What do you think?
A Soul Reaping Gone Wrong
Just when Katha thinks nothing could be worse than betrayal and heartbreak, the universe sends an unexpected twist her way – death. Katha cannot stay in Nasayan, the afterlife, because she has been reaped before her time. Unfortunately, she can't be sent back either, because she knows what comes after death. Varuna knows he reaped Katha's soul as per the rules. Then, why the error? He knows he has been framed and must figure out why. The Reaper is determined to return Katha to her time. But is it even possible? Can he return Katha to Earth, and unearth what went wrong before more souls are left in limbo?
And, what of Katha? Why was she a target? Can she erase her time in Nasayan? Can time be reset? Or, will she always remain in limbo?
And, what of Katha? Why was she a target? Can she erase her time in Nasayan? Can time be reset? Or, will she always remain in limbo?
463 pages, Paperback
Published June 24, 2022
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 45 reviews
September 5, 2025
When I picked up A Soul Reaping Gone Wrong, I didn’t expect it to be completely pulled into a world that felt haunting, emotional, and impossible to leave behind.
The story begins with Katha who's broken, betrayed, and longing for peace. But instead of finding rest, she wakes up in Nasayan, the afterlife. The catch? She was never meant to be there. That idea alone being a mistake in the universe chilled me. And then came Varuna, the reaper whose path collides with hers, and suddenly the story became so much more than I imagined.
What kept me hooked was how fast-paced yet deeply layered it was. The chapters made me tear through it, but the emotions slowed me down, forcing me to pause and think. The afterlife was described as some faraway myth; it felt real, alive, unsettling in the best way. And at the heart of it all were two characters who felt so human in their struggles that I couldn’t stop rooting for them.
For me, this book was about choice, grief, second chances, and the terrifying idea of what happens when fate gets it wrong. The twists kept surprising me, but it was the questions the book left me with is Can a mistake be undone? Can a soul find its way back? Or does destiny always win?
I closed this book feeling both satisfied and unsettled, which is exactly what I want from a story like this. It’s gripping, it’s thought-provoking, and it proves that Indian fantasy can be every bit as bold and imaginative as anything on the shelves today.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️.5 / 5 — a haunting, unique, and unforgettable read.
The story begins with Katha who's broken, betrayed, and longing for peace. But instead of finding rest, she wakes up in Nasayan, the afterlife. The catch? She was never meant to be there. That idea alone being a mistake in the universe chilled me. And then came Varuna, the reaper whose path collides with hers, and suddenly the story became so much more than I imagined.
What kept me hooked was how fast-paced yet deeply layered it was. The chapters made me tear through it, but the emotions slowed me down, forcing me to pause and think. The afterlife was described as some faraway myth; it felt real, alive, unsettling in the best way. And at the heart of it all were two characters who felt so human in their struggles that I couldn’t stop rooting for them.
For me, this book was about choice, grief, second chances, and the terrifying idea of what happens when fate gets it wrong. The twists kept surprising me, but it was the questions the book left me with is Can a mistake be undone? Can a soul find its way back? Or does destiny always win?
I closed this book feeling both satisfied and unsettled, which is exactly what I want from a story like this. It’s gripping, it’s thought-provoking, and it proves that Indian fantasy can be every bit as bold and imaginative as anything on the shelves today.
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️.5 / 5 — a haunting, unique, and unforgettable read.
December 10, 2025
3.5/5✨
A Soul Reapening Gone Wrong is a YA gothic fantasy book, and I had such a good time reading it😍🥰
This book has the greatest found-family vibes.🎉😍
I absolutely loved the friendships and the bonding between the characters, and honestly, I’m still missing all of them. 😆🥰❤️
The character development was beautiful, and these characters are definitely going to stay with me forever. ❤️💯
At first, the pacing felt a bit slow for me, but once it picked up, the story became interesting and entertaining. The writing and language were easy to follow and nicely done. I was fully invested-though somewhere in the middle I got a little lost, and it felt like something was missing. Some parts also became a bit predictable.
The story and world-building lacked a bit of depth, and I found myself wanting more from the world. But overall, I had a really good reading experience, and I’m definitely excited for the next book😊🎉
So if you love YA fantasy with magical creatures, enchanting forests, mermaids, unforgettable characters, the chosen one trope, beautiful friendships, and a fast-paced plot, you should definitely pick this one up.💯😍
A Soul Reapening Gone Wrong is a YA gothic fantasy book, and I had such a good time reading it😍🥰
This book has the greatest found-family vibes.🎉😍
I absolutely loved the friendships and the bonding between the characters, and honestly, I’m still missing all of them. 😆🥰❤️
The character development was beautiful, and these characters are definitely going to stay with me forever. ❤️💯
At first, the pacing felt a bit slow for me, but once it picked up, the story became interesting and entertaining. The writing and language were easy to follow and nicely done. I was fully invested-though somewhere in the middle I got a little lost, and it felt like something was missing. Some parts also became a bit predictable.
The story and world-building lacked a bit of depth, and I found myself wanting more from the world. But overall, I had a really good reading experience, and I’m definitely excited for the next book😊🎉
So if you love YA fantasy with magical creatures, enchanting forests, mermaids, unforgettable characters, the chosen one trope, beautiful friendships, and a fast-paced plot, you should definitely pick this one up.💯😍
June 28, 2025
A Soul Reaping Gone Wrong is a fantasy novel by Rosheena Zehra that revolves around Katha, who dies unexpectedly and arrives in Nasayan, a realm where she cannot stay because her soul has been reaped before its time. Varuna, the reaper, believes he followed the rules. So, was he framed? To find out what happens, you have to read the book.
Firstly, kudos to the author for writing a fantasy novel because I rarely come across fantasy novels written by Indian authors. I loved how she developed and fleshed out all the characters. Each chapter has a title that gives a hint of what is to come. Although the novel is quite lengthy, the chapters are short and action-packed, which kept me hooked from start to finish.
The world-building is imaginative and well thought-out, making the story even more engaging. I highly recommend the book to readers who enjoy the fantasy genre.
Firstly, kudos to the author for writing a fantasy novel because I rarely come across fantasy novels written by Indian authors. I loved how she developed and fleshed out all the characters. Each chapter has a title that gives a hint of what is to come. Although the novel is quite lengthy, the chapters are short and action-packed, which kept me hooked from start to finish.
The world-building is imaginative and well thought-out, making the story even more engaging. I highly recommend the book to readers who enjoy the fantasy genre.
November 10, 2025
What did I just read🥺💗
The story is expertly woven with multiple POVs, which kept me hooked from start to end. The blurb and the title drew me in, but the author's vivid and picturesque narration truly kept me turning the pages✨️ This is definitely one of those books that totally engulfs you in right from the first page and leaves you wanting more.
The world-building is incredibly done, with a rich tapestry of mythical creatures (including centaurs, merfolk, fairies, elves, and a lot more)✨️The plot is packed with action, suspense and emotional moments that will leave you breathless🥶
What I truly adored about this book is its focus on Friendship, Hope, Trust, Grief and Resilience. Absolutely adored the strong FMC and loved the fact that equal importance is given to all the characters which added a layer of depth to the plot !!
The bond shared between Arjun and Varuna is underrated and priceless🤍Definitely an unforgettable read for me! If you're looking for a fantasy book that will keep you on the edge of your seat and leave you feeling inspired, look no further!
The story is expertly woven with multiple POVs, which kept me hooked from start to end. The blurb and the title drew me in, but the author's vivid and picturesque narration truly kept me turning the pages✨️ This is definitely one of those books that totally engulfs you in right from the first page and leaves you wanting more.
The world-building is incredibly done, with a rich tapestry of mythical creatures (including centaurs, merfolk, fairies, elves, and a lot more)✨️The plot is packed with action, suspense and emotional moments that will leave you breathless🥶
What I truly adored about this book is its focus on Friendship, Hope, Trust, Grief and Resilience. Absolutely adored the strong FMC and loved the fact that equal importance is given to all the characters which added a layer of depth to the plot !!
The bond shared between Arjun and Varuna is underrated and priceless🤍Definitely an unforgettable read for me! If you're looking for a fantasy book that will keep you on the edge of your seat and leave you feeling inspired, look no further!
December 15, 2025
I didn’t just read this book.
I fell into it—and once I did, I couldn’t climb back out.
From the very first page, the story wraps itself around a feeling I didn’t know how to name but have carried for years: restlessness that doesn’t come from wanting more, but from feeling slightly misplaced in what you already have. The protagonist’s thoughts move the way real thoughts do—messy, circular, half-finished. Insomnia, strange dreams, an odd sense of familiarity with something unknown, the dull comfort of coffee, the quiet pressure of friends who mean well but don’t quite understand. It all feels achingly human. There is no rush to explain, no dramatic hook screaming for attention. Instead, the story leans in close and whispers, “You’ve felt this too, haven’t you?”
