The coming of Carnage! When Venom’s offspring transforms psychopath Cletus Kasady into a symbiotic serial killer, Peter Parker makes the hardest decision of his life — and turns to Venom for help! But will Eddie Brock join the fight…or continue his single-minded mission to squash Spider-Man? Plus: Spider-Man enters the Lizard’s lair — and faces a powerful enemy alongside the New Warriors! And when Spidey is haunted by Kraven the Hunter, can he save the soul of his fiercest foe? Then, when familiar faces make a startling return, Spidey must investigate a painful piece of his past — assuming he can get through Taskmaster and the Red Skull!
COLLECTING: Amazing Spider-Man (1963) 361-367, Amazing Spider-Man Annual (1964) 26, Amazing Spider-Man: Soul of the Hunter (1992) 1; material from Spectacular Spider-Man Annual (1979) 12, Web of Spider-Man Annual (1985) 8, New Warriors Annual (1991) 2
Some decent stories for the 90s, brought down by a very bad set of annuals that take up way too much space.
Carnage (ASM 361-363). Carnage is such a 1990s concept for a villain: he's not just a villain! He's a serial killer! But still it was a pretty big innovation, a step beyond the already insane Venom. And it's carried off well here: Carnage seems generally dangerous-scary. A solid intro [4/5].
The Hero Killers (1992 SM + NW Annuals). 1992 was a bad year for Marvel annuals, and "The Hero Killers" is Exhibit A. That year, every set of annuals was grouped into a set of 4 that might or might not be related. So, the three Spider-Man titles got grouped with the New Warriors for a pointless fight with The Living Pharaoh. I felt like comics generally have a problem with pacing when they run these extra-long stories, but the year of four made it even worse because you actually get four extra-long stories making up a single storyline. That means so, so, so much pointless fighting. There's almost no characterization here, very little joy of a unique team-up, and pretty much no attention to the supporting castl As a result, "The Hero Killers" is entirely skippable and that's deadly for a serialized art form like comics. [1/5]
Soul of the Hunter. A sequel to Kraven's Last Hunt. This one is much more spectacle than its predecessor, but it's interesting, philosophical spectacle that acknowledges that some of Spider-Man's experience can damage Peter. (And that offers a really nice coda to Kraven given the manner of his death. Overall, a nice piece, though a quick read. [4/5]
The 30th Anniversary (ASM 364-367). A nice lead-up to the 30th with good one-off stories of Shocker and Lizard which both acknowledge the evolution of the characters. However the big event is the return of Peter's parents. The Red Skull arc that ends things is a nice way to deal with. Overall, an intriguing read, even decades later! (Though I'm annoyed the issue of the parents isn't fully dealt with, but that's what we ask for in serials, after all.) [4/5]
I enjoyed this collection much more than the rating might suggest, the problem is though i really did not like the JM DeMatteis/Mike Zeck Kraven follow up at all. Maybe it was because it just didnt seem to fit in with what was going on in the main series but I dont think so. It started off with an atrocious use of the spider sense... if it worked how it is suggested it does in the early pages of the graphic novel then Parker would have had a mental breakdown years ago, the spider sense would be going off all the time. I really do not know how this not only got written but also got past an editor.
This is such a random hodgepodge of different stories from 1992 that it’s rather hard to give a blanket recommendation or turn-away.
Soul of the Hunter is great, Bagley’s art is classic, and Michelinie’s storytelling is generally fine. The storyline that threads through the annuals, though, is dull and generic. Some of the mainline ASM stories in the latter half of the book also feel a bit too much like filler.
So, depending on what you’re looking for (and whether or not you’d rather just get Soul of the Hunter by itself), you may find something of real value here.