What do you think?
Rate this book
Truly Series #1
Truly Wanted
After a chaotic childhood in a long line of foster homes, Sam McKenna found her version of serenity in her friendship with Brooke Fields. When tragedy forces Brooke to become a single mother, Sam is there for her. Sam ignores the crush she’s had on Brooke since college. Their relationship is too precious to risk.
After the loss of her husband, Brooke finally dips her toes back into the dating world only to have each encounter end in disaster. If it wasn’t for Sam by her side picking her back up, she might give up on ever finding love again.
After a night of unexpected passion when Brooke and Sam cross the line of friendship, Brooke can’t help but yearn for more with Sam. A chance encounter leads Brooke and Sam on a journey to Sam’s birth family, uncovering the ghosts of Sam’s past and revealing wounds that threaten the friendship both once believed to be indestructible, and any chance for something more.
After the loss of her husband, Brooke finally dips her toes back into the dating world only to have each encounter end in disaster. If it wasn’t for Sam by her side picking her back up, she might give up on ever finding love again.
After a night of unexpected passion when Brooke and Sam cross the line of friendship, Brooke can’t help but yearn for more with Sam. A chance encounter leads Brooke and Sam on a journey to Sam’s birth family, uncovering the ghosts of Sam’s past and revealing wounds that threaten the friendship both once believed to be indestructible, and any chance for something more.
215 pages, Kindle Edition
First published October 11, 2022
12 people are currently reading
290 people want to read
About the author
J.J. Hale
5 books32 followersJ.J. Hale (she/her) has been devouring books since she was able to hold one and has dreamt about publishing romance novels with queer leading ladies since she discovered such a thing existed, in her late teens.
The last few years have been filled with embracing and understanding her neurodiversity, which has expanded the dream to include representing kick-ass queer, neurodivergent women who find their happily ever afters.
Jess lives in the south of Ireland, and when she’s not daydreaming, she works in technology, plays with LEGO, and (according to the kids) fixes things.
The last few years have been filled with embracing and understanding her neurodiversity, which has expanded the dream to include representing kick-ass queer, neurodivergent women who find their happily ever afters.
Jess lives in the south of Ireland, and when she’s not daydreaming, she works in technology, plays with LEGO, and (according to the kids) fixes things.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 46 reviews
September 15, 2022
Family.
I try not to pick romance novels with single or divorced mothers these days because I think children add a layer of complication to a new relationship that I don't typically like. But this book is different because the kid is essentially raised by both main characters, Brooke and Sam, and little Finley helps to bring out a different side of Sam.
Sam and Brooke are best friends who have been each other's pillars of support in good times and bad. This story begins three years after the passing of Brooke's husband, Jacob, and Brooke is ready to move on. She goes on dates with men and women until one weird conversation leads her to re-evaluate her feelings for the one person who has stood by her through her marriage, grief and motherhood. But unknown to Brooke, her feelings are actually requited. Sam and Brooke persistently refuse to speak of their feelings, even as their bodies give in to temptation, for fear that they would lose their friendship and this creates a lot of angst. Sam is extremely vulnerable - she had a terrible childhood, she has ADHD, and has a lot to lose if their friendship breaks, so I can understand why she acts this way. But I am far less empathetic towards Brooke who has so much reservations about them dating but still makes a move on Sam.
Sam and Brooke have a lot of romantic chemistry and sexual tension and it is all very passionate, but I also love how they lean to each other and understand each other. And more than a story about best friends falling in love, this story is also about family - not only the ones we are given, but also the ones we choose to have. I love how the author explores this theme with different family dynamics, including the kinship that Sam, Brooke and Finley share.
This story is a debut and there are parts I felt could definitely have been better written, but for what it's worth, I thought this heartfelt read deserves some recognition.
I received an ARC from Bold Strokes Books through Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.
I try not to pick romance novels with single or divorced mothers these days because I think children add a layer of complication to a new relationship that I don't typically like. But this book is different because the kid is essentially raised by both main characters, Brooke and Sam, and little Finley helps to bring out a different side of Sam.
Sam and Brooke are best friends who have been each other's pillars of support in good times and bad. This story begins three years after the passing of Brooke's husband, Jacob, and Brooke is ready to move on. She goes on dates with men and women until one weird conversation leads her to re-evaluate her feelings for the one person who has stood by her through her marriage, grief and motherhood. But unknown to Brooke, her feelings are actually requited. Sam and Brooke persistently refuse to speak of their feelings, even as their bodies give in to temptation, for fear that they would lose their friendship and this creates a lot of angst. Sam is extremely vulnerable - she had a terrible childhood, she has ADHD, and has a lot to lose if their friendship breaks, so I can understand why she acts this way. But I am far less empathetic towards Brooke who has so much reservations about them dating but still makes a move on Sam.
Sam and Brooke have a lot of romantic chemistry and sexual tension and it is all very passionate, but I also love how they lean to each other and understand each other. And more than a story about best friends falling in love, this story is also about family - not only the ones we are given, but also the ones we choose to have. I love how the author explores this theme with different family dynamics, including the kinship that Sam, Brooke and Finley share.
This story is a debut and there are parts I felt could definitely have been better written, but for what it's worth, I thought this heartfelt read deserves some recognition.
I received an ARC from Bold Strokes Books through Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.
October 28, 2022
Brooke and Sam have been friends for ten years, ever since Brooke invited Sam to join a group project in college. It took a while for Sam to let Brooke in but from then on, they’ve been best friends. Inseparable. Even more so after Brooke’s husband died. So where does this sudden mutual attraction come from? And can they really manage to act on it and keep their friendship intact? As if that wasn’t enough to navigate, Sam, who grew up in foster care, has to face hard questions concerning her biological family.
Truly Wanted is a solid debut novel, with relatable characters, a good plot, and a really sweet child. I wish there had been slightly more about Sam’s ADHD and rejection sensitive dysphoria. I understand not wanting the character to be entirely defined by being neurodivergent, but I would have liked to know a bit more about how Sam thinks, not just about how it has affected her life.