What struck me most was how gently it normalizes alienation. Not the loud, tragic kind—but the everyday version. Going to work. Meeting people. Laughing at the right moments. Pretending that this rhythm is enough. The writing captures that hollow space between “I should be fine” and “why don’t I feel like I belong anywhere?” with frightening accuracy. Even the smallest details—zoning out mid-conversation, forgetting names, fixating on sensations like taste and warmth—feel intentional, like breadcrumbs leading toward something bigger without ever spelling it out.
And then there’s the subtle hint of the unreal. Fire imagined between palms. A dream that refuses to stay a dream. A sense that reality itself might be slightly misaligned. The book doesn’t shove fantasy at you—it lets it seep in slowly, the way strange thoughts do at three in the morning when you’re exhausted and alone with yourself. By the time you realize something is off, you’re already too emotionally invested to step back.
What makes this book unforgettable is its refusal to offer easy answers. Not everything is fixed. Not every wound is healed. The questions remain, heavy and unresolved — but there is strength in that honesty. There is something deeply brave about choosing awareness over comfort, truth over illusion. By the end, it doesn’t feel like finishing a story. It feels like surviving a reckoning.
This is not a book you casually recommend.
This is the kind of book you press into someone’s hands and say,
“Read this. Trust me.”
If you’ve ever felt detached from your own life, if you’ve ever followed all the rules and still felt wrong, if you’ve ever wondered whether you were meant for something else but couldn’t name it—this book will haunt you in the best way possible.
I closed it and immediately wanted to start over.
And if you’re reading this review right now, wondering whether it’s worth your time—
it already has you.
I fell into it—and once I did, I couldn’t climb back out.
From the very first page, the story wraps itself around a feeling I didn’t know how to name but have carried for years: restlessness that doesn’t come from wanting more, but from feeling slightly misplaced in what you already have. The protagonist’s thoughts move the way real thoughts do—messy, circular, half-finished. Insomnia, strange dreams, an odd sense of familiarity with something unknown, the dull comfort of coffee, the quiet pressure of friends who mean well but don’t quite understand. It all feels achingly human. There is no rush to explain, no dramatic hook screaming for attention. Instead, the story leans in close and whispers, “You’ve felt this too, haven’t you?”
What struck me most was how gently it normalizes alienation. Not the loud, tragic kind—but the everyday version. Going to work. Meeting people. Laughing at the right moments. Pretending that this rhythm is enough. The writing captures that hollow space between “I should be fine” and “why don’t I feel like I belong anywhere?” with frightening accuracy. Even the smallest details—zoning out mid-conversation, forgetting names, fixating on sensations like taste and warmth—feel intentional, like breadcrumbs leading toward something bigger without ever spelling it out.
And then there’s the subtle hint of the unreal. Fire imagined between palms. A dream that refuses to stay a dream. A sense that reality itself might be slightly misaligned. The book doesn’t shove fantasy at you—it lets it seep in slowly, the way strange thoughts do at three in the morning when you’re exhausted and alone with yourself. By the time you realize something is off, you’re already too emotionally invested to step back.
What makes this book unforgettable is its refusal to offer easy answers. Not everything is fixed. Not every wound is healed. The questions remain, heavy and unresolved — but there is strength in that honesty. There is something deeply brave about choosing awareness over comfort, truth over illusion. By the end, it doesn’t feel like finishing a story. It feels like surviving a reckoning.
This is not a book you casually recommend.
This is the kind of book you press into someone’s hands and say,
“Read this. Trust me.”
If you’ve ever felt detached from your own life, if you’ve ever followed all the rules and still felt wrong, if you’ve ever wondered whether you were meant for something else but couldn’t name it—this book will haunt you in the best way possible.
I closed it and immediately wanted to start over.
And if you’re reading this review right now, wondering whether it’s worth your time—
it already has you.
August 14, 2026
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 5/5
I came for the soul-reaping mystery and fantasy world building, but stayed for the premise that made me question about life, death, the possibility of a second chance, concept of time, choice, and whether things that go wrong can ever truly be undone.
The premise immediately caught my attention. Katha is not supposed to be dead. She has been reaped before her time and wakes up in Nasayan, the afterlife, carrying knowledge she was never meant to have. She cannot return to the normal cycle of death because she knows too much, but she cannot simply be sent back to Earth either. And Varuna, the reaper responsible for her soul, knows he followed the rules. So how did this happen? Did the system falter? Or did someone else intervene?
That question kept pulling me deeper.
What I particularly loved was that the book never treats its afterlife setting as just a backdrop for the mystery. Nasayan feels like a place with its own rules, consequences, and order, and Katha's very existence there becomes a problem that someone has to solve. The idea of a soul being caught between worlds creates this constant feeling of uncertainty that is how you know something has gone terribly wrong, but you don't know how far-reaching that mistake is going to be.
Katha also makes the story much more than a supernatural mystery. Her situation is terrifying, but there is something deeply emotional about watching someone who has already experienced betrayal and heartbreak suddenly have to confront death itself, especially when even death has not gone according to plan.
And Varuna was such an interesting part of the story for me. He isn't simply a mysterious reaper who appears to move the plot forward. His certainty that he did everything correctly, followed by the realization that he may have been framed, gives the mystery another layer. His determination to find the mistake and return Katha to her rightful time creates a sense of urgency that keeps the story moving.
What stayed with me most, though, was the question underneath everything: Can time really be reset once something has gone wrong?
The book plays with that idea beautifully. If one person's death happens too early, what else changes because of it? Can you simply put a soul back where it belongs and expect everything to return to normal? Or do some mistakes permanently alter the course of a life?
I also appreciated that the story doesn't rely only on the novelty of its concept. There is genuine emotional weight behind the mystery. Katha isn't just trying to understand why she died. She is trying to understand what happens to her now, whether her life can still be reclaimed, and whether she can erase what happened in Nasayan at all.
There were moments when I genuinely had no idea where the story was heading, and that is exactly what I want from a book built around a mystery like this. The questions keep multiplying rather than disappearing, and every answer seems to open another door.
By the end, it became a story about destiny, consequences, identity, and the frightening possibility that even the systems we believe are absolute can fail, with a fantastical world building, solid characters and a storyline that will have you coming back to it not just once but again and again.
A beautifully strange, emotional, and thought-provoking read. If you enjoy fantasy with an unusual premise, afterlife mythology, mysteries, morally complicated characters, and stories that make you question the rules of life and death, this one deserves a place on your TBR.
I came for the soul-reaping mystery and fantasy world building, but stayed for the premise that made me question about life, death, the possibility of a second chance, concept of time, choice, and whether things that go wrong can ever truly be undone.
The premise immediately caught my attention. Katha is not supposed to be dead. She has been reaped before her time and wakes up in Nasayan, the afterlife, carrying knowledge she was never meant to have. She cannot return to the normal cycle of death because she knows too much, but she cannot simply be sent back to Earth either. And Varuna, the reaper responsible for her soul, knows he followed the rules. So how did this happen? Did the system falter? Or did someone else intervene?
That question kept pulling me deeper.
What I particularly loved was that the book never treats its afterlife setting as just a backdrop for the mystery. Nasayan feels like a place with its own rules, consequences, and order, and Katha's very existence there becomes a problem that someone has to solve. The idea of a soul being caught between worlds creates this constant feeling of uncertainty that is how you know something has gone terribly wrong, but you don't know how far-reaching that mistake is going to be.
Katha also makes the story much more than a supernatural mystery. Her situation is terrifying, but there is something deeply emotional about watching someone who has already experienced betrayal and heartbreak suddenly have to confront death itself, especially when even death has not gone according to plan.
And Varuna was such an interesting part of the story for me. He isn't simply a mysterious reaper who appears to move the plot forward. His certainty that he did everything correctly, followed by the realization that he may have been framed, gives the mystery another layer. His determination to find the mistake and return Katha to her rightful time creates a sense of urgency that keeps the story moving.
What stayed with me most, though, was the question underneath everything: Can time really be reset once something has gone wrong?
The book plays with that idea beautifully. If one person's death happens too early, what else changes because of it? Can you simply put a soul back where it belongs and expect everything to return to normal? Or do some mistakes permanently alter the course of a life?
I also appreciated that the story doesn't rely only on the novelty of its concept. There is genuine emotional weight behind the mystery. Katha isn't just trying to understand why she died. She is trying to understand what happens to her now, whether her life can still be reclaimed, and whether she can erase what happened in Nasayan at all.
