What do you think?
Rate this book
Worlds Collide Along the Shores of the Outer Banks
Immerse yourself in the “what if” questions related to the Lost Colony of Roanoke. What if an English boy and a native girl met in the wilderness? The push-and-pull between two very different worlds begins as one seeks simple friendship and the other struggles to trust. And can it—dare they—allow it to be more?
Sparks fly between Mushaniq, free-spirited daughter of Manteo, and Georgie Howe, whose father was brutally murdered by undiscovered native warriors before they’d been on Roanoac Island a full week. As Georgie struggles to make sense of his life and to accept that not all they call “savage” are guilty of his father’s death, Mushaniq grapples with her own questions about who Manteo has become. As tentative friendship becomes more, forged in the fire of calamity and attack upon their community, both must decide whether the One True God is indeed who He claims to be and whether He is worthy of their trust.
Author Shannon McNear portrays history with vivid authenticity.
Also of interest:
Elinor by Shannon McNear (Book 1 – Daughters of the Lost Colony)
Immerse yourself in the “what if” questions related to the Lost Colony of Roanoke. What if an English boy and a native girl met in the wilderness? The push-and-pull between two very different worlds begins as one seeks simple friendship and the other struggles to trust. And can it—dare they—allow it to be more?
Sparks fly between Mushaniq, free-spirited daughter of Manteo, and Georgie Howe, whose father was brutally murdered by undiscovered native warriors before they’d been on Roanoac Island a full week. As Georgie struggles to make sense of his life and to accept that not all they call “savage” are guilty of his father’s death, Mushaniq grapples with her own questions about who Manteo has become. As tentative friendship becomes more, forged in the fire of calamity and attack upon their community, both must decide whether the One True God is indeed who He claims to be and whether He is worthy of their trust.
Author Shannon McNear portrays history with vivid authenticity.
Also of interest:
Elinor by Shannon McNear (Book 1 – Daughters of the Lost Colony)
323 pages, Kindle Edition
First published October 1, 2022
13 people are currently reading
1092 people want to read
About the author
Shannon McNear
24 books969 followersShannon has been writing one thing or another since third grade and finished her first novel at age fifteen—but waited more than thirty years for her first book contract. In the meantime, she graduated from high school, attended college, met and married her husband, birthed nine children, lost one, taught five to drive, revised that first story innumerable times, and completed six others.
Her first published novella, Defending Truth, in A Pioneer Christmas Collection (Barbour, 2013 & 2015), was a 2014 RITA® nominee, and her most recent one, The Wise Guy and the Star in Love's Pure Light was a 2021 SELAH winner. She writes regularly for Colonial Quills, is a member of American Christian Fiction Writers and Faith-Hope-Love Christian Writers, and is represented by Tamela Hancock Murray of the Steve Laube Agency.
Transplanted to North Dakota after more than two decades in Charleston, South Carolina, she loves losing herself in local history. When this homeschooling mom isn't cooking, researching, or leaking story from her fingertips, she enjoys being outdoors, basking in the beauty of the northern prairies.
Her first published novella, Defending Truth, in A Pioneer Christmas Collection (Barbour, 2013 & 2015), was a 2014 RITA® nominee, and her most recent one, The Wise Guy and the Star in Love's Pure Light was a 2021 SELAH winner. She writes regularly for Colonial Quills, is a member of American Christian Fiction Writers and Faith-Hope-Love Christian Writers, and is represented by Tamela Hancock Murray of the Steve Laube Agency.
Transplanted to North Dakota after more than two decades in Charleston, South Carolina, she loves losing herself in local history. When this homeschooling mom isn't cooking, researching, or leaking story from her fingertips, she enjoys being outdoors, basking in the beauty of the northern prairies.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 96 reviews
March 11, 2024
This is an entertaining, well-written, well researched, historical fiction novel which describes what might have happened to the settlers of the lost colony of Roanoke. It vividly depicts fascinating Native American culture and customs, and has young love, faith, and a happily ever after ending. The author's notes are interesting and informative, and are truly appreciated. This is the second entry in Ms. McNear's outstanding Daughters of the Lost Colony series, and and it can be read as a stand alone, but it is even better when read after reading Elinor, whose timeline this story parallels. I am looking forward to reading the next entry in this series with great anticipation. I listened to the audio book, and the narrator, Ms. Lauren Ezzo, has a lovely voice and does an excellent job portraying the characters and their personalities.
October 23, 2022
Shannon McNear has the ability to craft a story rich in history. She deftly spins a tale of what could have happened to the Lost Colony of Roanoke, Virginia in the late 1500s. She reaches back in history and steeps the story in the traditions of native tribes of long ago as they interact with the colonists from England. It must have been so hard with the language barrier and the differing beliefs about God. But Ms McNear brings the past alive with the portrayal of English Georgie and Mushaniq, daughter of a chief.
The story parallels Elinor, the first book in the series, and fleshes out facts and tells the story from a different perspective. Ms. McNear captures the child like acceptance of faith in Christ by the natives. Her descriptions of a coming of age ceremony and a correlation to baptism is very well put.
An interesting custom was giving a milk name to an infant and the taking of an adult name when one was deemed grown-up enough. The conversion of Mushaniq/Mary was very moving.
This was an excellent foray into the distant past. It showed how faith was communicated long ago and how the truth of the Gospel remains.
Do we know what happened to the Lost Colony of Roanoke? No, but this author does a commendable job of: suppose it was this?
*I received a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour on behalf of the author and through Barbour Review Program. I was not required to post a favorable review. All opinions are my own.*
The story parallels Elinor, the first book in the series, and fleshes out facts and tells the story from a different perspective. Ms. McNear captures the child like acceptance of faith in Christ by the natives. Her descriptions of a coming of age ceremony and a correlation to baptism is very well put.
An interesting custom was giving a milk name to an infant and the taking of an adult name when one was deemed grown-up enough. The conversion of Mushaniq/Mary was very moving.
This was an excellent foray into the distant past. It showed how faith was communicated long ago and how the truth of the Gospel remains.
Do we know what happened to the Lost Colony of Roanoke? No, but this author does a commendable job of: suppose it was this?