This novel is relatively short, with a nice pace, despite a few repetitions here and there. Some chapters, especially at the beginning, are more tell than show, which is a classic issue with debut novels. It gets better after the exposition is set, so if you’re not hooked from the start, be patient. The tension between the main characters is well-written, the lack of communication is just frustrating enough but not overdone, and the chemistry is real. 3.5⭐️
I received a copy from the publisher and I am voluntarily leaving a review.
Read all my reviews on my blog (and please buy from the affiliation links!): Jude in the Stars
May 10, 2023
An emotional story!
Two close friends who are also soul mates, one night of unexpected passion and the harder it get to hide your true feelings. Yet the pull is just too strong to deny and sometimes it’s worth crossing the line for love. Truly Wanted has beautifully written characters and a storyline that was not only heart warming but also an emotional page turner. Loved it!
Two close friends who are also soul mates, one night of unexpected passion and the harder it get to hide your true feelings. Yet the pull is just too strong to deny and sometimes it’s worth crossing the line for love. Truly Wanted has beautifully written characters and a storyline that was not only heart warming but also an emotional page turner. Loved it!
December 8, 2022
It took too long for the two presumably best friends since college to actually start talking. There was very little dialog compared to all the fluff and descriptions of everything else. Every topic was followed by a generous amount of "what ifs". I understand this is a debut novel, and although it wasn't right for me, I would keep an eye on this author in the future.
September 29, 2022
Sam is secretly in love with her best friend Brooke. Brooke is just getting back into the dating game after husbands death when her first date points out she may be secretly in love with her best friend Sam. As Brooke and Sam navigate various life events and family drama they realize that they can't stay just friends anymore.
I liked this and thought it was a well written debut from JJ Hale. Both characters navigate their way through difficult life events with each other's help and I liked their friends to lovers story. It did start with some drama and confusion on the part of both MCs but they had great chemistry together. I loved Finley, he was adorable and Jake's family was awesome, I would have liked to see a bit more of them. The plot definitely kept me invested through the end and I'd happily pick up any future books by this author.
I liked this and thought it was a well written debut from JJ Hale. Both characters navigate their way through difficult life events with each other's help and I liked their friends to lovers story. It did start with some drama and confusion on the part of both MCs but they had great chemistry together. I loved Finley, he was adorable and Jake's family was awesome, I would have liked to see a bit more of them. The plot definitely kept me invested through the end and I'd happily pick up any future books by this author.
October 19, 2022
A terrific debut for Hale.
I liked the loyalty and love (friendship) between our two mains, and the unconditional love they both have for little Finley. I obviously enjoyed it even more when they took their friendship (love) to another level and cemented their little family of three... even with the struggles and misunderstandings it took for them to get there.
Finley was definitely the star for me though. Cute kid.
I liked the loyalty and love (friendship) between our two mains, and the unconditional love they both have for little Finley. I obviously enjoyed it even more when they took their friendship (love) to another level and cemented their little family of three... even with the struggles and misunderstandings it took for them to get there.
Finley was definitely the star for me though. Cute kid.
November 6, 2022
Looks like I’ve come across another author to watch out for in the next few years! Truly wanted is JJ Hales's debut book. It has a solid plot, and realistic characters and centres around real life issues such as ADHD, childhood trauma and new chances. The only problem I had, is it is a little bit short.
Overall, I've given Truly wanted a 3.7 out of 5
Overall, I've given Truly wanted a 3.7 out of 5
May 2, 2025
I'm always on the lookout for friends-to-lovers stories because I love them. Truly Wanted even won a Golden Crown Literary Award for Debut Novel, so I had relatively high hopes, even if this is a Bold Strokes Novel and they've not been a reliable publisher lately. Unfortunately, Truly Wanted didn't quite work for me, which is unfortunate because the premise really grabbed me.
Okay, so what didn't work? Just about everything. But here are its big missteps:
1. This book is tell, tell, tell to an astonishing degree. There's no showing the chemistry between BFFs Sam and Brooke, but you'll know about it because the narrative tells you it's there. Part of this is due to my next point:
2. There is very little dialogue in this book. And it's frustrating. Dialogue in novels is key in showing a character's personality, their humour, their sincerity, or lack thereof. In romance, dialogue allows for flirtation to happen before your eyes. But Hale seems to be afraid of extended dialogue, choosing instead to tell us everything we might need to know in prosaic paragraphs that dull the story and leave little to the imagination.
3. For BFFs who can tell each other everything, they spend a lot of time of time telling each other nothing. If you like miscommunication as a narrative device, you're in luck here because the entire book goes like this: I really should tell [Brooke or Sam] about [my feelings/my lunch plans with my friend/the fact that I found your biological sibling/the fact that I met my biological sibling/I'm in love with you and it scares me...] because she's the most important person in my life and I can't lose her, but [we're interrupted/I chicken out/it's not the right time...]. It got frustrating very quickly.
On the other hand, this is a debut novel and there's potential here. But the fact that this is a Bold Strokes Book, which means Hale did not self publish this, is very shocking. Because it means this book had to pass at least some independent scrutiny to make it better and it's just not what I'd expect for a ebook that I paid $10 for.
I'm landing at generous 2 stars because I do feel Hale has potential, but this felt like an early draft of a novel.
Okay, so what didn't work? Just about everything. But here are its big missteps:
1. This book is tell, tell, tell to an astonishing degree. There's no showing the chemistry between BFFs Sam and Brooke, but you'll know about it because the narrative tells you it's there. Part of this is due to my next point:
2. There is very little dialogue in this book. And it's frustrating. Dialogue in novels is key in showing a character's personality, their humour, their sincerity, or lack thereof. In romance, dialogue allows for flirtation to happen before your eyes. But Hale seems to be afraid of extended dialogue, choosing instead to tell us everything we might need to know in prosaic paragraphs that dull the story and leave little to the imagination.
