What do you think?
Rate this book
The Rose and the Thistle
In 1715, Lady Blythe Hedley's father is declared an enemy of the British crown because of his Jacobite sympathies, forcing her to flee her home in northern England. Secreted to the tower of Wedderburn Castle in Scotland, Lady Blythe awaits who will ultimately be crowned king. But in a house with seven sons and numerous servants, her presence soon becomes known.
No sooner has Everard Hume lost his father, Lord Wedderburn, than Lady Hedley arrives with the clothes on her back and her mistress in tow. He has his own problems--a volatile brother with dangerous political leanings, an estate to manage, and a very young brother in need of comfort and direction in the wake of losing his father. It would be best for everyone if he could send this misfit heiress on her way as soon as possible.
Drawn into a whirlwind of intrigue, shifting alliances, and ambitions, Lady Blythe must be careful whom she trusts. Her fortune, her future, and her very life are at stake. Those who appear to be adversaries may turn out to be allies--and those who pretend friendship may be enemies.
No sooner has Everard Hume lost his father, Lord Wedderburn, than Lady Hedley arrives with the clothes on her back and her mistress in tow. He has his own problems--a volatile brother with dangerous political leanings, an estate to manage, and a very young brother in need of comfort and direction in the wake of losing his father. It would be best for everyone if he could send this misfit heiress on her way as soon as possible.
Drawn into a whirlwind of intrigue, shifting alliances, and ambitions, Lady Blythe must be careful whom she trusts. Her fortune, her future, and her very life are at stake. Those who appear to be adversaries may turn out to be allies--and those who pretend friendship may be enemies.
414 pages, Kindle Edition
First published January 1, 2023
About the author
Laura Frantz
25 books2,922 followersLaura Frantz is passionate about all things historical, particularly the 18th-century, and writes her manuscripts in longhand first. Her stories often incorporate Scottish themes that reflect her family heritage. She is a direct descendant of George Hume, Wedderburn Castle, Berwickshire, Scotland, who was exiled to the American colonies for his role in the Jacobite Rebellion of 1715, settled in Virginia, and is credited with teaching George Washington surveying in the years 1748-1750. Frantz lives and writes in a log cabin in the heart of Kentucky.According to Publishers Weekly, "Frantz has done her historical homework." With her signature attention to historical detail and emotional depth, she is represented by Janet Kobobel Grant, Literary Agent & Founder, Books & Such Literary Agency of Santa Rosa, California.Readers can find Laura Frantz at www.laurafrantz.net.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 800 reviews
January 19, 2023
This is a story that is rich in history with a lovely, picturesque setting from England to Lowland Scotland in the early 1700's during a time when one's religion is determined by the king on the throne. Blythe, daughter of a duke who is against the new king on the throne is sent away from home in England to the home of her godparents in Scotland to avoid danger. Both her godparents are now dead and the new laird, Everard, and the whole household are in mourning for their laird. Times are scary as the whole of Britain is at war with each other over their religious beliefs. This is a complicated story but what is beautiful about this story is how two people of different backgrounds, strong in their faith, come together to worship the same God and find a way to meet each other in friendship and love. The Rose and the Thistle grabs on and touches all aspects one wants in a great read: love, faith, loyalty, family, fear, anger, tenderness, and conflict, all against a rich tapestry of history and emotion. Highly recommended for those who love history and love stories. I received a copy for the purpose of an honest review. All thoughts are mine only.
December 20, 2022
Love love love love love love love etc.
I mean, I feel like I say this with every Laura Frantz book, but she's just forever one of my favorites, and this book in particular hit all my sweet spots. I loved the Scottish setting. The slow-burn romance is so well done. The writing is beautiful. The history is intriguing. The plot moves at just the right pace—with plenty of conflict alongside the story's emotional tension. I just loved every moment of this one.
I mean, I feel like I say this with every Laura Frantz book, but she's just forever one of my favorites, and this book in particular hit all my sweet spots. I loved the Scottish setting. The slow-burn romance is so well done. The writing is beautiful. The history is intriguing. The plot moves at just the right pace—with plenty of conflict alongside the story's emotional tension. I just loved every moment of this one.
January 16, 2023
Thanks to Netgalley and Revell Publishing for an egalley
I have longed to read a Laura Frantz historical romance novel and finally in 2023, it happened.
Scotland, 1715. Lady Blythe Hedley, only child of the Duke of Northumbria is called back to England by her father from the exiled Stuart court in France. However, their reunion is short and Blythe and her companion, Elodie must take sanctuary on Scotland with the Hume family. Sparks fly between Blythe and the new laird, Everard, Lord Wedderburn. But can the daughter of a Catholic Jacobite sympathizer truly expect to be the wife of a Scottish Protestant who once fought for Queen Anne?
I quite enjoyed this novel and read it between Saturday chores. The characters were intriguing and I did have a soft spot for all those Hume brothers especially little Orion. I found it interesting as revealed in the author's note that there was a personal family history connection to the Humes of Scotland.
The romance worked for me and I loved that the author took her time building it up.
I think I shall have to explore more Laurie Frantz titles in 2023 now that I have experienced her writing.
Publication Date. 03/01/23
Goodreads review published 14/01/23
#TheRoseandtheThistle #NetGalley.
I have longed to read a Laura Frantz historical romance novel and finally in 2023, it happened.
Scotland, 1715. Lady Blythe Hedley, only child of the Duke of Northumbria is called back to England by her father from the exiled Stuart court in France. However, their reunion is short and Blythe and her companion, Elodie must take sanctuary on Scotland with the Hume family. Sparks fly between Blythe and the new laird, Everard, Lord Wedderburn. But can the daughter of a Catholic Jacobite sympathizer truly expect to be the wife of a Scottish Protestant who once fought for Queen Anne?
I quite enjoyed this novel and read it between Saturday chores. The characters were intriguing and I did have a soft spot for all those Hume brothers especially little Orion. I found it interesting as revealed in the author's note that there was a personal family history connection to the Humes of Scotland.
The romance worked for me and I loved that the author took her time building it up.
I think I shall have to explore more Laurie Frantz titles in 2023 now that I have experienced her writing.
Publication Date. 03/01/23
Goodreads review published 14/01/23
#TheRoseandtheThistle #NetGalley.
February 7, 2023
Exquisite and exceptional. I loved every moment spent inside the world of this story. The romance, historical details, and lovely characterization had me glued to the pages. A lady in need, an unlikely knight, war, loss, and love are all key pieces of this beautiful tale.
Lady Blythe might be pale and willowy, but she is no wilting flower. She is soft but strong, proud but realistically flawed, and at her core, a heart that reaches out to the hurting souls around her. Everard, Lord Wedderburn, is a soldier through and through, gruff and to the point but not without a mind bent on caring for those under his watch. I enjoyed these two together so much, especially how they are something of enemies, neither wishing to be in the situation that their fathers have put them in. Maybe it’s just me, but I enjoy some good verbal sparring when both parties are sure that they will absolutely never see eye to eye.
While I’m not overly familiar with the Jacobite Rebellion besides what I’ve seen on the History Channel, it’s evident that Frantz took care to research the historical setting and climate of the times. The tension between Catholics and Protestants plays a big role – even marrying means renouncing one for the other. I appreciated that the focus was not on one or the other, but rather the core belief in Christ. Of course, it is always eye-opening to see how one group has persecuted another one simply for the way they chose to worship, live, etc. throughout human history. Also of interest is how so many lives were moved about like pawns by the current monarchy – and how easily the tides are turned. This is a smart story that is accessible to all readers – those more familiar with the history, as well as those looking for a rousing plot and tender romance.
Of note are the wonderful secondary characters, my favorites being young Orin, and Peg, a devoted lady’s maid to Blythe. And the romance, ah, the romance – it is the best slow burn, but how brightly and exquisitely it burns when it finally ignited. Frantz excels at the swoony, tender moments – I’ve never known a pear could be so romantic. The faith element weaves naturally throughout the tale, with prayer and beseeching the Lord’s help as genuine as breathing and in keeping with the personalities of the characters.
Frantz’s love of Scotland and her own ties to its history shine in the pages of this book. If you enjoy romantic stories steeped in the historical context and details of the time, The Rose and the Thistle should be on your to-read list for 2023.
I received a complimentary copy of this novel from the publisher; a positive review was not required, and these are my honest thoughts and opinions.
Lady Blythe might be pale and willowy, but she is no wilting flower. She is soft but strong, proud but realistically flawed, and at her core, a heart that reaches out to the hurting souls around her. Everard, Lord Wedderburn, is a soldier through and through, gruff and to the point but not without a mind bent on caring for those under his watch. I enjoyed these two together so much, especially how they are something of enemies, neither wishing to be in the situation that their fathers have put them in. Maybe it’s just me, but I enjoy some good verbal sparring when both parties are sure that they will absolutely never see eye to eye.
While I’m not overly familiar with the Jacobite Rebellion besides what I’ve seen on the History Channel, it’s evident that Frantz took care to research the historical setting and climate of the times. The tension between Catholics and Protestants plays a big role – even marrying means renouncing one for the other. I appreciated that the focus was not on one or the other, but rather the core belief in Christ. Of course, it is always eye-opening to see how one group has persecuted another one simply for the way they chose to worship, live, etc. throughout human history. Also of interest is how so many lives were moved about like pawns by the current monarchy – and how easily the tides are turned. This is a smart story that is accessible to all readers – those more familiar with the history, as well as those looking for a rousing plot and tender romance.