*I received a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour on behalf of the author and through Barbour Review Program. I was not required to post a favorable review. All opinions are my own.*
August 15, 2023
My family and I recently visited the area this takes place in, the Lost Colony of Roanoke. Having read the book, I was excited to visit the area and see it for myself. As we walked along listening to our tour guide talking and explaining I had an even better understanding of it because of having read this exciting book. The author gives a vivid historical description of the going ons and the people of the area. A wonderful factual and fictional combination makes for an interesting read. The natives had a wonderful spiritual connection with the earth. Beautifully written and faith filled. The author has meticulously researched the book and I enjoyed it a lot.
Pub Date 01 Oct 2022
I was given a complimentary copy of this book.
All opinions expressed are my own.
Pub Date 01 Oct 2022
I was given a complimentary copy of this book.
All opinions expressed are my own.
October 2, 2022
This was certainly an amazing book. I couldn't help but keep reading and reading. The research that must have gone into this book would be quite difficult due to the early years in which it took place. There were many new words that I had to learn as I read the book with many checks to the glossary in the back.
The customs and the beliefs of the people were fascinating to read about. I really enjoy reading about history and especially the early history of our country. As Muschaniq hears of the One True God, how will she relate to this? Having read book 1, I was happy to see Elinor in this book. I love to see this type of continuity. This book is a reminder of how the early beginnings of our country were filled with danger as well as faith and trust in God. This is a fascinating book and well worth reading!
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour Publishing. All thoughts are my own.
The customs and the beliefs of the people were fascinating to read about. I really enjoy reading about history and especially the early history of our country. As Muschaniq hears of the One True God, how will she relate to this? Having read book 1, I was happy to see Elinor in this book. I love to see this type of continuity. This book is a reminder of how the early beginnings of our country were filled with danger as well as faith and trust in God. This is a fascinating book and well worth reading!
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour Publishing. All thoughts are my own.
October 16, 2022
Author Shannon McNear has discovered the perfect formula for penning historical fiction. Find an intriguing subject, do your research well, and then, add enough fiction to make it a story that readers can't put down! This is exactly what happens in Mary, the second book of her Daughters of the Lost Colony series. McNear takes us back to the Lost Roanoke colony, reunites us with characters we've already met, and introduces us to others who become just as endearing. Manteo is a native who's been introduced to the teachings of Christ, and his daughter Mushaniq sees the change that has occurred in her father. She also discovers young Georgie Howe. Is it possible that the friendship that blooms between them could deepen into something more? Is this why she changes her name to Mary?
I loved that McNear continues the story that began with Elinor and includes Sees Far and Georgie. She shares a deeper insight into the efforts of the colonists and the natives to live together peacefully. Will the struggle to preserve their heritage while being introduced to new beliefs help them find common ground, or are there too many differences between these two cultures? Can they accept that Mary and Georgie deserve a chance at happiness...together?
Mary is a well-developed story that will appeal to history lovers and fans of romance, and it ends with the hint of another book in the Daughters of the Lost Colony series. I recommend it to all who enjoy historical Christian romance.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour Publishing and was under no obligation to post a review.
I loved that McNear continues the story that began with Elinor and includes Sees Far and Georgie. She shares a deeper insight into the efforts of the colonists and the natives to live together peacefully. Will the struggle to preserve their heritage while being introduced to new beliefs help them find common ground, or are there too many differences between these two cultures? Can they accept that Mary and Georgie deserve a chance at happiness...together?
Mary is a well-developed story that will appeal to history lovers and fans of romance, and it ends with the hint of another book in the Daughters of the Lost Colony series. I recommend it to all who enjoy historical Christian romance.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour Publishing and was under no obligation to post a review.
August 14, 2022
I’ve gone on record as saying that I love stories set in the early days of settlement in America, especially the settlements of Roanoke. The daunting task of going to a land you do not know, learning how to co-exist with the indigenous peoples and the balancing of religious “freedom” with totalitarianism all make for such compelling stories. Last year McNear brought us the story of Elinor, daughter of the governor and her adjustment to the new land. We do get more of Elinor's story in this one, but I'll not go into detail so there are no spoilers but her story plays in well with Mary's.
This is the story of the settlers as they learn the harshness of the land and how to truly live with The People. This story explores the true mixing of the two peoples. How they spread Christianity (before the more oppressive missions) and how the groups considered inter-marriage. We see Manteo's daughter, Mushaniq, grow from a precocious young girl in her tribe to become friends with George Howe, a young English boy. The two fall in love and explore the rituals each group of people has in order to usher them into adulthood and to be worthy of marriage.
Mushaniq is a fabulous protagonist, she is strong willed and appreciative of her people and yet open to change and hope for what a woman could be. I liked the exploring of the politics between the people and the good and bad of religion guiding one's life choices.
Thanks to Barbour Publishing for access to this novel via Netgalley. All opinions above are my own.
This is the story of the settlers as they learn the harshness of the land and how to truly live with The People. This story explores the true mixing of the two peoples. How they spread Christianity (before the more oppressive missions) and how the groups considered inter-marriage. We see Manteo's daughter, Mushaniq, grow from a precocious young girl in her tribe to become friends with George Howe, a young English boy. The two fall in love and explore the rituals each group of people has in order to usher them into adulthood and to be worthy of marriage.
Mushaniq is a fabulous protagonist, she is strong willed and appreciative of her people and yet open to change and hope for what a woman could be. I liked the exploring of the politics between the people and the good and bad of religion guiding one's life choices.
Thanks to Barbour Publishing for access to this novel via Netgalley. All opinions above are my own.
October 18, 2022
Mary is the second book in the Daughters of the Lost Colony series. It overlaps in the timeline with the first book, Elinor, which I personally feel is essential to read in order to fully understand all that these characters have gone through, including what has been lost and what has been gained.
It was very interesting to see things from Mushaniq and Georgie’s perspectives in this novel as they grew up together and began to have feelings for each other. The traditions of Mushaniq’s people regarding intimacy and marriage were very different than the English settlers, which created some difficulties for these two people who loved each other.