3. For BFFs who can tell each other everything, they spend a lot of time of time telling each other nothing. If you like miscommunication as a narrative device, you're in luck here because the entire book goes like this: I really should tell [Brooke or Sam] about [my feelings/my lunch plans with my friend/the fact that I found your biological sibling/the fact that I met my biological sibling/I'm in love with you and it scares me...] because she's the most important person in my life and I can't lose her, but [we're interrupted/I chicken out/it's not the right time...]. It got frustrating very quickly.
On the other hand, this is a debut novel and there's potential here. But the fact that this is a Bold Strokes Book, which means Hale did not self publish this, is very shocking. Because it means this book had to pass at least some independent scrutiny to make it better and it's just not what I'd expect for a ebook that I paid $10 for.
I'm landing at generous 2 stars because I do feel Hale has potential, but this felt like an early draft of a novel.
Read
January 29, 2024Three years after Brooke's husband's death she's ready to start dating again. Her best friend Sam has essentially been a co-parent of Brooke's young son, Finley since Jacob's death. Sam has had feelings for Brooke for years but never envisioned those feelings ever being returned. When Brooke begins to realize how Sam is always there for her through good times and bad, one thing leads to another, and the two women give in to their attraction.
This is J.J. Hale's debut and I see a lot of potential in her writing. I think what kept me from really fully investing in this story was the lack of communication between the leads. Best friends talk things through, especially when that friendship evolves into something much deeper. It took so long for the communication to come, I had already checked out. I appreciate the author trying to show that family is what you make it and the scenes with Finley are well written and heartfelt. While I wasn't fully invested in this one, I will absolutely look forward to more from this author in the future.
An ARC was provided by Bold Strokes Books via NetGalley for an honest review.
This is J.J. Hale's debut and I see a lot of potential in her writing. I think what kept me from really fully investing in this story was the lack of communication between the leads. Best friends talk things through, especially when that friendship evolves into something much deeper. It took so long for the communication to come, I had already checked out. I appreciate the author trying to show that family is what you make it and the scenes with Finley are well written and heartfelt. While I wasn't fully invested in this one, I will absolutely look forward to more from this author in the future.
An ARC was provided by Bold Strokes Books via NetGalley for an honest review.
December 1, 2023
4⭐️
After reading book #2 Truly Enough first, I finally listened to book #1 Truly Wanted.
Friends to lovers romance, same trope, different story.
Sam grew up in the Foster system and always felt like she wasn't good enough to be loved. With the help of her best friend Brooke, she has learned to deal with her ADHD and is now a successful web designer. Sam has been in love with Brooke for what feels like forever, but she doesn't want to jeopardize the best and most enduring thing in her life. The fear of losing Brooke if she makes a move is too great.
Brooke can't imagine life without Sam because she has been a part of her life since they met in high school. She has been a great help, especially after the death of her husband and father of her three-year-old son Flynn. Sam is a member of her family. As she begins to open herself up to a relationship again, she quickly realizes that she doesn't have to look far. The one who ticks off all the important boxes for a potential partner is right in front of her. If only she had the courage to tell her.
Told from the point of view of both MCs, we witness the struggle and fear of losing the best thing in life if they mess up. But the attraction is immense and it becomes harder and harder to hide their true feelings. I was rooting for them from the start. They have such a great relationship as friends. Everyone should have a Brooke or Sam in their corner. A beautifully told romance, without unnecessary drama but with very real and loveable characters, good dialog, important themes like grief and not having a family, but also lots of fun with little sunny boy Flynn (although sometimes I had the feeling that Flynn was much older than three years, which was a little bit strange) and well developed and integrated secondary characters.
Narrated by Lula Larkin, who did a nice job.
After reading book #2 Truly Enough first, I finally listened to book #1 Truly Wanted.
Friends to lovers romance, same trope, different story.
Sam grew up in the Foster system and always felt like she wasn't good enough to be loved. With the help of her best friend Brooke, she has learned to deal with her ADHD and is now a successful web designer. Sam has been in love with Brooke for what feels like forever, but she doesn't want to jeopardize the best and most enduring thing in her life. The fear of losing Brooke if she makes a move is too great.
Brooke can't imagine life without Sam because she has been a part of her life since they met in high school. She has been a great help, especially after the death of her husband and father of her three-year-old son Flynn. Sam is a member of her family. As she begins to open herself up to a relationship again, she quickly realizes that she doesn't have to look far. The one who ticks off all the important boxes for a potential partner is right in front of her. If only she had the courage to tell her.
Told from the point of view of both MCs, we witness the struggle and fear of losing the best thing in life if they mess up. But the attraction is immense and it becomes harder and harder to hide their true feelings. I was rooting for them from the start. They have such a great relationship as friends. Everyone should have a Brooke or Sam in their corner. A beautifully told romance, without unnecessary drama but with very real and loveable characters, good dialog, important themes like grief and not having a family, but also lots of fun with little sunny boy Flynn (although sometimes I had the feeling that Flynn was much older than three years, which was a little bit strange) and well developed and integrated secondary characters.
Narrated by Lula Larkin, who did a nice job.
November 2, 2022
3.5 ⭐️ rounded up.
This is a story about Sam who is raised in foster care and has always felt unwanted and unloved. She’s a self made web designer and with the help of her best friend Brooke has learned to cope with her ADHD. Brooke is a widow raising a 3 year old son Finley. Sam and Brooke met in college and became best friends. After Brook’s husband dies in a car crash, Sam helps Brooke recover from his death and helps her raise Finley. At the start of this book they both begin to realize that they are secretly in love with each other and are afraid to let the other know for fear of loosing their friendship.
I liked Hale’s easy writing style and the deep feelings that the MCs have for each other and the devotion to Finely and his love for both of them. It seemed like a very real life book. I think that they were almost paralyzed with fear that if they told each other how they felt they would loose one another. Sam had such a difficult life and was totally in need of Brooke’s love and sensibility. Brooke knew how much Finely loved Sam and was scared he would loose her too.
