What do you think?
Rate this book
The Uncertainty of Fire
What price will she pay for following her heart?
Chicago, 1871. Sixteen-year-old Whimsy Greathart would rather fight against Chicago’s child labor practices than attend her privileged family’s high society events. And a very public social blunder only strengthens her resolve to use her influence for good.
On the night of the Great Chicago Fire, her tenderhearted choice leads her into danger and results in life-changing consequences.
With her world turned to ash, she must rely on the mercy of poor relations to rebuild her future and is forced into the very labor system she wished to fight against. As Whimsy staggers under the weight of street gang violence and hazardous working conditions, a chance at deliverance persuades her to make a promise. One she intends to keep. But now she must determine whether it’s God’s heart she’s following or her own.
A Top Faved Christian story on Amazon’s Kindle Vella. Now available in paperback and e-book.
Chicago, 1871. Sixteen-year-old Whimsy Greathart would rather fight against Chicago’s child labor practices than attend her privileged family’s high society events. And a very public social blunder only strengthens her resolve to use her influence for good.
On the night of the Great Chicago Fire, her tenderhearted choice leads her into danger and results in life-changing consequences.
With her world turned to ash, she must rely on the mercy of poor relations to rebuild her future and is forced into the very labor system she wished to fight against. As Whimsy staggers under the weight of street gang violence and hazardous working conditions, a chance at deliverance persuades her to make a promise. One she intends to keep. But now she must determine whether it’s God’s heart she’s following or her own.
A Top Faved Christian story on Amazon’s Kindle Vella. Now available in paperback and e-book.
456 pages, Kindle Edition
Published July 29, 2022
5 people are currently reading
296 people want to read
About the author
Stephanie Daniels
2 books96 followersStephanie Daniels is a Christian wife and mother who lives in the present but dreams in the past. Her debut novel, The Uncertainty of Fire, first appeared as an episodic story on Amazon's Kindle Vella.
In between chauffeuring her sons to baseball practices, music lessons, and whatever else has caught their interest at the moment, supporting her very understanding lives-with-a-writer husband, substitute teaching in Sunday school, singing in the church choir, and attending all of the birthdays, sports events, concerts of not only her sons, but her large extended family, she slips away and attempts to bring past worlds to life.
She writes historical fiction with strong faith themes and often romance, targeted for teens/young adults.
She loves clean period dramas, touring historical sites, drinking a large cup of coffee in the morning, and delving into research. And she is always up for a conversation about books and writing. You can follow her at https://www.facebook.com/AuthorStepha... and at https://www.instagram.com/stephaniead...
In between chauffeuring her sons to baseball practices, music lessons, and whatever else has caught their interest at the moment, supporting her very understanding lives-with-a-writer husband, substitute teaching in Sunday school, singing in the church choir, and attending all of the birthdays, sports events, concerts of not only her sons, but her large extended family, she slips away and attempts to bring past worlds to life.
She writes historical fiction with strong faith themes and often romance, targeted for teens/young adults.
She loves clean period dramas, touring historical sites, drinking a large cup of coffee in the morning, and delving into research. And she is always up for a conversation about books and writing. You can follow her at https://www.facebook.com/AuthorStepha... and at https://www.instagram.com/stephaniead...
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 38 reviews
November 28, 2022
About this book:
“What price will she pay for following her heart?
Chicago, 1871. Sixteen-year-old Whimsy Greathart would rather fight against Chicago’s child labor practices than attend her privileged family’s high society events. And a very public social blunder only strengthens her resolve to use her influence for good.
On the night of the Great Chicago Fire, her tenderhearted choice leads her into danger and results in life-changing consequences.
With her world turned to ash, she must rely on the mercy of poor relations to rebuild her future and is forced into the very labor system she wished to fight against. As Whimsy staggers under the weight of street gang violence and hazardous working conditions, a chance at deliverance persuades her to make a promise. One she intends to keep. But now she must determine whether it’s God’s heart she’s following or her own.”
Series: Book #1 in the “Uncertain Riches” series.
Spiritual Content- At beginning of each part (four in total), there is a Scripture; Scriptures are quoted, read, & remembered; Prayers; Church going, services, sermons, & hymns; Many talks about God, why God allows things to happen, His plans/will for us, being called by Him, callings, trusting Him, listening to God, praying, & forgiveness; 'H's are capital when referring to God; Whimsy struggles to understand why God allowed something to happen & why she’s alive (there’s quite a few discussion about this and the answer is that God has a plan for her, even if she doesn’t want to hear that); Whimsy doesn’t want to pray at one time because she’s weary of being told no; In a couple possible dying scenarios, Whimsy thinks that if she surrenders to death, she’ll be in Heaven, but remembers a conversation about there being a reason she’s alive and doesn’t give up; Whimsy doesn’t believe that someone that has caused her pain and trouble has accepted God; When asked to forgive that someone, Whimsy lies and says she does (*Spoiler* ); Whimsy wants someone who is cynical about God and religion to turn to Him (*Major Spoiler* ); Many, many mentions of God, Jesus, trusting Him, His will, listening to God, callings, & forgiveness; Many mentions of prayers, praying, answered prayers, blessings over food, & Thanking/Praising God; Many mentions of Bibles, Bible reading, & Bible studies; Many mentions of churches, church going, church meetings, services, pastors/reverends, & hymns; Mentions of those & events in the Bible; Mentions of Heaven; Mentions of missions & missionaries; Mentions of a conversion & a new believer in God; Mentions of Christians & faiths; Mentions of Protestants, Baptists, & Methodists; Mentions of someone’s distain for Christianity & preachers (including calling the “religious folks” that didn’t like saloons “dippers” (called that because they’re “the ones who say you gotta get dunked underwater”), pointing out religious hypocrisy (of Christians converting Indians but then rejecting their children to be able to come to school), saying he’d prefer the company of an outlaw than a preacher, that a preacher’s charity baskets had a double-meaning about wanting the people to give money to the church, and wanting to prove that a preacher is a con-man); A few mentions of paintings of those & events in the Bible; A few mentions of sins & sinners; A couple mentions of testimonies & praises; A couple mentions of a man wondering if God is punishing him for his past actions when something terrible happens (Whimsy tells him that’s not true); A couple mentions of the Catholics crossing themselves & mass; A mention of being baptized; A mention of a Catholic shrine; A mention of sisters at a church;
*Note: A couple mentions of a near-perfect memory being a curse or a blessing; A mention of that in some countries, it’s considered demonic to be left-handed; A mention of a spiritualist’s candlelit skull; A (teasing) mention of a magic spell being casted on someone (because they did something that is not normal for them); A mention of a Greek Mythology character (Odysseus).
