What do you think?
Rate this book
Operation Redwood
"Sibley Carter is a moron and a worldclass jerk." When Julian Carter-Li intercepts an angry e-mail message meant for his greedy, high-powered uncle, it sets him on the course to stop an environmental crime!
His uncle’s company plans to cut down some of the oldest remaining California redwood trees, and it’s up to Julian and a ragtag group of friends to figure out a way to stop them. This fantastic debut novel, full of clever stunts and pranks, shows the power of determined individuals, no matter what their age, to stand up to wrongdoing. And it introduces readers to a memorable cast of characters—smart kids who care about the world around them.
His uncle’s company plans to cut down some of the oldest remaining California redwood trees, and it’s up to Julian and a ragtag group of friends to figure out a way to stop them. This fantastic debut novel, full of clever stunts and pranks, shows the power of determined individuals, no matter what their age, to stand up to wrongdoing. And it introduces readers to a memorable cast of characters—smart kids who care about the world around them.
353 pages, Hardcover
First published May 1, 2009
52 people are currently reading
785 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 158 reviews
August 31, 2009
I wonder if contemporary children’s authors ever look at the writers of the past and think to themselves, “It was easier then. You could get away with so much more.” Morality, at least in retrospect, was so clear cut and uncomplicated in the books of the past. You could have a kid defeat a great big villain with relative simplicity and folks wouldn’t object at all. Or maybe not. That’s how we think of old children’s books... as simple. But when you try to sit down and think of all the realistic novels of the past, their conclusions are never as free and easy as all that. I’m mentioning all this because I just finished, Operation Redwood, one of the finest children's novels of the year, and while reading the book I kept thinking about how author S. Terrell French never cheats her readers. She is constantly covering her tracks and making this a strangely realistic middle grade novel, albeit one about kids trying to take down a big business. It’s a first novel on the author's part, but French has crafted an interesting, intelligent, and ultimately satisfying debut that will undoubtedly garner more than a few fans. A book that shows us that doing the moral thing is a complicated business.
Let’s say you’re sick and your uncle Sibley Carter (who you’ve been staying with while your mom works in China) has left you in his office for hours and hours. You are Julian Carter-Li and after your nap you’re bored. You sit in your uncle’s chair and there, right before your eyes, is an email in his in-box with your name on it. And after that? A message with the subject of “Sibley Carter is a moron and a world-class jerk.” It has begun. Prying where his eyes should not be, Julian learns that his uncle intends to destroy a patch of ancient redwoods and that the plucky girl who lives near them needs Julian’s help to stop the destruction. But what can a couple of kids really do? How about faux emails, daring escapes, a sit-in, and other plans? One thing’s for certain. After this summer, Julian’s life will never be the same again.
I think what I love about this book is how firmly it is rooted in reality. Not that I think this kind of story could actually happen in the real world, mind. But French has a wonderful sense of inserting real elements into a story when you least expect them. Kids (and adults) will walk into this book with a certain set of assumptions. So when they find that the child protagonists have clever plans that sometimes work and, more often than not do NOT work, that’s going to be a little shocking. Also shocking? Your hero runs away, gets to a beautiful place where you believe the rest of the book will take place, and then long before you’re even halfway through the novel his aunt comes and whisks him far far away. Whoa. It’s like the cover and the concept of the book were leading you astray. They’re not, but it feels that way for a second, and you become more wrapped up in the reading as a result.
Over and over again I noticed Ms. French was refusing to leave loose ends dangling or logical plot points flailing. How did Robin get Julian’s uncle’s personal email? “My brother’s taking a journalism course, and he was telling us how a lot of people, even big CEOs, read their own e-mail and their addresses are just their names and their company web addresses.” Pretty good explanation, eh? The book's chock full of them. Either it was workshopped within an inch of its life, or Ms. French understands how to have things make sense.
Someone (perhaps the author Mitali Perkins) once wondered why it is that authors of middle grade and YA fiction feel the need to compare their characters’ eyes or skin to food when making it clear that those characters aren’t white. “Her coffee colored skin.” “His almond shaped eyes.” Well Ms. French isn’t falling into that trap, no sir. If she wants to making it clear that Julian has Chinese ancestry then there’s his last name to consider (Carter-Li) and his eyes, which are mentioned as being “upturned” at one point. Race plays an interesting part in the book, then. In this day and age, racism has grown subtle. People use code words to cover up how they really feel. And in this particular novel, you’ve the distinct impression that Julian’s aunt resents him, not just because he’s been “imposed” upon them, but also because his mother was Asian. But of course she never actually SAYS any of this. It’s far less obvious than that. And more realistic too.
They say to “show don’t tell” when you’re writing, so I was constantly amazed at how much bubbles beneath the surface of this book. Julian almost turns Robin’s dad into a kind of surrogate father, but the text never has him figure this out or say as much. It just happens. And since we’re getting everything from Julian’s perspective, he has a view of his life that doesn’t look too far beneath the surface of things. His aunt and uncle are constantly insulting his mother, so Julian naturally wishes to defend her from them. On the other hand, French makes it pretty clear that this woman is not exactly going to win the World’s Best Parent of the Year Award anytime soon. She hears that her son ran away from home and his aunt and uncle are kicking him out... but does she shorten her assignment in China a little? She does not, the greedy thing. At one point Julian’s grandmother speculates that maybe she was too busy a parent and should have given his mother more attention at home. Maybe that’s why she’s so flighty. Whatever the reason, Julian’s just a bit too young to resent his mom’s meanderings, but give him a couple years. Full-fledged teenagerhood is just around the corner.
At its core, this book is basically a big eco-friendly morality lesson, and that’s tricky. More than once (and I think French acknowledges this) you find yourself wondering if it’s worth saving the trees if Julian or Robin end up disappointing her dad in some way. It’s strange, but she keeps the plot on such a down-to-earth level that that’s where your mind goes. Generally realistic middle grade novels where kids have to defeat evil corporations who are about to harm the earth (Hoot and the like) don’t spend a lot of time tying the book into real life. French does. When Julian says, “In school we’re always studying the rain forests in Brazil and Africa. And people are always trying to get you to sign petitions to save the rain forest and buy special rain-forest nuts. And we never learned anything about people cutting down redwoods in California,” I think a lot of kids are going to agree with that. We give our students the impression that disasters of this sort happen on other continents and to other people. So to hear that “national forests aren’t like parks. They log there all the time,” that kind of statement will probably surprise as many adults as it does children. The Author’s Note at the back clarifies exactly what in this story is true and what’s happening today. It makes it a little more real, and doesn’t feel preachy in the process either. The book is a screed to some extent, but one you don’t mind reading.
I won’t tell you what it is, but this book manages to pull off a surprise reveal at the end that I’d bet a good 85% of adults reading the book won’t see coming. In many ways this book makes for a natural companion to Jill Wolfson’s middle grade novel Home and Other Big Fat Lies where kids want to protect trees from logging, but understand that the local economy relies on them. In a lot of ways, French’s novel isn’t as complex in terms of the logging economy, but it makes up for that by weaving a true emotional journey full of adventure, friendship, complex morality, trust, lies, and discovery. You believe in this book and you believe in the characters.
Ages 9-12.
Let’s say you’re sick and your uncle Sibley Carter (who you’ve been staying with while your mom works in China) has left you in his office for hours and hours. You are Julian Carter-Li and after your nap you’re bored. You sit in your uncle’s chair and there, right before your eyes, is an email in his in-box with your name on it. And after that? A message with the subject of “Sibley Carter is a moron and a world-class jerk.” It has begun. Prying where his eyes should not be, Julian learns that his uncle intends to destroy a patch of ancient redwoods and that the plucky girl who lives near them needs Julian’s help to stop the destruction. But what can a couple of kids really do? How about faux emails, daring escapes, a sit-in, and other plans? One thing’s for certain. After this summer, Julian’s life will never be the same again.