Once the novel caught up to the ending scene from Elinor, it was wonderful to see what was next in her journey with her children, the community, and Sees Far. I loved that the reader was able to also read things from not only her perspective, but also from Sees Far’s and Manteo’s perspectives.
It was, once again, a joy to return to this world that was so different from our own, yet made up of people not unlike ourselves in their desires, hopes, and dreams. I really enjoyed this story and also listened to it on audio, as well. The narrator did an excellent job! I enjoyed the epilogue and peek into what might be coming in book three.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour Publishing and was under no obligation to post a review.
You can read this review on my blog:
https://brittreadsfiction.wordpress.c...
It was very interesting to see things from Mushaniq and Georgie’s perspectives in this novel as they grew up together and began to have feelings for each other. The traditions of Mushaniq’s people regarding intimacy and marriage were very different than the English settlers, which created some difficulties for these two people who loved each other.
Once the novel caught up to the ending scene from Elinor, it was wonderful to see what was next in her journey with her children, the community, and Sees Far. I loved that the reader was able to also read things from not only her perspective, but also from Sees Far’s and Manteo’s perspectives.
It was, once again, a joy to return to this world that was so different from our own, yet made up of people not unlike ourselves in their desires, hopes, and dreams. I really enjoyed this story and also listened to it on audio, as well. The narrator did an excellent job! I enjoyed the epilogue and peek into what might be coming in book three.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour Publishing and was under no obligation to post a review.
You can read this review on my blog:
https://brittreadsfiction.wordpress.c...
October 13, 2022
This was the first book in this series that I read, but I enjoyed it anyway. I liked the references to Elinor and it made me want to read that book (and any others in the series) also. I loved Mary’s dad. I love this part of history (and I enjoyed the author’s note about staying authentic to the past even when it’s not politically correct) and while I don’t agree with all the opinions and values that were spoken back then, I also don’t agree with all the opinions and values flying around today. It’s called life and imperfect people, and sin in the world. I appreciated the author keeping things real and seeing life through the eyes of another. Again, I loved Mary’s dad and his relationship with God being so authentic and then coming back and sharing it with the rest of his people. This was a great book and anyone who loves historical books will truly appreciate all the time and effort put into making this book authentic, heartwarming, and realistic.
I received a copy of this book from Celebrate Lit but was not under any obligation to write a review. All opinions are strictly mine.
I received a copy of this book from Celebrate Lit but was not under any obligation to write a review. All opinions are strictly mine.
July 23, 2022
Wow! Another awesome story by Shannon McNear that I lost myself in! Just finished it this morning.
I love McNear's style of writing because she leaves my heart feeling full and satisfied after a good read like this one! I was so excited when I seen this book and I wasn't one bit discouraged either!
Indians are a fascinating people and I felt like I got to know them better through this book. I was happy to Sees Far and Elinor back again. They're my favorite characters.
I hope to see them again in another novel.
I sure hated to come back to the present.
But I will be thinking about this book for a while longer.
I highly recommend this book and author! She's so good at what she does and I'll guarantee you that you will be hooked too!
My thanks for a copy of this book. I was NOT required to write a positive review. All opinions are my own
I love McNear's style of writing because she leaves my heart feeling full and satisfied after a good read like this one! I was so excited when I seen this book and I wasn't one bit discouraged either!
Indians are a fascinating people and I felt like I got to know them better through this book. I was happy to Sees Far and Elinor back again. They're my favorite characters.
I hope to see them again in another novel.
I sure hated to come back to the present.
But I will be thinking about this book for a while longer.
I highly recommend this book and author! She's so good at what she does and I'll guarantee you that you will be hooked too!
My thanks for a copy of this book. I was NOT required to write a positive review. All opinions are my own
September 4, 2022
Fantastic Book 2 in the Daughters of the Lost Colony series. A completely engaging historical fiction "what if" story. I couldn't stop turning pages! I've long been intrigued by the mystery of The Lost Colony of Roanoke. The immense amount of research and the talented pen of Author Shannon McNear takes the reader on a journey you won't soon forget. "Mary" is a continuation of the story in the book "Elinor". This compelling tale is of English settlers and the native peoples who try their hand at living in the same community. Manteo is the native who has bridged the gap between the English and his people. In part, it is the story of his daughter's coming of age, it also picks up where we left off with Elinor and "Sees Far" who risked everything to help her, and we get to know Georgie Howe better. His father was brutally murdered when they arrived three years ago, and it is Georgie's coming of age story too.
With so many differing beliefs and customs, the elders have many joint discussions, between the people of the land, and the English. Manteo is a recent convert to the Christian faith, and he helps both sides to try to understand each other better. In great part this is the young people's journey to discover who they are, and what they believe, and how that fits in with both cultures. But most importantly, do they trust the God who loves them and is with them through every hardship?
I highly recommend Mary and Elinor, and I cannot wait for the next tale in this series!
Thank you to the author and publisher for allowing me to read an early copy. All opinions are my own.
With so many differing beliefs and customs, the elders have many joint discussions, between the people of the land, and the English. Manteo is a recent convert to the Christian faith, and he helps both sides to try to understand each other better. In great part this is the young people's journey to discover who they are, and what they believe, and how that fits in with both cultures. But most importantly, do they trust the God who loves them and is with them through every hardship?
I highly recommend Mary and Elinor, and I cannot wait for the next tale in this series!
Thank you to the author and publisher for allowing me to read an early copy. All opinions are my own.
September 25, 2023
The pure winds of Roanoac Island are unmistakably blowing across the beautiful lands again, while humming realities in a chilly chord throughout the course of this lovely story.
October 26, 2022
As stated in the author’s note at the beginning of the book, Mary by Shannon McNear serves as both a companion novel and a sequel to Elinor, and I appreciate visiting this community of people again.
Let’s start with the research that must have gone into this book. McNear not only gives us details of the land, the history of the lost colony of Roanoke, and a peek into the lives of the Native Americans during this time in history, she details some of the language, clothing, traditions, and so much more. The author’s attention to detail make this story even richer.