Negative Content- Minor cussing including: a ‘bosh’, a ‘drat’, a ‘dumb’, an ‘idiot’, a ‘sissy’, and three ‘stupid’s; Mentions of curses; Whimsy says “flumadiddle” when she drops something or something unexpected happens (as opposed to a curse word, said six times); Some eye rolling & Sarcasm; Fires, Close calls, Being caught in a fire, Being lost in a crowd, Fights/Fighting, Being beaten/attacked (Whimsy is beaten by a gang of young men because she told on them, happens a few times), Running away from a gang, Being attacked by a drunk and Being held at knife-point (the man intends to kill Whimsy), Pain, Injuries, Blood/Bleeding, & Passing out (up to semi-detailed); Helping someone who is injured & their blood/bleeding (up to semi-detailed); Throwing up; Grief, Grieving, & Guilt for loved one’s deaths (parents and family members, *Spoiler* ); In a couple possible dying scenarios, Whimsy thinks that if she surrenders to death, she’ll be in Heaven, but remembers a conversation about there being a reason she’s alive and doesn’t give up; Whimsy imagines punching someone (she does not, however the thought brings a smile to her face) & later pushes the annoying person; Whimsy lies (a couple times to throw her cousin off of her trail and another time to keep from explaining about someone she doesn’t want to tell others about; She has opportunities to correct it all, but does not and this bothers and causes her guilt; *Spoiler* ); Whimsy says doesn’t care if a man dies after being tormented by him (*Spoiler* ); All about many mentions of fires, smoke, crowds, screams, injuries, deaths, & bodies/remains (up to semi-detailed); Many mentions of fights, fighting, a gang, that gang beating others, the head bully, stabbings, attacks, pain, injuries, & blood/bleeding (up to semi-detailed); Mentions of a woman being murdered due to a man’s animosity towards her picking another man to marry (barely-above-not-detailed); Mentions of a murder & someone trying to see the murderer hung; Mentions of wars, fighting, injuries, & deaths (barely-above-not-detailed); Mentions of a massacre, raids, fights against the Indians in the West, & deaths of mostly women and child; Mentions of riots, violence, injuries, & deaths; Mentions of child labor, accidents, injuries, blood/bleeding, & deaths (barely-above-not-detailed); Mentions of a man willing to kill another man for hurting his girl; Mentions of stealing, crimes, thieves/robbers/criminals, & seeing a group of men attacking a delivery wagon; Mentions of cons & swindlers (including children and a man posing as a preacher); Mentions of bets, gambling, & horse races; Mentions of explosions/TNT; Mentions of saloons, alcohol, drinking, drunks, & temperance laws (also including a man saying he’s been drinking since he was ten and trying to fight the addiction); Mentions of cigars, tobacco, & smoking; Mentions of grief (parents, mother, sister, wife, other family members) & guilt over deaths; Mentions of nightmares (including ones of being attacked and threatened, barely-above-not-detailed); Mentions of lies, lying, liars, & deceit; Mentions of gossip, rumors, & eavesdropping; Mentions of slaughterhouses & pigs going to the slaughter pins (barely-above-not-detailed); Mentions of a dead rodent & the smell (barely-above-not-detailed); A few mentions of President Lincoln’s funeral; A few mentions of bribes & dirty police officers; A few mentions of bar fights/brawls; A few mentions of throwing up; A few mentions of malnutrition; A few mentions of hatred; A few mentions of jealousy; A couple mentions of a family’s infants/children dying young; A couple mentions of malaria & a death; A couple mentions of a jail & prisoners; A couple mentions of hunting & hunters; A couple mentions of boys messing with & trying to kill a tarantula; A mention of a doctor being killing for helping another man; A mention of a young man wanting to kill his father because of the way he and his mother were treated by him; A mention of diarrhea; A mention of manure;
*Note: Mentions of prejudices (towards the poor, the religious, & Indians/Native Americans and someone’s possible prejudice towards interracial marriages); Mentions of books (A couple of Charles Dickens’ books, Julius Caesar, and Little Women).
Sexual Content- Three hand kisses (one unwanted), a cheek kiss, four head/forehead kisses, two barely-above-not-detailed kisses, and a border-line barely-above-not-detailed // semi-detailed kiss; Recalling kisses (barely-above-not-detailed); A mention of a young man staring at Whimsy’s lips; Touches, Embraces, Hand holding, Warmth, & Butterflies (barely-above-not-detailed); Wanting to embrace; Blushes; Noticing, Nearness, & Smelling (barely-above-not-detailed); Whimsy makes a promise to be with a young man while she’s uncertain about her feelings for him; Whimsy lies to her cousin about a boy & being interested in him (twice); Mentions of mean leering at Whimsy and other young women with wolfish stares; Mentions of kisses & couples kissing; Mentions of blushes, crushes, flirting, & a flirt; Mentions of chaperones & reputations (Whimsy thinks often that her mother wouldn’t like her being alone with a young man); Mentions of girls giggling & staring at a young man; A couple mentions of jealousy; Love, wondering if she’s in love, falling in love, & the emotions;
*Note: A mention of women wearing dresses that hug their curves; A mention of a neckline of a dress possibly being “too liberal” in a land full of men.
-Whimsy Greathart, age 16-17
1st person P.O.V. of Whimsy
Set in 1871-1872 (Epilogue in 1873)
372 pages
~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
Pre Teens- One Star
New Teens- Two Stars
Early High School Teens- Four Stars
Older High School Teens- Four Stars
My personal Rating- Four Stars
{Might be a hard (or possible comforting) read for girls who have lost their parents}
The sigh of happy relief I did once finishing this novel was probably heard a couple states over.
What can I say? Love triangles make me nervous. And this one definitely did.
Going back a bit, the beginning of this story really reminded me of an American Girl historical novel. I can’t place why exactly, because it was much better written, but perhaps because of the historical setting and this being one of the few Historical YA novels I’ve seen in the Christian Fiction genre?
This novel is broken up into four parts and spans over a year in total. Which felt very realistic for all the things Whimsy goes through and has to learn. The last part really reminded me of a Janette Oke novel, with Whimsy having to learn and own up to her actions and past lies.
On Whimsy, I really liked her and was honestly brought to tears at some points and events. I love her name, but also her compassion. I will admit that she frustrated and stressed me out at times because of her decisions, but every time was a learning experience for her and to help her grow. I have to find those parts relatable and wonder if the Lord’s felt the same way with me a times. (Sorry, Lord!) I also really liked the writing style and how different events or emotions were described.
Back to the love triangle, not to sound dramatic or anything, but it was literally killing me. Okay, obviously not actually killing me, but it felt like it was for a chunk of the book. Those who enjoy love triangles will probably enjoy this element, but even me (the not-a-fan-of-love-triangles-tropes-because-I-hate-someone-to-be-dissappointed-and-hurt) thoroughly got involved into that element and was (very thankfully) satisfied at the ending. But, again, I did a sigh of (happy) relief when finishing this novel. I’m very curious about the next book in the series as it will be about a side character we met towards the end of this book and plan to anticipate reading it.
Link to review:
https://booksforchristiangirls.blogsp...
*BFCG may (Read the review to see) recommend this book by this author. It does not mean I recommend all the books by this author.
*I received this book for free from the Author for this honest review.
“What price will she pay for following her heart?
Chicago, 1871. Sixteen-year-old Whimsy Greathart would rather fight against Chicago’s child labor practices than attend her privileged family’s high society events. And a very public social blunder only strengthens her resolve to use her influence for good.
On the night of the Great Chicago Fire, her tenderhearted choice leads her into danger and results in life-changing consequences.
With her world turned to ash, she must rely on the mercy of poor relations to rebuild her future and is forced into the very labor system she wished to fight against. As Whimsy staggers under the weight of street gang violence and hazardous working conditions, a chance at deliverance persuades her to make a promise. One she intends to keep. But now she must determine whether it’s God’s heart she’s following or her own.”
Series: Book #1 in the “Uncertain Riches” series.