Of note are the wonderful secondary characters, my favorites being young Orin, and Peg, a devoted lady’s maid to Blythe. And the romance, ah, the romance – it is the best slow burn, but how brightly and exquisitely it burns when it finally ignited. Frantz excels at the swoony, tender moments – I’ve never known a pear could be so romantic. The faith element weaves naturally throughout the tale, with prayer and beseeching the Lord’s help as genuine as breathing and in keeping with the personalities of the characters.
Frantz’s love of Scotland and her own ties to its history shine in the pages of this book. If you enjoy romantic stories steeped in the historical context and details of the time, The Rose and the Thistle should be on your to-read list for 2023.
I received a complimentary copy of this novel from the publisher; a positive review was not required, and these are my honest thoughts and opinions.
January 17, 2023
4.5 - As ever, Laura Frantz's writing is eloquent, imaginative, and lovely. For those of you who loved detailed and engaging historical fiction, The Rose and the Thistle takes you on a journey of intrigue mostly set in the Scottish lowlands (as part of Laura's ancestry). We join the serene and intelligent "English Rose" Lady Blythe and the enigmatic and thoughtful Scottish laird, Everard as they are forced together through circumstances surrounding the Jacobite uprising in the 1700s. Laura's turns of phrases and lyrical descriptions bring the Scottish atmosphere to life and the romance between Everard and Blythe is slow burn, but when the burning starts...WOWZA!
A Note for Romance Readers: The real romance of the story doesn't start until about halfway through the book, so if you go in with that in mind, it may help because when it starts...it's SOOOOO worth the read! The romance between Blythe and Everard is palpable, sweet, and endearing...and wonderfully romantic.
A Note for Romance Readers: The real romance of the story doesn't start until about halfway through the book, so if you go in with that in mind, it may help because when it starts...it's SOOOOO worth the read! The romance between Blythe and Everard is palpable, sweet, and endearing...and wonderfully romantic.
January 15, 2023
When I first read the synopsis of The Rose & The Thistle by Laura Frantz, I KNEW this book was going to be a new favorite of mine. I love stories set in Scotland, particularly during the 1700s and the added details surrounding the Jacobite Uprising, the Scottish Highlands/Lowlands, the Stuarts, the Scottish dialogue – were perfection! This was my first Laura Frantz read and it will NOT be my last! 5 big stars for such a stunning Christian historical fiction with a sweet, clean romance between a “Sassenach” Englishwoman and a hunk of a Scotsman!
Set in 1715, Lady Blythe Hedley, who is the daughter of a Jacobite sympathizer and enemy of the British crown, finds herself forced to flee her home in Northern England to the tower of Wedderburn Castle in Scotland. She is sent there for her protection when she meets the Scottish Laird, Lord Everard Wedderburn. Everard has recently assumed his position as Laird of Wedderburn Castle and proceeds to honor his father’s last wish to offer Lady Blythe protection since she was his father’s goddaughter. There is so much political turmoil going on during this time between Scotland and England so keeping her safe is going to be a task for Everard. The story takes off from here as we learn all about their families, history and how they get to know one another.
As I said, this book was right up my alley. I am a big Outlander fan, so I am already familiar with so much surrounding this time period in Scotland, the Jacobite rebellion, the Stuarts, Culloden War, and the Scottish dialogue. Laura Frantz truly transports you right in the middle of this phenomenal historical setting in Scotland and you truly root for the characters in each situation. The romance is a slow burn that made my heart SO happy at the end. I love a Scotsman in a book and this book did NOT disappoint! I also loved the faith messages interweaved throughout the story.
For those that struggle with Historical settings at times, I think this would still be a good book for you because I was not bored in any way. I feel like she truly brought to life the history of Scotland during this time with our characters.
Overall, my Scottish loving heart was SO happy to have read this and I hope many of you will pick this one up! I can’t wait to read more of Laura’s books this year! Thank you to Baker Publishing, Revell and NetGalley for a copy of this book to honestly read and review.
Set in 1715, Lady Blythe Hedley, who is the daughter of a Jacobite sympathizer and enemy of the British crown, finds herself forced to flee her home in Northern England to the tower of Wedderburn Castle in Scotland. She is sent there for her protection when she meets the Scottish Laird, Lord Everard Wedderburn. Everard has recently assumed his position as Laird of Wedderburn Castle and proceeds to honor his father’s last wish to offer Lady Blythe protection since she was his father’s goddaughter. There is so much political turmoil going on during this time between Scotland and England so keeping her safe is going to be a task for Everard. The story takes off from here as we learn all about their families, history and how they get to know one another.
As I said, this book was right up my alley. I am a big Outlander fan, so I am already familiar with so much surrounding this time period in Scotland, the Jacobite rebellion, the Stuarts, Culloden War, and the Scottish dialogue. Laura Frantz truly transports you right in the middle of this phenomenal historical setting in Scotland and you truly root for the characters in each situation. The romance is a slow burn that made my heart SO happy at the end. I love a Scotsman in a book and this book did NOT disappoint! I also loved the faith messages interweaved throughout the story.
For those that struggle with Historical settings at times, I think this would still be a good book for you because I was not bored in any way. I feel like she truly brought to life the history of Scotland during this time with our characters.
Overall, my Scottish loving heart was SO happy to have read this and I hope many of you will pick this one up! I can’t wait to read more of Laura’s books this year! Thank you to Baker Publishing, Revell and NetGalley for a copy of this book to honestly read and review.
February 9, 2023
I almost stopped reading this book twice, and no one is more depressed that I didn't love it more than me.
I LIKED:
-The last 40% of the book. Well done!
-If I could do a slow hand clap for the writing, I would. I’m truthfully impressed with the level of polish and attention to detail the author took.
-The spiritual observances and references to God.
-The impeccable effort that went into making ALL of the Scottish accent’s show in the writing. It made reading and listening a bit slower, but it also transported me to the place.
-The author is excellent at creating angst and aching with her love stories. She knows how to make the reader feel right along with her characters. (When the romance finally hits)
THOUGHTS:
-The first 60% of the book was boring and uneventful. Roughly 220 pages. Its honestly about 120 pages too long. The characters went around in circles for pages and pages. I didn’t need heads chopped off. I just wanted SOMETHING to happen.
-This felt like two different books. It was almost like it snapped into gear in chapter 43. The author hit her stride from that point on. (70 chapters in all)
-The politics of the time period were not explained enough. You are thrown into the political world without knowing much of what's happening and WHY a connection between the two MC's would be disastrous.
-While I loved the characters, they had little development. They had depth but they hardly grew. Yes, the MC’s grow to love each other, but this isn’t a book where the character growth is forefront. Normally, this wouldn’t bother me but in a 416-page book, I was hoping for more.
-Two of the six brothers had no purpose to the story, and I was confused and sad that one brother was basically used to move the plot along and not much else.
-This time in history was not used to its full potential. To the authors credit, the politics showed up during the last 40% of the book but It was a serious missed opportunity to not have that energy from the start.
-I didn’t believe the romance In the beginning..... He catches her, she thinks he’s a sexy Scotsman, (I can’t blame her that) and after he gives her one indirect compliment, she thinks she’s lost her heart.
He is enamored with her because she is graceful, nice to his little brother and has impeccable taste in clothes. They don’t actually go through anything together to merit that affection until everything shifts later. My opinion of their relationship obviously changes, but for the majority of the book, I wasn’t truly invested.
OVERALL:
For me, this book is good but not great. I completely understand why people are obsessed with it. Unfortunately, I just don’t see it. Trust me, I really wanted to love this. I’m jealous of all the reviewers who had a beautiful reading experience, and I will support anyone who raves about it. I’m happy for them and I hope the author has mountains of success.
I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Characters/Depth/Growth – 6
Atmosphere/World - 8
Writing Style - 10
Plot - 5
Intrigue -6
Love/Relationships - 7
Enjoyment/Memorable - 7
Total: 49
Divided by 7 = 7.0 (3 1/2 stars)
1.1-2.2 *
2.3-4.5 **
4.6-6.9 ***
7.0-8.9 ****
9.0-10 *****
I LIKED:
-The last 40% of the book. Well done!
-If I could do a slow hand clap for the writing, I would. I’m truthfully impressed with the level of polish and attention to detail the author took.
-The spiritual observances and references to God.
-The impeccable effort that went into making ALL of the Scottish accent’s show in the writing. It made reading and listening a bit slower, but it also transported me to the place.
-The author is excellent at creating angst and aching with her love stories. She knows how to make the reader feel right along with her characters. (When the romance finally hits)
THOUGHTS:
-The first 60% of the book was boring and uneventful. Roughly 220 pages. Its honestly about 120 pages too long. The characters went around in circles for pages and pages. I didn’t need heads chopped off. I just wanted SOMETHING to happen.