There were moments when I genuinely had no idea where the story was heading, and that is exactly what I want from a book built around a mystery like this. The questions keep multiplying rather than disappearing, and every answer seems to open another door.
By the end, it became a story about destiny, consequences, identity, and the frightening possibility that even the systems we believe are absolute can fail, with a fantastical world building, solid characters and a storyline that will have you coming back to it not just once but again and again.
A beautifully strange, emotional, and thought-provoking read. If you enjoy fantasy with an unusual premise, afterlife mythology, mysteries, morally complicated characters, and stories that make you question the rules of life and death, this one deserves a place on your TBR.
January 7, 2026
A soul reaping gone wrong tells the story about friendship,sacrifice,destiny & determination. When the god of death reaps the wrong soul both of them has to face the consequences, yet it’s completely different for both of them Katha the girl whose soul gets reaped earlier than her said time gets stuck in a place called Nasayan that looks like the exact replica of her home back on Earth but evil lurks in every step. Katha makes out the best of her situation by befriending immortals Arjun and Kaushiky,their friendship was one of the best things about this book. Even though Katha was the mc I personally loved Kaushiky a lot more than her bcoz of her sheer determination to protect her friends at all costs,she completely won my heart when she traded her immortality for the key to hell for saving Varuna (God of death) who was framed for reaping the wrong soul.
The story focuses a lot on what comes after death and also questions our assumptions about afterlife. The world building was quite heavy on the first few chapters,it had all the elements of a fantasy land like valley of flowers,colourful lakes,fairies,elves,floating rocks called Kurmas and several immortal beings. The writing was very descriptive with multiple povs and the author deserves all the appreciation for writing such a complicated story with an engaging flow. I also loved the fact that the author gave importance to all the characters and their personal journey rather than just focusing on Katha & adding other characters in between. The fantasy and magic portions of the story was equally fascinating and added a lot more depth to the story than what I was expecting. Overall the book mixes mythology with fantasy very beautifully and I loved ever second of it. This is perfect for those who love a good mythology inspired fantasy novels.
The story focuses a lot on what comes after death and also questions our assumptions about afterlife. The world building was quite heavy on the first few chapters,it had all the elements of a fantasy land like valley of flowers,colourful lakes,fairies,elves,floating rocks called Kurmas and several immortal beings. The writing was very descriptive with multiple povs and the author deserves all the appreciation for writing such a complicated story with an engaging flow. I also loved the fact that the author gave importance to all the characters and their personal journey rather than just focusing on Katha & adding other characters in between. The fantasy and magic portions of the story was equally fascinating and added a lot more depth to the story than what I was expecting. Overall the book mixes mythology with fantasy very beautifully and I loved ever second of it. This is perfect for those who love a good mythology inspired fantasy novels.
January 11, 2026
Some tales aren’t simply read they stay with you, whispering in your thoughts long after the book is closed.A Soul Reaping Gone Wrong is one of those stories.
Katha, a young woman taken from life too soon, drifts into Nasayan—a realm where reality shimmers like a half-remembered dream. Time bends, shadows murmur, and light spills in impossible ways. Each step she takes is both fragile and fierce, fear and wonder entwined, and I felt as though I were walking beside her, suspended between life and death, between the seen and the unseen.
What touched me most was the quiet endurance of love. Maenikah’s grief, Arjun’s fragile soul teetering on the edge, and the guiding presence of Varuna and Kaushiky reminded me that even in a world ruled by cosmic laws, human connection endures. Zehra’s writing captures grief, trust, and attachment with such subtlety that every heartbeat of the characters felt like my own
The journey into Vismaran a realm of dreamlike liminality was mesmerizing. Fragile tension hangs in every corner, the kind that makes the heart tremble at the thought of being lost, left behind, or untethered. These passages urging reflection on the fleetingness of life, the weight of love, and the quiet courage it takes to hold on.
More than a fantasy adventure, this story is a meditation on life, love, grief, and the choices that shape who we are. Reading it felt like standing on the edge of two worlds, holding both wonder and heartbreak in my hands.
If you’re someone who cherishes fantasy that moves your heart as much as it sparks your imagination, who loves about love, identity, and resilience threaded through mystical worlds, then this book is the perfect choice for you.
Katha, a young woman taken from life too soon, drifts into Nasayan—a realm where reality shimmers like a half-remembered dream. Time bends, shadows murmur, and light spills in impossible ways. Each step she takes is both fragile and fierce, fear and wonder entwined, and I felt as though I were walking beside her, suspended between life and death, between the seen and the unseen.
What touched me most was the quiet endurance of love. Maenikah’s grief, Arjun’s fragile soul teetering on the edge, and the guiding presence of Varuna and Kaushiky reminded me that even in a world ruled by cosmic laws, human connection endures. Zehra’s writing captures grief, trust, and attachment with such subtlety that every heartbeat of the characters felt like my own
The journey into Vismaran a realm of dreamlike liminality was mesmerizing. Fragile tension hangs in every corner, the kind that makes the heart tremble at the thought of being lost, left behind, or untethered. These passages urging reflection on the fleetingness of life, the weight of love, and the quiet courage it takes to hold on.
More than a fantasy adventure, this story is a meditation on life, love, grief, and the choices that shape who we are. Reading it felt like standing on the edge of two worlds, holding both wonder and heartbreak in my hands.
If you’re someone who cherishes fantasy that moves your heart as much as it sparks your imagination, who loves about love, identity, and resilience threaded through mystical worlds, then this book is the perfect choice for you.
August 3, 2026
A Soul Reaping Gone Wrong was one of those books that completely caught me by surprise.
The premise alone had me hooked: what happens when a soul is reaped before its destined time? When Katha finds herself trapped in Nasayan after being mistakenly taken by a soul reaper, she becomes entangled in a mystery far bigger than a simple error. What follows is a fascinating journey filled with secrets, revelations, and questions that kept me turning pages late into the night.
One of my favorite aspects of the book was its originality. The concept felt fresh and unlike anything I've read before. The world of Nasayan was beautifully imagined, and I loved discovering its rules, mysteries, and hidden truths alongside the characters.
The pacing was another major highlight. Every chapter left me wanting more, and I found it almost impossible to put the book down. Just when I thought I had figured something out, the story would reveal another layer of the mystery.
I also grew incredibly attached to the characters. Katha's journey was compelling, Varuna's determination to uncover the truth kept me invested, and Kaushiky quickly became one of my favorite characters because of her kindness, strength, and selflessness.
What started as a mistake in death slowly unfolded into something much bigger, and I loved watching all the pieces come together.
If you're a fan of fantasy, unique magical worlds, intriguing mysteries, and characters you'll genuinely care about, I would highly recommend picking this one up.
And now comes the hardest part, waiting for book two.
A Soul Reaping Gone Wrong delivered an imaginative world, memorable characters, and a story that kept me hooked from beginning to end. I cannot wait to return to Nasayan.
The premise alone had me hooked: what happens when a soul is reaped before its destined time? When Katha finds herself trapped in Nasayan after being mistakenly taken by a soul reaper, she becomes entangled in a mystery far bigger than a simple error. What follows is a fascinating journey filled with secrets, revelations, and questions that kept me turning pages late into the night.
One of my favorite aspects of the book was its originality. The concept felt fresh and unlike anything I've read before. The world of Nasayan was beautifully imagined, and I loved discovering its rules, mysteries, and hidden truths alongside the characters.
The pacing was another major highlight. Every chapter left me wanting more, and I found it almost impossible to put the book down. Just when I thought I had figured something out, the story would reveal another layer of the mystery.
I also grew incredibly attached to the characters. Katha's journey was compelling, Varuna's determination to uncover the truth kept me invested, and Kaushiky quickly became one of my favorite characters because of her kindness, strength, and selflessness.
What started as a mistake in death slowly unfolded into something much bigger, and I loved watching all the pieces come together.
If you're a fan of fantasy, unique magical worlds, intriguing mysteries, and characters you'll genuinely care about, I would highly recommend picking this one up.
And now comes the hardest part, waiting for book two.
A Soul Reaping Gone Wrong delivered an imaginative world, memorable characters, and a story that kept me hooked from beginning to end. I cannot wait to return to Nasayan.
July 16, 2026
📖 A Short Insight
This book surprised me in the best way possible. What starts as a story of betrayal and heartbreak quickly transforms into an engrossing fantasy filled with mystery, mythology, and questions about fate. The premise of an accidental death and an afterlife that isn't as perfect as it seems immediately drew me in and kept me invested until the end.
