Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

The Misadventures of Margaret Finch

Rate this book
Blackpool, 1938. Miss Margaret Finch - a rather demure young woman - has just begun work in a position that relies on her discretion and powers of observation. Then, her path is crossed by the disgraced Rector of Stiffkey (aka Harold Davidson), who is the subject of a national scandal.

Margaret is determined to discover the truth behind the headlines: is Davidson a maligned hero or an exploiter of the vulnerable? But her own troubles are never far away, and Margaret's fear that history is about to repeat itself means she needs to uncover that truth urgently.

This deeply evocative novel ripples with the tension of a country not yet able to countenance the devastation of another war. Margaret walks us along the promenade, peeks into the baths and even dares a trip on the love boat in this, her first seaside summer season, on a path more dangerous than she could ever have imagined.

320 pages, Hardcover

First published April 4, 2023

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Claire McGlasson

2 books22 followers
Claire is a journalist who works for ITV News Anglia and enjoys the variety of life on the road with a TV camera. Her role gives her access to high-profile interviewees, and takes her behind-the-scenes at places that she’d never ordinarily get to go. But the biggest privilege of her job is spending time with people at the very best, and very worst, times of their lives and helping them to tell their stories. She lives in Cambridgeshire with her favourite people – her husband, daughter and son.

Her first novel, THE RAPTURE, which is based on true events in an Edwardian women’s cult, was published by Faber in Spring 2019. McGlasson’s debut novel about a real-life cult, set in 1920s England, is being turned into a television series after Hillbilly Television optioned the rights.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
62 (15%)
4 stars
154 (37%)
3 stars
151 (37%)
2 stars
35 (8%)
1 star
4 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 92 reviews
Profile Image for Ceecee .
2,955 reviews2,477 followers
March 12, 2023
Blackpool. 1938

Margaret Finch is a clever but unremarkable young woman which is perfect for the job she is currently doing as it relies on her powers of observation without drawing attention to herself. One assignment leads to a tricky situation and a surprise but welcome rescue. Her path has crossed that of the disgraced and defrocked former Rector of Stiffkey (Norfolk), Harold Davidson, whose church trial has hit the headlines in a big way. Is he a victim of a campaign against him or as the church maintains an exploiter of those that are vulnerable? Davidson is in Blackpool seeking support and understanding of his plight. Margaret is determined to investigate and try to get to the truth but her own many issues and troubles may be her undoing.

This is a really different and colourful historical fiction and although Margaret herself is fictional, much here is grounded in fact such as the Davidson case and the research Margaret is engaged in for the ‘Mass Observation’ project. Margaret is complex, she’s self conscious, misunderstood and misjudged especially within her own family where adverse judgement is inevitably swift to follow. She is immensely likeable despite her awkwardness and the effect the Davidson case has on her. Her character fits with the context of the times and the position of women. Harold Davidson is an intriguing conundrum and his case is that of historical fact being stranger than fiction. It’s well worth reading up about him! It’s certainly a colourful tale!

The book is steeped in atmosphere, Blackpool with its many attractions comes alive as mill workers pour in for wakes weeks to let their hair down on The Golden Mile, the Pleasure Beach or the world famous Tower Ballroom. Margaret observes all as these holiday makers relax and have fun and through this Margaret comes to many a realisation about herself and the wrongness of what she’s doing. Descriptions here are rich, lively and you can easily picture them as the as the author captures the people as they wander from entertainment to entertainment. It’s gleeful, lurid, a bit vulgar but great fun. In the background but increasingly in awareness is the spectre of war and the growing realisation that this is inevitable.

Overall, I really enjoy this well written novel which transports you to the coast where you meet intriguing characters and in the case of Margaret, she shakes off the past and discovers exactly who she is. Recommended if you want to read some well researched HF that’s a bit different from the norm.