-This felt like two different books. It was almost like it snapped into gear in chapter 43. The author hit her stride from that point on. (70 chapters in all)
-The politics of the time period were not explained enough. You are thrown into the political world without knowing much of what's happening and WHY a connection between the two MC's would be disastrous.
-While I loved the characters, they had little development. They had depth but they hardly grew. Yes, the MC’s grow to love each other, but this isn’t a book where the character growth is forefront. Normally, this wouldn’t bother me but in a 416-page book, I was hoping for more.
-Two of the six brothers had no purpose to the story, and I was confused and sad that one brother was basically used to move the plot along and not much else.
-This time in history was not used to its full potential. To the authors credit, the politics showed up during the last 40% of the book but It was a serious missed opportunity to not have that energy from the start.
-I didn’t believe the romance In the beginning..... He catches her, she thinks he’s a sexy Scotsman, (I can’t blame her that) and after he gives her one indirect compliment, she thinks she’s lost her heart.
He is enamored with her because she is graceful, nice to his little brother and has impeccable taste in clothes. They don’t actually go through anything together to merit that affection until everything shifts later. My opinion of their relationship obviously changes, but for the majority of the book, I wasn’t truly invested.
OVERALL:
For me, this book is good but not great. I completely understand why people are obsessed with it. Unfortunately, I just don’t see it. Trust me, I really wanted to love this. I’m jealous of all the reviewers who had a beautiful reading experience, and I will support anyone who raves about it. I’m happy for them and I hope the author has mountains of success.
I voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Characters/Depth/Growth – 6
Atmosphere/World - 8
Writing Style - 10
Plot - 5
Intrigue -6
Love/Relationships - 7
Enjoyment/Memorable - 7
Total: 49
Divided by 7 = 7.0 (3 1/2 stars)
1.1-2.2 *
2.3-4.5 **
4.6-6.9 ***
7.0-8.9 ****
9.0-10 *****
January 12, 2023
“Prayer may be the best weapon we have.”
Thank you to Revell for the opportunity to read this author’s work for the first time and to provide a review. I’ve always been fascinated by this time period and love teaching Canadian Grade Nine Social Studies where The Fight For Democracy and The English Civil War are two of the topics.
Things I loved:
✔️characters are well developed and complement each other
✔️didn’t just read about history, I was transported and watched it unravel from the sidelines
✔️tension resulting from divided loyalties
✔️a greater understanding of the complex political situation
✔️subtle faith messages interspersed
✔️authentically developed impossible romance
✔️fantastic title that takes on new meaning as the book progresses
✔️themes of family loyalty, trust and faith
✔️delicious food references
✔️questioning God’s control to deepen one’s roots
✔️not dry history; author breathes life into it
If you are interested in this time period, this story about Lady Blythe Hedley, a Catholic noblewoman, and her fight for survival during the Jacobite Rebellion of 1715, is outstanding. It’ll have you comparing the events of the early 1700s Britain to events today and concluding that we are not so far removed from history! Beware, you may develop a Scottish brogue and surprise those you meet.
Thank you to Revell for the opportunity to read this author’s work for the first time and to provide a review. I’ve always been fascinated by this time period and love teaching Canadian Grade Nine Social Studies where The Fight For Democracy and The English Civil War are two of the topics.
Things I loved:
✔️characters are well developed and complement each other
✔️didn’t just read about history, I was transported and watched it unravel from the sidelines
✔️tension resulting from divided loyalties
✔️a greater understanding of the complex political situation
✔️subtle faith messages interspersed
✔️authentically developed impossible romance
✔️fantastic title that takes on new meaning as the book progresses
✔️themes of family loyalty, trust and faith
✔️delicious food references
✔️questioning God’s control to deepen one’s roots
✔️not dry history; author breathes life into it
If you are interested in this time period, this story about Lady Blythe Hedley, a Catholic noblewoman, and her fight for survival during the Jacobite Rebellion of 1715, is outstanding. It’ll have you comparing the events of the early 1700s Britain to events today and concluding that we are not so far removed from history! Beware, you may develop a Scottish brogue and surprise those you meet.
February 23, 2023
Ridiculously good Christian historical romance
Well, I certainly came in unprepared. I had read so many raving reviews and was like “ Me, me, me, I want to be transported to the Scottish Lowlands too!”. And yet, unprepared to be truly transported, devastated, and delighted as I was.
This is ridiculously good historical romance. I love to be hit with a nice and hefty glossary right off the bat (I think I’m basically a polyglot now, if we count sparsely interjected 18th century Lowland Scots terms). I was doing that short-chapter-dual-POV happy dance, and, once we got them in the same room, was ready to shirk all responsibilities to follow along with the Scottish thistle and his English rose. We have our older MCs, established in their faith and maturity, just good and pious down to their core. What’s a grieving new laird to do when a scholarly, lanky, no-frills, spectacle-wearing Jacobite duke’s daughter unexpectedly lands on his doorstep? Why, hide her in his tower and promptly become simultaneously confounded, impressed and charmed by her, of course. Oh man, their first meeting? Deliciously awkward and terse. The Hume brothers, the loyal servants, the progression of their time together bantering and drawing closer amidst so much threat and worry, just so, so lovely. You’re lulled by the beautiful, tender romance and then “Bam! Oh right, these are perilous times”. It’s been a while since the imminent third act struggle/drama/peril whatever it would be had me so nervously bracing for impact. And I was right to because it does not let off, to the point I was reminding myself “This is a romance. I mean, it is, right? It’ll be fiiiine”. But for all the intensity, all the more satisfying, and I finally got my heart rate down and all the warm fuzzies.
Speaking of bracing for impact, my TBR better bolster up because now I need to read all Laura Frantz books.
Well, I certainly came in unprepared. I had read so many raving reviews and was like “ Me, me, me, I want to be transported to the Scottish Lowlands too!”. And yet, unprepared to be truly transported, devastated, and delighted as I was.
This is ridiculously good historical romance. I love to be hit with a nice and hefty glossary right off the bat (I think I’m basically a polyglot now, if we count sparsely interjected 18th century Lowland Scots terms). I was doing that short-chapter-dual-POV happy dance, and, once we got them in the same room, was ready to shirk all responsibilities to follow along with the Scottish thistle and his English rose. We have our older MCs, established in their faith and maturity, just good and pious down to their core. What’s a grieving new laird to do when a scholarly, lanky, no-frills, spectacle-wearing Jacobite duke’s daughter unexpectedly lands on his doorstep? Why, hide her in his tower and promptly become simultaneously confounded, impressed and charmed by her, of course. Oh man, their first meeting? Deliciously awkward and terse. The Hume brothers, the loyal servants, the progression of their time together bantering and drawing closer amidst so much threat and worry, just so, so lovely. You’re lulled by the beautiful, tender romance and then “Bam! Oh right, these are perilous times”. It’s been a while since the imminent third act struggle/drama/peril whatever it would be had me so nervously bracing for impact. And I was right to because it does not let off, to the point I was reminding myself “This is a romance. I mean, it is, right? It’ll be fiiiine”. But for all the intensity, all the more satisfying, and I finally got my heart rate down and all the warm fuzzies.
Speaking of bracing for impact, my TBR better bolster up because now I need to read all Laura Frantz books.
February 20, 2023
I listened to the audio version of The Rose and the Thistle and loved the story! Laura makes you feel like you are in historic Scotland! The characters are well written and the plot is wonderfully engaging. I wish I could give it more than 5 stars!
February 16, 2023
'Lord, please steady my spirit.'
How in the world do I even begin to write a review for a book written by Laura Frantz that will do it justice? I have been held captive by her words since reading her first book thirteen years ago. She absolutely never fails to completely take hold of my heart with her amazing way with words.
As always, Frantz's research is truly impeccable. For this history lover and reader, she always manages to have me looking up some of her details. It's just such an absolute delight to read her work. Then she crafts the most real characters and shows the reader their deepest heart. When I settle down to read a book by Laura Frantz, I am immediately transported to the time of the story and snuggle in for a totally satisfying adventure. For that is what her books do: they take me on an adventure. I am, quite simply, lost in her created world and regret having to return to the present world. She is a master at her craft and my heart sings when I hear she has a new book coming.
A forever favorite is Laura Frantz's work and her books are definitely on my keeper shelf and are reread. Well done!
My thanks to Revell Publishing for a copy of this book via the Net Galley platform. The opinion here is my own.
How in the world do I even begin to write a review for a book written by Laura Frantz that will do it justice? I have been held captive by her words since reading her first book thirteen years ago. She absolutely never fails to completely take hold of my heart with her amazing way with words.
As always, Frantz's research is truly impeccable. For this history lover and reader, she always manages to have me looking up some of her details. It's just such an absolute delight to read her work. Then she crafts the most real characters and shows the reader their deepest heart. When I settle down to read a book by Laura Frantz, I am immediately transported to the time of the story and snuggle in for a totally satisfying adventure. For that is what her books do: they take me on an adventure. I am, quite simply, lost in her created world and regret having to return to the present world. She is a master at her craft and my heart sings when I hear she has a new book coming.
A forever favorite is Laura Frantz's work and her books are definitely on my keeper shelf and are reread. Well done!
My thanks to Revell Publishing for a copy of this book via the Net Galley platform. The opinion here is my own.
