What do you think?
Rate this book
The Hong Kong Collection
The Flame Tree
Based on a little-known true story, from award-winning author Siobhan Daiko comes a tale of love and survival against all the odds.
In the spring of 1939, dashing young William Burton and the beautiful Constance Han set sail from London on the same ocean liner to Hong Kong.
Romance blossoms while they enjoy games of deck quoits and spend sultry tropical evenings dancing under the stars. Connie is intrigued by Will’s talent for writing poetry, and she offers to give him Cantonese lessons to help him with his new job—a cadet in the colonial service.
But once in Hong Kong, Connie is constrained by filial duty towards her Eurasian parents, and their wish for her to marry someone from her own background. She can't forget Will however and arranges to meet him in secret under the magnificent canopy of a flame of the forest tree—where she fulfils her promise to teach him to speak Chinese.
Before too long, trouble looms as Japanese forces gather on the border between Hong Kong and mainland China. Will joins a commando group tasked with operating behind enemy lines, and Connie becomes involved in the fight against local fifth columnists.
When war breaks out, they find themselves drawn into a wider conflict than their battle against prejudice. Can they survive and achieve a future together? Or do forces beyond their control keep them forever apart?
In the spring of 1939, dashing young William Burton and the beautiful Constance Han set sail from London on the same ocean liner to Hong Kong.
Romance blossoms while they enjoy games of deck quoits and spend sultry tropical evenings dancing under the stars. Connie is intrigued by Will’s talent for writing poetry, and she offers to give him Cantonese lessons to help him with his new job—a cadet in the colonial service.
But once in Hong Kong, Connie is constrained by filial duty towards her Eurasian parents, and their wish for her to marry someone from her own background. She can't forget Will however and arranges to meet him in secret under the magnificent canopy of a flame of the forest tree—where she fulfils her promise to teach him to speak Chinese.
Before too long, trouble looms as Japanese forces gather on the border between Hong Kong and mainland China. Will joins a commando group tasked with operating behind enemy lines, and Connie becomes involved in the fight against local fifth columnists.
When war breaks out, they find themselves drawn into a wider conflict than their battle against prejudice. Can they survive and achieve a future together? Or do forces beyond their control keep them forever apart?
311 pages, Kindle Edition
First published January 6, 2023
51 people are currently reading
155 people want to read
About the author
Siobhan Daiko
26 books321 followersSiobhan Daiko is a British historical fiction author. A lover of all things Italian, she lives in the Veneto region of northern Italy with her husband, a Havanese dog and a Siberian cat. Siobhan was born of English parents in Hong Kong, attended boarding school in Australia, and then moved to the UK — where she taught modern foreign languages in a Welsh high school. She now spends her time writing page-turners and living the dolce vita sweet life near Venice. Her novels are compelling, poignant, and deeply moving, with strong female characters and evocative settings, but always with romance at their heart. You can find more about her books on her website www.siobhandaiko.org
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 39 reviews
January 25, 2023
Spanning across the globe, conflict, cultural division, and geography, The Flame Tree is a harken back to traditional love stories I grew up reading.
Connie comes from an established Hong Kong family. She begins a shipboard romance with Will but can it last?
As the two get swept up in the political storms and wars of the 1930s, they are torn apart. Can their love survive?
This book also reminds me of of classical movies as all the comments are there: forbidden love, war, intrigue, separation, and perhaps reunion.
I was the most risen with the dynamics of Connie’s family. I have long been fascinated with Chinese culture and family makeup so I read eagerly when it’s nuances were described.
If you like reading a classic romantic tale, The Flame Tree will light your fire.
Thanks to Asolando Books and Rachel’s Random Resources for the complimentary copy.
Connie comes from an established Hong Kong family. She begins a shipboard romance with Will but can it last?
As the two get swept up in the political storms and wars of the 1930s, they are torn apart. Can their love survive?
This book also reminds me of of classical movies as all the comments are there: forbidden love, war, intrigue, separation, and perhaps reunion.
I was the most risen with the dynamics of Connie’s family. I have long been fascinated with Chinese culture and family makeup so I read eagerly when it’s nuances were described.
If you like reading a classic romantic tale, The Flame Tree will light your fire.
Thanks to Asolando Books and Rachel’s Random Resources for the complimentary copy.
January 24, 2023
A convincing and very moving romance, a fascinating slice of history – coupled with the most wonderful story-telling, this book delivered everything I could have possibly wanted.
It begins with a shipboard romance, as Will – sailing to Hong Kong to join the colonial service – meets Connie, the daughter of a prominent and well-to-do Eurasian businessman. And it’s a connection you really feel – but it becomes fraught by obstacles once they arrive in Hong Kong with its deep cultural divide. Unwilling – and unable – to give each other up, they meet in secret beneath the flame tree in the botanical gardens, where he shares his poetry, and she helps him with the intricacies of Cantonese. But then, everything becomes many times more difficult – the war is drawing closer, the Japanese invasion imminent and inevitable, and although their paths are able to cross more publicly when they both take on key roles in the defence of Hong Kong, the situation also plays its part in tearing them apart. The story then becomes an intense one of bravery and survival – and hope that their love might see them reunited.