With thanks to NetGalley and especially to Faber and Faber for the much appreciated arc in return for an honest review.
Profile Image for Fay Flude.
761 reviews42 followers
April 12, 2023
I usually avoid novels with an historical basis as I am an ignoramus, purporting to not be the slightest bit interested in world events. I just think dates, battles and the Church.
However, via Pigeonhole, I have slowly expanded my repertoire of reading material, choosing to read some historical books if the facts are based on social history.
Margaret Finch and her misadventures falls neatly into this category as author Claire McClasson has skilfully woven facts from the 1930's and 1927, with fictional but beautifully drawn characters to create a kaleidoscope of truth and imagination. The reader can experience what it was like to be a woman in 1930s England and how Mass Observation of social classes on holiday really did take place.
The events are entertaining and as we journey with a rather repressed Margaret we are given the same opportunity she is to reconsider our views of other people and their behaviours.
Interesting, gentle and rather enjoyable.
Profile Image for Mrs.
227 reviews2 followers
Read
May 23, 2024
LOVED this.
Set in the leadup to WW2, misfit lead character, bit of linguistics, Mass Observation, class, stories based on real events, the seaside.
Margaret escapes her unhappy home with a job in Blackpool, researching the behaviour of the working classes on holiday for Mass Observation. She comes across Rev Harold Davidson, Rector of Stiffkey, who is trying to raise money to clear his name by turning himself in to a sideshow. Incredibly, his part of the story is true.
I loved how Margaret’s character developed, how she learnt more about herself, and managed to change the parts of her she didn’t like while retaining her individuality. Great ending.
Profile Image for Hannah.
Author 0 books5 followers
February 22, 2026
4+ stars. An enjoyable read. The author's style is reminsicent of Claire Chambers and, similarly, this novel is rooted in real-life events. I had never heard of Mass Observation before reading this book, nor the disgraced Rector of Stiffkey, but am glad I have learnt about them. The characters are well-rounded, and the writing evocative.
461 reviews4 followers
September 22, 2023
What an unusual idea for a book! Works very well and, apart from the fascinating storyline, is full of interest for anyone familiar with the Wakes Weeks when whole swathes of north west towns took the train to Blackpool for their annual holiday. Felt very authentic.
Profile Image for Nicola Smith.
1,210 reviews43 followers
April 8, 2023
The Misadventures of Margaret Finch. First of all, what a title! That was what drew me in initially: what has Margaret Finch been up to? Then I read the synopsis, and the setting of 1930s Blackpool and a Mass Observation project had me really intrigued.

Margaret is there to observe holidaymakers' habits and dialects, to see what they eat, which activities they choose to do and so on, and it turns out she's rather good at the stealth observations and making detailed notes for her research. Through her work she meets Harold Davidson, the defrocked Rector of Stiffkey and she finds herself drawn into his case, trying to work out whether he's really guilty or not.

Margaret is an unusual character and her time in Blackpool led to what I felt were quite unexpected situations for a well-brought up girl in 1938, but I think it was a sort of rebellion for her and a gradual understanding of the kind of life she really wanted.

Where this book excels for me is the sense of time and place, the carefree holiday destination for so many families but with the prospect of war looming over them. I loved Margaret's exchanges with her landlady, and I particularly liked her interactions with her colleague, James. Sometimes I felt quite frustrated with Margaret but then I remembered that she had lived a fairly sheltered life and had very bravely set off for a new experience and a role that was very important to her.

Some of the book is based on fact and Harold Davidson did really exist. They say the truth is stranger than fiction and his story is quite bizarre and fascinating. I thought this was quite a quirky read, which took me a little settling into whilst I got a handle on Margaret and where the story was going, but which drew me in and got me really interested in the characters and the lives they were leading.
Profile Image for ✰matthew✰.
882 reviews
September 27, 2023
i have mixed feelings about this book. i really enjoyed the parts about mass observation and any scenes with james, as well scenes about the seaside as it was then.

learning about blackpool in the 30’s and how it was then, and all about the mass observation programme was super interesting to me, i would personally have liked more information and time spent discussing this.

the parts with the rector weren’t as enjoyable for me and i recognise this was an important part of the book but it didn’t add anything for me.

in some parts the narrative seemed to stumble and struggle with where it was going, some of the scenes in pubs for example.

the past could maybe have done with a bit more exploration as i think this could open up the conversation about some events that happen later on in the book.
Profile Image for Lana Levy.
77 reviews
February 10, 2024
Sadly I didn’t love this book, although some of the character relationships and the observations made were quite charming. I felt it lacked some of the humour that could have made the narrative arc more enjoyable to experience as a reader. That being said, it had a certain peculiar nature to it that was quite interesting.
Profile Image for Mike Riley.
55 reviews
August 25, 2023
Nice story with lots of depth and interest. I can’t wait for the authors next work.
Profile Image for Rae.
4,105 reviews
Read
July 3, 2024
Blackpool 1938. Mass Observation. Harold Davidson. Complicated protagonist. A slow burn and rather boring at times.
Profile Image for Grace J .
2,137 reviews106 followers
March 28, 2023
A very different type of read - but no less interesting!