January 7, 2023
Where do I begin? How can I put into words the enchanting beauty of this novel, this lovely work of art?
I’ve noticed many reviews for The Rose and the Thistle thus far coming from first-time Frantz readers—and I’m not surprised that they all say this book of hers won’t be their last. TRATT is exactly the exquisite wonder I have come to expect from Laura Frantz, and I know everyone—long-time fans and new readers—will be as captivated by this story of an English rose and a Scottish thistle as I was.
I first fell in love for this novel just from the blurb (or, let’s face it, the author name). A love story set in the Scottish Lowlands during the beginning of the Jacobite Uprising? I simply could not ask for anything better. I’ve long wanted a novel set during the Jacobite rebellions, because it was SUCH an intriguing time period that seems so often overlooked in favor of the classics like the American Revolution or the American Civil War. (Is it just me, or are all the American wars overdone?)
Then I met Lady Blythe Hedley. A tall, “plain” bluestocking tossed to and fro by the ever-shifting loyalties and betrayals within and without her country. Despite this, she kept such a level head, a gracious spirit, and a God-honoring heart. Never complained, never snapped, never lorded herself over others, never expressed false humility...basically, she never fell for any of the classic blunders of most heroines, so how could I not love her? (For the record, all of Frantz’s heroines are p e r f e c t i o n.)
I did have one qualm with Blythe. She was one of those heroines who jumped to a harebrained (and really unnecessary) conclusion and dwelt on it even when it was completely unfounded and just plain dumb. But more on that later!
As for Everard Hume… The first chapter with him had me cocking an eyebrow, and I told him sternly, “Make me fall in love with you, dude.” And he did. Oh, good heavens, he did. Why did I ever doubt him (and Laura)? He was the ideal strong, silent, tall, dark, broody, and handsome type (read: my type), and his character was always so authentically written and flawlessly portrayed. He had his soft spots (namely Orin), but he never acted out of character or weak. He was just the perfect combination of sweet and precious and blunt and brooding. Plus, he didn’t take no crap! *applause rings out* I love a good nondramatic hero.
Obviously, I had no qualms with him.
But I did have a small issue (not necessarily a good or bad issue, I guess) with both of them. Neither had an arc. No character growth. The development was spot-on, yes, but there was no change or, well, anything. Had the novel been plot-driven, it would’ve made sense. But…it wasn’t. It was the perfect blend of character-driven and plot-driven, but still no character arcs. THAT SAID, I didn’t miss them, not really. The story was fine without it, but in retrospect it does make me wonder if it would’ve been even better with at least one small character arc.
In keeping with my addressing of qualms, let’s revisit the jumping-to-conclusions subject, shall we? I feel like some drama/conflict may have been forced in with that stupid conclusion Blythe jumped to, and it a way it felt a bit sloppy/contrived...but on the other hand, Everard took all the drama in stride and put it to a swift end. So the drama never saw its fullness, which made me curious as to why it was even there to begin with. *shrugs* Not that big of a deal, I suppose, but I have to find something to nitpick on about this pretty much perfect book. *winks*
Now, back to the good stuff.
This story was ripe for contention and ranting. Frantz could have easily turned this into a Catholic vs. Protestant rant or a political argument…but she didn’t. She clearly and graciously portrayed both sides (religiously and politically) and didn’t create unnecessary conflict between Blythe and Everard with their different beliefs. They respected each other, considered everything from an objective point-of-view, and moved on with their lives. Literally the first time this has ever happened in the history of everything I’ve ever read. *sobs tears of joy*
On that note, I love how Frantz so naturally and authentically writes faith. Nothing is forced, diluted, or too concentrated—everything flows so seamlessly and genuinely. It feels real, not written, you know?
The same goes for her romances, her settings, her accents—all of it! This story came to life so vibrantly and, as Blythe would say, enthrallingly, and I am just in pure awe every time of how talented and skilled Laura Frantz is. How she weaves every element together in a glorious tapestry. How she draws you in and grips you through every single page. How her words become poetry, even when written in Scots.
It’s like this: I’d like to say I found a way to put The Rose and the Thistle into words...but even in this I have still failed. Just read it, folks, and you’ll see this magnificent story unfold a million times better than I could ever describe.
Disclaimer: I received a complimentary review copy of this novel from the publisher. All opinions expressed are my own.
I’ve noticed many reviews for The Rose and the Thistle thus far coming from first-time Frantz readers—and I’m not surprised that they all say this book of hers won’t be their last. TRATT is exactly the exquisite wonder I have come to expect from Laura Frantz, and I know everyone—long-time fans and new readers—will be as captivated by this story of an English rose and a Scottish thistle as I was.
I first fell in love for this novel just from the blurb (or, let’s face it, the author name). A love story set in the Scottish Lowlands during the beginning of the Jacobite Uprising? I simply could not ask for anything better. I’ve long wanted a novel set during the Jacobite rebellions, because it was SUCH an intriguing time period that seems so often overlooked in favor of the classics like the American Revolution or the American Civil War. (Is it just me, or are all the American wars overdone?)
Then I met Lady Blythe Hedley. A tall, “plain” bluestocking tossed to and fro by the ever-shifting loyalties and betrayals within and without her country. Despite this, she kept such a level head, a gracious spirit, and a God-honoring heart. Never complained, never snapped, never lorded herself over others, never expressed false humility...basically, she never fell for any of the classic blunders of most heroines, so how could I not love her? (For the record, all of Frantz’s heroines are p e r f e c t i o n.)
I did have one qualm with Blythe. She was one of those heroines who jumped to a harebrained (and really unnecessary) conclusion and dwelt on it even when it was completely unfounded and just plain dumb. But more on that later!
As for Everard Hume… The first chapter with him had me cocking an eyebrow, and I told him sternly, “Make me fall in love with you, dude.” And he did. Oh, good heavens, he did. Why did I ever doubt him (and Laura)? He was the ideal strong, silent, tall, dark, broody, and handsome type (read: my type), and his character was always so authentically written and flawlessly portrayed. He had his soft spots (namely Orin), but he never acted out of character or weak. He was just the perfect combination of sweet and precious and blunt and brooding. Plus, he didn’t take no crap! *applause rings out* I love a good nondramatic hero.
Obviously, I had no qualms with him.
But I did have a small issue (not necessarily a good or bad issue, I guess) with both of them. Neither had an arc. No character growth. The development was spot-on, yes, but there was no change or, well, anything. Had the novel been plot-driven, it would’ve made sense. But…it wasn’t. It was the perfect blend of character-driven and plot-driven, but still no character arcs. THAT SAID, I didn’t miss them, not really. The story was fine without it, but in retrospect it does make me wonder if it would’ve been even better with at least one small character arc.
In keeping with my addressing of qualms, let’s revisit the jumping-to-conclusions subject, shall we? I feel like some drama/conflict may have been forced in with that stupid conclusion Blythe jumped to, and it a way it felt a bit sloppy/contrived...but on the other hand, Everard took all the drama in stride and put it to a swift end. So the drama never saw its fullness, which made me curious as to why it was even there to begin with. *shrugs* Not that big of a deal, I suppose, but I have to find something to nitpick on about this pretty much perfect book. *winks*
Now, back to the good stuff.
This story was ripe for contention and ranting. Frantz could have easily turned this into a Catholic vs. Protestant rant or a political argument…but she didn’t. She clearly and graciously portrayed both sides (religiously and politically) and didn’t create unnecessary conflict between Blythe and Everard with their different beliefs. They respected each other, considered everything from an objective point-of-view, and moved on with their lives. Literally the first time this has ever happened in the history of everything I’ve ever read. *sobs tears of joy*
On that note, I love how Frantz so naturally and authentically writes faith. Nothing is forced, diluted, or too concentrated—everything flows so seamlessly and genuinely. It feels real, not written, you know?
The same goes for her romances, her settings, her accents—all of it! This story came to life so vibrantly and, as Blythe would say, enthrallingly, and I am just in pure awe every time of how talented and skilled Laura Frantz is. How she weaves every element together in a glorious tapestry. How she draws you in and grips you through every single page. How her words become poetry, even when written in Scots.
It’s like this: I’d like to say I found a way to put The Rose and the Thistle into words...but even in this I have still failed. Just read it, folks, and you’ll see this magnificent story unfold a million times better than I could ever describe.
Disclaimer: I received a complimentary review copy of this novel from the publisher. All opinions expressed are my own.
February 7, 2023
I can't express how amazing this story was. Laura Frantz has written yet another great story that I completely was consumed with until the wee hours of the night! The research for this story was impeccable. The details were so vivid it was like you were in the story with these characters. Made you want to travel to Scotland!
The story is set in the 1700's during the Jacobite rebellion. Lady Blythe and Everard are put together rather blindly due to some unpreventable circumstances but I loved how their story comes together. Theirs is definitely a slow burn but I was completely invested in it. Their interactions were great and goodness is he swoony!! The way their love blossomed was truly amazing
There are other characters in the story that also need mentioning, the Hume brothers definitely not only make a mark on the storyline but also in your heart especially the adorable younger brother Orin. Seriously I could go back into this timeline to read his story as a grown man and also his brothers.