Do you know, I was appallingly ignorant about the war in the Pacific – but not any more, as I learned so much from this sweeping and wonderfully told story. The Japanese advance through Canton, the role of Chiang Kai-shek and the Chinese, the British failure to take the threat seriously, the fifth columnists and the role of the Triads – totally fascinating, all seen from within through Connie and Will’s involvement, an entirely compelling fact-based story. The author’s research, and the way she uses it, is incredibly impressive – but it never becomes a history lesson, always a human story about how events affected the lives of individuals. The love story at the story’s heart was one that totally consumed me – both Will and Connie are wonderfully drawn (as, indeed, are all the supporting characters), and they both held a piece of my heart as they became caught up in the action, the pace of the story escalating as the danger intensified, and everything looking increasingly hopeless.
I read this book in almost a single sitting – I was entirely caught up in the story’s twists and turns, desperately hoping that Connie and Will would have their happy ending. And it was one of those books that I was more than happy to allow to sweep me away – the story-telling is just superb (I felt I was in particularly safe hands), the emotional impact intense, and there was never a time when I felt I wasn’t part of Will and Connie’s story. Quite wonderful – and the only thing stopping me from saying “one of my books of the year” is the fact that I know there’ll be more to come from this very talented author. Highly recommended – I loved it.
It begins with a shipboard romance, as Will – sailing to Hong Kong to join the colonial service – meets Connie, the daughter of a prominent and well-to-do Eurasian businessman. And it’s a connection you really feel – but it becomes fraught by obstacles once they arrive in Hong Kong with its deep cultural divide. Unwilling – and unable – to give each other up, they meet in secret beneath the flame tree in the botanical gardens, where he shares his poetry, and she helps him with the intricacies of Cantonese. But then, everything becomes many times more difficult – the war is drawing closer, the Japanese invasion imminent and inevitable, and although their paths are able to cross more publicly when they both take on key roles in the defence of Hong Kong, the situation also plays its part in tearing them apart. The story then becomes an intense one of bravery and survival – and hope that their love might see them reunited.
Do you know, I was appallingly ignorant about the war in the Pacific – but not any more, as I learned so much from this sweeping and wonderfully told story. The Japanese advance through Canton, the role of Chiang Kai-shek and the Chinese, the British failure to take the threat seriously, the fifth columnists and the role of the Triads – totally fascinating, all seen from within through Connie and Will’s involvement, an entirely compelling fact-based story. The author’s research, and the way she uses it, is incredibly impressive – but it never becomes a history lesson, always a human story about how events affected the lives of individuals. The love story at the story’s heart was one that totally consumed me – both Will and Connie are wonderfully drawn (as, indeed, are all the supporting characters), and they both held a piece of my heart as they became caught up in the action, the pace of the story escalating as the danger intensified, and everything looking increasingly hopeless.
I read this book in almost a single sitting – I was entirely caught up in the story’s twists and turns, desperately hoping that Connie and Will would have their happy ending. And it was one of those books that I was more than happy to allow to sweep me away – the story-telling is just superb (I felt I was in particularly safe hands), the emotional impact intense, and there was never a time when I felt I wasn’t part of Will and Connie’s story. Quite wonderful – and the only thing stopping me from saying “one of my books of the year” is the fact that I know there’ll be more to come from this very talented author. Highly recommended – I loved it.
January 26, 2023
Many, many years ago (because I am older than I look) I read a book called Tanamera by Noel Barber which was all about Singapore from just before the start of WWII to the 1950s encompassing the Japanese invasion in WWII and then through the Malayan war. It is this book I credit with my interest in WWII stories set in the Asian theatre of war.
Despite the proliferation of WWII books being published now, there are still relatively few stories that are set in Asia, and so, when I was offered this book, which is set in Hong Kong, I jumped at the opportunity.
William Burton and Constance Han meet on board a ship heading to Hong Kong, He is just beginning his career working in the Colonial Service. She is returning home after studying in Britain. Will is excited about his new life in the exotic city, knowing that he has to work hard to learn the language quickly.
Connie is pleased to be going home, although she does know that, as the daughter of a very wealthy and influential Eurasian businessman, her life is all planned out. She will marry a suitable Chinese man, and begin having children, just like her sisters.
William and Connie are immediately attracted to each other, but Connie knows it will be foolhardy to begin a romance with a man who will definitely be unacceptable to her family who have strong Chinese traditions. They agree to be friends and she will help him learn the language. But when the attraction is strong, it's easy to forget that there's no future as they dance the night away on board and spend time together.
To read more
http://www.theintrepidreader.com/2023...
Despite the proliferation of WWII books being published now, there are still relatively few stories that are set in Asia, and so, when I was offered this book, which is set in Hong Kong, I jumped at the opportunity.
William Burton and Constance Han meet on board a ship heading to Hong Kong, He is just beginning his career working in the Colonial Service. She is returning home after studying in Britain. Will is excited about his new life in the exotic city, knowing that he has to work hard to learn the language quickly.
Connie is pleased to be going home, although she does know that, as the daughter of a very wealthy and influential Eurasian businessman, her life is all planned out. She will marry a suitable Chinese man, and begin having children, just like her sisters.
William and Connie are immediately attracted to each other, but Connie knows it will be foolhardy to begin a romance with a man who will definitely be unacceptable to her family who have strong Chinese traditions. They agree to be friends and she will help him learn the language. But when the attraction is strong, it's easy to forget that there's no future as they dance the night away on board and spend time together.
