I was one of the thousands who watched The Willis Clan on TLC, and their audition on America's Got Talent captivated me immediately. When I heard about Toby's arrest, I was shocked and grieved. Here was yet another professed Christian exposed as a liar and a fraud. When I learned that Jessica was releasing a book, I couldn't wait to get my hands on it.
I really wanted to give this book 5 stars, but I couldn't for two reasons.
First, this book is a hard, hard read. If you have any history of sexual or physical abuse, this book will no doubt trigger memories and feelings that are painful. Immediately, starting with the prologue, I was swept away and into Jessica's world. In small ways, I related to her story. I was raised in a semi-large, musical, homeschooling, Christian family too. For most of my life, I also traveled in a bus with my family to sing and play. However, I never experienced abuse like her, her siblings, and her mother, and reading about their life was nauseating and difficult. Most nights as I sat reading, tears were in my eyes and a knot was in my stomach. While I couldn't seem to put the book down, it is raw and graphic, and not at all a pleasant read.
Second, while I appreciated the honesty with which Jessica shares her confusion regarding faith, the book ended without a clear, concise explanation of the God of the Bible. Chapter after chapter, Jessica empties her heart, sharing her struggles with misinterpreted Scriptures that had been used to abuse and destroy. I appreciated her vulnerability in sharing her journey with the world, relating to her frantic search to disentangle truth from error, but I closed the book saddened because the conclusion was vague and incomplete.
I'll say what the book should have: The problem wasn't the Scriptures, the problem was the mishandling of the Scriptures. The problem was a man - Toby - professing to be a follower of God and touting Bible truths, half-truths, and outright lies, while habitually living in opposition to everything that God defines as a Christian. The Biblical God is a God of holiness and righteousness who WILL execute justice, yet He is also a God of great love and mercy and grace. A one-sided Christianity isn't Biblical Christianity. While I'm grateful for therapy and the common graces we have to aid in healing, Jessica's ultimate freedom, and power, and rest is, and will always only be, at the cross.
This book was well-written, articulate, vulnerable, and full of passion, but it would have delivered the hope that people need if it had ended with praise to God for being everything that her father is NOT, instead of vaguely mentioned as if He were a carry-on in her suitcase for her journey. God sustained Jessica, and I hope and pray that she will see that and feel His love and grace.
2.5 stars.