lacked in development, it made up for it in the intrigue surrounding the artifacts. Unfortunately, it took way too long to get there. This story dragged in the beginning and only picked up after over halfway through. I may read the next one but it won’t be for a while.
May 12, 2024
4.75 stars! Really enjoyed this one!
March 12, 2023
This book was fantastic. It brought back memories of visiting the Field Museum in Chicago. One of my favorite exhibits was Egyptian artifacts.
The story was informative and spellbinding from the first glimpse of the Metropolitan Museum to the dramatic conclusion.
Ms. Green made me care about Lauren, her grief surrounding her mother and the complicated relationship with her father.
The details of uncovering forgeries were so interesting. “If you become an expert on the real thing, you will know the counterfeit when you see it.” This goes for antiquities and also for reading people and their motives.
When Detective Joe Caravello enlists the help of longtime friend, Lauren, they quickly renew their friendship. It is significant that they met at the Museum as children and many places there hold fond memories.
The story is filled with unique characters, some based on real people. The author has given Joe a warm, loving family that Lauren found missing in her own life. She tried to please her father but was chasing after a false love. Then she realized the true love God had for her.
A riveting book from a remarkable storyteller.
*I received a complimentary copy of this book from Bethany House Reviewers program. I was not required to post a favorable review. All opinions are my own.*
The story was informative and spellbinding from the first glimpse of the Metropolitan Museum to the dramatic conclusion.
Ms. Green made me care about Lauren, her grief surrounding her mother and the complicated relationship with her father.
The details of uncovering forgeries were so interesting. “If you become an expert on the real thing, you will know the counterfeit when you see it.” This goes for antiquities and also for reading people and their motives.
When Detective Joe Caravello enlists the help of longtime friend, Lauren, they quickly renew their friendship. It is significant that they met at the Museum as children and many places there hold fond memories.
The story is filled with unique characters, some based on real people. The author has given Joe a warm, loving family that Lauren found missing in her own life. She tried to please her father but was chasing after a false love. Then she realized the true love God had for her.
A riveting book from a remarkable storyteller.
*I received a complimentary copy of this book from Bethany House Reviewers program. I was not required to post a favorable review. All opinions are my own.*
February 3, 2023
“I’ve learned many things from Egyptology, not the least of which is the idea that what we do in this life matters in the next. That we should be preparing ourselves for what comes after. Death isn’t the end of life—it’s really the beginning of our eternity.”
“Ancient history isn’t the only past worth preserving.”
“Do not fear, for I have redeemed you; I have summoned you by name; you are mine.”
What can I say about this book except it was outstanding. This is my second book by Jocelyn Green and I am a big fan of her Christian historical fiction. I have always been interested in archaeology and Egypt so this book was perfect in learning more. Although this book focuses more on the museum aspect with artifacts, and not the archaeological dig part, it was still all fascinating and interesting. And Green is a master at writing descriptive scenes that will transport you to another time and place.
I really loved the characters in this book. Dr. Lauren Westlake was both well written as well as a sympathetic, relatable character. I could feel her struggle as she sought the approval of an earthly father. And Detective Joe Caravello was awesome. He was a man whose moral compass pointed true north as he pursued truth and justice. I liked the interactions between Joe and Lauren. I loved the setting in New York in 1925/1926 and it makes me want to visit the Metropolitan Museum of Art.
The mystery aspect was also really good. Murder (more on that later) as well as the forgery of ancient artifacts. Very unique and very well executed. And it isn’t just a mystery that deals with Egyptology. It is also a story about family, pain, loss, and trying to gain love and approval from another. And most importantly, drawing closer to our Heavenly Father.
One thing that I really loved about this book is that Jocelyn Green made me a character that was killed off in this book. For real! I had volunteered myself through Facebook and she agreed to have a Wade Martin character murdered. Quite the experience coming across my name in the book. But don’t worry; even if my name was not in this book, this is still an awesome book. Easy 5 stars.
I received this book free from Netgalley and publisher Bethany House in exchange for an honest review.
“Ancient history isn’t the only past worth preserving.”
“Do not fear, for I have redeemed you; I have summoned you by name; you are mine.”
What can I say about this book except it was outstanding. This is my second book by Jocelyn Green and I am a big fan of her Christian historical fiction. I have always been interested in archaeology and Egypt so this book was perfect in learning more. Although this book focuses more on the museum aspect with artifacts, and not the archaeological dig part, it was still all fascinating and interesting. And Green is a master at writing descriptive scenes that will transport you to another time and place.
I really loved the characters in this book. Dr. Lauren Westlake was both well written as well as a sympathetic, relatable character. I could feel her struggle as she sought the approval of an earthly father. And Detective Joe Caravello was awesome. He was a man whose moral compass pointed true north as he pursued truth and justice. I liked the interactions between Joe and Lauren. I loved the setting in New York in 1925/1926 and it makes me want to visit the Metropolitan Museum of Art.
The mystery aspect was also really good. Murder (more on that later) as well as the forgery of ancient artifacts. Very unique and very well executed. And it isn’t just a mystery that deals with Egyptology. It is also a story about family, pain, loss, and trying to gain love and approval from another. And most importantly, drawing closer to our Heavenly Father.