The faith thread was intact and strong as Lady Blythe must make a choice to follow her Catholic faith or Laird Everard's. Decisions must be made, there are twists and turns that were not expected and there is of course romance!!
Overall I absolutely loved this story so much and I cannot wait to read more from Mrs. Frantz! I now wait impatiently for her next book!
I received a copy of this book from the publisher. I was not required to post a positive review. All views expressed are only my honest opinion.
The story is set in the 1700's during the Jacobite rebellion. Lady Blythe and Everard are put together rather blindly due to some unpreventable circumstances but I loved how their story comes together. Theirs is definitely a slow burn but I was completely invested in it. Their interactions were great and goodness is he swoony!! The way their love blossomed was truly amazing
There are other characters in the story that also need mentioning, the Hume brothers definitely not only make a mark on the storyline but also in your heart especially the adorable younger brother Orin. Seriously I could go back into this timeline to read his story as a grown man and also his brothers.
The faith thread was intact and strong as Lady Blythe must make a choice to follow her Catholic faith or Laird Everard's. Decisions must be made, there are twists and turns that were not expected and there is of course romance!!
Overall I absolutely loved this story so much and I cannot wait to read more from Mrs. Frantz! I now wait impatiently for her next book!
I received a copy of this book from the publisher. I was not required to post a positive review. All views expressed are only my honest opinion.
January 1, 2023
Ms. Frantz has penned a tender love story set during the Jacobite Rebellion of 1715 in Scotland. An unlikely pairing of Catholic Lady Blythe Hadley from northern England and a Presbyterian Scottish laird, Everard Hume, from just across the border.
This was a very well-researched story. The author went the extra miles to travel to the area where the book is set. It was fascinating to find out that the hero was patterned after her ancestors and that she used actual castles and places. Some of the real characters leapt out of history and onto the page to make history come alive.
The dangers seemed very possible and the plot was well-crafted. You could feel the struggles that Blythe had to deal with being put in an awkward and perilous situation. The descriptions set the stage admirably.
Everard was a worthy hero who had his earldom thrust upon him unexpectedly. However, he did everything with prayer and relied on God. He and Blythe focused on their common faith and were not swayed by their circumstances.
Another wonderful historical from a favorite author.
*I received a complimentary copy of this book from Library Thing and Revell on behalf of the author. I was not required to post a favorable review. All opinions are my own.*
This was a very well-researched story. The author went the extra miles to travel to the area where the book is set. It was fascinating to find out that the hero was patterned after her ancestors and that she used actual castles and places. Some of the real characters leapt out of history and onto the page to make history come alive.
The dangers seemed very possible and the plot was well-crafted. You could feel the struggles that Blythe had to deal with being put in an awkward and perilous situation. The descriptions set the stage admirably.
Everard was a worthy hero who had his earldom thrust upon him unexpectedly. However, he did everything with prayer and relied on God. He and Blythe focused on their common faith and were not swayed by their circumstances.
Another wonderful historical from a favorite author.
*I received a complimentary copy of this book from Library Thing and Revell on behalf of the author. I was not required to post a favorable review. All opinions are my own.*
January 19, 2023
Disclosure: I received this book free from the publisher/author. The opinions I have expressed are my own, and I was not required to write a review. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255.
Characters: Both Everard and Blythe were believable characters who had flaws. In the beginning of the book, Everard was the typical sullen historical dude at the beginning. Once he started to take notice of Blythe, his sullenness lessened and his good character traits became apparent. Although I understand a dram of liquor is a small amount, he partook of whiskey and brandy quite a bit. I liked that Blythe was different than the average romance heroine in that she was plain and kind of tall (even though she hated it).
Language: Clean
Plot: Action and suspenseful scenes kept the book moving, but the main story revolved around Everard and Blythe's budding romance.
Random comments: I thought the Catholic/Protestant subplot was presented in a wishy-washy manner. It was presented that if the characters believed in God, religious affiliation or beliefs were insignificant.
Romance: Clean. Kissing and some comments I would rather not have read.
Themes: This novel featured themes of devotion to family, kindness, honor, and worth.
Writing: I found the time period a little confusing, but I understood better the more I read. Or maybe it didn't matter because the romance was the main storyline! I wasn't a fan of Everard's written-out accent. Sometimes it got way too thick and cumbersome. I suppose it did add a touch of realism though. The writing was beautifully descriptive; I could picture myself in a 1700s castle, looking out over the Scottish countryside, or relaxing in the picturesque gardens.
Overall: The Rose and the Thistle was an entertaining read that I'd recommend to those who enjoy Christian fiction and historical romance.
** Written with the assistance of the Typo Queen **
Characters: Both Everard and Blythe were believable characters who had flaws. In the beginning of the book, Everard was the typical sullen historical dude at the beginning. Once he started to take notice of Blythe, his sullenness lessened and his good character traits became apparent. Although I understand a dram of liquor is a small amount, he partook of whiskey and brandy quite a bit. I liked that Blythe was different than the average romance heroine in that she was plain and kind of tall (even though she hated it).
Language: Clean
Plot: Action and suspenseful scenes kept the book moving, but the main story revolved around Everard and Blythe's budding romance.
Random comments: I thought the Catholic/Protestant subplot was presented in a wishy-washy manner. It was presented that if the characters believed in God, religious affiliation or beliefs were insignificant.
Romance: Clean. Kissing and some comments I would rather not have read.
Themes: This novel featured themes of devotion to family, kindness, honor, and worth.
Writing: I found the time period a little confusing, but I understood better the more I read. Or maybe it didn't matter because the romance was the main storyline! I wasn't a fan of Everard's written-out accent. Sometimes it got way too thick and cumbersome. I suppose it did add a touch of realism though. The writing was beautifully descriptive; I could picture myself in a 1700s castle, looking out over the Scottish countryside, or relaxing in the picturesque gardens.
Overall: The Rose and the Thistle was an entertaining read that I'd recommend to those who enjoy Christian fiction and historical romance.
** Written with the assistance of the Typo Queen **
Did Not Finish
November 12, 2023dnf at page 120, ch 21.
If you like history, slow burn romance, and old Scottish slang, you might like this!
I can like slow burn romance, but history and words I don't understand? nahhhhh
I struggled to connect to these characters due to the dialogue being lost on me a lot of the time.
Then all the descriptions of the political upheaval just lost me right away.
I'm glad I gave it a try! I've heard that this is a great alternative to Outlander.
I would still try another book by this author.
If you like history, slow burn romance, and old Scottish slang, you might like this!
I can like slow burn romance, but history and words I don't understand? nahhhhh
I struggled to connect to these characters due to the dialogue being lost on me a lot of the time.
Then all the descriptions of the political upheaval just lost me right away.
I'm glad I gave it a try! I've heard that this is a great alternative to Outlander.
I would still try another book by this author.
May 24, 2026
When a raid hits Lady Blythe’s Loyalist home, she flees to Scotland and crashes straight into Everard Wedderburn’s grief, guarded heart, and fragile patience.
Lord Wedderburn is determined to stay cold and composed, and absolutely unimpressed by the sharp tongued English lady invading his life. Naturally, enemy banter begins immediately.
Blythe desperately wants to leave. Everard seems delighted by the idea. Or… maybe not quite as delighted as he claims.
Then comes the fun. A misunderstanding involving a water kelpie. A tutoring job she definitely did not sign up for.
The slow burn is perfection. Every glance, clipped conversation and moment of reluctant admiration builds beautifully:
If you love Jane Austen, this Scottish twist in the Jacobite era will steal your heart with lines like this:
You will inhale the entire last 25%, the end is a wild ride of twists, turns, hopes and prayers.
👉Overall: if you love a great plot, beautiful themes of faith, loyalty, family, and sacrifice; you’ll love this book. Standouts were: dual love stories, the rich Jacobite history, and immersive historical quotes woven before each chapter. Between the humor, yearning and emotional punches, this book completely swept me away.
Lord Wedderburn is determined to stay cold and composed, and absolutely unimpressed by the sharp tongued English lady invading his life. Naturally, enemy banter begins immediately.
“See your mistress becomes herself as a lady of her station.” 🫢
Blythe desperately wants to leave. Everard seems delighted by the idea. Or… maybe not quite as delighted as he claims.
Then comes the fun. A misunderstanding involving a water kelpie. A tutoring job she definitely did not sign up for.
“Do you often assign houseguests such tasks?”
“Only Duke’s daughters.” 🤣
The slow burn is perfection. Every glance, clipped conversation and moment of reluctant admiration builds beautifully:
“M’Lord, forgive me I’m not fit to be seen.”
“I beg to differ, such becomes you.” 💛
If you love Jane Austen, this Scottish twist in the Jacobite era will steal your heart with lines like this:
“I am yours completely.” 💛
You will inhale the entire last 25%, the end is a wild ride of twists, turns, hopes and prayers.
👉Overall: if you love a great plot, beautiful themes of faith, loyalty, family, and sacrifice; you’ll love this book. Standouts were: dual love stories, the rich Jacobite history, and immersive historical quotes woven before each chapter. Between the humor, yearning and emotional punches, this book completely swept me away.
December 22, 2022
This was my first book of Laura Frantz's, but it will not be my last. Set in beautiful Scotland during the first Jacobite rebellion of 1715, this book is rich in historical details with layers of political and religious intrigue.
