4 stars
KyAnn Waters leans into a far more emotionally charged dynamic in Initiation Into Submission: High Protocol #3 – Forbidden, and the story feels heavier, more intimate, because of it. Claire and Gavin aren’t strangers pulled together by chemistry—they’re two people with a long, complicated history, bound by grief, loyalty, and a kind of quiet love that’s been simmering for years. That foundation makes their shift into a BDSM‑infused relationship feel risky in a way that goes beyond the physical.
Claire’s background as a domestic‑violence counselor adds a layer of vulnerability that shapes the entire narrative. She’s someone who has spent her life helping others reclaim their power, yet she’s still carrying her own wounds. Gavin has been her anchor through all of it, the one person who has seen her break and never turned away. That closeness makes her desire for him feel deeply personal—almost inevitable—but it also raises the stakes. She isn’t just falling for a man; she’s stepping toward someone who knows her shadows.
Gavin’s internal conflict is the heart of the book. As Ronan, he’s a man who understands pain, control, and the structured world of High Protocol. As Gavin, he’s terrified of tainting the one person he considers pure. That tension—wanting her, fearing he’ll hurt her, needing her to understand the difference between consensual power exchange and real harm—gives the story its emotional weight. His love for Claire isn’t gentle; it’s protective, conflicted, and edged with longing he’s tried to bury for years.
What makes the book compelling is how Waters handles the question at its core: can someone with Claire’s history embrace submission without feeling like she’s betraying herself? And can Gavin trust that the part of him he hides—the part that thrives on intensity—won’t destroy the most important relationship in his life?
The romance becomes less about erotic tension and more about emotional truth. It’s a story about two people who have already survived the worst life can throw at them, trying to figure out whether they can survive each other.