🌸 Main Highlights of the Book
The biggest strength of the story is its imaginative world-building. Nasayan, the rules governing souls, and the concept of being trapped in limbo create a fascinating backdrop for the mystery. I also enjoyed the dynamic between Katha and Varuna. While Katha struggles to understand why she became a target, Varuna's determination to uncover the truth adds tension and keeps the plot moving. The twists unfold at a steady pace, making it difficult to predict what will happen next.
💫 Author's Way of Writing, Theme and Tone
The author's writing is simple yet engaging, making it easy to immerse yourself in the story. The blend of mythology, fantasy, mystery, and subtle romance feels well-balanced without one element overshadowing another. The emotional undertones of grief, destiny, justice, and second chances add depth to the narrative, while the suspense keeps the pages turning.
📙 Conclusion and Recommendation
Overall, this was an enjoyable and imaginative read that offers more than just a fantasy adventure. It explores love, loss, and the idea that even destiny can go wrong. If you enjoy mythology-inspired fantasy, supernatural mysteries, and stories with emotional depth and intriguing twists, this book is definitely worth adding to your reading list.
This book surprised me in the best way possible. What starts as a story of betrayal and heartbreak quickly transforms into an engrossing fantasy filled with mystery, mythology, and questions about fate. The premise of an accidental death and an afterlife that isn't as perfect as it seems immediately drew me in and kept me invested until the end.
🌸 Main Highlights of the Book
The biggest strength of the story is its imaginative world-building. Nasayan, the rules governing souls, and the concept of being trapped in limbo create a fascinating backdrop for the mystery. I also enjoyed the dynamic between Katha and Varuna. While Katha struggles to understand why she became a target, Varuna's determination to uncover the truth adds tension and keeps the plot moving. The twists unfold at a steady pace, making it difficult to predict what will happen next.
💫 Author's Way of Writing, Theme and Tone
The author's writing is simple yet engaging, making it easy to immerse yourself in the story. The blend of mythology, fantasy, mystery, and subtle romance feels well-balanced without one element overshadowing another. The emotional undertones of grief, destiny, justice, and second chances add depth to the narrative, while the suspense keeps the pages turning.
📙 Conclusion and Recommendation
Overall, this was an enjoyable and imaginative read that offers more than just a fantasy adventure. It explores love, loss, and the idea that even destiny can go wrong. If you enjoy mythology-inspired fantasy, supernatural mysteries, and stories with emotional depth and intriguing twists, this book is definitely worth adding to your reading list.
August 3, 2025
You know those books that just completely change your mind about a genre? That's what
"A Soul Reaping Gone Wrong” by rosheena did for me. l've always been a little on the fence about fantasy, but this one was a total game-changer. The story kicks off with a massive cosmic screw-up: a heartbroken girl named Katha dies, but she wasn't supposed to yet. Now she's a major glitch in the system, and the reaper who took her soul, Varuna, is certain he did everything by the book. But what really hooked me was the surprising bond and friendship that blossoms between these characters amidst all the cosmic chaos.I love such stories.
As I turned the pages, I found myself getting lost in the world-building and the complexities of the characters. The author's writing is engaging AF, and the way they weave together themes of fate, reincarnation, and cosmic balanc is pure magic. I loved how the story explores the complexities of Katha and Varuna's relationship, and how their bond evolves throughout the book. What really stood out to me was the way the author balanced action, grief, and friendship - it's a delicate balance, but they pulled it off perfectly. The short chapters make it impossible to put down, and the story is full of twists and turns that keep you on the edge of your seat. Honestly, this book still haunts me - in the best way possible! The characters and story stuck with me long after I finished reading, and I'm still thinking about them. If you're looking for a book that'll leave a lasting impression, this is it.
"A Soul Reaping Gone Wrong” by rosheena did for me. l've always been a little on the fence about fantasy, but this one was a total game-changer. The story kicks off with a massive cosmic screw-up: a heartbroken girl named Katha dies, but she wasn't supposed to yet. Now she's a major glitch in the system, and the reaper who took her soul, Varuna, is certain he did everything by the book. But what really hooked me was the surprising bond and friendship that blossoms between these characters amidst all the cosmic chaos.I love such stories.
As I turned the pages, I found myself getting lost in the world-building and the complexities of the characters. The author's writing is engaging AF, and the way they weave together themes of fate, reincarnation, and cosmic balanc is pure magic. I loved how the story explores the complexities of Katha and Varuna's relationship, and how their bond evolves throughout the book. What really stood out to me was the way the author balanced action, grief, and friendship - it's a delicate balance, but they pulled it off perfectly. The short chapters make it impossible to put down, and the story is full of twists and turns that keep you on the edge of your seat. Honestly, this book still haunts me - in the best way possible! The characters and story stuck with me long after I finished reading, and I'm still thinking about them. If you're looking for a book that'll leave a lasting impression, this is it.
May 11, 2026
A Soul Reaping Gone Wrong felt less like reading a fantasy novel and more like stepping into a strange, haunting world where life, death, and destiny all blur together.
The story starts with one mistake that Katha’s soul is taken before its destined time and from there, it unfolds into something much deeper than I expected. It’s not just about the afterlife or fantasy realms, but also about grief, purpose, and understanding where we truly belong.
I really loved how immersive the world-building was. The unfamiliar realms, mythological elements, and dreamlike atmosphere made every chapter feel vivid and almost surreal. It had that kind of storytelling where you feel like you’re living inside the book instead of just reading it.
What stayed with me the most was how beautifully it explored fate and free will. It makes you think about how one small mistake can change everything, and how fragile the balance of life really is. Beyond the fantasy, there’s a strong emotional depth that makes the story feel very real.
Some scenes genuinely lingered in my mind even after I finished the book, and that’s always a sign of a good read for me. It’s dark, atmospheric, emotional, and quietly philosophical.
Not big fan of fantasy personally but this one was totally worth reading.
⭐ Rating: 3.5/5
I’d definitely recommend it to anyone who enjoys fantasy that isn’t just about magic and adventure, but also about emotions, questions, and the kind of stories that stay with you long after the last page.
The story starts with one mistake that Katha’s soul is taken before its destined time and from there, it unfolds into something much deeper than I expected. It’s not just about the afterlife or fantasy realms, but also about grief, purpose, and understanding where we truly belong.
I really loved how immersive the world-building was. The unfamiliar realms, mythological elements, and dreamlike atmosphere made every chapter feel vivid and almost surreal. It had that kind of storytelling where you feel like you’re living inside the book instead of just reading it.
What stayed with me the most was how beautifully it explored fate and free will. It makes you think about how one small mistake can change everything, and how fragile the balance of life really is. Beyond the fantasy, there’s a strong emotional depth that makes the story feel very real.
Some scenes genuinely lingered in my mind even after I finished the book, and that’s always a sign of a good read for me. It’s dark, atmospheric, emotional, and quietly philosophical.
Not big fan of fantasy personally but this one was totally worth reading.
⭐ Rating: 3.5/5
I’d definitely recommend it to anyone who enjoys fantasy that isn’t just about magic and adventure, but also about emotions, questions, and the kind of stories that stay with you long after the last page.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
September 20, 2025
A Soul Reaping Gone Wrong by Rosheena Zehra tracks Katha, a young girl who dies prematurely and finds herself in Nasayan, the afterlife. She wasn't supposed to be there, though, and her arrival disrupts the balance of everything. Varuna, the reaper in charge, has to determine why this went wrong and whether or not he can make things right. A combination of mystery, magic, and battling against fate ensues.
honestly, this book was like entering a movie. The author writes so vividly that I was able to imagine every scene play out in my mind. It is easy for beginners and the words are basic, so even if you have not read a lot of books, you will not get lost or confused. The short chapters keep you guessing and make it extremely easy to binge read. My favorite thing is the way the action and emotion are balanced within the story. It's not simply about fantasy beings or the rules of the afterlife, it's also about sorrow, decisions, and do-overs. Katha and Varuna's story seemed so authentic that I couldn't help but be rooting for them. The pace is fast, but the novel also forces you to take a step back and consider life, death, and destiny.
If you're after an Indian fantasy that's new, well written, and easy to follow, this is it. It's emotional, evocative, and full of twists that make you keep turning the pages. The tale stays with you long after you finish reading, leaving you to ponder destiny and second chances. A ride that's not soon forgotten.
honestly, this book was like entering a movie. The author writes so vividly that I was able to imagine every scene play out in my mind. It is easy for beginners and the words are basic, so even if you have not read a lot of books, you will not get lost or confused. The short chapters keep you guessing and make it extremely easy to binge read. My favorite thing is the way the action and emotion are balanced within the story. It's not simply about fantasy beings or the rules of the afterlife, it's also about sorrow, decisions, and do-overs. Katha and Varuna's story seemed so authentic that I couldn't help but be rooting for them. The pace is fast, but the novel also forces you to take a step back and consider life, death, and destiny.