To read more
http://www.theintrepidreader.com/2023...
January 19, 2023
Having been to Hong Kong a number of times I was looking forward to this, a historical novel, part of The Hong Kong Collection, based on a true story and set in Hong Kong shortly before and during WWII. William (Will) Burton leaves his home in Bristol to work for the colonial service in Hong Kong and on the liner sailing there he meets Constance (Connie) Han, the beautiful Eurasian daughter of a very wealthy businessman. The attraction is mutual but Connie knows her family will expect her to marry someone from the same background. There has clearly been a lot of research and the writing is very descriptive, I could imagine I was there walking through the botanical gardens, up Nathan Road or crossing the river to HK Island to Kowloon.
Briefly, Will and Connie decide to meet in secret in a pavilion by a flame tree and their relationship grows as Connie teaches Will Cantonese. But when the Japanese start to move through China towards HK Will and Connie both get heavily involved in the fight again the invading Japanese forces.
Life was clearly difficult during this period in HK history. Not just the war, which decimated much of the islands but in everyday life prejudice was rife, the class system was all important and mixing of class, race or culture was pretty much forbidden. Should Connie and Will have been seen together she would be disgraced and he could lose his job. How brave they were to continue to meet and how strong their love was to fight to overcome prejudice. A wonderful story of how romance can survive against all the odds but also an interesting history of HK during this time.
Briefly, Will and Connie decide to meet in secret in a pavilion by a flame tree and their relationship grows as Connie teaches Will Cantonese. But when the Japanese start to move through China towards HK Will and Connie both get heavily involved in the fight again the invading Japanese forces.
Life was clearly difficult during this period in HK history. Not just the war, which decimated much of the islands but in everyday life prejudice was rife, the class system was all important and mixing of class, race or culture was pretty much forbidden. Should Connie and Will have been seen together she would be disgraced and he could lose his job. How brave they were to continue to meet and how strong their love was to fight to overcome prejudice. A wonderful story of how romance can survive against all the odds but also an interesting history of HK during this time.
January 25, 2023
Wow ! Just WOW! What a completely absorbing read The Flame Tree is. I absolutely lapped up every single word. The fact that it is based on a true story made this book all the more emotional for me. Siobhan Daiko really creates a picture in your minds eye so vivid you can almost feel, smell and live every character, situation and passion contained with in each page. I was totally lost in this epic book. I adored it, I can not say enough just how much I enjoyed The Flame Tree. It offers an insight into just how terrible the war was in Hong Kong. Something I really didn’t have much of idea on until now. I have a deeper understanding of how heart breaking it was. How strong the camaraderie was, how important friendships were and even more, how to live each day as it comes.
Have a read of the blurb as it really sets the scene much better than I can. All I can do is recommend and then recommend again. It is an utterly breathe taking book of epic proportions. FABULOUS !
Have a read of the blurb as it really sets the scene much better than I can. All I can do is recommend and then recommend again. It is an utterly breathe taking book of epic proportions. FABULOUS !
January 21, 2023
We follow Connie and Will. They meet on a cruise ship to Hong Kong and their relationship quickly grows. But when Japanese forces are at the borders their lives are about to change drastically.
Like other book by Siobhan this one is filled with actual history weaved through a story of romance. The characters are strong. And I very book I read I feel like I’ve come away having learned something new. Same here. As someone who was born in Europe I grew up with extensive knowledge of WWII, but somehow there was so much here I never knew, a part of the war we weren’t really taught. You can really tell just how much sheer research went into this. Add to that beautiful descriptions, writing and how much I loved Connie and Will both and I’m sold.
The story was beautifully heartbreaking and I do very much recommend it!
Like other book by Siobhan this one is filled with actual history weaved through a story of romance. The characters are strong. And I very book I read I feel like I’ve come away having learned something new. Same here. As someone who was born in Europe I grew up with extensive knowledge of WWII, but somehow there was so much here I never knew, a part of the war we weren’t really taught. You can really tell just how much sheer research went into this. Add to that beautiful descriptions, writing and how much I loved Connie and Will both and I’m sold.
The story was beautifully heartbreaking and I do very much recommend it!
December 14, 2022
Based on a little-known true story, award winning author Siobhan Daiko shares with us a powerful book.
Set in 1939, this is William and Constances tale. They met aboard a ship bound for Hong Kong. They bond over boat games and the nightly dances resulting in their falling in Love. The storyline takes off as they face challenges with her familial obligations. She and William begin to meet secretly under a flame tree so she can continue his language lessons.
The world build for the 1930s and WW2 backdrop is phenomenal. You will feel like you are there. The characters are vividly portrayed and you will feel their emotions. The storyline is woven perfectly and well-written you will be engrossed from beginning to end. I highly recommend this book.
Set in 1939, this is William and Constances tale. They met aboard a ship bound for Hong Kong. They bond over boat games and the nightly dances resulting in their falling in Love. The storyline takes off as they face challenges with her familial obligations. She and William begin to meet secretly under a flame tree so she can continue his language lessons.
The world build for the 1930s and WW2 backdrop is phenomenal. You will feel like you are there. The characters are vividly portrayed and you will feel their emotions. The storyline is woven perfectly and well-written you will be engrossed from beginning to end. I highly recommend this book.