Spiritual Content- At beginning of each part (four in total), there is a Scripture; Scriptures are quoted, read, & remembered; Prayers; Church going, services, sermons, & hymns; Many talks about God, why God allows things to happen, His plans/will for us, being called by Him, callings, trusting Him, listening to God, praying, & forgiveness; 'H's are capital when referring to God; Whimsy struggles to understand why God allowed something to happen & why she’s alive (there’s quite a few discussion about this and the answer is that God has a plan for her, even if she doesn’t want to hear that); Whimsy doesn’t want to pray at one time because she’s weary of being told no; In a couple possible dying scenarios, Whimsy thinks that if she surrenders to death, she’ll be in Heaven, but remembers a conversation about there being a reason she’s alive and doesn’t give up; Whimsy doesn’t believe that someone that has caused her pain and trouble has accepted God; When asked to forgive that someone, Whimsy lies and says she does (*Spoiler* ); Whimsy wants someone who is cynical about God and religion to turn to Him (*Major Spoiler* ); Many, many mentions of God, Jesus, trusting Him, His will, listening to God, callings, & forgiveness; Many mentions of prayers, praying, answered prayers, blessings over food, & Thanking/Praising God; Many mentions of Bibles, Bible reading, & Bible studies; Many mentions of churches, church going, church meetings, services, pastors/reverends, & hymns; Mentions of those & events in the Bible; Mentions of Heaven; Mentions of missions & missionaries; Mentions of a conversion & a new believer in God; Mentions of Christians & faiths; Mentions of Protestants, Baptists, & Methodists; Mentions of someone’s distain for Christianity & preachers (including calling the “religious folks” that didn’t like saloons “dippers” (called that because they’re “the ones who say you gotta get dunked underwater”), pointing out religious hypocrisy (of Christians converting Indians but then rejecting their children to be able to come to school), saying he’d prefer the company of an outlaw than a preacher, that a preacher’s charity baskets had a double-meaning about wanting the people to give money to the church, and wanting to prove that a preacher is a con-man); A few mentions of paintings of those & events in the Bible; A few mentions of sins & sinners; A couple mentions of testimonies & praises; A couple mentions of a man wondering if God is punishing him for his past actions when something terrible happens (Whimsy tells him that’s not true); A couple mentions of the Catholics crossing themselves & mass; A mention of being baptized; A mention of a Catholic shrine; A mention of sisters at a church;
*Note: A couple mentions of a near-perfect memory being a curse or a blessing; A mention of that in some countries, it’s considered demonic to be left-handed; A mention of a spiritualist’s candlelit skull; A (teasing) mention of a magic spell being casted on someone (because they did something that is not normal for them); A mention of a Greek Mythology character (Odysseus).
Negative Content- Minor cussing including: a ‘bosh’, a ‘drat’, a ‘dumb’, an ‘idiot’, a ‘sissy’, and three ‘stupid’s; Mentions of curses; Whimsy says “flumadiddle” when she drops something or something unexpected happens (as opposed to a curse word, said six times); Some eye rolling & Sarcasm; Fires, Close calls, Being caught in a fire, Being lost in a crowd, Fights/Fighting, Being beaten/attacked (Whimsy is beaten by a gang of young men because she told on them, happens a few times), Running away from a gang, Being attacked by a drunk and Being held at knife-point (the man intends to kill Whimsy), Pain, Injuries, Blood/Bleeding, & Passing out (up to semi-detailed); Helping someone who is injured & their blood/bleeding (up to semi-detailed); Throwing up; Grief, Grieving, & Guilt for loved one’s deaths (parents and family members, *Spoiler* ); In a couple possible dying scenarios, Whimsy thinks that if she surrenders to death, she’ll be in Heaven, but remembers a conversation about there being a reason she’s alive and doesn’t give up; Whimsy imagines punching someone (she does not, however the thought brings a smile to her face) & later pushes the annoying person; Whimsy lies (a couple times to throw her cousin off of her trail and another time to keep from explaining about someone she doesn’t want to tell others about; She has opportunities to correct it all, but does not and this bothers and causes her guilt; *Spoiler* ); Whimsy says doesn’t care if a man dies after being tormented by him (*Spoiler* ); All about many mentions of fires, smoke, crowds, screams, injuries, deaths, & bodies/remains (up to semi-detailed); Many mentions of fights, fighting, a gang, that gang beating others, the head bully, stabbings, attacks, pain, injuries, & blood/bleeding (up to semi-detailed); Mentions of a woman being murdered due to a man’s animosity towards her picking another man to marry (barely-above-not-detailed); Mentions of a murder & someone trying to see the murderer hung; Mentions of wars, fighting, injuries, & deaths (barely-above-not-detailed); Mentions of a massacre, raids, fights against the Indians in the West, & deaths of mostly women and child; Mentions of riots, violence, injuries, & deaths; Mentions of child labor, accidents, injuries, blood/bleeding, & deaths (barely-above-not-detailed); Mentions of a man willing to kill another man for hurting his girl; Mentions of stealing, crimes, thieves/robbers/criminals, & seeing a group of men attacking a delivery wagon; Mentions of cons & swindlers (including children and a man posing as a preacher); Mentions of bets, gambling, & horse races; Mentions of explosions/TNT; Mentions of saloons, alcohol, drinking, drunks, & temperance laws (also including a man saying he’s been drinking since he was ten and trying to fight the addiction); Mentions of cigars, tobacco, & smoking; Mentions of grief (parents, mother, sister, wife, other family members) & guilt over deaths; Mentions of nightmares (including ones of being attacked and threatened, barely-above-not-detailed); Mentions of lies, lying, liars, & deceit; Mentions of gossip, rumors, & eavesdropping; Mentions of slaughterhouses & pigs going to the slaughter pins (barely-above-not-detailed); Mentions of a dead rodent & the smell (barely-above-not-detailed); A few mentions of President Lincoln’s funeral; A few mentions of bribes & dirty police officers; A few mentions of bar fights/brawls; A few mentions of throwing up; A few mentions of malnutrition; A few mentions of hatred; A few mentions of jealousy; A couple mentions of a family’s infants/children dying young; A couple mentions of malaria & a death; A couple mentions of a jail & prisoners; A couple mentions of hunting & hunters; A couple mentions of boys messing with & trying to kill a tarantula; A mention of a doctor being killing for helping another man; A mention of a young man wanting to kill his father because of the way he and his mother were treated by him; A mention of diarrhea; A mention of manure;
*Note: Mentions of prejudices (towards the poor, the religious, & Indians/Native Americans and someone’s possible prejudice towards interracial marriages); Mentions of books (A couple of Charles Dickens’ books, Julius Caesar, and Little Women).
Sexual Content- Three hand kisses (one unwanted), a cheek kiss, four head/forehead kisses, two barely-above-not-detailed kisses, and a border-line barely-above-not-detailed // semi-detailed kiss; Recalling kisses (barely-above-not-detailed); A mention of a young man staring at Whimsy’s lips; Touches, Embraces, Hand holding, Warmth, & Butterflies (barely-above-not-detailed); Wanting to embrace; Blushes; Noticing, Nearness, & Smelling (barely-above-not-detailed); Whimsy makes a promise to be with a young man while she’s uncertain about her feelings for him; Whimsy lies to her cousin about a boy & being interested in him (twice); Mentions of mean leering at Whimsy and other young women with wolfish stares; Mentions of kisses & couples kissing; Mentions of blushes, crushes, flirting, & a flirt; Mentions of chaperones & reputations (Whimsy thinks often that her mother wouldn’t like her being alone with a young man); Mentions of girls giggling & staring at a young man; A couple mentions of jealousy; Love, wondering if she’s in love, falling in love, & the emotions;
*Note: A mention of women wearing dresses that hug their curves; A mention of a neckline of a dress possibly being “too liberal” in a land full of men.
-Whimsy Greathart, age 16-17
1st person P.O.V. of Whimsy
Set in 1871-1872 (Epilogue in 1873)
372 pages
~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
Pre Teens- One Star
New Teens- Two Stars
Early High School Teens- Four Stars
Older High School Teens- Four Stars
My personal Rating- Four Stars
{Might be a hard (or possible comforting) read for girls who have lost their parents}
The sigh of happy relief I did once finishing this novel was probably heard a couple states over.
What can I say? Love triangles make me nervous. And this one definitely did.
Going back a bit, the beginning of this story really reminded me of an American Girl historical novel. I can’t place why exactly, because it was much better written, but perhaps because of the historical setting and this being one of the few Historical YA novels I’ve seen in the Christian Fiction genre?
This novel is broken up into four parts and spans over a year in total. Which felt very realistic for all the things Whimsy goes through and has to learn. The last part really reminded me of a Janette Oke novel, with Whimsy having to learn and own up to her actions and past lies.
On Whimsy, I really liked her and was honestly brought to tears at some points and events. I love her name, but also her compassion. I will admit that she frustrated and stressed me out at times because of her decisions, but every time was a learning experience for her and to help her grow. I have to find those parts relatable and wonder if the Lord’s felt the same way with me a times. (Sorry, Lord!) I also really liked the writing style and how different events or emotions were described.