Margaret Finch is 'in digs' in Blackpool as she works at her job. This is a novel which keeps it's cards close to it's chest; the story unravels slowly and enticingly. I wasn't exactly sure what Margaret was up to to begin with, but she is studious and methodical about her job, rarely interacting with her colleagues except for James, the man in charge of them all. As things proceed, we discover more about Margaret and her family life and I was most definitely on her side from there on in. A good read, true to the period and one which held my interest all the way to the very satisfying ending. 4*.
Profile Image for Ruby.
143 reviews8 followers
April 6, 2023
Margaret Finch is a researcher living in Blackpool in the pre-WW2 1930s. She stays on the outskirts of society looking and taking note of what she sees.

After a chance meeting she becomes friendly with Harold Davidson, a former priest who was ousted from the church after accusations of inappropriate behaviour with young girls.

Margaret makes it her mission to find out the truth about Harold and whether he is as innocent as he claims…

This is an interesting book that took me quite a while to get into, I didn’t realise that it was based on a true case and that Harold Davidson was a real person (don’t google the case beforehand as it will give the books ending away!)

I really enjoyed Margaret’s character and her quirks and darker backstory. I also thought the the mixture of fact and fiction was great - it was really well written and transports you right back to 1930’s Blackpool!
Profile Image for Lynne.
140 reviews3 followers
April 12, 2023
Margaret is involved in recording the habits and speech of working class people on their wakes week holidays in 1930's Blackpool. She soon becomes embroiled in intrigue and adventures as she makes contact with a true person from history, a vicaracused of crimes against women who becomes an exhibit on the Golden Mile. I enjoyed the depiction of Blackpool, a town very fgamiliar to me from my childhood. The novel has a very southern and patriarchal view of the working classes as depicted from Margarets point of view. On the whole it was an enjoyable narrative on Margarets growing personality from detached and almost autistic, to enjoying life and letting go.

I found the prose somewhat slow and laboured in places but overall an engaging story with lots of evidence of research.
Thanks to Pigeonhole for the opportunity to read this book.
Profile Image for Catalina.
929 reviews48 followers
April 24, 2023
Umm I guess is me not the book?! Lol. I can't say this is a bad novel, but it failed to grip me! I was attracted by the fact it's set in Blackpool, where I've been a number of times. I wanted to learn more about it's heyday. We do get glimpses of some of the shows/scandals that were famous at the time, of the threat of WW2 and the most interesting Mass Observation project, but ultimately The Misadventures of Margaret Finch is more of a character driven novel, rather than a historical one, and I really did not take to Margaret. The only reason why I didn't rated it 2* is because I've enjoyed the end, so to speak(maybe last 20%?!). It felt like some action and some excited was finally added to the mix and the story progressed in a satisfactory manner towards a gratifying resolution!