I would have liked more description of each MC physical appearance and details on their jobs. Also it felt like it took place in America and not Ireland. Very few Irish words used for common things.
I did like that there were some small plot surprises that added a bit of depth and interest to the story.
And for a 3 year old, Finley had much older vocabulary and thought process, but still super cute.
ARC received from Net Galley for a voluntary and honest review.
This is a story about Sam who is raised in foster care and has always felt unwanted and unloved. She’s a self made web designer and with the help of her best friend Brooke has learned to cope with her ADHD. Brooke is a widow raising a 3 year old son Finley. Sam and Brooke met in college and became best friends. After Brook’s husband dies in a car crash, Sam helps Brooke recover from his death and helps her raise Finley. At the start of this book they both begin to realize that they are secretly in love with each other and are afraid to let the other know for fear of loosing their friendship.
I liked Hale’s easy writing style and the deep feelings that the MCs have for each other and the devotion to Finely and his love for both of them. It seemed like a very real life book. I think that they were almost paralyzed with fear that if they told each other how they felt they would loose one another. Sam had such a difficult life and was totally in need of Brooke’s love and sensibility. Brooke knew how much Finely loved Sam and was scared he would loose her too.
I would have liked more description of each MC physical appearance and details on their jobs. Also it felt like it took place in America and not Ireland. Very few Irish words used for common things.
I did like that there were some small plot surprises that added a bit of depth and interest to the story.
And for a 3 year old, Finley had much older vocabulary and thought process, but still super cute.
ARC received from Net Galley for a voluntary and honest review.
October 3, 2022
J.J. Hale
Truly Wanted
New Release
Sam and Brooke met in college, and Sam was taken with Brooke. She thought she was beautiful and had a crush, but decided being friends with her was the safer bet so that she could be in her life.
Sam was a sweet woman who loved Finley (Brookes son) and took great care of him, she loved that kid and Finley love Sam back .
The family that Sam and Brooke created was just beautiful, the way that they understood one another and took care of each other and cared about others' feelings.
The supporting characters added to the story and made it interesting. Finley was just a sweet and lovable little boy.
Side note : I can’t believe this was a debut novel. The pace was amazing and I was hooked from page one. I went through this book in one sitting. I could not stop reading it. I couldn’t put it down. I’m already in love with the characters in the story. The author did a miraculous job.
Both characters were in there head about loving each other so much and wanted to take care of each other . Sam was afraid of losing Brooke and Finley , she just pushed her away The love that Brooke had for Sam would never change no matter how Sam try to hide.
Side note : The sad part about parents is that they are human like us. Unfortunately everyone is not meant to be a parent. In today’s society we have access to therapy and other tools to understand that if we are not mentally or emotionally capable of being a parent. Years ago when are parents were raising children they didn’t have as much help or resources. They didn’t have those tools yet to make those decisions, to choose themselves. To deal with their trauma or addictions. It was a different time back then, people didn’t talk about their feelings and the struggles and the demons.
This book will touch your heart in so many ways. Family does not have to be who you are born to. I think it more special when you have a chosen family who loves you in spite of everything that’s true love .
I have to say this was an amazing debut book. It had well developed characters and it was very well written.
I would like to thank Bold Strokes Books and NetGalley for the arc! 5 stars.
Truly Wanted
New Release
Sam and Brooke met in college, and Sam was taken with Brooke. She thought she was beautiful and had a crush, but decided being friends with her was the safer bet so that she could be in her life.
Sam was a sweet woman who loved Finley (Brookes son) and took great care of him, she loved that kid and Finley love Sam back .
The family that Sam and Brooke created was just beautiful, the way that they understood one another and took care of each other and cared about others' feelings.
The supporting characters added to the story and made it interesting. Finley was just a sweet and lovable little boy.
Side note : I can’t believe this was a debut novel. The pace was amazing and I was hooked from page one. I went through this book in one sitting. I could not stop reading it. I couldn’t put it down. I’m already in love with the characters in the story. The author did a miraculous job.
Both characters were in there head about loving each other so much and wanted to take care of each other . Sam was afraid of losing Brooke and Finley , she just pushed her away The love that Brooke had for Sam would never change no matter how Sam try to hide.
Side note : The sad part about parents is that they are human like us. Unfortunately everyone is not meant to be a parent. In today’s society we have access to therapy and other tools to understand that if we are not mentally or emotionally capable of being a parent. Years ago when are parents were raising children they didn’t have as much help or resources. They didn’t have those tools yet to make those decisions, to choose themselves. To deal with their trauma or addictions. It was a different time back then, people didn’t talk about their feelings and the struggles and the demons.
This book will touch your heart in so many ways. Family does not have to be who you are born to. I think it more special when you have a chosen family who loves you in spite of everything that’s true love .
I have to say this was an amazing debut book. It had well developed characters and it was very well written.
I would like to thank Bold Strokes Books and NetGalley for the arc! 5 stars.
June 18, 2023
This friends to lovers story was with really high stake, both MC already deeply entangled in each other's lives and with a toddler in the middle. The struggle and questioning they went through made sense. Sam suffers from rejection sensitive dysphoria which leads to her shutting down and some miscommunication. I am not usually a fan of miscommunication in books, but this one was well explained, and with a precise point. The book was really moving, I especially loved how Hale treated the family topic, with the notion that blood doesn't make everything. With everything Sam has been through I was so glad she eventually felt love and at peace. Despite her doubt, Brooke was steady and a true rock, deeply caring about Sam. You can truly feel the love they have for each other. There were so many times I just want to bang them with each other's head then say : talk about your feelings you fools in love.
In this book you almost dive in immediately in the "we could be more than friends" phase, and I would have wanted a few chapters before were they are just friends, and make me really settle in their friendship to truly feel the change, with the risk of having the second phase of their relationship shortened ; for example, I would have loved a few more flashbacks of when Jacob was alive.
Overall, I had a good time reading this book. It was a quick and emotional read.