If you're after an Indian fantasy that's new, well written, and easy to follow, this is it. It's emotional, evocative, and full of twists that make you keep turning the pages. The tale stays with you long after you finish reading, leaving you to ponder destiny and second chances. A ride that's not soon forgotten.
November 10, 2025
Finally a fantasy fiction that gives us a glimpse of afterlife and the in-between/the limbo (a magical realm comprising elves, fairies, talking frogs, unicorns and
what not）!
- The story revolves around Katha, who recently got her heart broken and was trying to cope up with it.
One day, as per her friend's suggestion, she goes to a party only to have her heart ripped again (figuratively-sees her boyfriend already moved on)
Devastated, she runs away from the party, unaware that not only her heart; but her soul is also going to get reaped by the ripper literally) , when she meets with an accident.
Katha finds herself in a place which looks familiar but doesn't feel the same & is accompanied by a strange man, Varuna (the soul reaper).
To add to her misery, Varuna confesses that there has been a glitch and it wasn't her time yet!!! ( See, even Gods can make a mistake) i
While Varuna contemplates the reason of this grave mistake; Katha is left thinking if there any way she can go back to Earth or will she be stuck in Nasayan (the limbo) forever?
Rosheena has a vivid imagination and has curated
the details impeccably well!
You will notice the minute details she has given a lot of thought to; for example, when she addressed goddesses as Lord in her story, emphasising on the fact that all royalty is addressed as Lord irrespective of the gender.
A unputdownable read
Pick it up if you enjoy fantasy fiction or want to explore new genres!
what not）!
- The story revolves around Katha, who recently got her heart broken and was trying to cope up with it.
One day, as per her friend's suggestion, she goes to a party only to have her heart ripped again (figuratively-sees her boyfriend already moved on)
Devastated, she runs away from the party, unaware that not only her heart; but her soul is also going to get reaped by the ripper literally) , when she meets with an accident.
Katha finds herself in a place which looks familiar but doesn't feel the same & is accompanied by a strange man, Varuna (the soul reaper).
To add to her misery, Varuna confesses that there has been a glitch and it wasn't her time yet!!! ( See, even Gods can make a mistake) i
While Varuna contemplates the reason of this grave mistake; Katha is left thinking if there any way she can go back to Earth or will she be stuck in Nasayan (the limbo) forever?
Rosheena has a vivid imagination and has curated
the details impeccably well!
You will notice the minute details she has given a lot of thought to; for example, when she addressed goddesses as Lord in her story, emphasising on the fact that all royalty is addressed as Lord irrespective of the gender.
A unputdownable read
Pick it up if you enjoy fantasy fiction or want to explore new genres!
January 13, 2026
A Soul Reaping Gone Wrong by Rosheena Zehra is a welcome entry into a place of magic that draws heavily upon Indian imagination. With mermaid, centaurs, elf, flying turtle, and fairy elements, it is clear that there is much more to the narrative than meets the surface level.
A Soul Reaping Gone Wrong introduces Katha, a soul whose reaping by Varuna is premature, causing her to be neither here nor there, in either the world of Nasayan, which is the afterlife. Instead, her questions turn into discoveries.
A tragic error morphs gradually into something far larger on its scale. A realization sets in that Nasayan itself is at risk, and that our protagonist may be the only one to bring counterbalance. I thoroughly enjoyed how it seamlessly weaved magical quests and emotions of belonging, duty, and loyalty. Friendships in this story appear quite authentic, and no detail goes unexplored in terms of building this fantasy world of theirs. It was like observing a fantasy show playing out, episode by episode, and chapter by chapter.
The writing style itself flows well, which lends to the story being an easy, though immersive, read for those who love fantasy. Additionally, it’s great to see fantasy elements blended with Indian mythology inspired settings.
✨ A magical and heartfelt fantasy that offers adventure, emotion and imagination in equal measure. Perfect for readers who enjoy rich fantasy worlds with a strong emotional core.
A Soul Reaping Gone Wrong introduces Katha, a soul whose reaping by Varuna is premature, causing her to be neither here nor there, in either the world of Nasayan, which is the afterlife. Instead, her questions turn into discoveries.
A tragic error morphs gradually into something far larger on its scale. A realization sets in that Nasayan itself is at risk, and that our protagonist may be the only one to bring counterbalance. I thoroughly enjoyed how it seamlessly weaved magical quests and emotions of belonging, duty, and loyalty. Friendships in this story appear quite authentic, and no detail goes unexplored in terms of building this fantasy world of theirs. It was like observing a fantasy show playing out, episode by episode, and chapter by chapter.
The writing style itself flows well, which lends to the story being an easy, though immersive, read for those who love fantasy. Additionally, it’s great to see fantasy elements blended with Indian mythology inspired settings.
✨ A magical and heartfelt fantasy that offers adventure, emotion and imagination in equal measure. Perfect for readers who enjoy rich fantasy worlds with a strong emotional core.
June 2, 2026
4.7/5
A Soul Reaping Gone Wrong wasn’t just a fantasy novel for me—it was an experience.
I went into this book expecting an interesting afterlife story, but what I found was so much more. Katha’s journey hit hard because before she even dies, life has already broken her heart in ways that feel painfully real. Watching her wake up in Nasayan and discover that her death was literally a cosmic mistake instantly pulled me into the story.
What I loved most was the world-building. Nasayan isn’t the dreamy afterlife we’re used to seeing. It’s a cold, organized system where every soul is a file and every death is scheduled. One tiny error creates chaos, and suddenly Katha is trapped between life and death with nowhere to belong.
And then there’s Varuna…
At first, he seems distant, strict, and emotionally unavailable—a reaper obsessed with rules. But beneath that stoic exterior is someone deeply honorable and protective. The slow evolution of Katha and Varuna’s relationship was my favorite part of the book. Their trust feels earned, their connection feels genuine, and every interaction carries emotional weight.
The mystery, the conspiracy, the emotional healing, the tension, and the atmosphere all blend together beautifully. This story constantly asks whether fate is fixed or whether we can fight for a different ending.
Dark, emotional, immersive, and unforgettable—this is a book that stayed with me long after I turned the final page…
A Soul Reaping Gone Wrong wasn’t just a fantasy novel for me—it was an experience.
I went into this book expecting an interesting afterlife story, but what I found was so much more. Katha’s journey hit hard because before she even dies, life has already broken her heart in ways that feel painfully real. Watching her wake up in Nasayan and discover that her death was literally a cosmic mistake instantly pulled me into the story.
What I loved most was the world-building. Nasayan isn’t the dreamy afterlife we’re used to seeing. It’s a cold, organized system where every soul is a file and every death is scheduled. One tiny error creates chaos, and suddenly Katha is trapped between life and death with nowhere to belong.
And then there’s Varuna…
At first, he seems distant, strict, and emotionally unavailable—a reaper obsessed with rules. But beneath that stoic exterior is someone deeply honorable and protective. The slow evolution of Katha and Varuna’s relationship was my favorite part of the book. Their trust feels earned, their connection feels genuine, and every interaction carries emotional weight.
The mystery, the conspiracy, the emotional healing, the tension, and the atmosphere all blend together beautifully. This story constantly asks whether fate is fixed or whether we can fight for a different ending.
Dark, emotional, immersive, and unforgettable—this is a book that stayed with me long after I turned the final page…
July 31, 2026
“What if death wasn’t the end… but the beginning of the biggest mistake?”
This book immediately pulled me in with its fascinating premise, a soul reaped before its destined time, an eerie limbo called Nasayan, and a mystery that unfolds between life and death. It beautifully blends fantasy, mythology, mystery, and emotion into a story that’s both thought-provoking and immersive.
The world-building is one of its greatest strengths. Nasayan feels haunting, surreal, and unlike anything I’ve read recently. Rosheena Zehra’s writing has a lyrical quality that makes every page feel atmospheric, while the emotional journey of the characters keeps the story grounded.
The pacing is more gradual than action-packed, allowing the mystery and mythology to develop naturally. If you’re someone who enjoys richly imagined fantasy worlds and stories that make you reflect long after you’ve finished reading, this one deserves a spot on your TBR.
✨ What I Loved:
🤍 Original afterlife concept
🌌 Beautifully immersive world-building
🖋️ Poetic and engaging writing
💙 Emotional character arcs
🔮 A compelling blend of fantasy and mystery
⚠️ Things to Keep in Mind:
The middle slows down a little as the world and its rules are explored, but it pays off if you enjoy character-driven fantasy.
