3.8 stars.
This book made me reflect on what i loved and loathed about Singapore-writing. I found all of these aspects in this book.
These stories' common Singaporeanity are intended to raise questions about (you guessed it!!) How We Live Now in Singapore.
So - i quite liked this collection. I was pleasantly surprised to find I liked almost every story. I only despised 2 stories. This is rare for the few Singanthologies I've read.
The stories I loved most snagged my imagination with a shard of Singapore. Some small, lived moment.They made me ache quietly, with words and meanings that hung unsaid, or only half-spoken.
Jinny Koh's "Close to Home", though heavily described at the start, ended on a very wrenching note. I also liked very much Dave Chua's "Fireworks", about (in part) all the unspoken things left unsaid between fathers and their daughters.
Yeoh Jo-Ann's very weird The Thing, unexplained and just sitting there all on its own, really made me appreciate the value of letting some images just sit/hang/float there, unexplained and unexplainable.
Rachel Heng's "After the Valley", about growing old alone or with friends in an old folks' home was also quietly wrenching.
Karen Kwek's "Night Fishing" conjured up scenes of older, wilder Singapore coastlines; its vivid, strangely ambiguous ending ended on the book on a powerful note.
But some stories also made me go, YUCK.
Should I be Understanding and say: oh maybe they were written in diff contexts so we we shouldn't be too harsh...Ok, there: I have said it.
Now, let me say that I despise writers who preach to me. Use a lecture or soapbox, maybe. Don't use a story to preach your naked opinions at me. I'm here for story, not sermon.
And don't use stale animal tropes to do it. Especially, don't resort to Merlions or Tigers. It is often clumsy and probably very insulting to the animals involved.
Also, PLEASE don't tell me about how Banal, Unimaginative, and Materialistic Singaporeans are!
That just SCREAMS to me how banal, unimaginative, and materialistic of a writer YOU are!!
If you have an urge to rant abt the Gahmen, young condo buyers, head over to Facebook!! Please don't inflict unsuspecting readers with your opinions!!
Yet - only 2 stories made me roll my eyes. The other 8 in this collection were all solid pieces in their own way, lovingly and thoughtfully crafted.
3.8/5 majulahs 🇸🇬