I think what I love about this book is how firmly it is rooted in reality. Not that I think this kind of story could actually happen in the real world, mind. But French has a wonderful sense of inserting real elements into a story when you least expect them. Kids (and adults) will walk into this book with a certain set of assumptions. So when they find that the child protagonists have clever plans that sometimes work and, more often than not do NOT work, that’s going to be a little shocking. Also shocking? Your hero runs away, gets to a beautiful place where you believe the rest of the book will take place, and then long before you’re even halfway through the novel his aunt comes and whisks him far far away. Whoa. It’s like the cover and the concept of the book were leading you astray. They’re not, but it feels that way for a second, and you become more wrapped up in the reading as a result.
Over and over again I noticed Ms. French was refusing to leave loose ends dangling or logical plot points flailing. How did Robin get Julian’s uncle’s personal email? “My brother’s taking a journalism course, and he was telling us how a lot of people, even big CEOs, read their own e-mail and their addresses are just their names and their company web addresses.” Pretty good explanation, eh? The book's chock full of them. Either it was workshopped within an inch of its life, or Ms. French understands how to have things make sense.
Someone (perhaps the author Mitali Perkins) once wondered why it is that authors of middle grade and YA fiction feel the need to compare their characters’ eyes or skin to food when making it clear that those characters aren’t white. “Her coffee colored skin.” “His almond shaped eyes.” Well Ms. French isn’t falling into that trap, no sir. If she wants to making it clear that Julian has Chinese ancestry then there’s his last name to consider (Carter-Li) and his eyes, which are mentioned as being “upturned” at one point. Race plays an interesting part in the book, then. In this day and age, racism has grown subtle. People use code words to cover up how they really feel. And in this particular novel, you’ve the distinct impression that Julian’s aunt resents him, not just because he’s been “imposed” upon them, but also because his mother was Asian. But of course she never actually SAYS any of this. It’s far less obvious than that. And more realistic too.
They say to “show don’t tell” when you’re writing, so I was constantly amazed at how much bubbles beneath the surface of this book. Julian almost turns Robin’s dad into a kind of surrogate father, but the text never has him figure this out or say as much. It just happens. And since we’re getting everything from Julian’s perspective, he has a view of his life that doesn’t look too far beneath the surface of things. His aunt and uncle are constantly insulting his mother, so Julian naturally wishes to defend her from them. On the other hand, French makes it pretty clear that this woman is not exactly going to win the World’s Best Parent of the Year Award anytime soon. She hears that her son ran away from home and his aunt and uncle are kicking him out... but does she shorten her assignment in China a little? She does not, the greedy thing. At one point Julian’s grandmother speculates that maybe she was too busy a parent and should have given his mother more attention at home. Maybe that’s why she’s so flighty. Whatever the reason, Julian’s just a bit too young to resent his mom’s meanderings, but give him a couple years. Full-fledged teenagerhood is just around the corner.
At its core, this book is basically a big eco-friendly morality lesson, and that’s tricky. More than once (and I think French acknowledges this) you find yourself wondering if it’s worth saving the trees if Julian or Robin end up disappointing her dad in some way. It’s strange, but she keeps the plot on such a down-to-earth level that that’s where your mind goes. Generally realistic middle grade novels where kids have to defeat evil corporations who are about to harm the earth (Hoot and the like) don’t spend a lot of time tying the book into real life. French does. When Julian says, “In school we’re always studying the rain forests in Brazil and Africa. And people are always trying to get you to sign petitions to save the rain forest and buy special rain-forest nuts. And we never learned anything about people cutting down redwoods in California,” I think a lot of kids are going to agree with that. We give our students the impression that disasters of this sort happen on other continents and to other people. So to hear that “national forests aren’t like parks. They log there all the time,” that kind of statement will probably surprise as many adults as it does children. The Author’s Note at the back clarifies exactly what in this story is true and what’s happening today. It makes it a little more real, and doesn’t feel preachy in the process either. The book is a screed to some extent, but one you don’t mind reading.
I won’t tell you what it is, but this book manages to pull off a surprise reveal at the end that I’d bet a good 85% of adults reading the book won’t see coming. In many ways this book makes for a natural companion to Jill Wolfson’s middle grade novel Home and Other Big Fat Lies where kids want to protect trees from logging, but understand that the local economy relies on them. In a lot of ways, French’s novel isn’t as complex in terms of the logging economy, but it makes up for that by weaving a true emotional journey full of adventure, friendship, complex morality, trust, lies, and discovery. You believe in this book and you believe in the characters.
Ages 9-12.
June 15, 2009
This book was one of the best books I have ever read. The book, which is about four kids trying to save a redwood forest, is printed on recycled paper. I like how the one main bad guy has a son who is also interested in the redwoods and doesn't want his dad to cut down al the redwoods.I liked the reference to Julia Butterfly Hill, who lived in a redwood tree to save it, just like the main characters.
November 10, 2012
Reviewed by Sally Kruger aka "Readingjunky" for TeensReadToo.com
In OPERATION REDWOOD, four young kids take on big business to save a forest full of giant redwood trees.
Debut author S. Terrell French has written an adventure filled with creative ideas, spunky ambition, and a love of the environment.
Julian Carter-Li is staying with his uncle and aunt while his mother travels to China to photograph Buddhist temples. Things are not going well. Julian doesn't seem to be able to do anything according to the strict rules his aunt has established, and his uncle seems constantly disappointed in him. In fact, while alone in his uncle's fancy office, Julian stumbles across an extremely insulting email. It appears that his uncle believes Julian is unruly and "sullen" just like his late father. Julian can't believe what he is reading.
Another email that attracts Julian's attention is from a young girl complaining that IPX, his uncle's company, is planning to destroy an area of redwood forest known as Big Tree Grove. Although he has never met this girl named Robin, Julian can relate to her anger that a huge company like IPX, that already has more money than he can imagine, would want to destroy something as important and historical as the redwoods just to make more money selling lumber.
Julian keeps the emails he reads a secret until he hears his aunt's plans to send him off to Math Camp for the summer. He appeals to his friend, Danny, for help. When he tells Danny about the emails, Danny begins to concoct a plan that would keep Julian from spending his summer doing math calculations and instead possibly saving the redwoods.
What follows is a daring adventure. Julian and Danny scheme to get Julian out of the city and off to Big Tree Grove where he can help Robin protect her old-growth forest. They may be just a few young kids, but they have big ideas. Even when their plans seem to be wrecked by Julian's annoying and interfering aunt, they manage to use creativity and determination to keep their eye on the goal.
OPERATION REDWOOD provides excellent reinforcement for conservation lessons and the importance of preserving our natural habitats. It would work for readers in the 8-13 age group for independent reading or as a great classroom read-aloud.
In OPERATION REDWOOD, four young kids take on big business to save a forest full of giant redwood trees.
Debut author S. Terrell French has written an adventure filled with creative ideas, spunky ambition, and a love of the environment.
Julian Carter-Li is staying with his uncle and aunt while his mother travels to China to photograph Buddhist temples. Things are not going well. Julian doesn't seem to be able to do anything according to the strict rules his aunt has established, and his uncle seems constantly disappointed in him. In fact, while alone in his uncle's fancy office, Julian stumbles across an extremely insulting email. It appears that his uncle believes Julian is unruly and "sullen" just like his late father. Julian can't believe what he is reading.