Mary is told there the eyes of Mushaniq, Georgie, and Mushaniq’s father Manteo as two children grow into adulthood and friendship grows into respect, admiration, and love. It’s the joining of two individuals and two people groups at the same time.
While the details sometimes made the overall plot drag, I didn’t mind at all because I was so immersed in this setting with these characters and their paths to love and salvation. There are some difficult parts to this book (Native Americans lived lives so much differently than the English settlers, almost to the point of shocking in some aspects), but again, McNear’s dedication to authenticity is what makes this book a wonderful and educational read.
Disclosure statement: I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book and was not required to write a positive or negative review. All opinions are my own.
Let’s start with the research that must have gone into this book. McNear not only gives us details of the land, the history of the lost colony of Roanoke, and a peek into the lives of the Native Americans during this time in history, she details some of the language, clothing, traditions, and so much more. The author’s attention to detail make this story even richer.
Mary is told there the eyes of Mushaniq, Georgie, and Mushaniq’s father Manteo as two children grow into adulthood and friendship grows into respect, admiration, and love. It’s the joining of two individuals and two people groups at the same time.
While the details sometimes made the overall plot drag, I didn’t mind at all because I was so immersed in this setting with these characters and their paths to love and salvation. There are some difficult parts to this book (Native Americans lived lives so much differently than the English settlers, almost to the point of shocking in some aspects), but again, McNear’s dedication to authenticity is what makes this book a wonderful and educational read.
Disclosure statement: I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book and was not required to write a positive or negative review. All opinions are my own.
October 19, 2022
The colonizing of America comes at a high price. The early explorers and settlers give of their lives and future to settle a new land. Well, it is new to the Europeans. Not so new to the indigenous people. Mary plays a role in binding her people to the English. The road is not easy. It never is with the melding of cultures.
Cultural awareness and inclusion are not new concepts. This practice has existed since the beginning of time. We could take our cue from these early settlers. Fighting, arguing, and resisting are not the answers that God wants. Working beside and striving for good are better choices.
Bravo, Shannon!
Cultural awareness and inclusion are not new concepts. This practice has existed since the beginning of time. We could take our cue from these early settlers. Fighting, arguing, and resisting are not the answers that God wants. Working beside and striving for good are better choices.
Bravo, Shannon!
September 30, 2022
Mary, Daughters of the Lost Colony, is one of the best books I have read. The story and the quality of the writing drew me in so that I couldn’t put it down. The characterization is such that these were real people and I was living alongside them. Their hopes, fears, wonder, and all their emotions became mine too. I wished I could just somehow crawl into the story and be with them, because reading the books in this series has given me a profound respect for Native American culture and people.
This book, even more so than Eleanor, presented a very plausible theory of what happened to the “lost” settlers of Roanoke. It gave me hope that they were not slaughtered, but rather assimilated with the native people who helped them.
I enjoyed the author’s switching regularly and often between characters. It kept the story moving along rapidly.
Shannon McNear has a truly Christian outlook, following the spirit of the law, rather than the letter of the law. With compassion, and not judgement, she described the various ways her characters viewed religion. Their attitudes ranged from humility to pride, but all of them grew in their faith. And as for the native people, one could feel their sense of awe at their burgeoning understanding of Christianity.
I truly loved this book (and Book one as well). I cannot wait for Book 3 to come out. This is a remarkably well written and important series.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
#Mary #NetGalley
This book, even more so than Eleanor, presented a very plausible theory of what happened to the “lost” settlers of Roanoke. It gave me hope that they were not slaughtered, but rather assimilated with the native people who helped them.
I enjoyed the author’s switching regularly and often between characters. It kept the story moving along rapidly.
Shannon McNear has a truly Christian outlook, following the spirit of the law, rather than the letter of the law. With compassion, and not judgement, she described the various ways her characters viewed religion. Their attitudes ranged from humility to pride, but all of them grew in their faith. And as for the native people, one could feel their sense of awe at their burgeoning understanding of Christianity.
I truly loved this book (and Book one as well). I cannot wait for Book 3 to come out. This is a remarkably well written and important series.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
#Mary #NetGalley
Read
October 9, 2022I really liked liked this beautiful “what if” story of an English boy and a Native American girl and their personal journey of friendship, faith and love as well as the complex relationship between the English settlers and Native Americans as a whole. The story is full of interesting Native American culture and customs and a nice mix of fictional and real life characters. It took me several chapters to settle in to the book because of all the unfamiliar words and names that I struggled with trying to “pronounce” as I read, but it was well worth the effort. I have not read book one in this series Elinor but I plan to now.
Thanks to NetGalley and Barbour for the chance to read for my honest review.
Thanks to NetGalley and Barbour for the chance to read for my honest review.
September 30, 2022
Mary is the continuation of the characters from Elinor with new ones in the Daughter of the Lost Colony series by gifted author Shannon McNear. McNear’s research and fictional creativity penned a story that will immerse readers into how the newcomers faced challenges with the ways, beliefs, rituals and so much more in the New World. This is Mushaniq’s story, who chose to become Mary. The struggles Georgie and Mary encountered because they fell for each other were intense at times due to the conflicts of their heritage and faith. The story line will give insight to the challenges faced by the newcomers and how lives grew to accept different aspects of each culture. The mystery, intrigue, and budding romance will delight fans of Christian historical fiction.
McNear’s historical notes, regions and people groups, Carolina Algonquian words and more were a plus giving a clearing understanding to this well penned historical fiction set in the 1590’s.
Thank you to Barbour Publishers for an early copy of this book without any obligation to write a positive review. I have expressed my own opinion.
McNear’s historical notes, regions and people groups, Carolina Algonquian words and more were a plus giving a clearing understanding to this well penned historical fiction set in the 1590’s.
Thank you to Barbour Publishers for an early copy of this book without any obligation to write a positive review. I have expressed my own opinion.
September 24, 2022
Shannon McNear pens a unique story of a young girl's journey of faith. With impeccable research and rich detail, McNear skillfully intertwines the POV of several characters to create a fascinating story. Taking the traditions and culture of the native peoples in early America and blending it with that of the newly arrived English colonists, she pens a possible theory of what happened to the missing Roanoke colonists in the 1580's. I found her portrayal of the early fear and intolerance felt by both cultures as they strove to live together compelling.