⭐ Final Rating: 4.5/5
If you’re a fan of books that explore life, death, fate, mythology, and second chances, I definitely recommend giving A Soul Reaping Gone Wrong a try.
This book immediately pulled me in with its fascinating premise, a soul reaped before its destined time, an eerie limbo called Nasayan, and a mystery that unfolds between life and death. It beautifully blends fantasy, mythology, mystery, and emotion into a story that’s both thought-provoking and immersive.
The world-building is one of its greatest strengths. Nasayan feels haunting, surreal, and unlike anything I’ve read recently. Rosheena Zehra’s writing has a lyrical quality that makes every page feel atmospheric, while the emotional journey of the characters keeps the story grounded.
The pacing is more gradual than action-packed, allowing the mystery and mythology to develop naturally. If you’re someone who enjoys richly imagined fantasy worlds and stories that make you reflect long after you’ve finished reading, this one deserves a spot on your TBR.
✨ What I Loved:
🤍 Original afterlife concept
🌌 Beautifully immersive world-building
🖋️ Poetic and engaging writing
💙 Emotional character arcs
🔮 A compelling blend of fantasy and mystery
⚠️ Things to Keep in Mind:
The middle slows down a little as the world and its rules are explored, but it pays off if you enjoy character-driven fantasy.
⭐ Final Rating: 4.5/5
If you’re a fan of books that explore life, death, fate, mythology, and second chances, I definitely recommend giving A Soul Reaping Gone Wrong a try.
August 14, 2025
A Soul Reaping Gone Wrong hooked me from the very first chapter.The premise is fresh and intriguing.Katha’s accidental death and arrival in Nasayan,a realm where souls go after death,immediately sets the tone for a thought-provoking yet comforting fantasy.I loved how the story weaves together themes of fate,cosmic balance and the ripple effects of one unexpected mistake,while also grounding itself in very human themes of grief,friendship and purpose.
.
.
Rosheena’s writing is clear,accessible and beautifully paced.She doesn’t overwhelm the reader with complex lore instead,she allows you to explore this new realm alongside Katha,making you feel every moment of her emotional journey.I particularly appreciated how the fantastical elements never overshadowed the heart of the story and Katha’s internal struggle remains the emotional anchor throughout the book.
.
.
While the plot was engaging and the characters memorable,I did find myself wanting a bit more depth in certain world-building aspects,especially regarding Nasayan’s rules and the consequences of such cosmic mistakes.That said,the balance between light storytelling and deeper themes makes this a wonderful read for both seasoned fantasy fans and those new to the genre.
.
.
Overall,it's a heartfelt,page-turning fantasy that lingers long after you close the last page.I recommend this masterpiece to all the readers out there!🤍
.
.
Rosheena’s writing is clear,accessible and beautifully paced.She doesn’t overwhelm the reader with complex lore instead,she allows you to explore this new realm alongside Katha,making you feel every moment of her emotional journey.I particularly appreciated how the fantastical elements never overshadowed the heart of the story and Katha’s internal struggle remains the emotional anchor throughout the book.
.
.
While the plot was engaging and the characters memorable,I did find myself wanting a bit more depth in certain world-building aspects,especially regarding Nasayan’s rules and the consequences of such cosmic mistakes.That said,the balance between light storytelling and deeper themes makes this a wonderful read for both seasoned fantasy fans and those new to the genre.
.
.
Overall,it's a heartfelt,page-turning fantasy that lingers long after you close the last page.I recommend this masterpiece to all the readers out there!🤍
January 17, 2026
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ A gripping sci-fi fantasy that stays with you
A Soul Reaping Gone Wrong is one of those rare books that instantly pulls you into its world and refuses to let go. The concept itself is intriguing — a soul taken before its time — but the way the story unfolds makes it truly unforgettable.
Katha’s journey begins with chaos, betrayal, and heartbreak, only to take a shocking turn when death arrives too early. Waking up in Nasayan, a place where souls are judged and sent forward according to strict rules, she becomes an exception that shouldn’t exist. The mystery of why she was taken, and how such an error could occur, keeps you hooked from start to finish. Varuna, the reaper, adds depth to the story with his moral conflict and determination to uncover the truth.
What makes this book stand out is its immersive storytelling and emotionally intense writing. The characters are morally grey, layered, and very human, making their struggles feel real. The plot balances sci-fi, fantasy, and emotional depth beautifully, with constant tension and unanswered questions that push you to keep reading.
If you enjoy afterlife concepts, time errors, strong world-building, and stories that don’t play safe, this book is absolutely worth your time. A compelling, thought-provoking read that leaves you thinking long after the last page. Highly recommend
A Soul Reaping Gone Wrong is one of those rare books that instantly pulls you into its world and refuses to let go. The concept itself is intriguing — a soul taken before its time — but the way the story unfolds makes it truly unforgettable.
Katha’s journey begins with chaos, betrayal, and heartbreak, only to take a shocking turn when death arrives too early. Waking up in Nasayan, a place where souls are judged and sent forward according to strict rules, she becomes an exception that shouldn’t exist. The mystery of why she was taken, and how such an error could occur, keeps you hooked from start to finish. Varuna, the reaper, adds depth to the story with his moral conflict and determination to uncover the truth.
What makes this book stand out is its immersive storytelling and emotionally intense writing. The characters are morally grey, layered, and very human, making their struggles feel real. The plot balances sci-fi, fantasy, and emotional depth beautifully, with constant tension and unanswered questions that push you to keep reading.
If you enjoy afterlife concepts, time errors, strong world-building, and stories that don’t play safe, this book is absolutely worth your time. A compelling, thought-provoking read that leaves you thinking long after the last page. Highly recommend
February 3, 2026
A Soul Reaping Gone Wrong by Roseena Zehra is a haunting fantasy that begins with a single mistake and gradually unfolds into a far deeper and more mysterious journey....The story follows Katha, whose soul is taken before its destined time, leaving her suspended between Earth and the afterlife....What starts as disorientation soon turns into revelation, as hidden truths, unfamiliar realms, and powerful forces begin to emerge.
The novel’s world-building is rich and immersive, layered with mythological elements, strange beings, and dream-like landscapes that make each chapter visually striking.... The plot expands steadily, weaving small, seemingly insignificant moments into much larger consequences, keeping the reader constantly curious and emotionally invested....
Even after finishing the book, it feels as though the story hasn’t fully let go. Certain scenes linger in the mind, and the atmosphere stays with you long after the final page... It’s a surreal reading experience, otherworldly while reading, yet oddly real once you step back into reality.
While reading it, I felt like I was a part of that unreal world, like I had been living there.
A beautifully imagined fantasy with lingering emotional depth, highly recommended for readers who enjoy mythological themes, atmospheric storytelling, and slow-unfolding mysteries!!
The novel’s world-building is rich and immersive, layered with mythological elements, strange beings, and dream-like landscapes that make each chapter visually striking.... The plot expands steadily, weaving small, seemingly insignificant moments into much larger consequences, keeping the reader constantly curious and emotionally invested....
Even after finishing the book, it feels as though the story hasn’t fully let go. Certain scenes linger in the mind, and the atmosphere stays with you long after the final page... It’s a surreal reading experience, otherworldly while reading, yet oddly real once you step back into reality.
While reading it, I felt like I was a part of that unreal world, like I had been living there.
A beautifully imagined fantasy with lingering emotional depth, highly recommended for readers who enjoy mythological themes, atmospheric storytelling, and slow-unfolding mysteries!!
March 10, 2026
The story follows Katha, a woman already dealing with heartbreak and betrayal who suddenly finds herself dead even though it wasn’t her time. She awakens in Nasayan, a realm that closely mirrors Earth but carries an unsettling sense of danger. What begins as an unexpected mistake soon unfolds into a larger narrative about destiny, cosmic balance, and the consequences of disrupting the natural order. The world-building is quite detailed, especially in the early chapters. While it can feel dense at times, it effectively establishes a vivid alternate realm. The writing flows well and the multiple perspectives add depth to the narrative.
I particularly enjoyed the relationships between the characters, especially the friendships Katha forms along the way. These bonds add emotional weight to the story and highlight themes of loyalty, resilience, and sacrifice. Overall, this book blends mythology and fantasy while also touching on deeper ideas about fate, identity and belonging. Beyond the fantasy elements, the book also carries a thoughtful philosophical layer. It reflects on fate, free will and how a single mistake can disrupt the balance of the universe. It also explores themes of grief, identity & belonging, while Varuna’s situation raises deeper questions about justice, responsibility & redemption, adding emotional depth to the narrative.