July 12, 2024
This was a good book. The relationship was realistic and parts of the story were quite gripping. I was worried that it was going to be an Asian-White trope with colonialist overtones, and while that was a tangential issue, the story's grounding in historical fact gave it some cover I have some relatively minor quibbles. I found the writing a touch too sentimental for my taste, but I think others might like that. Also, I found the story a bit too heavily anti-communist. Chiang Kai Chek and his nationalist movement has never been a favourite - I would have preferred a more balanced treatment of the two groups. It was interesting to read about Hong Kong, which I have never visited, and I followed the story along with Google Maps to understand the geography.
November 29, 2022
Will and Connie meet on a boat unexpectedly - it’s a clash of cultures, but that meeting sets in stone the events that transpire. They are flung together but are also so far apart in Hong Kong during the start of the Pacific War in WW2. They are caught in the horror of war as their worlds explode around them. Follow their tantalising story in this well written book. Once again the author mixes detailed research, beautiful scenarios alongside a cracking story. If you like characters you care about, romance, history and suspense, then this is a must 5 star read
January 10, 2023
The Flame Tree is based on a little-known true story, set in 1939, that follows a young woman named Constance Han and British soldier William Burton. On a cruise to Hong Kong, the pair meet and while playing games and dancing, the beginning of a young romance begins to bloom between the pair. As they meet in secret, Constance teaches Will how to speak Cantonese and their relationship continues to grow. When Japanese forces arrive at the border, and Will is sent behind enemy lines, will he make it back to her alive? And will Constance’s family obligations and duties keep her from Will?
January 19, 2023
I love when Will is talking since he writes poetry that his thoughts about the scenery and Connie are like poetry . The love Connie and Will share is written by the author so great that reading it you can feel what they feel for each other . But the war going on and their culture difference are a extra burden to them both . I learned a lot from this book about what goes on during the war that I never thought of .
January 25, 2023
I’ve read many books by this author and felt this is her best yet. Evocative and gripping, with a wonderful sense of Hong Kong and the time period. I rooted for the characters all the way and the history was fascinating. Five stars without a moment’s hesitation - highly recommended if you enjoy historical romance.
January 18, 2023
Siobhan has such a way with words. She takes history and spins such a great story into it. She always goes so deep with her story, that she always puts us right in the mix. Her two main characters, William (Will) and Constance(Connie) have to endure so much, not only with the war, but the culture clash. Siobhan pulls on our hearts and makes us yearn for more.
January 20, 2023
If you have read this author before you know her writing style and how it’s always a heartfelt read and this book did not disappoint! This is an amazing historical read that will pull you in and make you feel like you are there.
January 26, 2023
Wonderful story of love and survival in wartime Hong Kong
This beautifully written and well researched story of the fall of Hong Kong to the Japanese depicts the terror and atmosphere of that time accurately. We live through those frightening times with Will and Connie and keep turning the pages to find out if their love will triumph. This will delight readers of the genre and keep you on the edge of your seat right to the end.
This beautifully written and well researched story of the fall of Hong Kong to the Japanese depicts the terror and atmosphere of that time accurately. We live through those frightening times with Will and Connie and keep turning the pages to find out if their love will triumph. This will delight readers of the genre and keep you on the edge of your seat right to the end.
January 19, 2023
This book based on a true events has blossomed into another wonderful novel by Siobhan Daiko!
If you like learning about different cultures, history, or romance, this book is a must read for 2023. Set in Hong Kong during WWII, the author is able to add life to the story from her own experiences growing up in Hong Kong. She weaves lessons on speaking Cantonese into the story seamlessly, along with the cultural differences between the natives and the British colonialists. The horrors of the war show a conflicting backdrop to a beautiful romance. Highly recommend.
If you like learning about different cultures, history, or romance, this book is a must read for 2023. Set in Hong Kong during WWII, the author is able to add life to the story from her own experiences growing up in Hong Kong. She weaves lessons on speaking Cantonese into the story seamlessly, along with the cultural differences between the natives and the British colonialists. The horrors of the war show a conflicting backdrop to a beautiful romance. Highly recommend.
October 10, 2023
Siobhan Daiko è un’autrice che mi ha catturato con la sua serie legata alle Ragazze della Resistenza. Ero davvero curiosa di leggere il suo nuovo romanzo anche perché è ambientato in Oriente, in paesi che io amo.
Se con Le ragazze della Resistenza avevamo visto gli effetti della Seconda Guerra Mondiale sul popolo Italiano occupato dai tedeschi, con Amore sotto l’albero delle fiamme ci si sposta sull’altro fronte della guerra: sul Pacifico e sulle azioni portate avanti dai giapponesi. Così troviamo Connie, che appartiene a un mondo e a una cultura diversa, fare scelte simili e vivere emozioni simili a quelle vissute da Lidia (La ragazza di Venezia), da Leila (La ragazza di Bologna) e dalle sorelle Gina e Adele (La ragazza di Portofino). Le loro vicende sono diverse, ma tutte loro sono state giovani in quei terribili anni di guerra, si sono innamorate e soprattutto sono state costrette a prendere decisioni difficili che le hanno esposte a pericoli costanti.
Ammetto di essere molto più ferrata sulla storia Italiana della Resistenza rispetto all’invasione giapponese di Hong Kong e quindi questo romanzo mi è servito per conoscere nuove nozioni storiche sulle quali vorrei continuare a documentarmi.