I heartily recommend this book for fans of early American historical fiction. While it is not necessary, I would suggest readers read book one in the series first. These are stories to be enjoyed but at times are realistic and raw. Filled with both historical and fictional characters, their story will remain with you long after the last page has been read.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the author/publisher and was not required to write a review. All opinions expressed are my own.
I heartily recommend this book for fans of early American historical fiction. While it is not necessary, I would suggest readers read book one in the series first. These are stories to be enjoyed but at times are realistic and raw. Filled with both historical and fictional characters, their story will remain with you long after the last page has been read.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the author/publisher and was not required to write a review. All opinions expressed are my own.
October 26, 2022
I got into this series with Elinor and enjoyed it a lot more than I expected. Mary was also a book I liked a lot, continuing a speculative story of what may have happened to settlers at the lost Colony of Roanoke. This follows a romance between an English young man and an indigenous woman, the daughter of the Manteo, the Native American leader who became a friend and mentor of the early settlers.
From when the author's note said we should not apply modern standards to the past- something many so called historians could do with learning, I suspected I would enjoy this book and it was not a let-down. I don't often talk about "learning" about the past through fiction, but I did with this: even if it was just learning about how indigenous cultures of what is now North America at the close of the 16th century hunted and used medicinal herbs.
Hey, I like that type of thing.
Needless to say, this story is incredibly well researched, and it shows but not by boggling the reading down. I found the portrayal of life in the mixed community of English and Native American people thought the eyes of two teenagers fascinating. There was no assumption that one way of life was "superior" to the other except in regard to some practices such as slavery (though again, there's an honesty to both sides involvement in that).
Mushaniq and Georgie’s relationship was very well written. There was no Insta-love, it was more of a growing relationship between two people who had grown up together and faced similar struggles in their early life. Both had to fact the judgement of their community (which led to a scenario which might be considered quite controversial in this genre) but were prepared to make sacrifices for one another.
I enjoyed following both their journeys to love and faith and getting a story which had a somewhat happier ending than the last one. Spoiler alert: Elinor also returns, but she’s not the woman everyone knew, and there are possibly darker days on the horizon.
You’ve made me care about these characters Mrs McNear, I know it may be historically accurate, but I don’t want anything too bad to happen to them. I’m not prepared for that yet. They deserve some peace and quiet for now!
Recommended, and as usual I need to mention I requested this title from Barbour via Netgalley. I was not required to leave a positive one and all opinions expressed are my own.
September 18, 2022
I have not read the first book in this series : Daughters of The Lost Colony" by Shannon McNear but I found that Mary could be enjoyed as a stand alone. I do plan on reading Elinor ( book 1 ) next and would suggest that readers read this series in order.
Set in the 1590's Mary is a story of the English colonists trying to establish themselves in a new world. This story is full of intense feelings; fear, adversity and new beliefs . It tells how as one becomes a Christian their lives change as well as the communities in which they live.
Alot of research has went into this book making it informative as well as a great story.
Elinor is next on my to be read list as I wait for book 3 in this series.
Received this book from Barbour Publishing; Review Crew copy.
Set in the 1590's Mary is a story of the English colonists trying to establish themselves in a new world. This story is full of intense feelings; fear, adversity and new beliefs . It tells how as one becomes a Christian their lives change as well as the communities in which they live.
Alot of research has went into this book making it informative as well as a great story.
Elinor is next on my to be read list as I wait for book 3 in this series.
Received this book from Barbour Publishing; Review Crew copy.
October 26, 2022
“We can walk in holiness and yet do it in such a way that is loving and gracious!”
Mary by Shannon McNear is an emotional and spiritual coming of age story of two young people from different cultures. McNear strives to show both the good and the ugly of both the English and the Native American cultures. Manteo is the dominant physical thread that holds these two tenuous cultures together. What an unusual man he is! Can Elinor and Sees Far help Manteo guide the fledgling love of Georgie and Mushaniq, as well as guide the racially diverse colony to unity?
McNear’s research is impeccable. I learned a lot of history. But hopefully, mostly, I learned to give grace for those of different from me, so that unity can prevail whenever possible. “The sacraments and doctrines are clear enough! That is not our trouble here. It is that we wish to administer the letter of the law and not be mindful of the spirit thereof.” Would the Roanoke Colony as portrayed in Mary be dissolved from within by disagreement and insistence upon each culture’s mores?
While a sequel to “Elinor, ” Mary by Shannon McNear has quite enough backstory one can read this as a stand-alone.
Different personal rivalries helped drive the action, creating tension and suspense. The outcome of all of them surprised me.
One last note: due to the subject matter, I would recommend this book for mature readers.
I received a copy of the book from Celebrate Lit via NetGalley. No positive review was required, and all opinions are my own.
Mary by Shannon McNear is an emotional and spiritual coming of age story of two young people from different cultures. McNear strives to show both the good and the ugly of both the English and the Native American cultures. Manteo is the dominant physical thread that holds these two tenuous cultures together. What an unusual man he is! Can Elinor and Sees Far help Manteo guide the fledgling love of Georgie and Mushaniq, as well as guide the racially diverse colony to unity?
McNear’s research is impeccable. I learned a lot of history. But hopefully, mostly, I learned to give grace for those of different from me, so that unity can prevail whenever possible. “The sacraments and doctrines are clear enough! That is not our trouble here. It is that we wish to administer the letter of the law and not be mindful of the spirit thereof.” Would the Roanoke Colony as portrayed in Mary be dissolved from within by disagreement and insistence upon each culture’s mores?
While a sequel to “Elinor, ” Mary by Shannon McNear has quite enough backstory one can read this as a stand-alone.
Different personal rivalries helped drive the action, creating tension and suspense. The outcome of all of them surprised me.
One last note: due to the subject matter, I would recommend this book for mature readers.
I received a copy of the book from Celebrate Lit via NetGalley. No positive review was required, and all opinions are my own.
August 21, 2022
Another great book in the series, the Daughters of the Lost Colony of Roanoke.