I particularly enjoyed the relationships between the characters, especially the friendships Katha forms along the way. These bonds add emotional weight to the story and highlight themes of loyalty, resilience, and sacrifice. Overall, this book blends mythology and fantasy while also touching on deeper ideas about fate, identity and belonging. Beyond the fantasy elements, the book also carries a thoughtful philosophical layer. It reflects on fate, free will and how a single mistake can disrupt the balance of the universe. It also explores themes of grief, identity & belonging, while Varuna’s situation raises deeper questions about justice, responsibility & redemption, adding emotional depth to the narrative.
June 30, 2026
A unique afterlife fantasy filled with mystery and heart
A Soul Reaping Gone Wrong was such an enjoyable surprise. I expected a fantasy novel about the afterlife, but I ended up reading a story filled with mystery, emotions, and memorable characters.
Katha is a character I immediately felt for. After everything she has already been through in life, she suddenly finds herself caught in an afterlife because of a mistake that was never supposed to happen. That unexpected twist hooked me from the very beginning. I loved slowly uncovering the truth alongside her, and every new revelation made me want to keep reading.
One of the strongest parts of this book is the world-building. The afterlife feels well thought out, with its own rules, responsibilities, and consequences. Varuna was another standout character for me. He starts off as serious and reserved, but as the story progresses, his protective nature and emotional depth begin to shine. His growing bond with Katha felt genuine and added warmth to the story.
The writing is simple, engaging, and easy to follow, making it a quick yet immersive read. The mix of suspense, emotional moments, and themes of fate, second chances, and choice kept me invested until the final pages. If you enjoy fantasy with mystery, slow-burn relationships, and a fresh take on life after death, I highly recommend giving this book a try.
A Soul Reaping Gone Wrong was such an enjoyable surprise. I expected a fantasy novel about the afterlife, but I ended up reading a story filled with mystery, emotions, and memorable characters.
Katha is a character I immediately felt for. After everything she has already been through in life, she suddenly finds herself caught in an afterlife because of a mistake that was never supposed to happen. That unexpected twist hooked me from the very beginning. I loved slowly uncovering the truth alongside her, and every new revelation made me want to keep reading.
One of the strongest parts of this book is the world-building. The afterlife feels well thought out, with its own rules, responsibilities, and consequences. Varuna was another standout character for me. He starts off as serious and reserved, but as the story progresses, his protective nature and emotional depth begin to shine. His growing bond with Katha felt genuine and added warmth to the story.
The writing is simple, engaging, and easy to follow, making it a quick yet immersive read. The mix of suspense, emotional moments, and themes of fate, second chances, and choice kept me invested until the final pages. If you enjoy fantasy with mystery, slow-burn relationships, and a fresh take on life after death, I highly recommend giving this book a try.
November 1, 2025
Imagine waking up in a place where you don’t belong stuck between life and death. That’s what happens to Katha when she dies suddenly and finds herself in a mysterious realm called Nasayan. Her soul wasn’t meant to be taken yet, and the reaper, Varuna, is sure he followed the rules. So, what really went wrong?
This book isn’t just about the afterlife it’s about choices, mistakes, and the beautiful chaos of being human. The story moves smoothly, sometimes fast and exciting, sometimes calm and emotional. You really start to care about Katha and Varuna as their journey unfolds with moments of tension, and hope.
The book has story parts and each chapter contains some really beautiful quotes. I’ve underlined my favorite ones you can read them by sliding through. Also, the opening dedication line of the book was so, so beautiful.
The world Rosheena creates feels magical yet real. The writing is clear, the chapters are short and action-packed, and every detail adds to the charm. I especially loved how the author built such a unique fantasy world that still feels relatable & magical. A beautifully written tale that stays with you well beyond the final chapter.
Highly recommended for anyone who enjoys fantasy and emotional storytelling. ✨
This book isn’t just about the afterlife it’s about choices, mistakes, and the beautiful chaos of being human. The story moves smoothly, sometimes fast and exciting, sometimes calm and emotional. You really start to care about Katha and Varuna as their journey unfolds with moments of tension, and hope.
The book has story parts and each chapter contains some really beautiful quotes. I’ve underlined my favorite ones you can read them by sliding through. Also, the opening dedication line of the book was so, so beautiful.
The world Rosheena creates feels magical yet real. The writing is clear, the chapters are short and action-packed, and every detail adds to the charm. I especially loved how the author built such a unique fantasy world that still feels relatable & magical. A beautifully written tale that stays with you well beyond the final chapter.
Highly recommended for anyone who enjoys fantasy and emotional storytelling. ✨
April 28, 2026
“I am the rejected child of two realms.”
What happens when you die… even when it isn’t your time?
Soul Reaping Gone Wrong takes readers on a fascinating journey beyond the world we know into the land between Earth and Heaven — Nasayan.
The story follows Katha, a girl who dies in a car accident and is mistakenly taken to Nasayan by a soul reaper. Nasayan is an in-between realm — familiar yet unsettlingly foreign, magical yet not quite a home. It is filled with fairies and mystical creatures that give the story a whimsical, otherworldly charm.
The author crafts a majestic and imaginative adventure that questions the order of the universe, morality, and the complexity of human emotions. The premise itself is intriguing and pulls you quickly into the narrative.
On the flip side, the book is very beginner-friendly and easy to read, making it a great pick for readers new to fantasy. However, at times the world-building feels a little shallow. I found myself wanting to know more about Nasayan and its magic — its rules, its history, and its deeper layers.
Overall: A creative and enjoyable fantasy read with an imaginative premise, perfect for beginners, though readers who love deep world-building may wish for more detail. ⭐️
What happens when you die… even when it isn’t your time?
Soul Reaping Gone Wrong takes readers on a fascinating journey beyond the world we know into the land between Earth and Heaven — Nasayan.
The story follows Katha, a girl who dies in a car accident and is mistakenly taken to Nasayan by a soul reaper. Nasayan is an in-between realm — familiar yet unsettlingly foreign, magical yet not quite a home. It is filled with fairies and mystical creatures that give the story a whimsical, otherworldly charm.
The author crafts a majestic and imaginative adventure that questions the order of the universe, morality, and the complexity of human emotions. The premise itself is intriguing and pulls you quickly into the narrative.
On the flip side, the book is very beginner-friendly and easy to read, making it a great pick for readers new to fantasy. However, at times the world-building feels a little shallow. I found myself wanting to know more about Nasayan and its magic — its rules, its history, and its deeper layers.
Overall: A creative and enjoyable fantasy read with an imaginative premise, perfect for beginners, though readers who love deep world-building may wish for more detail. ⭐️
October 6, 2026
A Soul Reaping Gone Wrong follows Katha, whose soul is taken too soon, leaving her caught between the world of the living and the afterlife. She finds herself in Nasayan, a mysterious realm with its own rules and finds out that her death was actually a mistake. From there, Katha’s journey begins as she tries to find a way out of Nasayan and return home.
I really liked the concept because I hadn’t read a story with this kind of plot before. Since fantasy is my favourite genre, the whole idea of an afterlife, a different realm and all the supernatural elements naturally caught my interest. I did find myself a little confused while trying to understand Nasayan and Vismaran in the beginning but it became clear as I read further.
One of my favourite parts of the book was the friendship between Katha, Arjun and Kaushiky. I really liked how natural their friendship felt and it added a warm, emotional touch to the story.
The story was fast-paced, and the chapters were short too. As soon as Part 2 started, my interest increased even more.
Overall, I enjoyed this fantasy story and the journey Katha goes through. If you enjoy fantasy stories with supernatural elements, different realms you can definitely give this one a try.
I really liked the concept because I hadn’t read a story with this kind of plot before. Since fantasy is my favourite genre, the whole idea of an afterlife, a different realm and all the supernatural elements naturally caught my interest. I did find myself a little confused while trying to understand Nasayan and Vismaran in the beginning but it became clear as I read further.
One of my favourite parts of the book was the friendship between Katha, Arjun and Kaushiky. I really liked how natural their friendship felt and it added a warm, emotional touch to the story.
The story was fast-paced, and the chapters were short too. As soon as Part 2 started, my interest increased even more.
Overall, I enjoyed this fantasy story and the journey Katha goes through. If you enjoy fantasy stories with supernatural elements, different realms you can definitely give this one a try.
September 10, 2026
This book is much more than I thought I would.
There was something about the whole idea of death, souls, and what happens when things don’t go according to plan that immediately caught my attention.
What I liked most was the way the story mixes a supernatural concept with emotions and human experiences.
It doesn’t feel like the story is only about reaping souls; there’s much more happening underneath, and that made me want to keep turning the pages.
