This is the kind of book that makes you realize that fiction can teach you more than facts can. I’ve read everything I can get my hands on by Gautreaux, and this book ranks up with the best.
There are 21 stories here, some drawn from earlier collections (Same Place, Same Things and Welding with Children). The tone is mostly down, but with heart. It’s that hard thud of realization, about how the world really is and about what kind of person you really are. Gautreaux likes to focus on the drama of unremarkable lives — a furnace repairman, a junkyard owner, an exterminator — and show that drama. What is an unremarkable life in the big picture is a drama in which things matter enormously on their own stage.
The most poignant of the stories, for me, may be The Furnace Man’s Lament. Mel Todd is a furnace repairman in ice-cold Minnesota. His life is punctuated by calls from desperate homeowners in the throes of freezing weather with broken heating systems. And he does his best to help. But when a teenager, Jack, is orphaned by the death of his grandfather in a dilapidated, heatless house, Todd does only his best. He doesn’t take the opportunity to take Jack in to his family. He gives Jack a job, and he supports him emotionally as well as he can, but that’s as far as he will go. When Jack makes his own choices in life, Todd bears the consequences of his holding back. He did nothing wrong, Jack does nothing wrong, but that missed opportunity will haunt him. Jack will be fine, more than fine, but he won’t be part of Todd’s life.
Sometimes Gautreaux can be unrelenting. Sympathetic characters don’t always enjoy happy endings. But that’s not the point. Happy endings can not only be unrealistic, they can be boring. Boring because they fail to surface the mixture of effort, courage, failure, injustice, and chance that makes our lives take the course that they take. Sometimes you do the best that you can do, or you fail to do the best that you can do. And sometimes your efforts fail or succeed through no fault or virtue of your own. Regardless, it’s the real drama of a real life.
After I’ve read Gautreaux’s stories, I feel as though I’m better equipped to try to live a good life, to accept my own failures, and to take the consequences.