One thing that I really loved about this book is that Jocelyn Green made me a character that was killed off in this book. For real! I had volunteered myself through Facebook and she agreed to have a Wade Martin character murdered. Quite the experience coming across my name in the book. But don’t worry; even if my name was not in this book, this is still an awesome book. Easy 5 stars.
I received this book free from Netgalley and publisher Bethany House in exchange for an honest review.
Read
October 19, 2022from endorsement
Impeccably researched and electrically told, The Metropolitan Affair is all of my catnip: mystery, romance and a beguiling 1920's museum setting underscored by the fascinating pulse of Egyptomania.
A splendid and fascinating world is captured both in the Golden Age of the Met and through Green's marvellously painted New York. With a dash of Elizabeth Peters' Amelia Peabody and sure to delight fans of Miss Fisher's Murder Mysteries, The Metropolitan Affair finds Jocelyn Green at the top of her game as one of the reigning queens of inspirational fiction.
Impeccably researched and electrically told, The Metropolitan Affair is all of my catnip: mystery, romance and a beguiling 1920's museum setting underscored by the fascinating pulse of Egyptomania.
A splendid and fascinating world is captured both in the Golden Age of the Met and through Green's marvellously painted New York. With a dash of Elizabeth Peters' Amelia Peabody and sure to delight fans of Miss Fisher's Murder Mysteries, The Metropolitan Affair finds Jocelyn Green at the top of her game as one of the reigning queens of inspirational fiction.
February 19, 2023
I really enjoyed this historical mystery! Ancient Egypt has always fascinated me, and this story surrounding Egyptian artifacts was so interesting. The characters were great and the story kept me engaged to the very end.
March 12, 2025
Why did I wait so long to read this?! The experience was magical.
Green layered the story is such a way that each chapter brought new revelations and twists, completely engaging my attention. It’s woven together with Joe & Lauren’s personal lives, their history, and their present feelings. It’s their families’ drama/loss/strained relationships. It’s a string of Egyptian forgeries. Joe’s partner incarceration. 1920s Prohibition. So many threads richly nuanced that add a layer of intrigue to the bigger picture. I was loathe to have to put it down when I had to break for real life duties!
Anything Egyptology has a way to my heart where my previous teen self can geek out to her heart’s content, and I’m always so fascinated by the history & intricacies of the culture. I absolutely loved the post-WW1 vibes and the cultural/societal carry over it brought into the ‘20s, including an honest nod to the economic ruin of Germany and many Americans distrust of Germans.
Joe & Lauren’s relationship felt like a privilege to read about. It’s second chance but not in a “you broke my heart once, now we get a second try,” but in a “the timing wasn’t right for us the first time but I’ve always loved you” sort of way. They’re older now (33 & 35), they know what they want and can communicate maturely. It was also such a respectful romance built on mutual trust and friendship without physical attraction being overly mentioned.
There were a few twists that made me sad, and rightly so. But I loved the closing message about feeling a Father’s love and how the failure of our earthly fathers shouldn’t keep us from the love our perfect Father in heaven.
I’m so excited to have book 2 on hand because I need more of this world asap!!
Green layered the story is such a way that each chapter brought new revelations and twists, completely engaging my attention. It’s woven together with Joe & Lauren’s personal lives, their history, and their present feelings. It’s their families’ drama/loss/strained relationships. It’s a string of Egyptian forgeries. Joe’s partner incarceration. 1920s Prohibition. So many threads richly nuanced that add a layer of intrigue to the bigger picture. I was loathe to have to put it down when I had to break for real life duties!
Anything Egyptology has a way to my heart where my previous teen self can geek out to her heart’s content, and I’m always so fascinated by the history & intricacies of the culture. I absolutely loved the post-WW1 vibes and the cultural/societal carry over it brought into the ‘20s, including an honest nod to the economic ruin of Germany and many Americans distrust of Germans.
Joe & Lauren’s relationship felt like a privilege to read about. It’s second chance but not in a “you broke my heart once, now we get a second try,” but in a “the timing wasn’t right for us the first time but I’ve always loved you” sort of way. They’re older now (33 & 35), they know what they want and can communicate maturely. It was also such a respectful romance built on mutual trust and friendship without physical attraction being overly mentioned.
There were a few twists that made me sad, and rightly so. But I loved the closing message about feeling a Father’s love and how the failure of our earthly fathers shouldn’t keep us from the love our perfect Father in heaven.
I’m so excited to have book 2 on hand because I need more of this world asap!!
August 17, 2023
Such a beautifully crafted story! The characters have real psychological depth to them, too, especially Lauren and her relationship with her parents. That relationship arch was both realistic and redemptive. I love Lauren and Joe’s occupations and how committed and well suited they are to their work. Joe’s parents are dear as are Lauren’s roommates. It seems like we may get Elsa and Ivy’s stories in Books 2 & 3, and I am here for it! The Egyptian and Prohibition angles of the story are very well researched and keep the mystery thread of the story moving along. I thought the romance was delightful. It was understated but in a positive way. I love that it is Persuasion-like with the two leads meeting again after many years. The story of how they first met is adorable. The New York setting is lovely too. So many good elements to this novel and they all blend together into a wonderfully moving story and a compelling mystery.