Amore sotto l’albero delle fiamme è un romanzo che cattura, che ti fa respirare il sapore di un mondo complesso, diverso dal nostro e sul quale inesorabilmente si sta per abbattere la distruzione portata dalla Seconda Guerra Mondiale. Un mondo con le sue rigide regole che vedono con un certo disappunto le unioni miste, un mondo dove i padri possono ancora combinare dei matrimoni e dove le mogli e le concubine dividono oneri e piaceri della vita familiare. Un mondo, però, che sta per sgretolarsi. Davanti all’avanzare del nemico, con una guerra ormai alle porte, ciò che conta è godere l’attimo, coglierlo e assaporarlo perché del domani non si ha certezza. Connie e Will decideranno di farlo?
La protagonista mi ha colpito per il suo coraggio e per la sua forza. Sfida tutto e tutti per combattere, secondo le sue possibilità, il nemico e rendersi utile. Rifiuta la sicurezza per l’ignoto. Ha conquistato la mia ammirazione con la sua intraprendenza. Del resto è un’eroina femminile nata dalla Daiko. La storia incanta chi legge e ci introduce in un mondo, quello del 1939, in cui ancora le persone erano inconsapevoli della catastrofe che le attendeva. Un mondo in cui si viaggiava per il mondo in nave e si ballava in un salone durante la traversata. Un mondo che pian piano, come ho già detto, vediamo sempre di più incupirsi e riempirsi di minacce.
Lo stile dell’autrice è semplice, chiaro e in grado di fornire nozioni interessanti. Si vede che la Daiko ha fatto un grosso lavoro di ricostruzione storica.
Siobhan Daiko mi ha portato nel mio amato Oriente negli anni bui della Seconda Guerra mondiale e mi ha letteralmente incollata al Kindle.
Se con Le ragazze della Resistenza avevamo visto gli effetti della Seconda Guerra Mondiale sul popolo Italiano occupato dai tedeschi, con Amore sotto l’albero delle fiamme ci si sposta sull’altro fronte della guerra: sul Pacifico e sulle azioni portate avanti dai giapponesi. Così troviamo Connie, che appartiene a un mondo e a una cultura diversa, fare scelte simili e vivere emozioni simili a quelle vissute da Lidia (La ragazza di Venezia), da Leila (La ragazza di Bologna) e dalle sorelle Gina e Adele (La ragazza di Portofino). Le loro vicende sono diverse, ma tutte loro sono state giovani in quei terribili anni di guerra, si sono innamorate e soprattutto sono state costrette a prendere decisioni difficili che le hanno esposte a pericoli costanti.
Ammetto di essere molto più ferrata sulla storia Italiana della Resistenza rispetto all’invasione giapponese di Hong Kong e quindi questo romanzo mi è servito per conoscere nuove nozioni storiche sulle quali vorrei continuare a documentarmi.
Amore sotto l’albero delle fiamme è un romanzo che cattura, che ti fa respirare il sapore di un mondo complesso, diverso dal nostro e sul quale inesorabilmente si sta per abbattere la distruzione portata dalla Seconda Guerra Mondiale. Un mondo con le sue rigide regole che vedono con un certo disappunto le unioni miste, un mondo dove i padri possono ancora combinare dei matrimoni e dove le mogli e le concubine dividono oneri e piaceri della vita familiare. Un mondo, però, che sta per sgretolarsi. Davanti all’avanzare del nemico, con una guerra ormai alle porte, ciò che conta è godere l’attimo, coglierlo e assaporarlo perché del domani non si ha certezza. Connie e Will decideranno di farlo?
La protagonista mi ha colpito per il suo coraggio e per la sua forza. Sfida tutto e tutti per combattere, secondo le sue possibilità, il nemico e rendersi utile. Rifiuta la sicurezza per l’ignoto. Ha conquistato la mia ammirazione con la sua intraprendenza. Del resto è un’eroina femminile nata dalla Daiko. La storia incanta chi legge e ci introduce in un mondo, quello del 1939, in cui ancora le persone erano inconsapevoli della catastrofe che le attendeva. Un mondo in cui si viaggiava per il mondo in nave e si ballava in un salone durante la traversata. Un mondo che pian piano, come ho già detto, vediamo sempre di più incupirsi e riempirsi di minacce.
Lo stile dell’autrice è semplice, chiaro e in grado di fornire nozioni interessanti. Si vede che la Daiko ha fatto un grosso lavoro di ricostruzione storica.
Siobhan Daiko mi ha portato nel mio amato Oriente negli anni bui della Seconda Guerra mondiale e mi ha letteralmente incollata al Kindle.
October 5, 2023
Siobhan Daiko con la serie "Ragazze della resistenza italiana" ci ha regalato delle storie intese e toccanti ambientate in Italia durante la Seconda Guerra Mondiale, con "Amore sotto l'albero delle fiamme" ci porta, invece, nella lontana Hong Kong.
Il periodo è lo stesso ma siamo dall'altra parte del mondo che vede impegnati il Giappone contro Stati Uniti e Gran Bretagna (Hong Kong era una colonia inglese). Confesso che le mie conoscenze storiche di ciò che successe, in quella che viene chiamata Guerra del Pacifico, sono praticamente nulle, per cui questo libro mi ha dato lo spunto per informarmi ed approfondire uno spaccato di storia comunque molto importante.