This is book two and the colonists have relocated to Kurawoten Island after the attack on Roanoke. It continues on with Eleanor and the other colonists that have now joined with other native tribes to live peacefully. They learn their language and customs and teach them the ways of the English. Also, introducing them to the God of their religion.
There are lots of intense moments with great danger, but also some of great joy and conversions to faith. I loved the historical aspects due to what appears to be extensive research. The faith elements are woven in so well. I can't wait to read the next book in the series.
I received a complimentary copy from the publisher and willingly choose to review it.
This is book two and the colonists have relocated to Kurawoten Island after the attack on Roanoke. It continues on with Eleanor and the other colonists that have now joined with other native tribes to live peacefully. They learn their language and customs and teach them the ways of the English. Also, introducing them to the God of their religion.
There are lots of intense moments with great danger, but also some of great joy and conversions to faith. I loved the historical aspects due to what appears to be extensive research. The faith elements are woven in so well. I can't wait to read the next book in the series.
I received a complimentary copy from the publisher and willingly choose to review it.
October 5, 2022
This was a beautifully written and touching novel about the early settlers in the Lost Colony in Roanoake in the late sixteenth century!
This is the sequel to Elinor, the first book which I have not yet read, and it can be perfectly read as a standalone. Although, I have to say, Mary made me want to read Elinor and get to know the characters in this adventure better as they have become dear to me.
The book is written by different point of views and I liked that, it made the story richer. Mushaniq, Manteo, Georgie. Mushaniq is Manteo’s free-spirited native daughter, coming of age, and rediscovering her father who has returned from years spent with the Inqutish, as they called the English settlers, with a different faith to their traditional beliefs about a loving God who gave His life in order to save His people from evil. Mateo returns to Roanoake as a new man, never imagining that his life could become so liberating after accepting Christ as his savior. But how to explain his deep change to his family? And Georgie, a young boy becoming man, who is still grieving the brutal murder of his father only a week after they arrived in the New World. Can he trust that these people are not all responsible for his father’s death, nor violent warriors ready to attack. He’s determined to protect Elinor’s daughter, Ginny Dare, and as Mushaniq volunteers to help him, a unique friendship blossom between the two, that will gradually develop into a deep love. A love that defies their upbringing, as two completely different cultures clash and blend into a community, as the author describes, of one heart and one mind. Can a love so challenged thrive and perdure?
This was a beautiful journey that I completely enjoyed because of its historicity and reality. Even if it’s a work of fiction, you can perfectly see how deeply researched it is. The language and native words and beliefs, the traditions, left me in awe. I felt as if I had traveled back in time and was myself among the natives, wanting to understand their culture, full of virtues, as well as flaws. The character felt very relatable and loveable. The author immerses us in their thoughts, their fears, and their dreams with genuine talent. The love story between Mushaniq and Georgie was sweet and endearing, full of struggle and challenges to overcome. Trust doesn’t come easy, and less even in the midst of tragedy. Yet, the way these two souls come to believe in a God that loves with an Unconditional love, was humbling and heartrending. Full of hope, the faith inspired message will stay with you and make you reflect of the deepness of your own faith. It didn’t feel preachy at all. And the plot captivates you from page one, full of danger and adventure.
The story is not light-hearted, yet it is heart-tugging and touching. A beautiful journey of love above the differences of race and culture. The hope of humanity becoming what God created us to be. A community of one heart and one mind!
I totally recommend this to Historical fans! A true gem! I received a complimentary book from Barbour Publishing but wasn’t required to post a review. This is my honest and unbiased opinion.
This is the sequel to Elinor, the first book which I have not yet read, and it can be perfectly read as a standalone. Although, I have to say, Mary made me want to read Elinor and get to know the characters in this adventure better as they have become dear to me.
The book is written by different point of views and I liked that, it made the story richer. Mushaniq, Manteo, Georgie. Mushaniq is Manteo’s free-spirited native daughter, coming of age, and rediscovering her father who has returned from years spent with the Inqutish, as they called the English settlers, with a different faith to their traditional beliefs about a loving God who gave His life in order to save His people from evil. Mateo returns to Roanoake as a new man, never imagining that his life could become so liberating after accepting Christ as his savior. But how to explain his deep change to his family? And Georgie, a young boy becoming man, who is still grieving the brutal murder of his father only a week after they arrived in the New World. Can he trust that these people are not all responsible for his father’s death, nor violent warriors ready to attack. He’s determined to protect Elinor’s daughter, Ginny Dare, and as Mushaniq volunteers to help him, a unique friendship blossom between the two, that will gradually develop into a deep love. A love that defies their upbringing, as two completely different cultures clash and blend into a community, as the author describes, of one heart and one mind. Can a love so challenged thrive and perdure?
This was a beautiful journey that I completely enjoyed because of its historicity and reality. Even if it’s a work of fiction, you can perfectly see how deeply researched it is. The language and native words and beliefs, the traditions, left me in awe. I felt as if I had traveled back in time and was myself among the natives, wanting to understand their culture, full of virtues, as well as flaws. The character felt very relatable and loveable. The author immerses us in their thoughts, their fears, and their dreams with genuine talent. The love story between Mushaniq and Georgie was sweet and endearing, full of struggle and challenges to overcome. Trust doesn’t come easy, and less even in the midst of tragedy. Yet, the way these two souls come to believe in a God that loves with an Unconditional love, was humbling and heartrending. Full of hope, the faith inspired message will stay with you and make you reflect of the deepness of your own faith. It didn’t feel preachy at all. And the plot captivates you from page one, full of danger and adventure.
The story is not light-hearted, yet it is heart-tugging and touching. A beautiful journey of love above the differences of race and culture. The hope of humanity becoming what God created us to be. A community of one heart and one mind!
I totally recommend this to Historical fans! A true gem! I received a complimentary book from Barbour Publishing but wasn’t required to post a review. This is my honest and unbiased opinion.
