Identical twins Della and Darby Redd confound everyone with their differences instead of their likeness. Della, college-educated and vibrant, makes purple her signature color and, at 29, still works hard at fitting in. Even though the people of Clay Station, Mississippi, can’t seem to overlook the sins of her mother and delight in exacting revenge on Della and Darby.
Darby keeps her head down and seems content living in her own small world—working at a pill bottle factory and hanging out in her bedroom at home. As an introvert, she doesn’t see the need to expand her horizons or worry much about what others think. She wishes Della would return to Chattanooga and her circle of friends instead of settling for a dead-end job as a receptionist at a doctor’s office.
Both girls live with Birdie, their maternal grandmother, and the woman who raised them after their mother’s tragic death. Most people in town would consider their mother’s death a blessing and the circumstances a tragedy for the rest of the town. Birdie can’t forgive herself for her mistakes as a parent and wants nothing more than for Della and Darby to find happiness. But it looks like a losing battle.
When Della and Birdie decide to throw a 30th birthday bash for the sisters, Darby has her doubts. Della fantasizes about showing up with her suddenly-in-love-with-her boss and finding redemption in the town’s eyes after 25 years of ridicule and bullying.
When a new employee at the factory starts pestering Darby with unwanted friendship, Darby struggles to know how to react. Even worse, her unasked-for friend, Cliff, tells her about a sting operation involving Della’s boss. When Darby shares the information with Della, she fears she may have pushed her sister out of her life for good.
What I Loved About this Book
While the subtitle proclaims Della and Darby is a novel about sisters, it could just as easily be subtitled ‘a novel about regrets.’ We all have them, and we often forget how we deal with them has a ripple effect that touches other people’s lives.
Another possible subtitle, ‘a novel of blindness,’ works, too. We all have a blind side to our characters where we buy into false narratives—victim, introvert, failure as a parent, or extrovert. Della, Darby, and Birdie show us how false narratives can take over our lives and trap us in places we never want to go.
Told from multiple points of view (Della’s, Darby’s, and Birdie’s), I found it sometimes painful to enter Della’s point of view. Her desperation to fit in made me ache physically. Birdie’s point of view made me examine my parenting failures and how I grieve and move on (or don’t).
But most of all, Della and Darby helped me understand and have compassion for those on the margins. We each have beautiful, painful, intriguing, and heart-rending stories which shape us. The world would be better if we took the time to explore, listen more, and judge less.