Infatti, come per i libri precedenti, i protagonisti sono inventati ma l'autrice ha preso spunto da personaggi realmente esistiti ed i fatti storici narrati sono reali e leggendo si percepisce un grande lavoro di studio e ricerca ed una certa cura per i particolari.
Protagonisti sono Will e Connie.
Lui è un giovane inglese, appena laureatosi in lettere classiche, reclutato nel servizio coloniale come cadetto, in partenza per Hong Kong con il transatlantico Carthage.
Connie è la figlia di un importante uomo d'affari euroasiatico e, dopo tre anni di studi in Inghilterra, sta tornando a casa.
S'incontrano durante il lungo viaggio e Connie si offre di insegnargli il cinese così tra una lezione, una cena ed un ballo hanno modo di trascorre molto tempo insieme. Ad Hong Kong, però, la loro frequentazione non può continuare perché Connie, come da volere di suo padre, che ha abbracciato completamente la cultura e la filosofia cinesi, pur essendo in parte inglese, deve contrarre un buon matrimonio con un cinese mentre Will, se sposasse una cinese, sarebbe obbligato a dimettersi.
Ecco perché i due ragazzi iniziano ad incontrarsi di nascosto fino a quando i giapponesi non invadono il paese e le loro tranquille vite vengono completamente sconvolte.
Mi sono piaciuti sia Will che Connie: quest'ultima, conoscendo le protagoniste dei libri della Daiko, non poteva che essere una ragazza di un certo temperamento, attiva, volenterosa e coraggiosa. Sia Will che Connie non fuggono davanti ai problemi e alla tragedia ma cercano e vogliono fare la loro parte per il bene del paese, a costo di mettere in pericolo la loro stessa vita. Devo dire, però, che nell'insieme la storia mi ha emozionata meno delle precedenti: nei momenti clou non ho percepito molta ansia o paura ed il tutto mi è sembrato più soft. Sì, ci sono colpi di scena, pericoli, tragedie ma non mi hanno colpito così tanto.
D'altra parte ho trovato molto interessante conoscere usi e costumi di una cultura completamente diversa dalla mia ed ho apprezzato come nasce ed evolve la storia d'amore tra Will e Connie. Credo che l'autrice sia stata brava a mescolare e bilanciare la parte romantica, molto dolce, con le vicende storiche e gli aspetti culturali in una lettura piacevole che scorre via velocemente.
Il periodo è lo stesso ma siamo dall'altra parte del mondo che vede impegnati il Giappone contro Stati Uniti e Gran Bretagna (Hong Kong era una colonia inglese). Confesso che le mie conoscenze storiche di ciò che successe, in quella che viene chiamata Guerra del Pacifico, sono praticamente nulle, per cui questo libro mi ha dato lo spunto per informarmi ed approfondire uno spaccato di storia comunque molto importante.
Infatti, come per i libri precedenti, i protagonisti sono inventati ma l'autrice ha preso spunto da personaggi realmente esistiti ed i fatti storici narrati sono reali e leggendo si percepisce un grande lavoro di studio e ricerca ed una certa cura per i particolari.
Protagonisti sono Will e Connie.
Lui è un giovane inglese, appena laureatosi in lettere classiche, reclutato nel servizio coloniale come cadetto, in partenza per Hong Kong con il transatlantico Carthage.
Connie è la figlia di un importante uomo d'affari euroasiatico e, dopo tre anni di studi in Inghilterra, sta tornando a casa.
S'incontrano durante il lungo viaggio e Connie si offre di insegnargli il cinese così tra una lezione, una cena ed un ballo hanno modo di trascorre molto tempo insieme. Ad Hong Kong, però, la loro frequentazione non può continuare perché Connie, come da volere di suo padre, che ha abbracciato completamente la cultura e la filosofia cinesi, pur essendo in parte inglese, deve contrarre un buon matrimonio con un cinese mentre Will, se sposasse una cinese, sarebbe obbligato a dimettersi.
Ecco perché i due ragazzi iniziano ad incontrarsi di nascosto fino a quando i giapponesi non invadono il paese e le loro tranquille vite vengono completamente sconvolte.
Mi sono piaciuti sia Will che Connie: quest'ultima, conoscendo le protagoniste dei libri della Daiko, non poteva che essere una ragazza di un certo temperamento, attiva, volenterosa e coraggiosa. Sia Will che Connie non fuggono davanti ai problemi e alla tragedia ma cercano e vogliono fare la loro parte per il bene del paese, a costo di mettere in pericolo la loro stessa vita. Devo dire, però, che nell'insieme la storia mi ha emozionata meno delle precedenti: nei momenti clou non ho percepito molta ansia o paura ed il tutto mi è sembrato più soft. Sì, ci sono colpi di scena, pericoli, tragedie ma non mi hanno colpito così tanto.
D'altra parte ho trovato molto interessante conoscere usi e costumi di una cultura completamente diversa dalla mia ed ho apprezzato come nasce ed evolve la storia d'amore tra Will e Connie. Credo che l'autrice sia stata brava a mescolare e bilanciare la parte romantica, molto dolce, con le vicende storiche e gli aspetti culturali in una lettura piacevole che scorre via velocemente.