*Read on ThePigeonhole with many thanks for the opportunity!
56 reviews2 followers
April 18, 2024
Read as a member of Coundon Library Book Club Coventry
The main character Margaret described herself as unremarkable. Margaret’s upbringing had stifled her development and left her lacking in the qualities she felt other women possessed. She was unable to see her true value as a woman. Her story was so interesting and at times humorous. As a researcher and collector of data Margaret’s character was able to develop and question boundaries. The concept of Margaret and Other Margaret was clever and allowed us to see her character grow. The author brought a new perspective on this era that was full of social change. Really enjoyed reading this
Profile Image for Kim Russell.
Author 4 books21 followers
April 12, 2023
This morning I read the final stave of The Misadventures of Margaret Finch with The Pigeonhole. It’s written by Claire McGlasson, who is familiar to me as a journalist on ITV Anglia. I enjoyed being transported to the days before the Second World War and the interweaving of fact and fiction. The characters were so well written that I felt I knew them, and Blackpool was so vividly described that I felt I was there. The most interesting thing about this book was the protagonist’s development throughout the book from a wilting wallflower to a woman on a mission, with a few hiccups in between.
Profile Image for Christine Rennie.
3,203 reviews42 followers
April 12, 2023
The Misadventures of Margaret Finch by Claire McGlasson is a fascinating read of a research study carried out during the late 1930’s prior to the Second World War. Margaret the main character is a fascinating character, someone who feels different from everyone else but whilst she is naive and unworldly, she is highly intelligent and observant.
It is a very slow and well researched story that builds up to the start of World War 2 and shows what people,such as Margaret and James, who believe they are different can play in the forthcoming war.
Highly recommended
Profile Image for Michelle.
729 reviews5 followers
April 13, 2023
Set in Blackpool, the year is 1938.
Margaret gets a job as a mass observer. Here, she encounters Harold Davidson.
I really liked Margaret, although at the beginning she is very naive and not at all worldly. But slowly, she comes out of her shell, especially with the help of James.
This is part true story interlaced with fiction, and it's cleverly done.
I read this over 10 days with the Pigeonhole bookclub. Many thanks to them and the author Claire McGlasson for the opportunity to read. It's not my usual type of book but I thoroughly enjoyed it.
12 reviews
April 7, 2023
I found this a bit of a struggle to read. I'm not sure if it was because it was based on real life but I didn't find myself getting involved in the storyline or any empathy with the characters. Interesting to follow life as it was before the war and the issues that women had in those days. However, for me, this was just lacking that certain something that keeps you want to keep turning the page.
306 reviews3 followers
April 18, 2023
The Misadventures of Margaret Finch by Claire McGlasson is the rather strange tale of Margaret Finch, employed to observe humans for research by an organisation based in Blackpool in 1938.
I did find this a rather slow burner, however, it was well written and the fact that the book was inspired by true facts was completely fascinating. I think the book cover is inspiring, love it. Another interesting read with Pigeonhole.
Profile Image for Leia Williamson.
44 reviews
January 2, 2026
To be perfectly honest I didn't actually finish this book, I only got up to chapter 23. It seemed like a good story, but it was very slow. I was looking for a more action packed and faster paced story. The character of Margaret Finch was interesting, she had a lot of backstory that I wanted to learn more about. Her boss was a very quirky character, I enjoyed the parts that he was in. I'm sure this is a good book, it's just not what I was looking for at that moment in time.
Profile Image for Mags Schofield.
416 reviews8 followers
April 13, 2023
An interesting mix of fact and fiction, telling a tale of spinster Margaret Finch.
Well written with the main character well drawn, but I did find the pace a bit slow at times. Not a book I would usually read, but I found this interesting rather than enjoyable.
Thanks to Claire and Pigeonhole.
Profile Image for Paradise.
543 reviews23 followers
April 19, 2023
2.5 stars

I wanted to love this but it was sadly rather dull. I definitely nodded off at one point and just wasn’t interested in the story. All the characters were listless and there wasn’t really much point to the book.

The concept seemed engaging but as a whole, nothing really happened.
202 reviews4 followers
August 19, 2023
A fascinating story, based on real life events. The writing is so poetic and descriptive.
Profile Image for Roelia (Roelia Reads).
569 reviews1 follower
October 3, 2023
This historical fiction novel follows the life of Margaret Finch, a young woman who works as an observer for a mysterious research organisation in Blackpool in the 1930s.

“She had always been a watcher, a listener, a collector of other people’s stories. She had a knack for blending into the background, for being invisible. She was a human sponge, soaking up the details of life around her.”

Margaret is a shy and lonely character, who feels out of place in the world and struggles with her past. She becomes fascinated by the controversial figure of Harold Davidson, a former rector who was defrocked for his involvement with prostitutes and who now performs as a lion tamer in a circus.

“He was a man of contradictions, a paradox. He was both saint and sinner, hero and villain, martyr and madman. He was a man who had fallen from grace, but who still believed in redemption. He was a man who had dared to challenge the establishment, but who had paid a heavy price for it. He was a man who had loved many women, but who had lost the one he loved most. He was a man who had tamed lions, but who could not tame himself.”