I wish I read 𝙏𝙍𝙐𝙇𝙔 𝙒𝘼𝙉𝙏𝙀𝘿 before because now I want to read 𝙏𝙍𝙐𝙇𝙔 𝙀𝙉𝙊𝙐𝙂𝙃 again to see how happy Sam and Brooke are now. I don't know what are Hale's plans but I wouldn't be surprised if Dani's story is coming next and I will definitely be there.
In this book you almost dive in immediately in the "we could be more than friends" phase, and I would have wanted a few chapters before were they are just friends, and make me really settle in their friendship to truly feel the change, with the risk of having the second phase of their relationship shortened ; for example, I would have loved a few more flashbacks of when Jacob was alive.
Overall, I had a good time reading this book. It was a quick and emotional read.
I wish I read 𝙏𝙍𝙐𝙇𝙔 𝙒𝘼𝙉𝙏𝙀𝘿 before because now I want to read 𝙏𝙍𝙐𝙇𝙔 𝙀𝙉𝙊𝙐𝙂𝙃 again to see how happy Sam and Brooke are now. I don't know what are Hale's plans but I wouldn't be surprised if Dani's story is coming next and I will definitely be there.
September 19, 2022
I think you should always give debut authors a chance and that’s why I decided to go for this one, despite my reservations on the story.
I think it would have been better if I had skipped this book, I didn’t connect with it at all.
Sam and Brooke have been friends for a long time. The last few years they’ve grown even closer. After Brooke’s husband past away Sam and Brooke have basically been raising Brooke’s son together and for all intents and purposes are together. Except for the physical part. When this physical part does actually happen, rather early on in the book, it seems like it is all these best friends can do. Talking about your fears? No way! They are best internalised and told to the readers, instead of experienced through dialogue between the characters. The lack of communication for fear of changing the friendship is frustrating. If you can read every eye movement you should be able to talk things out.
And this is just one issue I have, but it’s a major one I just can’t shake.
Oh and the kid? Finley is three seems to live on pancakes and sweets and acts like he’s at least 5-6.
I can see the author is trying to tell some beautiful stories about family, the one you are born into, the one you choose, the one that finds you. The lack of communication and just the “vibe” make me miss all this, I don’t feel it.
Also this book is set in Ireland but I just can’t believe that with American spelling of words, that’s just a me thing (probably), aside from the spelling some words a different in British English vs American English and I do appreciate the British versions being used.
Conclusion: not a book for me. I can see the potential of this author and I’ll likely pick up their second book. This first one just wasn’t for me. 2.5 stars
*ARC received from the publisher through NetGalley in exchange for an honest review*
I think it would have been better if I had skipped this book, I didn’t connect with it at all.
Sam and Brooke have been friends for a long time. The last few years they’ve grown even closer. After Brooke’s husband past away Sam and Brooke have basically been raising Brooke’s son together and for all intents and purposes are together. Except for the physical part. When this physical part does actually happen, rather early on in the book, it seems like it is all these best friends can do. Talking about your fears? No way! They are best internalised and told to the readers, instead of experienced through dialogue between the characters. The lack of communication for fear of changing the friendship is frustrating. If you can read every eye movement you should be able to talk things out.
And this is just one issue I have, but it’s a major one I just can’t shake.
Oh and the kid? Finley is three seems to live on pancakes and sweets and acts like he’s at least 5-6.
I can see the author is trying to tell some beautiful stories about family, the one you are born into, the one you choose, the one that finds you. The lack of communication and just the “vibe” make me miss all this, I don’t feel it.
Also this book is set in Ireland but I just can’t believe that with American spelling of words, that’s just a me thing (probably), aside from the spelling some words a different in British English vs American English and I do appreciate the British versions being used.
Conclusion: not a book for me. I can see the potential of this author and I’ll likely pick up their second book. This first one just wasn’t for me. 2.5 stars
*ARC received from the publisher through NetGalley in exchange for an honest review*
November 13, 2022
J.J. Hale’s debut novel Truly Wanted is a friends-to-lovers romance with an MC who is neurodivergent and grew up in foster care. Two things that are close to my heart, so I was really eager to see how this one turned out.
Sam and Brooke have a strong friendship built with years of memories, heartbreaks and support. Their foundations are strong and secure right up until they decide to sleep together. That one night brings to light feelings Brooke didn’t know she had, and Sam had tamped down out of respect for their friendship for years. They must then work through their own personal demons to decide if taking something that they both rely so strongly on and turning it into a relationship is worth the risk.
J.J Hale has done brilliantly in creating relevant characters, both in her MCs and their friends and family. Her themes of found family, trust and resilience are written with sensitivity and empathy. There is angst, but it’s needed and handled well, while interjecting sweetness in the form of Brooke’s son.
A really solid debut by an author worth checking out.
I received and ARC from Bold Strokes Books via NetGalley in exchange for my honest review.
Sam and Brooke have a strong friendship built with years of memories, heartbreaks and support. Their foundations are strong and secure right up until they decide to sleep together. That one night brings to light feelings Brooke didn’t know she had, and Sam had tamped down out of respect for their friendship for years. They must then work through their own personal demons to decide if taking something that they both rely so strongly on and turning it into a relationship is worth the risk.
J.J Hale has done brilliantly in creating relevant characters, both in her MCs and their friends and family. Her themes of found family, trust and resilience are written with sensitivity and empathy. There is angst, but it’s needed and handled well, while interjecting sweetness in the form of Brooke’s son.
A really solid debut by an author worth checking out.
I received and ARC from Bold Strokes Books via NetGalley in exchange for my honest review.
September 15, 2022
Sam McKenna becomes best friends with Brooke Fields while attending college. She sees her through her marriage, birth of her son Finley and widowhood at a young age. Now two years after her husbands passing she’s beginning to date again. Sam is still there for weekly lunches, to tend Finley and to binge tv shows. It takes the two a while to see what everyone else around them already knows. They may be perfect for each other. There is a side story, Sam who has ADHD being raised in foster care and not knowing why her parents left her. Sam’s story provides some angst to an otherwise friends to more love story.