Another email that attracts Julian's attention is from a young girl complaining that IPX, his uncle's company, is planning to destroy an area of redwood forest known as Big Tree Grove. Although he has never met this girl named Robin, Julian can relate to her anger that a huge company like IPX, that already has more money than he can imagine, would want to destroy something as important and historical as the redwoods just to make more money selling lumber.
Julian keeps the emails he reads a secret until he hears his aunt's plans to send him off to Math Camp for the summer. He appeals to his friend, Danny, for help. When he tells Danny about the emails, Danny begins to concoct a plan that would keep Julian from spending his summer doing math calculations and instead possibly saving the redwoods.
What follows is a daring adventure. Julian and Danny scheme to get Julian out of the city and off to Big Tree Grove where he can help Robin protect her old-growth forest. They may be just a few young kids, but they have big ideas. Even when their plans seem to be wrecked by Julian's annoying and interfering aunt, they manage to use creativity and determination to keep their eye on the goal.
OPERATION REDWOOD provides excellent reinforcement for conservation lessons and the importance of preserving our natural habitats. It would work for readers in the 8-13 age group for independent reading or as a great classroom read-aloud.
June 30, 2022
This book used to be my favorite book. I probably read it more than 5 times in sixth grade. I don’t know if it still holds up, but thinking about it never ceases to make me smile.
November 27, 2009
I enjoyed all the characters in Operation Redwood - it was funny and inspiring and exciting and realistic, all at the same time. The quality of the writing was beautiful - the prose was lucid and evocative, as well as emotionally truthful. I especially enjoyed the age range of the characters. This book is a classic.
November 7, 2009
Fuse #8 review: "one of the finest children's novels of the year."
Super fun and true to its characters in a sort of Pinkwater way, though way more grounded and less wacky. And San Francisco!
Super fun and true to its characters in a sort of Pinkwater way, though way more grounded and less wacky. And San Francisco!
August 17, 2018
I thoroughly enjoyed reading this book. After spending many summers camping in the redwood forests in Northern California, I became a volunteer at the Visitor Center in Avenue of the Giants in Humboldt County. This book is well written, gives factual information about the coastal redwoods and reminds us to protect these majestic trees for future generations,
February 26, 2017
A young tree-hugging me would have looooved this book.
May 22, 2010
This is, simply put, the best middle-grade novel I have read in a long time. A winsome cast of varied characters, excellent writing, and an urgent but not proselytistic theme make this a book I would be an evangelist for.
S. Terrell French writes like J. K. Rowling—and no, I am not exaggerating when I make that comparison. The third-person narration from Julian’s point of view is wonderfully engaging and moving. Compared to his friends, Julian is really quiet, but it’s his dedication to the environmental cause in the face of his introversion that make him endearing. He is an unusual yet much-desired protagonist: quietly observant but not in an annoyingly self-pitying way, old enough to act on his own, young enough to have recognizable naivetes and limitations, and half-Asian. MG and YA literature needs more characters like him.
The other characters in the book are, of course, fantastic also. Julian’s best friend, Danny Lopez, is a laugh-out-loud force of his own, and certainly reminds me of my crazily outgoing and selfless middle school classmates. Robin’s a bit more difficult to define, but in the end both she and her friend Ariel are realistic, poised at the edges of the pages, ready to jump out and start chattering away right next to you. And it says a lot that the adults in OPERATION REDWOOD can be believable also, no matter how horrible some of them might be.
I also would like to point out how much I appreciated the diverse characters. Julian’s mixed race is a solid part of his identity without overwhelming the story. Indeed, if you fixate on his race in the story, then you have company in his nasty aunt Daphne, who is one of those characters that makes you really really hate them but be amazed that the author could write such a hateful character so well at the same time.
There’s nothing bad I have to say about this novel. It’s an easy must-read for all ages, both for its rarity of being an excellent middle-grade novel and its inspirational environmentalist themes. Find it and give it a try!
S. Terrell French writes like J. K. Rowling—and no, I am not exaggerating when I make that comparison. The third-person narration from Julian’s point of view is wonderfully engaging and moving. Compared to his friends, Julian is really quiet, but it’s his dedication to the environmental cause in the face of his introversion that make him endearing. He is an unusual yet much-desired protagonist: quietly observant but not in an annoyingly self-pitying way, old enough to act on his own, young enough to have recognizable naivetes and limitations, and half-Asian. MG and YA literature needs more characters like him.
The other characters in the book are, of course, fantastic also. Julian’s best friend, Danny Lopez, is a laugh-out-loud force of his own, and certainly reminds me of my crazily outgoing and selfless middle school classmates. Robin’s a bit more difficult to define, but in the end both she and her friend Ariel are realistic, poised at the edges of the pages, ready to jump out and start chattering away right next to you. And it says a lot that the adults in OPERATION REDWOOD can be believable also, no matter how horrible some of them might be.
I also would like to point out how much I appreciated the diverse characters. Julian’s mixed race is a solid part of his identity without overwhelming the story. Indeed, if you fixate on his race in the story, then you have company in his nasty aunt Daphne, who is one of those characters that makes you really really hate them but be amazed that the author could write such a hateful character so well at the same time.
There’s nothing bad I have to say about this novel. It’s an easy must-read for all ages, both for its rarity of being an excellent middle-grade novel and its inspirational environmentalist themes. Find it and give it a try!
November 29, 2009
Julian Carter Li is miserable. While is mother is in China taking pictures of Buddhist Temples for a grant she was awarded, he is stuck with his rich aunt and uncle. All the money in the world doesn't matter if the people who have it are terrible. Julian can't seem to do anything right. To try and improve his behavior his aunt decides to set up a point system that rewards good behavior. Unfortunately for Julian, no matter how hard he tries his points keep going backwards and now they are in the negatives. While sick he is stuck at his uncles office and begins snooping around. He finds an email that was unopened and reads it. It is from someone named Robin who is upset because his uncle is going to clear-cut the redwoods in Big Tree Grove. Julian and his best friends write back in answer and find out the sender is a girl about their age. Together they hatch a plan to help save the redwoods. This book is great for getting kids to look at the larger issues in the world today. It shows them that no matter how young they are they can still take steps to help protect the world they will one day inherit. I am excited to share this book with my students.
June 8, 2011
I did not think I would like this book because I don't like having environmentalism cramed down my throat. BUT....I was very pleasantly surprised! Operation Redwood has a great plot and fun characters. Yes, the story is totally "environmental" but not in a superior or preachy way. The environmental theme doesn't overshadow the story but nicely co-exists with it. Also, the author's tone doesn't have the human-hating edge that often turns me off to environmentalist propaganda. Instead, the author emphasizes good stewardship of the land and preservation of the rare and beautiful natural things which share our earth. I can swallow that and even get behind it! I enjoyed the story and in the end I was right there cheering for the kids in the story and wanting to save a redwood or two!
Well done!
Well done!
March 14, 2010
Both Coel and I thoroughly enjoyed this book. In fact on more that one occasion there were tears and lot's of resistance when it was time for me to stop reading!
It was a tangled drama set in San Francisco and the Wilits area. The characters were both young and old, rich and poor, traditional and not so much.
Just read it, even if you don't have kids to share it with!
It was a tangled drama set in San Francisco and the Wilits area. The characters were both young and old, rich and poor, traditional and not so much.
Just read it, even if you don't have kids to share it with!