Back to the love triangle, not to sound dramatic or anything, but it was literally killing me. Okay, obviously not actually killing me, but it felt like it was for a chunk of the book. Those who enjoy love triangles will probably enjoy this element, but even me (the not-a-fan-of-love-triangles-tropes-because-I-hate-someone-to-be-dissappointed-and-hurt) thoroughly got involved into that element and was (very thankfully) satisfied at the ending. But, again, I did a sigh of (happy) relief when finishing this novel. I’m very curious about the next book in the series as it will be about a side character we met towards the end of this book and plan to anticipate reading it.
Link to review:
https://booksforchristiangirls.blogsp...
*BFCG may (Read the review to see) recommend this book by this author. It does not mean I recommend all the books by this author.
*I received this book for free from the Author for this honest review.
December 18, 2025
“God will equip you to do whatever He has called you to do….Sometimes He wants us to set aside our own wants and desires to follow His leading. Our hearts can be deceitful in even the smallest areas of our lives.”
I really enjoyed this book! Great cast of characters, amazing character development for not only the protagonist but another character that I didn’t think would have changed like they did. The themes woven in here are seamless and I appreciated the way the author tied everything together by the end. At first I thought this would surely be 4 stars but everything came together beautifully and organically that I had to change my mind.
Highly recommend this to anyone who loves Christian historical fiction and YA historical fiction! I’m looking forward to when my Littles are older so I can make them read this book for homeschool! Until then, I’ll be recommending this to friends!
I’m so glad there’s gonna be more books in the series! 📚
I really enjoyed this book! Great cast of characters, amazing character development for not only the protagonist but another character that I didn’t think would have changed like they did. The themes woven in here are seamless and I appreciated the way the author tied everything together by the end. At first I thought this would surely be 4 stars but everything came together beautifully and organically that I had to change my mind.
Highly recommend this to anyone who loves Christian historical fiction and YA historical fiction! I’m looking forward to when my Littles are older so I can make them read this book for homeschool! Until then, I’ll be recommending this to friends!
I’m so glad there’s gonna be more books in the series! 📚
February 12, 2022
This story gripped me from page one. Daniels whisked me away to 1871 Chicago and the great fire that ravished the city. But that was just the start. Whimsy's life is turned upside down, and her strength through adversity is inspiring. The characters were multi-dimensional, and the writing was so engaging that I would continually tell myself, "This is the last chapter for today," and then I'd keep on reading! Fascinating, inspirational, and very entertaining. I'm so glad I've discovered this new author and can't wait to see what she writes next.
January 26, 2022
Riveting.
November 21, 2022
Bravo! Wonderful debut for this author. I would highly recommend for Young Adults and Adults alike (full-fledged adult here adored the story). It takes a gift to make the reader fall in love with the direction of the story, change the direction and somehow manage to carry the reader with you. This author did this multiple times and because her characters were so well written, I was right there with them. Whimsy lived through many trials in this story, and God's goodness was seeded in throughout in a very natural way. And the last third?! I couldn't flip the pages fast enough.
And the best news? There will be another book in this series. I can't wait to journey further in this story world :)
And the best news? There will be another book in this series. I can't wait to journey further in this story world :)
April 16, 2022
This story had me hooked from the first paragraph and I could not read it fast enough! It's set during and after the Chicago fires in the 1870s. Although I know about the fires, I haven't read any books that's storyline took place during them. Learning some of the history surrounding the fires was interesting and also heartbreaking.
I loved all the characters (even the ones who weren't so likable). There is great character development and poor Whimsy endures so much as she learns to build a life after everything she loves is ripped away from her.
I highly recommend this and am so excited to read the next in the series!
I loved all the characters (even the ones who weren't so likable). There is great character development and poor Whimsy endures so much as she learns to build a life after everything she loves is ripped away from her.
I highly recommend this and am so excited to read the next in the series!
February 9, 2023
Update after reading in paperback: Thoroughly enjoyed experiencing the story again with my preteen. Sparked some good discussions and kept her interest throughout.
This debut YA historical from Stephanie Daniels is currently being released on Kindle Vella, but I was fortunate enough to receive an advance copy from the author. All opinions are my own.
The settings of this story are intriguing and well-researched. I appreciated the attention to historical detail and how it was woven into the story (not given as a history lesson). However the greatest strength of this book is the incredibly memorable characters. I kept thinking about them long after I finished the book, wondering what would happen next in their lives. Each character stood out distinct from the others and bursting with their own story to tell and secrets to learn. Daniels shines as an immersive and captivating storyteller, and followers of The Uncertainty of Fire will not be disappointed.
This book presents several biblical themes without being preachy or heavy-handed. The characters learn through their mistakes, failures, and victories. It is wholesome YA reading with a little light (clean) romance. I plan to read it with my preteen daughter soon, but the story certainly held my attention as an adult reader as well. Good family-friendly fiction!
This debut YA historical from Stephanie Daniels is currently being released on Kindle Vella, but I was fortunate enough to receive an advance copy from the author. All opinions are my own.
The settings of this story are intriguing and well-researched. I appreciated the attention to historical detail and how it was woven into the story (not given as a history lesson). However the greatest strength of this book is the incredibly memorable characters. I kept thinking about them long after I finished the book, wondering what would happen next in their lives. Each character stood out distinct from the others and bursting with their own story to tell and secrets to learn. Daniels shines as an immersive and captivating storyteller, and followers of The Uncertainty of Fire will not be disappointed.
This book presents several biblical themes without being preachy or heavy-handed. The characters learn through their mistakes, failures, and victories. It is wholesome YA reading with a little light (clean) romance. I plan to read it with my preteen daughter soon, but the story certainly held my attention as an adult reader as well. Good family-friendly fiction!
January 12, 2023
This book destroyed me...in the way only a good book can.
I was not expecting this book to be so intense, with so many plot twists, and second guessing myself on which way the story would end up going...since it is YA. But, wow! Talk about suspense and torture at the hands of words.
Whimsy Greatheart was a very well developed character and portrayed perfectly as a 16-year-old. The first person POV made me able to get right into her head and I related with her on many levels. Her character arc was something I watched develop with great anticipation, wondering how she would adjust to all the tragic changes in her life, what choices she would make, whether she would follow her heart or God.
The beginning kept my attention with the event of the Great Chicago Fire. I had not anticipated it being so personally tragic for poor Whimsy, but it made for the amazing story The Uncertainty of Fire is. I was intrigued by Keller, loved the Bradshaws. They were all characters that stick with you.
When Whimsy goes to live with her aunt and uncle, however, I felt like the story started to drag a little at times, despite the dangers and suspenseful scenarios. It definitely plays a big part in the story though. I was happy when she and Keller ran into each other again, and I liked the way he protected her.
But then when Whimsy is rescued from that dangerous life she had to live for 4 months and comes to live with the Bradshaws again, I was ripped down the center not knowing what I wanted to happen. Collin was a dear and I loved his heart, his love for the Lord. But Keller...
I was quite delightfully surprised by a plot twist that takes place during this time as well. A miracle, along with a great story of forgiveness.
Oh, but then when it came time for Whimsy to keep a promise she'd made with Keller I don't know for sure if I was disappointed or excited for her. It didn't take long after her arrival in Arizona territory, however that I knew how I wanted it to turn out.
Great lessons are portrayed through this time. Like following the Lord and seeking his will and direction rather than following our own heart. And the importance of making sure the one you marry is without a doubt the person God has for you. Ah, I was so relieved when Whimsy finally paid attention to her discomfited stomach and saw the truth of the situation. And without saying too much to spoil everything, let me just say that in just a short time later I found myself tearing up right along with Whimsy's sobbing. I thought for sure everything was over.😭 But then...then, the beauty, the tenderness. Ahhh, it couldn't have ended more perfectly, the story told more amazingly.
Yes, it was a frustrating love triangle at times, but I feel like it is a great story for young adult readers to see how important it is to be sure about the man you're marrying and the importance to seek God in every life decision. The romance is tender, gentle, and does not go into deep character detail. I read this book on KU to see what it'd be like, but I am for sure buying a copy for my sister to read now.