February 18, 2023
The Flame Tree is both a love story against the background of cultural divisions and a tale of true heroism in war-torn Hong Kong. Connie Han, the daughter of a wealthy Eurasian with strict beliefs about proper behaviour meets Will Burton on his way to his first job in the Colonial Office. On board they become good friends, but she warns him that just as she must not be seen in public socialising with a European, he would also be criticised if he sought out an Oriental lady friend. But they both have difficulty denying their feelings, so they meet up once a week in the Botanical Gardens.
Two years later the Japanese army are approaching Hong Kong from the Chinese mainland. William is part of the Z force, volunteers who have been trained in sabotage techniques, while Connie is working as a secretary for a renowned Chinese Admiral who is acting as a go-between for the British authorities’ negotiations with the Chinese government and the local Triad gang leaders. But a disastrous attempt at escape to China, as Hong Kong falls, brings danger and tragedy. Based on true events at the time, a thrilling adventure ensues.
Having visited Hong Kong many times from 1967 until 2013 I particularly liked identifying with familiar locations mentioned in the book and the sites, sounds and smells are realistically described. The wartime events are shocking but it is important not to forget those who suffered at that time. However the novel ends on a note of hope for a better future for those who survived. A real page-turner.
Two years later the Japanese army are approaching Hong Kong from the Chinese mainland. William is part of the Z force, volunteers who have been trained in sabotage techniques, while Connie is working as a secretary for a renowned Chinese Admiral who is acting as a go-between for the British authorities’ negotiations with the Chinese government and the local Triad gang leaders. But a disastrous attempt at escape to China, as Hong Kong falls, brings danger and tragedy. Based on true events at the time, a thrilling adventure ensues.
Having visited Hong Kong many times from 1967 until 2013 I particularly liked identifying with familiar locations mentioned in the book and the sites, sounds and smells are realistically described. The wartime events are shocking but it is important not to forget those who suffered at that time. However the novel ends on a note of hope for a better future for those who survived. A real page-turner.
January 19, 2023
When I read Daiko's books I have to check the dictionary and regularly check Google maps to see if I can follow the Hero/heroine's travel/escape routes. My education about Asia is so lacking, I thoroughly enjoyed learning about Hong Kong's severe troubles with Japan during WWII. From following their ship on the month-long journey through the Suez Canal, the Red Sea, the Arabian Sea, etc., to following Connie's father to Macao, the Portuguese colony, to finding the Lion's Head that Will climbed atop soon after arriving at his civil service post, to Mirs Bay where two years later Will's group sank their escape British boats equipped with thunderous airplane engines and he entered Mainland China without any knowledge of Connie to deliver the one-legged Chinese Admiral she worked for through the Red Chinese to Chan Kia Shek. How I admired Will's intelligence to be able to learn a language with 6 different tones for one-syllable words to mean 6 completely different things and then to find he was working not just with but for Red Chinese sympathizers unknowingly? I feared for both Connie and Will as they kept their love a secret from her family and the biased folk of all classes, nationalities, and mixed races. My feelings, like theirs, got out of proportion as they treasured the small gifts from each other while they were separated. What danger, what hardships, what unbelievable occurrences they suffered! Most of all, what a great read!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
January 25, 2023
Based on factual events this fictional WW2 story takes us into the heart of a country torn apart by conflict but which at the heart of it all is a love story between two people who refused to let prejudice and war tear them apart.
William Burton and Constance Han meet on board the P&O liner RMS Carthage heading for Hong Kong. Twenty-three year old Will is to take up a post as a cadet in the colonial services, whist Connie is returning to her family after studying in England for three years. Irresistibly attracted to each other from the start, and once in Hong Kong, Will and Connie continue their relationship in secret as Connie’s Eurasian parents would not approve of Will’s background. However, the shadow of war beckons ever closer and soon both Will and Connie findthat they are caught up in a fast moving conflict which places them both in grave danger.
The Flame Tree is well written historical fiction which sheds light on a particular moment in history and brings to life the horror of living through a time of conflict and of the political and cultural differences leading to the fall of Hong Kong in 1941. Whilst I knew something of the events around the war in the Pacific, it has been interesting to have this fictional account which describes everything so vividly and in such well researched detail.
Intricately written, and with a beautiful love story at its heart, The Flame Tree is a story which stays with you long after the last page is turned.
January 9, 2023
The Flame Tree by Siobhan Daiko is a fascinating historical novel and part of the Hong Kong Collection.
The story is fictional but has its roots in fact. It is set in 1939 and into the World War II years in Hong Kong. I was educated as I read about the brave people of Hong Kong during the war.
Ordinary men and women were flung into war after the Japanese attacked Peral Harbour in December 1941. As a British colony, the Hong Kong people fought against the Japanese.
Some young British men living in Hong Kong formed an elite group Z. They were fearless in their fight.
We see the difficulties facing a young British man and a Eurasian woman, the daughter of a prominent Hong Kong citizen. To be seen with the man would mean ruin for the young woman. Love must find a way.
Prejudice and a class system were rife in Hong Kong but there were those who only saw brave beating hearts rather than skin colour.
All the characters were well drawn, likable and realistic.
I thoroughly enjoyed The Flame Tree. I have been educated and entertained as I read about the bravery of ordinary citizens. This is a marvelous read.
I received a free copy via Rachel’s Random Resources for a blog tour. A favourable review was not required. All opinions are my own.