This is gentle romance with caring and supportive people. Finley is a very adult three year old sometimes acting beyond his years. Also I swear he was always eating sweets, pizza or pancakes. The author is from Ireland and although the story could be set in any city, I enjoyed a few less American words like creche for nursery or day care. The lack of communication for fear of changing the friendship is frustrating. If you can read every eye movement you should be able to talk. I did also wonder how Sam is coping with her ADHD in adulthood as it seems to drop from the story after being mentioned in college. Overall a nice story and while there is nothing wrong with it there isn’t anything that stands out for me either. Thank you to NetGalley and Bold Strokes Books for an eARC in exchange for an honest review. (3.5 stars)
This is gentle romance with caring and supportive people. Finley is a very adult three year old sometimes acting beyond his years. Also I swear he was always eating sweets, pizza or pancakes. The author is from Ireland and although the story could be set in any city, I enjoyed a few less American words like creche for nursery or day care. The lack of communication for fear of changing the friendship is frustrating. If you can read every eye movement you should be able to talk. I did also wonder how Sam is coping with her ADHD in adulthood as it seems to drop from the story after being mentioned in college. Overall a nice story and while there is nothing wrong with it there isn’t anything that stands out for me either. Thank you to NetGalley and Bold Strokes Books for an eARC in exchange for an honest review. (3.5 stars)
June 20, 2023
Sam had a hard life growing up. Her mom left and her father was into drugs, so she was put into the system. When she aged out, she went to college and met Brooke.
Brooke is now a single mother trying out the dating world. Thank god for Sam, and Brooke's sister in law Maddie for babysitting duties. But, Sam is in love with Brooke, and though she doesn't realize it, Brooke is in love with Sam. This is their story, and it's HOT! 5 stars!!
Brooke is now a single mother trying out the dating world. Thank god for Sam, and Brooke's sister in law Maddie for babysitting duties. But, Sam is in love with Brooke, and though she doesn't realize it, Brooke is in love with Sam. This is their story, and it's HOT! 5 stars!!
July 18, 2024
3 stars
I enjoyed it. Can't comment on relatability because I'm nowhere near that life stage (kids, in-laws,...), but I liked the writing and read it in one go, so it was written better than average.
I enjoyed it. Can't comment on relatability because I'm nowhere near that life stage (kids, in-laws,...), but I liked the writing and read it in one go, so it was written better than average.
May 23, 2023
Truly Wanted is a heart-warming debut novel by J.J. Hale. Sam McKenna has ADHD and grew up in foster care moving from family to family, not the greatest of start in life. During a college class, Brooke Fields invites Sam to make up their project team. As their friendship blossoms, with Sam harbouring a secret crush, Brooke just gets Sam realising when she needs space and when to interject.
After Brooke’s marriage to Jacob and the birth of her son, Finley, Sam remains a constant in Brooke’s life. A road traffic accident involving Jacob sees Brooke becoming a single mother. Sam is her go-to person and ensures she is there for the two important people in her life.
The character development draws you in as Sam discovers her past, and Brooke questions herself as she dates again. Beware the cute toddler Fin who calls things as he sees them, and holds a unique relationship with Sam.
Can they cross the line from best friends to lovers with no consequences? Are they even compatible? This well-paced book had me fighting for their future as I rode the emotional highs and lows.
I look forward to more from this author.
After Brooke’s marriage to Jacob and the birth of her son, Finley, Sam remains a constant in Brooke’s life. A road traffic accident involving Jacob sees Brooke becoming a single mother. Sam is her go-to person and ensures she is there for the two important people in her life.
The character development draws you in as Sam discovers her past, and Brooke questions herself as she dates again. Beware the cute toddler Fin who calls things as he sees them, and holds a unique relationship with Sam.
Can they cross the line from best friends to lovers with no consequences? Are they even compatible? This well-paced book had me fighting for their future as I rode the emotional highs and lows.
I look forward to more from this author.
May 24, 2024
Story is really strong on family by choice and family through birth dynamics. Touching and entertaining.
August 25, 2023
I did not care much for MCs, childish immature behavior.
July 11, 2023
Decent but pretty high drama for no reason, which is my least favorite kind of conflict. You know the kind where you literally need to sit down and have one five minute conversation like adults so that you're on the same page or work out what you're both thinking but somehow there is never time for it, ever? That.
September 18, 2022
There were some things I struggled with in this story. It was slow and repetitive and entirely frustrating in the first half. But the second half got me. Sam's struggle with her RSD and anxiety was so relatable and I loved how her self-realization turned out.
September 21, 2022
Truly Wanted by J.J. Hale
Thank you Netgallery and Bold Stroke books for an arc for an unbiased review.
This is what I would consider the wlw version of a chick-lit book, and I felt it doesn't hurt it at all. It is afterall pretty much what the synopsis surmises.
However, it was a book that was charming in its own way, for me personally it fell flat in a couple of areas.
The most notably was how Brooke and Sam couldn't communicate! For two best friends, they seemed more content simply having a fun aspect of communication, but when it came to communication about each other in any way other than superficial friendship, it felt completely lacking. I understood the fear of not wanting to rock the boat, to upset the friendship they had. Particularly under the circumstances of their upbringing. That was written well and underscored some of their vulnerability. This was definitely a plus point for the book.
Yet, for all this, physically they get together. But still emotionally it is a block wall of not talking about it. It was just frustrating to read for as long as it was.
Finley also seemed older and less realistic as a 3 year old to my experiences around many children of that age. Of course, they can be great communicators then, but it all seemed just too convenient for the story.
Perhaps I'm doing the book as a whole an injustice. It wasn't bad per se, but it didn't stand out for me. Probably for others it will be enjoyed more. It was a story that was cute enough, but didn't quite fall into the bracket of great or exceptional. It was solid. I certainly wouldn't discourage others from trying to read this, and if I know this is a favourite genre of someone's I'd consider gifting the book to them.
A solid 3/5 stars 🌟
Thank you Netgallery and Bold Stroke books for an arc for an unbiased review.