I definitely recommend this book!
I was not expecting this book to be so intense, with so many plot twists, and second guessing myself on which way the story would end up going...since it is YA. But, wow! Talk about suspense and torture at the hands of words.
Whimsy Greatheart was a very well developed character and portrayed perfectly as a 16-year-old. The first person POV made me able to get right into her head and I related with her on many levels. Her character arc was something I watched develop with great anticipation, wondering how she would adjust to all the tragic changes in her life, what choices she would make, whether she would follow her heart or God.
The beginning kept my attention with the event of the Great Chicago Fire. I had not anticipated it being so personally tragic for poor Whimsy, but it made for the amazing story The Uncertainty of Fire is. I was intrigued by Keller, loved the Bradshaws. They were all characters that stick with you.
When Whimsy goes to live with her aunt and uncle, however, I felt like the story started to drag a little at times, despite the dangers and suspenseful scenarios. It definitely plays a big part in the story though. I was happy when she and Keller ran into each other again, and I liked the way he protected her.
But then when Whimsy is rescued from that dangerous life she had to live for 4 months and comes to live with the Bradshaws again, I was ripped down the center not knowing what I wanted to happen. Collin was a dear and I loved his heart, his love for the Lord. But Keller...
I was quite delightfully surprised by a plot twist that takes place during this time as well. A miracle, along with a great story of forgiveness.
Oh, but then when it came time for Whimsy to keep a promise she'd made with Keller I don't know for sure if I was disappointed or excited for her. It didn't take long after her arrival in Arizona territory, however that I knew how I wanted it to turn out.
Great lessons are portrayed through this time. Like following the Lord and seeking his will and direction rather than following our own heart. And the importance of making sure the one you marry is without a doubt the person God has for you. Ah, I was so relieved when Whimsy finally paid attention to her discomfited stomach and saw the truth of the situation. And without saying too much to spoil everything, let me just say that in just a short time later I found myself tearing up right along with Whimsy's sobbing. I thought for sure everything was over.😭 But then...then, the beauty, the tenderness. Ahhh, it couldn't have ended more perfectly, the story told more amazingly.
Yes, it was a frustrating love triangle at times, but I feel like it is a great story for young adult readers to see how important it is to be sure about the man you're marrying and the importance to seek God in every life decision. The romance is tender, gentle, and does not go into deep character detail. I read this book on KU to see what it'd be like, but I am for sure buying a copy for my sister to read now.
I definitely recommend this book!
August 9, 2024
4.25, I think. It was better than a 4.
I had high hopes for this book! I was pumped when I saw it at a library!! It met a lot of my expectations.
Okay, let’s start with the fact that this is Christian historical fiction, but for teens. I feel like that’s not super common. It takes place during and after the Chicago Fire in 1871. Her family dies tragically and she’s left alone. But, not for long.
The lessons Whimsy learned are very relatable for teens I feel like. My heart hurt to see her follow her heart, but go against God’s will. It frustrated me! You can tell when she made those rash decisions her relationship with God suffered. But, she learns and grows through it.
There was actually a little more romance than I was expecting. There was a love triangle…that’s always ruff to read through. But, I read the blurb for the next book and knew who she would end up with…and it was pretty obvious half way through.
I liked Keller, but he needs some working on. Character development. So, I’m glad we get to see him in the next book. Actually can not wait for the second book!!
Colin was so sweet. He had a strong faith, which is what Whimsy needed.
It’s very clean, but the majority of the book is her trying to figure out who the right guy is…kinda. Other things happen, but they didn’t seem to have as much of an impact, maybe, idk.
The redemption arc with Mattie M was so cool. That was well done. Not sure what I thought about him in Arizona…maybe we’ll see more of him in later books???
Little things that I was kinda like meh, but enjoyed most of it. Especially the end…actually it kinda broke my heart open!! But it was so good! The way the author tied the fire into the end was a good full circle effect!
The writing was very well done. It drew me into the story and was hard to put down. We need more books like this on the YA market!
I had high hopes for this book! I was pumped when I saw it at a library!! It met a lot of my expectations.
Okay, let’s start with the fact that this is Christian historical fiction, but for teens. I feel like that’s not super common. It takes place during and after the Chicago Fire in 1871. Her family dies tragically and she’s left alone. But, not for long.
The lessons Whimsy learned are very relatable for teens I feel like. My heart hurt to see her follow her heart, but go against God’s will. It frustrated me! You can tell when she made those rash decisions her relationship with God suffered. But, she learns and grows through it.
There was actually a little more romance than I was expecting. There was a love triangle…that’s always ruff to read through. But, I read the blurb for the next book and knew who she would end up with…and it was pretty obvious half way through.
I liked Keller, but he needs some working on. Character development. So, I’m glad we get to see him in the next book. Actually can not wait for the second book!!
Colin was so sweet. He had a strong faith, which is what Whimsy needed.
It’s very clean, but the majority of the book is her trying to figure out who the right guy is…kinda. Other things happen, but they didn’t seem to have as much of an impact, maybe, idk.
The redemption arc with Mattie M was so cool. That was well done. Not sure what I thought about him in Arizona…maybe we’ll see more of him in later books???
Little things that I was kinda like meh, but enjoyed most of it. Especially the end…actually it kinda broke my heart open!! But it was so good! The way the author tied the fire into the end was a good full circle effect!
The writing was very well done. It drew me into the story and was hard to put down. We need more books like this on the YA market!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
September 7, 2024
the uncertainty of fire
3 ✨
overview: the main character is such a main character.
characters: while Whimsy’s mental struggles were relatable and understandable, and she was having a rough time, sometimes I found her self-centered, presumptive, and a bit superior. It was definitely part of her character development, but I just couldn’t connect to her fully. Also this girl was STOOPID 😭😭😭 there was SO much miscommunication just because of her stupidity.
The love interests were both sweet, but one of them made a certain comment and I immediately knew he wasn’t the one lol. Plus he started to annoy me towards the end.
I love the reverend, his wife, and a certain bully-turned-Christian’s characters.
romance: TRIGGER WARNING!!! It’s a love triangle 😭 I didn’t know that going into it, but I didn’t hate it like others I’ve read. I knew who she was gonna end up with, so whenever Whimsy interacted with the other boy, it seemed like a waste of time lol.
It got to the point that I was so annoyed by how she was dragging the other one on + she got her happy ending without really even caring about others to an extent… it was like “oh yeah sorry! Gonna go get married now that I’ve seen the error of my ways!” Like no.
The lil romance was sweet! I enjoyed how patient, long suffering, and encouraging the endgame love interest was. Sometimes I really felt that Whimsy really didn’t deserve him lol.
writing: easy to read, thoughtful, and potentially emotional. I appreciate the inclusion of spiritually struggling, faith aspects, forgiveness, and moving on.
atmosphere: the slums in the dead of winter, a grand house tinged with flames, the past catching up with you, a little civilization in Arizona, the blush of a tanned cheek.
season: all seasons but primarily autumn.
———
content: language (n/a). sexual (innocent touches, kisses). other (bullying, fighting, people dying in a fire (no details), being orphaned, child labor).
———
💌PS (I LOVE YOU)
— Kirsten <3
3 ✨
overview: the main character is such a main character.
characters: while Whimsy’s mental struggles were relatable and understandable, and she was having a rough time, sometimes I found her self-centered, presumptive, and a bit superior. It was definitely part of her character development, but I just couldn’t connect to her fully. Also this girl was STOOPID 😭😭😭 there was SO much miscommunication just because of her stupidity.
The love interests were both sweet, but one of them made a certain comment and I immediately knew he wasn’t the one lol. Plus he started to annoy me towards the end.
I love the reverend, his wife, and a certain bully-turned-Christian’s characters.
romance: TRIGGER WARNING!!! It’s a love triangle 😭 I didn’t know that going into it, but I didn’t hate it like others I’ve read. I knew who she was gonna end up with, so whenever Whimsy interacted with the other boy, it seemed like a waste of time lol.