June 29, 2016
My kids liked the adventure a lot, but didn't like that the author kept encouraging them to break laws if you have a strong passion about something. It was a great book to discuss why people log and also how authors can try to really push their beliefs on the reader.
August 6, 2009
A fun book about conservation for kids - featuring a boy main character. What's not to like here!?
Recommended for 4th - 6th grade
Recommended for 4th - 6th grade
June 17, 2010
A very detailed exciting book. It felt like you were in the story. When it seemed like it was over, a new problem came up like in real life with twists and turns! I reccomend it to everyone!
June 4, 2011
This was written by the sister of my midwife/nurse practitioner. If you loved Harry Potter, you'll love this book....it's excellent and I could hardly put it down.
May 7, 2017
What a wonderful book. We all enjoyed reading it.
August 28, 2017
Its awesome!
September 15, 2017
This book was amazing. I highly recommend this book. I won't say anything else because of spoilers.
October 25, 2025
P6
Finally, his curiosity grew larger than his fear.
P12 facade — typo façade
P25 un perfecto caballerito - a perfect little gentleman
P27 popo (GMA)
Golden Gate Park - homeless people (SF)
P28
La familia no la escogemos.
You can’t pick your relatives.
P29
in staccato Cantonese
P34 hola, mi hijito
Vegetariano
P35
“I had cow tongue once,” Eduardo said. “It wasn’t bad. But you know what they say: You shouldn’t taste anything that can taste you back!”
P38 clear-cut
P39
Muir Woods
And a father and mother, obviously. (I don’t really like this part).
P41 Farm/Urban Network (FUN)
P42
Maybe in real life your uncle is not such a moron. I may be unfairly judging him and not understanding things from his shoes. My mom says I have a tendency to do this.
P57
“You always look on the dark side,” Danny said in exasperation. “And you have no sense of adventure! You’re the most boring person on earth. You’re going to live the boringest life ever and then bore yourself to death.”
P58
Sometimes, in restaurants, Julian would see large families gathered together, everybody laughing and talking at once, and he would study them, trying to figure out what made them so happy.
P62
“I’ll sleep on it. My brain works better when I’m unconscious. …”
P63
“As Sherlock Holmes says, ‘Once you have eliminated the impossible, whatever remains, no matter how improbable, must be the truth’ or, in your case, the Plan. I know it can work. I have a vision. …”
P69
Petirrojo- robin
Trata bien a mi amigo o lo pagarás caro! - Treat my friend well or you’ll pay!
P71
“Happy Good-Bye!”
Duck, chicken noodles, stir-fried green beans, spicy tofu
P74 (wasteful people - food - the lady dumped the rest of the ice cream cake in the garbage instead of letting anybody have extra or putting it in the freezer)
P75 high speed banana missiles
P77
“False hope’s better than no hope,” Danny said cheerfully.
P79
… I hope Julian isn’t eaten by a lion or anything,” the woman said cheerfully.
“Oh, that wouldn’t be the worst thing,” Danny said in a confidential tone. “In fact, I rather hope he is. He’s quite a holy terror. Well, toodle-loo!”
“Toodle-loo to you too!”
The woman was still laughing giddily when Danny put down the phone. “Am I good or what?” he said with a broad smile.
“You have a real talent for lying. And you ruined my reputation too. Congratulations!“
“We all have our gifts,” Danny said humbly.
P82
Most people, it seemed to him, had jobs that did not produce anything or create anything useful, yet somehow they lived. And some, like his uncle, produced nothing at all, and yet lived extremely well.
Miwok Indians
P90
Brandishing the stick like a miniature naked samurai
P97 switchbacks
P99 clear-cut
P104 motes of dust
P105 typo
Bent down the kissed ( should be “and kissed”)
P106 (how to milk a goat)
“Here, now you try,” Robin said. “There are two teats. Take one teat and squeeze, from the top to the bottom.”
The word “teat,” which Robin said so casually, made Julian blush. He reached out for the closest one, squeezed, and nothing happened.
“Wait, stop!” Robin said. “Squeeze just at the top. Harder.”
Julian squeezed.
“Now, work the milk down with your fingers. Down toward your pinky.”
P110
“Let’s get these weeds into the compost,” Bob said. They carried the tangle of uprooted weeds over to a large black plastic canister. “That’ll be good dirt in a few months. In good farming, nothing‘s wasted. A family can work the same land forever, if they do it right.”
P111
… all he heard was the sound of emptiness.
P112 (list of books)
The encyclopedia of organic gardening, the solar home, applied Silviculture and Forest ecology, small-scale aquaculture.
P118
THP = timber harvest plan
P121
“I guess that taught me a lesson: Don’t be afraid to ask for what you want.”
Build your own smart home (book name)
P122
Spigot
P129
“…I thought it was against the law, or they were all preserved in the national forests.”
Bob gave him a puzzled look. “The national forests?”
“You know, I thought they were protected. I mean, if Big Tree Grove were in a national forest, they couldn’t cut it down, right?”
Bob and Nancy exchanged glances.
“Julian!” Robin was giving him that superior look again. “The national forests aren’t like parks. They log there all the time. Right, Dad?”
“Well, that’s true,” Bob said slowly.
“That was the whole reason the national forests were set up in the first place, to make sure America would have enough timber.“
Robin gave him a look of exasperation. “Haven’t you ever heard of Gifford Pinchot?”
P157 (animals)
marbeled murrelets, fishers
P184
…But, of course, how you measure profit depends on what you value.”
P191
When his mom and Popo were together, Julian felt like he was watching a play in a language he couldn’t completely understand.
P193
She was fierce but polite, he decided, like a samurai or a knight. He could picture her in one of those Chinese kung-fu movies, brandishing her sword and deflecting bullets with her bracelets. He drifted off to sleep, imagining his grandmother as a Chinese warrior woman, leaping from treetop to treetop.
P194 winnowed down
P205
Strategize for success
Understand the market
Communicate power
Compete for the prize
Educate your adversary
Expand your portfolio
Demand allegiance
P210
Danny shrugged. “Learn Spanish. You’ll be a better spy.”
P240 (knot types)
Blake’s hitch, foot loop
P267
“Well, I don’t see how it could do any harm, really,” Nancy said. “And they are working for something they believe in. ‘Speak truth to power’ - that’s what we’ve taught them. “
P276
The sky flickered again and Robin started counting aloud – “one thousand, two thousand, three thousand, four thousand…” There was another low rumble.
“Five seconds!” Robin said. “That means the storm is still a mile away.”
P302-304
“… We should make a mental snapshot so we never forget this night."
“What’s that?" Julian said.
“You know how grown-ups can never remember what it was like being a kid?"
He nodded.
“I’m not going to be that way. I remember everything. I remember standing in my crib. I remember our old house, when I lived here with my mom and dad. And if I think I might forget something, I write it in my diary or I take a mental snapshot. I concentrate really hard and tell myself that I’m going to remember every single thing about that moment."
She sat down on a storage bin. “Come on. I’ll show you how. You have to be very, very quiet." She took a deep breath. “First, shut your eyes." They sat down and Julian closed his eyes. “You start with smelling," she said, sniffing hard. “Right now, I can smell spaghetti and lavender from the candle. And trees. The smell of the forest," she said in a low, breathless voice. “Now, listen."
Julian listened to the river, murmuring in the language of water on stone. The birds sang their evening songs. The mosquito whined in his ear and he swatted it away. He could hear his own breathing and Danny, sniffing loudly.
“Now," said Ariel, “concentrate on what you feel."
“I feel something coiling around my leg!" Danny cried. “A rattlesnake! Help!"