It did take me a couple of chapters to really get into, but once I did, I adored every second of it. I loved seeing a glimpse of both sides of the rebellion. The faith was masterfully interwoven through each page. The characters were wonderful. Even the side characters were well developed more than one-dimensional.
The banter between Blythe and Everard was so much fun. I loved the Hume brothers (most of them). I honestly would read an entire series based on them.
I look forward to reading more of Frantz's work!
*Thank you to NetGalley and Revell for the advanced copy. All opinions are my own.
"Sin oft comes disguised glittering and crowned, not reeking and clad in rags."
"God Himself sets rulers upon thrones, does He not? And topples those He wills."
"You are still my English rose. While I remain your Scottish thistle."
"Though much was beyond her control, she could still rejoice the Almighty ruled over earthly kings and military commanders."
It did take me a couple of chapters to really get into, but once I did, I adored every second of it. I loved seeing a glimpse of both sides of the rebellion. The faith was masterfully interwoven through each page. The characters were wonderful. Even the side characters were well developed more than one-dimensional.
The banter between Blythe and Everard was so much fun. I loved the Hume brothers (most of them). I honestly would read an entire series based on them.
I look forward to reading more of Frantz's work!
*Thank you to NetGalley and Revell for the advanced copy. All opinions are my own.
"Sin oft comes disguised glittering and crowned, not reeking and clad in rags."
"God Himself sets rulers upon thrones, does He not? And topples those He wills."
"You are still my English rose. While I remain your Scottish thistle."
"Though much was beyond her control, she could still rejoice the Almighty ruled over earthly kings and military commanders."
November 27, 2023
A damsel in distress, a stalwart hero, grief, betrayal, war, and love. This story has it all.
Lady Blythe is secreted in the middle of the night to a castle in Scotland for her protection. We meet the former soldier, Everard, now Lord Wedderburn, thankfully first impressions aren't always what they seem. Each has to make choices about their futures and where their alliances will lie - knowing these decisions aren't made lightly.
The author does an excellent job unveiling these characters and the circumstances they find themselves in. This story kept moving into new scenes, with new dangers until you finish this book and end with a sigh of contentment.
It takes place during a historical time and place I was less familiar with. The tension between Protestant and Catholic faith is evident, while both characters lean strongly on their faith in Christ.
This will be a favourite of the year! Highly recommend.
Lady Blythe is secreted in the middle of the night to a castle in Scotland for her protection. We meet the former soldier, Everard, now Lord Wedderburn, thankfully first impressions aren't always what they seem. Each has to make choices about their futures and where their alliances will lie - knowing these decisions aren't made lightly.
The author does an excellent job unveiling these characters and the circumstances they find themselves in. This story kept moving into new scenes, with new dangers until you finish this book and end with a sigh of contentment.
It takes place during a historical time and place I was less familiar with. The tension between Protestant and Catholic faith is evident, while both characters lean strongly on their faith in Christ.
This will be a favourite of the year! Highly recommend.
October 5, 2023
✨England and Scotland in 1715. the story centered around the Jacobite rebellion that occurred in Britain. The political climate is tense, with strong supporters on both sides making life difficult for those who want to survive the upheaval intact regardless of who is on the throne. It was a story that was delivered perfectly in just about every way…It has tender emotion, human struggle, intrigue, faith, courage, and strength of character beautifully displayed, and a warm and endearing romance, her descriptions were wonderfully visual..... the romance that developed from a rocky start, was very sweet, Everard was a perfect complement to Blythe strong and wise leader with the capacity for kindness and understanding.
“’ Surely there are praiseworthy things about her, as she was made in the Lord’s image.’” - What a great thought to ponder when struggling with others.
Just wanted to share my thoughts on The Rose and the Thistle by Laura Frantz, which I received as an ARC from Revell. I want to make it clear that I'm not obligated to write a positive review nor am I being compensated for doing so. With that said, I have to say that this novel is truly wonderful. It's my honest assessment and reflects my thoughts and opinions.
“’ Surely there are praiseworthy things about her, as she was made in the Lord’s image.’” - What a great thought to ponder when struggling with others.
Just wanted to share my thoughts on The Rose and the Thistle by Laura Frantz, which I received as an ARC from Revell. I want to make it clear that I'm not obligated to write a positive review nor am I being compensated for doing so. With that said, I have to say that this novel is truly wonderful. It's my honest assessment and reflects my thoughts and opinions.
January 18, 2023
What an exquisite novel! I felt as if I was truly immersed in the setting as the author wove her descriptions in seamlessly with the beautiful flow of the story. Even now, a day later, I can not stop thinking about these characters.
I so enjoyed the way they were basically thrown together. Their first meeting was jarring to them both, being both a surprise to Everard and happening in the middle of the night. He was definitely not the most gracious host that evening. However, it was fun to see into Blythe’s thoughts concerning him. She warred between frustration and attraction throughout their first few meetings.
It was a tumultuous time in Scotland and the threat to both Everard and his family, as well as Lady Blythe, was very real. It was intriguing to watch Everard attempt to keep everyone safe while hoping not to get pulled into the politics of the time.
The romance that bloomed between Everard and Blythe was simply swoon worthy! I loved seeing them both separately realize that their feelings had grown into love somewhere along the way. And they were both such genuinely caring and kind people, which was easily seen in the way the brothers and staff who resided at Wedderburn Castle were devoted to them.
I loved this wonderful story from start to finish and know that these characters will stay with me for a long time.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. All opinions are my own.
You can read this review on my blog:
https://brittreadsfiction.wordpress.c...
I so enjoyed the way they were basically thrown together. Their first meeting was jarring to them both, being both a surprise to Everard and happening in the middle of the night. He was definitely not the most gracious host that evening. However, it was fun to see into Blythe’s thoughts concerning him. She warred between frustration and attraction throughout their first few meetings.
It was a tumultuous time in Scotland and the threat to both Everard and his family, as well as Lady Blythe, was very real. It was intriguing to watch Everard attempt to keep everyone safe while hoping not to get pulled into the politics of the time.
The romance that bloomed between Everard and Blythe was simply swoon worthy! I loved seeing them both separately realize that their feelings had grown into love somewhere along the way. And they were both such genuinely caring and kind people, which was easily seen in the way the brothers and staff who resided at Wedderburn Castle were devoted to them.
I loved this wonderful story from start to finish and know that these characters will stay with me for a long time.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. All opinions are my own.
You can read this review on my blog:
https://brittreadsfiction.wordpress.c...
January 2, 2023
Laura Frantz’s books are amazing! She really knows how to make history come alive. Not only do you feel like you’ve been transported back in time, but the characters become so real it’s hard to let them go. The Rose and the Thistle is no exception and has to be one of my favorites of her books. It’s one I’ll want to reread and savor.
It’s the year 1715 and the Duke of Northumbria’s Jacobite sympathies have made him an enemy to the English King. He calls his daughter Lady Blythe home from France and appeals to her godfather Lord Wedderburn to take her in for her own protection. Before any arrangements can be made, Lady Blythe is forced to leave her home with just the clothes on her back. She flees to Wedderburn Castle in Scotland, but finds her presence is unwelcome.
Lord Everard Wedderburn is suddenly thrust into his position as Laird when his father dies. With several younger brothers to contend with, he finds his new responsibilities a bit overwhelming. The brewing political turmoil in which his brother David is involved also makes his position precarious despite his distinguished military service.
When Lady Blythe unexpectedly shows up on his doorstep, her presence is not only a threat, but must remain secret for her welfare as well as his own. But, keeping her a secret from his brothers proves to be too much. Her brilliant intellect and sweet disposition are just what his youngest brother Orin needs. The more time Everard spends with Blythe the more he loves their witty banter and feels an attraction towards her he’s not felt with any other woman. But are their differences too much to overcome especially with so much at stake?
I absolutely adored Blythe and Everard. Everard is everything a hero is meant to be. Not only is he absolutely swoon worthy with that Scottish brogue, but his dry sense of humor, leadership, strength, and tenderness are so endearing. I also loved that he has strong faith and isn’t afraid to show it.
I loved Blythe’s character as well. She’s faithful, smart, humble, and quick witted. She’s a bit self consciousness about her height, and her mother’s past which weighs on her. The attraction and love she feels towards Everard make her afraid she’ll turn out to be like her mother. It was so enjoyable when she finally allows herself to believe in Everard’s love. I also enjoyed her spunk and all the verbal repartee with Everard.
There’re some great twists and turns in this story that about tore my heart out. It’s one of those epic slow burn romances that pulls you in and won’t let go. All the characters are fabulous especially the brothers and I can’t wait to read more about them.
The history behind the story is fascinating. It was interesting to learn that this book is based on the author’s own ancestors. I loved the famous quotes at the beginning of each chapter and the way faith was naturally woven into the story. The historical religious conflict between Catholics and Protestants was a key issue which the author handled so well. Highly recommend this book to historical fiction, historical romance, and Christian fiction readers. Looking forward to the next book! I received an advanced complimentary copy from the publisher. All opinions are my own and I was not required to provide a positive review.