It got to the point that I was so annoyed by how she was dragging the other one on + she got her happy ending without really even caring about others to an extent… it was like “oh yeah sorry! Gonna go get married now that I’ve seen the error of my ways!” Like no.
The lil romance was sweet! I enjoyed how patient, long suffering, and encouraging the endgame love interest was. Sometimes I really felt that Whimsy really didn’t deserve him lol.
writing: easy to read, thoughtful, and potentially emotional. I appreciate the inclusion of spiritually struggling, faith aspects, forgiveness, and moving on.
atmosphere: the slums in the dead of winter, a grand house tinged with flames, the past catching up with you, a little civilization in Arizona, the blush of a tanned cheek.
season: all seasons but primarily autumn.
———
content: language (n/a). sexual (innocent touches, kisses). other (bullying, fighting, people dying in a fire (no details), being orphaned, child labor).
———
💌PS (I LOVE YOU)
— Kirsten <3
May 1, 2023
Sixteen-year-old Whimsey's life will never be the same after the Chicago fire. Her life of privilege governed by high-society rules doesn't make her any safer than a common newsboy when flames ravage the city. Surviving the fire doesn't mean survival is always easy afterwards. Whimsey faces an ugly side of Chicago life up close. Whimsey also learns a hard lesson about honesty and love.
As the author continues to work on the series, could I request that we hear Bessie's continued story at some point? :)
As the author continues to work on the series, could I request that we hear Bessie's continued story at some point? :)
April 19, 2022
A Wonderful Story with a Christian Influence
4/2022
There is so much I want to say, but I don't want to spoil anything for new readers. I loved watching Whimsey grow each episode through the struggles she has to face. And she never does it alone, praying for guidance every step of the way (or at least she tries to). I won't say which one of the handsome young men she ends up with, but I will say I was VERY happy with her choice. I can't wait to see what else Ms. Daniels has up her sleeve.
****
8/2021
I'm still reading this one, but so far Ms. Daniels has captivated my attention with her characters and the story she is weaving (based on a true event). I can feel the flames burning from my phone as I read and I can't wait to see what happens next. And if that wasn't enough for me to love it, the message of faith rings clear in my heart. Wonderfully done!
4/2022
There is so much I want to say, but I don't want to spoil anything for new readers. I loved watching Whimsey grow each episode through the struggles she has to face. And she never does it alone, praying for guidance every step of the way (or at least she tries to). I won't say which one of the handsome young men she ends up with, but I will say I was VERY happy with her choice. I can't wait to see what else Ms. Daniels has up her sleeve.
****
8/2021
I'm still reading this one, but so far Ms. Daniels has captivated my attention with her characters and the story she is weaving (based on a true event). I can feel the flames burning from my phone as I read and I can't wait to see what happens next. And if that wasn't enough for me to love it, the message of faith rings clear in my heart. Wonderfully done!
May 19, 2023
⭐⭐⭐⭐ - 4 stars
About the book:
“What price will she pay for following her heart?
Chicago, 1871. Sixteen-year-old Whimsy Greathart would rather fight against Chicago’s child labor practices than attend her privileged family’s high society events. And a very public social blunder only strengthens her resolve to use her influence for good.
On the night of the Great Chicago Fire, her tenderhearted choice leads her into danger and results in life-changing consequences.
With her world turned to ash, she must rely on the mercy of poor relations to rebuild her future and is forced into the very labor system she wished to fight against. As Whimsy staggers under the weight of street gang violence and hazardous working conditions, a chance at deliverance persuades her to make a promise. One she intends to keep. But now she must determine whether it’s God’s heart she’s following or her own.”
Series: Book #1 in the “Uncertain Riches” series.
This book was awesome! Personally speaking, I am not a huge fan of historical fiction. However, this book was intriguing and held my attention. If I have to learn about history I would prefer to do it this way. Reading an historical fiction book just like this.
When I started the book I had forgotten about the love triangle and was surprised when two entirely different young men came into the picture. This love triangle made me nervous. You do not want to know how I acted towards Whimsy when she was making some decisions. I could clearly see who was meant for her, yet she could not. How agitating is that?
I will also mention that this book did bring tears to my eyes. This was a satisfying read and anyone who likes historical ya fiction should enjoy this book. (This world really needs more historical ya christian fiction. Anyone up for the challenge?)
About the book:
“What price will she pay for following her heart?
Chicago, 1871. Sixteen-year-old Whimsy Greathart would rather fight against Chicago’s child labor practices than attend her privileged family’s high society events. And a very public social blunder only strengthens her resolve to use her influence for good.
On the night of the Great Chicago Fire, her tenderhearted choice leads her into danger and results in life-changing consequences.
With her world turned to ash, she must rely on the mercy of poor relations to rebuild her future and is forced into the very labor system she wished to fight against. As Whimsy staggers under the weight of street gang violence and hazardous working conditions, a chance at deliverance persuades her to make a promise. One she intends to keep. But now she must determine whether it’s God’s heart she’s following or her own.”
Series: Book #1 in the “Uncertain Riches” series.
This book was awesome! Personally speaking, I am not a huge fan of historical fiction. However, this book was intriguing and held my attention. If I have to learn about history I would prefer to do it this way. Reading an historical fiction book just like this.
When I started the book I had forgotten about the love triangle and was surprised when two entirely different young men came into the picture. This love triangle made me nervous. You do not want to know how I acted towards Whimsy when she was making some decisions. I could clearly see who was meant for her, yet she could not. How agitating is that?
I will also mention that this book did bring tears to my eyes. This was a satisfying read and anyone who likes historical ya fiction should enjoy this book. (This world really needs more historical ya christian fiction. Anyone up for the challenge?)
January 30, 2025
I loved this book so much. Going into it, I didn't know if I was going to enjoy it as much as I wanted to. It did not disappoint!
*sigh* the love triangle. I can't. This was a doozy of a triangle but also SO awesome! It kept me on my toes wondering which boy I wanted to win and I agreed with Whimsy throughout most of the book that "my heart drifted closer to whichever boy happened to be near." Mmm so true lol. So it was a hard triangle but also a great one. And I was satisfied with the ending which (going into it knowing which boy was going to win unfortunately) I didn't think I was going to be. I think the author did us a solid in making the boy who won clearly the best choice in the end.
And this brings me to the fact that if you don't want the love triangle spoiled for you don't (DON'T!) get giddy about book number two and read the blurb about it in the back. It gives it away. Yeah . . . I did that. But I'm so glad the boy who lost gets a second chance it book two! Can't wait for that.
The characters in this book were amazing. I loved Whimsy, both her awesome name and her sweet personality. I genuinely felt so sorry for her with all her hard love-triangle predicaments that she got into. But so satisfied with the outcome.
The boys (THE BOYS). I loved them both. Honestly newsboy Keller was like my favorite person in the world while I was reading the book lol. And oh, Colin was so adorable. His shyness and sweetness were killing me.
I loved the faith aspect and also the real hardships that people went through. Sure, some of it felt a little like: Hmm, I don't know if that's how it actually would've went down. But I easily got over that cuz the book was so good.
I don't think I truly realized how much I loved this book until I wrote this review lol.
*sigh* the love triangle. I can't. This was a doozy of a triangle but also SO awesome! It kept me on my toes wondering which boy I wanted to win and I agreed with Whimsy throughout most of the book that "my heart drifted closer to whichever boy happened to be near." Mmm so true lol. So it was a hard triangle but also a great one. And I was satisfied with the ending which (going into it knowing which boy was going to win unfortunately) I didn't think I was going to be. I think the author did us a solid in making the boy who won clearly the best choice in the end.
And this brings me to the fact that if you don't want the love triangle spoiled for you don't (DON'T!) get giddy about book number two and read the blurb about it in the back. It gives it away. Yeah . . . I did that. But I'm so glad the boy who lost gets a second chance it book two! Can't wait for that.