The concept itself felt fresh and interesting to me.
I especially enjoyed the moments where things took an unexpected turn because they kept me curious about what would happen next.
The characters also made the story more engaging, and I found myself getting emotionally invested in their journey.
I also liked how the story makes you look at life and death from a slightly different perspective.
Rosheena Zehra has created a story that is imaginative, intriguing, and different from what I usually pick up.
If you enjoy fantasy, supernatural stories, mysterious situations, and stories that play with the idea of life and death, this one is definitely worth giving a try.
There was something about the whole idea of death, souls, and what happens when things don’t go according to plan that immediately caught my attention.
What I liked most was the way the story mixes a supernatural concept with emotions and human experiences.
It doesn’t feel like the story is only about reaping souls; there’s much more happening underneath, and that made me want to keep turning the pages.
The concept itself felt fresh and interesting to me.
I especially enjoyed the moments where things took an unexpected turn because they kept me curious about what would happen next.
The characters also made the story more engaging, and I found myself getting emotionally invested in their journey.
I also liked how the story makes you look at life and death from a slightly different perspective.
Rosheena Zehra has created a story that is imaginative, intriguing, and different from what I usually pick up.
If you enjoy fantasy, supernatural stories, mysterious situations, and stories that play with the idea of life and death, this one is definitely worth giving a try.
January 30, 2026
Okay HELLO???
Who gave this book the right to yank me out of real life and dump me into a limbo full of elves, merfolk, fairies, reapers??????
Katha is literally just vibing through heartbreak like the rest of us depressed girlies and BAM suddenly she’s dead-but-not-dead and dragged into Nasayan by a soul reaper named Varuna who may or may not be a menace but also kinda adorable??
Love that for her. Could NOT be me. I would’ve simply refused to die 💀
The vibes??
Immaculate.
The world-building??
Head-empty-no-thoughts-just-VIBES.
The mythical creatures??
Serving ✨Avengers of folklore✨ and I ate it up.
The plot has action, grief, friendship, betrayal, AND emotional damage, all sprinkled in like Rosheena said "pain? sprinkle sprinkle"
AND THE FRIENDSHIP FACTOR???
I’ll fight anyone who says that wasn’t precious. 🤺🤍
Hands down to one of the best reads of January😭✨ Can't wait to read more of her works in future!!
✨ Pick it up if you want an emotional roller coaster with mythical spice and mental breakdown seasoning✨
Who gave this book the right to yank me out of real life and dump me into a limbo full of elves, merfolk, fairies, reapers??????
Katha is literally just vibing through heartbreak like the rest of us depressed girlies and BAM suddenly she’s dead-but-not-dead and dragged into Nasayan by a soul reaper named Varuna who may or may not be a menace but also kinda adorable??
Love that for her. Could NOT be me. I would’ve simply refused to die 💀
The vibes??
Immaculate.
The world-building??
Head-empty-no-thoughts-just-VIBES.
The mythical creatures??
Serving ✨Avengers of folklore✨ and I ate it up.
The plot has action, grief, friendship, betrayal, AND emotional damage, all sprinkled in like Rosheena said "pain? sprinkle sprinkle"
AND THE FRIENDSHIP FACTOR???
I’ll fight anyone who says that wasn’t precious. 🤺🤍
Hands down to one of the best reads of January😭✨ Can't wait to read more of her works in future!!
✨ Pick it up if you want an emotional roller coaster with mythical spice and mental breakdown seasoning✨
May 30, 2026
⭐ Rating: 4.5/5
A Soul Reaping Gone Wrong was such a refreshing fantasy read. From the very first chapter, I was drawn into its unique premise and found myself completely invested in Katha's journey. The story balances mystery, emotion, and fantasy beautifully, making it difficult to put down.
What stood out the most for me was the author's creativity. The world felt magical and intriguing, and every new revelation made me even more curious about what would happen next. The characters were memorable, each bringing something special to the story, and their relationships added emotional depth without overshadowing the plot.
The writing style is engaging and easy to follow, making the book accessible even for readers who don't usually pick up fantasy novels. While I would have loved a little more detail in certain parts of the world-building, it didn't take away from my overall enjoyment.
If you're looking for a fantasy novel filled with adventure, emotions, unexpected twists, and a fascinating concept, this book is definitely worth adding to your TBR.
A Soul Reaping Gone Wrong was such a refreshing fantasy read. From the very first chapter, I was drawn into its unique premise and found myself completely invested in Katha's journey. The story balances mystery, emotion, and fantasy beautifully, making it difficult to put down.
What stood out the most for me was the author's creativity. The world felt magical and intriguing, and every new revelation made me even more curious about what would happen next. The characters were memorable, each bringing something special to the story, and their relationships added emotional depth without overshadowing the plot.
The writing style is engaging and easy to follow, making the book accessible even for readers who don't usually pick up fantasy novels. While I would have loved a little more detail in certain parts of the world-building, it didn't take away from my overall enjoyment.
If you're looking for a fantasy novel filled with adventure, emotions, unexpected twists, and a fascinating concept, this book is definitely worth adding to your TBR.
September 10, 2026
This book felt like a magical dream I was living in.
A supernatural mystery where Katha, heartbroken and already dealing with enough, DIES WHEN SHE SHOULDN’T. Her soul is reaped too early, leaving her stranded in Nasayan, an entirely different AFTERLIFE filled with secrets, rules, and magical powers.
Katha DOESN’T BELONG IN NASAYAN, yet she finds friendship, love, and a place among people who become her family. I loved how Arjun, Kaushkiy, and Varuna had their own depth too, rather than everything revolving around Katha.
Kaushkiy was my FAVOURITE! Fiercely loyal, selfless, headstrong, and the kind of friend everyone deserves. And the BOND BETWEEN THE FOUR FRIENDS was honestly one of my favourite parts.
The conspiracy, unexpected turns, friendships, and romance kept me hooked. A few Nasayan names were tricky to keep track of, but that’s part of entering a completely different world.
And THAT EPILOGUE! It left me hopeful and definitely wanting more.
Officially rooting for a sequel!
A supernatural mystery where Katha, heartbroken and already dealing with enough, DIES WHEN SHE SHOULDN’T. Her soul is reaped too early, leaving her stranded in Nasayan, an entirely different AFTERLIFE filled with secrets, rules, and magical powers.
Katha DOESN’T BELONG IN NASAYAN, yet she finds friendship, love, and a place among people who become her family. I loved how Arjun, Kaushkiy, and Varuna had their own depth too, rather than everything revolving around Katha.
Kaushkiy was my FAVOURITE! Fiercely loyal, selfless, headstrong, and the kind of friend everyone deserves. And the BOND BETWEEN THE FOUR FRIENDS was honestly one of my favourite parts.
The conspiracy, unexpected turns, friendships, and romance kept me hooked. A few Nasayan names were tricky to keep track of, but that’s part of entering a completely different world.
And THAT EPILOGUE! It left me hopeful and definitely wanting more.
Officially rooting for a sequel!
September 27, 2026
A magical and refreshing fantasy read
A Soul Reaping Gone Wrong by Rosheena Zehra is such a unique and interesting story. The idea of a soul being reaped before its destined time immediately caught my attention, and the story takes you into a fascinating world filled with mythology, magic, mystery, and unexpected twists.
I really enjoyed the way the story slowly unfolds and introduces the world of Nasayan and its intriguing characters. The blend of Indian mythology with fantasy made the book feel different from the usual fantasy stories I read.
The storytelling is engaging, imaginative, and beautifully mysterious. There were moments that genuinely made me curious about what would happen next, and I loved discovering the secrets of this magical world along with Katha.
Overall, this was a really enjoyable and refreshing read. If you enjoy mythology-inspired fantasy, magical worlds, mysteries, and stories that take you somewhere completely different, this is definitely worth picking up.
A Soul Reaping Gone Wrong by Rosheena Zehra is such a unique and interesting story. The idea of a soul being reaped before its destined time immediately caught my attention, and the story takes you into a fascinating world filled with mythology, magic, mystery, and unexpected twists.
I really enjoyed the way the story slowly unfolds and introduces the world of Nasayan and its intriguing characters. The blend of Indian mythology with fantasy made the book feel different from the usual fantasy stories I read.
The storytelling is engaging, imaginative, and beautifully mysterious. There were moments that genuinely made me curious about what would happen next, and I loved discovering the secrets of this magical world along with Katha.
Overall, this was a really enjoyable and refreshing read. If you enjoy mythology-inspired fantasy, magical worlds, mysteries, and stories that take you somewhere completely different, this is definitely worth picking up.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 45 reviews