It’s the year 1715 and the Duke of Northumbria’s Jacobite sympathies have made him an enemy to the English King. He calls his daughter Lady Blythe home from France and appeals to her godfather Lord Wedderburn to take her in for her own protection. Before any arrangements can be made, Lady Blythe is forced to leave her home with just the clothes on her back. She flees to Wedderburn Castle in Scotland, but finds her presence is unwelcome.
Lord Everard Wedderburn is suddenly thrust into his position as Laird when his father dies. With several younger brothers to contend with, he finds his new responsibilities a bit overwhelming. The brewing political turmoil in which his brother David is involved also makes his position precarious despite his distinguished military service.
When Lady Blythe unexpectedly shows up on his doorstep, her presence is not only a threat, but must remain secret for her welfare as well as his own. But, keeping her a secret from his brothers proves to be too much. Her brilliant intellect and sweet disposition are just what his youngest brother Orin needs. The more time Everard spends with Blythe the more he loves their witty banter and feels an attraction towards her he’s not felt with any other woman. But are their differences too much to overcome especially with so much at stake?
I absolutely adored Blythe and Everard. Everard is everything a hero is meant to be. Not only is he absolutely swoon worthy with that Scottish brogue, but his dry sense of humor, leadership, strength, and tenderness are so endearing. I also loved that he has strong faith and isn’t afraid to show it.
I loved Blythe’s character as well. She’s faithful, smart, humble, and quick witted. She’s a bit self consciousness about her height, and her mother’s past which weighs on her. The attraction and love she feels towards Everard make her afraid she’ll turn out to be like her mother. It was so enjoyable when she finally allows herself to believe in Everard’s love. I also enjoyed her spunk and all the verbal repartee with Everard.
There’re some great twists and turns in this story that about tore my heart out. It’s one of those epic slow burn romances that pulls you in and won’t let go. All the characters are fabulous especially the brothers and I can’t wait to read more about them.
The history behind the story is fascinating. It was interesting to learn that this book is based on the author’s own ancestors. I loved the famous quotes at the beginning of each chapter and the way faith was naturally woven into the story. The historical religious conflict between Catholics and Protestants was a key issue which the author handled so well. Highly recommend this book to historical fiction, historical romance, and Christian fiction readers. Looking forward to the next book! I received an advanced complimentary copy from the publisher. All opinions are my own and I was not required to provide a positive review.
January 4, 2023
I didn't want this beautiful book to end as I turned each page, mesmerized by Laura Frantz's brilliance. It's a rare author that really captures long-ago cultures as believably as she.
Everard is the dark, brawny Lord of a Scottish castle, a Presbyterian, and neutral in the Jacobite uprising. Blythe is a willowy, fair, Catholic from England, the daughter of a duke who is in hiding for his part in the rebellion.
It was interesting when the time came for one of them to set aside their loyalties for the sake of the marriage, how effortless it seemed; one short conversation, and they were converted (with a few short mentions later). It just made me wonder about it, how many people in history have had to make a similar decision based not on their study of theology or conviction from God but for the sake of politics or family.
But I found the story entrancing and educational. This is a book that forces you to slow down but is not too academic to enjoy.
I received a copy through JustReads Tours for posting on social media but was not required to write a review.
Everard is the dark, brawny Lord of a Scottish castle, a Presbyterian, and neutral in the Jacobite uprising. Blythe is a willowy, fair, Catholic from England, the daughter of a duke who is in hiding for his part in the rebellion.
It was interesting when the time came for one of them to set aside their loyalties for the sake of the marriage, how effortless it seemed; one short conversation, and they were converted (with a few short mentions later). It just made me wonder about it, how many people in history have had to make a similar decision based not on their study of theology or conviction from God but for the sake of politics or family.
But I found the story entrancing and educational. This is a book that forces you to slow down but is not too academic to enjoy.
I received a copy through JustReads Tours for posting on social media but was not required to write a review.
January 5, 2023
This book has religious tensions, political intrigue, rich Scottish & English heritage, and so much more. With once again both a strong male and female lead, I'm beginning to see Laura Frantz's type... ;)
I enjoyed this story, with so many rich historical details set in a period of time I don't know much about or read about either. Laura has the skill to craft a story about history no one knows about and take you directly into the setting with her words. This particular time of history fascinated me and now I'd like to do some research on my own.
I did find it slow to get going (the plot only really started around the 20-25% mark), but once I got past the beginning, I finished it in one sitting.
For some reason, I had the impression this would be a Beauty & the Beast retelling, which it was not - at least, I don't know for sure... it had some very similar aspects to the fairytale. You have the smart, bookish heroine, coupled with a faraway castle in foreign lands.
I wasn't sure how faith would be dealt with considering the tensions between Catholics and Protestants during this time period, but I thought Laura Frantz did a good job sharing both sides. I did have to wonder at how easily one of characters took up the other religion in order to marry. That's quite a step to take, laying aside loyalties to a religion and all the religious ceremonies that go with it. It makes one wonder how many people truly believed the faith they were professing during that time.
All that to say, I did love how both characters were serious about their faith, and not just token Christians but actually turned to God in prayer in many situations where direction was needed. This was encouraging and refreshing to read.
*I received a copy of The Rose and the Thistle from the publisher via Netgalley. I was not required to leave a positive opinion, and all thoughts are my own.
Content Note: This does feature a married couple at one point, although this aspect was very tastefully done. I enjoyed seeing a peek at the 'happily-ever-after' side of marriage.
I enjoyed this story, with so many rich historical details set in a period of time I don't know much about or read about either. Laura has the skill to craft a story about history no one knows about and take you directly into the setting with her words. This particular time of history fascinated me and now I'd like to do some research on my own.
I did find it slow to get going (the plot only really started around the 20-25% mark), but once I got past the beginning, I finished it in one sitting.
For some reason, I had the impression this would be a Beauty & the Beast retelling, which it was not - at least, I don't know for sure... it had some very similar aspects to the fairytale. You have the smart, bookish heroine, coupled with a faraway castle in foreign lands.
I wasn't sure how faith would be dealt with considering the tensions between Catholics and Protestants during this time period, but I thought Laura Frantz did a good job sharing both sides. I did have to wonder at how easily one of characters took up the other religion in order to marry. That's quite a step to take, laying aside loyalties to a religion and all the religious ceremonies that go with it. It makes one wonder how many people truly believed the faith they were professing during that time.
All that to say, I did love how both characters were serious about their faith, and not just token Christians but actually turned to God in prayer in many situations where direction was needed. This was encouraging and refreshing to read.
*I received a copy of The Rose and the Thistle from the publisher via Netgalley. I was not required to leave a positive opinion, and all thoughts are my own.
Content Note: This does feature a married couple at one point, although this aspect was very tastefully done. I enjoyed seeing a peek at the 'happily-ever-after' side of marriage.
January 4, 2023
The Rose and the Thistle is an engaging and wonderful book set in France, England and Scotland. I know virtually nothing about the United Kingdom's history so I found myself "googling" to find out even more about the historical figures in the book. I fell in love with Everard the very tall, dark and handsome warrior. Especially by the way he took such loving care of his eight year old brother Orin. Who, by the way is absolutely precious. The heroine, Blythe is very intelligent and kind hearted lady. The romance is beautifully done and I did some swooning. If you love historical romance, then I recommend this exceptional book to you.
I do hope the author would do a romance story with Everard's other brothers. They each are such great characters, that I'd love to see them have their own story.
*I was given a copy by Revell Publishers and this is my honest opinion.
I do hope the author would do a romance story with Everard's other brothers. They each are such great characters, that I'd love to see them have their own story.
*I was given a copy by Revell Publishers and this is my honest opinion.
January 13, 2023
“Lord, please steady my spirit.”
From the moment I met Colonel Cassius McLinn on the pages of The Colonel’s Lady I have been a HUGE fan of Laura Frantz and her exquisitely written stories. Since it’s humanly impossible for me to read all the books (though that certainly doesn’t keep me from trying), I’m sadly behind on a couple of her most recent novels but I was determined to be intentional about reading her newest, The Rose and the Thistle. Because, hello. Swoony Scottish hero. Strong English heroine. Political tensions. Family tensions. Romantical tensions. Even a water kelpie, of sorts.
Did I mention the swoony Scottish hero??
There’s something so knee-weakening about a Scottish brogue when attached to a man of integrity & quiet strength. And Everard Hume, the newly appointed laird of Wedderburn, definitely fits the bill… as do most of his brothers, too. I fell a bit in love with all of the Hume brothers, save the onerous David, and I could contentedly read novels that follow each of them for years to come. (And ohhhhhhh how I need a story that features the adorable youngest brother Orin – “I have met the water kelpie, and she is, in fact, a duke’s daughter” – once he’s all grown up.) Frantz does a splendid job of developing Everard’s character through a series of difficult circumstances, any one of which by itself would be enough to test my own emotional mettle. You will savor time spent with Everard, just as Blythe does, because in spite of facing several uphill challenges he maintains his quiet affection for those in his charge, his integrity, and even his sense of humor.
“Remember whose you are.”
