Fifth Avenue Glamour Girl, by Renée Rosen
2.5 Stars
Renée Rosen's Fifth Avenue Glamour Girl had a lot of promise with its intriguing premise and historical setting, but it ultimately fell short in its execution. This book is a mixed bag, and I would recommend it primarily to those curious about Estée Lauder or those who enjoy stories set in 1930s and 1940s New York. However, for most readers, it might be an underwhelming and unsatisfying experience.
The Good
Rosen does a wonderful job evoking the atmosphere of the historical period. The novel is rich with details that bring the 1930s to life, like the language of the time and everyday objects, such as the term ‘taxicab’ or even a vending machine of the era. These small touches made the setting feel authentic and immersive.
The themes of independence, ambition, perseverance, and friendship are strong points. Our protagonist, Gloria, and Estée Lauder herself, rise to success through their own intelligence and hard work, which is both empowering and refreshing, especially against the backdrop of 1930s and 1940s sexism.
Additionally, seeing the industry divas interact adds a layer of fun to the narrative.
The Not So Good
Despite the vibrant setting and themes, the characters, especially our protagonist Gloria, remain somewhat flat. Gloria's struggle with her past and her issues with her father is a central aspect of her character, yet it sees little development throughout the story. Her circumstances change dramatically, but her character doesn't evolve much until the very end, making her journey feel stagnant.
The Bad
The weakest aspect of this novel is its plot. The story unfolds in a chronological manner without much narrative drive or suspense. Major events happen, but they lack the buildup and impact needed to keep the reader engaged. The plot elements tied to character development only surface towards the very end, making the overall experience feel monotonous. I often had to push myself to keep reading, which is not the sign of a compelling narrative.
Overall, Fifth Avenue Glamour Girl wasn't a particularly enjoyable read for me. It has its moments and interesting characters (Soda Pop, here’s a shout out to you!), but the lack of dynamic character development and a well-crafted plot made it a struggle to get through. If you're a fan of historical fiction or enjoy stories about the cosmetic industry's pioneers, you might find some value in this book. However, I suspect many readers will find it lacking in engagement and depth.
Criteria:
2.5 Stars: A 2.5-star rating indicates a book that straddles the middle ground. It had elements that I appreciated, such as an engaging premise or some well-crafted characters, but it didn't quite come together as a cohesive whole. The book may have been enjoyable in parts, yet it lacked the consistency in quality or impact to push it into the higher rating categories. This rating is for books that I'm ambivalent about – neither regretting the time spent reading nor feeling compelled to recommend them enthusiastically.