“Be quiet, Danny!" Robin ordered.
A light breeze stirred against Julian’s face. The wood under his hands was rough and hard.
“OK, now open your eyes. Look all around and remember what you see."
Their faces, in the twilight, looked new to Julian for a moment: Ariel’s smile, crooked and mysterious; Danny's look of skeptical good–humor; Robin's steady gaze. The redwoods rose up all around them, and they floated among the trunks as if they were riding on a magic carpet. The white sky showed between the treetops.
“Finally," Ariel’s voice was hushed, “you have to look in your heart and remember what you’re feeling. Like if you’re angry or sad…"
“Or if you are filled with glee because you defeated your enemy," Danny said.
“Hush!" Robin frowned. “If you don’t want to participate, Danny, nobody’s making you."
Danny crossed himself. “Forgive me," he said in his Mafia accent.
Julian’s stomach told him he was full of spaghetti and his mind told him he was secure in a tree house in a redwood forest, a place unimaginable just a few months before. His new friends had undertaken a brave quest on his behalf, and his father’s knife was safely in its wooden box. He had looked down on his uncle and spoken the truth.
“OK, now," Ariel said, looking intently from one to the other, “you will never, ever, ever forget this moment. Even when you’re sixteen or twenty–seven or sixty–five. You will always remember it exactly this way, the way it really was.”
P305
Certainly, he would remember everything in a day, a month, a year. Why not forever? All he had to do was remember to keep remembering.
P325 pabulum
P342 patrician
P345 twilit
Finally, his curiosity grew larger than his fear.
P12 facade — typo façade
P25 un perfecto caballerito - a perfect little gentleman
P27 popo (GMA)
Golden Gate Park - homeless people (SF)
P28
La familia no la escogemos.
You can’t pick your relatives.
P29
in staccato Cantonese
P34 hola, mi hijito
Vegetariano
P35
“I had cow tongue once,” Eduardo said. “It wasn’t bad. But you know what they say: You shouldn’t taste anything that can taste you back!”
P38 clear-cut
P39
Muir Woods
And a father and mother, obviously. (I don’t really like this part).
P41 Farm/Urban Network (FUN)
P42
Maybe in real life your uncle is not such a moron. I may be unfairly judging him and not understanding things from his shoes. My mom says I have a tendency to do this.
P57
“You always look on the dark side,” Danny said in exasperation. “And you have no sense of adventure! You’re the most boring person on earth. You’re going to live the boringest life ever and then bore yourself to death.”
P58
Sometimes, in restaurants, Julian would see large families gathered together, everybody laughing and talking at once, and he would study them, trying to figure out what made them so happy.
P62
“I’ll sleep on it. My brain works better when I’m unconscious. …”
P63
“As Sherlock Holmes says, ‘Once you have eliminated the impossible, whatever remains, no matter how improbable, must be the truth’ or, in your case, the Plan. I know it can work. I have a vision. …”
P69
Petirrojo- robin
Trata bien a mi amigo o lo pagarás caro! - Treat my friend well or you’ll pay!
P71
“Happy Good-Bye!”
Duck, chicken noodles, stir-fried green beans, spicy tofu
P74 (wasteful people - food - the lady dumped the rest of the ice cream cake in the garbage instead of letting anybody have extra or putting it in the freezer)
P75 high speed banana missiles
P77
“False hope’s better than no hope,” Danny said cheerfully.
P79
… I hope Julian isn’t eaten by a lion or anything,” the woman said cheerfully.
“Oh, that wouldn’t be the worst thing,” Danny said in a confidential tone. “In fact, I rather hope he is. He’s quite a holy terror. Well, toodle-loo!”
“Toodle-loo to you too!”
The woman was still laughing giddily when Danny put down the phone. “Am I good or what?” he said with a broad smile.
“You have a real talent for lying. And you ruined my reputation too. Congratulations!“
“We all have our gifts,” Danny said humbly.
P82
Most people, it seemed to him, had jobs that did not produce anything or create anything useful, yet somehow they lived. And some, like his uncle, produced nothing at all, and yet lived extremely well.
Miwok Indians
P90
Brandishing the stick like a miniature naked samurai
P97 switchbacks
P99 clear-cut
P104 motes of dust
P105 typo
Bent down the kissed ( should be “and kissed”)
P106 (how to milk a goat)
“Here, now you try,” Robin said. “There are two teats. Take one teat and squeeze, from the top to the bottom.”
The word “teat,” which Robin said so casually, made Julian blush. He reached out for the closest one, squeezed, and nothing happened.
“Wait, stop!” Robin said. “Squeeze just at the top. Harder.”
Julian squeezed.
“Now, work the milk down with your fingers. Down toward your pinky.”
P110
“Let’s get these weeds into the compost,” Bob said. They carried the tangle of uprooted weeds over to a large black plastic canister. “That’ll be good dirt in a few months. In good farming, nothing‘s wasted. A family can work the same land forever, if they do it right.”
P111
… all he heard was the sound of emptiness.
P112 (list of books)
The encyclopedia of organic gardening, the solar home, applied Silviculture and Forest ecology, small-scale aquaculture.
P118
THP = timber harvest plan
P121
“I guess that taught me a lesson: Don’t be afraid to ask for what you want.”
Build your own smart home (book name)
P122
Spigot
P129
“…I thought it was against the law, or they were all preserved in the national forests.”
Bob gave him a puzzled look. “The national forests?”
“You know, I thought they were protected. I mean, if Big Tree Grove were in a national forest, they couldn’t cut it down, right?”
Bob and Nancy exchanged glances.
“Julian!” Robin was giving him that superior look again. “The national forests aren’t like parks. They log there all the time. Right, Dad?”
“Well, that’s true,” Bob said slowly.
“That was the whole reason the national forests were set up in the first place, to make sure America would have enough timber.“
Robin gave him a look of exasperation. “Haven’t you ever heard of Gifford Pinchot?”
P157 (animals)
marbeled murrelets, fishers
P184
…But, of course, how you measure profit depends on what you value.”
P191
When his mom and Popo were together, Julian felt like he was watching a play in a language he couldn’t completely understand.
P193
She was fierce but polite, he decided, like a samurai or a knight. He could picture her in one of those Chinese kung-fu movies, brandishing her sword and deflecting bullets with her bracelets. He drifted off to sleep, imagining his grandmother as a Chinese warrior woman, leaping from treetop to treetop.
P194 winnowed down
P205
Strategize for success
Understand the market
Communicate power
Compete for the prize
Educate your adversary
Expand your portfolio
Demand allegiance
P210
Danny shrugged. “Learn Spanish. You’ll be a better spy.”
P240 (knot types)
Blake’s hitch, foot loop
P267
“Well, I don’t see how it could do any harm, really,” Nancy said. “And they are working for something they believe in. ‘Speak truth to power’ - that’s what we’ve taught them. “
P276
The sky flickered again and Robin started counting aloud – “one thousand, two thousand, three thousand, four thousand…” There was another low rumble.
“Five seconds!” Robin said. “That means the storm is still a mile away.”
P302-304
“… We should make a mental snapshot so we never forget this night."
“What’s that?" Julian said.
“You know how grown-ups can never remember what it was like being a kid?"
He nodded.
“I’m not going to be that way. I remember everything. I remember standing in my crib. I remember our old house, when I lived here with my mom and dad. And if I think I might forget something, I write it in my diary or I take a mental snapshot. I concentrate really hard and tell myself that I’m going to remember every single thing about that moment."