This is what I would consider the wlw version of a chick-lit book, and I felt it doesn't hurt it at all. It is afterall pretty much what the synopsis surmises.
However, it was a book that was charming in its own way, for me personally it fell flat in a couple of areas.
The most notably was how Brooke and Sam couldn't communicate! For two best friends, they seemed more content simply having a fun aspect of communication, but when it came to communication about each other in any way other than superficial friendship, it felt completely lacking. I understood the fear of not wanting to rock the boat, to upset the friendship they had. Particularly under the circumstances of their upbringing. That was written well and underscored some of their vulnerability. This was definitely a plus point for the book.
Yet, for all this, physically they get together. But still emotionally it is a block wall of not talking about it. It was just frustrating to read for as long as it was.
Finley also seemed older and less realistic as a 3 year old to my experiences around many children of that age. Of course, they can be great communicators then, but it all seemed just too convenient for the story.
Perhaps I'm doing the book as a whole an injustice. It wasn't bad per se, but it didn't stand out for me. Probably for others it will be enjoyed more. It was a story that was cute enough, but didn't quite fall into the bracket of great or exceptional. It was solid. I certainly wouldn't discourage others from trying to read this, and if I know this is a favourite genre of someone's I'd consider gifting the book to them.
A solid 3/5 stars 🌟
October 2, 2022
Based on the description, I thought this might be a book that hit a lot of the tropes that I really enjoy, but it ended up being a completely different story than I anticipated. Sam and Brooke are our title characters and they've been best friends since college. Brooke is recently widowed with a 3 year old named Finley. Sam has had a tumultuous past to say the least and has a very difficult time trusting people. We begin the novel with Brooke getting back in to the dating arena and unexpectedly sharing a passionate moment with Sam, who has had a crush on Brooke since they became friends.
I've mentioned in my other reviews that I am not a fan of insta-love stories. While there were reservations on both Sam and Brooke's end, it still felt like they fell in to bed a little quickly. I also prefer more dialogue in my stories. I feel like this book tended to lean towards the descriptive paragraphs of feelings and background, but I like to learn this more through character interactions. However, with all that being said, Brooke and Sam had excellent chemistry and the depth behind these characters was exceptionally written. I enjoyed the author's descriptions of Sam's neurodivergence and it was great to see this part of her highlighted.
Overall, I think this would be a really good book for those who enjoy these themes. Though it didn't hit home for me, the writing and story telling is superb. Enjoy!
I was given an ARC for my honest feedback.
I've mentioned in my other reviews that I am not a fan of insta-love stories. While there were reservations on both Sam and Brooke's end, it still felt like they fell in to bed a little quickly. I also prefer more dialogue in my stories. I feel like this book tended to lean towards the descriptive paragraphs of feelings and background, but I like to learn this more through character interactions. However, with all that being said, Brooke and Sam had excellent chemistry and the depth behind these characters was exceptionally written. I enjoyed the author's descriptions of Sam's neurodivergence and it was great to see this part of her highlighted.
Overall, I think this would be a really good book for those who enjoy these themes. Though it didn't hit home for me, the writing and story telling is superb. Enjoy!
I was given an ARC for my honest feedback.
September 19, 2022
Thanks to Netgalley and Bold Strokes Books for a copy of the book.
Brooke's been a single mother to 3 year old, Finley since the sudden death of her husband, Jacob 3 years ago. She's now read to get back into the dating world.
Sam spent her childhood bouncing between foster homes. Sam's been ignoring the crush on best friend, Brooke since they first met in college, as their friendship was too important for her.
One drunken night however leads them to cross the line from friendship to something more. How will they go from there?
An unexpected encounter leads Sam to connect to some of her birth family and uncover her past.
This is a cute romance, but I found the story with Sam and her family far more intriguing, as I found the romance plot lacking in substance. I would have liked if Brooke's ADHD and it's impact on her life in the present would have played a bigger role, but I appreciate that it is written by someone with ADHD.
This is supposedly set in Ireland but due to the names, language and spelling it feels more American, so if you're looking for a book with an Irish feel, this isn't it.
Overall, this is a good debut novel and I'm interested to see what the author will do in future.
Brooke's been a single mother to 3 year old, Finley since the sudden death of her husband, Jacob 3 years ago. She's now read to get back into the dating world.
Sam spent her childhood bouncing between foster homes. Sam's been ignoring the crush on best friend, Brooke since they first met in college, as their friendship was too important for her.
One drunken night however leads them to cross the line from friendship to something more. How will they go from there?
An unexpected encounter leads Sam to connect to some of her birth family and uncover her past.
This is a cute romance, but I found the story with Sam and her family far more intriguing, as I found the romance plot lacking in substance. I would have liked if Brooke's ADHD and it's impact on her life in the present would have played a bigger role, but I appreciate that it is written by someone with ADHD.
This is supposedly set in Ireland but due to the names, language and spelling it feels more American, so if you're looking for a book with an Irish feel, this isn't it.
Overall, this is a good debut novel and I'm interested to see what the author will do in future.
September 20, 2022
This is your classic cliche best friends in a love story and it made an okay read, especially for a debut.
Brooke lost her husband and is now back on the dating scene meanwhile best friend Sam watches on in utter despair after years of harbouring feelings for Brooke.
I can probably write paragraphs about what I didn't like about this book but I realized I can just summarize it with one thought. The author played way too safe.
This is your classic stumbling debut. Awkward writing and dialogue at the beginning, which thankfully irons out before the halfway mark, and the very noticeable fear of taking risks.
This book had so much potential for a deeper plot, deeper character development and just overall more specialisation with an already saturated cliche paradigm.
The book isn't the only thing with potential though, the author herself exhibits clear signs of writing skill, one definitely better than mine and it shows in the sex scenes within this book the most.
But yeah, overall my general advice and critique of this book have to do with the lack of risk.
I do actually recommend this if you're looking for something incredibly light and short. '
Thanks to NetGalley for the Arc in return for an honest review.
