Certain historical situations are written about more than others, so it's refreshing to see Gary D. Schmidt tells a story from a less familiar historical setting. Anson's Way introduces Anson Granville Staplyton, the latest in a long family line to defend the British Empire. It's the 1700s, and the Irish are unhappy with King George II's strict laws and behavioral code. British Fencibles—including Anson, a young drummer—are dispatched to quell any uprising in the Irish territory, but Anson is mostly excited about serving under his father, the respected Colonel Staplyton. Others in his unit are wary of Anson at first—will the colonel afford him special treatment?—but as soon as it's apparent that Anson will be regarded as any other Fencible, he finds himself at home among his brothers in arms. He's on his way to becoming a man.
Fencibles are esteemed by all except Irishmen, and Anson soon comes to question how the Irish are treated by the British monarch. They aren't allowed to own horses of value or speak their native tongue. The penalty for violating these rules is, at best, a savage whipping—which a horrified Anson watches a hedge master receive one day in the public square—and at worst, deportation to the Australian prison colony, or death. Anson isn't the only Fencible unsure the British are doing the right thing by the Irish: Corporal Oakes, Lieutenant Fielding, even Colonel Staplyton waver in their certainty. But being a Fencible means loyalty to the crown, and Anson is determined to make his father proud.
When Anson sees an Irish farmer and his son executed over a property dispute, he's faced with a decision: redouble his commitment to the Fencibles no matter how his conscience protests, or risk soiling the Staplyton name by dissenting from British political dogma. Anson finds himself mingling with Irish outlaws, including Sorcha O'Leary, a girl who shows him the beauty of Ireland's hidden places and what it's like to be educated in secret for fear of the Fencibles. The Irish are unwilling to relinquish their cultural heritage even if the crown demands they do so. Violent rebellion is coming, and Anson is torn between defending his friends who wear the red coat of the Fencibles, or Sorcha and the downtrodden Irish who only wish to be left alone. Can Anson walk the thin line and not betray either side, or will he inevitably have to choose between family honor and moral responsibility to an afflicted people?
Who is Anson, if not a Fencible? What else can he aspire to be? "You are to be Anson Staplyton," an Irish hedge master answers him. "Plant your own hedgerow. Plant it and pray God it leads as straight and true as ever it might in this tired old world." The only way to move confidently into an uncertain future is to plant your row as evenly as possible and hope the earnest effort leads where you intend to go. Anson's Way showcases Gary D. Schmidt's splendid facility with words, which contain a weight and beauty that most authors' don't have, though his later novels are crisper, wiser, and more emotionally affecting. A Historical Note at the end of this one would have helped put the story in context. Anson's Way is one of Gary D. Schmidt's early works, and he went on to have a distinguished career in juvenile literature. I particularly recommend his books from five or ten years later.