She sat down on a storage bin. “Come on. I’ll show you how. You have to be very, very quiet." She took a deep breath. “First, shut your eyes." They sat down and Julian closed his eyes. “You start with smelling," she said, sniffing hard. “Right now, I can smell spaghetti and lavender from the candle. And trees. The smell of the forest," she said in a low, breathless voice. “Now, listen."
Julian listened to the river, murmuring in the language of water on stone. The birds sang their evening songs. The mosquito whined in his ear and he swatted it away. He could hear his own breathing and Danny, sniffing loudly.
“Now," said Ariel, “concentrate on what you feel."
“I feel something coiling around my leg!" Danny cried. “A rattlesnake! Help!"
“Be quiet, Danny!" Robin ordered.
A light breeze stirred against Julian’s face. The wood under his hands was rough and hard.
“OK, now open your eyes. Look all around and remember what you see."
Their faces, in the twilight, looked new to Julian for a moment: Ariel’s smile, crooked and mysterious; Danny's look of skeptical good–humor; Robin's steady gaze. The redwoods rose up all around them, and they floated among the trunks as if they were riding on a magic carpet. The white sky showed between the treetops.
“Finally," Ariel’s voice was hushed, “you have to look in your heart and remember what you’re feeling. Like if you’re angry or sad…"
“Or if you are filled with glee because you defeated your enemy," Danny said.
“Hush!" Robin frowned. “If you don’t want to participate, Danny, nobody’s making you."
Danny crossed himself. “Forgive me," he said in his Mafia accent.
Julian’s stomach told him he was full of spaghetti and his mind told him he was secure in a tree house in a redwood forest, a place unimaginable just a few months before. His new friends had undertaken a brave quest on his behalf, and his father’s knife was safely in its wooden box. He had looked down on his uncle and spoken the truth.
“OK, now," Ariel said, looking intently from one to the other, “you will never, ever, ever forget this moment. Even when you’re sixteen or twenty–seven or sixty–five. You will always remember it exactly this way, the way it really was.”
P305
Certainly, he would remember everything in a day, a month, a year. Why not forever? All he had to do was remember to keep remembering.
P325 pabulum
P342 patrician
P345 twilit
March 26, 2020
I give it a 9/10
Target age demographic:5-7 grade (10-13 years old)
May also be enjoy it: 8-11 grade (14-16 years old)
I am a 17-year-old female, so I was not the target demographic for this book, yet it still entertained me and taught me so much! I stayed up late reading this wonderful story. One of the things I love about this book is that it spreads awareness and a love for the environment without being overly scholarly or boring. Operation Redwood also provides a lot of information about environmental activism, environmental laws, and state parks that I never knew. (Except about Julia Butterfly Hill- I learned about her in the Judy Moody series!) It entices kids with a beautifully crafted story, and carefully plants a seed of awareness in their hearts without them even knowing.
This book is not only environmentally aware, but it is also racially aware. Many of the characters are parts of minority groups in California. Julian is half-Chinese, and his best friend Danny is Hispanic. What I truly love about what French did in this book is that she didn't let her characters become stereotypes because of their race/ethnicity, nor does she bring up the point bluntly. Rather, she treats their race like it were a normal part of their identity which she describes through a description of their image and character dialogue. It is rare to see children's books that are not only diverse, but also racially aware.
Lastly, (and probably the most important part for kids) is that this book is funny and entertaining. The story may talk about serious environmental issues, but it keeps a kind, positive tone that is sure to inspire kids not only to keep reading, but also to keep learning about the issues mentioned in the story. This book made me laugh at the ingenuity of the kids and their adventure. The only flaw I would have with this book is that it stretches out the reality of the situation on certain occasions, and slightly exaggerates the ability of these kids to pull off some stunts. Overall though, this book achieves a great level of realism with no plot holes. Even though the kids in the book achieved some things we would not consider possible in our daily lives, French gives a good explanation of how and why everything happened the way it did in the book. There were no big plot twists (at least not for me, maybe younger kids will experience something different while reading), except for occasional small surprises for readers to learn more about characters and the big issue of the story. I recommend this book to everyone who can read English! You'll not only enjoy a great story; you'll learn a lot from it too.
Target age demographic:5-7 grade (10-13 years old)
May also be enjoy it: 8-11 grade (14-16 years old)
I am a 17-year-old female, so I was not the target demographic for this book, yet it still entertained me and taught me so much! I stayed up late reading this wonderful story. One of the things I love about this book is that it spreads awareness and a love for the environment without being overly scholarly or boring. Operation Redwood also provides a lot of information about environmental activism, environmental laws, and state parks that I never knew. (Except about Julia Butterfly Hill- I learned about her in the Judy Moody series!) It entices kids with a beautifully crafted story, and carefully plants a seed of awareness in their hearts without them even knowing.
This book is not only environmentally aware, but it is also racially aware. Many of the characters are parts of minority groups in California. Julian is half-Chinese, and his best friend Danny is Hispanic. What I truly love about what French did in this book is that she didn't let her characters become stereotypes because of their race/ethnicity, nor does she bring up the point bluntly. Rather, she treats their race like it were a normal part of their identity which she describes through a description of their image and character dialogue. It is rare to see children's books that are not only diverse, but also racially aware.
Lastly, (and probably the most important part for kids) is that this book is funny and entertaining. The story may talk about serious environmental issues, but it keeps a kind, positive tone that is sure to inspire kids not only to keep reading, but also to keep learning about the issues mentioned in the story. This book made me laugh at the ingenuity of the kids and their adventure. The only flaw I would have with this book is that it stretches out the reality of the situation on certain occasions, and slightly exaggerates the ability of these kids to pull off some stunts. Overall though, this book achieves a great level of realism with no plot holes. Even though the kids in the book achieved some things we would not consider possible in our daily lives, French gives a good explanation of how and why everything happened the way it did in the book. There were no big plot twists (at least not for me, maybe younger kids will experience something different while reading), except for occasional small surprises for readers to learn more about characters and the big issue of the story. I recommend this book to everyone who can read English! You'll not only enjoy a great story; you'll learn a lot from it too.
August 24, 2019
“I am the Lorax who speaks for the trees, which you seem to be chopping as fast as you please.” In Operation Redwood, Julian, the nephew of a covetous and tyrannical businessman, is similar to the Lorax. He discovers that his uncle, Sibley Carter, is formulating plans to cut down a redwood grove, including a world-famous tree, Big Tree. Instead of using the redwoods to build something useful, he wants to use the space that the majestic trees once stood in to build resorts to become rich, similar to the Once-ler in The Lorax. Fortunately, Julian stops his uncle from cutting down the redwood grove, unlike in The Lorax.
However, Julian couldn’t have done it alone. His uncle’s son, Preston, is not your usual wealthy kid. He does an ecology project on redwoods and wants to conserve the redwoods, unlike his father, who’s money-making plans have not been revealed to him. I like how Preston resists the temptation of becoming rich and powerful like his father one day, sides with Julian, his father’s enemy, and protests along with Julian and his friends, and his grandma.
The only thing Sibley is afraid of is his mom. When she read Julian’s story that had been posted in the newspaper, she travels to the grove to support her grandsons and challenge her son. In the end, Sibley is forced to abandon his plans and give up the grove to Julian.
The complete opposite happens to the Lorax. He is forced to give up on trying to save the truffula trees and has to leave. I think this ending is realistic. Sometimes, activists succeed, but a lot of times they don’t. The ending in Operation Redwood is too fantastical for my taste. I do like how the grove is saved. However, I would have preferred that the grove be handed off to the government and become a national forest, monument, or park, like it is in real life. I think that S. Terrell French didn't have to make Sibley so evil. Personifying Dr. Seuss’s character, the Lorax, is genius because the readers can relate better to a human kid rather than a mystical yellow creature.