Her father’s Jacobite ties lead to Lady Blythe Hedley fleeing her home in England with only her lady’s maid in the middle of the night and bedraggledly arriving at Wedderburn castle where refuge had been promised. By Everard’s father. Who has just died. From the moment she opens her mouth upon arrival, Blythe challenges Everard in every way and I loved it! She’s Catholic. He’s Protestant. She’s English. He’s Scottish. He wants to keep her sequestered away for her own safety. She wants to be free to explore and interact. Her spirit is strong, even as she worries about her father and mourns the separation, and she clings to her faith despite the dangers in doing so. Gaining his respect first, she soon gains his heart and oh my stars you’ll love their romance! Be prepared to swoon… but don’t relax just yet. The most challenging part of their story is yet to come.
“Mine without question. But the Almighty’s foremost.”
Bottom Line: What a richly layered & beautiful story from start to finish! I easily embraced both Blythe and Everard as well as the delightful cast of supporting characters who also took over my heart. The history fascinated me and has me wanting to read more about this tumultuous time in English/Scottish history, and it just becomes even more intriguing when you read about the author’s personal ties to Wedderburn Castle and the Hume clan in her note to readers. Nobody captures the setting, the lilt, the romance and heartbreak of history quite like Laura Frantz does, and The Rose and the Thistle is another gorgeous example of her talent.
(I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book)
first reviewed (with full disclosure) at Reading Is My SuperPower
From the moment I met Colonel Cassius McLinn on the pages of The Colonel’s Lady I have been a HUGE fan of Laura Frantz and her exquisitely written stories. Since it’s humanly impossible for me to read all the books (though that certainly doesn’t keep me from trying), I’m sadly behind on a couple of her most recent novels but I was determined to be intentional about reading her newest, The Rose and the Thistle. Because, hello. Swoony Scottish hero. Strong English heroine. Political tensions. Family tensions. Romantical tensions. Even a water kelpie, of sorts.
Did I mention the swoony Scottish hero??
There’s something so knee-weakening about a Scottish brogue when attached to a man of integrity & quiet strength. And Everard Hume, the newly appointed laird of Wedderburn, definitely fits the bill… as do most of his brothers, too. I fell a bit in love with all of the Hume brothers, save the onerous David, and I could contentedly read novels that follow each of them for years to come. (And ohhhhhhh how I need a story that features the adorable youngest brother Orin – “I have met the water kelpie, and she is, in fact, a duke’s daughter” – once he’s all grown up.) Frantz does a splendid job of developing Everard’s character through a series of difficult circumstances, any one of which by itself would be enough to test my own emotional mettle. You will savor time spent with Everard, just as Blythe does, because in spite of facing several uphill challenges he maintains his quiet affection for those in his charge, his integrity, and even his sense of humor.
“Remember whose you are.”
Her father’s Jacobite ties lead to Lady Blythe Hedley fleeing her home in England with only her lady’s maid in the middle of the night and bedraggledly arriving at Wedderburn castle where refuge had been promised. By Everard’s father. Who has just died. From the moment she opens her mouth upon arrival, Blythe challenges Everard in every way and I loved it! She’s Catholic. He’s Protestant. She’s English. He’s Scottish. He wants to keep her sequestered away for her own safety. She wants to be free to explore and interact. Her spirit is strong, even as she worries about her father and mourns the separation, and she clings to her faith despite the dangers in doing so. Gaining his respect first, she soon gains his heart and oh my stars you’ll love their romance! Be prepared to swoon… but don’t relax just yet. The most challenging part of their story is yet to come.
“Mine without question. But the Almighty’s foremost.”
Bottom Line: What a richly layered & beautiful story from start to finish! I easily embraced both Blythe and Everard as well as the delightful cast of supporting characters who also took over my heart. The history fascinated me and has me wanting to read more about this tumultuous time in English/Scottish history, and it just becomes even more intriguing when you read about the author’s personal ties to Wedderburn Castle and the Hume clan in her note to readers. Nobody captures the setting, the lilt, the romance and heartbreak of history quite like Laura Frantz does, and The Rose and the Thistle is another gorgeous example of her talent.
(I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book)
first reviewed (with full disclosure) at Reading Is My SuperPower
January 3, 2023
Let me first start by saying I received this book in the mail on Sunday and I finished it today. I’m more than thrilled I was able to devour this book in time for release day!
Now onto my main review:
This was my first time reading anything by Laura Frantz, and I know it won’t be my last. I was absolutely blown away by so many aspects: her prose, her attention to historical detail, her pacing and plot.
Truly, reading this novel felt like a time-traveling experience as I was thrust into the throes of Scottish and English life in the early 1700s. It just felt so real and authentic, like a movie played out on paper.
One of my favorite aspects about Laura’s characters was their communication! I don’t like the miscommunication trope at all, but any time something remotely reeked of it, the situation was approached with decorum and maturity. It was a breath of fresh air to read a book with mature characters, yes they are in their late to early thirties, but they actually acted like it.
And the romance was so pure and sweet! What started out as enemies soon turned into lovers in the most beautiful way.
I also love how this book’s focus wasn’t solely on the romance, either. It had family and friendships, war tactics and politics, suspense and depth, the divide between Protestantism and Catholicism (which I thought was handled well). There was just so much to love.
All in all, I give this a full 5/5 stars! Well done, Laura! I look forward to reading more from you.
Content:
Closed door romance—the couple is married and intimacy is implied, but you see nothing.
Mentions of infidelity.
No language.
Minor war violence.
*I received a complimentary copy of this book from Revell. All thoughts expressed are my own*
Now onto my main review:
This was my first time reading anything by Laura Frantz, and I know it won’t be my last. I was absolutely blown away by so many aspects: her prose, her attention to historical detail, her pacing and plot.
Truly, reading this novel felt like a time-traveling experience as I was thrust into the throes of Scottish and English life in the early 1700s. It just felt so real and authentic, like a movie played out on paper.
One of my favorite aspects about Laura’s characters was their communication! I don’t like the miscommunication trope at all, but any time something remotely reeked of it, the situation was approached with decorum and maturity. It was a breath of fresh air to read a book with mature characters, yes they are in their late to early thirties, but they actually acted like it.
And the romance was so pure and sweet! What started out as enemies soon turned into lovers in the most beautiful way.
I also love how this book’s focus wasn’t solely on the romance, either. It had family and friendships, war tactics and politics, suspense and depth, the divide between Protestantism and Catholicism (which I thought was handled well). There was just so much to love.
All in all, I give this a full 5/5 stars! Well done, Laura! I look forward to reading more from you.
Content:
Closed door romance—the couple is married and intimacy is implied, but you see nothing.
Mentions of infidelity.
No language.
Minor war violence.
*I received a complimentary copy of this book from Revell. All thoughts expressed are my own*
February 24, 2023
Every time I read Laura Frantz, I can't help but admire her writing style. It's always poetic and full of language characteristic of the setting, so much so in this novel that the first few pages contain a glossary of Scottish terms! Her substantial research is evident here and as a historical fiction connoisseur, this is something I always appreciate. I loved this book. It's full of romance and intrigue. The plot line flowed beautifully and I enjoyed the characters. I was immersed in it from start to finish. I'd happily read anything written by this author, but this is my favorite one yet.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed are entirely my own.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed are entirely my own.
February 28, 2023
Beautifully written historical fiction! I always enjoy Laura Frantz’s books! I prefer the American to the Scottish books. But I did really enjoy the characters and the lovely story telling.
January 8, 2023
“You are still my English rose. While I remain your Scottish thistle.”
My favorite Laura Frantz novel to date! I loved returning to Scotland through the author’s captivating storytelling and learned a great deal about the Jacobite Rising in 1715 through Blythe and Everard. Lush details of Scottish country life and swirling political unrest, unforgettable characters, heart-stopping romance, strong faith thread that overcomes denominational barrier, and gripping plot all make this book a worthy read and one of my favorites this year.
Everard is a classic Laura Frantz hero - gruff but tender, loyal to the core, a fierce warrior and an innovative leader. Blythe is an educated intellectual, daughter of a duke, and compassionate. Their meeting is under distressing circumstances but their blossoming relationship is fun and witty and shows a side of them that others rarely see. I know the author doesn’t usually write sequels but I would love to see books that follow Everard’s younger brothers.
If you enjoy historical romance that will transport you to a different time and place with action and depth, you will absolutely adore this book. I received the book from the publisher and was under no obligation to post a positive comment. All opinions are my own.
My favorite Laura Frantz novel to date! I loved returning to Scotland through the author’s captivating storytelling and learned a great deal about the Jacobite Rising in 1715 through Blythe and Everard. Lush details of Scottish country life and swirling political unrest, unforgettable characters, heart-stopping romance, strong faith thread that overcomes denominational barrier, and gripping plot all make this book a worthy read and one of my favorites this year.
Everard is a classic Laura Frantz hero - gruff but tender, loyal to the core, a fierce warrior and an innovative leader. Blythe is an educated intellectual, daughter of a duke, and compassionate. Their meeting is under distressing circumstances but their blossoming relationship is fun and witty and shows a side of them that others rarely see. I know the author doesn’t usually write sequels but I would love to see books that follow Everard’s younger brothers.
If you enjoy historical romance that will transport you to a different time and place with action and depth, you will absolutely adore this book. I received the book from the publisher and was under no obligation to post a positive comment. All opinions are my own.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 800 reviews