June 20, 2023
Jocelyn Green's books never disappoint, and The Metropolitan Affair was no exception! Rife with intrigue, mystery, and Eqyptian artifacts, this 1920s tale is not one to miss!
August 10, 2024
I really enjoyed this book. I thought it was paced well, and both main characters (Lauren and Joe) were immediately likeable. I also enjoyed the overall mystery that was going on, but my sleuthing skills were off by a smidge on whodunnit.
I also appreciated the faith element, though it was subtle until the end (which, when you read it, you'll understand why).
4.5 stars
I also appreciated the faith element, though it was subtle until the end (which, when you read it, you'll understand why).
4.5 stars
September 5, 2023
Jocelyn Green knows how to write a captivating story! Complete with historical richness and a plot that kept me turning pages, The Metropolitan Affair was an absolute treat to read. I loved the time period and connected with the characters . . . and I'm already eager for her next novel!
April 3, 2023
What a great new read by author Jocelyn Green! Definitely kept me thoroughly engaged throughout. Loved how the story centered around The Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York City in the 1920s. A new-to-me setting for sure! Green’s research really shines through in this tale. Mystery, family, relationships, romance, art history, as well as the history of the 20s era, including new-to-me Egyptology. A little bit of everything! A great read and highly recommended.
September 14, 2025
Blog Post: https://fictionwithphoebe.com/the-met...
4.5 stars
Pretty much all my knowledge of Egyptian history comes from high school history classes 😅 So it was interesting to get a more in-depth look into ancient Egypt, as well as learn about “Egyptomania.” However the information didn’t feel forced, thanks to the forgery storyline.
Lauren and Joe are one of my favorite couples! I loved how much they respected and supported each other.
They also balanced each other out, which came in handy during their investigation. (Lauren is diplomatic and tactful, while Joe is more blunt and direct. Joe is distrustful. Lauren sees the best in others, but can be a little naive.)
Joe and Lauren’s backstories explained a lot of their present personalities and outlooks. The fears that kept them from pursuing a romantic relationship were completely understandable.
And as bittersweet as it was, I appreciated how Jocelyn Green handled Lauren’s relationship with her father.
The next book in this fascinating series will feature Lauren’s cousin and roommate Elsa, an ornithologist.
Favorite Moments
🐪 Lauren tying Joe’s bow tie
🐪 the gala
🐪 “as guardian of your well-being”
🐪 ice skating
🐪 “Capisce? Capisco”
🐪 “a tour of our Metropolitan affair”
Content Notes:
death of a parent from illness (mentioned), mention of guns and shooting, mention of a seance, noticing and awareness, kissing, touching, alcohol consumption, mention of women being assaulted, mention of war, mentions of various crimes, blood, mention of (partially nude) gods and goddesses, mention of miscarriages, death of a baby (mentioned), mention of swearing and filthy talk (“fudge”), mention of “floozies,” mention of a woman’s curves and figure, murder, suspicions of infidelity, description of a dying man (not overly graphic)
4.5 stars
Pretty much all my knowledge of Egyptian history comes from high school history classes 😅 So it was interesting to get a more in-depth look into ancient Egypt, as well as learn about “Egyptomania.” However the information didn’t feel forced, thanks to the forgery storyline.
Lauren and Joe are one of my favorite couples! I loved how much they respected and supported each other.
They also balanced each other out, which came in handy during their investigation. (Lauren is diplomatic and tactful, while Joe is more blunt and direct. Joe is distrustful. Lauren sees the best in others, but can be a little naive.)
Joe and Lauren’s backstories explained a lot of their present personalities and outlooks. The fears that kept them from pursuing a romantic relationship were completely understandable.
And as bittersweet as it was, I appreciated how Jocelyn Green handled Lauren’s relationship with her father.
The next book in this fascinating series will feature Lauren’s cousin and roommate Elsa, an ornithologist.
Favorite Moments
🐪 Lauren tying Joe’s bow tie
🐪 the gala
🐪 “as guardian of your well-being”
🐪 ice skating
🐪 “Capisce? Capisco”
🐪 “a tour of our Metropolitan affair”
Content Notes:
death of a parent from illness (mentioned), mention of guns and shooting, mention of a seance, noticing and awareness, kissing, touching, alcohol consumption, mention of women being assaulted, mention of war, mentions of various crimes, blood, mention of (partially nude) gods and goddesses, mention of miscarriages, death of a baby (mentioned), mention of swearing and filthy talk (“fudge”), mention of “floozies,” mention of a woman’s curves and figure, murder, suspicions of infidelity, description of a dying man (not overly graphic)
August 11, 2023
Books should come with warning labels if a major plot point involves attempts to reconcile with some clearly horrible parent. I also think books with big Christian themes should make that obvious on the cover- it would be a marketing point for many, and then readers like me would not be unpleasantly surprised when the key to happiness is revealed as trusting in God’s love. Big mismatch between Pok and reader here.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 470 reviews