Margaret is determined to find out the truth about Davidson and his motives, but she also has to face her own secrets and fears.

“She realised that she had been living in a bubble, a cocoon, a shell. She realised that she had been hiding from the world, from herself, from the truth. She realised that she had been wasting her life, her potential, her gifts. She realised that she had been missing out on so much, on adventure, on passion, on love. She realised that she had to change, to grow, to blossom. She realised that she had to live.”

The novel is well-written and richly detailed, creating a vivid picture of Blackpool in the late 1930s, with its seaside attractions, social classes, and looming threat of war. The author uses real historical events and characters, such as the research organisation Mass Observation and the scandalous Davidson, to create a realistic and intriguing backdrop for the story. The novel also explores themes such as identity, morality, sexuality, and love, through the complex and nuanced characters of Margaret and Davidson.

“She felt a surge of emotion, a mixture of pity and admiration, of curiosity and fear. She felt drawn to him, to his story, to his mystery. She felt a connection, a kinship, a bond. She felt something she had never felt before. She felt alive.”

The novel is both entertaining and thought-provoking, as it challenges the reader to question their own assumptions and prejudices.

The Misadventures of Margaret Finch by Claire McGlasson is a gem of a book, that will appeal to fans of historical fiction, mystery, and romance.

With thanks to Jonathan Ball Publishers for the opportunity to read this book.
Profile Image for Adam Stevenson.
Author 1 book17 followers
July 14, 2023
I had very high expectations for The Misadventures of Margaret Finch. Claire McGlasson had written a novel about the Panacea Society (which I am very interested in) called The Rapture and it was very good. When I saw this new novel dealt with something else I’m really interested in, the unfortunate priest Harold Davidson, I was excited.

Margaret Finch is in Blackpool as part of Mass Observation (something else that interests me, the book on ‘the pub’ is very interesting). As such, she is introduced like a secret agent, aloof from the people around her, listening in and recording. She’s a spy in the herd, not part of the things around her, hiding in a changing cubicle and taking her clothes off so she doesn’t stand out. When her spying goes wrong, she’s saved by a kindly older gent with gapped teeth who assumes she knows who he is.

He is Harold Davidson, a genuine historical figure with a fascinating story - I read it in Troublesome Priest by Jonathan Tucker. At this point in his life, he’s become a rector of Stiffkey in Norfolk but discovered a passion for working in Soho in London. There’ he’s gained the name ‘the prostitute’s padre’ and claims to have ‘saved’ 500 people. One of them took him to court though and the scandal has led to him being defrocked. In Blackpool, he plans to make a spectacle of himself, sitting in a barrel, to rise awareness of his unfair dismissal and funds for his appeal. Margaret finds herself drawn to the man and the puzzle over whether he was a naughty priest or something else.

Meanwhile, she has her own demons to face. From the outset, she is clearly the victim of much childhood repression, and this is spooled out throughout the book. It’s led to her feeling that a cold, outsider approach is the best in life and this leads to her being a very good spy for Mass Observation. However, this position of being outside everything also strengthens and emphasises this feeling of being empty. She finds herself filling this with alcohol, and later prescription opiates. At one low point in her drinking, she wets herself, stuffs her knickers in her bag and wakes up the next morning to find them still in there, clammy and cold - it’s quite the realistic comedown.

There is also hope though, in her blossoming relationship with her immediate superior in Mass Observation. James is a puppydoggish figure, his interest in people being as gleeful and involved as hers is detached. There’s is a really lovely relationship that develops.

Set in the 30s, there’s a growing unease of the war; the last gasp of end-of-the-pier shows, with a flea circus operator feeding the fleas with his own arm, and a general feeling of immediate crisis and change. Mass Observation itself seems to come from a really unpleasant place. The founder is presented as a terrible snob, who sees the working class as an alien race who need to be studied but never understood or accepted.

The characters are all believable and interesting. I particularly liked the presentation of Davidson, a victim of his own ego, no sex-pest but definitely a pest, whose strange ending is a result of his self-absorption and love of drama.

The Rapture was one of my favourite books when it came out but I enjoyed The Misadventures of Margaret Finch even more. What historical curlicue is she going to write a novel about next?
Displaying 1 - 30 of 92 reviews