This is my favorite quote from the The Lorax: “Unless someone like you cares a whole awful lot, nothing is going to get better. It’s not.” Throughout the book, we learn that Julian cares so much about the redwoods that he is motivated to save the ancient trees his uncle plans to chop down. He succeeds after persisting through many failures and proves that caring a whole awful lot gets you very far.
However, Julian couldn’t have done it alone. His uncle’s son, Preston, is not your usual wealthy kid. He does an ecology project on redwoods and wants to conserve the redwoods, unlike his father, who’s money-making plans have not been revealed to him. I like how Preston resists the temptation of becoming rich and powerful like his father one day, sides with Julian, his father’s enemy, and protests along with Julian and his friends, and his grandma.
The only thing Sibley is afraid of is his mom. When she read Julian’s story that had been posted in the newspaper, she travels to the grove to support her grandsons and challenge her son. In the end, Sibley is forced to abandon his plans and give up the grove to Julian.
The complete opposite happens to the Lorax. He is forced to give up on trying to save the truffula trees and has to leave. I think this ending is realistic. Sometimes, activists succeed, but a lot of times they don’t. The ending in Operation Redwood is too fantastical for my taste. I do like how the grove is saved. However, I would have preferred that the grove be handed off to the government and become a national forest, monument, or park, like it is in real life. I think that S. Terrell French didn't have to make Sibley so evil. Personifying Dr. Seuss’s character, the Lorax, is genius because the readers can relate better to a human kid rather than a mystical yellow creature.
This is my favorite quote from the The Lorax: “Unless someone like you cares a whole awful lot, nothing is going to get better. It’s not.” Throughout the book, we learn that Julian cares so much about the redwoods that he is motivated to save the ancient trees his uncle plans to chop down. He succeeds after persisting through many failures and proves that caring a whole awful lot gets you very far.
April 25, 2025
This middle grade book won the 2009 Beatty Award for the best book depicting California history, culture or geology. In this case, it's all about the California redwoods, 94% of which has been cut down. The redwoods use to cover all of northern California. Believe it or not, there is a redwood grove in Brea, California (just north of Disneyland) in Carbon Canyon Park. When the park first opened in 1975, 100 Redwood seeds were planted at the grove. The seeds were left over from a bank promotion giving them out to customers opening accounts. Now, Southern California does not have a conducive climate for redwoods, as they like morning mist and cooler weather, but these trees have been nurtured and are now 50 years old! It's an easy hike out to visit them; I've taken 2nd grade Brownies on this hike.
Back to the book...can a 12-year old boy really prevent one of the last old-grove redwood forests from being chopped down by his uncle's company? Can he and his friends come up with a plan to stop them?
The characters are well-drawn and though Uncle Sibley and Aunt Daphne are rather one-dimensional, Julian, Daniel (who is a hoot), and Robin are very realistic. There is a deux ex machina ending, but I'm all for happy endings.
Back to the book...can a 12-year old boy really prevent one of the last old-grove redwood forests from being chopped down by his uncle's company? Can he and his friends come up with a plan to stop them?
The characters are well-drawn and though Uncle Sibley and Aunt Daphne are rather one-dimensional, Julian, Daniel (who is a hoot), and Robin are very realistic. There is a deux ex machina ending, but I'm all for happy endings.
August 19, 2017
Julian Carter-Li has been staying with his aunt and uncle for the past few weeks while his mother is in China. It is very clear to him that they don't want him there, though he gets along quite well with his younger cousin Preston. When Julian finds himself alone for several hours in his uncle's office, he notices first an email with his name as the subject, and then an irresistible email just below it. Although he knows he shouldn't, he can't help but read them, which is how he learns that his uncle's company plans to cut down a stand of old growth redwoods outside of Willits, CA. He and his best friend Danny strike up an email friendship with a girl who lives on a farm next door to the redwoods. With her help, they devise a way to get Julian up to the farm and out of his aunt and uncle's clutches and hopefully save the redwoods.
Operation Redwood looks at family relations as well as the need to save what is left of the old growth forests. French manages to give the reader the necessary facts without sounding preachy or didactic. Highly recommended for grades 4 & up.
Operation Redwood looks at family relations as well as the need to save what is left of the old growth forests. French manages to give the reader the necessary facts without sounding preachy or didactic. Highly recommended for grades 4 & up.
April 10, 2024
In Operation Redwood, Terrell French crafts an exhilarating tale of youthful ingenuity and environmental activism that captivates from the very first page. The novel follows the courageous efforts of Julian Carter-Li and his band of friends as they embark on a mission to thwart a plan to fell ancient California redwoods.
At its core, Operation Redwood is a poignant exploration of the power of determination and collective action in the face of injustice. Through Julian's unwavering resolve and the solidarity of his allies, the novel delivers a powerful message about the importance of standing up for what is right, no matter the odds.
With its richly drawn characters, gripping plot, and timely themes, the book is a nice-read for young readers and adults alike. It reminds us that even the smallest voices can make a big impact and inspires hope for a more sustainable and just future.
At its core, Operation Redwood is a poignant exploration of the power of determination and collective action in the face of injustice. Through Julian's unwavering resolve and the solidarity of his allies, the novel delivers a powerful message about the importance of standing up for what is right, no matter the odds.
With its richly drawn characters, gripping plot, and timely themes, the book is a nice-read for young readers and adults alike. It reminds us that even the smallest voices can make a big impact and inspires hope for a more sustainable and just future.
May 31, 2019
Superficially this is a great adventure story where a few kids save the ecosystem in the form of a redwood forest.
But, in order to do so the kids repeatedly use lying, cheating, manipulation, trespassing and other immoral maneuvers that are consistently disguised as ingenuity and resourcefulness. These are not the morals I’m hoping my kids will replicate and it is all so cleverly packaged - since it all works out in the end, those misbehavior are not just excused but celebrated (just get the goods no matter the manner) - the end message is deceit is okay if the end result is “good”.
Disappointed. The only positive part is that homeschooling is portrayed as giving a stronger education then public schools.
But, in order to do so the kids repeatedly use lying, cheating, manipulation, trespassing and other immoral maneuvers that are consistently disguised as ingenuity and resourcefulness. These are not the morals I’m hoping my kids will replicate and it is all so cleverly packaged - since it all works out in the end, those misbehavior are not just excused but celebrated (just get the goods no matter the manner) - the end message is deceit is okay if the end result is “good”.
Disappointed. The only positive part is that homeschooling is portrayed as giving a stronger education then public schools.
July 11, 2017
This book was fantastic. Julian, the main character, sees an email sent to his uncle and discovers that his uncle's company is planning to cut down a Redwood grove. It is up to Julian to save the trees. He and his friends move into a treehouse and refuse to leave. His uncle is furious. As long as the kids are up in the tree, his company can't level the grove. The local newspaper runs an article on Julian and his friends' efforts to save the trees, and others become involved. This book showed how even kids can make change happen.