The story is fictional but has its roots in fact. It is set in 1939 and into the World War II years in Hong Kong. I was educated as I read about the brave people of Hong Kong during the war.
Ordinary men and women were flung into war after the Japanese attacked Peral Harbour in December 1941. As a British colony, the Hong Kong people fought against the Japanese.
Some young British men living in Hong Kong formed an elite group Z. They were fearless in their fight.
We see the difficulties facing a young British man and a Eurasian woman, the daughter of a prominent Hong Kong citizen. To be seen with the man would mean ruin for the young woman. Love must find a way.
Prejudice and a class system were rife in Hong Kong but there were those who only saw brave beating hearts rather than skin colour.
All the characters were well drawn, likable and realistic.
I thoroughly enjoyed The Flame Tree. I have been educated and entertained as I read about the bravery of ordinary citizens. This is a marvelous read.
I received a free copy via Rachel’s Random Resources for a blog tour. A favourable review was not required. All opinions are my own.
January 26, 2023
An epic love story set in Hong Kong at the start of the Pacific war in WW2. Will, a colonial cadet, and Connie, the daughter of a powerful Hong Kong businessman, meet on a ship sailing from England to Hong Kong. The attraction is powerful, and when they arrive in Hong Kong, they agree to keep seeing each other despite the societal conflict and prejudices, meeting by the Flame Tree in a botanical garden. The writing is atmospheric and lyrical, sharing the vibrancy of Hong Kong and the robust class system and prejudices that define the society.
The characterisation is detailed, and the historical setting is vividly portrayed. Courage and sacrifice define the characters and immerse the reader in their lives. I love this tale's characters, historical detail and epic romance.
I received a copy of this book from the author.
The characterisation is detailed, and the historical setting is vividly portrayed. Courage and sacrifice define the characters and immerse the reader in their lives. I love this tale's characters, historical detail and epic romance.
I received a copy of this book from the author.
February 6, 2023
I have to confess to being utterly spellbound by this book from the outset. The writing is exquisite, the characters incredibly likeable and the description of the settings so well executed, you can picture yourself there.
The author’s expert knowledge and accuracy in historical references lends the narrative a real authenticity and details life in Hong Kong during that period vividly.
The budding romance between Will and Constance which begins on the ocean liner as they travel to Hong Kong from England is beautifully portrayed and I love how it blossoms despite all that threatens to destroy it.
This is the first book of Siobhan Daiko’s I have read but it certainly won’t be the last.
A wonderful read and highly recommended!
With thanks to the author and Rachel at Random Resources for the opportunity to participate in the blog tour.
The author’s expert knowledge and accuracy in historical references lends the narrative a real authenticity and details life in Hong Kong during that period vividly.
The budding romance between Will and Constance which begins on the ocean liner as they travel to Hong Kong from England is beautifully portrayed and I love how it blossoms despite all that threatens to destroy it.
This is the first book of Siobhan Daiko’s I have read but it certainly won’t be the last.
A wonderful read and highly recommended!
With thanks to the author and Rachel at Random Resources for the opportunity to participate in the blog tour.
February 13, 2023
Hong Kong Saga
Took me right back to Hong Kong in the early 60’s and the mid-70’s, even though this was written about a time two decades earlier. Would have given an extra star but couldn’t quite reconcile some of the maritime scenes as a lifelong sailor, but not a bad effort. However, the way that life in the Colony was described was so true to my memories it was incredible. Can’t wait to start The Orchid.
Took me right back to Hong Kong in the early 60’s and the mid-70’s, even though this was written about a time two decades earlier. Would have given an extra star but couldn’t quite reconcile some of the maritime scenes as a lifelong sailor, but not a bad effort. However, the way that life in the Colony was described was so true to my memories it was incredible. Can’t wait to start The Orchid.
February 11, 2025
Oy, another WWII historical fiction story with so much potential, but that was ultimately disappointing. (Maybe I’ve read too many?) How can a book about the Japanese invasion and occupation of Hong Kong have no tension or suspense? And the dialogue (especially between the two main characters) was so melodramatic and repetitive. I slogged through to the end, but I won’t be recommending it to friends.
October 3, 2024
I always enjoy Daiko historic fiction novels and this one was no exception! Sat in Hi g along on the cusp of WWII, it is a love story in the midst of war. William Burton is headed to Hong Kong for a new job and he meets Constance Han on board - romance ensues but the difficulties of war get in the way as do cultural issues between the East and the west. It’s a great read!
January 19, 2023
A beautiful written story that illustrates what the people of Hong Kong went through in that time period. The detail the author went into makes you feel like your immersed in the history. I don't read this genre often but this book totally had my heart.
November 17, 2023
What a waste of time; I can't believe I even finished it! This is not in the genre of historical fiction as I was led to believe; rather, it is romance with a wee bit of history thrown in for background ambiance. It reads like a young readers novel, the warfare and sex scenes are that tame.
May 14, 2024
Very Very moving and incredibly detailed.
I just wish that there had been a map of Hong Kong at this period because I kept getting confused and had to keep receding to a map!
Apart from that it was was such a detailed book,a real adventure and love story combined.
I just wish that there had been a map of Hong Kong at this period because I kept getting confused and had to keep receding to a map!
Apart from that it was was such a detailed book,a real adventure and love story combined.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 39 reviews