The characters in this book were amazing. I loved Whimsy, both her awesome name and her sweet personality. I genuinely felt so sorry for her with all her hard love-triangle predicaments that she got into. But so satisfied with the outcome.
The boys (THE BOYS). I loved them both. Honestly newsboy Keller was like my favorite person in the world while I was reading the book lol. And oh, Colin was so adorable. His shyness and sweetness were killing me.
I loved the faith aspect and also the real hardships that people went through. Sure, some of it felt a little like: Hmm, I don't know if that's how it actually would've went down. But I easily got over that cuz the book was so good.
I don't think I truly realized how much I loved this book until I wrote this review lol.
November 18, 2023
A Masterful Weave
I’m not always a fan of religious Christian fiction because despite being a dedicated Christian, the fiction associated with the genre often feels trite. But this was the opposite. It was openly and unapologetically religious; God was a major part of the main characters’ lives. It showcases the main character’s struggle to understand how to follow Him. It’s really not always clear in reality. But like in reality, God comes through despite and through the struggles, to teach you what really matters, and to show you your heart.
So this is probably the most realistically religious work of Christian fiction I’ve read.
But it’s not just religious; it’s well-written and enjoyable. Being historical fiction, the history and story integrate well. There is no shoehorning of one into the other. I don’t normally enjoy historical fiction, but I devoured this.
I wasn’t sure that one particular tragic event was necessary or lent much to the overall storyline, but it wasn’t central to it either and didn’t wholly detract.
I love the themes of redemption and grief and especially forgiveness. Having had to learn to forgive the murderer of a family member myself, I appreciated this theme especially.
I look forward to seeing what else Author Daniels creates in the future. In the meantime, I’ll solidly add this to my recommended list.
(Conservatively recommend for ages 14+. Contains themes of courtship and controlled, appropriate romance, and moderate but overall non-graphic violence.)
I’m not always a fan of religious Christian fiction because despite being a dedicated Christian, the fiction associated with the genre often feels trite. But this was the opposite. It was openly and unapologetically religious; God was a major part of the main characters’ lives. It showcases the main character’s struggle to understand how to follow Him. It’s really not always clear in reality. But like in reality, God comes through despite and through the struggles, to teach you what really matters, and to show you your heart.
So this is probably the most realistically religious work of Christian fiction I’ve read.
But it’s not just religious; it’s well-written and enjoyable. Being historical fiction, the history and story integrate well. There is no shoehorning of one into the other. I don’t normally enjoy historical fiction, but I devoured this.
I wasn’t sure that one particular tragic event was necessary or lent much to the overall storyline, but it wasn’t central to it either and didn’t wholly detract.
I love the themes of redemption and grief and especially forgiveness. Having had to learn to forgive the murderer of a family member myself, I appreciated this theme especially.
I look forward to seeing what else Author Daniels creates in the future. In the meantime, I’ll solidly add this to my recommended list.
(Conservatively recommend for ages 14+. Contains themes of courtship and controlled, appropriate romance, and moderate but overall non-graphic violence.)
February 16, 2023
The Uncertainty of Fire by Stephanie Daniels is a historical fiction Christian romance
Age: middle grade, YA, new adult
Theme: following your heart versus following God
I loved this book! The history and romance were well incorporated, yet the story and the message took center stage. The characters were relatible, realistic, and likable (even ones who weren't so nice). The story was perfectly paced, exciting, deep, well thought-out, and just so good! I couldn't stop reading.
The message and spiritual aspects filled the pages yet were written in such a realistic, relatible way that you understood them in an applicable way. The message is so, so important, and the way this book handles it shows just how destructive following your heart can be.
I usually think love triangles are so predictable and unrealistic, but this one was totally different. Usually one guy ends up being a complete jerk, but neither was in this book.
I so appreciated that Whimsy realized how good her parents were to her.
I love that this book made me happy, sad, mad, afraid, and made me want to make sure to live by its lesson.
Overall, this is a really great book and everyone should read it.
Age: middle grade, YA, new adult
Theme: following your heart versus following God
I loved this book! The history and romance were well incorporated, yet the story and the message took center stage. The characters were relatible, realistic, and likable (even ones who weren't so nice). The story was perfectly paced, exciting, deep, well thought-out, and just so good! I couldn't stop reading.
The message and spiritual aspects filled the pages yet were written in such a realistic, relatible way that you understood them in an applicable way. The message is so, so important, and the way this book handles it shows just how destructive following your heart can be.
I usually think love triangles are so predictable and unrealistic, but this one was totally different. Usually one guy ends up being a complete jerk, but neither was in this book.
I so appreciated that Whimsy realized how good her parents were to her.
I love that this book made me happy, sad, mad, afraid, and made me want to make sure to live by its lesson.
Overall, this is a really great book and everyone should read it.
April 24, 2024
A great read!
Sometimes when you read a novel, you can picture what it would be like as a movie. In this case, "The Uncertainty of Fire" would be a sweeping saga, spotlighting two years of history through the eyes and experiences of a young teenager whose life is deeply affected both by tragic events unique to her time, and also by her own rash decisions, often dictated by fear and the need to survive.
With careful attention to historical accuracy, the author tells an engaging story that covers many themes- grief, friendship, romance, faith and forgiveness, to name a few. The characters are well-developed and "real", so much so that I had to remind myself that one in particular was fictional and I didn't need to actually pray for him!
In my opinion, this book is not only a wonderful read for a Young Adult audience, but also for any adult who enjoys a good escape into the past, revealed from a Christian perspective. I look forward to reading the next book in this series!
Sometimes when you read a novel, you can picture what it would be like as a movie. In this case, "The Uncertainty of Fire" would be a sweeping saga, spotlighting two years of history through the eyes and experiences of a young teenager whose life is deeply affected both by tragic events unique to her time, and also by her own rash decisions, often dictated by fear and the need to survive.
With careful attention to historical accuracy, the author tells an engaging story that covers many themes- grief, friendship, romance, faith and forgiveness, to name a few. The characters are well-developed and "real", so much so that I had to remind myself that one in particular was fictional and I didn't need to actually pray for him!
In my opinion, this book is not only a wonderful read for a Young Adult audience, but also for any adult who enjoys a good escape into the past, revealed from a Christian perspective. I look forward to reading the next book in this series!
October 6, 2022
The Uncertainty of Fire is a story full of excitement and intrigue wrapped around a well-written and researched story based on events that happened during and after the great Chicago fire of 1871. The story follows Whimsy, a young woman with a compassionate heart who faces unthinkable trials.
The characters are rich and well developed and easy to love – or hate depending on the character.
Once you start, be prepared to find it difficult to put the book down without blazing your way through the entire book to find out what happens. Whimsy’s life takes so many twists and turns you’re never quite sure what might happen next.
While there is heartbreak, there is also hope, healing, and joy.
Daniels does an amazing job pulling you into the story and never letting you go. I’m looking forward to her next book, which I’m sure will be just as enthralling as this first one.
The characters are rich and well developed and easy to love – or hate depending on the character.
Once you start, be prepared to find it difficult to put the book down without blazing your way through the entire book to find out what happens. Whimsy’s life takes so many twists and turns you’re never quite sure what might happen next.
While there is heartbreak, there is also hope, healing, and joy.
Daniels does an amazing job pulling you into the story and never letting you go. I’m looking forward to her next book, which I’m sure will be just as enthralling as this first one.
January 1, 2026
What a fantastic book! The whole thing blew me away! Stephanie Daniels' writing is so immersive and I felt so caught up in the historical time frame of it. The characters and conflicts were so real and I gladly jostled and bumped through each adventure right alongside the character. The themes here are spot on but it wasn't preachy (in my opinion). This book had me thinking of my own relationship with God and encouraged me to follow Him and trust Him in everything. All in all, a wonderful read and I can't wait to read the next book!