October 1, 2022
What a captivating story that is lathered in and drips of, historical figures and happenings on New World soil. A colony that was purportedly lost - vanished. However, this book hints of where they may have gotten lost to...integrated with Algonquian tribal groups from Roanoac Island, Outer Banks, North Carolina, such as among the Croatoan, Kurawoten, Powhatan, Secon, Sukwoten and other native Americans/FirstNation Peoples.
Some true-to-life native characters were people like Manteo, Wanchese, Towaye and others who in the late 1500's were brought to England for a short period of time. Other characters of English origin such as Ananias and Elinor (White) Dare; John White, Roger Bailie, featured in the pioneering of the New World in this area, assimilating into native culture either of free will or by captive force.
The gospel of Jesus Christ was well represented throughout this whole story I'm very pleased to report and noted that many of Manteo's people came to know Christ. When a reader comes to the addenda at book end, he or she will find suggestion of such, based on some of what the author, Shannon McNair, discovered in her research hunts, preparatory to writing this book.
I loved Manteo, Mushaniq, Georgie, Two Feathers, Timqua, Elinor, Sees Far, and others who really did try to "make room" for each other's respective culture in what was, at times, an uneasy truce of fine-tuned balance and relationship. Anyone who has been an expat anywhere in the world, or who has even inter-married with a culture vastly different than their own and become immersed therein, will understand the depth, nuances and struggles of such alliances. McNair has really done an excellent, excellent job of this, almost as if she'd lived such herself.
What a wonderful bridge she inter-weaves too, with the forgiveness, grace, and love of God, and respectful comparisons with the spirit world and culture of the various First Nation Peoples.
I found the explanations of the First Nation Peoples' culture and practices fascinating especially the 'huskanaw' and 'huskanasqua' but I'll let any potential reader find out for themselves what they are all about. I liked that the pubescent girls and women would be allowed a stay at "the women's house" during their monthly 'visitor' time and how the native man would respect a pregnant woman.
Anyway, do read the story which is full of excitement and NOT boring for even a second. This is a second book in a series called Daughters of the Lost Colony and a third may well be on its way.
The addenda gives good historical notes of the book's characters who were true to history, both English and Native; actual and fictional; lists of: those who moved to Beechland; were taken captive; the region's people groups; native vocabulary and more.
Happy Reading, should you decide to go for it! Oh yes, and find out who Mary is, or was....
~Eunice C., Reviewer/Blogger~
August 2022
Disclaimer: This is my honest opinion based on the review copy sent by NetGalley and the publisher.
Some true-to-life native characters were people like Manteo, Wanchese, Towaye and others who in the late 1500's were brought to England for a short period of time. Other characters of English origin such as Ananias and Elinor (White) Dare; John White, Roger Bailie, featured in the pioneering of the New World in this area, assimilating into native culture either of free will or by captive force.
The gospel of Jesus Christ was well represented throughout this whole story I'm very pleased to report and noted that many of Manteo's people came to know Christ. When a reader comes to the addenda at book end, he or she will find suggestion of such, based on some of what the author, Shannon McNair, discovered in her research hunts, preparatory to writing this book.
I loved Manteo, Mushaniq, Georgie, Two Feathers, Timqua, Elinor, Sees Far, and others who really did try to "make room" for each other's respective culture in what was, at times, an uneasy truce of fine-tuned balance and relationship. Anyone who has been an expat anywhere in the world, or who has even inter-married with a culture vastly different than their own and become immersed therein, will understand the depth, nuances and struggles of such alliances. McNair has really done an excellent, excellent job of this, almost as if she'd lived such herself.
What a wonderful bridge she inter-weaves too, with the forgiveness, grace, and love of God, and respectful comparisons with the spirit world and culture of the various First Nation Peoples.
I found the explanations of the First Nation Peoples' culture and practices fascinating especially the 'huskanaw' and 'huskanasqua' but I'll let any potential reader find out for themselves what they are all about. I liked that the pubescent girls and women would be allowed a stay at "the women's house" during their monthly 'visitor' time and how the native man would respect a pregnant woman.
Anyway, do read the story which is full of excitement and NOT boring for even a second. This is a second book in a series called Daughters of the Lost Colony and a third may well be on its way.
The addenda gives good historical notes of the book's characters who were true to history, both English and Native; actual and fictional; lists of: those who moved to Beechland; were taken captive; the region's people groups; native vocabulary and more.
Happy Reading, should you decide to go for it! Oh yes, and find out who Mary is, or was....
~Eunice C., Reviewer/Blogger~
August 2022
Disclaimer: This is my honest opinion based on the review copy sent by NetGalley and the publisher.
October 11, 2022
About the Book:
Immerse yourself in the “what if” questions related to the Lost Colony of Roanoke. What if an English boy and a native girl met in the wilderness? The push-and-pull between two very different worlds begins as one seeks simple friendship and the other struggles to trust. And can it—dare they—allow it to be more?
Sparks fly between Mushaniq, free-spirited daughter of Manteo, and Georgie Howe, whose father was brutally murdered by undiscovered native warriors before they’d been on Roanoac Island a full week. As Georgie struggles to make sense of his life and to accept that not all they call “savage” are guilty of his father’s death, Mushaniq grapples with her own questions about who Manteo has become. As tentative friendship becomes more, forged in the fire of calamity and attack upon their community, both must decide whether the One True God is indeed who He claims to be and whether He is worthy of their trust.
My Review:
So if you are into a lot of the colony type stories or movies or even TV shows---this book series is for you. I feel like this book could be a stand alone type book. But with all due respect you really need to start with the first book in the series, Elinor. It gives you Elinor's background and how she came to be and then we have this lovely addition to the series, Mary. Just some really good stuff!
Just when you think all is well and this is a "cupcakes and rainbows" type story for Mary you will quickly find that it is not. Mary had it tough. She couldn't decide who to trust and who was out to get her. She was always on guard. But she soon meets someone that will change all of that. thankfully it couldn't happen fast enough.The wilderness isn't a safe place for a young woman.
Even though there were many challenges for Mary and Georgie, they made it work and were able to live and tell about it.
Great read!