Brooke lost her husband and is now back on the dating scene meanwhile best friend Sam watches on in utter despair after years of harbouring feelings for Brooke.
I can probably write paragraphs about what I didn't like about this book but I realized I can just summarize it with one thought. The author played way too safe.
This is your classic stumbling debut. Awkward writing and dialogue at the beginning, which thankfully irons out before the halfway mark, and the very noticeable fear of taking risks.
This book had so much potential for a deeper plot, deeper character development and just overall more specialisation with an already saturated cliche paradigm.
The book isn't the only thing with potential though, the author herself exhibits clear signs of writing skill, one definitely better than mine and it shows in the sex scenes within this book the most.
But yeah, overall my general advice and critique of this book have to do with the lack of risk.
I do actually recommend this if you're looking for something incredibly light and short. '
Thanks to NetGalley for the Arc in return for an honest review.
October 12, 2022
A cute forbidden romance with a refreshing take on what it means to be family.
After the death of her husband, Brooke has come to rely on her best friend Sam for support. Especially when it comes to her son Finley. When Brooke decides to start dating again it doesn’t take either of them long to realize that maybe there’s something more than just friendship between them. However, neither is willing to risk losing what they have. But, with the memories of a shared night of passion they can only fight it for so long.
The relationship between Sam and Brooke’s son Finley was adorable and really helped build the connection between Sam and Brooke. The relationship between the main characters leans more on romantic attraction than sexual attraction, but this works well given the premise. That being said, there are sex scenes. I really enjoyed the secondary storyline about Sam’s experience growing up in foster care and the chosen family she’s been able to find overtime. I wasn’t a fan of how the flashbacks were used in the novel, I felt like they disrupted the flow and only provided minimal insight into the characters’ pasts.
Thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for the ARC!
After the death of her husband, Brooke has come to rely on her best friend Sam for support. Especially when it comes to her son Finley. When Brooke decides to start dating again it doesn’t take either of them long to realize that maybe there’s something more than just friendship between them. However, neither is willing to risk losing what they have. But, with the memories of a shared night of passion they can only fight it for so long.
The relationship between Sam and Brooke’s son Finley was adorable and really helped build the connection between Sam and Brooke. The relationship between the main characters leans more on romantic attraction than sexual attraction, but this works well given the premise. That being said, there are sex scenes. I really enjoyed the secondary storyline about Sam’s experience growing up in foster care and the chosen family she’s been able to find overtime. I wasn’t a fan of how the flashbacks were used in the novel, I felt like they disrupted the flow and only provided minimal insight into the characters’ pasts.
Thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for the ARC!
October 5, 2022
Sam and Brooke have been best friends since college, and since Brooke’s husband passed away 3 years prior, Sam has been helping Brooke with her son, Finley. Since some time has passed, Brooke is ready to start dating again, and of course, Sam has been harboring feelings for Brooke since they met. Brooke goes on a few disastrous dates when she meets Dani (who I love and need more of). While Brooke thinks things could go further with Dani, Dani points out that Brooke is clearly in love with her best friend, and friends, I do love it when the “oh yeah” moment hits one of the MCs in romance novels. Brooke, realizing how Sam is always there for her and Finley and maybe that could mean more, decides to give into her attraction and see if the two are compatible.
I really enjoyed Truly Wanted and think it’s a great debut. Friends-to-lovers / idiots-in-love are some of my favorite tropes and the book hits them perfectly. Plus Sam and Brooke have amazing chemistry. I love how well Sam and Brooke know and understand each other, even though there was plenty of miscommunication. Both Sam and Brooke want to be together, but never fully communicate that to each other. Don’t get me wrong, I’m here for the angst, but I felt like they were having the same conversation over and over, without changing the ending. Overall, Truly Wanted is a great read and full of heart. There’s amazing secondary characters (can Ruby and Dani kiss please), real life struggles we all go through, and a quick trip to see the Spice Girls! Like what else do you want in a book? I’m looking forward to what comes next from JJ Hale!
I received an ARC from Bold Strokes Books, Inc. through NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
4 / 5 stars.
I really enjoyed Truly Wanted and think it’s a great debut. Friends-to-lovers / idiots-in-love are some of my favorite tropes and the book hits them perfectly. Plus Sam and Brooke have amazing chemistry. I love how well Sam and Brooke know and understand each other, even though there was plenty of miscommunication. Both Sam and Brooke want to be together, but never fully communicate that to each other. Don’t get me wrong, I’m here for the angst, but I felt like they were having the same conversation over and over, without changing the ending. Overall, Truly Wanted is a great read and full of heart. There’s amazing secondary characters (can Ruby and Dani kiss please), real life struggles we all go through, and a quick trip to see the Spice Girls! Like what else do you want in a book? I’m looking forward to what comes next from JJ Hale!
I received an ARC from Bold Strokes Books, Inc. through NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
4 / 5 stars.
October 10, 2022
J.J. Hale has written an enjoyable friends to lovers romance between a young widow and her neurodivergent best friend with Truly Wanted. As a reader, I felt for both women and their traumatic pasts.
As with most friends to lovers romances, one friend has been in love with the other for some time. It's the other friend I usually have a hard time believing suddenly falls for her best friend, but at least the author reinforced certain elements as having been long-standing to support it.
The child was believable and not too much, as some kids can be in romances.
The author did a nice job of not wrapping up one plot point with a happy bow. Sometimes choosing outcomes that are not ideal is more realistic.
An ARC was provided by the publisher via NetGalley for an honest review.
As with most friends to lovers romances, one friend has been in love with the other for some time. It's the other friend I usually have a hard time believing suddenly falls for her best friend, but at least the author reinforced certain elements as having been long-standing to support it.
The child was believable and not too much, as some kids can be in romances.
The author did a nice job of not wrapping up one plot point with a happy bow. Sometimes choosing outcomes that are not ideal is more realistic.
An ARC was provided by the publisher via NetGalley for an honest review.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 46 reviews