August 4, 2025
I don't know how I missed leaving an official review when the book first released, but it's a book I think about often. I was struck by the unpredictable story ... and a particular handsome hero that stole my heart the moment I meant him.
There's lots of depth, history, tender romance, inspiring theme, and a truly unpredictable story. If you want a fresh take on Christian romance (that's perfectly safe for the teens!) romance, give Stephanie Daniels a try!
There's lots of depth, history, tender romance, inspiring theme, and a truly unpredictable story. If you want a fresh take on Christian romance (that's perfectly safe for the teens!) romance, give Stephanie Daniels a try!
September 21, 2025
The Uncertainty of Fire Content Warnings and Review
The Toe Beans:
🤐 Language: none
💋 Romantic Content: Three nondescript hand kisses (one is unwanted); One nondescript cheek kiss; Four nondescript four head kisses; Three nondescript kisses; A short/nondescript mention of women that weren’t wearing corsets (appropriate for ages 13+)
⚔️ Violence:Fire; mentions of dead bodies; malnutrition; one fistfight; Whimsy has a knife held to her throat once; passing out; orphans; child labor; a woman is murdered by a man because she didn’t marry him; Whimsy wishes a man would die (she later regrets this, and asks the Lord for forgiveness); mentions of riots; someone gets stabbed; stitches; death; blood; mention of someone wishing to watch another person get hanged (appropriate for 14+)
👻 Spiritual Content: Prayer; Verses are quoted; The main characters read their Bibles; Church; Hymns; Many mentions of God’s will; Blessing their food; Asking God for forgiveness; Baptists are called “dippers” because they are “the ones who say you gotta get dunked underwater”; A mention of some countries thinking that being left-handed is demonic; A mention of a spiritualist’s candlelit skull
⭐️ Other Content Considerations: Saloons; Beer; A man gets saved he says that he’s been drinking since he was ten but he is trying to fight the addiction; Tobacco; Smoking
🧑🧑🧒🧒 Age Rating: 14/15+
The Tale:
OH. MY. GRACIOUS. THIS. BOOK!
If I could give this book 100 stars I 100% would (Why Goodreads doesn’t have a 100 star option, I’ll never know) The plot was amazing. The characters were so, so, so lovable. The Christian elements were so sweet. This book was literally amazing!
My Top reasons for ADORING this book:
6. The wonderful research that went into it!
5. The Bible verses are from the KJV!!! *squeals of delight*
4. It tells you NOT to follow your heart and follow God’s instead. (Amen!)
3. The new found family. *sob* *sob* *soooooob* (IT’S SOOO SWEET)
2. It’s very, very, clean!
1. COLIN! (AGGGGGH! COLIN! HOW CAN YOU JUST NOT LOVE HIM?! I mean comon’… As soon as Whimsy regained consciousness he offered her a book!!! AGGGGGGGGH! BEST MMC EVER!!!!!!)
The Toe Beans:
🤐 Language: none
💋 Romantic Content: Three nondescript hand kisses (one is unwanted); One nondescript cheek kiss; Four nondescript four head kisses; Three nondescript kisses; A short/nondescript mention of women that weren’t wearing corsets (appropriate for ages 13+)
⚔️ Violence:Fire; mentions of dead bodies; malnutrition; one fistfight; Whimsy has a knife held to her throat once; passing out; orphans; child labor; a woman is murdered by a man because she didn’t marry him; Whimsy wishes a man would die (she later regrets this, and asks the Lord for forgiveness); mentions of riots; someone gets stabbed; stitches; death; blood; mention of someone wishing to watch another person get hanged (appropriate for 14+)
👻 Spiritual Content: Prayer; Verses are quoted; The main characters read their Bibles; Church; Hymns; Many mentions of God’s will; Blessing their food; Asking God for forgiveness; Baptists are called “dippers” because they are “the ones who say you gotta get dunked underwater”; A mention of some countries thinking that being left-handed is demonic; A mention of a spiritualist’s candlelit skull
⭐️ Other Content Considerations: Saloons; Beer; A man gets saved he says that he’s been drinking since he was ten but he is trying to fight the addiction; Tobacco; Smoking
🧑🧑🧒🧒 Age Rating: 14/15+
The Tale:
OH. MY. GRACIOUS. THIS. BOOK!
If I could give this book 100 stars I 100% would (Why Goodreads doesn’t have a 100 star option, I’ll never know) The plot was amazing. The characters were so, so, so lovable. The Christian elements were so sweet. This book was literally amazing!
My Top reasons for ADORING this book:
6. The wonderful research that went into it!
5. The Bible verses are from the KJV!!! *squeals of delight*
4. It tells you NOT to follow your heart and follow God’s instead. (Amen!)
3. The new found family. *sob* *sob* *soooooob* (IT’S SOOO SWEET)
2. It’s very, very, clean!
1. COLIN! (AGGGGGH! COLIN! HOW CAN YOU JUST NOT LOVE HIM?! I mean comon’… As soon as Whimsy regained consciousness he offered her a book!!! AGGGGGGGGH! BEST MMC EVER!!!!!!)
December 22, 2025
Bravo!!! A well-done YA historical fiction novel that captured my heart and gripped me all the way thru. Definitely a yes for my daughter to read once she’s about 16 (searching God’s will for her future mate is a big part of this story, but done very tastefully). Enjoyed the obvious historical research and spiritual truths as well.
My only complaint: I will never remember the name to recommend it to someone! Not a name that sticks with you. But the story will. 💕
Loved it 👍
My only complaint: I will never remember the name to recommend it to someone! Not a name that sticks with you. But the story will. 💕
Loved it 👍
November 17, 2023
I bought this book for my teen daughter and this is what she had to say after reading the book:
“I could not put this book down! Uncertainty of Fire is an amazing read. The plot is complex and well structured, but at the same time it’s not predictable or mechanical…The places and characters feel real. I would DEFINITELY recommend.”
“I could not put this book down! Uncertainty of Fire is an amazing read. The plot is complex and well structured, but at the same time it’s not predictable or mechanical…The places and characters feel real. I would DEFINITELY recommend.”
May 14, 2024
Wow! 🤩 I really wish there were more YA historical novels like this, the plot was great and the faith content was so good 😊💖💖💖 At first I didn’t care where the love triangle went but then after like 50% Keller started annoying me but I knew it would all turn out well. The ending felt I little rushed but an overall great read.
July 14, 2024
I absolutely devoured this book. It was so well written and I couldn’t predict anything. The Uncertainty of Fire has one of the best love triangles I’ve read in a long time. I couldn’t decide who I wanted Whimsy to end up with until almost the end. I look forward to reading whatever Stephanie writes next!
January 7, 2022
I love learning about real life events through fiction. Stephanie's writing is gripping and her characters will capture your heart. Be prepared to step back in time and be immersed in the history surrounding the Great Chicago Fire.
February 21, 2022
This was a sweet romance with lots of historical references. Whimsy’s development was so real and well-done. And the love triangle kept things even more interesting! But this story had a lot of heart as well as the the characters faced hard losses and tough decisions. If you like historical romance, then I recommend this story!
Read
December 12, 2022This was an excellent, clean book from start to finish. It takes place during the Great Chicago Fire where Whimsy Greatheart is caught in a love triangle amidst challenges of grief, hardship, and reliance on God. A very good read for ladies, young and old!
March 23, 2023
I thoroughly enjoyed this story. Whimsy was a fascinating character and I loved that I couldn't predict what would happen. This book is a romantic slow-burn, but mostly an adventure with a side of love triangle. Completely clean and sweet and appropriate for the most innocent of YA readers.
March 19, 2024
Wonderful book
What an unexpected gem! I stumbled upon a recommendation for this author on a FB site. She writes believable, vivid characters. You can tell she researched out the historical time period.
I am looking forward to any other books she writes.
What an unexpected gem! I stumbled upon a recommendation for this author on a FB site. She writes believable, vivid characters. You can tell she researched out the historical time period.
I am looking forward to any other books she writes.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 38 reviews