**Disclosure**This book was sent to me free of charge for my honest review. All opinions are my own.
Immerse yourself in the “what if” questions related to the Lost Colony of Roanoke. What if an English boy and a native girl met in the wilderness? The push-and-pull between two very different worlds begins as one seeks simple friendship and the other struggles to trust. And can it—dare they—allow it to be more?
Sparks fly between Mushaniq, free-spirited daughter of Manteo, and Georgie Howe, whose father was brutally murdered by undiscovered native warriors before they’d been on Roanoac Island a full week. As Georgie struggles to make sense of his life and to accept that not all they call “savage” are guilty of his father’s death, Mushaniq grapples with her own questions about who Manteo has become. As tentative friendship becomes more, forged in the fire of calamity and attack upon their community, both must decide whether the One True God is indeed who He claims to be and whether He is worthy of their trust.
My Review:
So if you are into a lot of the colony type stories or movies or even TV shows---this book series is for you. I feel like this book could be a stand alone type book. But with all due respect you really need to start with the first book in the series, Elinor. It gives you Elinor's background and how she came to be and then we have this lovely addition to the series, Mary. Just some really good stuff!
Just when you think all is well and this is a "cupcakes and rainbows" type story for Mary you will quickly find that it is not. Mary had it tough. She couldn't decide who to trust and who was out to get her. She was always on guard. But she soon meets someone that will change all of that. thankfully it couldn't happen fast enough.The wilderness isn't a safe place for a young woman.
Even though there were many challenges for Mary and Georgie, they made it work and were able to live and tell about it.
Great read!
**Disclosure**This book was sent to me free of charge for my honest review. All opinions are my own.
October 17, 2022
Wow! This book is wonderful for those that are fans of the early times in American history. It is very apparent that Shannon McNear did much research to write this book. Readers will travel through time as if they are within the pages.
This book is a sequel to the book Elinor. As the colonists try to live with and among the natives tragedy ensues as battles rage and leaves colonists bewildered .
Moving forward with the story Mushaniq, one of the natives and George who has lost his father in the first book forge a relationship which each other. Many of the natives have come to Christ. With the blending of two different cultures and traditions the reader will be drawn into the story line. The mystery of the Roanoke Colony has long been disgusted among historians and McNear gives another idea of what may have happened.
I think the reader would enjoy reading book one first. I felt the fear among the characters and there is raw emotion within the pages.
I was received a complimentary copy of this book by Barbour Publishing and was under no obligatio to post a review.
This book is a sequel to the book Elinor. As the colonists try to live with and among the natives tragedy ensues as battles rage and leaves colonists bewildered .
Moving forward with the story Mushaniq, one of the natives and George who has lost his father in the first book forge a relationship which each other. Many of the natives have come to Christ. With the blending of two different cultures and traditions the reader will be drawn into the story line. The mystery of the Roanoke Colony has long been disgusted among historians and McNear gives another idea of what may have happened.
I think the reader would enjoy reading book one first. I felt the fear among the characters and there is raw emotion within the pages.
I was received a complimentary copy of this book by Barbour Publishing and was under no obligatio to post a review.
October 15, 2022
This book is about the early English settlers in Roanoke in the 16th century. I love reading about how our country was settled and especially about the native Americans and the English when we first settled in America. This book centers on George Howe, the young boy who lost his father in a brutal Native uprising. It is about him falling in love with an Indian girl, Mushaniq and both races were against their marrying. Her father Manteo is not against them marrying as he has become a Christian and some of the other natives have become Christians, but not all. There is much danger from the natives and the people of the colony have to keep alert and on watch at all times. There have been kidnapping and brutal murders from the evil natives. Can the two peoples come together and allow these young people in love to be married? This is a most interesting book and it makes me want to read the first book as this book takes up where the first book leaves off…. Thanks to Barbour publishing for allowing me to read and review this great book.
October 17, 2022
This is my second book by Shannon McNear. I thoroughly enjoyed her first Daughters of the Lost Colony series, Elinor. Elinor is also a character in this book. It's amazing how Mushaniq and Georgie's lives change individually, but through it all they're drawn closer to one another. Georgie learns to embrace some of the ways of the native people. He grows into manhood during this time, Mushaniq finally turns her life to Christ and becomes Mary during her conversion. I received a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour Publishing and was under no obligation to post a review.
September 5, 2023
I am up past my bedtime again to reach the end of this one. There are no words to do it justice right now, besides highly recommend!
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher and was under no obligation to post a review. The opinions expressed are my own.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher and was under no obligation to post a review. The opinions expressed are my own.
October 15, 2022
This was a truly incredible read! I was enthralled reading Elinor, but had no idea there would be a sequel…and now I know I can look forward to a third book as well!
More than a historical romance, McNear weaves together the angst of coming of age both physically and spiritually. I love how Georgie and Mary each examine their own culture’s standards and practices before choosing their personal life path. They didn’t take the easiest way, but their choices led to the solidarity of the fused community. And what a treat to catch up on Elinor’s story! Her wisdom and courage grows over the space of both books. She is a true “mother in Israel.”
Impeccable research and sensitivity make this easily a 5-star book. I received a complimentary copy from NetGalley and was not required to post a review.
More than a historical romance, McNear weaves together the angst of coming of age both physically and spiritually. I love how Georgie and Mary each examine their own culture’s standards and practices before choosing their personal life path. They didn’t take the easiest way, but their choices led to the solidarity of the fused community. And what a treat to catch up on Elinor’s story! Her wisdom and courage grows over the space of both books. She is a true “mother in Israel.”
Impeccable research and sensitivity make this easily a 5-star book. I received a complimentary copy from NetGalley and was not required to post a review.
October 15, 2022
I absolutely loved this one! I enjoyed the fact that it starts in the middle of Elinor, goes back and gives some backstory and then picks up where Elinor ended. I actually enjoyed it more than Elinor. Shannon McNear is one of my favorite authors. She doesn't shy away from the gritty truth that comes with real, historical events. She tells it with grace in her books. For that reason, among several others, I would recommend this book and series.
I received a complimentary copy from the publisher. I was not required to write a positive review. All opinions expressed are mine alone.
I received a complimentary copy from the publisher. I was not required to write a positive review. All opinions expressed are mine alone.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 96 reviews