February 15, 2011
There is not a single thing I didn't like about this book. Some might complain that it started off rather slow but I live for slow contemporary starts, I like getting to know every little detail about the main character and their friends. Sure some things are a little too convenient (Danny speaks Spanish but Julian doesn't speak Spanish so naturally Danny must translate often. also Julian's Chinese grandmother writes for a sizable newspaper), but who cares? This story is too fun to get wrapped up in such minor things. I'm a sucker for kids and teens engaging in social justice because I think too many books only show us as selfish brats who don't care about the future of our world. That's simply not true and this author gets that. At the core of this book (or the trunk of this book, and yes there will be more annoying tree metaphors) is a message of environmentalism. Here we have three kids who don't have an extraordinary amount of resources available to them and yet they manage to come up with a plan, a plan that has the potential to work. They aren't hackers or geniuses or super wealthy, instead they have lots of heart and pool together their respective brain power to find a solution. These qualities make the book an interesting read and one that is authentic. I could easily see myself and other kids in middle school coming up with a similar plan (instead of those outrageous plots that you know would never work out in real life. Not that those can't be fun). The core has different branches that all lead back to the plan to save the redwoods but they divert (in the best of ways) to stories dealing with racism, family abandonment, strong friendships and the actual application of what we learn in school.
In addition to the save-the-trees message that rocked, I also adored the subtle displays of racism. In today's world, rarely do we see outright prejudice and Operation Redwood perfectly reflects that fact. Julian's mother travels a lot and his father died when he was seven, so when Julian's mother leaves for China for several months, he has to go live with his uncle Sibley. Sibley is his father's brother and while Sibley's young son, Preston, adores Julian, Sibley and his wife do not. Sibley's wife, Daphne, goes out of his way to make sure Julian knows he is not welcome (she has a point system. A POINTS system, but that's actually not a totally implausible situation). Of course since she never spells it out, you can't be sure that part of that dislike is race-based, but it probably doesn't help that Julian's Chinese (his mother is Chinese, his father is white) heritage 'ruins' her image of the perfect all-American blonde family. Like when Julian says '[s]omething about the way his aunt said 'half-Chinese' always made it sound vaguely like an insult-or not an insult exactly, but something that made him less than Preston, who at least in her view, wasn't half anything." (pg. 51) I had such a YES moment when I read that, I totally get what Julian's describing and I think many people from different cultural backgrounds may have a similar moment. Julian doesn't spend the entire book talking about the hardships of being a biracial kid, he mentions it, but he also talks about the joys of being biracial and how funny it can be to think about "how strange it was that he should be descended from two such different people, how weird and improbable that their DNA would end up mixed together in his own body." (pg.341). I would be remiss not to rave about Danny. I LOVE Danny, I want him to be my best friend. He is a mess, always hamming it up and yet his silly ways often help him to come up with the most outrageous-but-they-just-might-work stunts. But he can also be very practical (he's quite handy with computer basics such as sending emails in which Julian is hopelessly defunct). One of my favorite exchanges between Danny and Julian is below
"Am I good or what?' he [Danny] said with a broad smile.
'You have a real talent for lying. And you've ruined my reputation too. Congratulations!' [Julian]
'We all have our gifts,' Danny said humbly." (pg. 79) What a great kid.
Operation Redwood has many different branches that all lead back to the importance of speaking up when a wrong is being committed and the value of nature. Julian lives in San Francisco which can be a bit polluted, and he ends up going to see the Big Grove of redwood trees and is in awe of nature. I probably would be too. I don't live in the heart of the city, but I can relate to not spending much time relaxing and pondering nature, especially as we kids become older. I love that Julian has such a diverse group of friends, as the 21st century pushes on, we are going to see more diverse friendships, even now, people are rarely friends with only white people, and it's soo nice to see a book that reflects this. In fact this is the kind of contemporary middle grade I want to see more of, pretty please publishers? The ending certainly surprised me and it's realistic. Robin is resourceful, Danny is imaginative and Julian has the quiet strength that only unveils itself when push comes to shove. I could go on and on and on, but I'll stop. Ultimately this is a prime example of a book where it's the LITTLE THINGS that make it such a phenomenal read. The plot is not complex but it is revolutionary in that it so accurately depicts our world through the eyes of middle school students. A definite favorite of 2011 already.
In addition to the save-the-trees message that rocked, I also adored the subtle displays of racism. In today's world, rarely do we see outright prejudice and Operation Redwood perfectly reflects that fact. Julian's mother travels a lot and his father died when he was seven, so when Julian's mother leaves for China for several months, he has to go live with his uncle Sibley. Sibley is his father's brother and while Sibley's young son, Preston, adores Julian, Sibley and his wife do not. Sibley's wife, Daphne, goes out of his way to make sure Julian knows he is not welcome (she has a point system. A POINTS system, but that's actually not a totally implausible situation). Of course since she never spells it out, you can't be sure that part of that dislike is race-based, but it probably doesn't help that Julian's Chinese (his mother is Chinese, his father is white) heritage 'ruins' her image of the perfect all-American blonde family. Like when Julian says '[s]omething about the way his aunt said 'half-Chinese' always made it sound vaguely like an insult-or not an insult exactly, but something that made him less than Preston, who at least in her view, wasn't half anything." (pg. 51) I had such a YES moment when I read that, I totally get what Julian's describing and I think many people from different cultural backgrounds may have a similar moment. Julian doesn't spend the entire book talking about the hardships of being a biracial kid, he mentions it, but he also talks about the joys of being biracial and how funny it can be to think about "how strange it was that he should be descended from two such different people, how weird and improbable that their DNA would end up mixed together in his own body." (pg.341). I would be remiss not to rave about Danny. I LOVE Danny, I want him to be my best friend. He is a mess, always hamming it up and yet his silly ways often help him to come up with the most outrageous-but-they-just-might-work stunts. But he can also be very practical (he's quite handy with computer basics such as sending emails in which Julian is hopelessly defunct). One of my favorite exchanges between Danny and Julian is below
"Am I good or what?' he [Danny] said with a broad smile.
'You have a real talent for lying. And you've ruined my reputation too. Congratulations!' [Julian]
'We all have our gifts,' Danny said humbly." (pg. 79) What a great kid.
Operation Redwood has many different branches that all lead back to the importance of speaking up when a wrong is being committed and the value of nature. Julian lives in San Francisco which can be a bit polluted, and he ends up going to see the Big Grove of redwood trees and is in awe of nature. I probably would be too. I don't live in the heart of the city, but I can relate to not spending much time relaxing and pondering nature, especially as we kids become older. I love that Julian has such a diverse group of friends, as the 21st century pushes on, we are going to see more diverse friendships, even now, people are rarely friends with only white people, and it's soo nice to see a book that reflects this. In fact this is the kind of contemporary middle grade I want to see more of, pretty please publishers? The ending certainly surprised me and it's realistic. Robin is resourceful, Danny is imaginative and Julian has the quiet strength that only unveils itself when push comes to shove. I could go on and on and on, but I'll stop. Ultimately this is a prime example of a book where it's the LITTLE THINGS that make it such a phenomenal read. The plot is not complex but it is revolutionary in that it so accurately depicts our world through the eyes of middle school students. A definite favorite of 2011 already.
May 13, 2025
Four middle schoolers try to save a grove of old growth redwoods in Northern California. A major theme is finding a way even when something seems impossible. There is also a pitiful orphan that no one wants until they do character arc (á la Secret Garden).
There are parts that are unrealistic, and my kids thought some of the dialogue was not believable. But it’s a good story for redwood lovers and anyone who has ever dreamed of living in a treehouse.
There are parts that are unrealistic, and my kids thought some of the dialogue was not believable. But it’s a good story for redwood lovers and anyone who has ever dreamed of living in a treehouse.
February 11, 2022
Read for climate change lit course—was a cute story with very lovable characters who all come to climate advocacy in their own way. I loved that there were historical elements tied in throughout the book about the history of Redwood trees and deforestation, as well as the continuing education of other characters throughout the book.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 158 reviews